Performance of mycology and histopathology tests for the diagnosis of toenail onychomycosis due to filamentous fungi: Dermatophyte and non-dermatophyte moulds

Update on nail unit histopathology

Histopathologic evaluation of the nail unit is an essential component in the diagnosis of nail unit disorders. This review highlights recent updates in nail unit histopathology and discusses literature covering a wide range of nail disorders including melanoma/melanocytic lesions, squamous cell carcinoma, onychomatricoma, onychopapilloma, onychomycosis, lichen planus, and other inflammatory conditions. Herein we also discuss recent literature on nail clipping histopathology, a useful and noninvasive diagnostic tool that continues to grow in popularity and importance to both dermatologists and dermatopathologists.

High Diversity of Fusarium Species in Onychomycosis: Clinical Presentations, Molecular Identification, and Antifungal Susceptibility

Fusarium are uncommon but important pathogenic organisms; they cause non-dermatophyte mould (NDM) onychomycosis. Patients typically respond poorly to treatment owing to Fusarium's native resistance to multiple antifungal drugs. However, epidemiological data for Fusarium onychomycosis are lacking in Taiwan. We retrospectively reviewed the data of 84 patients with positive Fusarium nail sample cultures at Chang Gung Memorial Hospital, Linkou Branch between 2014 and 2020. We aimed to investigate the clinical presentations, microscopic and pathological characteristics, antifungal susceptibility, and species diversity of Fusarium in patients with Fusarium onychomycosis. We enrolled 29 patients using the six-parameter criteria for NDM onychomycosis to determine the clinical significance of Fusarium in these patients. All isolates were subjected to species identification by sequences and molecular phylogeny. A total of 47 Fusarium strains belonging to 13 species in four different Fusarium species complexes (with Fusarium keratoplasticum predominating) were isolated from 29 patients. Six types of histopathology findings were specific to Fusarium onychomycosis, which may be useful for differentiating dermatophytes from NDMs. The results of drug susceptibility testing showed high variation among species complexes, and efinaconazole, lanoconazole, and luliconazole showed excellent in vitro activity for the most part. This study's primary limitation was its single-centre retrospective design. Our study showed a high diversity of Fusarium species in diseased nails. Fusarium onychomycosis has clinical and pathological features distinct from those of dermatophyte onychomycosis. Thus, careful diagnosis and proper pathogen identification are essential in the management of NDM onychomycosis caused by Fusarium sp.

Fractional CO2 laser - assisted methylene blue photodynamic therapy is a potential alternative therapy for onychomycosis in the era of antifungal resistance

BACKGROUND

Treatment of onychomycosis is challenging by virtue of the impact of nail disfigurement, the location of the fungi within the nail and reported antifungal resistance worldwide. Light-based technologies are promising primary or adjunctive therapeutic modalities. We aimed to compare the efficacy of photodynamic therapy and fractional CO2 laser monotherapy either alone or in combination for onychomycosis.

PATIENTS AND METHODS

This prospective randomized comparative study was conducted on 51 onychomycosis patients divided into three groups. In group A, patients were treated using 6 photodynamic therapy sessions using methylene blue and IPL (560 to 700 nm, fluence 12 J/cm2). Group B patients were treated using 6 bimonthly fractional CO2 laser sessions (10,600 nm, 1.600 mj energy and 0.6 mm density) and group C patients were treated using 6 combined fractional CO2 laser and photodynamic therapy sessions. Patients were evaluated mycologically, dermoscopically and clinically by calculation of proximal nail diameter percentage at baseline, monthly, at the end of treatment and after a 6-month follow-up period post-treatment.

RESULTS

Candida was the most commonly isolated organismin in 64.7%, 70.6% and 70.6% of the pateints in groups A, B and C, respectively. The dermoscopic findings in the total dystrophic onychomycosis was subungual hyperkeratosis in 6 patients (100%), longitudinal streaks and striae in 1 patient (16.7%). In dorsolateral subungual onychomycosis, jagged proximal edge in 31 patients (70.5%), and pigmentation in 30 patients (68.2%) were noted. In proximal subungual onychomycosis irregular matt patches were seen in 1 patient (100%). Proximal nail diameter percentage showed statistically significant improvement after treatment and 6 months follow up in the 3 studied groups. Mean increase of proximal nail diameter after treatment was highest in group C (52.94 ± 20.24), followed by group B (43.82 ± 21.03) and least in group A (35.29 ± 17.0). This difference was statistically significant (p = 0.044). Reported side effects were mild-moderate pain, discoloration and paronychia.

CONCLUSION

We conclude that fractional CO2 laser and photodynamic monotherapy, and their combination achieve high success rates, good patient satisfaction and safety profile. Fractional CO2-assisted photodynamic therapy is associated with the highest improvement over either fractional CO2 or photodynamic therapy alone.

Epidemiological analysis of nail aspergillosis and non-dermatophyte moulds. Criteria for the involvement of Aspergillus in 102 cases of onychomycosis at Montpellier University Hospital, France (1991-2019)

BACKGROUND

Moulds are often wrongly considered contaminants, not very sensitive to conventional antifungal treatments, but they may cause ungual hyphomycosis, particularly Aspergillus. Due to the lack of precise diagnostic criteria, their real impact is underestimated.

OBJECTIVES

Retrospective descriptive analysis of all ungual hyphomycosis cases diagnosed at Montpellier Hospital from 1991 to 2019 to: (i) determine the incidence of onychomycosis by pseudo-dermatophytes and moulds; (ii) perform an epidemiological analysis of nail aspergillosis; and (iii) provide simple criteria for mould involvement in onychopathy.

PATIENTS/METHODS

Data concerning 4053 patients were collected: age, sex, onychomycosis location, direct examination results, species(s) identified and fungal co-infections. Moreover, clinical data of patients with nail aspergillosis were analysed to identify potential contributing factors, and the classical criteria for mould involvement in onychopathy were critically reviewed.

RESULTS

A pseudo-dermatophyte or a mould was involved in nail colonisation in 17.25% of patients (men/women ratio: 0.70; mean age: 53.1 years). The identified hyphomycetes belonged mainly to the genera Fusarium (45.68%), Scopulariopsis (30.23%) and Aspergillus (16.94%). Analysis of the clinical reports of 102 patients with ungual aspergillosis (men/women ratio: 0.67; mean age: 56.3 years) identified cardiovascular (43.9%), endocrine (25.8%), cancer (19.7%) and skin (18.2%) diseases as contributing factors.

CONCLUSIONS

The adoption of simple and reliable criteria (ie, characteristic filaments on direct microscopic examination after periodic acid-Schiff staining, growth at seeding points in culture) allows determining the formal involvement of a mould in chronic onychopathies and avoiding possible side effects and costs of empirical or inappropriate and repetitive treatments.

Ex vivo potential of a quinoline-derivative nail lacquer as a new alternative for dermatophytic onychomycosis treatment

Introduction. Onychomycosis infections currently show a significant increase, affecting about 10 % of the world population. Trichophyton rubrum is the main agent responsible for about 80 % of the reported infections. The clinical cure for onychomycosis is extremely difficult and effective new antifungal therapy is needed.Hypothesis/Gap Statement. Ex vivo onychomycosis models using porcine hooves can be an excellent alternative for evaluating the efficacy of new anti-dermatophytic agents in a nail lacquer.Aim. Evaluation of the effectiveness of a nail lacquer containing a quinoline derivative on an ex vivo onychomycosis model using porcine hooves, as well as the proposal of a plausible antifungal mechanism of this derivative against dermatophytic strains.Methodology. The action mechanism of a quinoline derivative was evaluated through the sorbitol protection assay, exogenous ergosterol binding, and the determination of the dose-response curves by time-kill assay. Scanning electron microscopy evaluated the effect of the derivative in the fungal cells. The efficacy of a quinoline-derivative nail lacquer on an ex vivo onychomycosis model using porcine hooves was evaluated as well.Results. The quinoline derivative showed a time-dependent fungicidal effect, demonstrating reduction and damage in the morphology of dermatophytic hyphae. In addition, the ex vivo onychomycosis model was effective in the establishment of infection by T. rubrum.Conclusion. Treatment with the quinoline-derivative lacquer showed a significant inhibitory effect on T. rubrum strain in this infection model. Finally, the compound presents high potential for application in a formulation such as nail lacquer as a possible treatment for dermatophytic onychomycosis.

Onychomycosis caused by the environmental mold Neoscytalidium dimidiatum in Colombia, and in vitro antifungal susceptibility evaluation

Neoscytalidium dimidiatum is a plant pathogen, but can also cause onychomycosis. We compared clinical and epidemiological data of cases of onychomycosis caused by N. dimidiatum and Trichophyton rubrum. We also evaluated the in vitro antifungal susceptibility of N. dimidiatum clinical isolates. It was not possible to establish any statistical differences between groups, except the place of residence and the number of affected nails. The results suggest that onychomycosis caused by N. dimidiatum is clinically similar to that caused by T. rubrum; besides, N. dimidiatum has been shown to have low sensitivity to itraconazole, but high to terbinafine.

LAY SUMMARY

Cases of onychomycosis caused by Neoscytalidium dimidiatum were studied and compared to cases of onychomycosis caused by T. rubrum. The individuals affected were adults, and the clinical characteristics were not different between groups; accordingly, mycological diagnosis is mandatory.

Direct examination, histopathology and fungal culture for the diagnosis of onychomycosis: A retrospective, comparative study on 2245 specimens

BACKGROUND

Onychomycosis affects 5.5% of the general population and represents up to 50% of all nail diseases. Diagnosis and pathogen identification are essential in order to plan an adequate treatment. Many diagnostic techniques are available, and however, no solid data regarding comparison between different techniques over a large number of specimens are available to date.

OBJECTIVES

To compare sensitivity and specificity of direct examination, histopathology and fungal culture in our referral mycology laboratory.

METHODS

Nail specimens received at the cutaneous pathology and mycology laboratory of the University Hospital Saint-Pierre (Brussels, Belgium) between 1 January and 15 May 2018 were retrospectively analysed. All specimens were submitted to direct examination and culture. In cases of adequate specimen size, histopathology was performed. Fungal culture was considered the gold standard for diagnosis.

RESULTS

A total of 2245 nail samples were included in the study. Onychomycosis was diagnosed in 1266 specimens. Sensitivity and positive predictive value were found to be higher for direct examination compared to histopathology, while sensitivity of direct examination was found to be lower. Combined approach with all the three techniques showed the highest rate of positivity, followed by the association of direct examination and histopathology.

CONCLUSIONS

To our knowledge, this study included the largest number of nail specimens to date, allowing a comparison between direct examination, culture and histopathology. Direct examination showed to be the most performing technique in routine practice. Histopathology represents the most effective option in cases where both specimen size and laboratory resources are adequate. Our paper adds to the literature the 'real-life' experience of the mycology laboratory of a referral centre for nail diseases.

PAS and GMS utility in dermatopathology: Review of the current medical literature

The American Society of Dermatopathology has established an Appropriate Use Criteria (AUC) Committee with the intention of establishing evidence-based recommendations regarding the appropriateness of various ancillary tests commonly utilized by dermatopathologists. Periodic acid Schiff (PAS) and Grocott (or Gomori) methenamine silver (GMS) stains represent some of the most commonly employed ancillary tests in dermatopathology. The utility of these tests was targeted for evaluation by the AUC. This literature review represents a comprehensive evaluation of available evidence for the utility of PAS and/or GMS staining of skin and nail biopsies. In concert with expert opinion, these data will be incorporated into future recommendations by the AUC for PAS and GMS staining in routine dermatopathology practice.

Detection and identification of dermatophyte fungi in clinical samples using a commercial multiplex tandem PCR assay

We evaluated the performance of a commercial multiplex tandem polymerase chain reaction (PCR) for detection of dermatophytes and other fungi in skin and nail specimens by (1) testing a range of fungal and bacterial reference cultures, (2) retrospectively testing a set of skin and nail specimens with known microscopy and culture results, and (3) prospectively testing skin and nail specimens in parallel to microscopy and culture. The AusDiagnostics Dermatophytes and Other Fungi assay accurately detected and identified a range of common dermatophytes to species, species complex or genus level, as well as Candida, Aspergillus and Scopulariopsis spp. It was unable to detect uncommon dermatophytes such as Nannizzia fulva (previously Microsporum fulvum), and Paraphyton cookei (previously Microsporum cookei). PCR identified a dermatophyte in 25.9% of prospective specimens which were culture negative. Sensitivity, specificity, positive predictive value, and negative predictive value were highest where microscopy and PCR results were combined, versus microscopy and culture combined, which highlights the significant contribution of microscopy in the diagnostic pathway. This assay has the potential to reduce the workload and results turnaround time associated with culturing and identification of dermatophytes, although microscopy remains important.

Neutrophils in Nail Clipping Histology: A Retrospective Review of 112 Cases

BACKGROUND

Nail clipping histology is more sensitive than mycology for detecting nail fungi. However, in the absence of fungi, established diagnostic clues for this and other nail dystrophy causes are lacking, namely for nail psoriasis. Neutrophils have been reported in onychomycosis and nail psoriasis samples but have been insufficiently characterized.

OBJECTIVES

The aim of this paper is to differentiate neutrophil-containing nail clipping samples in nail psoriasis and onychomycosis regarding histology.

METHODS

We performed a 3-year retrospective review of all nail clipping test results included in our department's database and re-analyzed samples containing neutrophils.

RESULTS

In total,112 neutrophil-containing nail clipping samples were accounted. Onychomycosis was the commonest diagnosis (74.1%), followed by nail psoriasis (18.8%). Onychomycosis samples had more abundant neutrophils, more often arranged in collections (60.2%) (p = 0.002) and with smaller quantities of parakeratosis, in a lamellar distribution. In nail psoriasis, neutrophils were mostly aggregated (57.1%) with parakeratosis in all samples, in increased amounts, and showing no predominant pattern.

CONCLUSIONS

Neutrophils are present in both nail psoriasis and onychomycosis, warranting careful interpretation. However, less dense aggregates of neutrophils with more abundant parakeratosis are clues of nail psoriasis when all other fungal tests are negative.

ITS rDNA Gene Analysis Versus MALDI-TOF MS For Identification of Neoscytalidium dimidiatum Isolated from Onychomycosis and Dermatomycosis Cases in Medellin (Colombia)

Within the Neoscytalidium genus, N. dimidiatum, N. oculus, N. orchidacearum, and N. novaehollandiae have been recognized. Although these species are frequently found in soil, N. dimidiatum has been identified as an etiologic agent of onychomycosis or dermatomycosis, and N. oculus has been identified as an etiologic agent of an ocular lesion. All these species can be cultured in vitro, but their morphological identification by macroscopic and microscopic traits is difficult and imprecise due to their similarity. In this study, 34 isolates of Neoscytalidium spp. from 32 onychomycosis and two dermatomycosis cases in Medellin (Colombia) were identified at the species level using sequencing of the ITS1+5.8S+ITS2 nuclear rDNA region and MALDI-TOF mass spectrometry (MS). Neoscytalidium dimidiatum strain MUM 17.21 was used to construct the reference spectrum in the in-house library to identify the clinical isolates by MALDI-TOF MS. Additionally, N. dimidiatum PPC-216 and PLAB-055 strains were used to validate the in-house constructed reference spectra. Although four groups were observed in the dendrogram obtained from the proteins of each isolate profile, MALDI-TOF MS and sequencing results are in accordance, since all isolates were identified as N. dimidiatum.

Nail clipping in onychomycosis and comparison with normal nails and ungual psoriasis

BACKGROUND

Of all nail disorders seen in dermatology offices, half of them are due to onychomycosis. The main differential diagnosis is nail psoriasis. The objective of this study was to compare the microscopic findings, other than the presence of fungi, in the clipping of onychomycosis versus normal nails and nail psoriasis.

METHODS

Cross-sectional study of onychomycosis cases, analyzed by clipping and compared with data on normal nails and those with nail psoriasis.

RESULTS

Sixty-two onychomycosis samples were compared with 30 normal nails and 50 nails with psoriasis. In onychomycosis, measurement of subungual region, serous lakes, neutrophils and number of layers of parakeratosis are more intense than in psoriasis. Onychocariosis is less common in psoriasis, while bacteria are more frequent. The nail transition zone is more commonly blurred and irregular in onychomycosis.

CONCLUSION

Clipping helps in the differential diagnosis of onychomycosis and nail psoriasis and may be useful even when fungi are not found.