Immunopathology of the inner ear: an update

Macrophage-related immune responses in inner ear: a potential therapeutic target for sensorineural hearing loss

Hearing loss is the most common sensory disorder in human beings. Cochlear sensory cells are the basis of hearing. Cochlear sensory cells suffer from various acute or chronic injuries, such as excessive sound stimulation, ototoxic drugs, and age-related degeneration. In response to these stresses, the cochlea develops an immune response. In recent years, studies have shown that the immune response of the inner ear has been regarded as one of the important pathological mechanisms of inner ear injury. Therapeutic interventions for inflammatory responses can effectively alleviate different types of inner ear injury. As the main immune cells in the inner ear, macrophages are involved in the process of inner ear injury caused by various exogenous factors. However, its specific role in the immune response of the inner ear is still unclear. This review focuses on discusses the dynamic changes of macrophages during different types of inner ear injury, and clarifies the potential role of macrophage-related immune response in inner ear injury.

Case Report: Anti-NMDA Receptor Encephalitis With Bilateral Hearing Loss as the Initial Symptom

Introduction: Anti-N-methyl-D-aspartate receptor (anti-NMDAR) encephalitis is an autoimmune disease associated with the NMDA receptor. This paper describes a patient who presented with bilateral hearing loss as the initial symptom of anti-NMDAR encephalitis.

Case Report: We describe a 31-year-old young female with anti-NMDAR encephalitis who presented with bilateral severe hearing loss after brief loss of consciousness and then accompanied by other symptoms, such as generalized tonic–clonic seizures, manic episodes, excessive salivation, severe cognitive impairment, and complex non-convulsive status epilepticus. Great improvement was achieved by a combined treatment of steroid, IVIG, and plasmapheresis, especially after surgical removal of the ovarian teratoma. When she was discharged on hospital day 43, her hearing loss obtained a significant improvement.

Conclusion: This case study and literature review investigated the impairment of hearing loss and its subsequent treatment in patients with anti-NMDAR encephalitis.

Response of the inner ear to lipopolysaccharide introduced directly into scala media

In an attempt to develop an animal model of immune mediated Meniere's disease, we have injected lipopolysaccharide (LPS) directly into scala media of guinea pigs and monitored functional and morphological changes over a period of 6 weeks. Depending on the concentration of LPS, changes ranged from moderate-to-severe hearing loss and endolymphatic hydrops with minimal cellular infiltrate or fibrosis, to dense cellular infiltration that filled the scalae. Interestingly, higher concentrations of LPS not only induced severe cellular infiltration, hydrops, and hearing loss, but also a substantial enlargement of the endolymphatic duct and sac. Moreover, LPS injections into perilymph failed to induce hydrops, yet still resulted in cellular infiltration and fibrosis in the cochlea. This suggests that chronic hydrops resulting from an immune challenge of the cochlea may not be due to blockage of the endolymphatic duct and sac, restricting fluid absorption. Furthermore, injecting antigen into endolymph may produce chronic immune-mediated hydrops, and provide a more promising animal model of Meniere's, although animals did not display signs of vestibular dysfunction, and the hearing loss was relatively severe.

Macrophages in the Human Cochlea: Saviors or Predators-A Study Using Super-Resolution Immunohistochemistry

The human inner ear, which is segregated by a blood/labyrinth barrier, contains resident macrophages [CD163, ionized calcium-binding adaptor molecule 1 (IBA1)-, and CD68-positive cells] within the connective tissue, neurons, and supporting cells. In the lateral wall of the cochlea, these cells frequently lie close to blood vessels as perivascular macrophages. Macrophages are also shown to be recruited from blood-borne monocytes to damaged and dying hair cells induced by noise, ototoxic drugs, aging, and diphtheria toxin-induced hair cell degeneration. Precise monitoring may be crucial to avoid self-targeting. Macrophage biology has recently shown that populations of resident tissue macrophages may be fundamentally different from circulating macrophages. We removed uniquely preserved human cochleae during surgery for treating petroclival meningioma compressing the brain stem, after ethical consent. Molecular and cellular characterization using immunofluorescence with antibodies against IBA1, TUJ1, CX3CL1, and type IV collagen, and super-resolution structured illumination microscopy (SR-SIM) were made together with transmission electron microscopy. The super-resolution microscopy disclosed remarkable phenotypic variants of IBA1 cells closely associated with the spiral ganglion cells. Monitoring cells adhered to neurons with “synapse-like” specializations and protrusions. Active macrophages migrated occasionally nearby damaged hair cells. Results suggest that the human auditory nerve is under the surveillance and possible neurotrophic stimulation of a well-developed resident macrophage system. It may be alleviated by the non-myelinated nerve soma partly explaining why, in contrary to most mammals, the human’s auditory nerve is conserved following deafferentiation. It makes cochlear implantation possible, for the advantage of the profoundly deaf. The IBA1 cells may serve additional purposes such as immune modulation, waste disposal, and nerve regeneration. Their role in future stem cell-based therapy needs further exploration.

Immune system of the inner ear as a novel therapeutic target for sensorineural hearing loss

Sensorineural hearing loss (SNHL) is a common clinical condition resulting from dysfunction in one or more parts in the auditory pathway between the inner ear and auditory cortex. Despite the prevalence of SNHL, little is known about its etiopathology, although several mechanisms have been postulated including ischemia, viral infection or reactivation, and microtrauma. Immune-mediated inner ear disease has been introduced and accepted as one SNHL pathophysiology; it responds to immunosuppressive therapy and is one of the few reversible forms of bilateral SNHL. The concept of immune-mediated inner ear disease is straightforward and comprehensible, but criteria for clinical diagnosis and the precise mechanism of hearing loss have not been determined. Moreover, the therapeutic mechanisms of corticosteroids are unclear, leading to several misconceptions by both clinicians and investigators concerning corticosteroid therapy. This review addresses our current understanding of the immune system in the inner ear and its involvement in the pathophysiology in SNHL. Treatment of SNHL, including immune-mediated inner ear disorder, will be discussed with a focus on the immune mechanism and immunocompetent cells as therapeutic targets. Finally, possible interventions modulating the immune system in the inner ear to repair the tissue organization and improve hearing in patients with SNHL will be discussed. Tissue macrophages in the inner ear appear to be a potential target for modulating the immune response in the inner ear in the pathophysiology of SNHL.

Sensorineural hearing loss in pediatric celiac patients

OBJECTIVE

Celiac disease (CD) is an immune-mediated chronic inflammatory gluten-dependent intestinal disease affecting 0.5-1% of the general population worldwide. CD is underdiagnosed even with sophisticated health care; approximately 10% of people affected by CD are now diagnosed. The recognition of the atypical extra-intestinal manifestations, including neurological disorders increased the diagnosis of CD. At present, no data are available on the presence of sensorineural hearing loss in pediatric CD patients. The aim of this study was to determine the incidence and severity of sensorineural hearing loss (SNHL) in different frequencies in pediatric CD patients.

METHODS

A sample of 32 biopsies and serologically proven newly diagnosed pediatric CD patients (CD group) (64 ears) and 32 sex and age-matched healthy subjects (64 ears) as control group (C group) were included in this study. Anthropometric measurements, physical examinations including ear nose and throat and pure-tone audiometry at frequencies 250-8000 Hz were performed in all subjects in both groups. Slight/mild SNHL was defined as a loss of detection of sound within the 16-40 dB range. The mean age of patient and control group was 11.9 and 11.3, respectively (p>0.05).

RESULTS

In CD group, sensorineural hearing loss was found in 13 (40.6%) patients (group A) as it was bilateral in six and unilateral in seven patients. In control group (group C), slight/mild SNHL was found in one (3.1%) subject. The frequency of hearing loss was significantly higher in CD group than in group C (p<0.001).

CONCLUSION

The present study showed a higher prevalence of sensory neural hearing loss in pediatric celiac patients than in healthy controls, suggesting an association between CD and SNHL. The findings of this study suggest that hearing impairment should be searched in newly diagnosed pediatric CD patients. Further longitudinal investigations on a larger sample size will be necessary to confirm the present data and to search the immunological processes which could be the basis of the association between CD and SNHL.

Distribution of bone marrow-derived cells in the vestibular end organs and the endolymphatic sac

CONCLUSION

Bone marrow-derived cells (BMDCs) are constitutively present in the vestibular end organs and in the endolymphatic sac, and may play a role in the maintenance of inner ear homeostasis.

OBJECTIVES

The aim was to examine the distribution and characteristics of BMDCs in the vestibular end organs and in the endolymphatic sac.

METHODS

Bone marrow-chimeric mice were generated by bone marrow transplantation from mice genetically labeled with enhanced green fluorescent protein to C57 Bl/6 mice to visualize BMDCs. Three months after bone marrow transplantation, inner ear specimens were processed for histochemical analyses.

RESULTS

BMDCs were widely distributed in the vestibular end organs and the endolymphatic sac, whereas there were differences in the phenotype and the distribution between the vestibular end organs and the endolymphatic sac. A subpopulation of BMDCs in the vestibular end organs expressed antigen-presenting protein MHC class II. Moreover, the density of BMDCs in the vestibular end organs increased in response to local mechanical stress.

HLA-B27-Associated Bilateral Ménière Disease

We describe 2 cases of bilateral Ménière disease with features resembling autoimmune inner ear disease in patients who were found to be carriers of human leukocyte antigen (HLA) B27. For immunohistochemical analysis, mouse inner ear sections were used as the tissue substrate for reaction with serum. Both patients demonstrated an increased immunofluorescence reaction compared with a normal control. We suggest that an antibody-mediated mechanism may be responsible for HLA-B27–associated Ménière disease.

Potential role for lipopolysaccharide in congenital sensorineural hearing loss

Congenital sensorineural hearing loss (SNHL) is common. In the Western world, the incidence is 1-3 per 1000 live births. The aetiology encompasses genetic and non-genetic factors accounting for 55 % and 45 % of cases, respectively. Reports that describe the contribution of intrauterine infection to the occurrence of congenital SNHL are limited, and comparative analysis of the different pathogens is lacking. Lipopolysaccharide (LPS), a product of bacteriolysis, has been demonstrated to be associated with inner ear damage in experimental studies. To elucidate the potential role of this toxin in congenital SNHL and to identify the pathogenesis and transmission routes, we reviewed the literature. We speculate that different routes of exposure to LPS in utero may result in congenital inner ear damage.

Cochlin isoforms and their interaction with CTL2 (SLC44A2) in the inner ear

Choline transporter-like protein 2 (CTL2) is a multi-transmembrane protein expressed on inner ear supporting cells that was discovered as a target of antibody-induced hearing loss. Its function is unknown. A 64 kDa band that consistently co-precipitates with CTL2 from inner ear extracts was identified by mass spectroscopy as cochlin. Cochlin is an abundant inner ear protein expressed as multiple isoforms. Its function is also unknown, but it is suspected to be an extracellular matrix component. Cochlin is mutated in individuals with DFNA9 hearing loss. To investigate the CTL2-cochlin interaction, antibodies were raised to a cochlin-specific peptide. The antibodies identify several cochlin polypeptides on western blots and are specific for cochlin. We show that the heterogeneity of the cochlin isoforms is caused, in part, by in vivo post-translational modification by N-glycosylation and, in part, caused by alternative splicing. We verified that antibody to CTL2 co-immunoprecipitates cochlin from the inner ear and antibody to cochlin co-immunoprecipitates CTL2. Using cochlear cross-sections, we show that CTL2 is more widely distributed than previously described, and its prominent expression on cells facing the scala media suggests a possible role in homeostasis. A prominent but previously unreported ribbon-like pattern of cochlin in the basilar membrane was demonstrated, suggesting an important role for cochlin in the structure of the basilar membrane. CTL2 and cochlin are expressed in close proximity in the inner sulcus, the spiral prominence, vessels, limbus, and spiral ligament. The possible functional significance of CTL2-cochlin interactions remains unknown.

Diagnostic tests for immunomediated hearing loss: a systematic review

OBJECTIVE

To quantitatively evaluate the diagnostic accuracy of diagnostic tests for immunomediated hearing loss.

DATA SOURCES

We searched Medline and the Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews for potentially relevant studies.

STUDY SELECTION

Twenty-five studies met the inclusion criteria of this systematic review. The diagnosis of immunomediated hearing loss was based on the clinical presentation and the response to corticosteroid administration.

DATA EXTRACTION

The following data were extracted from the selected studies and entered into a standardised database: population demographics; exclusion and inclusion criteria; diagnostic tests; sensitivity; specificity; the number of true positive, true negative, false positive and false negative values; therapy used, including dose and duration; and delay between symptom onset and therapy commencement.

DATA SYNTHESIS

This systematic review combined data from 679 patients with immunomediated hearing loss, reported by 22 research teams. Substantial heterogeneity was found among the included studies; for this reason, summary sensitivity and specificity values were not computed.

CONCLUSIONS

The results of diagnostic tests for immunomediated hearing loss depend on many factors, and there is a risk of potential bias. This is the first time that such a systematic review has been presented; such a review is a more rigorous method of demonstrating the utility of the available diagnostic tests.

Serial Audiometry in a Clinical Trial of AIED Treatment

OBJECTIVE

We analyzed pure-tone and speech audiometric results from a prospective trial of anti-inflammatory treatment of subjects with active autoimmune inner ear disease (AIED). We sought to characterize the pattern and size of the treatment effect as reflected in clinical audiometry and to identify audiometric predictors of response to steroid treatment of AIED.

SUBJECTS

Adult participants demonstrated clinically established criteria for AIED (n = 116). Eligibility required audiometric evidence of active AIED as indicated by idiopathic sensorineural hearing loss with threshold elevations within 3 months of enrollment.

METHODS

We evaluated audiometric changes after 4 weeks of treatment with pharmacologic doses (60 mg/day) of prednisone. We examined the relationship between audiometric pure-tone thresholds at baseline and changes in word intelligibility score (WIS) using parametric and nonparametric analyses. Magnitudes of change were assessed using independent or paired t-tests. Separate analyses were performed on subgroups that did or did not show improved WIS score with steroid treatment.

RESULTS

Overall mean pure-tone averages improved from baseline to closeout of prednisone treatment in better hearing ears from 52.4 to 48.3 dB (p < .0001). Mean WIS improved in the better ear from 71.4% to 78.1% (p < .0001). Of pure-tone measures, only the six-tone average showed significant correlation with both the absolute improvements in WIS and with the percentage change in WIS after treatment. Individual frequencies at baseline showed no significant relationship with changes in WIS score after treatment. In 69 (59.5%) of 116 subjects, WIS improved (range, 2-80%) in the better ear. In these subjects, the baseline pure-tone thresholds and pure-tone averages correlated significantly and positively with improvement in WIS.

CONCLUSIONS

Steroid treatment in AIED-mediated hearing loss produce variable but significant hearing gains. Neither a focal, cochleotopic region of greatest vulnerability to AIED nor frequency-specific amenability to treatment were evident. We did observe that analysis of predictors and the degree of treatment effect vary with different approaches to measuring change in the WIS. Depending on the approach adopted, the size of the treatment effect may be greatest across intermediate hearing levels at baseline. These observations offer an audiometric database that may enable greater precision in judging clinically meaningful parameters for future studies of AIED treatment and other interventions for sensorineural hearing loss.

Immunological responses in acute low-tone sensorineural hearing loss and Ménière's disease

OBJECTIVE

The autoimmune response appears to play an important role in some types of acute sensorineural hearing loss. Endolymphatic hydrops associated with fluctuating hearing loss has also been suggested to be caused by an immunological mechanism. Acute low-tone hearing loss (ALHL) associated with Ménière's disease (MD) is characterized by fluctuating hearing loss, and its etiology is thought to involve endolymphatic hydrops. The aim of this study was to attempt to determine the etiology of ALHL in MD.

MATERIAL AND METHODS

A flow cytometer was used to analyze intracellular cytokine levels in peripheral blood from 19 patients with ALHL and 26 patients with MD and the data compared to those obtained from age- and gender-matched healthy volunteers.

RESULTS

The patients with ALHL showed significantly increased levels of Th1 subsets (interferon-gamma-producing helper T cells) as compared to those in normal controls. The levels of Th2 (IL-4-producing helper T cells) subsets did not differ from those in the control group and thus Th1 predominated in ALHL patients. The patients with MD showed significantly increased natural killer cell activity but no Th1 dominance. These patients had no obvious systemic or local disease except in the inner ear.

CONCLUSION

An abnormality of the Th1/Th2 balance in ALHL and increased natural killer cell activity in MD are thought to relate to inner ear disorder. These results are consistent with the possibility that the etiology of ALHL and MD involves an immune response.

Demyelination of Vestibular Nerve Axons in Unilateral Ménière's Disease

We conducted a study to determine whether vestibular nerves inpatients with unilateral Ménière's disease whose symptoms are refractory to medical management exhibit neuropathologic changes. We also endeavored to determine whether retrocochlear abnormalities are primary or secondary factors in the disease process. To these ends, we obtained vestibular nerve segments from five patients during retrosigmoid (posteriorfossa) neurectomy, immediately fixed them, and processed them for light and electron microscopy. We found that all five segments exhibited moderate to severe demyelination with axonal sparing. Moreover, we noted that reactive astrocytes produced an extensive proliferation of fibrous processes and that the microglia assumed a phagocytic role. We conclude that the possible etiologies of demyelination include viral and/or immune-mediated factors similar to those seen in other demyelinating diseases, such as multiple sclerosis and Guillain-Barré syndrome. Our findings suggest that some forms of Ménière's disease that are refractory to traditional medical management might be the result of retrocochlear pathology that affects the neuroglial portion of the vestibular nerve.

COCH5B2 is a target antigen of anti-inner ear antibodies in autoimmune inner ear diseases

OBJECTIVE

This study was designed to identify the 58-kDa inner ear protein against which the sera of some patients with idiopathic, progressive sensorineural hearing loss or Ménière's disease strongly react.

BACKGROUND

We and other groups have previously demonstrated that a 58-kDa protein extracted from guinea pig or bovine inner ear tissue is a target of antibodies in serum samples from some patients with autoimmune inner ear diseases.

METHODS

After separation of inner ear proteins by 10% sodium dodecyl sulfate polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis, the bands corresponding to 58 kDa were localized and excised from the gel. The concentrated protein was then digested with trypsin, and the peptide fragments were separated by high-pressure liquid chromatography. Three fractions were subjected to amino acid sequencing by the classic Edman degradation.

RESULTS

The sequence of a stretch of 14 amino acids of the first fragment was identical to that of amino acids 526 to 539 of the COCH5B2 protein. The sequences of 11 and 10 amino acids of the second and third fragments, respectively, also were identical to residues 417 to 427 and 396 to 405 of the COCH5B2 protein. These data, together with two-dimensional gel electrophoresis followed by Western blot experiments, confirmed that the 58-kDa inner ear protein is the COCH5B2 protein.

DISCUSSION

These findings indicate that the 58-kDa target protein of antibodies in serum samples of patients with autoimmune inner ear diseases is the COCH5B2 protein, a molecule that is highly and specifically expressed in the cochlea and vestibule.

Identification of beta-actin as a candidate autoantigen in autoimmune inner ear disease

It has been shown that sera from patients with autoimmune inner ear disease contain antibodies to several inner ear antigens. We report here the characterization of the 42-43 kDa protein against which a significant number of patients' sera react strongly. After separation of inner ear proteins from guinea-pig cochleas by SDS-PAGE, the band corresponding to the 42-43 kDa protein was digested with trypsin and the peptide fragments were separated by high-performance liquid chromatography. Two fractions were then subjected to amino acid sequencing by the classical automated Edman degradation. The sequence of a stretch of 15 amino acids of the first fragment was identical to that of amino acids 148-162 of beta-actin. The sequence of the 10 amino acids of the second fragment was also identical to beta-actin. On Western blots, monoclonal antibody directed against beta-actin reacted with the inner ear 42-43 kDa proteins. The serum samples from the patients and the monoclonal antibody reacted with the non-muscle actin used as antigen in Western blotting. Immunoblot analysis of inner ear proteins after two-dimensional gel electrophoresis showed a spot, corresponding to the region of the 43 kDa as compared to the protein standards. On the basis of these data it is concluded that the target 42-43 kDa protein for antibodies in sera of patients with autoimmune inner ear disease is beta-actin, a molecule, which has important and numerous functions inside cells. This is the first report to identify the cytoskeletal protein beta-actin as a candidate autoantigen in autoimmune inner ear disease.

Vertigo and dysequilibrium with associated hearing loss

There are numerous disorders that can present with hearing loss and vertigo or dysequilibrium. The combination of vertigo and imbalance associated with hearing loss are symptoms suggestive of a peripheral vestibular disorder. This article summarizes presentation, diagnosis, and treatment of the various common and rare peripheral vestibular disorders that can present with these symptoms.

Cogan's syndrome

Work originating in the 1940s led to the characterization of a rare, chronic inflammatory disorder with a unique predilection for the cornea and vestibuloauditory apparatus, now called Cogan's syndrome (CS) after the ophthalmologist who first described it. CS occurs primarily in young adults and typically presents with interstitial keratitis (IK) and Ménière's-like episodes developing within several months of each other. The inflammatory process may target other ocular sites, and the disease itself may be accompanied by aortitis or a Takayasu's-like or medium-sized vessel vasculitis. Morbidity in CS results from deafness and complications from cardiovascular disease. Most evidence suggests that the ocular and vestibuloauditory manifestations are not a consequence of vasculitis but rather mediated by other immunologic mechanisms, possibly organ-specific autoimmunity. The cornerstone of treatment in CS is corticosteroids, topically for IK and systemically for inner ear dysfunction. Early corticosteroid therapy appears to be critical for reversing hearing loss. Cochlear implants can partially restore auditory function and have been a salvation for patients who suffer from deafness as a result of permanent cochlear damage.