Plasma Leak From the Circulation Contributes to Poor Outcomes for Preterm Infants: A Working Hypothesis

Preterm infants are at high risk of death and disability resulting from brain injury. Impaired cardiovascular function leading to poor cerebral oxygenation is a significant contributor to these adverse outcomes, but current therapeutic approaches have failed to improve outcome. We have re-examined existing evidence regarding hypovolemia and have concluded that in the preterm infant loss of plasma from the circulation results in hypovolemia; and that this is a significant driver of cardiovascular instability and thus poor cerebral oxygenation. High capillary permeability, altered hydrostatic and oncotic pressure gradients, and reduced lymphatic return all combine to increase net loss of plasma from the circulation at the capillary. Evidence is presented that early hypovolemia occurs in preterm infants, and that capillary permeability and pressure gradients all change in a way that promotes rapid plasma loss at the capillary. Impaired lymph flow, inflammation and some current treatment strategies may further exacerbate this plasma loss. A framework for testing this hypothesis is presented. Understanding these mechanisms opens the way to novel treatment strategies to support cardiovascular function and cerebral oxygenation, to replace current therapies, which have been shown not to change outcomes.

Physiology of Fetal Heart Rate Monitoring

Fetal heart tracings (FHTs) are useful as a window into the oxygenation status of the fetal brain. Patterns in the FHT reflect the oxygen status of the fetal brain. Fetal adaptive response to progressive hypoxemia and acidosis are detectable and produce recognizable patterns in the fetal heart rate. The basic physiology and adaptive responses that regulate the fetal heart rate and physiological fetal adaptations to stress as reflected in the FHTs are described. Mechanisms of oxygen delivery to the fetus including ways in which those mechanisms can be disrupted are reviewed.

Peripheral chemoreflex control of fetal heart rate decelerations overwhelms the baroreflex during brief umbilical cord occlusions in fetal sheep

KEY POINTS

The majority of intrapartum decelerations are widely believed to be mediated by the baroreflex secondary to brief umbilical cord occlusions (UCOs) but this remains unproven. We examined the responses to brief-UCOs in fetal sheep and compared these to a phenylephrine-stimulated baroreflex in a separate cohort. A further cohort was instrumented with near-infrared spectroscopy to measure cerebral oxygenation during UCO. The first 3-4 s of the brief-UCOs were consistent with a baroreflex, and associated with a minor fall in fetal heart rate (FHR). Thereafter, the remainder of the FHR decelerations were highly consistent with the peripheral chemoreflex. The baroreflex is not sufficient to produce deep, rapid decelerations characteristic of variable decelerations and it is therefore likely to be a minor contributor to intrapartum decelerations.

ABSTRACT

Fetal heart rate (FHR) monitoring is widely used to assess fetal wellbeing during labour, yet the physiology underlying FHR patterns remains incompletely understood. The baroreflex is widely believed to mediate brief intrapartum decelerations, but evidence supporting this theory is lacking. We therefore investigated the physiological changes in near-term fetal sheep during brief repeated umbilical cord occlusions (brief-UCOs, n = 15). We compared this to separate cohorts that underwent a phenylephrine challenge to stimulate the baroreflex (n = 9) or were instrumented with near-infrared spectroscopy and underwent prolonged 15-min complete UCO (prolonged-UCO, n = 9). The first 3-4 s of brief-UCOs were associated with hypertension (P = 0.000), a fall in FHR by 9.7-16.9 bpm (P = 0.002). The FHR/MAP relationship during this time was consistent with that observed during a phenylephrine-induced baroreflex. At 4-5 s, the FHR/MAP relationship began to deviate from the phenylephrine baroreflex curve as FHR fell independently of MAP until its nadir in association with intense peripheral vasoconstriction (P = 0.000). During prolonged-UCO, cerebral oxygenation remained steady until 4 s after the start of prolonged-UCO, and then began to fall (P = 0.000). FHR and cerebral oxygenation then fell in parallel until the FHR nadir. In conclusion, the baroreflex has a minor role in mediating the first 3-4 s of FHR decelerations during complete UCO, but thereafter the peripheral chemoreflex is the dominant mediator. Overall, the baroreflex is neither necessary nor sufficient to produce deep, rapid decelerations characteristic of variable decelerations; it is therefore likely to be a minor contributor to intrapartum decelerations.

Improving pregnancy outcomes in humans through studies in sheep

Experimental studies that are relevant to human pregnancy rely on the selection of appropriate animal models as an important element in experimental design. Consideration of the strengths and weaknesses of any animal model of human disease is fundamental to effective and meaningful translation of preclinical research. Studies in sheep have made significant contributions to our understanding of the normal and abnormal development of the fetus. As a model of human pregnancy, studies in sheep have enabled scientists and clinicians to answer questions about the etiology and treatment of poor maternal, placental, and fetal health and to provide an evidence base for translation of interventions to the clinic. The aim of this review is to highlight the advances in perinatal human medicine that have been achieved following translation of research using the pregnant sheep and fetus.

The effect of sex and prematurity on the cardiovascular baroreflex response in sheep

NEW FINDINGS

What is the central question of this study? Late preterm infants are often assumed to escape long-term morbidities known to impact earlier preterm offspring. Is this true for the cardiovascular system? What is the main finding and its importance? We show that late preterm birth is a risk factor for cardiovascular dysfunction in early adulthood and is influenced by sex. Early signs of cardiovascular dysfunction might predispose to heart disease in adulthood. Very preterm infants have an increased risk of cardiovascular disease; however, the effects of a late preterm birth on future cardiovascular function are not known. We hypothesized that after a late preterm birth, the well-described impairments in heart rate variability and baroreflex sensitivity would persist into adulthood. To test this hypothesis, sheep born preterm (0.9 gestation; nine male and seven female) or term (11 male and six female) underwent surgery at 14 months of age for insertion of femoral arterial and venous catheters and a femoral flow probe. After recovery, heart rate variability was assessed, followed by a baroreflex challenge (using the vasoactive agents phenylephrine and sodium nitroprusside) in conscious adult lambs. Our data demonstrate decreased low-frequency normalised units (LFnu) and low-frequency/high-frequency ratio in female but not male ex-preterm sheep at rest. When challenged, mature male ex-preterm sheep have an increased blood pressure response but dampened heart rate baroreflex response. We show that even a late preterm birth leads to cardiovascular dysfunction in adulthood. These early signs of cardiovascular dysfunction might underpin the later hypertension and increased risk of heart disease observed in adults born preterm. These findings are particularly important because late preterm infants are often assumed to escape the long-term morbidities known to impact on very preterm and extremely preterm offspring.

The myths and physiology surrounding intrapartum decelerations: the critical role of the peripheral chemoreflex

A distinctive pattern of recurrent rapid falls in fetal heart rate, called decelerations, are commonly associated with uterine contractions during labour. These brief decelerations are mediated by vagal activation. The reflex triggering this vagal response has been variably attributed to a mechanoreceptor response to fetal head compression, to baroreflex activation following increased blood pressure during umbilical cord compression, and/or a Bezold-Jarisch reflex response to reduced venous return from the placenta. Although these complex explanations are still widespread today, there is no consistent evidence that they are common during labour. Instead, the only mechanism that has been systematically investigated, proven to be reliably active during labour and, crucially, capable of producing rapid decelerations is the peripheral chemoreflex. The peripheral chemoreflex is triggered by transient periods of asphyxia that are a normal phenomenon associated with all uterine contractions. This should not cause concern as the healthy fetus has a remarkable ability to adapt to these repeated but short periods of asphyxia. This means that the healthy fetus is typically not at risk of hypotension and injury during uncomplicated labour even during repeated brief decelerations. The physiologically incorrect theories surrounding decelerations that ignore the natural occurrence of repeated asphyxia probably gained widespread support to help explain why many babies are born healthy despite repeated decelerations during labour. We propose that a unified and physiological understanding of intrapartum decelerations that accepts the true nature of labour is critical to improve interpretation of intrapartum fetal heart rate patterns.

Sustained sympathetic nervous system support of arterial blood pressure during repeated brief umbilical cord occlusions in near-term fetal sheep

Sympathetic nervous system (SNS)-mediated peripheral vasoconstriction plays a key role in initial maintenance of blood pressure during rapid-onset asphyxia in the mammalian fetus, but it is attenuated after the first few minutes. It is unclear whether the SNS response is sustained during the brief, but frequently repeated, episodes of asphyxia characteristic of labor. In the present study, 14 fetal sheep at 0.85 of gestation received either chemical sympathectomy with 6-hydroxydopamine (6-OHDA; n = 7) or sham injection (control; n = 7), followed 4-5 days later by repeated 2-min episodes of complete umbilical cord occlusion every 5 min for up to 4 h or until mean arterial blood pressure (MAP) fell to <20 mmHg for two successive occlusions. In controls, umbilical cord occlusions were associated with a rapid initial fall in fetal heart rate (FHR) and femoral blood flow (FBF), with initial hypertension, followed by progressive development of hypotension during ongoing occlusions. Sympathectomy was associated with attenuation of the initial rise in MAP during umbilical cord occlusion, and after the onset of hypotension, a markedly more rapid fall of MAP to the nadir, with a correspondingly slower fall in FBF (P < 0.05). In contrast, MAP and FHR between successive occlusions were higher after sympathectomy (P < 0.05). There was no significant difference in the number of occlusions before terminal hypotension (6-OHDA; 16.1 ± 2.2 vs. control; 18.7 ± 2.3). These data show that SNS activity provides ongoing support for fetal MAP during prolonged exposure to brief repeated asphyxia.

Heart rate-mediated blood pressure control in preterm fetal sheep under normal and hypoxic-ischemic conditions

BACKGROUND

The understanding of hypoxemia-induced changes in baroreflex function is limited and may be studied in a fetal sheep experiment before, during, and after standardized hypoxic conditions.

METHODS

Preterm fetal lambs were instrumented at 102 d gestation (term: 146 d). At 106 d, intrauterine hypoxia--ischemia was induced by 25 min of umbilical cord occlusion (UCO). Baroreflex-related fluctuations were calculated at 30-min intervals during the first week after UCO by transfer function (cross-spectral) analysis between systolic blood pressure (SBP) and R-R interval fluctuations, estimated in the low-frequency (LF, 0.04-0.15 Hz) band. LF transfer gain (baroreflex sensitivity) and delay (s) reflect the baroreflex function.

RESULTS

Baseline did not differ in LF transfer gain and delay between controls and the UCO group. In controls, LF gain showed postnatal increase. By contrast, LF gain gradually decreased in the UCO group, resulting in significantly lower values 4-7 d after UCO. In the UCO group, LF delay increased and differed significantly from controls.

CONCLUSION

Our results show that intrauterine hypoxia-ischemia results in reduced baroreflex sensitivity over a period of 7 d, indicating limited efficacy to buffer BP changes by adapting heart rate. Cardiovascular dysregulation may augment already present cerebral damage after systemic hypoxia-ischemia in the reperfusion period.

Acute on chronic exposure to endotoxin in preterm fetal sheep

Acute, high-dose exposure to endotoxin lipopolysaccharide (LPS) in preterm fetal sheep can trigger periventricular white matter lesions (PVL), in association with severe hypotension/hypoxemia and significant mortality. Intriguingly, however, chronic or repeated exposure to LPS can induce tachyphylaxis. We therefore tested the hypothesis that progressive, acute on chronic fetal infection would be associated with white matter injury with little fetal mortality. Chronically instrumented preterm (0.7 gestational age) fetal sheep were exposed to a continuous low-dose LPS infusion (100 ng over 24 h, followed by 250 ng/24 h for 96 h) or saline. Boluses of 1 μg LPS or saline were given at 48, 72, and 96 h; sheep were killed at day 10. Six of 11 fetal sheep exposed to saline infusion + LPS boluses died 4-7 h after the first bolus. In contrast, there was no fetal mortality after saline infusions alone (n = 9), low-dose LPS infusion + saline boluses (n = 5), or low-dose LPS + LPS boluses (n = 9). Low-dose LPS infusion + LPS boluses was associated with greater microglial induction than low-dose LPS + saline boluses but a similar area of periventricular white matter inflammation. One fetus developed severe focal white matter necrosis after LPS infusion + boluses. The acute cardiovascular compromise associated with high-dose, acute exposure to LPS is markedly attenuated by previous low-dose infusions, with limited apparent exacerbation of periventricular white matter injury compared with low-dose infusion alone.

Late preterm birth: a review of medical and neuropsychological childhood outcomes

Late preterm (LP) birth (34 0/7 - 36 6/7 weeks' gestation) accounts for nearly three-fourths of all preterm births, making this population a sizeable public health concern. The immature fetal development associated with LP delivery increases the risk of mortality and short-term medical complications. Which combination of maternal, fetal, or neonatal risk factors may be most critical has only recently begun to be addressed, and whether LP birth's disruptive impact on brain development will exert adverse effects on neuropsychological functioning in childhood and adolescence has been understudied. Early data have shown a graded response, with LP children often functioning better than very preterm children but worse than term children, and with subtle intellectual and neuropsychological deficits in LP children compared with healthy children born at term gestational age. Further characterization of the neuropsychological profile is required and would be best accomplished through prospective longitudinal studies. Moreover, since moderate and LP births result in disparate medical and psychological outcomes, the common methodology of combining these participants into a single research cohort to assess risk and outcome should be reconsidered. The rapidly growing LP outcomes literature reinforces a critical principle: fetal development occurs along a dynamic maturational continuum from conception to birth, with each successive gestational day likely to improve overall outcome.