Comparison of multiple electrode aggregometry with lumi-aggregometry for the diagnosis of patients with mild bleeding disorders

Point-of-Care Testing in Patients with Hereditary Disorders of Primary Hemostasis: A Narrative Review

Inherited disorders of primary hemostasis, such as von Willebrand disease and congenital platelet disorders, can cause extensive, typically mucocutaneous bleeding. Assays to diagnose and monitor these disorders, such as von Willebrand factor activity assays and light transmission aggregometry, are performed in specialized hemostasis laboratories but are commonly not available in local hospitals. Due to the complexity and relative scarcity of these conventional assays, point-of-care tests (POCT) might be an attractive alternative in patients with hereditary bleeding disorders. POCTs, such as thromboelastography, are increasingly used to assess hemostasis in patients with acquired hemostatic defects, aiding clinical decision-making in critical situations, such as during surgery or childbirth. In comparison, the use of these assays in patients with hereditary hemostasis defects remains relatively unexplored. This review aims to give an overview of point-of-care hemostasis tests in patients with hereditary disorders of primary hemostasis. A summary of the literature reporting on the performance of currently available and experimental POCTs in these disorders is given, and the potential utility of the assays in various use scenarios is discussed. Altogether, the studies included in this review reveal that several POCTs are capable of identifying and monitoring severe defects in the primary hemostasis, while a POCT that can reliably detect milder defects of primary hemostasis is currently lacking. A better understanding of the strengths and limitations of POCTs in assessing hereditary defects of primary hemostasis is needed, after which these tests may become available for clinical practice, potentially targeting a large group of patients with milder defects of primary hemostasis.

Factors that modulate platelet reactivity as measured by 5 assay platforms in 3429 individuals

Background

Assessment of platelet function is key in diagnosing bleeding disorders and evaluating antiplatelet drug efficacy. However, there is a prevailing "one-size-fits-all" approach in the interpretation of measures of platelet reactivity, with arbitrary cutoffs often derived from healthy volunteer responses.

Objectives

Our aim was to compare well-used platelet reactivity assays.

Methods

Blood and platelet-rich plasma obtained from the Framingham Heart Study (N = 3429) were assayed using a range of agonists in 5 platelet assays: light transmission aggregometry, Optimul aggregometry, Multiplate impedance aggregometry (Roche Diagnostics), Total Thrombus-Formation Analysis System, and flow cytometry. Using linear mixed-effect models, we determined the contribution of preanalytical and technical factors that modulated platelet reactivity traits.

Results

A strong intra-assay correlation of platelet traits was seen in all assays, particularly Multiplate velocity (r = 0.740; ristocetin vs arachidonic acid). In contrast, only moderate interassay correlations were observed (r = 0.375; adenosine diphosphate Optimul Emax vs light transmission aggregometry large area under the curve). As expected, antiplatelet drugs strongly reduced platelet responses, with aspirin use primarily targeting arachidonic acid-induced aggregation, and explained substantial variance (β = -1.735; P = 4.59 × 10-780; variance proportion = 46.2%) and P2Y12 antagonists blocking adenosine diphosphate responses (β = -1.612; P = 6.75 × 10-27; variance proportion = 2.1%). Notably, female sex and older age were associated with enhanced platelet reactivity. Fasting status and deviations from standard venipuncture practices did not alter platelet reactivity significantly. Finally, the agonist batch, phlebotomist, and assay technician (more so for assays that require additional sample manipulation) had a moderate to large effect on measured platelet reactivity.

Conclusion

Caution must be exercised when extrapolating findings between assays, and the use of standard ranges must be medication-specific and sex-specific at a minimum. Researchers should also consider preanalytical and technical variables when designing experiments and interpreting platelet reactivity measures.

Platelet function testing: Current practice among clinical centres in Northern Europe

Introduction

Platelet function tests are used to screen and diagnose patients with possible inherited platelet function defects (IPFD). Some acquired platelet dysfunction may be caused by certain drugs or comorbidities, which need to be excluded before testing.

Aims

To identify current practice among centres performing platelet function tests in Northern Europe.

Methods

A total of 14 clinical centres from Sweden (six), Finland (two), Denmark (two), Norway (one), Estonia (two) and Iceland (one) completed the survey questionnaire, the population capture area of about 29.5 million.

Results

Six of the 14 (42.8%) centres providing platelet function assessment represent comprehensive treatment centres (EUHANET status). A Bleeding score (BS) or ISTH bleeding assessment tool (ISTH BAT score) is evaluated in 11/14 (78.6%) centres and family history in all. Five/14 centres (35.7%) use structured preanalytical patient instructions, and 10/14 (71.4%) recorded questionnaire on the preassessment of avoidance of any drugs or natural products affecting platelet functions. Preliminary investigations of screening tests of coagulation are performed in 10/14 (71.4%), while in 4/14 (28.6%), the diagnostic work‐up of IPFD and von Willebrand disease (VWD) is performed simultaneously. The work‐up of IPFD includes peripheral blood smear in 10/14 (71.4%), platelet aggregometry in all, flow cytometry in 10/14 (71.4%) and Platelet Function Analysis (PFA) in 3/11 (28.6%). Molecular genetic diagnosis is available in 7/14 (50%) centres.

Conclusions

The considerable variability in the current practice illustrates the need for harmonization between the Northern European centres according to the international registers (i.e. EUHASS) and IPFD guidelines (ISTH, EHA).

Screening and diagnosis of inherited platelet disorders

Inherited platelet disorders are important conditions that often manifest with bleeding. These disorders have heterogeneous underlying pathologies. Some are syndromic disorders with non-blood phenotypic features, and others are associated with an increased predisposition to developing myelodysplasia and leukemia. Platelet disorders can present with thrombocytopenia, defects in platelet function, or both. As the underlying pathogenesis of inherited thrombocytopenias and platelet function disorders are quite diverse, their evaluation requires a thorough clinical assessment and specialized diagnostic tests, that often challenge diagnostic laboratories. At present, many of the commonly encountered, non-syndromic platelet disorders do not have a defined molecular cause. Nonetheless, significant progress has been made over the past few decades to improve the diagnostic evaluation of inherited platelet disorders, from the assessment of the bleeding history to improved standardization of light transmission aggregometry, which remains a "gold standard" test of platelet function. Some platelet disorder test findings are highly predictive of a bleeding disorder and some show association to symptoms of prolonged bleeding, surgical bleeding, and wound healing problems. Multiple assays can be required to diagnose common and rare platelet disorders, each requiring control of preanalytical, analytical, and post-analytical variables. The laboratory investigations of platelet disorders include evaluations of platelet counts, size, and morphology by light microscopy; assessments for aggregation defects; tests for dense granule deficiency; analyses of granule constituents and their release; platelet protein analysis by immunofluorescent staining or flow cytometry; tests of platelet procoagulant function; evaluations of platelet ultrastructure; high-throughput sequencing and other molecular diagnostic tests. The focus of this article is to review current methods for the diagnostic assessment of platelet function, with a focus on contemporary, best diagnostic laboratory practices, and relationships between clinical and laboratory findings.

A guide to molecular and functional investigations of platelets to bridge basic and clinical sciences

Platelets have been shown to be associated with pathophysiological process beyond thrombosis, demonstrating critical additional roles in homeostatic processes, such as immune regulation, and vascular remodeling. Platelets themselves can have multiple functional states and can communicate and regulate other cells including immune cells and vascular smooth muscle cells, to serve such diverse functions. Although traditional platelet functional assays are informative and reliable, they are limited in their ability to unravel platelet phenotypic heterogeneity and interactions. Developments in methods such as electron microscopy, flow cytometry, mass spectrometry, and 'omics' studies, have led to new insights. In this Review, we focus on advances in platelet biology and function, with an emphasis on current and promising methodologies. We also discuss technical and biological challenges in platelet investigations. Using coronavirus disease 2019 (COVID-19) as an example, we further describe the translational relevance of these approaches and the possible 'bench-to-bedside' utility in patient diagnosis and care.

Flavonoids: Antiplatelet Effect as Inhibitors of COX-1

Flavonoids are compounds with a benzopyranic structure that exhibits multiple pharmacological activities. They are known for their venotonic activity, but their mechanism of action remains unclear. It is thought that, as this mechanism is mediated by prostaglandins, these compounds may interfere with the arachidonic acid (AA) cascade. These assays are designed to measure the antiplatelet aggregation capacity of quercetin, rutin, diosmetin, diosmin, and hidrosmin, as well as to evaluate a potential structure−activity ratio. In this paper, several studies on platelet aggregation at different concentrations (from 0.33 mM to 1.5 mM) of different flavone compounds are conducted, measuring platelet aggregation by impedance aggregometry, and the cyclooxygenase (COX) activity by metabolites generated, including the activity of the pure recombinant enzyme in the presence of these polyphenols. The results obtained showed that quercetin and diosmetin aglycones have a greater antiplatelet effect and inhibit the COX enzyme activity to a greater extent than their heterosides; however, the fact that greater inhibition of the pure recombinant enzyme was achieved by heterosides suggests that these compounds may have difficulty in crossing biological membranes. In any case, in view of the results obtained, it can be concluded that flavonoids could be useful as coadjuvants in the treatment of cardiovascular pathologies.

Diagnosing Inherited Platelet Disorders: Modalities and Consequences

Inherited platelet disorders (IPDs) are a group of rare conditions featured by reduced circulating platelets and/or impaired platelet function causing variable bleeding tendency. Additional hematological or non hematological features, which can be congenital or acquired, distinctively mark the clinical picture of a subgroup of patients. Recognizing an IPD is challenging, and diagnostic delay or mistakes are frequent. Despite the increasing availability of next-generation sequencing, a careful phenotyping of suspected patients-concerning the general clinical features, platelet morphology, and function-is still demanded. The cornerstones of IPD diagnosis are clinical evaluation, laboratory characterization, and genetic testing. Achieving a diagnosis of IPD is desirable for several reasons, including the possibility of tailored therapeutic strategies and individual follow-up programs. However, detailed investigations can also open complex scenarios raising ethical issues in case of IPDs predisposing to hematological malignancies. This review offers an overview of IPD diagnostic workup, from the interview with the proband to the molecular confirmation of the suspected disorder. The main implications of an IPD diagnosis are also discussed.

The Current Role of Platelet Function Testing in Clinical Practice

Platelet dysfunction, whether hereditary or acquired, may increase an individual's risk of spontaneous, posttraumatic, or postoperative bleeding. Conversely, increased platelet reactivity on antiplatelet agents following vascular (in particular, coronary vascular) intervention may increase the risk of thrombosis and adverse vascular events. The aim of platelet function testing is to identify and characterize platelet dysfunction in these settings to inform bleeding/ thrombosis risk and guide perioperative prophylactic management strategies. A vast array of screening and diagnostic tests is available for this purpose. The successful clinical application of platelet function tests depends on the knowledge of their analytical strengths and limitations and the correct extrapolation of derived results to a particular clinical scenario. This review critically appraises traditional and contemporary platelet function testing focusing on their role in clinical practice.

Platelet Phenotyping and Function Testing in Thrombocytopenia

Patients who suffer from inherited or acquired thrombocytopenia can be also affected by platelet function defects, which potentially increase the risk of severe and life-threatening bleeding complications. A plethora of tests and assays for platelet phenotyping and function analysis are available, which are, in part, feasible in clinical practice due to adequate point-of-care qualities. However, most of them are time-consuming, require experienced and skilled personnel for platelet handling and processing, and are therefore well-established only in specialized laboratories. This review summarizes major indications, methods/assays for platelet phenotyping, and in vitro function testing in blood samples with reduced platelet count in relation to their clinical practicability. In addition, the diagnostic significance, difficulties, and challenges of selected tests to evaluate the hemostatic capacity and specific defects of platelets with reduced number are addressed.

Bleeding Disorders Associated with Abnormal Platelets: Glanzmann Thrombasthenia and Bernard-Soulier Syndrome

Platelets, the smallest cells in the blood, are associated with hemostasis, bowel formation, tissue remodeling, and wound healing. Although the prevalence of inherited platelet disorders is not fully known, it is a rare disease group and is encountered in approximately between 10000 and 1000000. Glanzmann thrombasthenia (GT) and Bernard-Soulier syndrome (BSS) are more frequently observed in inherited platelet disorders. In GT, the platelet aggregation stage due to deficiency or dysfunction of the platelet GPIIb/IIIa complex cannot take place. BSS is a platelet adhesion disorder due to the absence or abnormality of GPIb/IX complex on the platelet surface. If there is bleeding after easy bruising, mucous and oral cavities, menorrhagia, tooth extraction, tonsillectomy, or other surgical interventions, inherited platelet dysfunction should be considered if the platelet count is normal while the bleeding time is long. Firstly, other causes should be investigated by making differential diagnosis of GT and BSS. In this chapter, the definition, etiology, historical process, epidemiology, genetic basis, pathophysiology, clinical findings, diagnosis, differential diagnosis, and the follow-up and treatment approach of GT and BSS will be reviewed according to the current medical literature.

Optimized tool for evaluation of platelet function measured by impedance aggregometry

Platelet aggregation measured by impedance aggregometry is highly dependent on platelet count. We previously developed a tool to interpret impedance aggregometry based on the strong linear correlation between platelet counts and platelet aggregation at reduced platelet counts. The present study aimed to optimize the tool by expanding the model to include normal platelet counts. We combined data from three previous studies on 266 healthy individuals measuring impedance aggregometry with four agonists (collagen, adenosine diphosphate, thrombin receptor activating peptide-6, and ristocetin). Reduced platelet counts were established in vitro. The investigated platelet counts ranged from 26-425x10⁹/L. A positive linear correlation was found between platelet counts and platelet aggregation across normal and reduced platelet counts (all p-values <0.001). We established 95% prediction intervals for healthy platelet aggregation in relation to platelet count. The new expanded model serves as an optimized tool for evaluation of platelet aggregation at normal and reduced platelet counts.

Advances in Platelet Function Testing-Light Transmission Aggregometry and Beyond

Platelet function testing is essential for the diagnosis of hemostasis disorders. While there are many methods used to test platelet function for research purposes, standardization is often lacking, limiting their use in clinical practice. Light transmission aggregometry has been the gold standard for over 60 years, with inherent challenges of working with live dynamic cells in specialized laboratories with independent protocols. In recent years, standardization efforts have brought forward fully automated systems that could lead to more widespread use. Additionally, new technical approaches appear promising for the future of specialized hematology laboratories. This review presents developments in platelet function testing for clinical applications.

Effects of Time-Interval since Blood Draw and of Anticoagulation on Platelet Testing (Count, Indices and Impedance Aggregometry): A Systematic Study with Blood from Healthy Volunteers

Platelet count, indices (mean volume, young-immature platelet fraction) and aggregation are widely used laboratory parameters to investigate primary hemostasis. We performed a systematic, thorough evaluation of the influence of the time-interval since blood draw from 20 healthy individuals and of the anticoagulation of collected blood on such parameters. Blood was anticoagulated with citrate, K₂-ethylenediaminetetraacetic acid (EDTA) and hirudin and analyzed 5, 30, 60, 120 and 180 min after blood draw. Multiple electrode aggregometry (MEA) was performed with either hirudin (half-diluted with NaCl) or citrate samples (half-diluted with NaCl or CaCl₂ 3 mM). Platelet count and indices (Sysmex XN-20) were rather stable over time with EDTA blood. MEA results were lower with citrate blood than with hirudin blood; supplementation with calcium was partially compensatory. MEA results were also lower when performed less than 30 or more than 120 min after blood draw. Platelet clumping, quantitatively estimated with microscope examination of blood smears, was more important in hirudin blood than citrate or EDTA blood and could explain some of the differences observed between preanalytical variables. The results stress once more the importance of preanalytical variables in hemostasis laboratory testing. Decision thresholds based on those tests are only applicable within specific preanalytical conditions.

Harmonizing light transmission aggregometry in the Netherlands by implementation of the SSC-ISTH guideline

Light transmission aggregometry (LTA) is considered the gold standard method for evaluation of platelet function. However, there are a lot of variation in protocols (pre-analytical procedures and agonist concentrations) and results. The aim of our study was to establish a national LTA protocol, to investigate the effect of standardization and to define national reference values for LTA. The SSC guideline was used as base for a national procedure. Almost all recommendations of the SSC were followed e.g. no adjustment of PRP, citrate concentration of 109 mM, 21 needle gauge, fasting, resting time for whole blood and PRP, centrifugation time, speed and agonists concentrations. LTA of healthy volunteers was measured in a total of 16 hospitals with 5 hospitals before and after standardization. Results of more than 120 healthy volunteers (maximum aggregation %) were collected, with participating laboratories using 4 different analyzers with different reagents. Use of low agonist concentrations showed high variation before and after standardization, with the exception of collagen. For most high agonist concentrations (ADP, collagen, ristocetin, epinephrine and arachidonic acid) variability in healthy subjects decreased after standardization. We can conclude that a standardized Dutch protocol for LTA, based on the SSC guideline, does not result in smaller variability in healthy volunteers for all agonist concentrations.

Glanzmann thrombasthenia: genetic basis and clinical correlates

Glanzmann thrombasthenia (GT) is an autosomal recessive disorder of platelet aggregation caused by quantitative or qualitative defects in integrins αIIb and β3. These integrins are encoded by the ITGA2B and ITGB3 genes and form platelet glycoprotein (GP)IIb/IIIa, which acts as the principal platelet receptor for fibrinogen. Although there is variability in the clinical phenotype, most patients present with severe mucocutaneous bleeding at an early age. A classic pattern of abnormal platelet aggregation, platelet glycoprotein expression and molecular studies confirm the diagnosis. Management of bleeding is based on a combination of hemostatic agents including recombinant activated factor VII with or without platelet transfusions and antifibrinolytic agents. Refractory bleeding and platelet alloimmunization are common complications. In addition, pregnant patients pose unique management challenges. This review highlights clinical and molecular aspects in the approach to patients with GT, with particular emphasis on the significance of multidisciplinary care.

An integrated approach to inherited platelet disorders: results from a research collaborative, the Sydney Platelet Group

Inherited disorders of platelet function (IPFD) and/or number (IPND) are heterogeneous conditions that result in variable mucocutaneous bleeding symptoms as a result of deranged primary haemostasis caused by platelet dysfunction or thrombocytopenia. Diagnosis is important to guide post-operative bleeding prophylactic strategies, to avoid treatment with inappropriate medications, and inform prognosis. Achieving an accurate diagnosis has traditionally been hampered by the requirement of multiple, often complex, laboratory tests that are not always available at single centres. To improve the diagnosis of these disorders a research collaborative was established, the Sydney Platelet Group, that explored an integrated approach combining traditional and contemporary platelet phenotypic and genetic diagnostic platforms available at four Sydney tertiary hospitals. Herein we report the outcomes of the first 50 patients evaluated using this approach. The cohort included 22 individuals with suspected IPFD and 28 with thrombocytopenia. Bleeding scores were higher in individuals with IPFD (mean 5.75; SD 4.83) than those with IPNDs (mean 2.14; SD 2.45). In cases with suspected IPFD, diagnosis to the level of the defective pathway was achieved in 71% and four individuals were found not to have a definitive platelet function defect. Dense granule secretion disorders were the most common platelet pathway abnormality detected (n=5). Mean bleeding scores in these individuals were not significantly different to individuals with defects in other commonly detected platelet pathways (dense granules, signal transduction and 'undetermined'). A molecular diagnosis was achieved in 52% of individuals with IPNDs and 5% with IPFD. Likely pathogenic and pathogenic variants detected included variants associated with extra-haematological complications (DIAPH1, MYH9) and potential for malignancy (ANKRD26 and RUNX1). The level of platelet investigation undertaken by this initiative is currently not available elsewhere in Australia and initial results confirm the utility of this integrated phenotypic-genetic approach.

Acquired platelet function disorders

The possibility of an acquired platelet function disorder should be considered in patients who present with recent onset muco-cutaneous bleeding. Despite the availability of newer and faster platelet function assays, light transmission aggregometry (LTA) remains the preferred diagnostic test. This review examines and discusses the causes of acquired platelet dysfunction; most commonly drugs, dietary factors, medical disorders and procedures. In addition to well-known antiplatelet therapies, clinicians should be alert for newer drugs which can affect platelets, such as ibrutinib. There is little clinical trial evidence to guide the management of acquired platelet function defects, but we summarise commonly employed strategies, which include addressing the underlying cause, antifibrinolytic agents, desmopressin infusions, and in selected patients, platelet transfusions.

Diagnostic challenges of inherited mild bleeding disorders: a bait for poorly explored clinical and basic research

The best-known inherited mild bleeding disorders (MBDs), i.e. type 1 von Willebrand disease (VWD), platelet function disorders (PFDs), and mild to moderate clotting factor deficiencies, are characterized clinically by mucocutaneous bleeding, and, although they are highly prevalent, still pose difficult diagnostic problems. These include establishing the pathological nature of bleeding, and the uncertainties surrounding the clinical relevance of laboratory results. Furthermore, the high frequency of bleeding symptoms in the normal population and the subjective appraisal of symptoms by patients or parents makes elucidating the pathological nature of bleeding difficult. Standardized bleeding assessment tools and semiquantitative bleeding scores (BSs) help to discriminate normal from abnormal bleeding. However, as most MBDs have similar bleeding patterns, for example, bleeding sites, frequency, and severity, BSs are of little help for diagnosing specific diseases. Global tests of primary hemostasis (bleeding time; PFA-100/200) lack sensitivity and, like BSs, are not disease-specific. Problems with the diagnosis of type 1 VWD and PFD include assay standardization, uncertain definition of von Willebrand factor cut-off levels, and the lack of universal diagnostic criteria for PFD. Regarding clotting factor deficiencies, the bleeding thresholds of some coagulation factors, such as factor VII and FXI, are highly variable, and may lead to misinterpretation of the clinical relevance of mild to moderate deficiencies. Remarkably, a large proportion of MBDs remain undiagnosed even after comprehensive and repeated laboratory testing. These are tentatively considered to represent bleeding of undefined cause, with clinical features indistinguishable from those of classical MBD; the pathogenesis of this is probably multifactorial, and unveiling these mechanisms should constitute a fertile source of translational research.

High prevalence of reduced thrombin generation and/or decreased platelet response in women with unexplained heavy menstrual bleeding

INTRODUCTION

Heavy menstrual bleeding (HMB) is a condition that affects 20%-30% of women of reproductive age. HMB has a multifactorial pathophysiology, which is incompletely understood. HMB symptoms are very common in patients with established haemostasis defects, likewise, women with heavy menstrual bleeding have a higher prevalence of impaired Von Willebrand factor (VWF) levels and function, thrombocytopenia, impaired platelet function and impaired coagulation. The aim of this study was to quantify the prevalence of impaired platelet function, impaired coagulation and reduced VWF activity in patients with HMB.

METHODS

We have used thrombin generation (TG), a flow cytometry-based platelet function test and a flow cytometry-based VWF function test to study haemostasis in 58 women (median age: 48.4 years, range 40-60 years) with HMB. In addition, we determined VWF antigen levels and VWF ristocetin co-factor activity in platelet-poor plasma. Reference ranges of platelet function were measured in whole blood of 123 healthy volunteers, while reference ranges of TG were determined in platelet-poor plasma (PPP) of 126 healthy volunteers.

RESULTS

Fourteen (24%) patients with HMB had impaired platelet function and 17 (29.3%) patients had impaired coagulation. Five patients (8.6%) had both impaired platelet function and impaired coagulation. Only 2 (3.4%) patients had an impaired VWF function or levels; one of them was in combination with impaired coagulation.

CONCLUSION

Our approach in women with HMB using a high precision platelet function test in combination with thrombin generation showed impaired coagulation or impaired platelet function in more than 40% of the patients.