Photodynamic therapy induced ultrastructural alterations in microvasculature of the rat cremaster muscle

Current Challenges and Opportunities of Photodynamic Therapy against Cancer

BACKGROUND

Photodynamic therapy (PDT) is an established, minimally invasive treatment for specific types of cancer. During PDT, reactive oxygen species (ROS) are generated that ultimately induce cell death and disruption of the tumor area. Moreover, PDT can result in damage to the tumor vasculature and induce the release and/or exposure of damage-associated molecular patterns (DAMPs) that may initiate an antitumor immune response. However, there are currently several challenges of PDT that limit its widespread application for certain indications in the clinic.

METHODS

A literature study was conducted to comprehensively discuss these challenges and to identify opportunities for improvement.

RESULTS

The most notable challenges of PDT and opportunities to improve them have been identified and discussed.

CONCLUSIONS

The recent efforts to improve the current challenges of PDT are promising, most notably those that focus on enhancing immune responses initiated by the treatment. The application of these improvements has the potential to enhance the antitumor efficacy of PDT, thereby broadening its potential application in the clinic.

Photodynamic therapy using methylene blue in lung adenocarcinoma xenograft and hamster cheek pouch induced squamous cell carcinoma

BACKGROUND

Photodynamic therapy (PDT) is used to treat early proximal bronchial cancer during a flexible bronchoscopy. The technique relies on the excitation of a photosensitizer by an appropriate wavelength, which is delivered into the bronchus in close contact with the tumor.

OBJECTIVE

To assess methylene blue (MB) as a PDT agent for the treatment of respiratory tract cancer in animal models.

METHODS

MB-induced PDT was performed on 7 subcutaneous NCI-H460 lung adenocarcinoma xenografts in nude mice and 9 induced squamous cell cancer in the hamster cheek pouch model. In mice, PDT was carried out on right-sided tumors after intratumoral injection of methylene blue 1% (w/v) and illumination at 630nm at 200J/cm (Diomed PDT 630), with the left tumor used as control (illumination alone or MB alone). The tumoral volume was assessed before and 15 days after PDT.

RESULTS

Fourteen xenografts were treated in mice, including seven treated with MB-PDT, producing a 52% mean tumor volume regression (1568mm(3)vs. 544mm(3)) compared to seven control cases in which tumor volume increased (p=0.007; Mann-Whitney test). Nine cheek pouch induced carcinomas were treated in the hamster group, with a mean volume decrease of 85.8% (from 44.8% to 100%) (initial mean volume=210mm(3)vs. post PDT mean volume=97mm(3)). Histology analysis showed 4/9 complete responses.

CONCLUSION

Intratumoral MB appears efficient as PDT agent for cancer treatment in animal models. Further studies are needed to assess the safety and efficacy of MB-associated PDT for the treatment of lung cancer in humans.

Photodynamic therapy of cancer: an update

Photodynamic therapy (PDT) is a clinically approved, minimally invasive therapeutic procedure that can exert a selective cytotoxic activity toward malignant cells. The procedure involves administration of a photosensitizing agent followed by irradiation at a wavelength corresponding to an absorbance band of the sensitizer. In the presence of oxygen, a series of events lead to direct tumor cell death, damage to the microvasculature, and induction of a local inflammatory reaction. Clinical studies revealed that PDT can be curative, particularly in early stage tumors. It can prolong survival in patients with inoperable cancers and significantly improve quality of life. Minimal normal tissue toxicity, negligible systemic effects, greatly reduced long-term morbidity, lack of intrinsic or acquired resistance mechanisms, and excellent cosmetic as well as organ function-sparing effects of this treatment make it a valuable therapeutic option for combination treatments. With a number of recent technological improvements, PDT has the potential to become integrated into the mainstream of cancer treatment.

Tissue localization of photosensitizers and the mechanism of photodynamic tissue destruction

This paper outlines our present knowledge of photosensitizer tissue distribution, derived from preclinical animal studies, and relates it to the observed biological response to photodynamic therapy (PDT). Emphasis is placed on porphyrins (haematoporphyrin derivative (HpD), Photofrin II) and phthalocyanines (aluminum phthalocyanine sulphonate AlPcS). In mice, both groups of sensitizers show multiphasic plasma clearance kinetics with an initial rapid decline followed by further slow reduction. Residual amounts of Photofrin II are detectable 75 days after injection. Drug elimination occurs through urine and faeces, but faecal elimination predominates for Photofrin II. Circulating sensitizer greatly influences the mouse ear-swelling response, but not the foot response. Tumours and normal skin can be destroyed by vascular damage, if illumination occurs at times of maximal plasma sensitizer concentration, with no detectable sensitizer accumulation in tumour cells. Organ retention for both photosensitizer groups is similar and persistent. Organs rich in reticuloendothelial elements (liver, kidney, spleen) accumulate and retain the highest levels, skin and muscle the lowest, while normal brain tissue excludes sensitizer. The adrenal and pancreatic glands, as well as urinary bladder, also retain high amounts of Photofrin II. Tumour/skin ratios of 1 to 3:1 and 2 to 7:1 have been reported for porphyrins and sulphonated phthalocyanines respectively. Tissue destruction upon light exposure is not always correlated with photosensitizer levels, as is exemplified by liver and pancreas. Stromal sensitizer localization usually predominates in tumour and normal tissue, and often determines tumour response. Certain compounds, such as monosulphonated tetraphenylporphyrin and AlPcS, may favour parenchymal localization. The formed blood elements remain free of photosensitizer, while mast cells and macrophages accumulate especially large amounts and, upon illumination, release an array of vasoactive inflammatory and immune mediators.

The effects of thrombocytopenia on vessel stasis and macromolecular leakage after photodynamic therapy using photofrin

Several studies have reported thrombus formation and/or the release of specific vasoactive eicosanoids, suggesting that platelet activation or damage after photodynamic therapy (PDT) may contribute to blood flow stasis. The role of circulating platelets on blood flow stasis and vascular leakage of macromolecules during and after PDT was assessed in an intravital animal model. Sprague-Dawley rats bearing chondrosarcoma on the right hind limb were injected intravenously (i.v.) with 25 mg/kg Photofrin 24 h before light treatment of 135 J/cm2 at 630 nm. Thrombocytopenia was induced in animals by administration of 3.75 mg/kg of rabbit anti-rat platelet antibody i.v. 30 min before the initiation of the light treatment. This regimen reduced circulating platelet levels from 300,000/mm3 to 20,000/mm3. Reductions in the luminal diameter of the microvasculature in normal muscle and tumor were observed in control animals given Photofrin and light. Venule leakage of macromolecules was noted shortly after the start of light treatment and continued throughout the period of observation. Animals made thrombocytopenic showed none of these changes after PDT in either normal tissues or tumor. The lack of vessel response correlated with the absence of thromboxane release in blood during PDT. These data suggest that platelets and eicosanoid release are necessary for vessel constriction and blood flow stasis after PDT using Photofrin.

Tumour vessel damage resulting from laser-induced hyperthermia alone and in combination with photodynamic therapy

This study examined tumour vessel injury resulting from laser-induced hyperthermia alone and in combination with photodynamic therapy (PDT) in the treatment of rat liver tumours by means of scanning electron microscopy. A total of 18 Wistar rats were divided into three groups. Group I (six animals) underwent hyperthermia for 15 min (15-min hyperthermia). Group II (six animals) underwent hyperthermia for 30 min (30-min hyperthermia). Group III (six animals) received the combined treatment of PDT and 30-min hyperthermia. For PDT, delta-amino laevulinic acid at a dose of 60 mg/kg of body weight was intravenously administered 60 min before irradiation at 635 nm. The morphological results indicated that 15-min hyperthermia gave rise to an increase in permeability of the vessels in the treated tumour. Thirty-min hyperthermia caused extreme oedema of vascular endothelial cells and restrictive openings of tumour branch vessels. The combined therapy of PDT and hyperthermia destroyed tumour vasculature. Large breaks of the inner wall of the treated tumour vessels were deeply involved in the basement membrane of the vessel. The results indicate that there may be a close link between inhibition of tumour growth and degree of damage to tumour vessels.

Local photodynamic therapy reduces tissue hyperplasia in an experimental restenosis model

Local photodynamic therapy may have potential in preventing myointimal hyperplasia after angioplasty. In this study, the effect of photodynamic therapy was evaluated in an experimental model of restenosis. Standardized unidirectional arterial injury with a directional atherectomy catheter was performed in porcine arteries. Animals were randomly allocated to four groups: group 1, unidirectional injury only; group 2, injury followed by local delivery of photosensitizer; group 3, injury followed by local exposure to monochromatic light; and group 4, where injury was followed by local drug delivery of photosensitizer and subsequent exposure to light (photodynamic therapy). Seven, 14 or 21 days after treatment, all experimental vessels were excised, fixed and processed for histology. An inflammatory and myoproliferative response was observed after injury in vessels from groups 1, 2 and 3. In group 4, after injury followed by photodynamic therapy, the myoproliferative response was significantly reduced. Thus, in this study, tissue hyperplasia after unidirectional injury was effectively suppressed by photodynamic therapy.

The effect of aminolaevulinic acid-induced, protoporphyrin IX-mediated photodynamic therapy on the cremaster muscle microcirculation in vivo

The effect of photodynamic therapy on normal striated muscle was investigated using 30 adult male rats. Animals were divided into six groups. Three control groups received phosphate-buffered saline by gavage and violet light at 105, 178 and 300 mW cm-2 respectively. Three experimental groups received aminolaevulinic acid (ALA; 200 mg kg-1) and violet light at 105, 178 and 300 mW cm-2 respectively. After exposure of the cremaster muscle animals were allowed to equilibrate and vessel diameters and bloodflow assessed. Following photoactivation measurements were taken every 10 min over a 2 h period. Photoactivation of experimental groups at the two higher power densities resulted in an initial decrease in both arteriolar and venular diameters, and a concomitant decrease in blood flow. The magnitude of these changes and the degree of recovery by the end of the observation period was related to power density. No effects were observed in the control groups. These results suggest that microcirculatory damage may contribute to the mechanism of action of photodynamic therapy with ALA.

Changes in perfusion of mouse tumours after photodynamic therapy

The influence of photodynamic therapy (PDT) on vascular perfusion was investigated in 2 s.c. mouse tumours, a radiation-induced fibrosarcoma (RIF I) and a squamous-cell carcinoma (SCCVII). The 86Rb extraction technique was used to measure changes in perfusion relative to cardiac output at various intervals after interstitial PDT. Control groups showed that vascular perfusion in the RIF I tumours decreased with increasing tumour size. For both tumours, of constant size, vascular perfusion decreased to less than 10% of control values within 5 min after high PDT doses. Significant decreases in vascular perfusion were also seen after lower, sub-curative doses. Thereafter there was slow recovery towards control levels. Photofrin given at shorter intervals before illumination generally resulted in even larger decreases in tumour perfusion, and slower recovery. Comparison of tumour perfusion measurements after PDT with tumour response revealed an inverse correlation with tumour growth delay both for the RIF I and for the SCCVII tumours. PDT with sub-curative light doses appears to decrease vascular perfusion in the RIF I and SCCVII for a period of at least 24 hr. The most severe reductions in tumour blood flow were associated with the longest regrowth delays, indicating a major role of vascular damage in tumour response to PDT.

Phthalocyanine photodynamic therapy: new strategy for closure of choroidal neovascularization

Chloro-aluminum sulfonated phthalocyanine (CASPc) is a photo-chemically active dye employed in photodynamic therapy (PDT). CASPc is a potent generator of singlet oxygen when irradiated with 675 nm light and is also capable of fluorescence, allowing visualization of the dye in tissues. We devised an angiography system using CASPc fluorescence to determine its localization in experimental choroidal neovascularization in monkeys and then investigated the ability of CASPc to produce photochemical closure of neovascularization upon irradiation with 675nm laser light. Fluorescent imaging indicated that CASPc localized angiographically in areas of neovascularization for at least 24 hours. Irradiation with 675 nm laser light 5-30 minutes after CASPc injection produced complete closure of choroidal neovascularization with minimal damage to overlying retina. We conclude that CASPc localizes in neovascular choroidal vessels and that CASPc photodynamic therapy can produce closure of these choroidal vessels.

Retinal and choroidal vessel closure using phthalocyanine photodynamic therapy

Chloro-aluminum sulfonated phthalocyanine (CASPc) is a photoactive dye capable of generating photochemical reactions when excited with 675 nm light. We used CASPc to produce photochemical closure of retinal medullary ray vessels and choroidal vessels in normal rabbits. Irradiation prior to CASPc injection produced no photographic, angiographic, or histologic lesions in any eyes. Identical irradiation of medullary ray and choroidal vessels after CASPc injection produced complete vessel closure in all eyes. Histopathologic examination showed marked thrombosis of medullary ray and choroidal vessels, with minimal damage to contiguous tissues including the neurosensory retina. We conclude that CASPc can produce profound closure of normal retinal and choroidal vessels with minimal deleterious effect on surrounding tissues.

The ultrastructure of photochemically induced thrombi with embolization in a rat model

BACKGROUND AND PURPOSE

Photochemical techniques, currently used in stroke and cancer research, produce endothelial damage and thrombosis. To further characterize these thrombi and to determine whether they embolize, we studied the ultrastructure of photochemically damaged carotid arteries and small vessels distal to the irradiated carotid.

METHODS

The right carotid artery of 9 Wistar rats was irradiated with a laser (632 nm, 200 mW/cm2, 15 minutes) after the injection of the photosensitizing dye Photofrin II, 12.5 mg/kg. There were 6 additional control rats: laser only, 2 rats; dye only, 2; carrier only (5% dextrose), 1; and normal, 1. The carotid artery and cerebral arterioles were studied using scanning and transmission electron microscopy.

RESULTS

Endothelial damage was present in all irradiated carotid arteries, and consisted of exposure of the subendothelium and the formation of a nonocclusive thrombus. Although most cerebral arterioles were normal, 32 of these vessels contained peripheral blood elements, with platelet or red blood cell aggregates present in 15. The endothelium adjacent to the aggregates was intact. A few scattered endothelial cells had been lost in the carotid artery of control animals (compatible with normal cell turnover), with a few platelets adhering to the exposed subendothelium.

CONCLUSIONS

Aggregates of blood cells and platelets in cerebral vessels in the absence of endothelial denudation verifies embolism as the mechanism for cerebral vascular occlusion in this experimental model. The possibility of embolization distal to the site of photochemical irradiation has implications for potential applications of photochemistry for cancer treatment and the ablation of vascular malformations and/or aneurysms.

Effect of aspirin on photodynamic therapy utilizing chloroaluminum sulfonated phthalocyanine (CASP)

The efficacy of photodynamic therapy (PDT) is mediated through a direct vascular effect. Interference with platelet function and resulting vascular stasis have been recently demonstrated utilizing the photosensitizer dihematoporphyrin ether (DHE). We examined the effect of aspirin, a known inhibitor of both cyclooxygenase and platelet activity, on PDT using chloroaluminum sulfonated phthalocyanine (CASP). Thirty-six rats implanted with a window chamber were given either 0.1 mg/kg (low dose) or 10 mg/kg (high dose) aspirin immediately before, immediately after, or 6 hours after the completion of CASP-PDT. Aspirin in either dosage did not appear to have any effect on the window vasculature when given immediately after light exposure. A moderate inhibition of vascular response was seen in animals treated with aspirin pre-PDT, whereas high-dose aspirin completely abrogated the CASP-PDT vascular response when given 6 hours post-PDT. These data indicate that aspirin can effect CASP-PDT in both time-dependent and dose-dependent fashions.

The influence of photodynamic therapy on the ultrastructure of the normal rat bladder

Reduced bladder capacity is a major side effect for patients receiving photodynamic therapy (PDT) for bladder cancer. A rat bladder model has been developed to address both the vascular and tissue effects of the photodynamic treatment of the urinary bladder. Bladders were exteriorized and positioned in a plexiglass tissue bath. Effects on microvasculature were assessed during PDT of the bladder by recording luminal diameter changes in arterioles and venules. Animals receiving Photofrin II (10 mg kg-1) 30 min prior to PDT scored a statistically significant reduction in the diameter of the red blood cell column in the vessels, whereas administration of Photofrin II 48 h prior to PDT was ineffective. Morphological changes included significant endothelial and vascular myocyte damage in the 30 min PDT group alone. Among the other tissue components, the mucosal lining was minimally affected and the response of the muscularis was highly variable. Smooth muscle cell changes ranged from mild contraction to frank necrosis with many of the affected cells located near the altered vascular beds. These data suggest that the clinical symptoms of reduced bladder capacity can be accounted for by vascular damage and myocyte sensitivity. Further refinements in the Photofrin II and light doses used in therapy may reduce bladder complications and allow for better management of bladder cancer.

An improved photochemical model of embolic cerebral infarction in rats

To provide further evidence that the multiple cerebral infarcts found in rats following photochemical damage to the carotid artery are caused by emboli and to eliminate the systemic hypotension and heating of the blood reported with the previous photochemical embolic stroke model (rose bengal and a green laser), I have modified the photochemical technique. Brain pathology was studied in 18 Wistar rats following carotid artery irradiation with a red laser (632 nm) at powers ranging from 100 to 800 mW/cm2 for 10 or 20 minutes following the injection of the photosensitizing dye Photofrin II. Multiple cerebral arterioles were occluded by platelet aggregates containing frequent erythrocytes and leukocytes, identical to the thrombotic material in the carotid artery but different from the platelet aggregates seen in the carotid artery and the brain in the rose bengal model. Eighty infarcts were distributed randomly throughout the brain ipsilateral to the nonocclusive carotid thrombus. Significant heating (0.5 degree C or more) of the blood occurred only with laser powers higher (1,600 mW/cm2) or laser irradiations longer (25 minutes) than those used in the improved model of embolic stroke. This model mimics one mechanism of stroke in humans and provides a means to study systematically the morphological evolution of small cerebral infarcts.

Gross and microscopic changes in the viscera induced by photodynamic therapy applied to the lower abdomen of intact rats

Photodynamic therapy (PDT) is a promising approach to the treatment of cancer. Preferential retention of the photosensitizer by malignant tissue has been considered a hallmark of this treatment modality. However, photosensitivity can be observed in normal, non-neoplastic tissues, and the present study investigated the effects of PDT treatment on the abdomen of intact rats. A circular region (1 cm diameter) on the shaved abdomen of Fischer rats, pretreated 24 h prior with Photofrin II, was irradiated for 30 min at 632 nm. Control animals received either photoradiation or Photofrin II administration. Subsequent lesions were observed in the irradiated skin, its associated abdominal wall, and the underlying gut in rats receiving Photofrin II and laser irradiation. All tissues were not equally sensitive to PDT treatment. Gut lesions were consistently more severe than were skin and abdominal wall injuries. By 24 hr after treatment, the gut manifested a transmural hemorrhagic necrosis, while the irradiated skin and abdominal wall were edematous, with an inflammatory infiltrate in the dermis and around occasional swollen myocytes. These results indicate that superficial lesions induced by PDT may not be reliable indicators of the extent of deeper PDT tissue damage. Further, it may be possible to take advantage of this discrepancy in tissue sensitivity and treat deep tissues through less sensitive superficial tissues.