Does surgeon handedness or experience predict immediate complications after mastectomy? A critical examination of outcomes in a single health system

Does the Surgeon's Handedness Affect the Complications Rate in the Inframammary Approach Breast Augmentation?

BACKGROUND

Humans show a preference for left or right handedness in most cases. For this reason, surgeons might find it more difficult to operate on the "nondominant breast", i.e. the breast opposite to the surgeon´s dominant hand (left breast for right-handed surgeons and right breast for left-handed surgeons). The nondominant breast might therefore potentially be prone to a higher complication rate.

METHOD

Retrospective data of all consecutive patients who underwent breast augmentations by the first author over the past 15 years was reviewed. In all cases, the entire operation was carried out with the surgeon standing on the right side of the table. All the complications of the right and left breasts were analyzed individually.

RESULTS

1707 patients with a minimum follow-up of six months were reviewed. Mean breast implant volume was 305.6 cc and mean follow-up was 16.12 months. A total of 151 complications were found (8.8%), including rotational deformity, capsular contracture, hematoma, seroma, bottoming out, high riding implant, double bubble deformity, implant rupture and infection. Of these complications, 77 (4.51%) affected the left breast, 48 (2.87%) were found on the right breast and 25 (1.46%) were bilateral. This difference was statistically significant.

CONCLUSION

Surgeons´ handedness seem to have an impact on the rate of complications after breast augmentation. As a result of some sort of unease when operating on the nondominant breast, this side might be prone to less precision during the dissection and, consequently, to more complications. Our study found that the rate of complications was higher in the nondominant breast.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE IV

This journal requires that authors assign a level of evidence to each article. For a full description of these Evidence-Based Medicine ratings, please refer to the Table of Contents or the online Instructions to Authors www.springer.com/00266 .

Head rotation and the perception of eyelid height and contour

PURPOSE

Effective visual perceptual processing is one of the many components of surgical competence. Human face identification is most efficient when viewed upright. However, it is not yet clear how this perception sensitivity impacts eyelid symmetry. This study investigates surgeons' and laypeople's accuracy and efficiency in perceiving eyelid asymmetry from different spatial perspectives.

METHODS

A prospective psychometric experiment was conducted where oculoplastic surgeons were recruited from the American Society of Ophthalmic Plastic and Reconstructive Surgery and the Brazilian Oculoplastic Surgery Society, and control participants were recruited via crowdsourcing (Amazon's Mechanical Turk). Standard illustrations of the human face with varying degrees of eyelid abnormality, laterality, gender and rotation were presented to participants who were asked to judge whether the eyelids were symmetric or asymmetric.

RESULTS

The survey was completed by 75 oculoplastic surgeons (49.33% male; mean age of 46.9±10.7) and 192 lay individuals (54.6% male; mean age 34.6±11.3 years). Among oculoplastic surgeons, deviation from upright was significantly associated with increased reaction time and decreased proportion correct (OR per 45° for peak 0.68, 95% CI 0.60 to 0.77, p<0.001; OR per 45° for ptosis 0.52, 95% CI 0.32 to 0.87, p=0.012; OR per 180° for aggregate responses 0.56, 95% CI 0.51 to 0.61, p<0.001). Oculoplastic surgeons demonstrated increasing accuracy and decreasing reaction time with additional trials for both peak and ptosis.

CONCLUSION

Oculoplastic surgeons perceive eyelid asymmetries more accurately and can better compensate for inverted sensory information. However, accuracy increases and reaction time decreases with additional trials, suggesting trainability and potential for improvement in inversion disability.

The Implications of Laterality in Unilateral Cleft Lip Reconstruction: A Global Survey of Cleft Surgeons

OBJECTIVE

To explore the impact of directional laterality in complete Unilateral Cleft Lip (UCL) amongst the global cleft surgeon community.

DESIGN

Cross-sectional survey study.

SETTING

Global distribution of online survey distributed in English and Spanish.

PARTICIPANTS

Cleft surgeons from around the world.

MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES

Survey participant perception of the impact of laterality on: (1) cleft presentation (2) surgical challenge and (3) surgical outcomes.

RESULTS

Responses were received from 453 cleft surgeons located in 54 countries around the world. 221 (49%) had previously considered differences in patients presenting with a left- versus right-sided UCL. 95 (21%) considered right-sided clefts more difficult to reconstruct, 37 (8%) reported left-sided clefts to be more difficult and 321 (71%) reported no difference in difficulty between the cleft sides. Higher volume cleft surgeons, characterised by those reporting cleft as their principal area of practice and performing >20 cleft operations per year, were more likely to have both previously considered differences in laterality in cleft and to report right-sided unilateral cleft lip to be more difficult to primarily reconstruct. 395 (87%) did not consider surgical outcomes to be influenced by cleft laterality.

CONCLUSIONS

This survey reports perceptions on cleft laterality from a large body of global surgeons and suggests a trend for increased difficulty in right-sided compared to left-sided cleft lip reconstruction, where such laterality-associated difficulty is perceived.

Stress and Strain During Total Joint Arthroplasty Are Not Impacted by Hand Dominance or Operative Laterality in Orthopedic Surgeons

BACKGROUND

Orthopedic surgeons experience significant musculoskeletal pain and work-related injuries while performing total joint arthroplasty (TJA). We sought to investigate the impact of operative extremity and surgeon limb dominance on surgeon physiologic stress and energy expenditure during TJA.

METHODS

This was a prospective cohort study conducted at a tertiary academic practice. Cardiorespiratory data was recorded continuously in 3 high-volume arthroplasty surgeons using a smart garment that measured heart rate (HR), HR variability, respiratory rate, minute ventilation, and energy expenditure (calories) during conventional total knee (TKA) and total hip arthroplasty (THA).

RESULTS

Surgeon 1 and 2 (right-handed) performed 21 right TKAs, 10 left TKAs, 13 right THAs, and 10 left THAs. Surgeon 3 (left-handed) performed 6 right TKAs, 9 left TKAs, 16 right THAs, and 10 left THAs. While performing TKA or THA, limb laterality had no significant impact on operative time and no significant differences existed in HR, HR variability, respiratory rate, minute ventilation, or energy expenditure for any right-handed or left-handed surgeons, regardless of the operative limb laterality. While performing TKA, consistently standing on the side of hand dominance was associated with decreased strain and stress, compared to always standing on the operative side.

CONCLUSION

This study suggests that surgeon hand dominance and operative limb laterality do not impact energy expenditure or physiologic strain during TJA. However, consistently standing on the side of hand dominance in TKA may lead to decreased physiologic strain and stress during surgery. Further study utilizing wearable technology during TJA may provide orthopedic surgeons with information about modifiable factors that contribute to differences in physiological parameters during surgery.

Diplopia following lower blepharoplasty

PURPOSE

To investigate the likelihood of surgeons performing lower blepharoplasties having cases of diplopia persisting for more than 1 week after surgery.

METHODS

An anonymous survey (13 questions) on the frequency and characteristics of persistent diplopia (lasting >1 week) after lower blepharoplasty was sent to members of the American Society of Ophthalmic Plastic and Reconstructive Surgery.

RESULTS

Of 703 members, 371 (52.8%) responded to the survey. Of these, 86 (23.2%) had at least 1 case of persistent diplopia following lower blepharoplasty. Complete data were available for 84 of the 86 physicians. The inferior oblique muscle was involved in 51 cases (61%), the inferior rectus muscle in 7 cases (8%), both the inferior oblique and inferior rectus muscles in 4 cases (5%), and the muscle involved was not identified in 22 patients (26%). The diplopia was paretic in 49 patients (58%) and restrictive in 35 (42%). The diplopia persisted in primary position in 7 patients (8%), in gaze positions other than primary position in 16 patients (19%), and resolved completely in 61 patients (73%).

CONCLUSIONS

There is a significant chance of surgeons performing lower blepharoplasties having at least 1 case of diplopia lasting over a week postoperatively. Our survey results indicate that this complication may be more common than is suggested by the medical literature.

A Surgeon's handedness in direct anterior approach-hip replacement

BACKGROUND

The impact of handedness on clinical outcomes was easily overlooked in hip replacement. This study aimed to find whether the component positioning and hip function were affected by the handedness in total hip arthroplasty (THA) through direct anterior approach (DAA).

METHODS

Total 102 patients who underwent bilateral DAA-THAs simultaneously between May 2016 and November 2018 in our institute were reviewed. All surgeries were operated by one right-handed surgeon. Their demographic, cup positioning, stem alignment, femoral stem fit, Harris hip score (HHS), intraoperative and postoperative complications were used to evaluate the role of handedness in DAA.

RESULTS

The inclination of left cups was significantly larger than that of right cups (42.61 ± 7.32 vs 39.42 ± 7.19, p = 0.000). The stem fit of left femur was significantly larger than that of right femur (84.34 ± 4.83 vs 82.81 ± 6.07, p = 0.043). No significant differences in safe zone ratio, HHS and complications between bilateral hips were found.

CONCLUSIONS

A surgeon's handedness had significant impact on cup's inclination and femoral stem fit in DAA-THA. However, there were no significant differences of cup malpositioning, stem alignment, hip function scores and complications between bilateral DAA-THAs.