Quantum yield of CHAPSO-solubilized rhodopsin and 3-hydroxy retinal containing bovine opsin

Rhodopsins: An Excitingly Versatile Protein Species for Research, Development and Creative Engineering

The first member and eponym of the rhodopsin family was identified in the 1930s as the visual pigment of the rod photoreceptor cell in the animal retina. It was found to be a membrane protein, owing its photosensitivity to the presence of a covalently bound chromophoric group. This group, derived from vitamin A, was appropriately dubbed retinal. In the 1970s a microbial counterpart of this species was discovered in an archaeon, being a membrane protein also harbouring retinal as a chromophore, and named bacteriorhodopsin. Since their discovery a photogenic panorama unfolded, where up to date new members and subspecies with a variety of light-driven functionality have been added to this family. The animal branch, meanwhile categorized as type-2 rhodopsins, turned out to form a large subclass in the superfamily of G protein-coupled receptors and are essential to multiple elements of light-dependent animal sensory physiology. The microbial branch, the type-1 rhodopsins, largely function as light-driven ion pumps or channels, but also contain sensory-active and enzyme-sustaining subspecies. In this review we will follow the development of this exciting membrane protein panorama in a representative number of highlights and will present a prospect of their extraordinary future potential.

The Biochemical Basis of Vitamin A Production from the Asymmetric Carotenoid β-Cryptoxanthin

Vitamin A serves essential functions in mammalian biology as a signaling molecule and chromophore. This lipid can be synthesized from more than 50 putative dietary provitamin A precursor molecules which contain at least one unsubstituted β-ionone ring. We here scrutinized the enzymatic properties and substrate specificities of the two structurally related carotenoid cleavage dioxygenases (CCDs) which catalyze this synthesis. Recombinant BCO1 split substrates across the C15,C15' double bond adjacent to a canonical β-ionone ring site to vitamin A aldehyde. Substitution of the ring with a hydroxyl group prevented this conversion. The removal of methyl groups from the polyene carbon backbone of the substrate did not impede enzyme activity. Homology modeling and site-directed mutagenesis identified amino acid residues at the entrance of the substrate tunnel, which determined BCO1's specificity for the canonical β-ionone ring site. In contrast, BCO2 split substrates across the C9,C10 double bond adjacent to assorted ionone ring sites. Kinetic analysis revealed a higher catalytic efficiency of BCO2 with substrates bearing 3-hydroxy-β-ionone rings. In the mouse intestine, the asymmetric carotenoid β-cryptoxanthin with one canonical and one 3-hydroxy-β-ionone ring site was meticulously converted to vitamin A. The tailoring of this asymmetric substrate occurred by a stepwise processing of the carotenoid substrate by both CCDs and involved a β-apo-10'-carotenal intermediate. Thus, opposite selectivity for ionone ring sites of the two mammalian CCDs complement each other in the metabolic challenge of vitamin A production from a chemically diverse set of precursor molecules.

The Biochemical Basis of Vitamin A3 Production in Arthropod Vision

Metazoan photochemistry involves cis-trans isomerization of a retinylidene chromophore bound to G protein coupled receptors. Successful production of chromophores is critical for photoreceptor function and survival. For chromophore production, animals have to choose from more than 600 naturally occurring carotenoids and process them by oxidative cleavage and geometric isomerization of double bonds. Vertebrates employ three carotenoid cleavage oxygenases to tailor the carotenoid precursor in the synthesis of 11-cis-retinal (vitamin A1). Lepidoptera (butterfly and moth) possess only one such enzyme, NinaB, which faces the challenge to catalyze these reactions in unison to produce 11-cis-3-hydroxy-retinal (vitamin A3). We here showed that key to this multitasking is a bipartite substrate recognition site that conveys regio- and stereoselectivity for double bond processing. One side performed the specific C11, C12 cis-isomerization and preferentially binds 3-OH-β-ionone rings sites. The other side maintained a trans configuration in the resulting product and preferentially binds noncanonical ionone ring sites. Concurrent binding of carotenoids containing two cyclohexyl rings to both domains is required for specific oxidative cleavage at position C15, C15' of the substrate. The unique reaction sequence follows a dioxygenase mechanism with a carbocation/radical intermediate. This ingenious quality control system guarantees 11-cis-3-hydroxy-retinal production, the essential retinoid for insect (vitamin A3) vision.

Rhodopsins carrying modified chromophores--the 'making of', structural modelling and their light-induced reactivity

A series of vitamin-A aldehydes (retinals) with modified alkyl group substituents (9-demethyl-, 9-ethyl-, 9-isopropyl-, 10-methyl, 10-methyl-13-demethyl-, and 13-demethyl retinal) was synthesized and their 11-cis isomers were used as chromophores to reconstitute the visual pigment rhodopsin. Structural changes were selectively introduced around the photoisomerizing C11=C12 bond. The effect of these structural changes on rhodopsin formation and bleaching was determined. Global fit of assembly kinetics yielded lifetimes and spectral features of the assembly intermediates. Rhodopsin formation proceeds stepwise with prolonged lifetimes especially for 9-demethyl retinal (longest lifetime τ3 = 7500 s, cf., 3500 s for retinal), and for 10-methyl retinal (τ3 = 7850 s). These slowed-down processes are interpreted as either a loss of fixation (9dm) or an increased steric hindrance (10me) during the conformational adjustment within the protein. Combined quantum mechanics and molecular mechanics (QM/MM) simulations provided structural insight into the retinal analogues-assembled, full-length rhodopsins. Extinction coefficients, quantum yields and kinetics of the bleaching process (μs-to-ms time range) were determined. Global fit analysis yielded lifetimes and spectral features of bleaching intermediates, revealing remarkably altered kinetics: whereas the slowest process of wild-type rhodopsin and of bleached and 11-cis retinal assembled rhodopsin takes place with lifetimes of 7 and 3.8 s, respectively, this process for 10-methyl-13-demethyl retinal was nearly 10 h (34670 s), coming to completion only after ca. 50 h. The structural changes in retinal derivatives clearly identify the precise interactions between chromophore and protein during the light-induced changes that yield the outstanding efficiency of rhodopsin.

Evolutionary tinkering with visual photoreception

Eyes have evolved many times, and arthropods and vertebrates share transcription factors for early development. Moreover, the photochemistry of vision in all eyes employs an opsin and the isomerization of a retinoid from the 11-cis to the all-trans configuration. The opsins, however, have associated with several different G proteins, initiating hyperpolarizing and depolarizing conductance changes at the photoreceptor membrane. Beyond these obvious instances of homology, much of the evolutionary story is one of tinkering, producing a great variety of morphological forms and variation within functional themes. This outcome poses a central issue in the convergence of evolutionary and developmental biology: what are the heritable features in the later stages of development that give natural selection traction in altering phenotypic outcomes? This paper discusses some results of evolutionary tinkering where this question arises and, in some cases, where the reasons for particular outcomes and the role of adaptation may not be understood. Phenotypic features include: the exploitation of microvilli in rhabdomeric photoreceptors for detecting the plane of polarized light; different instances of retinoid in the visual pigment; examples of the many uses of accessory pigments in tuning the spectral sensitivity of photoreceptors; selection of opsins in tuning sensitivity in aquatic environments; employing either reflection or refraction in the optics of compound eyes; the multiple ways of constructing images in compound eyes; and the various ways of regenerating 11-cis retinals to maintain visual sensitivity. Evolution is an irreversible process, but tinkering may recover some lost functions, albeit by new mutational routes. There is both elegance and intellectual coherence to the natural processes that produce such variety and functional complexity. But marginalizing the teaching of evolution in public education is a continuing social and political problem that contributes to the reckless capacity of humans to alter the planet without trying to understand how nature works.

Quantum mechanical/molecular mechanical structure, enantioselectivity, and spectroscopy of hydroxyretinals and insights into the evolution of color vision in small white butterflies

Since Vogt's discovery of A(3)-retinal or 3-hydroxyretinal in insects in 1983 and Matsui's discovery of A(4)-retinal or 4-hydroxyretinal in firefly squid in 1988, hydroxyretinal-protein interactions mediating vision have remained largely unexplored. In the present study, A(3)- and A(4)-retinals are theoretically incorporated into squid and bovine visual pigments by use of the hybrid quantum mechanics/molecular mechanics [SORCI+Q//B3LYP/6-31G(d):Amber96] method, and insights into structure, enantioselectivity, and spectroscopy are gathered and presented for the first time. Contrary to general perception, our findings rule out the formation of a hydrogen bond between the hydroxyl-bearing β-ionone ring portion of retinal and opsin. Compared to A(1)-pigments, A(3)- and A(4)-pigments exhibit slightly blue-shifted absorption maxima due to increase in bond-length alternation of the hydroxyretinal. We suggest that (i) the binding site of firefly squid (Watasenia scintillans) opsin is very similar to that of the Japanese common squid (Todarodes pacificus) opsin; (ii) the molecular mechanism of spectral tuning in small white butterflies involve sites S116 and T185 and breaking of a hydrogen bond between sites E180 and T185; and finally (iii) A(3)-retinal may have occurred during the conversion of A(1)- to A(2)-retinal and insects may have acquired them, in order to absorb light in the blue-green wavelength region and to speed up the G-protein signaling cascade.

NinaB combines carotenoid oxygenase and retinoid isomerase activity in a single polypeptide

In animals, successful production of the visual chromophore (11-cis-retinal or derivatives thereof such as 11-cis-3-hydroxy-retinal) is essential for photoreceptor cell function and survival. These carotenoid-derived compounds must combine with a protein moiety (the opsin) to establish functional visual pigments. Evidence from cell culture systems has implicated that the retinal pigment epithelium protein of 65 kDa (RPE65) is the long-sought all-trans to 11-cis retinoid isomerase. RPE65 is structurally related to nonheme iron oxygenases that catalyze the conversion of carotenoids into retinoids. In vertebrate genomes, two carotenoid oxygenases and RPE65 are encoded, whereas in insect genomes only a single representative of this protein family, named NinaB (denoting neither inactivation nor afterpotential mutant B), is encoded. We here cloned and functionally characterized the ninaB gene from the great wax moth Galleria mellonella. We show that the recombinant purified enzyme combines isomerase and oxygenase (isomerooxygenase) activity in a single polypeptide. From kinetics and isomeric composition of cleavage products of asymmetrical carotenoid substrates, we propose a model for the spatial arrangement between substrate and enzyme. In Drosophila, we show that carotenoid-isomerooxygenase activity of NinaB is more generally found in insects, and we provide physiological evidence that carotenoids such as 11-cis-retinal can promote visual pigment biogenesis in the dark. Our study demonstrates that trans/cis isomerase activity can be intrinsic to this class of proteins and establishes these enzymes as key components for both invertebrate and vertebrate vision.

The evolution of color vision in insects

We review the physiological, molecular, and neural mechanisms of insect color vision. Phylogenetic and molecular analyses reveal that the basic bauplan, UV-blue-green-trichromacy, appears to date back to the Devonian ancestor of all pterygote insects. There are variations on this theme, however. These concern the number of color receptor types, their differential expression across the retina, and their fine tuning along the wavelength scale. In a few cases (but not in many others), these differences can be linked to visual ecology. Other insects have virtually identical sets of color receptors despite strong differences in lifestyle. Instead of the adaptionism that has dominated visual ecology in the past, we propose that chance evolutionary processes, history, and constraints should be considered. In addition to phylogenetic analyses designed to explore these factors, we suggest quantifying variance between individuals and populations and using fitness measurements to test the adaptive value of traits identified in insect color vision systems.

Functional expression of a locust visual pigment in transgenic Drosophila melanogaster

The cDNA encoding a visual pigment of the locust Schistocerca gregaria has been inserted into the germline of the ninaE mutant of Drosophila melanogaster by P-element-mediated transformation. Functional expression has been documented by recording light-regulated electroretinograms in transgenic flies. The spectral properties of the expressed visual pigment were determined with detergent-solubilized material, prepared from the eyecups of the transgenic D. melanogaster. The recombinant locust pigment, as well as the genuine pigment of the fruitfly (Rh1) that served as a control for transformation/expression, showed photoreversibility between the pigment and metapigment forms. The absorptions of the difference spectra identify the locust visual pigment as a short wavelength-absorbing, blue-light-sensitive photoreceptor. The absorption maxima are similar to those recorded on living locust animals. These results show that, although locust visual pigments contain 11-cis retinal as chromophore, the expressed protein is able to adopt 3-hydroxyretinal that is provided by the transgenic fruitflies. The electrophysiological recordings reveal that the locust visual pigment is able to induce phototransduction in the fruitfly. The reported results have two important consequences: On the one hand, the binding site of the locust opsin is apparently able to interact with the 3-hydroxyretinal from Drosophila in a way that the biological signal generated by the photoisomerization of the chromophore can be used by the protein to adopt a physiologically active conformation. On the other hand, despite the relatively large phylogenetic distance between both insect species, the extent of conservation between the protein domains thought to be involved in G-protein activation is striking.

Honeybee blue- and ultraviolet-sensitive opsins: cloning, heterologous expression in Drosophila, and physiological characterization

The honeybee (Apis mellifera) visual system contains three classes of retinal photoreceptor cells that are maximally sensitive to light at 440 nm (blue), 350 nm (ultraviolet), and 540 nm (green). We performed a PCR-based screen to identify the genes encoding the Apis blue- and ultraviolet (UV)-sensitive opsins. We obtained cDNAs that encode proteins having a high degree of sequence and structural similarity to other invertebrate and vertebrate visual pigments. The Apis blue opsin cDNA encodes a protein of 377 amino acids that is most closely related to other invertebrate visual pigments that are thought to be blue-sensitive. The UV opsin cDNA encodes a protein of 371 amino acids that is most closely related to the UV-sensitive Drosophila Rh3 and Rh4 opsins. To test whether these novel Apis opsin genes encode functional visual pigments and to determine their spectral properties, we expressed them in the R1-6 photoreceptor cells of blind ninaE mutant Drosophila, which lack the major opsin of the fly compound eye. We found that the expression of either the Apis blue- or UV-sensitive opsin in transgenic flies rescued the visual defect of ninaE mutants, indicating that both genes encode functional visual pigments. Spectral sensitivity measurements of these flies demonstrated that the blue and UV visual pigments are maximally sensitive to light at 439 and 353 nm, respectively. These maxima are in excellent agreement with those determined previously by single-cell recordings from Apis photoreceptor cells and provide definitive evidence that the genes described here encode visual pigments having blue and UV sensitivity.

The steric trigger in rhodopsin activation

Rhodopsin is the seven transmembrane helix receptor responsible for dim light vision in vertebrate rod cells. The protein has structural homology with the other G protein-coupled receptors, which suggests that the tertiary structures and activation mechanisms are likely to be similar. However, rhodopsin is unique in several respects. The most striking is the fact that the receptor "ligand", 11-cis retinal, is covalently bound to the protein and is converted from an "antagonist" to an "agonist" upon absorption of light. NMR studies of rhodopsin and its primary photoproduct, bathorhodopsin, have generated structural constraints that enabled docking of the 11-cis and all-trans retinal chromophores into a low-resolution model of the protein proposed by Baldwin. These studies also suggest a mechanism for how retinal isomerization leads to rhodopsin activation. More recently, mutagenesis studies have extended these results by showing how the selectivity of the retinal-binding site can be modified to favor the all-trans over the 11-cis isomer. The structural constraints produced from these studies, when placed in the context of a high-resolution model of the protein, provide a coherent picture of the activation mechanism, which we show involves a direct steric interaction between the retinal chromophore and transmembrane helix 3 in the region of Gly121.

The transmembrane 7-alpha-bundle of rhodopsin: distance geometry calculations with hydrogen bonding constraints

A 3D model of the transmembrane 7-alpha-bundle of rhodopsin-like G-protein-coupled receptors (GPCRs) was calculated using an iterative distance geometry refinement with an evolving system of hydrogen bonds, formed by intramembrane polar side chains in various proteins of the family and collectively applied as distance constraints. The alpha-bundle structure thus obtained provides H bonding of nearly all buried polar side chains simultaneously in the 410 GPCRs considered. Forty evolutionarily conserved GPCR residues form a single continuous domain, with an aliphatic "core" surrounded by six clusters of polar and aromatic side chains. The 7-alpha-bundle of a specific GPCR can be calculated using its own set of H bonds as distance constraints and the common "average" model to restrain positions of the helices. The bovine rhodopsin model thus determined is closely packed, but has a few small polar cavities, presumably filled by water, and has a binding pocket that is complementary to 11-cis (6-s-cis, 12-s-trans, C = N anti)-retinal or to all-trans-retinal, depending on conformations of the Lys296 and Trp265 side chains. A suggested mechanism of rhodopsin photoactivation, triggered by the cis-trans isomerization of retinal, involves rotations of Glu134, Tyr223, Trp265, Lys296, and Tyr306 side chains and rearrangement of their H bonds. The model is in agreement with published electron cryomicroscopy, mutagenesis, chemical modification, cross-linking, Fourier transform infrared spectroscopy, Raman spectroscopy, electron paramagnetic resonance spectroscopy, NMR, and optical spectroscopy data. The rhodopsin model and the published structure of bacteriorhodopsin have very similar retinal-binding pockets.

Steric hindrance between chromophore substituents as the driving force of rhodopsin photoisomerization: 10-methyl-13-demethyl retinal containing rhodopsin

A visual chromophore analogue, 10-methyl-13-demethyl (dm) retinal, was synthesized and reconstituted with bleached bovine rhodopsin to form a visual pigment derivative with absorbance maximum at 505 nm. The investigations with this new compound were stimulated from recent results using 13-dm retinal as a chromophore that revealed a remarkable loss in quantum efficiency (phi of 13-dm retinal-containing rhodopsin: 0.30, Ternieden and Gärtner, J. Photochem. Photobiol. B Biol, 33, 83-86, 1996). The quantum efficiency of the new pigment was determined as 0.59 by quantitative bleaching using reconstituted rhodopsin as a reference. The very similar quantum efficiencies of rhodopsin and the new pigment give experimental support for the recently presented hypothesis that a steric hindrance between the substituents at positions 10 and 13 in 11-cis-retinal is elevated during the photoisomerization and thus facilitates the rapid photoisomerization of the visual chromophore (Peteanu et al., Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 90, 11762-11766, 1993). Such steric hindrance is removed from the molecule by the elimination of the methyl group from position 13 and can be re-established via a rearrangement of the substitution pattern by introducing a methyl group at position 10 of 13-dm retinal.

The primary structure of mantid opsin

The sequence encoding opsin from the mantid Sphodromantis sp. has been determined by dideoxynucleotide sequencing of PCR products from a cDNA derived from eye cup tissue. The 376-amino-acid (aa) residues show approx. 56% identity and 85% similarity to known insect opsins (Drosophila melanogaster and Calliphora erythrocephala). The predicted protein structure, based on the hydropathy profile and placement of key aa residues, reveals a seven-transmembrane structure typical of a rhodopsin. Unlike the previously characterised insect visual pigments which have 3-hydroxy retinal in their binding sites, mantid rhodopsin contains 11-cis retinal. Comparison of transmembrane sequences from the opsin family was performed in order to identify any specific aa substitutions which are able to account for the selection of retinal or its 3-hydroxy derivative by insect opsins.