The role of the T acceptor cell in suppressor systems. Antigen-specific T suppressor factor acts via a T acceptor cell; this releases a nonspecific inhibitor of the transfer of contact sensitivity when exposed to antigen in the context of I-J

Down-regulation of adoptive adjuvant-induced arthritis by suppressor factor(s)

We recently described a method for inducing immunologic tolerance to trinitrochlorobenzene (TNCB), a hapten that generates suppressor cells capable of down-regulating the efferent phase of TNP-specific contact hypersensitivity in rats. Peritoneal exudate cells (PEC) of such tolerized rats, upon being triggered by specific hapten, suppressed contact hypersensitivity to another hapten elicited at the same time. This implied that cells that mediate delayed-type hypersensitivity of any specificity might be down-regulated, provided that the suppressor cells are activated with specific antigen and that the unrelated delayed-type hypersensitivity is elicited in parallel. To rigorously test this possibility, we examined the ability of TNP-specific suppressor lymphoid cell factors to affect cells that mediate adoptively transferable adjuvant-induced arthritis (AIA) in rats. To induce arthritis, spleen cells from Freund's complete adjuvant-injected rats were stimulated with concanavalin A and administered to naive recipients. Prior to adoptive transfer, the cells were exposed for brief intervals to supernatants of lymphoid cells from control and hapten-tolerized rats. Supernatants of PEC and lymph node cells from hapten-tolerized rats were found to markedly reduce the effectiveness of cells that mediate AIA. The hapten-tolerized cells required reexposure to hapten prior to preparation of the supernatants. Supernatants of spleen cells from hapten-tolerized rats that had been hapten-painted as well as hapten-triggered and supernatants of lymph node cells and of PEC from only hapten-painted or hapten-triggered rats were ineffective in altering the AIA. Thus, factors from suppressor cells induced toward hapten-coupled self-antigens have been found to adversely affect the function of lymphoid cells that mediate a totally unrelated inflammatory response, namely, AIA. The clinical implications of these findings are discussed.

Immunosuppression in murine renal cell carcinoma. I. Characterization of extent, severity and sources

Four cell-mediated immunological responses related to tumor elimination have been examined in mice injected with a transplantable renal cell carcinoma (Renca). Lymphokine-activated killer (LAK) cells generated in vitro from spleen cells of normal mice were capable of attacking Renca, EL-4, P815 and YAC-1 targets, but those from mice bearing Renca for 3 weeks could not. Natural killer activity, stimulated in vivo by administering poly(I) poly(C), was less than 50% of normal in Renca-bearing hosts. In addition, development of cytotoxic T lymphocytes to allogeneic targets was markedly inhibited in mice possessing the renal tumor. Finally, the delayed hypersensitivity response to a dermally applied hapten was approximately 70% less than normal in tumor-bearing mice, no matter whether the tumor existed subcutaneously or intrarenally. A kinetic study of the development of non-responsiveness using the LAK assay showed onset of poor response at 1 week, which became maximal within 3 weeks following receipt of tumor subcutaneously. The immunological depression was seen to be attributable in part to suppressor cells present among spleen cells but not bone marrow cells of tumor-bearing hosts. The suppressor cells prevented in vitro LAK generation by normal spleen cells and, when adoptively transferred to normal mice, they inhibited natural killer stimulation and delayed hypersensitivity generation. Another source of immunological down-regulation was provided by Renca cells themselves. Incorporation of Renca cells that had been X-irradiated with 30,000 rad into cultures of normal and Renca-derived splenic cells suppressed replication of both almost completely. Furthermore, the presence of X-irradiated Renca cells in cultures of normal spleen cells prevented development of LAK cells. Thus, the suppression seen in Renca-bearing mice derives from multiple sources and whether each is in any way related to the other has been discussed. Identification of the phenotypes of cells responsible for the lymphoid cell-mediated suppression and examination of its elimination are communicated in the companion paper.

Role of macrophages in bypassing the inhibitory activity of Newcastle disease virus on the T-suppressor-cell circuit which regulates contact sensitivity to picryl chloride

The interaction between the paramyxovirus of Newcastle disease virus (NDV) and the T-suppressor-cell circuit which regulates the expression phase of contact sensitivity reaction to picryl chloride was investigated. NDV infection impairs the T-acceptor-cell (Tacc) activity, as demonstrated by the failure of Tacc from mice infected with NDV both on Day 0 and on Day 3 to release the nonspecific inhibitor of the passive transfer of contact sensitivity. Tacc from NDV-infected mice fail to bind appreciable amounts of exogenous T suppressor factor, so indicating that the virus eliminates this T-cell population. However, macrophages from mice infected with NDV are able to release a nonspecific inhibitor of the passive transfer of contact sensitivity, indicating that the inhibition of Tacc activity in mice infected with NDV is bypassed by macrophages, so that the T-suppressor circuit is functionally active in NDV-infected mice. The mechanism of the selective inhibition of the Tacc activity by NDV is discussed.

Calorie restriction modifies the delayed-type hypersensitivity response to the hapten trinitrobenzenesulfonic acid and to hapten-modified syngeneic spleen cells

We have studied the influence of different degrees of calorie restriction on the induction and the regulation of the delayed type hypersensitivity (DTH) response to trinitrobenzenesulfonic acid (TNBS) and TNBS-modified spleen cells (TNBS-SC), injected by the sc or the iv route. Immediately after weaning, BALB/c mice were placed on restricted diets for either 2 or 4 weeks and then the DTH response was induced. The results showed that a 37.5% restriction in the food supply significantly depressed the level of the DTH response induced by the sc injection of TNBS-SC. In contrast, a 25% restriction in the food supply was insufficient to depress the response. Calorie restriction did not modify the inhibitory influence of an iv injection of TNBS-SC on the DTH response. However, iv presensitization with free hapten or the simultaneous injection of TNBS-SC by the iv and the sc routes did not significantly depress the DTH response in calorie-restricted mice, indicating a defect in the inhibitory regulation of the DTH response in these dietary groups.

Possible mechanisms involved in the immunoregulation of chronic inflammatory periodontal disease

It is generally agreed that immunological mechanisms are involved in the pathogenesis of periodontal disease; however, regulation of these mechanisms has hitherto received scant attention. Regulatory networks exist at both a cellular and a molecular level. At the cellular level, the existence of helper (T4-positive) and suppressor (T8-positive) T lymphocytes, the expression of Class II major histocompatibility complex antigens, and the heterogeneity of macrophage subpopulations are central to an understanding of the regulatory mechanisms involved. It is only recently that studies of these separate components, in both humans and experimental animals, have begun to provide a basis for understanding the complex interactions occurring in periodontal disease. Studies using the human experimental gingivitis model have shown an immunoregulatory picture consistent with a controlled immunological reaction with an essentially normal T4:T8 ratio of 2.0. In contrast, studies utilizing cells extracted from adult periodontitis lesions have shown a reduced T4:T8 ratio (approximately 1.0) and an inability to respond in, or to stimulate, an autologous mixed lymphocyte reaction. Animal studies using athymic nude rats have supported the concept of a central role for T-cell control in periodontal disease and the possibility of an imbalance in this control with disease progression. These results are reviewed and areas of future research explored.

Mucosal induction of systemic T cell tolerance by Fusobacterium nucleatum

The present study was undertaken to determine if mucosal presentation of the periodontopathic bacterium Fusobacterium nucleatum could induce systemic tolerance. Two separate protocols of mucosal priming were carried out. In the first, mice were gastrically intubated on 2 consecutive days; this was repeated 5 days later. In the second protocol, mice were similarly primed but received another priming dose after a further 7 days. Positive control mice were similarly primed with sheep red blood cells (SRBC) while negative control animals were sham-primed with saline. Following mucosal priming, mice were systemically sensitized with the respective antigen and then subsequently challenged in the left hind footpad. The right footpad was challenged with saline and served as a negative control. Serum antibody levels were measured using enzyme-linked immunoabsorbent assay (ELISA) and haemagglutination assays. Mucosal priming with F. nucleatum was found to suppress the local delayed type hypersensitivity reaction as determined by footpad measurements. Sham-priming did not suppress the local response. On the other hand, the levels of serum antibodies were not influenced by mucosal priming. These results suggest that under the experimental conditions used, mucosal presentation of F. nucleatum can induce a degree of split tolerance in which T cell responses are suppressed while B cell responses remain intact. The implication of this finding to human periodontal disease is yet to be determined.

Nonspecific inhibitor of DNA synthesis elaborated by T-acceptor cells. II. Requirements for its production and action

The production of a nonspecific inhibitor of DNA synthesis (nsINH) appears to be one of the final events in the T-suppressor cell circuit in mice exposed to contact sensitizers. We report here that: The nsINH suppresses the proliferative response to a polyclonal T-cell mitogen, concanavalin A (Con A), regardless of the dose of Con A used. It also suppresses DNA synthesis in lymphoid cells stimulated with alloantigens. This suppression can be completely eliminated by adding exogenous interleukin 2 (IL-2). DNA synthesis in lymphoid cells exposed to nsINH before the proliferative stimulus is uninfluenced so that activation of the lymphoid cells at the same time as exposure to nsINH seems to be a requirement for its action. Since the activity of nsINH can be absorbed by activated Lyt-1+ or Lyt-2+ lymphocytes, the early activated T cell appears to be a target of the action of nsINH. The production of nsINH is abolished or severely reduced by adult thymectomy. Natural killer (NK) cells are resistant to nsINH action and no interferon (IFN)-like activity can be demonstrated in nsINH preparation using a conventional assay for IFN.

Selection of the delayed hypersensitivity T effector and T suppressor cell response by antigen-presenting macrophages

The T effector lymphocytes of delayed type hypersensitivity reactions (TDH) are regulated by a complex T suppressor (Ts) cell circuit. Induction of TDH cells requires Ia+ adherent cells as antigen-presenting cells. Little is known about the antigen presentation of the induction of Ts cells. We describe an experimental model in which TDH and Ts cells are induced separately by different antigen-presenting macrophages grown from bone marrow stem cells. Bone marrow derived macrophages grown in L cell-conditioned medium for various periods and labeled with 2,4-dinitrobenzene sulfonic acid differ in their ability to induce TDH and Ts cells in vitro. The functional activity of the two T subpopulations was assessed in vivo by epicutaneous challenge or sensitization with 2,4-dinitrofluorobenzene of mice receiving the in vitro educated cells. Ear swelling or suppression of swelling was recorded. It could be shown that 5-7 day bone marrow-derived DNP-labeled macrophages preferentially induced Thy 1+ Lyt 1+ antigen-specific TDH cells; 7-10 day old antigen-presenting bone marrow-derived macrophages induced preferentially Thy 1+ Lyt 2+ antigen specific Ts cells. Characterization of various phenotypic markers revealed different surface antigen expression and functional differences such as MIF responsiveness or transglutaminase activity on the two macrophage populations. These data support the concept that activation of the Ts regulatory circuit may require antigen presentation by specialized antigen presenting cells, characterized by certain surface and functional markers and different from those inducing preferentially TDH cells.

Selective induction of delayed hypersensitivity T-effector and T-suppressor lymphocytes in vitro by haptenized bone marrow-derived macrophages

The role of various subpopulations of antigen-presenting macrophages in the induction of T-lymphocyte subpopulations has been difficult to study in the past. We have used an in vitro system of bone marrow cell culture both to induce T-effector (TDH) and T-suppressor (Ts) cells active in delayed-type hypersensitivity. Bone marrow-derived macrophages (BM-MA) grown in Teflon bag cultures were allowed to attach to culture dishes and were pulse-labeled with 2,4-dinitrobenzene sulfonate (DNBSO3). Spleen cell lymphocytes from nonsensitized BALB/c mice were cocultured with antigen-pulsed or control BM-MA for 3 days. The lymphocytes were harvested, and injected iv into BALB/c mice which were challenged within 1 hr after injection by painting the right ear with 2,4-dinitrofluorobenzene (DNFB, effector test) or sensitized with DNFB on 2 days following iv injection of the cells and challenged 5 days later (suppressor test). Ear swelling was measured 24 hr later to assess the effector or suppressor function of the in vitro educated lymphocytes. BM-MA grown for 5 days (BM-MA 5) in L-cell conditioned medium induced only TDH cells (Thy 1+, Lyt 1+2-) whereas BM-MA grown for 10 days in conditioned medium induced only Ts cells (Thy 1+, Lyt 1-2+). In both cases, induced TDH and Ts cells were antigen specific. Functionally, induced Ts cells suppressed the afferent limb of the delayed response. When DNP-BM-MA 5 and DNP-BM-MA 10 were used to induce TDH or Ts cells in vivo by subcutaneous or intravenous injection respectively, only BM-MA 5 were able to sensitize recipient mice. Both 5- and 10-day macrophage populations induced Ts cells in vivo. Functionally, these Ts cells appeared to act on the efferent limb of the delayed reaction. We conclude that different populations of antigen-presenting macrophages can preferentially induce TDH or Ts cells, perhaps depending on antigen presentation in association with class II antigens or on the functional state of the antigen-presenting cell.

Characterization of two suppressor cells that together prevent in vivo development of cytolytic T cells to hapten-altered self

Two suppressor cell populations that interact to down-regulate in vivo development of the cytolytic T-cell (CTL) response to trinitrophenyl-modified syngeneic spleen cells (TNP-SC) have been further characterized. Suppressor cells induced by the iv injection of trinitrophenyl-modified syngeneic spleen cells possess Thy 1.2 antigen. Their precursors are insensitive to pretreatment of host animals with cyclophosphamide (CY). Suppressor cells that arise after dermal sensitization with trinitrochlorobenzene are also Thy 1.2 antigen positive but their precursors are sensitive to pretreatment with CY. These characteristics of the two suppressor T cells (Ts) are identical to those of the two Ts that are generated by similar methodologies and that together suppress contact sensitivity (CS) to picryl chloride. Neither the CS nor CTL response was suppressed when host animals possessed only one set of Ts. In contrast to suppression of CS at the efferent phase, development of CTL was suppressed only when the two Ts were present early during sensitization (afferent phase). Since the results point to several similarities between the two sets of Ts that are active in the down-regulation of the CS and CTL responses, it is suggested that the two dissimilar immune responses directed to the same hapten, namely CS and CTL, may be controlled by the same suppressor cells. Since it appears that the two sets of Ts interact to affect different phases of the CS and CTL responses, down-regulation of each must be accomplished through different mechanisms.

The role of I-J and Igh determinants on F1-derived suppressor factor in controlling restriction specificity

In the 4-hydroxy-3-nitrophenyl acetyl (NP) contact sensitivity system, the activity of third-order suppressor cells and their factors is restricted by H-2(I-J) and Igh linked genes. The present report analyzes the specificity of NP-specific Ts3 cells and factors derived from H-2 and Igh heterozygous (B6 X C3H)F1 mice. Two approaches were used. First, heterogeneous populations of F1 Ts3 cells were activated in vitro and then assayed in Ts3-depleted recipients which carried different combinations of H-2 and Igh alleles. The second approach was to hybridize the Ts3 cells and analyze the specificity of the F1-derived TsF3. The combined data demonstrated four functionally distinct populations of Ts3 cells. The activity of each population was restricted by a particular combination of H-2 and Igh haplotypes. Thus, Ts3 cells derived from F1 donors can demonstrate an apparent scrambling of H-2 and Igh restriction specificities. There was functional allelic exclusion of the H-2(I-J) and Igh determinants expressed on (B6 X C3H)F1 hybridoma-derived TsF3. Thus, TsF3 from each cloned hybridoma line expressed only one set of I-J and Igh determinants. Furthermore, there was a complete correlation between the I-J and Igh linked determinants expressed on TsF3 and the restriction specificity. In view of the recent findings on the molecular biology of the I-J region, an alternative interpretation of the role of I-J determinants on suppressor cells and factors is offered.

An antigen-specific signal is required for the activation of second-order suppressor T cells in the regulation of delayed-type hypersensitivity to 2,4,6-trinitrobenzene sulfonic acid

Suppressor T cells (Ts-1) induced with trinitrophenyl (TNP)-conjugated syngeneic spleen cells (TNP-SC) can be enriched on antigen-coated plates and are afferent suppressors. In addition, these suppressor cells produced soluble suppressor factors (TsF) that were active in vivo. Therefore, the Ts-1 cells in the TNP system are very similar to the Ts-1 cells in other systems we have studied earlier. Further characterization of these TsF-1 revealed that TsF-1 obtained from TNP-SC-induced Ts-1 is major histocompatibility complex restricted in its activity. Injection of TNP-specific TsF-1 into naive mice did not induce Ts-2 unless additional corresponding antigen was provided. Moreover, the Ts-2 cells induced by administration of both TsF-1 and trinitrobenzene sulfonic acid were antigen specific rather than antiidiotypic.

Analysis of T cell hybridomas. III. Distinctions between two types of hapten-specific suppressor factors that affect plaque-forming cell responses

The ability of two cloned T cell hybridomas and their products to specifically suppress the in vitro plaque-forming cell (PFC) response to the 4-hydroxy-3-nitrophenyl acetyl hapten (NP) was studied. Supernatant from one hybridoma (TS1) was shown to suppress in the induction but not the effector phase of the immune response. Supernatant from the TS1 hybridoma was capable of inducing second-order (TS2) effector-phase suppressor cells in vitro but did not suppress the response of anti-I-J plus C-treated responder cells. In contrast, supernatant from a second hybridoma (TS3) was capable of suppressing PFC responses when added either in the induction or the effector phase of the response. TS3 supernatant was unable to induce effector-phase suppressor cells but was capable of suppressing the response of anti-I-J plus C-treated responder cells. In addition, specific suppressor factors isolated from supernatants of the TS1 and TS3 hybridomas were shown to bind to NP, bear NPb idiotypic and I-J-encoded but not immunoglobulin-constant region determinants. The factor secreted by the TS3 hybridoma appears to act directly on B cell targets. Mild reduction of this factor results in two separable moieties, only one of which binds NP. Reconstitution experiments suggest that both chains are required for function. The collective data indicate that these hybridomas represent cells from first- and third-order suppressor T cell populations described previously in contact sensitivity and in vitro PFC systems. The implications of the ability of these hybridoma products to affect both T and B cell-mediated immune responses are discussed.