Estimation of signal and noise for a whole-body research photon-counting CT system

Photon Counting CT and Radiomic Analysis Enables Differentiation of Tumors Based on Lymphocyte Burden

The purpose of this study was to investigate if radiomic analysis based on spectral micro-CT with nanoparticle contrast-enhancement can differentiate tumors based on lymphocyte burden. High mutational load transplant soft tissue sarcomas were initiated in Rag2^+/− and Rag2^−/− mice to model varying lymphocyte burden. Mice received radiation therapy (20 Gy) to the tumor-bearing hind limb and were injected with a liposomal iodinated contrast agent. Five days later, animals underwent conventional micro-CT imaging using an energy integrating detector (EID) and spectral micro-CT imaging using a photon-counting detector (PCD). Tumor volumes and iodine uptakes were measured. The radiomic features (RF) were grouped into feature-spaces corresponding to EID, PCD, and spectral decomposition images. The RFs were ranked to reduce redundancy and increase relevance based on TL burden. A stratified repeated cross validation strategy was used to assess separation using a logistic regression classifier. Tumor iodine concentration was the only significantly different conventional tumor metric between Rag2^+/− (TLs present) and Rag2^−/− (TL-deficient) tumors. The RFs further enabled differentiation between Rag2^+/− and Rag2^−/− tumors. The PCD-derived RFs provided the highest accuracy (0.68) followed by decomposition-derived RFs (0.60) and the EID-derived RFs (0.58). Such non-invasive approaches could aid in tumor stratification for cancer therapy studies.

Dual-Contrast Biphasic Liver Imaging With Iodine and Gadolinium Using Photon-Counting Detector Computed Tomography: An Exploratory Animal Study

PURPOSE

The aims of this study were to develop a single-scan dual-contrast protocol for biphasic liver imaging with 2 intravenous contrast agents (iodine and gadolinium) and to evaluate its effectiveness in an exploratory swine study using a photon-counting detector computed tomography (PCD-CT) system.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

A dual-contrast CT protocol was developed for PCD-CT to simultaneously acquire 2 phases of liver contrast enhancement, with the late arterial phase enhanced by 1 contrast agent (iodine-based) and the portal venous phase enhanced by the other (gadolinium-based). A gadolinium contrast bolus (gadobutrol: 64 mL, 8 mL/s) and an iodine contrast bolus (iohexol: 40 mL, 5 mL/s) were intravenously injected in the femoral vein of a healthy domestic swine, with the second injection initiated after 17 seconds from the beginning of the first injection; PCD-CT image acquisition was performed 12 seconds after the beginning of the iodine contrast injection. A convolutional neural network (CNN)-based denoising technique was applied to PCD-CT images to overcome the inherent noise magnification issue in iodine/gadolinium decomposition task. Iodine and gadolinium material maps were generated using a 3-material decomposition method in image space. A set of contrast samples (mixed iodine and gadolinium) was attached to the swine belly; quantitative accuracy of material decomposition in these inserts between measured and true concentrations was calculated using root mean square error. An abdominal radiologist qualitatively evaluated the delineation of arterial and venous vasculatures in the swine liver using iodine and gadolinium maps obtained using the dual-contrast PCD-CT protocol.

RESULTS

The iodine and gadolinium samples attached to the swine were quantified with root mean square error values of 0.75 mg/mL for iodine and 0.45 mg/mL for gadolinium from the contrast material maps derived from the denoised PCD-CT images. Hepatic arteries containing iodine and veins containing gadolinium in the swine liver could be clearly visualized. Compared with the original images, better distinctions between 2 liver phases were achieved using CNN denoising, with approximately 60% to 80% noise reduction in contrast material maps acquired with the denoised PCD-CT images compared with the original images.

CONCLUSIONS

Simultaneous biphasic liver imaging in a single multienergy PCD-CT acquisition using a dual-contrast (iodine and gadolinium) injection protocol and CNN denoising was demonstrated in a swine study, where the enhanced hepatic arteries (containing iodine) and the enhanced hepatic veins (containing gadolinium) could be clearly visualized and delineated in the swine liver.

Simultaneous Dual-Contrast Imaging of Small Bowel With Iodine and Bismuth Using Photon-Counting-Detector Computed Tomography: A Feasibility Animal Study

OBJECTIVES

Dual-energy and multienergy computed tomography (DECT/MECT) has the potential to simultaneously visualize two contrast agents in the small bowel: arterial enhancement of iodine in the bowel wall and enteric enhancement of bismuth in the bowel lumen. The purpose of this study was to explore its feasibility in a swine study using a research whole-body photon-counting-detector (PCD) computed tomography (CT) system.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

A phantom study was initially performed to evaluate the quantification accuracy of iodine and bismuth separation from a single PCD-CT scan, which also served as the calibration reference for material decomposition of in vivo swine PCD-CT data. In the animal study, a test bolus scan was first performed to determine the time-attenuation curve for the arterial enhancement, based on which the timing of the PCD-CT dual-contrast scan was determined. A 600 mL homogeneous bismuth-saline solution (180 mL Pepto-Bismol + 420 mL normal saline) was orally administered to the pig using esophageal intubation. Approximately 1 hour after bismuth administration, 40 mL iodine contrast (Omnipaque 350, 5 mL/s) was injected intravenously. A PCD-CT scan was performed 13 seconds after the initiation of the contrast injection to simultaneously capture the arterial enhancement of iodine and the enteric enhancement of bismuth. To provide optimal material separation and quantification, all PCD-CT scans in both phantom and animal studies were operated at 140 kV with 4 energy thresholds of 25, 50, 75, and 90 keV.

RESULTS

Using a generic image-based material decomposition method, the iodine and bismuth samples were successfully delineated and quantified in the phantom images with a root-mean-square-error of 1.32 mg/mL in iodine measurement and 0.64 mg/mL in bismuth measurement. In the pig study, the enhancing bowel wall containing iodine and the small bowel loop containing bismuth were not differentiable in the original PCD-CT images. However, they were clearly distinctive from each other in the iodine- and bismuth-specific images after material decomposition, as reviewed by an abdominal radiologist. In addition, quantitative analysis showed that the misclassification between the two contrast materials was less than 1.0 mg/mL.

CONCLUSIONS

Our study demonstrated the feasibility of simultaneous imaging of iodine and bismuth in small bowel of swine using PCD-CT.

Dual source hybrid spectral micro-CT using an energy-integrating and a photon-counting detector

Preclinical micro-CT provides a hotbed in which to develop new imaging technologies, including spectral CT using photon counting detector (PCD) technology. Spectral imaging using PCDs promises to expand x-ray CT as a functional imaging modality, capable of molecular imaging, while maintaining CT's role as a powerful anatomical imaging modality. However, the utility of PCDs suffers due to distorted spectral measurements, affecting the accuracy of material decomposition. We attempt to improve material decomposition accuracy using our novel hybrid dual-source micro-CT system which combines a PCD and an energy integrating detector. Comparisons are made between PCD-only and hybrid CT results, both reconstructed with our iterative, multi-channel algorithm based on the split Bregman method and regularized with rank-sparse kernel regression. Multi-material decomposition is performed post-reconstruction for separation of iodine (I), gold (Au), gadolinium (Gd), and calcium (Ca). System performance is evaluated first in simulations, then in micro-CT phantoms, and finally in an in vivo experiment with a genetically modified p53fl/fl mouse cancer model with Au, Gd, and I nanoparticle (NP)-based contrasts agents. Our results show that the PCD-only and hybrid CT reconstructions offered very similar spatial resolution at 10% MTF (PCD: 3.50 lp mm-1; hybrid: 3.47 lp mm-1) and noise characteristics given by the noise power spectrum. For material decomposition we note successful separation of the four basis materials. We found that hybrid reconstruction reduces RMSE by an average of 37% across all material maps when compared to PCD-only of similar dose but does not provide much difference in terms of concentration accuracy. The in vivo results show separation of targeted Au and accumulated Gd NPs in the tumor from intravascular iodine NPs and bone. Hybrid spectral micro-CT can benefit nanotechnology and cancer research by providing quantitative imaging to test and optimize various NPs for diagnostic and therapeutic applications.

Multi-energy CT imaging for large patients using dual-source photon-counting detector CT

Multi-energy CT imaging of large patients with conventional dual-energy (DE)-CT using an energy-integrating-detector (EID) is challenging due to photon starvation-induced image artifacts, especially in lower tube potential (80-100 kV) images. Here, we performed phantom experiments to investigate the performance of DECT for morbidly obese patients, using an iodine and water material decomposition task as an example, on an emulated dual-source (DS)-photon-counting-detector (PCD)-CT, and compared its performance with a clinical DS-EID-CT. An abdominal CT phantom with iodine inserts of different concentrations was wrapped with tissue-equivalent gel layers to emulate a large patient (50 cm lateral size). The phantom was scanned on a research whole-body single-source (SS)-PCD-CT (140 kV tube potential), a DS-PCD-CT (100/Sn140 kV; Sn140 indicates 140 kV with Sn filter), and a clinical DS-EID-CT (100/Sn140 kV) with the same radiation dose. Phantom scans were repeated five times on each system. The DS-PCD-CT acquisition was emulated by scanning twice on the SS-PCD-CT using different tube potentials. The multi-energy CT images acquired on each system were then reconstructed, and iodine- and water-specific images were generated using material decomposition. The root-mean-square-error (RMSE) between true and measured iodine concentrations were calculated for each system and compared. The images acquired on the DS-EID-CT showed severe artifacts, including ringing, reduced uniformity, and photon starvation artifacts, especially for low-energy images. These were largely reduced in DS-PCD-CT images. The CT number difference that was measured using regions-of-interest across field-of-view were reduced from 20.3 ± 0.9 (DS-EID-CT) to 2.5 ± 0.4 HU on DS-PCD-CT, showing improved image uniformity using DS-PCD-CT. Iodine RMSE was reduced from 3.42 ± 0.03 mg ml^-1 (SS-PCD-CT) and 2.90 ± 0.03 mg ml^-1 (DS-EID-CT) to 2.39 ± 0.05 mg ml^-1 using DS-PCD-CT. DS-PCD-CT out-performed a clinical DS-EID-CT for iodine and water-based material decomposition on phantom emulating obese patients by reducing image artifacts and improving iodine quantification (RMSE reduced by 20%). With DS-PCD-CT, multi-energy CT can be performed on large patients that cannot be accommodated with current DECT.

Multi-energy computed tomography and material quantification: Current barriers and opportunities for advancement

Computed tomography (CT) technology has rapidly evolved since its introduction in the 1970s. It is a highly important diagnostic tool for clinicians as demonstrated by the significant increase in utilization over several decades. However, much of the effort to develop and advance CT applications has been focused on improving visual sensitivity and reducing radiation dose. In comparison to these areas, improvements in quantitative CT have lagged behind. While this could be a consequence of the technological limitations of conventional CT, advanced dual-energy CT (DECT) and photon-counting detector CT (PCD-CT) offer new opportunities for quantitation. Routine use of DECT is becoming more widely available and PCD-CT is rapidly developing. This review covers efforts to address an unmet need for improved quantitative imaging to better characterize disease, identify biomarkers, and evaluate therapeutic response, with an emphasis on multi-energy CT applications. The review will primarily discuss applications that have utilized quantitative metrics using both conventional and DECT, such as bone mineral density measurement, evaluation of renal lesions, and diagnosis of fatty liver disease. Other topics that will be discussed include efforts to improve quantitative CT volumetry and radiomics. Finally, we will address the use of quantitative CT to enhance image-guided techniques for surgery, radiotherapy and interventions and provide unique opportunities for development of new contrast agents.

Detective quantum efficiency of photon-counting CdTe and Si detectors for computed tomography: a simulation study

Purpose: Developing photon-counting CT detectors requires understanding the impact of parameters, such as converter material, thickness, and pixel size. We apply a linear-systems framework, incorporating spatial and energy resolution, to study realistic silicon (Si) and cadmium telluride (CdTe) detectors at a low count rate. Approach: We compared CdTe detector designs with 0.5 × 0.5    mm 2 and 0.225 × 0.225    mm 2 pixels and Si detector designs with 0.5 × 0.5    mm 2 pixels of 30 and 60 mm active thickness, with and without tungsten scatter blockers. Monte-Carlo simulations of photon transport were used together with Gaussian charge sharing models fitted to published data. Results: For detection in a 300-mm-thick object at 120 kVp, the 0.5- and 0.225-mm pixel CdTe systems have 28% to 41% and 5% to 29% higher detective quantum efficiency (DQE), respectively, than the 60-mm Si system with tungsten, whereas the corresponding numbers for two-material decomposition are 2% lower to 11% higher DQE and 31% to 54% lower DQE compared to Si. We also show that combining these detectors with dual-spectrum acquisition is beneficial. Conclusions: In the low-count-rate regime, CdTe detector systems outperform the Si systems for detection tasks, whereas silicon outperforms one or both of the CdTe systems for material decomposition.

Radiation dose efficiency of multi-energy photon-counting-detector CT for dual-contrast imaging

Compared to traditional multi-scan single-energy CT (SECT), one potential advantage of single-scan multi-energy CT (MECT) proposed for simultaneous imaging of multiple contrast agents is the radiation dose reduction. This phantom study aims to rigorously evaluate whether the radiation dose can truly be reduced in a single-scan MECT protocol (MECT_1s) in biphasic liver imaging with iodine and gadolinium, and small bowel imaging with iodine and bismuth, compared to traditional two-scan SECT protocols (SECT_2s). For MECT_1s, mixed iodine/gadolinium samples were prepared corresponding to late arterial/portal-venous phase for biphasic liver imaging. Mixed iodine/bismuth samples were prepared representing the arterial/enteric enhancement for small bowel imaging. For SECT_2s, separate contrast samples were prepared to mimic separate scans in arterial/venous phase and arterial/enteric enhancement. Samples were placed in a 35 cm wide water phantom and scanned by a research whole-body photon-counting-detector-CT (PCD-CT) system ('chess' mode). MECT images were acquired with optimized kV/threshold settings for each imaging task, and SECT images were acquired at 120 kV. Total CTDIvol was matched for the two protocols. Image-based three-material decomposition was employed in MECT_1s to determine the basis material concentration values, which were converted to CT numbers at 120 kV (i.e. virtual SECT images) to compare with the SECT images directly acquired with SECT_2s. The noise difference between the SECT and the virtual SECT images was compared to evaluate the dose efficiency of MECT_1s. Compared to SECT_2s, MECT_1s was not dose efficient for both imaging tasks. The amount of noise increase is highly task dependent, with noise increased by 203%/278% and 110%/82% in virtual SECT images for iodine/gadolinium and iodine/bismuth quantifications, respectively, corresponding to dose increase by 819%/1328% and 340%/230% in MECT_1s to achieve the same image noise level. MECT with the current PCD-CT technique requires higher radiation dose than SECT to achieve the same image quality.

Feasibility of multi-contrast imaging on dual-source photon counting detector (PCD) CT: An initial phantom study

PURPOSE

Photon-counting-detector-computed tomography (PCD-CT) allows separation of multiple, simultaneously imaged contrast agents, such as iodine (I), gadolinium (Gd), and bismuth (Bi). However, PCDs suffer from several technical limitations such as charge sharing, K-edge escape, and pulse pile-up, which compromise spectral separation of multi-energy data and degrade multi-contrast imaging performance. The purpose of this work was to determine the performance of a dual-source (DS) PCD-CT relative to a single-source (SS) PCD-CT for the separation of simultaneously imaged I, Gd, and Bi contrast agents.

METHODS

Phantom experiments were performed using a research whole-body PCD-CT and head/abdomen-sized phantoms containing vials of different I, Gd, Bi concentrations. To emulate a DS-PCD-CT, the phantoms were scanned twice on the SS-PCD-CT using different tube potentials for each scan. A tube potential of 80 kV (energy thresholds = 25/50 keV) was used for low-energy tube, while the high-energy tube used Sn140 kV (Sn indicates tin filter) and thresholds of 25/90 keV. The same phantoms were scanned also on the SS-PCD-CT using the chess acquisition mode. In chess mode, the 4 × 4 subpixels within a macro detector pixel are split into two sets based on a chess-board pattern. With each subpixel set having two energy thresholds, chess mode allows four energy-bin data sets, which permits simultaneous multi-contrast imaging. Because of this design, only 50% area of each detector pixel is configured to receive photons of a pre-defined threshold, leading to 50% dose utilization efficiency. To compensate for this dose inefficiency, the radiation dose for this scan was doubled compared to DS-PCD-CT. A 140 kV tube potential and thresholds = 25/50/75/90 keV were used. These settings were determined based on the K-edges of Gd, and Bi, and were found to yield good differentiation of I/Gd/Bi based on phantom experiments and other literature. The energy-bin images obtained from each scan (scan pair) were used to generate I-, Gd-, Bi-specific image via material decomposition. Root-mean-square-error (RMSE) between the known and measured concentrations was calculated for each scenario. A 20-cm water cylinder phantom was scanned on both systems, which was used for evaluating the magnitude of noise, and noise power spectra (NPS) of I/Gd/Bi-specific images.

RESULTS

Phantom results showed that DS-PCD-CT reduced noise in material-specific images for both head and body phantoms compared to SS-PCD-CT. The noise level of SS-PCD was reduced from 2.55 to 0.90 mg/mL (I), 1.97 to 0.78 mg/mL (Gd), and 0.85 to 0.74 mg/mL (Bi) using DS-PCD. NPS analysis showed that the noise texture of images acquired on both systems is similar. For the body phantom, the RMSE for SS-PCD-CT was reduced relative to DS-PCD-CT from 10.52 to 2.76 mg/mL (I), 7.90 to 2.01 mg/mL (Gd), and 1.91 to 1.16 mg/mL (Bi). A similar trend was observed for the head phantom: RMSE reduced from 2.59 (SS-PCD) to 0.72 (DS-PCD) mg/mL (I), 2.02 to 0.58 mg/mL (Gd), and 0.85 to 0.57 mg/mL (Bi).

CONCLUSION

We demonstrate the feasibility of performing simultaneous imaging of I, Gd, and Bi materials on DS-PCD-CT. Under the condition without cross scattering, DS-PCD reduced the RMSE for quantification of material concentration in relative to a SS-PCD-CT system using chess mode.

Functional imaging of tumor vasculature using iodine and gadolinium-based nanoparticle contrast agents: a comparison of spectral micro-CT using energy integrating and photon counting detectors

Advances in computed tomography (CT) hardware have propelled the development of novel CT contrast agents. In particular, the spectral capabilities of x-ray CT can facilitate simultaneous imaging of multiple contrast agents. This approach is particularly useful for functional imaging of solid tumors by simultaneous visualization of multiple targets or architectural features that govern cancer development and progression. Nanoparticles are a promising platform for contrast agent development. While several novel imaging moieties based on high atomic number elements are being explored, iodine (I) and gadolinium (Gd) are particularly attractive because of their existing approval for clinical use. In this work, we investigate the in vivo discrimination of I and Gd nanoparticle contrast agents using both dual energy micro-CT with energy integrating detectors (DE-EID) and photon counting detector (PCD)-based spectral micro-CT. Simulations and phantom experiments were performed using varying concentrations of I and Gd to determine the imaging performance with optimized acquisition parameters. Quantitative spectral micro-CT imaging using liposomal-iodine (Lip-I) and liposomal-Gd (Lip-Gd) nanoparticle contrast agents was performed in sarcoma bearing mice for anatomical and functional imaging of tumor vasculature. Iterative reconstruction provided high sensitivity to detect and discriminate relatively low I and Gd concentrations. According to the Rose criterion applied to the experimental results, the detectability limits for I and Gd were approximately 2.5 mg ml^-1 for both DE-EID CT and PCD micro-CT, even if the radiation dose was approximately 3.8 times lower with PCD micro-CT. The material concentration maps confirmed expected biodistributions of contrast agents in the blood, liver, spleen and kidneys. The PCD provided lower background signal and better simultaneous visualization of tumor vasculature and intratumoral distribution patterns of nanoparticle contrast agent compared to DE-EID decompositions. Preclinical spectral CT systems such as this could be useful for functional characterization of solid tumors, simultaneous quantitative imaging of multiple targets and for identifying clinically-relevant applications that benefit from the use of spectral imaging. Additionally, it could aid in the development nanoparticles that show promise in the developing field of cancer theranostics (therapy and diagnostics) by measuring vascular tumor biomarkers such as fractional blood volume and the delivery of liposomal chemotherapeutics.

Photon-Counting Computed Tomography for Vascular Imaging of the Head and Neck: First In Vivo Human Results

PURPOSE

The purpose of this study was to evaluate image quality of a spectral photon-counting detector (PCD) computed tomography (CT) system for evaluation of major arteries of the head and neck compared with conventional single-energy CT scans using energy-integrating detectors (EIDs).

METHODS

In this institutional review board-approved study, 16 asymptomatic subjects (7 men) provided informed consent and received both PCD and EID contrast-enhanced CT scans of the head and neck (mean age, 58 years; range, 46-75 years). Tube settings were (EID: 120 kVp/160 mA vs PCD: 140 kVp/108 mA) for all volunteers. Quantitative analysis included measurements of mean attenuation, image noise, and contrast-to-noise ratio (CNR). Spectral PCD data were used to reconstruct virtual monoenergetic images and iodine maps. A head phantom was used to validate iodine concentration measurements in PCD images only. Two radiologists blinded to detector type independently scored the image quality of different segments of the arteries, as well as diagnostic acceptability, image noise, and severity of artifacts of the PCD and EID images. Reproducibility was assessed with intraclass correlation coefficient. Linear mixed models that account for within-subject correlation of analyzed arterial segments were used. Linear regression and Bland-Altman analysis with 95% limits of agreement were used to calculate the accuracy of material decomposition.

RESULTS

Photon-counting detector image quality scores were significantly higher compared with EID image quality scores with lower image noise (P < 0.01) and less image artifacts (P < 0.001). Photon-counting detector image noise was 9.1% lower than EID image noise (8.0 ± 1.3 HU vs 8.8 ± 1.5 HU, respectively, P < 0.001). Arterial segments showed artifacts on EID images due to beam hardening that were not present on PCD images. On PCD images of the head phantom, there was excellent correlation (R = 0.998) between actual and calculated iodine concentrations without significant bias (bias: -0.4 mg/mL [95% limits of agreements: -1.1 to 0.4 mg/mL]). Iodine maps had 20.7% higher CNR compared with nonspectral PCD (65.2 ± 9.0 vs 54.0 ± 4.5, P = 0.01), and virtual monoenergetic image at 70 keV showed similar CNR to nonspectral images (52.6 ± 4.2 vs 54.0 ± 4.5, P = 0.39).

CONCLUSIONS

Photon-counting CT has the potential to improve the image quality of carotid and intracranial CT angiography compared with single-energy EID CT.