A disease-associated mutation that weakens ZAP70 autoinhibition enhances responses to weak and self-ligands

Novel Compound Heterozygous ZAP70 R37G A507T Mutations in Infant with Severe Immunodeficiency

Zeta-chain associated protein kinase 70 kDa (ZAP70) combined immunodeficiency (CID) is an autosomal recessive severe immunodeficiency that is characterized by abnormal T-cell receptor signaling. Children with the disorder typically present during the first year of life with diarrhea, failure to thrive, and recurrent bacterial, viral, or opportunistic infections. To date, the only potential cure is hematopoietic stem cell transplant (HSCT). The majority of described mutations causing disease occur in the homozygous state, though heterozygotes are reported without a clear understanding as to how the individual mutations interact to cause disease. This case describes an infant with novel ZAP-70 deficiency mutations involving the SH2 and kinase domains cured with allogeneic HSCT utilizing a reduced-intensity conditioning regimen and graft manipulation. We then were able to further elucidate the molecular signaling alterations imparted by these mutations that lead to altered immune function. In order to examine the effect of these novel compound ZAP70 heterozygous mutations on T cells, Jurkat CD4+ T cells were transfected with either wild type, or with individual ZAP70 R37G and A507T mutant constructs. Downstream TCR signaling events and protein localization results link these novel mutations to the expected immunological outcome as seen in the patient's primary cells. This study further characterizes mutations in the ZAP70 gene as combined immunodeficiency and the clinical phenotype.

Decoding the deactivation mechanism of R192W mutation of ZAP-70 using molecular dynamics simulations and binding free energy calculations

CONTEXT

ZAP-70 (zeta-chain-associated protein of 70 kDa), serving as a critical regulator for T cell antigen receptor signaling, represents an attractive therapeutic target for autoimmunity disease. How the mechanistical mechanism of ZAP-70 to a human autoimmune syndrome-associated R192W mutation remains unclear. The results indicated that the R192W mutation of ZAP-70 clearly affected the conformational flexibility of the N-terminal ITAM-Y2P. Structural analysis unveiled that the R192W mutation of ZAP-70 caused the exposure of the N-terminal ITAM-Y2P to the solvent. MM-GBSA binding free energy calculations exhibited that the R192W mutation decreased the binding affinity of ITAM-Y2P to the ZAP-70 mutant. Residue-based free energy decomposition further revealed that the protein-peptide interaction networks involving electrostatic interactions provide significant contributions for complex formation. The energy unfavorable residues include Arg43, Arg192, Tyr240, and Lys244 from ZAP-70 and Asn301, Leu303, pY304, and pY315 from ITAM-Y2P in the R192W mutant. Our obtained results may help the understanding of the deactivation mechanism of ZAP-70 induced by the R192W mutation.

METHODS

In the work, multiple replica molecular dynamics simulations and molecular mechanics-generalized Born surface area (MM-GBSA) method were performed to reveal the doubly phosphorylated ITAMs (ITAM-Y2P)-mediated deactivation mechanism of ZAP-70 induced by the R192W mutation.

Combined immunodeficiency caused by pathogenic variants in the ZAP70 C-terminal SH2 domain

Introduction

ZAP-70, a protein tyrosine kinase recruited to the T cell receptor (TCR), initiates a TCR signaling cascade upon antigen stimulation. Mutations in the ZAP70 gene cause a combined immunodeficiency characterized by low or absent CD8+ T cells and nonfunctional CD4+ T cells. Most deleterious missense ZAP70 mutations in patients are located in the kinase domain but the impact of mutations in the SH2 domains, regulating ZAP-70 recruitment to the TCR, are not well understood.

Methods

Genetic analyses were performed on four patients with CD8 lymphopenia and a high resolution melting screening for ZAP70 mutations was developed. The impact of SH2 domain mutations was evaluated by biochemical and functional analyses as well as by protein modeling.

Results and discussion

Genetic characterization of an infant who presented with pneumocystis pneumonia, mycobacterial infection, and an absence of CD8 T cells revealed a novel homozygous mutation in the C-terminal SH2 domain (SH2-C) of the ZAP70 gene (c.C343T, p.R170C). A distantly related second patient was found to be compound heterozygous for the R170C variant and a 13bp deletion in the ZAP70 kinase domain. While the R170C mutant was highly expressed, there was an absence of TCR-induced proliferation, associated with significantly attenuated TCR-induced ZAP-70 phosphorylation and a lack of binding of ZAP-70 to TCR-ζ. Moreover, a homozygous ZAP-70 R192W variant was identified in 2 siblings with combined immunodeficiency and CD8 lymphopenia, confirming the pathogenicity of this mutation. Structural modeling of this region revealed the critical nature of the arginines at positions 170 and 192, in concert with R190, forming a binding pocket for the phosphorylated TCR-ζ chain. Deleterious mutations in the SH2-C domain result in attenuated ZAP-70 function and clinical manifestations of immunodeficiency.

Progressive enhancement of kinetic proofreading in T cell antigen discrimination from receptor activation to DAG generation

T cells use kinetic proofreading to discriminate antigens by converting small changes in antigen-binding lifetime into large differences in cell activation, but where in the signaling cascade this computation is performed is unknown. Previously, we developed a light-gated immune receptor to probe the role of ligand kinetics in T cell antigen signaling. We found significant kinetic proofreading at the level of the signaling lipid diacylglycerol (DAG) but lacked the ability to determine where the multiple signaling steps required for kinetic discrimination originate in the upstream signaling cascade (Tiseher and Weiner, 2019). Here, we uncover where kinetic proofreading is executed by adapting our optogenetic system for robust activation of early signaling events. We find the strength of kinetic proofreading progressively increases from Zap70 recruitment to LAT clustering to downstream DAG generation. Leveraging the ability of our system to rapidly disengage ligand binding, we also measure slower reset rates for downstream signaling events. These data suggest a distributed kinetic proofreading mechanism, with proofreading steps both at the receptor and at slower resetting downstream signaling complexes that could help balance antigen sensitivity and discrimination.

Negative Regulation of Zap70 by Lck Forms the Mechanistic Basis of Differential Expression in CD4 and CD8 T Cells

Lck and Zap70, two non-receptor tyrosine kinases, play a crucial role in the regulation of membrane proximal TCR signaling critical for thymic selection, CD4/CD8 lineage choice and mature T cell function. Signal initiation upon TCR/CD3 and peptide/MHC interaction induces Lck-mediated phosphorylation of CD3 ITAMs. This is necessary for Zap70 recruitment and its phosphorylation by Lck leading to full Zap70 activation. In its native state Zap70 maintains a closed conformation creating an auto-inhibitory loop, which is relieved by Lck-mediated phosphorylation of Y315/Y319. Zap70 is differentially expressed in thymic subsets and mature T cells with CD8 T cells expressing the highest amount compared to CD4 T cells. However, the mechanistic basis of differential Zap70 expression in thymic subsets and mature T cells is not well understood. Here, we show that Zap70 is degraded relatively faster in DP and mature CD4 T cells compared to CD8 T cells, and inversely correlated with relative level of activated Zap70. Importantly, we found that Zap70 expression is negatively regulated by Lck activity: augmented Lck activity resulting in severe diminution in total Zap70. Moreover, Lck-mediated phosphorylation of Y315/Y319 was essential for Zap70 degradation. Together, these data shed light on the underlying mechanism of Lck-mediated differential modulation of Zap70 expression in thymic subsets and mature T cells.

ZAP70, too little, too much can lead to autoimmunity*

Establishing both central and peripheral tolerance requires the appropriate TCR signaling strength to discriminate self‐ from agonist‐peptide bound to self MHC molecules. ZAP70, a cytoplasmic tyrosine kinase, directly interacts with the TCR complex and plays a central and requisite role in TCR signaling in both thymocytes and peripheral T cells. By studying ZAP70 hypomorphic mutations in mice and humans with a spectrum of hypoactive or hyperactive activities, we have gained insights into mechanisms of central and peripheral tolerance. Interestingly, both hypoactive and hyperactive ZAP70 can lead to the development of autoimmune diseases, albeit through distinct mechanisms. Immature thymocytes and mature T cells rely on normal ZAP70 function to complete their development in the thymus and to modulate T cell responses in the periphery. Hypoactive ZAP70 function compromises key developmental checkpoints required to establish central tolerance, allowing thymocytes with potentially self‐reactive TCRs a greater chance to escape negative selection. Such ‘forbidden clones’ may escape into the periphery and may pose a greater risk for autoimmune disease development since they may not engage negative regulatory mechanisms as effectively. Hyperactive ZAP70 enhances thymic negative selection but some thymocytes will, nonetheless, escape negative selection and have greater sensitivity to weak and self‐ligands. Such cells must be controlled by mechanisms involved in anergy, expansion of Tregs, and upregulation of inhibitory receptors or signaling molecules. However, such potentially autoreactive cells may still be able to escape control by peripheral negative regulatory constraints. Consistent with findings in Zap70 mutants, the signaling defects in at least one ZAP70 substrate, LAT, can also lead to autoimmune disease. By dissecting the similarities and differences among mouse models of patient disease or mutations in ZAP70 that affect TCR signaling strength, we have gained insights into how perturbed ZAP70 function can lead to autoimmunity. Because of our work and that of others on ZAP70, it is likely that perturbations in other molecules affecting TCR signaling strength will be identified that also overcome tolerance mechanisms and cause autoimmunity. Delineating these molecular pathways could lead to the development of much needed new therapeutic targets in these complex diseases.