Clinically used antimicrobial drugs against experimental pneumocystosis, singly and in combination: analysis of drug interactions and efficacies

Pneumocystis Pneumonia: Pitfalls and Hindrances to Establishing a Reliable Animal Model

Pneumocystis pneumonia is a severe lung infection that occurs primarily in largely immunocompromised patients. Few treatment options exist, and the mortality rate remains substantial. To develop new strategies in the fields of diagnosis and treatment, it appears to be critical to improve the scientific knowledge about the biology of the Pneumocystis agent and the course of the disease. In the absence of in vitro continuous culture system, in vivo animal studies represent a crucial cornerstone for addressing Pneumocystis pneumonia in laboratories. Here, we provide an overview of the animal models of Pneumocystis pneumonia that were reported in the literature over the last 60 years. Overall, this review highlights the great heterogeneity of the variables studied: the choice of the host species and its genetics, the different immunosuppressive regimens to render an animal susceptible, the experimental challenge, and the different validation methods of the model. With this work, the investigator will have the keys to choose pivotal experimental parameters and major technical features that are assumed to likely influence the results according to the question asked. As an example, we propose an animal model to explore the immune response during Pneumocystis pneumonia.

Use of terbinafine in mouse and rat models of Pneumocystis carinii pneumonia

Terbinafine, an allylamine used to treat onychomycosis, has been reported to be active against rat Pneumocystis carinii in vitro and in vivo. By contrast, our in vitro data showed that the 50% inhibitory concentration of terbinafine against rat P. carinii is 3.7 microg/ml, a level that cannot be clinically achieved in serum. In the present study, terbinafine administered orally at doses of 20 to 400 mg/kg/day and 50 to 250 mg/kg/day was ineffective therapy for mouse and rat models of pneumocystosis, respectively. These results emphasize the complexities of P. carinii drug testing and the need for caution before considering studies in humans.

In vitro and in vivo effects of quinupristin-dalfopristin against Pneumocystis carinii

Quinupristin-dalfopristin (Q-D), which is active against bacteria and Toxoplasma gondii, was examined for its activity against Pneumocystis carinii. After 72 h of incubation with rat P. carinii in an ATP cytotoxicity assay, the 50% inhibitory concentration of Q-D was 10.6 microg/ml, a level that can be achieved in serum with high-dose administration. Q-D administered intraperitoneally at doses of 50 to 200 mg per kg of body weight per day in the treatment and 100 mg/kg/day three times per week in the prophylaxis of pneumocystosis in immunosuppressed mice reduced the organism burden up to 15- and 302-fold, respectively. We conclude that Q-D has activity against P. carinii in vitro and in vivo.

Activities and conformational fitting of 1,4-naphthoquinone derivatives and other cyclic 1,4-diones tested in vitro against Pneumocystis carinii

Atovaquone is a chemotherapeutic agent used to treat pneumonia caused by Pneumocystis carinii in some immunocompromised patients. A set of cyclic 1,4-diones were tested in vitro for ability to inhibit growth of P. carinii, including 22 variously substituted 1,4-naphthoquinones, one bis-1,4-naphthoquinone, and three other quinones. For comparison, the antipneumocystic primaquine and its 5-hydroxy-6-desmethyl metabolite were also tested. At 1.0 microg/ml, seven compounds inhibited growth by at least 39%, with atovaquone at 92%; of these seven, five are 2-hydroxy-1,4-naphthoquinones, while one is a 2-chloro- and another is a 2-methyl-1,4-naphthoquinone. At 0.1 microg/ml, however, the most active compound tested was the primaquine metabolite, which inhibited growth by more than 42% at this concentration. To ascertain a structure-activity relationship, all 1,4-naphthoquinones were compared conformationally by means of computer-based molecular modeling (Spartan) incorporating the Sybyl force field. Without exception, for all 21 monomers tested, the substituent at position 3 of the 1,4-naphthoquinone favored activity most strongly when it simultaneously occupied (i) space centered at about 3 A from position 3, without projecting steric bulk from the area encompassed by atovaquone's cyclohexyl ring, and (ii) roughly planar space at about 7.3 A from position 3, without projecting steric bulk perpendicularly. This structure-activity relationship may prove useful in the rational design of better antipneumocystis agents.

Inhibition of growth of Pneumocystis carinii by lactoferrins alone and in combination with pyrimethamine, clarithromycin and minocycline

The in vitro activity of lactoferrins alone and in combination with clarithromycin, minocycline and pyrimethamine was investigated against three clinical isolates of Pneumocystis carinii. Susceptibility was tested by inoculating isolates on to cell monolayers and determining the parasite count after 72 h incubation at 37 degrees C. The culture medium was supplemented with serial dilutions of each agent. At 20 mg/L, bovine lactoferrin, the most active agent, suppressed the growth of cystic and trophic forms by >60%. Human lactoferrin, at the same concentration, suppressed the growth of cystic and trophic forms by >50%. Lactoferrins at 20 mg/L combined with clarithromycin 4 mg/L had high anti-P. carinii activity, with a >90% decrease in cystic and trophic form counts. Our study suggests that lactoferrins may inhibit P. carinii growth in vitro and act synergically with other clinically used compounds. These findings lend experimental support to the use of iron-chelating agents in the therapy of pneumocystis infections.

In-vitro activity of rifabutin and albendazole singly and in combination with other clinically used antimicrobial agents against Pneumocystis carinii

The in-vitro activity of rifabutin and albendazole alone and in combination with clarithromycin, etoposide, minocycline and pyrimethamine was investigated against four clinical isolates of Pneumocystis carinii. The susceptibility tests were performed by inoculation of the isolates on to cell monolayers and by determining the parasite count after 72 h incubation at 37 degrees C. The culture medium was supplemented with serial dilutions of each agent. Albendazole tested alone was more active than rifabutin. Albendazole suppressed the growth of cysts and trophozoites by >50% at 4 mg/L. Rifabutin, at the same concentration, produced about 40% reduction in the mean cyst and trophozoite counts. Albendazole (4 mg/L) combined with etoposide 4 mg/L showed the highest anti-P. carinii activity, with a decrease of 86.3% and 90.1% in cyst and trophozoite counts, respectively. The greatest synergic interaction was detected when rifabutin (4 mg/L) was combined with clarithromycin (4 mg/L). Our study suggests that clinically used antimicrobial agents may be effective in inhibiting P. carinii growth in vitro and that, above all, some of these agents possess a positive interaction upon combination with other clinically used compounds. These findings may be useful in the establishment of a prophylaxis regimen for multiple opportunistic pathogens.

Evaluation of drug efficacy by using animal models or in vitro systems

The efficacy of most therapeutic and prophylactic protocols against Pneumocystis carinii pneumonia used in human patients has been tested in animal models, especially in the corticosteroid-treated rat. The advantages and drawbacks of this model have been examined in brief in Chapter 1 of this section. More recently, the nude rat, intratracheally inoculated with Pneumocystis, was used to test new anti-microbian molecules for their anti-Pneumocystis activity. In vitro systems, co-cultures of Pneumocystis with feeder cells as well as axenic cultures, were also used many times for drug screening. In this paper, the most used in vivo or in vitro drug screening systems are described. Moreover, as immunocompromised individuals, AIDS patients, especially, are often infected simultaneously by several infectious agents, a recent co-infection model is described.

Immunodeficient and immunosuppressed mice as models to test anti-Pneumocystis carinii drugs

Congenitally immunodeficient and immunosuppressed normal mice with naturally acquired Pneumocystis carinii infection were compared as models for testing anti-P. carinii drugs. Among the immunodeficient mice, mice with severe combined immunodeficiency disease (scid), which lack B and T cells, had higher levels of P. carinii pneumonia than did microMT mice, which lack K cells. Normal mice administered dexamethasone in the drinking water had more extensive pneumocystosis than mice administered parenteral methylprednisolone or hybridoma cells making a monoclonal antibody to CD4 cells. The standard anti-P. carinii drugs trimethoprim (TMP)-sulfamethoxazole (SMX), pentamidine, and atovaquone, which work well in rats and humans, worked well in the mice. Clindamycin and primaquine were effective in the scid and microMT mice but not in the immunosuppressed normal mice. High doses of epiroprim, an analog of TMP, appeared to enhance the activities of low doses of SMX and dapsone, while high doses of TMP did not; however, further studies are needed before definitive conclusions about the actions of these drugs can be drawn. Taken together, the data obtained in this study support the growing body of literature suggesting that the mouse is a valid alternative to the rat as a model for testing anti-P. carinii drugs. Additional differences involving the activities of individual drugs in these models will probably emerge as more experience is gained.