Rebuttal from James Duffin and Jason H. Mateika

Hypercapnic signaling influences hypoxic signaling in the control of breathing in C57BL6 mice

Interactions between hypoxic and hypercapnic signaling pathways, expressed as ventilatory changes occurring during and following a simultaneous hypoxic-hypercapnic gas challenge (HH-C) have not been determined systematically in mice. This study in unanesthetized male C57BL6 mice addressed the hypothesis that hypoxic (HX) and hypercapnic (HC) signaling events display an array of interactions indicative of coordination by peripheral and central respiratory mechanisms. We evaluated the ventilatory responses elicited by hypoxic (HX-C, 10%, O2, 90% N2), hypercapnic (HC-C, 5% CO2, 21%, O2, 90% N2), and HH-C (10% O2, 5%, CO2, 85% N2) challenges to determine whether ventilatory responses elicited by HH-C were simply additive of responses elicited by HX-C and HC-C, or whether other patterns of interactions existed. Responses elicited by HH-C were additive for tidal volume, minute ventilation and expiratory time, among others. Responses elicited by HH-C were hypoadditive of the HX-C and HC-C responses (i.e., HH-C responses were less than expected by simple addition of HX-C and HC-C responses) for frequency of breathing, inspiratory time and relaxation time, among others. In addition, end-expiratory pause increased during HX-C, but decreased during HC-C and HH-C, therefore showing that HC-C responses influenced the HX-C responses when given simultaneously. Return to room-air responses was additive for tidal volume and minute ventilation, among others, whereas they were hypoadditive for frequency of breathing, inspiratory time, peak inspiratory flow, apneic pause, inspiratory and expiratory drives, and rejection index. These data show that HX-C and HH-C signaling pathways interact with one another in additive and often hypoadditive processes.NEW & NOTEWORTHY We present data showing that the ventilatory responses elicited by a hypoxic gas challenge in male C57BL6 mice are markedly altered by coexposure to hypercapnic gas challenge with hypercapnic responses often dominating the hypoxic responses. These data suggest that hypercapnic signaling processes activated within brainstem regions, such as the retrotrapezoid nuclei, may directly modulate the signaling processes within the nuclei tractus solitarius resulting from hypoxic-induced increase in carotid body chemoreceptor input to these nuclei.

Strategies to improve respiratory chemoreflex characterization by Duffin's rebreathing

NEW FINDINGS

What is the central question of this study? We assessed the test-retest variability of respiratory chemoreflex characterization by Duffin's modified rebreathing method and explored whether signal averaging of repeated trials improves confidence in parameter estimation. What is the main finding and its importance? Modified rebreathing is a reproducible method to characterize responses of central and peripheral respiratory chemoreflexes. Signal averaging of multiple repeated tests minimizes within- and between-test variability, improves the confidence of chemoreflex characterization and reduces the minimal change in parameters required to establish an effect. Future experiments that apply this method might benefit from signal averaging to improve its discriminatory effect.

ABSTRACT

We assessed the test-retest variability of central and peripheral respiratory chemoreflex characterization by Duffin's modified rebreathing method and explored whether signal averaging of repeated trials improves confidence in parameter estimation. Over four laboratory visits, 13 participants (mean ± SD age, 25 ± 5 years) performed six repetitions of modified rebreathing in isoxic-hypoxic conditions [end-tidal P O 2 ${P_{{{\rm{O}}_{\rm{2}}}}}$ ( P ET , O 2 ${P_{{\rm{ET,}}{{\rm{O}}_{\rm{2}}}}}$ )  = 50 mmHg] and isoxic-hyperoxic conditions ( P ET , O 2 ${P_{{\rm{ET,}}{{\rm{O}}_{\rm{2}}}}}$   = 150 mmHg). End-tidal P C O 2 ${P_{{\rm{C}}{{\rm{O}}_{\rm{2}}}}}$ ( P ET , C O 2 ${P_{{\rm{ET,C}}{{\rm{O}}_{\rm{2}}}}}$ ), P ET , O 2 ${P_{{\rm{ET,}}{{\rm{O}}_{\rm{2}}}}}$ and minute ventilation ( V ̇ $\dot {\rm V}$ _E ) were measured breath-by-breath, by gas analyser and pneumotachograph. The V ̇ $\dot {\rm V}$ _E versus P ET , C O 2 ${P_{{\rm{ET,C}}{{\rm{O}}_{\rm{2}}}}}$ relationships were fitted with a piecewise model to estimate the ventilatory recruitment threshold (VRT) and the slope above the VRT ( V ̇ $\dot {\rm V}$ _E S). Breath-by-breath data from the three within- and between-day trials were averaged using two approaches [simple average (fit then average) and ensemble average (average then fit)] and compared with a single-trial fit. Variability was assessed by intraclass correlation (ICC) and coefficient of variance (CV), and the minimal detectable change was computed for each approach using two independent sets of three trials. Within days, the VRT and V ̇ $\dot {\rm V}$ _E S exhibited excellent test-retest variability in both hyperoxic conditions (VRT: ICC = 0.965, CV = 2.3%; V ̇ $\dot {\rm V}$ _E S: ICC = 0.932, CV = 15.5%) and hypoxic conditions (VRT: ICC = 0.970, CV = 2.9%; V ̇ $\dot {\rm V}$ _E S: ICC = 0.891, CV = 17.2%). Between-day reproducibility was also excellent (hyperoxia, VRT: ICC = 0.930, CV = 2.2%; V ̇ $\dot {\rm V}$ _E S: ICC = 0.918, CV = 14.2%; and hypoxia, VRT: ICC = 0.940, CV = 3.0%; V ̇ $\dot {\rm V}$ _E S: ICC = 0.880, CV = 18.1%). Compared with a single-trial fit, there were no differences in VRT or V ̇ $\dot {\rm V}$ _E S using the simple average or ensemble average approaches; however, ensemble averaging reduced the minimal detectable change for V ̇ $\dot {\rm V}$ _E S from 2.95 to 1.39 L min^-1  mmHg^-1 (hyperoxia) and from 3.64 to 1.82 L min^-1  mmHg^-1 (hypoxia). Single trials of modified rebreathing are reproducible; however, signal averaging of repeated trials improves confidence in parameter estimation.

Functional connectivity in raphé-pontomedullary circuits supports active suppression of breathing during hypocapnic apnea

Hyperventilation is a common feature of disordered breathing. Apnea ensues if CO2 drive is sufficiently reduced. We tested the hypothesis that medullary raphé, ventral respiratory column (VRC), and pontine neurons have functional connectivity and persistent or evoked activities appropriate for roles in the suppression of drive and rhythm during hyperventilation and apnea. Phrenic nerve activity, arterial blood pressure, end-tidal CO2, and other parameters were monitored in 10 decerebrate, vagotomized, neuromuscularly-blocked, and artificially ventilated cats. Multielectrode arrays recorded spiking activity of 649 neurons. Loss and return of rhythmic activity during passive hyperventilation to apnea were identified with the S-transform. Diverse fluctuating activity patterns were recorded in the raphé-pontomedullary respiratory network during the transition to hypocapnic apnea. The firing rates of 160 neurons increased during apnea; the rates of 241 others decreased or stopped. VRC inspiratory neurons were usually the last to cease firing or lose rhythmic activity during the transition to apnea. Mayer wave-related oscillations (0.04-0.1 Hz) in firing rate were also disrupted during apnea. Four-hundred neurons (62%) were elements of pairs with at least one hyperventilation-responsive neuron and a correlational signature of interaction identified by cross-correlation or gravitational clustering. Our results support a model with distinct groups of chemoresponsive raphé neurons contributing to hypocapnic apnea through parallel processes that incorporate disfacilitation and active inhibition of inspiratory motor drive by expiratory neurons. During apnea, carotid chemoreceptors can evoke rhythm reemergence and an inspiratory shift in the balance of reciprocal inhibition via suppression of ongoing tonic expiratory neuron activity.