Assenting to exposedness – meanings of receiving assisted bodily care in a nursing home as narrated by older persons

Self-determination in older patients: Experiences from nurse-dominated ambulance services

AIM

To describe ambulance clinicians' experiences of self-determination in older patients.

DESIGN

The study had an inductive and explorative design, guided from a life-world perspective.

METHODS

Thirty-two Swedish ambulance clinicians were interviewed in six focus groups in November 2019. The data were analysed with content analysis, developing manifest categories and latent themes.

FINDINGS

The ambulance clinicians assessed the older patients' exercise of self-determination by engaging in conversation and by being visually alert, to eventually gain an overall picture of their decision-making capacity. This assessment was used as a platform when informing older patients of their rights, thus promoting their participation in care. Having limited time and narrow guidelines counteracted ambulance clinicians' ambitions to support older patients' general desire to avoid hospitalization, which resulted in an urge to displace their responsibility to external decision-makers.

CONCLUSION

Expectations that older patients with impaired decision-making ability will give homogeneous responses mean an increased risk of ageist attitudes with a simplified view of patient autonomy. Such attitudes risk the withholding of information about options that healthcare professionals do not wish older patients to choose. When decision-making is difficult, requests for expanded guidelines may paradoxically risk alienation from the professional nursing role.

IMPLICATIONS AND IMPACT

The findings show ambulance clinicians' unwillingness to shoulder their professional responsibility when encountering older patients with impaired decision-making ability. In assuming that all older patients reason in the same way, ambulance clinicians tend to adopt a simplistic and somewhat ageist approach when it comes to patient autonomy. This points to deficiencies in ethical competence, which is why increased ethics support is deemed suitable to promote and develop ethical competence. Such support can increase the ability to act as autonomous professionals in accordance with professional ethical codes.

REPORTING METHOD

This study adhered to COREQ guidelines.

PATIENT AND PUBLIC CONTRIBUTION

None.

Effective Relationships Between Younger Caregivers and Older Care Recipients Across a Continuum of Formal Residential Care Settings: A Scoping Review and a Critical Analysis

Objective: This article aims to conduct a scoping review of what constitutes effective relational interactions between caregivers (CGs) and older persons (OPs) across formal residential care settings. Methods: A scoping review of publications between January 2000 and December 2021 yielded 10,929 articles, and after removing duplicates and applying exclusion criteria, 36 articles were analysed. Results: Articles were scrutinised for interactions involving both CGs and OPs, using a thematic framework analysis to identify effective relational constructs. Four themes emerged: 1) Diverse perspectives on the same context: for OPs it is home, and for CGs, workplace. 2) CGs move for a one-up position and OPs submit to a one-down, or as friends. 3) Relational qualities have been mostly associated with CGs, confirming care as a unidirectional action 4). Relationships between CGs and OPs result either in effective or ineffective care outcomes. Conclusion: The dual meanings attached to the same context limit the authentic interactions between CGs and OPs. We propose a relational caregiving approach by considering the interactions of both CGs and OPs, changing the relational definition, and demonstrating effective relational qualities.

The choreographies of the elimination of faeces-An ethnographic study of the institutionalized body care practices of older people in different health care settings

AIM

To explore the choreographies of the elimination of faeces of older people to gain insight into the institutionalized practices of body care of older people in hospitals and long-term care settings.

DESIGN

A qualitative ethnographic study, drawing on a perspective of socio-material theory. Reported in accordance with the Standards for Reporting Qualitative Research.

METHODS

A total of, 30 women and 11 men aged 80 years and above needing assistance with body care in a hospital ward, 2 nursing homes and home care and 32 care workers participated. Four individual interviews with older people and three focus group interviews with care workers were conducted, in addition to 135 h of participant observations, from December 2020 to September 2021. Data were analysed using a situational analysis approach.

RESULTS

The assistance with the elimination of faeces is a multiplicity of ongoing dynamic practices where different actors interrelate. Dominating actors are time, space, materialities, different ideals and professional knowledge. The choreographies aim at order the elimination of faeces to happen at the right time at the right place, to provide dignified care.

CONCLUSION

To assist older people with the elimination of faeces is complex institutionalized practices. The study argues for a greater focus on the ongoing relations between human and non-human actors to provide new understandings of an underexplored phenomenon in nursing.

IMPACT

What problem did the study address? The elimination of faeces of older people as part of body care is an underexplored phenomenon in nursing, often subject to stigma and taboo, and delegated to other healthcare workers than registered nurses. Internationally, there are challenges in the delivery of fundamentals of nursing care to older people across healthcare settings. Few studies have explored body care as an institutionalized practice across different settings, taking into consideration the contextual aspects of care as well as the involvement of non-human actors in the care practices. What were the main findings? Multiple human and non-human actors are involved when older people need assistance with the elimination of faeces. Time, space, materialities, different ideals and professional knowledge are important actors. The elimination of faeces is not a homogeneous practice but ongoing, dynamic, and multiple practices. The context of care practices related to the elimination of faeces is not an outer macro level distant from care, but part of the ongoing daily practices of body care. Where and on whom will the research have an impact? The findings can inspire researchers and clinicians to develop a new understanding of fundamental care needs. The study offers a critical perspective on possibilities for providing care, since political ideals and governance are active actors in daily care practices.

PATIENT OR PUBLIC CONTRIBUTION

No patient or public contribution. The study was conducted during the COVID-19 pandemic; restrictions limited the access to involving patients and care workers in the research process. An advisory board consisting of leaders from the different settings was a part of the design process and in the interpretation of data.

RECOMMENDATIONS FOR FURTHER RESEARCH

The socio material theoretical perspective has a potential to unfold the complexities in nursing care practices focusing on aspects that are underexplored in nursing research.

What about the fundamentals of nursing-its interventions and its continuity among older people in need of home- or facility-based care: a scoping review

AIM

This scoping review investigated and descriptively summarised previous research about fundamental nursing, its focus (what care needs are described, how is it described and by whom is it described), continuity of care (is it described in relation to fundamental nursing) and possible nursing interventions or activities targeting older people's fundamentals of care needs in home- or facility-based care.

METHODS

This scoping review was carried out following the steps of Arksey and O'Malley's methodology and PRISMA-ScR reporting guidelines. Searches were conducted in PubMed via NIH, CINAHL via EBSCO and PsycInfo via ProQuest for the time period between January 2002 and May 2023.

RESULTS

Forty-two studies were included where the majority had been conducted in a facility-based care context. Nutrition-or rather nutritional care activities targeting eating and drinking-was the most frequently described fundamental care needs addressed. After this came personal care such as cleansing, dressing, oral care, skin, and foot care. Few studies addressed more than one fundamental care need at the time. The nursing staff described fundamental nursing as complex, comprehensive, and demanding. Older people and relatives described a gap between the fundamental nursing provided and their perceived need for support. Less attention was given to older peoples relational and psychosocial needs. Identified nursing interventions mainly targeted physical care needs. Our findings also implied that interventions focusing on fundamental nursing were described as feasible in practice with favourable or moderate results, while long-term effects were difficult to detect. No studies were identified focusing on fundamental nursing in relation to outcomes such as continuity of care.

CONCLUSION

Fundamental nursing was mainly described in relation to physical care needs, which were essentially conducted within facility-based care contexts. Interventions and activities primarily focused on one fundamental need at the time, mainly within the physical domain. No nursing interventions were identified focusing on relational and psychosocial needs where continuity of care can be viewed as a relevant outcome. Such limited focus are especially concerning as research has highlighted the importance of that older people with complex care needs can benefit from a holistic and person-centred approach i.e. fundamental nursing.

TRIAL REGISTRATION

Open Science Framework https://doi.org/10.17605/OSF.IO/XJ39E Protocol: http://dx.doi.org/10.1136/bmjopen-2022-069798.

Body care of older people in different institutionalized settings: A systematic mapping review of international nursing research from a Scandinavian perspective

Body care is considered a key aspect of nursing and imperative for the health, wellbeing, and dignity of older people. In Scandinavian countries, body care as a professional practice has undergone considerable changes, bringing new understandings, values, and dilemmas into nursing. A systematic mapping review was conducted with the aims of identifying and mapping international nursing research on body care of older people in different institutionalized settings in the healthcare system and to critically discuss the dominant assumptions within the research by adapting a problematization approach. Most identified papers reported on empirical research with a biomedical approach focusing on outcome and effectiveness. Conceptual papers, papers with a focus on the perspectives of the older people, or contextual and material aspects were lacking. The research field is dominated by four dominant assumptions: Body care as an evidence-based practice, body care as a relational ethical practice, the body as a body-object and a body-subject, the objects in the body care practices as nonrelational materialities. Given the complexities of professional body care practices, there is a need for other research designs and theoretical perspectives within nursing that expand our understanding of body care taking into consideration the multiple social and material realities.

Barriers to and facilitators of ethical encounters at the end of life in a nursing home: an ethnographic study

Background

Among a growing population of older persons, many affected by multiple diseases and complex needs, are cared for in nursing homes. Previous studies of nursing homes have highlighted the importance of personalised palliative care. Nevertheless, we know little about whether everyday care practice involving assistant nurses and frail older persons accomplishes ethical encounters, especially in assisted bodily care. Therefore, the aim of this study was to understand and conceptualize the encounter between residents and assistant nurses in bodily care-situations at the end of life in a nursing home.

Methods

Focused ethnographic design was used. Residents and assistant nurses from one nursing home in an urban Swedish area participated in this study. Data were collected for 6 months and consisted of 170 h of fieldwork, including participant observation and interviews. Observations and digitally recorded interviews were analysed thematically. Five public community stakeholders contributed to the analysis by discussing preliminary results and clinical implications in a focus group.

Results

Four themes, each encompassing both barriers to and facilitators of ethical encounters in assisted bodily care, were identified: Coping with the impact of workplace demands; Interacting in dialogue and communication; Experiencing involvement in the provision of assisted bodily care; and Adapting to good care and comfort.

Conclusions

The findings suggest that accomplishing ethical encounters in assisted bodily care practice in a nursing home context has many barriers that are related to communication, relationships, and quality of care. Barriers included lack of resources, ineffective communication, and work values, which hinder ethical encounters. Nevertheless, moral sensitivity, genuine interest in resident engagement, and collaborative practices facilitated ethical encounters and are thus central to person-centred care. Uniquely, assistant nurses must be aware of their responsibility for performing their tasks in response to residents’ vulnerability. We therefore suggest that moral deliberation over issues of communication, compassion, decision-making, and behavior, with particular consideration for the care relationship. To further improve the quality of care, organisations must provide resources for the building of relationships, as well as time for assistant nurses to recover after long shifts. Additional research is warranted, including implementation of ethically grounded palliative care.

Supplementary Information

The online version contains supplementary material available at 10.1186/s12904-022-01024-0.

Dignity in bodily care at the end of life in a nursing home: an ethnographic study

BACKGROUND

Nursing homes (NHs) are populated by the frailest older people who have multiple physical or mental conditions and palliative care needs that may convey the violation of dignity. Although dignity is a commonly used concept and a core value of end-of-life care, it is assumed to be complex, ambiguous, and multivalent. Thus, the aim of this study was to explore aspects of dignity in older persons' everyday lives in a NH.

DESIGN

A focused ethnographic study design.

METHODS

Data consisted of 170 h of fieldwork, including observations (n = 39) with residents (n = 19) and assistant nurses (n = 22) in a Swedish NH. Interviews were undertaken with residents several times (in total, n = 35, mean 70 min/resident). To study dignity and dignity-related concerns, we used the Chochinov model of dignity to direct the deductive analysis.

RESULTS

The study showed that residents suffered from illness-related concerns that inhibited their possibilities to live a dignified life at the NH. Their failing bodies were the most significant threat to their dignity, as loss of abilities was constantly progressing. Together with a fear of becoming more dependent, this caused feelings of agony, loneliness, and meaninglessness. The most dignity-conserving repertoire came from within themselves. Their self-knowledge had provided them with tools to distinguish what was still possible from what they just had to accept. Socially, the residents' dignity depended on assistant nurses' routines and behaviour. Their dignity was violated by long waiting times, lack of integrity in care, deteriorating routines, and also by distanced and sometimes harsh encounters with assistant nurses. Because the residents cherished autonomy and self-determination, while still needing much help, these circumstances placed them in a vulnerable situation.

CONCLUSIONS

According to residents' narratives, important dignity-conserving abilities came from within themselves. Dignity-conserving interventions did occur, such as emphatic listening and bodily care, performed in respect for residents' preferences. However, no strategies for future crises or preparing for death were observed. To protect residents' dignity, NHs must apply a palliative care approach to provide holistic care that comprises attention to personal, bodily, social, spiritual, and psychological needs to increase well-being and prevent suffering.

Bodywork and nursing practice: Development of a bodywork in nursing practice instrument

Nursing's continued focus on caring for physical aspects of patients' bodies underscores the importance of bodywork and shows nursing's privileged, professional access to patients. This instrument development study presents the first phases of a new instrument. It established a conceptual definition of nursing's bodywork and initial psychometric properties of the Nursing Bodywork Instrument. Literature sources generated codes and clusters for item development. Literature-based and expert content validity were demonstrated. A pilot study tested nurses' (N = 53) agreement with draft items. The highest-ranked items confirmed nurses' bodywork and reliance on technological devices when giving direct patient care. Known groups validity testing by groups' years as a nurse did not differ statistically. Internal consistency reliability was 0.98 on the 128-item instrument, pointing to the need for future reduction. Inter-item correlations suggested that factor analysis with a large sample size might generate domains descriptive of nursing's bodywork. A total of 125 items resulted from item analysis and subsequent item revision. All items were matched with clusters; for example, technologic device management, physical comfort facilitation, skin/wound management, self-care facilitation, and respiratory management include some item clusters.

Older people's experiences of oral health and assisted daily oral care in short-term facilities

Background

Older people’s oral health has improved, and many retain their natural teeth throughout their life. However, their daily oral care can be more difficult because of compromised general health and the reduced capacity for self-care that often comes with old age. More knowledge is needed about how older people view their oral health and oral care. The aim of this study was to describe how older people in short-term care experience their oral health and daily oral care.

Method

A descriptive, qualitative study was performed through interviews with 14 older people (74–95 years) recruited from short-term care units in two Swedish regions. Data were analysed using inductive content analysis.

Results

The findings are described in one main category, three categories and nine sub-categories. The main category was Adapting to a changed oral condition while striving to retain independence. The first category, Wanting to manage daily oral care independently, contained three subcategories: Having always brushed my teeth without help, Being satisfied with my mouth and teeth, and Having to accept help if necessary. The second category, Acceptance of changes in oral condition, had three subcategories: Difficulty in chewing and swallowing, Difficulty with tooth brushing, and Not considering a dentist visit to be worth the cost. The third category, Barriers to receiving assistance from staff, had three subcategories: Staff lacking the time to help, Not wanting to be a burden, and Lack of confidence in staff’s knowledge.

Conclusions

The participants were generally satisfied with their oral health despite an expressed need for dental treatment. Daily oral care was something they wanted to manage themselves, and they had a strong desire to stay independent for as long as possible. Closer collaboration between dental and health care staff is necessary in order to implement clinical practice guidelines for oral health care and increase nursing staff’s attention towards older peoples’ oral health.

Supplementary Information

The online version contains supplementary material available at 10.1186/s12877-021-02281-z.

The 6S-model for person-centred palliative care: A theoretical framework

Palliative care is provided at a certain timepoint, both in a person's life and in a societal context. What is considered to be a good death can therefore vary over time depending on prevailing social values and norms, and the person's own view and interpretation of life. This means that there are many interpretations of what a good death can actually mean for an individual. On a more general level, research in palliative care shows that individuals have basic common needs, for example physical, mental, social and spiritual well-being. Therefore, in today's pluralistic Western society, it becomes important that palliative care is person centred to enable individuals to receive, as far as can be achieved, care that promotes as good a life as possible based on the person's own needs and preferences, and in accordance with evidence and current laws. For many years a research group, consisting nurse researchers together with nurses working in palliative care, has developed a model for person-centred palliative care, the 6S-model. The model's central concept is Self-image, where the starting point is the patient as a person and their own experience of the situation. The other concepts: Self-determination, Symptom relief, Social relationships, Synthesis and Strategies are all related to the patient's self-image, and often to each other. The model's development, value base and starting assumptions are reported here, as are examples of how the model is applied in palliative care in Sweden. The model has been, and still is, constantly evolving in a collaboration between researchers and clinically active nurses, and in recent years also with patients and close relatives.

Elements of assisted bodily care: Ethical aspects

BACKGROUND

Many frail older persons who die in Swedish nursing homes need assisted bodily care. They must surrender their bodies to the authority of assistant nurses, which may affect their autonomy and dignity of identity. While assistant nurses claim to support older persons' wishes, older persons claim they have to adapt to assistant nurses' routines. The provider-receiver incongruence revealed here warrants investigation.

AIM

To describe the elements of assisted bodily care, as performed in a nursing home.

RESEARCH DESIGN

Data were collected through thirty-nine observations of assisted bodily care, analyzed with qualitative content analysis.

PARTICIPANTS AND RESEARCH CONTEXT

Seventeen older persons and twenty-two assistant nurses from a Swedish nursing home.

ETHICAL CONSIDERATIONS

The research was conducted in line with the Declaration of Helsinki, further approved by the regional ethics committee.

FINDINGS

Findings show that assisted bodily care consists of assistant nurses' practical work, performed at a high tempo. Assistant nurses still attempt to adapt this work to the older persons' wishes for self-determination, taking into account their day-to-day state of health. In spite of time pressure and occasional interruptions, there is room for consideration and affection in assisted bodily care.

DISCUSSION

Assistant nurses try to promote older persons' dignity of identity, but sometimes fail, possibly due to lack of time. They nevertheless seem to know the older persons well enough to adapt the assisted bodily care according to their preferences and to support self-determination. This indicates that openness to older persons' lifeworlds may be more important than the amount of time available.

CONCLUSION

Nursing home contexts might benefit from adopting a person-centered palliative care perspective, highlighting the value of relationships and shared decision-making. If so, older persons and assisted nurses could agree on practices and goals in assisted bodily care beforehand. Such routines may be time-saving and beneficial to all.

Being a spectator in ambiguity-Family members' perceptions of assisted bodily care in a nursing home

AIM

The aim of this study was to explore family members' perceptions of assisted bodily care in a nursing home.

BACKGROUND

Many older people living in nursing homes need assisted bodily care, provided by assistant nurses. This means exposedness, as the assistance is often provided under stress, but also brings pleasure. Family members, who may wish to and often benefit from continuing to provide assisted bodily care, are perceived as visitors and are expected to relinquish the assisted bodily care to the assistant nurses.

DESIGN

This study has a qualitative design with a phenomenographic approach.

METHODS

Data were collected through semi-structured interviews (n = 13) with family members of older people who were aged > 80, permanently living in a nursing home, suffering from multimorbidity, and in daily need of assisted bodily care. The data were analysed using a phenomenographic method.

RESULTS

Three categories of description presenting an increasing complexity were identified. The family members perceived that assisted bodily care is built upon a respect for the older person's self-determination, practically supported by assistant nurses, and complemented by family members.

CONCLUSIONS

In the family members' perceptions, assisted bodily care signifies ambiguity, as they find themselves balancing between the older persons' need for self-determination and need for help, and, further, between their trust in the assistant nurses' skills and their own perceived inadequacies in intimate assisted bodily care.

IMPLICATIONS FOR PRACTICE

Policies that address the family members' role in nursing homes are needed. Furthermore, time for collaboration is needed for assistant nurses to inform and explain care decisions, become aware of the family members' perceptions of their situation and learn from them.