CrossTalk opposing view: Which technique for controlling resistant hypertension? Carotid chemoreceptor denervation/modulation

Variable role of carotid bodies in cardiovascular responses to exercise, hypoxia and hypercapnia in spontaneously hypertensive rats

KEY POINTS

Carotid bodies play a critical role in maintaining arterial pressure during hypoxia and this has important implications when considering resection therapy of the carotid body in disease states such as hypertension. Curbing hypertension in patients whether resting or under stress remains a major global health challenge. We demonstrated previously the benefits of removing carotid body afferent input into the brain for both alleviating sympathetic overdrive and reducing blood pressure in neurogenic hypertension. We describe a new approach in rats for selective ablation of the carotid bodies that spares the functional integrity of the carotid sinus baroreceptors, and demonstrate the importance of the carotid bodies in the haemodynamic response to forced exercise, hypoxia and hypercapnia in conditions of hypertension. Selective ablation reduced blood pressure in hypertensive rats and re-set baroreceptor reflex function accordingly; the increases in blood pressure seen during exercise, hypoxia and hypercapnia were unaffected, abolished and augmented, respectively, after selective carotid body removal. The data suggest that carotid body ablation may trigger potential cardiovascular risks particularly during hypoxia and hypercapnia and that suppression rather than obliteration of their activity may be a more effective and safer route to pursue.

ABSTRACT

The carotid body has recently emerged as a promising therapeutic target for treating cardiovascular disease, but the potential impact of carotid body removal on the dynamic cardiovascular responses to acute stressors such as exercise, hypoxia and hypercapnia in hypertension is an important safety consideration that has not been studied. We first validated a novel surgical approach to selectively resect the carotid bodies bilaterally (CBR) sparing the carotid sinus baroreflex. Second, we evaluated the impact of CBR on the cardiovascular responses to exercise, hypoxia and hypercapnia in conscious, chronically instrumented spontaneously hypertensive (SH) rats. The results confirm that our CBR technique successfully and selectively abolished the chemoreflex, whilst preserving carotid baroreflex function. CBR produced a sustained fall in arterial pressure in the SH rat of ∼20 mmHg that persisted across both dark and light phases (P < 0.001), with baroreflex function curves resetting around lower arterial pressure levels. The cardiovascular and respiratory responses to moderate forced exercise were similar between CBR and Sham rats. In contrast, CBR abolished the pressor response to hypoxia seen in Sham animals, although the increases in heart rate and respiration were similar between Sham and CBR groups. Both the pressor and the respiratory responses to 7% hypercapnia were augmented after CBR (P < 0.05) compared to sham. Our finding that the carotid bodies play a critical role in maintaining arterial pressure during hypoxia has important implications when considering resection therapy of the carotid body in disease states such as hypertension as well as heart failure with sleep apnoea.

Carotid sinus denervation ameliorates renovascular hypertension in adult Wistar rats

KEY POINTS

Peripheral chemoreflex sensitization is a feature of renovascular hypertension. Carotid sinus nerve denervation (CSD) has recently been shown to relieve hypertension and reduce sympathetic activity in other rat models of hypertension. We show that CSD in renovascular hypertension halts further increases in blood pressure. Possible mechanisms include improvements in baroreceptor reflex sensitivity and renal function, restoration of cardiac calcium signalling towards control levels, and reduced neural inflammation. Our data suggest that the peripheral chemoreflex may be a viable therapeutic target for renovascular hypertension.

ABSTRACT

The peripheral chemoreflex is known to be hyper-responsive in both spontaneously hypertensive (SHR) and Goldblatt hypertensive (two kidney one clip; 2K1C) rats. We have previously shown that carotid sinus nerve denervation (CSD) reduces arterial blood pressure (ABP) in SHR. In the present study, we show that CSD ameliorates 2K1C hypertension and reveal the potential underlying mechanisms. Adult Wistar rats were instrumented to record ABP via telemetry, and then underwent CSD (n = 9) or sham CSD (n = 9) 5 weeks after renal artery clipping, in comparison with normal Wistar rats (n = 5). After 21 days, renal function was assessed, and tissue was collected to assess sympathetic postganglionic intracellular calcium transients ([Ca²⁺ ]_i ) and immune cell infiltrates. Hypertensive 2K1C rats showed a profound elevation in ABP (Wistar: 98 ± 4 mmHg vs. 2K1C: 147 ± 8 mmHg; P < 0.001), coupled with impairments in renal function and baroreflex sensitivity, increased neuroinflammatory markers and enhanced [Ca²⁺ ]_I in stellate neurons (P < 0.05). CSD reduced ABP in 2K1C+CSD rats and prevented the further progressive increase in ABP seen in 2K1C+sham CSD rats, with a between-group difference of 14 ± 2 mmHg by week 3 (P < 0.01), which was accompanied by improvements in both baroreflex control and spectral indicators of cardiac sympatho-vagal balance. Furthermore, CSD improved protein and albuminuria, decreased [Ca²⁺ ]_i evoked responses from stellate neurons, and also reduced indicators of brainstem inflammation. In summary, CSD in 2K1C rats reduces the hypertensive burden and improves renal function. This may be mediated by improvements in autonomic balance, functional remodelling of post-ganglionic neurons and reduced inflammation. Our results suggest that the peripheral chemoreflex may be considered as a potential therapeutic target for controlling renovascular hypertension.

Blood Pressure: Return of the Sympathetics?

This brief review highlights new ideas about the role of the sympathetic nervous system in human blood pressure regulation. We emphasize how this role varies with age and sex and use our findings to raise questions about the sympathetic nervous system and hypertension in humans. We also focus on three additional areas, including (1) novel ideas about the carotid body and sympathoexcitation as it relates to hypertension, (2) clinical trials of renal denervation that attempted to treat hypertension by reducing ongoing sympathoexcitation, and (3) new ideas about resistant hypertension and cerebral blood flow. We further highlight that success of device-based therapy to modulate the sympathetic nervous system relies heavily on patient selection. Furthermore, data suggest that the majority of patients respond to anti-hypertensive therapy and the major cause of "resistant" hypertension is poor patient adherence. While the enthusiasm for device therapy or perhaps even "precision medicine" is high, it is likely that by far the most benefit to the most patients will occur via better screening, more aggressive therapy, and the development of strategies that improve patient adherence to medication regimens and lifestyle changes.

Sympathetic overactivity occurs before hypertension in the two-kidney, one-clip model

Our knowledge of mechanisms responsible for both the development and the maintenance of hypertension remains incomplete in the Goldblatt (two-kidney, one-clip; 2K1C) model. We tested the hypothesis that elevated sympathetic nerve activity (SNA) occurs before the onset of hypertension in 2K1C rats, considering the time course of the increase in SNA in relationship to the onset of the hypertension. We used a decorticated in situ working heart-brainstem preparation of three groups of male Wistar rats, namely sham-operated animals (SHAM, n = 7) and animals 3 weeks post-2K1C, of which some were hypertensive (2K1C-H, n = 6) and others normotensive (2K1C-N, n = 9), as determined in vivo a priori. Perfusion pressure was higher in both 2K1C groups (2K1C-H, 76 ± 1 mmHg; 2K1C-N, 74 ± 3 mmHg; versus SHAM, 60 ± 2 mmHg, P < 0.05). The SNA was significantly elevated in both 2K1C groups (2K1C-H, 47.7 ± 6.1 μV; 2K1C-N, 32.8 ± 2.8 μV; versus SHAM, 20.5 ± 2.5 μV, P < 0.05) owing to its increased respiratory modulation; the chemoreflex was augmented and baroreflex depressed. Precollicular transection reduced SNA in all groups (2K1C-H, -32.5 ± 7.5%; 2K1C-NH, -48 ± 6.9%; versus SHAM, -13.2 ± 1%, P < 0.05). Subsequent medullary spinal cord transection abolished SNA in both SHAM and 2K1C-N groups, but decreased it by only 57 ± 5.5% in 2K1C-H preparations. Thus, SNA is raised before the onset of hypertension, by the third week after renal artery clipping, and this originates, in part, from its enhanced respiratory modulation. Spinal circuits contribute to the elevation of SNA in the 2K1C model, but only after hypertension has developed.