Fibroblast growth factor and the control of vertebrate regeneration and repair

Endocrine regulation of regeneration: Linking global signals to local processes

Regeneration in amphibians and reptiles has been explored since the early 18th century, giving us a working in vivo model to study epimorphic regeneration in vertebrates. Studies aiming to uncover primary mechanisms of regeneration have predominantly focused on genetic pathways regulating specific stages of the regeneration process: wound healing, blastema formation and growth, and pattern formation. However, studies across organisms show that environmental conditions and physiological state of the animal can affect the rate or quality of regeneration, and endocrine signals are likely the mediators of these effects. Endocrine signals working/acting directly on receptors expressed in the structure or via neuroendocrine pathways can affect regeneration by modulating immune response to injury, allocation of energetic resources, or by enhancing or inhibiting proliferation and differentiation pathways in regenerating tissue. This review discusses the cumulative knowledge known about endocrine regulation of regeneration and important future research directions of interest to both ecological and biomedical research.

Mechanisms of Cardiac Regeneration

Adult humans fail to regenerate their hearts following injury, and this failure to regenerate myocardium is a leading cause of heart failure and death worldwide. Although all adult mammals appear to lack significant cardiac regeneration potential, some vertebrates can regenerate myocardium throughout life. In addition, new studies indicate that mammals have cardiac regeneration potential during development and very soon after birth. The mechanisms of heart regeneration among model organisms, including neonatal mice, appear remarkably similar. Orchestrated waves of inflammation, matrix deposition and remodeling, and cardiomyocyte proliferation are commonly seen in heart regeneration models. Understanding why adult mammals develop extensive scarring instead of regeneration is a crucial goal for regenerative biology.

Do you have the nerves to regenerate? The importance of neural signalling in the regeneration process

The importance of nerve-derived signalling for correct regeneration has been the topic of research for more than a hundred years, but we are just beginning to identify the underlying molecular pathways of this process. Within the current review, we attempt to provide an extensive overview of the neural influences during early and late phases of both vertebrate and invertebrate regeneration. In general, denervation impairs limb regeneration, but the presence of nerves is not essential for the regeneration of aneurogenic extremities. This observation led to the "neurotrophic factor(s) hypothesis", which states that certain trophic factors produced by the nerves are necessary for proper regeneration. Possible neuron-derived factors which regulate regeneration as well as the denervation-affected processes are discussed.

Regeneration inducers in limb regeneration

Limb regeneration ability, which can be observed in amphibians, has been investigated as a representative phenomenon of organ regeneration. Recently, an alternative experimental system called the accessory limb model was developed to investigate early regulation of amphibian limb regeneration. The accessory limb model contributed to identification of limb regeneration inducers in urodele amphibians. Furthermore, the accessory limb model may be applied to other species to explore universality of regeneration mechanisms. This review aims to connect the insights recently gained to emboss universality of regeneration mechanisms among species. The defined molecules (BMP7 (or2) + FGF2 + FGF8) can transform skin wound healing to organ (limb) regeneration responses. The same molecules can initiate regeneration responses in some species.

Denervation impairs regeneration of amputated zebrafish fins

BACKGROUND

Zebrafish are able to regenerate many of its tissues and organs after damage. In amphibians this process is regulated by nerve fibres present at the site of injury, which have been proposed to release factors into the amputated limbs/fins, promoting and sustaining the proliferation of blastemal cells. Although some candidate factors have been proposed to mediate the nerve dependency of regeneration, the molecular mechanisms involved in this process remain unclear.

RESULTS

We have used zebrafish as a model system to address the role of nerve fibres in fin regeneration. We have developed a protocol for pectoral fin denervation followed by amputation and analysed the regenerative process under this experimental conditions. Upon denervation fins were able to close the wound and form a wound epidermis, but could not establish a functional apical epithelial cap, with a posterior failure of blastema formation and outgrowth, and the accumulation of several defects. The expression patterns of genes known to be key players during fin regeneration were altered upon denervation, suggesting that nerves can contribute to the regulation of the Fgf, Wnt and Shh pathways during zebrafish fin regeneration.

CONCLUSIONS

Our results demonstrate that proper innervation of the zebrafish pectoral fin is essential for a successful regenerative process, and establish this organism as a useful model to understand the molecular and cellular mechanisms of nerve dependence, during vertebrate regeneration.

Peripheral nerve regeneration in the MRL/MpJ ear wound model

The MRL/MpJ mouse displays an accelerated ability to heal ear punch wounds without scar formation (whereas wounds on the dorsal surface of the trunk heal with scar formation), offering a rare opportunity for studying tissue regeneration in adult mammals. A blastema-like structure develops and subsequently the structure of the wounded ear is restored, including cartilage, skin, hair follicles and adipose tissue. We sought to assess if the MRL/MpJ strain also possessed an enhanced capacity for peripheral nerve regeneration. Female MRL/MpJ and C57BL/6 mice were wounded with a 2-mm excisional biopsy punch to the centre of each ear and two 4-mm excisional biopsy punches to the dorsal skin. Immunohistochemical dual staining of pan-neurofilament and CD31 markers was used to investigate reinnervation and vascularisation of both the dorsal surface of the trunk and ear wounds. The MRL/MpJ mouse ear exhibited a significantly (P > 0.01) higher density of regenerated nerves than C57BL/6 between 10 and 21 days post-wounding when the blastema-like structure was forming. Unlike dorsal skin wounds, nerve regeneration in the ear wound preceded vascularisation, recapitulating early mammalian development. Immunohistochemical data suggest that factors within the blastemal mesenchyme, such as aggrecan, may direct nerve regrowth in the regenerating ear tissue.

Cellular and molecular processes of regeneration, with special emphasis on fish fins

The phenomenon of 'epimorphic regeneration', a complete reformation of lost tissues and organs from adult differentiated cells, has been fascinating many biologists for many years. While most vertebrate species including humans do not have a remarkable ability for regeneration, the lower vertebrates such as urodeles and fish have exceptionally high regeneration abilities. In particular, the teleost fish has a high ability to regenerate a variety of tissues and organs including scales, muscles, spinal cord and heart among vertebrate species. Hence, an understanding of the regeneration mechanism in teleosts will provide an essential knowledge base for rational approaches to tissue and organ regeneration in mammals. In the last decade, small teleost fish such as the zebrafish and medaka have emerged as powerful animal models in which a variety of developmental, genetic and molecular approaches are applicable. In addition, rapid progress in the development of genome resources such as expressed sequence tags and genome sequences has accelerated the speed of the molecular analysis of regeneration. This review summarizes the current status of our understanding of the cellular and molecular basis of regeneration, particularly that regarding fish fins.

Vasculature in pre-blastema and nerve-dependent blastema stages of regenerating forelimbs of the adult newt, Notophthalmus viridescens

Immunocytochemistry utilizing a monoclonal antibody (BV1; blood vessel 1) highly reactive to the vasculature of the adult newt showed that a developing vasculature was present during early, pre-blastema, and early-bud blastema stages of forelimb regeneration in this species. Infusion of Prussian Blue and DiI into the brachial artery further delineated the intactness of this early vasculature. Finally, macroscopic observations of vascular flow underneath the apical epithelial cap (AEC) and microsurgical removal of the AEC and observation of subsequent bleeding buttressed the conclusion that an intact vasculature exists during early nerve-dependent stages of newt forelimb regeneration. The results suggest that this process of neovascular formation is angiogenesis, i.e., the formation of new vessels from pre-existing vessels in the stump. Furthermore, angiogenesis is an ongoing process initiated early after amputation. Blastema cells and the AEC are likely sourcesof factors that stimulate neovascularization.

Urodelean amphibians in studies on microgravity: effects upon organ and tissue regeneration

Results obtained from nine experiments performed onboard Russian biosatellites have shown that microgravity promotes tissue regeneration in the newt, Pleurodeles waltl. The effect has been reproduced in all flights and on a clinostat as well for eye tissues (lens and retina), limbs and tail. The effect was demonstrated in 1.5- to 2-fold increase in cell proliferation in the early stages of regeneration in space flight. Animals "flown" intact and operated after flight regenerated faster than control ones and showed long-lasting micro-"g" effect. The most recent experiment flew aboard the Bion-11 biosatellite. This test was performed for study on microgravity effect on neural retina regeneration after optic nerve lesioning in the newt. Obtained results confirmed our previous information about intensification of regenerative processes in detached neural retina in urodela exposed to simulated weightlessness (Grigoryan et al., 1998). In particular, we found the increase and activation of cell populations participating in neural retina restoration and maintenance of retinal structure. Our findings suggest that promoting effect of microgravity upon regeneration could be influenced by several factors, largely influenced by a response of the whole organism to changed gravity vector. We hypothesized the synthesis of the specific range of stress proteins induced by micro-"g" and their regulative role in cell proliferation. Such a hypothesis for the existence of "altered gravity stress proteins" is discussed.

Regeneration neurohormones and growth factors in echinoderms

There has been much recent interest in the presence and biological functions of growth regulators in invertebrates. In spite of the different distribution patterns of these molecules in different phyla (from molluscs, insects, and annelids to echinoderms and tunicates), they seem always to be extensively involved in developmental processes, both embryonic and regenerative. Echinoderms are well known for their striking regenerative potential and many can completely regenerate arms that, for example, are lost following self-induced or traumatic amputation. Thus, they provide a valuable experimental model for the study of regenerative processes from the macroscopic to the molecular level. In crinoids as well as probably all ophiuroids, regeneration is rapid and occurs by means of a mechanism that involves blastema formation, known as epimorphosis, where the new tissues arise from undifferentiated cells. In asteroids, morphallaxis is the mechanism employed, replacement cells being derived from existing tissues following differentiation and (or) transdifferentiation. This paper focuses on the possible contribution of neurohormones and growth factors during both repair and regenerative processes. Three different classes of regulatory molecules are proposed as plausible candidates for growth-promoting factors in regeneration: neurotransmitters (monoamines), neuropeptides (substance P, SALMFamides 1 and 2), and growth-factor-like molecules (TGF-β (transforming growth factor β), NGF (nerve growth factor), RGF-2 (basic fibroblast growth factor)).

Expression patterns of Fgf-8 during development and limb regeneration of the axolotl

Fgf-8 is one of the key signaling molecules implicated in the initiation, outgrowth, and patterning of vertebrate limbs. However, it is not clear whether FGF-8 plays similar role in development and regeneration of urodele limbs. We isolated a Fgf-8 cDNA from the Mexican axolotl (Ambystoma mexicanum) through the screening of an embryo cDNA library. The cloned 1.26-kb cDNA contained an open reading frame encoding 212 amino acid residues with 84%, 86%, and 80% amino acid identities to those of Xenopus, chick, and mouse, respectively. By using the above clone as a probe, we examined the temporal and spatial expression patterns of Fgf-8 in developing embryos and in regenerating larval limbs. In developing embryos, Fgf-8 was expressed in the neural fold, midbrain-hindbrain junction, tail and limb buds, pharyngeal clefts, and primordia of maxilla and mandible. In the developing axolotl limb, Fgf-8 began to be expressed in the prospective forelimb region at pre-limb-bud and limb bud stages. Interestingly, strong expression was detected in the mesenchymal tissue of the limb bud before digit forming stages. In the regenerating limb, Fgf-8 expression was noted in the basal layer of the apical epithelial cap (AEC) and the underlying thin layer of mesenchymal tissue during blastema formation stages. These data suggest that Fgf-8 is involved in the organogenesis of various craniofacial structures, the initiation and outgrowth of limb development, and the blastema formation and outgrowth of regenerating limbs. In the developing limb of axolotl, unlike in Xenopus or in amniotes such as chick and mouse, the Fgf-8 expression domain was localized mainly in the mesenchyme rather than epidermis. The unique expression pattern of Fgf-8 in axolotl suggests that the regulatory mechanism of Fgf-8 expression is different between urodeles and other higher species. The expression of Fgf-8 in the deep layer of the AEC and the thin layer of underlying mesenchymal tissue in the regenerating limbs support the previous notion that the amphibian AEC is a functional equivalent of the AER in amniotes.

Denervation retards but does not prevent toetip regeneration

Toetips of mammals regrow after amputation by a process similar, but not identical, to that which occurs during regeneration of a newt limb. Nerve is needed as a mitotic stimulant for newt limb regeneration but the requirement for nerve during rodent digit-tip regeneration is not known. Nerve dependence in rats was tested by severing the sciatic nerve in one hindlimb, amputating digit-tips from the central digits of both hind feet, and comparing the amount of regrowth in innervated and denervated digits. Denervation delayed soft-tissue wound healing. However, denervation did not significantly affect bone regrowth when animals were examined at one month. Because we suspected delayed bone regrowth, we used a new method that we developed to follow bone growth at several time points in each animal. Termed visible bone fluorescence through nail, this technique used serial injections of fluorescent calcium-deposition markers and observation through the toenails to observe bone growth in living animals. Using this method it was possible to detect retarded bone regrowth in denervated digits. Thus, although denervation of rodent tips delayed both soft tissue healing and bone regrowth, it did not prevent ultimate restitution of the amputated part. This suggests that neurotrophic stimulation in the mammalian digit-tip is not identical to that documented during newt limb regeneration, and that growth stimulation may be provided by tissues other than nerve.

Stimulation of axon growth from the spinal cord by a regenerating limb blastema in newts

The effects of limb blastemas of Pleurodeles waltl on axon growth from fragments of spinal cord were studied in vitro. Cultured in a defined medium, spinal cord fragments regenerated sparse, short axons. The culture of spinal fragments in the presence of blastemas greatly enhanced the length, number and survival of axons. Testing separately each of the two components of the blastema showed that only the mesenchyme exerts a neurotropic effect on the spinal fragments. Other tissues such as muscle or skin had a limited neurotrophic effect. Additionally, the neurotrophic activity of blastemas seems to be dependent of its proliferation status. Compared with blastemas of regenerating limbs from young animals, irradiated blastemas (devoid of mitotic activity) and blastemas of regenerating limbs from old animals or differentiated blastemas (both characterized by a low mitotic activity), exhibited a weaker neurotrophic influence. The blastema neurotrophic factor is not an attachment molecule but a soluble one and cannot be nerve growth factor (NGF) or fibroblast growth factor (FGF). It has a relatively low molecular weight (less than 15 kDa) and its protein nature was ascertained by its sensitivity to heating and proteases. As the production of this mesenchyme-derived neurotrophic factor depends upon mesenchymal cell proliferation of the blastema, we suggest that there is loop of positive regulation between spinal nerves and blastema. Blastema tissues may stimulate nerve regeneration allowing the stimulation of proliferation of blastema cells by regenerating nerve fibers. Alternatively, blastema cells may produce a neurotrophic factor whose secretion might be dependent on cell proliferation.

Gene expression during amphibian limb regeneration

Limb regeneration in adult urodeles is an important phenomenon that poses fundamental questions both in biology and in medicine. In this review, we focus on recent advances in the characterization of the regeneration blastema at cellular and molecular levels and on the current understanding of the molecular basis of limb regeneration and its relationship to development. In particular, we discuss (i) the spatiotemporal distribution of genes and gene products in the mesenchyme and wound epidermis of the regenerating limb, (ii) how growth is controlled in the regeneration blastema, and (iii) molecules that are likely to be involved in patterning the regenerating limb such as homeobox genes and retinoids.

Nerve-blastema interactions induce fibroblast growth factor-1 release during limb regeneration in Pleurodeles waltl

Previous studies have shown that both fibroblast growth factor (FGF)-1 and nerves play an important function during limb regeneration, but no correlation between these two regeneration factors has yet been demonstrated. In the present study we first establish that exogenous FGF-2, a member of the FGF family that binds to the same high-affinity receptors as FGF-1, is able to stimulate both [3H]-thymidine incorporation and the mitotic index in the mesenchyme and the epidermal cells of denervated blastemas. We then use cocultures of spinal cord and blastema on heparin-coated dishes, an in vitro system mimicking the in vivo interactions during limb regeneration, to show that interactions between nerve fibers from the spinal cord and the blastema enhance the release of bioactive FGF-1. Release of this growth factor seemed to correlate with nerve fiber regeneration, as it decreased in the presence of the dipeptide Leu-Ala, known to inhibit neurite outgrowth, while the inverse dipeptide Ala-Leu was inactive. Therefore, these results support our hypothesis that the interaction between nervous tissue and blastema is permissive for the release of FGF-1, which in turn stimulates blastema cell proliferation.

Amphibian FGF-1 is structurally and functionally similar to but antigenically distinguishable from its mammalian counterpart

Recent studies have shown that fibroblast growth factors (FGF) play an important role in the diverse cellular mechanisms involved with vertebrate development. One system which has received a great deal of attention is the developing limb in part because of the extensive epithelial-mesenchymal interactions that take place during this process. Because it closely parallels the developmental process of the limb and is a model for wound repair, the phenomenon of amphibian limb regeneration has been used to investigate the role of FGF in these processes. We have recently reported on the cloning and functional characterization of an FGF receptor (FGFR) isolated from amphibian regenerative tissue. In this report, we describe the isolation and characterization of an FGF-1 molecule from the newt, Notophthalmus viridescens. Amino acid sequence comparisons indicate that the newt FGF-1 exhibits between 79 to 83% identity with FGF-1 from mammalian and avian species. The full length cDNA of the newt FGF-1 was cloned into a prokaryotic expression vector and purified from E. coli. Although the newt FGF-1 shares a high degree of primary amino acid sequence similarity with other FGF-1 molecules, the recombinant protein was not detected in a Western blot analysis using a polyclonal antibody directed against mammalian FGF-1. Despite the antigenic divergence, the newt FGF-1 was capable of binding to NIH/3T3 and Chinese hamster ovary cells overexpressing mammalian and amphibian FGFRs with dissociation constants comparable to those reported for mammalian FGF-1. Newt FGF-1 could also be cross-linked to receptors on the surface of NIH/3T3 cells. In addition, it elicits a mitogenic response in NIH/3T3 cells indistinguishable from human recombinant FGF-1.

Regeneration of organs and tissues in lower vertebrates during and after space flight

In this paper most important data obtained in studies on the effect of space flight conditions on regeneration in the adult newt are summarized. We demonstrate a phenomenon of synchronization of limb and lens regeneration and increase in its rate during and after space flight. We also describe a peculiarities of cell proliferation in lens, limb and tail regenerates and of the process of minced muscle regeneration.

Conservation of ligand specificity between the mammalian and amphibian fibroblast growth factor receptors

We have previously cloned and sequenced a newt keratinocyte growth factor receptor (KGFR) cDNA which exhibited a unique spatial and temporal expression pattern in the regenerating newt limb. In this report, we further characterize the biochemical and functional properties of this newt KGFR. A stable Chinese hamster ovary transfectant overexpressing the newt KGFR was capable of binding both 125I-fibroblast growth factor-1 (FGF-1) and 125I-FGF-7 but not 125I-FGF-2, indistinguishable from the human KGFR. Scatchard analysis and cross-linking studies further support the conclusion that FGF-1 and FGF-7 are the ligands for the newt KGFR. In addition to their ability to bind to FGFs, both the human and the newt KGFR are also capable of repressing differentiation in mouse MM14 myoblasts. MM14 cells express FGFR1 and are repressed from differentiation by FGF-1, FGF-2, and FGF-4 but not FGF-7. Co-transfection of MM14 cells with either a human or newt KGFR expression construct conferred a response to FGF-7 as determined by a human alpha-cardiac actin/luciferase reporter construct. The response to FGF-7 was similar to the endogenous FGF response as FGF-7 prevented MM14 myoblasts from undergoing terminal differentiation. Thus, both the human and the newt KGFRs transduce signals similar to those transduced via the endogenous mouse FGFR1. Together these data indicate that this newly isolated newt KGFR is a functional receptor as it binds two FGF family members with high affinity and mediates signaling in skeletal muscle myoblasts. Because the binding pattern of the newt KGFR is similar to the pattern observed for its mammalian counterpart, it emphasizes the strict conservation that this ligand/receptor system has undergone through evolution.

Re-programming of expression of the KGFR and bek variants of fibroblast growth factor receptor 2 during limb regeneration in newts (Notophthalmus viridescens)

We have previously shown, by in situ hybridization, that fibroblast growth factor receptor 2 (FGFR2) is present in the basal layer of wound epithelium during limb regeneration in newts (Notophthalmus viridescens). In contrast, FGFR1 expression is observed throughout the blastema mesenchyme but is distinctly absent from the wound epithelium (Poulin et al. [1993] Development 119:353-361). Sequence analysis revealed that we have isolated both the KGFR and bek variants of FGFR2. These two variants differ only in the second half of the last of their three (or two) Ig-like domains. In this report, we show the expression patterns of FGFR2 variants during limb regeneration by in situ hybridization. During the pre-blastema stages of regeneration, FGFR2 expression was observed in the basal layer of the wound epithelium and in the cells of the periosteum. The wound epithelial hybridization was observed when the KGFR-specific probe was used while the bek-specific probe hybridized to mRNA in the cells of the periosteum. As regeneration progresses to the blastema stages, KGFR expression continued to be observed in the basal layer of the wound epithelium with additional hybridization seen in the blastema mesenchyme closely associated with the bisected bones. The bek-specific hybridization pattern observed at this stage corresponds specifically to the mesenchymal hybridization. In the differentiation stages of regeneration, the mesenchymal expression of FGFR2 becomes restricted to the cells of the condensing cartilage and later to the perichondrium. Interestingly, there appears to be a dorsoventral gradient of the expression of both KGFR and bek variants of FGFR2, which are opposite each other at the later stages of regeneration. Thus, re-programming of expression of the two FGFR2 variants is required during the initial wound closure of limb regeneration. Remarkably, the expression patterns of KGFR and bek mimic those observed in the mouse limb bud during early embryonic development (Orr-Urtreger et al. [1993] Dev. Biol. 18:475-486). Moreover, our results suggest that the two FGFR2 variants have distinct roles in limb regeneration. Further investigation regarding the potential sources of the FGF ligands will help establish the roles that FGFs and FGFRs play in limb regeneration.

Differential expression of myogenic regulatory genes and Msx-1 during dedifferentiation and redifferentiation of regenerating amphibian limbs

An amputated limb of an adult urodele amphibian is capable of undergoing regeneration. The new structures form from an undifferentiated mass of cells called the regenerative blastema. The cells of the blastema are believed to derive from differentiated tissues of the adult limb. However, the exact source of these cells and the process by which they undergo dedifferentiation are poorly understood. In order to elucidate the molecular and cellular basis for dedifferentiation we isolated a number of genes which are potential regulators of the process. These include Msx-1, which is believed to support the undifferentiated and proliferative state of cells in the embryonic limb bud; and two members of the myogenic regulatory gene family, MRF-4 and Myf-5, which are expressed in differentiated muscle and regulate muscle-specific gene activity. As anticipated, we find that Msx-1 is strongly up-regulated during the initiation of regeneration. It remains expressed throughout regeneration but is not found in the fully regenerated limb. The myogenic gene MRF-4 has the reverse expression pattern. It is expressed in adult limb muscle, is rapidly shut off in early regenerative blastemas, and is only reexpressed at the completion of regeneration. These kinetics are paralleled by those of a muscle-specific Myosin gene. In contrast Myf-5, a second member of the myogenic gene family, continues to be expressed throughout the regenerative process. Thus, MRF-4 and Myf-5 are likely to play distinct roles during regeneration. MRF-4 may directly regulate muscle phenotype and as such its repression may be a key event in dedifferentiation.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

Nucleotide sequences of two newt (Notophthalmus viridescens) fibroblast growth factor receptor-2 variants

The FGF receptor tyrosine kinase family consists of four members. We report the sequence of two newt (Notophthalmus viridescens) FGFR2 cDNAs which were isolated from a forelimb blastema cDNA library and represent the newt cognates of two different isoforms of FGFR2, one homologous to bek the other to the KGFR.

Heterogeneity in the expression of fibroblast growth factor receptors during limb regeneration in newts (Notophthalmus viridescens)

Two closely related fibroblast growth factor receptors, FGFR1 and FGFR2, have been cloned from a newt (Notophthalmus viridescens) limb blastema cDNA library. Sequence analysis revealed that we have isolated both the bek and KGFR variants of FGFR2. These two variants differ only in the second half of the last of their three Ig-like domains. The expression patterns of FGFR1 and FGFR2 during limb regeneration have been determined by in situ hybridization. During the preblastema stages of regeneration, FGFR2 expression is observed in the basal layer of the wound epithelium and in the cells of the periosteum. As regeneration progresses to the blastema stages, FGFR2 expression continues to be observed in the basal layer of the wound epithelium with additional hybridization seen in the blastema mesenchyme closely associated with the bisected bones. From the early bud to the mid-bud blastema stage, FGFR1 expression is observed throughout the blastema mesenchyme but, unlike FGFR2, is distinctly absent from the wound epithelium. In the differentiation stages of regeneration, the mesenchymal expression of FGFR2 becomes restricted to the cells of the condensing cartilage and later to the perichondrium. During these later stages of regeneration, the wound epithelium hybridization to the FGFR2 probe is no longer observed. The expression patterns of these receptors suggest that FGFR1 and FGFR2 have distinct roles in limb regeneration, despite their sharing a number of the FGF ligands. Further investigation regarding the potential sources of the FGF ligands will help establish the role that FGFs and FGFRs play in limb regeneration.

Release of basic fibroblast growth factor, an angiogenic factor devoid of secretory signal sequence: a trivial phenomenon or a novel secretion mechanism?

Basic fibroblast growth factor (bFGF), a potent angiogenesis inducer, lacks a signal sequence. Therefore, it has been proposed that bFGF is primarily released from dead or damaged cells. Other proteins devoid of secretion signals, interleukin 1 beta (IL-1 beta) and the muscle lectin L-14, have been shown to be released via exocytosis, a novel secretion pathway independent of the "classic" endoplasmic reticulum-Golgi route. In the light of these findings and of our own recent results, we discuss evidence that bFGF can be released from single, uninjured cells and mediate functions in an autocrine manner. As is the case for IL-1 beta and L-14, externalization of bFGF may occur via exocytosis, a pathway utilized during development and differentiation.

Acidic fibroblast growth factor is present in regenerating limb blastemas of axolotls and binds specifically to blastema tissues

The growth of regenerating limbs of amphibians depends upon proliferation of the blastema cells that accumulate beneath the epidermal cap. The epidermal cap is known to be mitogenic for the blastema cells. We have extracted a mitogenic activity from both the mesenchymal and epidermal (epidermal cap) components of cone stage blastemas which is retained on heparin-Sepharose and elutes with 1.15 M NaCl. This fraction stimulates neurite outgrowth of PC12 cells and [3H]thymidine incorporation into CCL 39 cells and is potentiated by heparin. The 2 M fraction was inactive. The heparin-Sepharose-purified growth factor cross-reacts with bovine acidic FGF polyclonal antibodies and shows a Mr of 16,000 on Western blots. Blastema membranes contain specific high affinity binding sites (Kd = 25 pM; capacity = 30 fmole/mg protein) and low affinity binding sites (Kd = 18 nM; capacity = 30 pmole/mg protein) for aFGF as revealed by Scatchard analysis. 125I-aFGF which is bound specifically by both the epidermal cap and mesenchyme of blastema frozen sections is displaced by an excess of unlabeled factor and inhibited by heparin. Heparinase treatment and 2 M NaCl washing which decreased the binding was fourfold more efficient for epidermal cap than for mesenchyme suggesting the presence of high affinity receptors in the latter tissue. The presence of aFGF (or a closely related molecule) in blastemas is consistent with our earlier results that showed stimulation of proliferation of cultured blastema cells by acidic or basic FGF or heparin alone. These results suggest the possibility that aFGF is stored in the epidermal cap during limb regeneration and that it stimulates the proliferation of the underlaying mesenchyme.

In vitro control of blastema cell proliferation by extracts from epidermal cap and mesenchyme of regenerating limbs of axolotls

The presence of a mitogenic activity in limb blastemas of axolotls was detected in crude extracts of blastemas at the mid-bud stage. The mitogenicity of the extracts was estimated from the mitotic index of blastema cells grown for 6 days in the presence of limb blastema extracts, with colchicine present for the last 2 days. All the extracts tested (whole blastema, blastemal mesenchyme, epidermal cap) significantly enhanced proliferation of blastema cells. The highest stimulation factors we observed were 7 × with 7 μg protein/ml whole blastema extracts, 5.2 × with 14 μg/ml blastemal mesenchyme extracts, and 11 x with 3.5 μg/ml epidermal cap extracts. Hence the epidermal cap extracts appeared to be the most mitogenic. Extracts from the blastemal mesenchyme, although less mitogenic than the epidermal cap extracts, were more potent than nerve extracts [Albert P, Boilly B (1986) Biol Cell 58:251-262]. These results are discussed with regard to the production of growth factors during limb regeneration.

Bioengineered human growth hormone supports limb regeneration in the hypophysectomized newt Notophthalmus viridescens

It is well documented that growth hormone (GH) replacement therapy will restore normal limb regeneration to hypophysectomized adult newts. However, it is also known that the GH preparations used in previous reports were contaminated by other pituitary hormones shown to support regeneration when administered free of GH. The recent availability of bioengineered human GH was studied for its ability to restore the regenerative capacity to hypophysectomized newts. Five days posthypophysectomy adult newts were subject to forelimb amputation distal to the elbow. Animals were divided into three groups (n greater than 20). Each received one of three GH preparations: pituitary-derived bovine GH, pituitary-derived human GH, or bioengineered human GH. GH was administered via intraperitoneal injection (0.029 IU/50 microliters) on alternate days for either the first 5 days (total of 3 injections) or for 35 days (total of 18 injections). Pituitary-intact and hypophysectomized control newts were subjected to forelimb amputation and injected with hormone diluent. All newts that received GH demonstrated normal limb regeneration to the early digitiform stage by 35 days postamputation. None of the hypophysectomized control newts showed any evidence of regeneration. We conclude that GH alone can restore the ability to undergo normal limb regeneration to hypophysectomized newts.

Production in vitro by spinal cord of growth factor(s) acting on newt limb regeneration: influence of regeneration of the nerve fibers

In order to approach the problem of regulation of growth factor(s) production during limb regeneration in newt, we co-cultivated spinal cord segments and blastemas. First we showed that, like the sensory supply, the spinal cord possesses size-dependent mitogenic capacities for limb blastemas. A 5-mm long spinal segment enhances radiolabelled thymidine incorporation to the same extent as spinal ganglia (1.6-fold). Second, we co-cultivated blastemas with spinal segments, the nerve fibers of which were previously stimulated to regenerate (= stimulated spinal segment) or not (= non-stimulated spinal segment). Only after a 24-h coculture, do stimulated spinal segments enhance thymidine incorporation in blastemas 2-fold more than non-stimulated spinal segments. Our results suggest that during limb regeneration brachial nerves produce more growth factor(s) when regrowing, inducing the proliferation of blastema cells which in return deliver a neuronotrophic factor acting on these nerves.

Stimulation in cell culture of mesenchymal cells of newt limb blastemas by EDGF I or II (basic or acidic FGF)

After amputation of a newt limb, a blastema forms on the amputation plane and later differentiates to regenerate all the missing parts of the limb. Proliferation of blastema cells is under the control of severed nerves which deliver a 'neurotrophic factor' (NTF) of unknown nature. In order to characterize this factor we use a primary culture of blastema mesenchymal cells; changes in mitotic index after 48-h colchicine treatment indicate mitogenic activity of potential growth substances. These cells, which are stimulated by nerve extracts (mitotic index X 6), were tested with two purified growth factors extracted from bovine retina or brain (EDGF I = basic FGF and EDGF II = acidic FGF). We show that these two growth factors stimulate proliferation of blastema cell cultures in a dose-dependent manner. Maximal stimulation was obtained at 3 pM for EDGF I (mitotic index X 5.7) or 300 pM for EDGF II (mitotic index X 4.9). So it appears that these two growth factors have a mitogenic activity on blastema mesenchymal cells similar to that obtained with nerve extracts. The fact that two different growth factors can stimulate these cells raises the question of whether both are present in NTF and/or whether there are receptors to both EDGF I and EDGF II on mesenchymal cell membranes.

Glial growth factor and nerve-dependent proliferation in the regeneration blastema of Urodele amphibians

After amputation of a limb from Urodele amphibians, division of the blastemal cells (the progenitor cells of the regenerate) depends on one or more unidentified growth factors provided by the nerve supply. Here we show that glial growth factor (GGF), a mitogenic protein previously purified from the bovine pituitary, is present in newt nervous system extracts. It is also detectable in extracts of the forelimb regeneration blastema, and its level there decreases after denervation. We have previously shown that blastemal cells dependent on the nerve for division are marked by a monoclonal antibody called 22/18. When denervated blastemas are cultured in the presence of partially purified GGF from newt brain, or pure GGF from the bovine pituitary, the thymidine labeling index of blastemal cells that are 22/18-positive is increased as much as sevenfold. These data indicate that GGF plays a role in nerve-dependent proliferation in the blastema.

Changes in the extracellular matrix and glycosaminoglycan synthesis during the initiation of regeneration in adult newt forelimbs

The extracellular matrix (ECM) of the distal tissues in a newt limb stump is completely reorganized in the 2-3-week period following amputation. In view of numerous in vitro studies showing that extracellular material influences cellular migration and proliferation, it is likely that the changes in the limb's ECM are important activities in the process leading to regeneration of such limbs. Using biochemical, autoradiographic, and histochemical techniques we studied temporal and spatial differences in the synthesis of glycosaminoglycans (GAGs) during the early, nerve-dependent phase of limb regeneration. Hyaluronic acid synthesis began with the onset of tissue dedifferentiation, became maximal within 1 weeks, and continued throughout the period of active cell proliferation. Chondroitin sulfate synthesis began somewhat later, increased steadily, and reached very high levels during chondrogenesis. During the first 10 days after amputation, distributions of sulfated and nonsulfated GAGs were both uniform throughout dedifferentiating tissues, except for a heavier localization near the bone. Since nerves are necessary to promote the regenerative process, we examined the neural influence on synthesis and accumulation of extracellular GAGs. Denervation decreased GAG production in all parts of the limb stump by approximately 50%. Newt dorsal root ganglia and brain-derived fibroblast growth factor each produced twofold stimulation of GAG synthesis in cultured 7-day regenerates. The latter effect was primarily on synthesis of hyaluronic acid. The results indicate that the trophic action of nerves on amphibian limb regeneration includes a positive influence on synthesis and extracellular accumulation of GAGs. Since the ECM exerts a major influence on cellular proliferation and migration, the effect of nerves on GAG metabolism may have considerable importance for growth and development of the early regenerate.

Pattern-deficient forelimb regeneration in adult bullfrogs

This study was designed to test the ability of adult bullfrogs (Rana catesbeiana) to regenerate forelimbs, both with and without various experimental treatments. Distal humerus-level forelimb amputations provided with additional deviated (sciatic) nerve and/or repeated soft-tissue injury exhibited considerable outgrowth. However, control sham-operated forelimbs also produced regenerates with comparable frequency, size, and morphological complexity. The lengths of the regenerates ranged from 0.4 to 2.6 cm, representing an outgrowth of 10-65% of the portion removed by the distal humerus amputation plane; some regenerates exhibited an external morphology indicative of digitlike structures. Some outgrowths were flexible but only one was capable of independent movement. Victoria Blue staining of whole regenerates revealed a variety of internal cartilage elements. Staining showed a single solid mass of cartilage in some regenerates while others had several individual and variably shaped cartilages projecting distally. Histological analysis also revealed the presence of connective tissue, striated muscle, and abundant nerve fibers in addition to the individual cartilage elements. We have tentatively termed these responses pattern-deficient regeneration.

Partial purification of a low-molecular-weight growth factor from chicken brain

The regenerating amphibian limb serves as a useful model for studying factors influencing cell proliferation and differentiation. In particular, peripheral nerves are thought to provide a stimulus for growth of the blastema, presumably via the elaboration of an as yet unidentified neurotrophic factor. In the present study, pressure ultrafiltration coupled with chromatofocusing have proven to be effective methods of partially purifying a neurotrophic factor from adult chicken brains. This chick brain growth factor (CBGF) appears to be a heat-stable, basic peptide of low molecular weight (less than 6,000). It is a potent mitogen in vitro, at nanomolar concentrations, for both blastema cells and Swiss mouse 3T3 fibroblasts. CBGF is apparently distinct from other peptide mitogens and/or neuromodulators that have been reported to stimulate blastema growth in vivo and in vitro. These include substance P, FGF from bovine brain and pituitary, EGF, transferrin (sciatin), and spinal cord growth factor (SCGF). The possible relationship of CBGF to other neural regulatory molecules is discussed.

A nonmitogenic pituitary function of fibroblast growth factor: regulation of thyrotropin and prolactin secretion

The addition of fibroblast growth factor (FGF) to primary cultures of rat anterior pituitary cells modifies their response to thyrotropin-releasing factor in a dose-dependent manner. While the pituitary response to the other releasing factors (corticotropin-releasing factor, growth hormone-releasing factor, and gonadotropin-releasing factor) is not altered, FGF increases both the sensitivity of the cells to thyrotropin-releasing factor and the amounts of prolactin and thyrotropin released. A minimum of 24 hr of preincubation with FGF is required to modify the pituitary response, and maximal effects were observed with 48 and 72 hr of preincubation. The effective doses of FGF are similar to those described for its mitogenic activity (i.e., 1-100 pM), but inhibition of cell growth with 5-fluorodeoxyuridine does not modify the effect of FGF on thyrotropin and prolactin release. These results suggest a novel paracrine, if not autocrine, role of pituitary FGF in the homeostatic mechanisms that regulate the secretion of prolactin and thyrotropin. They also suggest that the biological significance of the presence of FGF in various tissues may not be directly related to its in vitro mitogenic activity.

Radioimmunoassay for fibroblast growth factor (FGF): release by the bovine anterior pituitary in vitro

A radioimmunoassay (RIA) was developed to measure fibroblast growth factor (FGF) using antiserum generated against a synthetic replicate of [Tyr10]FGF(1-10). The antisera, previously shown to be capable of inhibiting the biological action of FGF on bovine aortic arch endothelial cells in vitro, are highly specific for the amino-terminus of FGF. In the RIA, the antisera recognize the decapeptide antigen [Tyr10]FGF(1-10) and the intact mitogen on an equimolar basis and show less than 0.01% cross-reactivity with N-acetyl-[Tyr10]FGF(1-10). Bovine adenohypophysial cells maintained in primary monolayer culture release and ir-FGF which is indistinguishable from the intact mitogen in as much as it is retained on heparin-Sepharose affinity columns and shows a dose-dependent and parallel displacement in RIA. The release of ir-FGF by the bovine adenohypophysis can be increased with forskolin (10(-5) M) or KCl (50 mM). Preincubation of pituitary cells with 17 beta-estradiol has no measurable effects on basal ir-FGF, but increases the release after KCl treatment 2-3-fold. These results show that ir-FGF can be released by the bovine adenohypophysis in vitro and lend credence to the hypothesis that FGF plays a physiological role in the homeostatic mechanisms regulating mesoderm-derived cell growth.

Temporal analysis of the role of growth hormone in the initiation and maintenance of limb regeneration in the hypophysectomized newt Notophthalmus viridescens

This study was designed to investigate and determine for how long, after either hypophysectomy or the third (last) growth hormone injection (to previously hypophysectomized newts), the circulating and now declining titers of endogenous or exogenous hormone remained at a sufficient concentration to permit a morphologically normal forelimb regeneration response in the adult newt Notophthalmus viridescens. To examine the declining levels of endogenous hormone (hormone withdrawal series [HW]), left forelimbs were amputated at specific times following hypophysectomy. Right forelimbs were amputated 5 days prior to hypophysectomy. The declining levels of exogenous hormone (hormone replacement series [HR] were examined in newts whose left forelimbs were amputated at specific times following the last of three consecutive alternate-day growth hormone injections that were initiated 5 days post hypophysectomy. Right forelimbs were amputated immediately following the first hormone injection. All experimental animals were sacrificed when their right forelimbs regenerated to an advanced digitiform regenerate. In both series right forelimbs regenerated normally. In the HW series normal regeneration resulted only when forelimbs were amputated within 48 hours post hypophysectomy, whereas in the HR series normal regeneration occurred in only those newts whose forelimbs were amputated within 12 hours of the last hormone injection. The regeneration response of left forelimbs in both series gradually declined with the time interval between either hypophysectomy or hormone injection and forelimb amputation. As the hormone titer declined, fewer limbs initiated a normal response; they became progressively more hypomorphic and eventually failed to undergo typical regeneration.

Immunoreactive fibroblast growth factor in cells of peritoneal exudate suggests its identity with macrophage-derived growth factor

Peritoneal exudate cells were collected from thioglycollate stimulated mice, extracted an examined for the presence of immunoreactive and bioactive fibroblast growth factor (FGF). The crude extract stimulated in a dose dependent fashion the proliferation of vascular endothelial cells derived from the bovine aortic arch. The extract also showed a parallel and dose-dependent inhibition of binding in a highly specific radioimmunoassay for FGF. The immunoreactive FGF (ir-FGF) contained in the extract was retained on a heparin-sepharose affinity column as is characteristic of pituitary FGF. Reverse-phase HPLC of the macrophage-derived material reveals one biologically active form of FGF which coelutes with the major form of immunoreactivity. The results demonstrate the presence of FGF in these cells and suggest that at least one of the hitherto unidentified mitotic activities in these extracts is due to a mitogen indistinguishable from FGF.

Mitogenic growth factors and nerve dependence of limb regeneration

Regeneration of the amphibian limb after amputation depends on division of blastemal cells, the progenitor cells of the regenerate. This division is controlled, at least in the early stages of regeneration, by the nerve supply to the blastema. A monoclonal antibody to newt blastema cells has provided evidence that Schwann cells and muscle fibers contribute to the blastema, and identifies blastemal cells whose division is persistently dependent on the nerve. Glial growth factor, a molecule identified by its action on rat Schwann cells, is present in the newt blastema and is lost on denervation.

Soluble age-related factors from skeletal muscle which influence muscle development

Successful regeneration of damaged striated muscle in adult mice is dependent on the regeneration of newly differentiated myofibers from proliferating satellite cells and inhibition of scar tissue formation by fibroblasts. As with most tissues, the ability of skeletal muscle to regenerate decreases in older animals. In this study, we have analysed soluble extracts from intact and regenerating skeletal muscle from mice of different ages for their ability to affect avian myogenesis in tissue culture. We were interested in determining whether an age-dependent difference could be detected with this tissue culture bioassay system. Total cell proliferation in the cultures, measured by [3H]thymidine incorporation was increased equally by muscle extracts from both young and older mice but the resulting cell populations differed in proportion of cell types. The ratio of myoblasts to fibroblasts was significantly greater in cultures exposed to extracts from younger mouse muscle as compared with cultures exposed to extracts from older animals. This age-related activity was found to reside in a low molecular weight (MW) (greater than 12 kD) component of the extract. This fraction had dissimilar effects on myoblasts and fibroblasts. Relative to saline controls, myoblast proliferation was increased and fibroblast proliferation decreased. The low MW fraction from younger mouse muscle extracts stimulated myogenic cell proliferation and myotube formation to a greater extent than the similar fraction prepared from older mouse muscle. Conversely, younger mouse muscle fractions had significantly greater inhibitory activity against fibroblast proliferation than did older mouse muscle fractions.

Regulation of skeletal muscle satellite cell proliferation by bovine pituitary fibroblast growth factor

Satellite cells in skeletal muscle have been implicated in muscle growth processes and regeneration. However, very little is known about the regulation of their proliferation and differentiation. The effect of fibroblast growth factor (FGF) on the proliferation of myogenic cells from adult rat skeletal muscle, presumably satellite cells, has been examined, and FGF has been found to be a potent mitogen for these cells. The mitogenic properties of serum were also documented and studied in conjunction with FGF. Even under conditions of maximal stimulation by serum, the addition of FGF caused a substantial increase in proliferation of satellite cells. The additive nature of the FGF and serum-stimulatory activity suggests that FGF-like molecules are not the active agents in serum and that more than one pathway may be involved in stimulating satellite cell proliferation.

Role of polypeptide growth factors in normal and abnormal growth

In the preceding sections we have shown evidence that growth-promoting factors are involved in three basic situations. In normal embryonic development and function of mature organisms, growth factors such as NGF and EGF are of prime importance in supporting the necessary embryonic cell proliferation and the development of specific cell types. Other factors operate on subsets of mature cells during specialized functions such as inflammation. Included in this set would be factors such as CSF/MGF and Interleukin-2. Another basic function of growth factors has been shown to be wound repair and organ regeneration. This includes the well characterized PDGF and FGF as well as the various renotropic factors and liver growth factors. As these factors must operate in mature organisms with many different cell types and similar cell types in many locations, more specificity is needed than in embryonic growth. This has resulted in the organ specific factors such as the renotropins and in the unique delivery system of the PDGF. The recent discovery and characterization of the transforming growth factors has provided a possible connection between embryonic and normal developmental growth and the rapid cellular proliferation characteristic of tumor cells. The TGF not only interacts with receptors for normal growth factors such as EGF but are also detectable in low levels in normal tissue and embryos. The exact relationships between these various factors will have to await the determinations of more amino acid sequences for comparisons. The other tumor-related product, tumor angiogenesis factor, is also found in normal tissue and inflammatory reaction sites.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

Effect of purified growth factors on rabbit articular chondrocytes in monolayer culture. II. Sulfated proteoglycan synthesis

The effect of 3 purified peptide growth factors--platelet-derived growth factor (PDGF), epidermal growth factor (EGF), pituitary fibroblast growth factor (FGF)--heat-inactivated fetal bovine serum (FBS), insulin, and 0.2 mM ascorbate on synthesis of sulfated proteoglycan by rabbit articular chondrocytes was studied in monolayer culture. Growth of the cells increased linearly as the concentration of heat-inactivated FBS rose from 0 to 30%. Glycosaminoglycan (GAG) synthesis (35SO4/micrograms DNA) was enhanced as the concentration of heat-inactivated FBS went from 0 to 5%. At higher levels of serum, radiosulfate incorporation declined progressively. Two modes of study of the test factors were used: 1) the dose of the factor was increased while the serum concentration was fixed at a low basal level (1% heat-inactivated FBS); 2) the dose of the test factor was kept constant but the level of heat-inactivated FBS varied from 0 to 10%. There was an inverse relationship between GAG and DNA synthesis when proliferation of cells was increased by EGF and platelet lysate. PDGF (1 U/ml) stimulated radiosulfate incorporation as well as DNA formation in the serum-free medium; the values for GAG synthesis did not increase as the serum concentration increased, but the cell mass did. The action of FGF was intermediate between that of EGF and PDGF: with 50 ng FGF/ml, increasing concentrations of serum caused a large progressive reduction of radiosulfate incorporation as growth was stimulated. In basal medium, however, FGF caused mild enhancement of GAG synthesis. Insulin increased aggregatable proteoglycan production far out of proportion to its growth-promoting activity in the presence of 1% heat-inactivated FBS. The response was effaced when higher concentrations of serum were employed. Ascorbate had a unique anabolic effect, increasing both cell growth and proteoglycan synthesis that is not suppressed by higher concentrations of serum. The content of serum and its several peptide and hormonal components thus have divergent effects on growth and proteoglycan synthesis in cell culture. This phenomenon must be taken into account in studying biochemical processes and pharmacologic reactions of articular chondrocytes in vitro.

Mitogens for glial cells: a comparison of the response of cultured astrocytes, oligodendrocytes and Schwann cells

We have identified two growth factors for cultured rat astrocytes: fibroblast growth factor, a peptide derived from either whole bovine brain, or pituitaries, and a growth factor in extracts of bovine pituitary which was previously identified as a Schwann cell mitogen. Oligodendrocytes in primary cultures derived from neonatal rat central nervous system divide only rarely if at all. These growth factors did not stimulate primary oligodendrocytes to divide. Occasionally cells found in suspension in long-term cultures of the central nervous system were enriched for cells which were identified as oligodendrocytes by the presence of galactocerebroside on their surface and myelin basic protein in their cytoplasm. When provided with a monolayer of irradiated 3T3 cells, these oligodendrocytes were able to spread out and extend elaborate branched processes typical of oligodendrocytes in the primary cultures. Unlike their counterparts in the primary cultures, these suspension-derived oligodendrocytes are capable of cell division as demonstrated by the uptake of [3H]thymidine and autoradiography.

Newt forelimb regeneration blastemas in vitro: cellular response to explanation and effects of various growth-promoting substances

Macromolecular synthesis was studied in cultured newt forelimb blastemas. Late bud stage blastemas were explanted into organ culture and thus denervated. When the response of the blastemas to explantation was examined, it was found that a peak in 3H-leucine incorporation occurred at 2 hr of incubation, and a similar peak in 3H-thymidine incorporation occurred at 3-4 hr. After these initial increases, both parameters declined to levels lower than those determined at the time of explantation. The peaks in macromolecular synthesis reported here in vitro are similar to those observed in blastemas in vivo after denervation (Singer, '74). In the second part of the study, the ability of various growth-promoting substances to stimulate DNA synthesis in cultured blastemas was investigated. Increasing concentrations of fetal bovine serum caused increased levels of 3H-thymidine incorporation, with maximal stimulation at 30% serum. Newt brain extract (NBVE) was as effective as additional serum, with optimal stimulation at 100 micrograms total NBE protein per ml culture medium. Fibroblast growth factor (FGF), derived from brain tissue, at a concentration of 10 ng/ml was as effective as both 30% serum and the optimal concentration of NBE. Epidermal growth factor (EGF) produced a maximal effect at 1 ng/ml. Neither nerve growth factor nor the platelet-derived growth factor were stimulatory. Bovine insulin was highly active in stimulating DNA synthesis at concentrations from 1-10 micrograms/ml. The requirement of nerves for blastemal development, as well as the possible roles of the various growth-promoting substances in this process, are discussed.