Are Antimicrobial Interventions Associated with Heat-Resistant Escherichia coli on Meat?

Relationship between Desiccation Tolerance and Biofilm Formation in Shiga Toxin-Producing Escherichia coli

Shiga toxin-producing Escherichia coli (STEC) is a major concern in the food industry and requires effective control measures to prevent foodborne illnesses. Previous studies have demonstrated increased difficulty in the control of biofilm-forming STEC. Desiccation, achieved through osmotic stress and water removal, has emerged as a potential antimicrobial hurdle. This study focused on 254 genetically diverse E. coli strains collected from cattle, carcass hides, hide-off carcasses, and processing equipment. Of these, 141 (55.51%) were STEC and 113 (44.48%) were generic E. coli. The biofilm-forming capabilities of these isolates were assessed, and their desiccation tolerance was investigated to understand the relationships between growth temperature, relative humidity (RH), and bacterial survival. Only 28% of the STEC isolates had the ability to form biofilms, compared to 60% of the generic E. coli. Stainless steel surfaces were exposed to different combinations of temperature (0 °C or 35 °C) and relative humidity (75% or 100%), and the bacterial attachment and survival rates were measured over 72 h and compared to controls. The results revealed that all the strains exposed to 75% relative humidity (RH) at any temperature had reduced growth (p < 0.001). In contrast, 35 °C and 100% RH supported bacterial proliferation, except for isolates forming the strongest biofilms. The ability of E. coli to form a biofilm did not impact growth reduction at 75% RH. Therefore, desiccation treatment at 75% RH at temperatures of 0 °C or 35 °C holds promise as a novel antimicrobial hurdle for the removal of biofilm-forming E. coli from challenging-to-clean surfaces and equipment within food processing facilities.

Stress Resistance and Virulence Gene Profiles Associated with Phylogeny and Phenotypes of Escherichia coli from Cattle

Seven serogroups of E. coli (Top seven E. coli) are frequently implicated in foodborne outbreaks in North America, largely due to their carriage of Shiga toxin genes (stx). This study aimed to profile resistance genes and virulence factors (VF), and their potential association with phylogeny and phenotypes of Top seven E. coli originating from cattle in Canada. 155 Top seven E. coli isolates previously characterized for heat and acid resistance and biofilm-forming ability were whole-genome sequenced and analyzed for phylogeny, VF, and stress resistance genes. The 155 E. coli strains belonged to six phylogroups: A (n = 32), B1 (n = 93), C (n = 3), D (n = 11), E (n = 15), and G (n = 1). Different phylogroups were clearly separated on the core genome tree, with strains of the same serotype closely clustered. The carriage of stx and the transmissible locus of stress tolerance (tLST), the extreme heat resistance marker, was mutually exclusive, in 33 and 15 genomes, respectively. A novel O84:H2 strain carrying stx1a was also identified. In total, 70, 41, and 32 VF, stress resistance genes and antibiotic resistance genes were identified. The stress resistance genes included those for metal (n = 29), biocides/acid (n = 4), and heat (n = 8) resistance. All heat resistance genes and most metal-resistance genes that were differentially distributed among the phylogroups were exclusively in phylogroup A. VF were least and most present in phylogroups A and D, respectively. No specific genes associated with acid resistance or biofilm formation phenotypes were identified. VF were more abundant (P < 0.05) in the non-biofilm-forming population and acid-resistant population.

Association of resistance to quaternary ammonium compounds and organic acids with genetic markers and their relationship to Escherichia coli serogroup

Sanitizer resistance is being extensively investigated due to the potential for bacterial survival and cross-resistance with other antimicrobials. Similarly, organic acids are being used due to their microbial inactivation potential as well as being generally recognized as safe (GRAS). However, little is known about associations of genetic and phenotypic factors in Escherichia coli related to resistance to sanitizers and organic acids as well as differences between "Top 7" serogroups. Therefore, we investigated 746 E. coli isolates for resistance to lactic acid and two commercial sanitizers based on quaternary ammonium and peracetic acid. Furthermore, we correlated resistance to several genetic markers and investigated 44 isolates using Whole Genome Sequencing. Results indicate that factors related to motility, biofilm formation, and Locus of Heat Resistance played a role in resistance to sanitizers and lactic acid. In addition, Top 7 serogroups significantly differed in sanitizer and acid resistance, with O157 being the most consistently resistant to all treatments. Finally, mutations in rpoA, rpoC, and rpoS genes were observed, in addition to presence of a Gad gene with alpha-toxin formation in all O121 and O145 isolates, which may be related to increased resistance of these serogroups to the acids used in the present study.

Bacteriophages for the Targeted Control of Foodborne Pathogens

Foodborne illness is exacerbated by novel and emerging pathotypes, persistent contamination, antimicrobial resistance, an ever-changing environment, and the complexity of food production systems. Sporadic and outbreak events of common foodborne pathogens like Shiga toxigenic E. coli (STEC), Salmonella, Campylobacter, and Listeria monocytogenes are increasingly identified. Methods of controlling human infections linked with food products are essential to improve food safety and public health and to avoid economic losses associated with contaminated food product recalls and litigations. Bacteriophages (phages) are an attractive additional weapon in the ongoing search for preventative measures to improve food safety and public health. However, like all other antimicrobial interventions that are being employed in food production systems, phages are not a panacea to all food safety challenges. Therefore, while phage-based biocontrol can be promising in combating foodborne pathogens, their antibacterial spectrum is generally narrower than most antibiotics. The emergence of phage-insensitive single-cell variants and the formulation of effective cocktails are some of the challenges faced by phage-based biocontrol methods. This review examines phage-based applications at critical control points in food production systems with an emphasis on when and where they can be successfully applied at production and processing levels. Shortcomings associated with phage-based control measures are outlined together with strategies that can be applied to improve phage utility for current and future applications in food safety.

Heat-resistant and biofilm-forming Escherichia coli in pasteurized milk from Brazil

Escherichia coli harboring a transmissible locus of stress tolerance (tLST) and the ability to form biofilms represent a serious risk in dairy production. Thus, we aimed to evaluate the microbiological quality of pasteurized milk from two dairy producers in Mato Grosso, Brazil, with a focus on determining the possible presence of E. coli with heat resistance (60 °C/6 min), biofilm-forming potential phenotypes and genotypes, and antimicrobial susceptibility. For this, fifty pasteurized milk samples from producers named A and B were obtained for 5 weeks to investigate the presence of Enterobacteriaceae members, coliforms, and E. coli. For heat resistance, E. coli isolates were exposed to a water bath at 60 °C for 0 and 6 min. In antibiogram analysis, eight antibiotics belonging to six antimicrobial classes were analyzed. The potential to form biofilms was quantified at 570 nm, and curli expression by Congo Red was analyzed. To determine the genotypic profile, we performed PCR for the tLST and rpoS genes, and pulsed-field gel electrophoresis (PFGE) was used to investigate the clonal profile of the isolates. Thus, producer A presented unsatisfactory microbiological conditions regarding Enterobacteriaceae and coliforms for weeks 4 and 5, while all samples analyzed for producer B were contaminated at above-the-limit levels established by national and international legislation. These unsatisfactory conditions enabled us to isolate 31 E. coli from both producers (7 isolates from producer A and 24 isolates from producer B). In this way, 6 E. coli isolates (5 from producer A and 1 from producer B) were highly heat resistant. However, although only 6 E. coli showed a highly heat-resistant profile, 97% (30/31) of all E. coli were tLST-positive. In contrast, all isolates were sensitive to all antimicrobials tested. In addition, moderate or weak biofilm potential was verified in 51.6% (16/31), and the expression of curli and presence of rpoS was not always related to this biofilm potential. Therefore, the results emphasize the spreading of heat-resistant E. coli with tLST in both producers and indicate the biofilm as a possible source of contamination during milk pasteurization. However, the possibility of E. coli producing biofilm and surviving pasteurization temperatures cannot be ruled out, and this should be investigated.

Distribution of Extremely Heat-Resistant Escherichia coli in the Beef Production and Processing Continuum

Understanding the dynamics of stress-resistant Escherichia coli (E. coli) across the meat production and processing continuum is important for tracking sources of such microbes and devising effective modes of control. The Locus of Heat Resistance (LHR) is a ∼14-19 Kb genetic element imparting extreme heat resistance (XHR) in Enterobacteriaceae. It has been hypothesized that thermal and antimicrobial interventions applied during meat processing may select for LHR⁺E. coli. Thus, our goal was to study the prevalence and molecular biology of LHR⁺E. coli among lots of beef cattle (n = 3) from production through processing. Two hundred thirty-two generic E. coli isolated from the same animals through seven stages of the beef processing continuum (cattle in feedyards to packaged strip loins) were examined. LHR⁺E. coli were rare (0.6%; 1 of 180) among the early stages of the beef continuum (feces and hides at feedlot, feces and hides at harvest, and preevisceration carcasses), whereas the prevalence of LHR⁺E. coli on final carcasses and strip loins was remarkably higher. Half (14 of 28) of the final carcass E. coli possessed the LHR, while 79.2% (19 of 24) of the strip loin E. coli did. Eighty-five percent (29 of 34) of the LHR⁺E. coli presented with the XHR phenotype. The selection or enrichment of LHR⁺E. coli from harvest steps to the final products appeared unlikely as the LHR⁺E. coli isolates were effectively controlled by antimicrobial interventions typically used during beef processing. Further, whole-genome sequencing of the isolates suggested LHR⁺E. coli are persisting in the chilled processing environment and that horizontal LHR transfer among E. coli isolates may take place.

Lactic Acid Resistance and Population Structure of Escherichia coli from Meat Processing Environment

To explore the effect of beef processing on Escherichia coli populations in relation to lactic acid resistance, this study investigated the links among acid response, phylogenetic structure, genome diversity, and genotypes associated with acid resistance of meat plant E. coli. Generic E. coli isolates (n = 700) were from carcasses, fabrication equipment, and beef products. Acid treatment was carried out in Luria-Bertani broth containing 5.5% lactic acid (pH 2.9). Log reductions of E. coli ranged from <0.5 to >5 log CFU/mL (median: 1.37 log). No difference in lactic acid resistance was observed between E. coli populations recovered before and after a processing step or antimicrobial interventions. E. coli from the preintervention carcasses were slightly more resistant than E. coli isolated from equipment, differing by <0.5 log unit. Acid-resistant E. coli (log reduction <1, n = 45) had a higher prevalence of genes related to energy metabolism (ydj, xap, ato) and oxidative stress (fec, ymjC) than the less resistant E. coli (log reduction >1, n = 133). The ydj and ato operons were abundant in E. coli from preintervention carcasses. In contrast, fec genes were abundant in E. coli from equipment surfaces. The preintervention E. coli contained phylogroups A and B1 in relatively equal proportions. Phylogroup B1 predominated (95%) in the population from equipment. Of note, E. coli collected after sanitation shared either the antigens of O8 or H21. Additionally, genome diversity decreased after chilling and equipment sanitation. Overall, beef processing did not select for E. coli resistant to lactic acid but shaped the population structure. IMPORTANCE Antimicrobial interventions have significantly reduced the microbial loads on carcasses/meat products; however, the wide use of chemical and physical biocides has raised concerns over their potential for selecting resistant populations in the beef processing environment. Phenotyping of acid resistance and whole-genome analysis described in this study demonstrated beef processing practices led to differences in acid resistance, genotype, and population structure between carcass- and equipment-associated E. coli but did not select for the acid-resistant population. Results indicate that genes coding for the metabolism of long-chain sugar acids (ydj) and short-chain fatty acids (ato) were more prevalent in carcass-associated than equipment-associated E. coli. These results suggest E. coli from carcasses and equipment surfaces have been exposed to different selective pressures. The findings improve our understanding of the microbial ecology of E. coli in food processing environments and in general.

Genetic Characteristics of the Transmissible Locus of Stress Tolerance (tLST) and tLST Harboring Escherichia coli as Revealed by Large-Scale Genomic Analysis

The transmissible locus of stress tolerance (tLST) confers resistance to multiple stresses in E. coli. Utilizing 18,959 E. coli genomes available in the NCBI database, we investigated the prevalence, phylogenetic distribution, and configuration patterns of tLST, and correlations between tLST, and virulence and antimicrobial resistance (AMR) genes in E. coli. Four tLST variants were found in 2.7% of E. coli, with the most prevalent (77.1%) variant being tLST1 followed by tLST2 (8.3%), tLST3b (8.3%) and tLST3a (6.3%). The majority (93%) of those tLST were in E. coli belonging to phylogroup A in which the prevalence was 10.4%. tLST was also found in phylogroup B1 (0.5%) and C (0.5%) but not found in B2 or D-G. An additional 1% of the 18,959 E. coli genomes harbored tLST fragments to various extent. Phylogenetic analysis revealed both intra- and interspecies transmission of both chromosomal and plasmid-borne tLST, with E. coli showing a preference of chromosomal over plasmid-borne tLST. The presence of tLST and virulence genes in E. coli was overall negatively correlated, but tLST was found in all genomes of a subgroup of enterotoxigenic E. coli (ST2332). Of note, no Shiga toxin-producing E. coli (n = 3,492) harbored tLST. The prevalence of tLST and AMR genes showed different temporal trends over the period 1985 to 2019. However, a substantial fraction of tLST positive E. coli harbor AMR genes, posing a threat to public health. In conclusion, this study improves our understanding of the genetic characteristics of tLST and E. coli harboring tLST. IMPORTANCE This study, through a large-scale genomic analysis, demonstrated that the genomic island tLST related to multiple stress resistance (such as extreme heat resistance and oxidative stress tolerance) in E. coli is differentially present in subgroups of E. coli and is strongly associated with certain phylogenetic background of the host strain. The study also shows the transmission mechanisms of tLST in E. coli and other bacterial species. The overall negative association of tLST, and virulence genes and antimicrobial (AMR) genes suggest the selective pressures for the acquisition and transmission of these traits likely differ. Even so, the high prevalence of tLST in the enterotoxigenic E. coli clone ST2332 and co-occurrence of tLST and AMR genes in E. coli are concerning. Thus, the findings better our understanding of tLST evolution and provide information for risk assessment of tLST harboring bacteria.

Resistance of biofilm- and pellicle-embedded strains of Escherichia coli encoding the transmissible locus of stress tolerance (tLST) to oxidative sanitation chemicals

Biofilm formation in food processing plants reduces the efficacy of sanitation. The presence of transmissible locus of stress tolerance (tLST) also enhances resistance of planktonic cells of Escherichia coli to sanitation chemicals but the role of tLST in resistance of biofilm-embedded cells remains unclear. This study investigated the link of tLST to biofilm formation and its contribution to resistance of biofilm-embedded E. coli to sanitation. Biofilms were formed as single-strain and as dual-strain biofilms in association with E. coli, Aeromonas australensis or Carnobacterium maltaromaticum. Biofilms on stainless steel were compared to floating biofilms formed at the air-liquid interface (pellicles). The resistance of biofilm-embedded tLST positive strains of E. coli to chlorine, hydrogen peroxide, and peroxyacetic acid was higher than the resistance of tLST negative strains. Higher biofilm density as measured by crystal violet staining was observed in tLST-positive strains of E. coli when compared to tLST negative strains. Biofilm density positively correlated to resistance to disinfectants. The use of confocal laser scanning microscopy detected more compact structure of pellicles compared to solid surface-attached biofilms, resulting in higher chlorine resistance despite the absence of tLST in strains of E. coli. Collectively, the findings of this study elucidated the impact of tLST in strains of E. coli on biofilm formation and sanitizer resistance. These findings may inform the development of improved sanitization protocols for food facilities.

Biofilm-Forming Capacity of Escherichia coli Isolated from Cattle and Beef Packing Plants: Relation to Virulence Attributes, Stage of Processing, Antimicrobial Interventions, and Heat Tolerance

Despite the importance of biofilm formation in the contamination of meat by pathogenic Escherichia coli at slaughter plants, drivers for biofilm remain unclear. To identify selection pressures for biofilm, we evaluated 745 isolates from cattle and 700 generic E. coli isolates from two beef slaughter plants for motility, the expression of curli and cellulose, and biofilm-forming potential. Cattle isolates were also screened for serogroup, stx₁, stx₂, eae, and rpoS. Generic E. coli isolates were compared by source (hide of carcass, hide-off carcass, and processing equipment) before and after the implementation of antimicrobial hurdles. The proportion of E. coli isolates capable of forming biofilms was lowest (7.1%; P < 0.05) for cattle isolates and highest (87.3%; P < 0.05) from equipment. Only one enterohemorrhagic E. coli (EHEC) isolate was an extremely strong biofilm former, in contrast to 73.4% of E. coli isolates from equipment. Isolates from equipment after sanitation had a greater biofilm-forming capacity (P < 0.001) than those before sanitation. Most cattle isolates were motile and expressed curli, although these traits along with the expression of cellulose and the detection of rpoS were not necessary for biofilm formation. In contrast, isolates capable of forming biofilms on equipment were almost exclusively motile and able to express curli. The results of the present study indicate that cattle rarely carry EHEC capable of making strong biofilms in slaughter plants. However, if biofilm-forming EHEC contaminates equipment, current sanitation procedures may not eliminate the most robust biofilm-forming strains. Accordingly, new and effective antibiofilm hurdles for meat-processing equipment are required to reduce future instances of foodborne disease. IMPORTANCE As the majority of enterohemorrhagic E. coli (EHEC) isolates are not capable of forming biofilms, sources were undetermined for biofilm-forming EHEC isolated from "high-event periods" in beef slaughter plants. This study demonstrated that sanitation procedures used on beef-processing equipment may inadvertently lead to the survival of robust biofilm-forming strains of E. coli. Cattle only rarely carry EHEC capable of forming strong biofilms (1/745 isolates evaluated), but isolates with greater biofilm-forming capacity were more likely (P < 0.001) to survive equipment sanitation. In contrast, chilling carcasses for 3 days at 0°C reduced (P < 0.05) the proportion of biofilm-forming E. coli. Consequently, an additional antibiofilm hurdle for meat-processing equipment, perhaps involving cold exposure, is necessary to further reduce the risk of foodborne disease.

Genomic and Phenotypic Analysis of Heat and Sanitizer Resistance in Escherichia coli from Beef in Relation to the Locus of Heat Resistance

The locus of heat resistance (LHR) can confer heat resistance to Escherichia coli to various extents. This study investigated the phylogenetic relationships and the genomic and phenotypic characteristics of E. coli with or without LHR recovered from beef by direct plating or from enrichment broth at 42°C. LHR-positive E. coli isolates (n = 24) were subjected to whole-genome sequencing by short and long reads. LHR-negative isolates (n = 18) from equivalent sources as LHR-positive isolates were short-read sequenced. All isolates were assessed for decimal reduction time at 60°C (D_60°C) and susceptibility to the sanitizers E-SAN and Perox-E. Selected isolates were evaluated for growth at 42°C. The LHR-positive and -negative isolates were well separated on the core genome tree, with 22/24 positive isolates clustering into three clades. Isolates within clade 1 and 2, despite their different D_60°C values, were clonal, as determined by subtyping (multilocus sequence typing [MLST], core genome MLST, and serotyping). Isolates within each clade are of one serotype. The LHR-negative isolates were genetically diverse. The LHR-positive isolates had a larger (P < 0.001) median genome size by 0.3 Mbp (5.0 versus 4.7 Mbp) and overrepresentation of genes related to plasmid maintenance, stress response, and cryptic prophages but underrepresentation of genes involved in epithelial attachment and virulence. All LHR-positive isolates harbored a chromosomal copy of LHR, and all clade 2 isolates had an additional partial copy of LHR on conjugative plasmids. The growth rates at 42°C were 0.71 ± 0.02 and 0.65 ± 0.02 log(OD) h^-1 for LHR-positive and -negative isolates, respectively. No meaningful difference in sanitizer susceptibility was noted between LHR-positive and -negative isolates. IMPORTANCE Resistant bacteria are serious food safety and public health concerns. Heat resistance conferred by the LHR varies largely among different strains of E. coli. The findings in this study show that genomic background and composition of LHR, in addition to the presence of LHR, play an important role in the degree of heat resistance in E. coli and that strains with certain genetic backgrounds are more likely to acquire and maintain the LHR. Also, caution should be exercised when recovering E. coli at elevated temperatures, as the presence of LHR may confer growth advantages to some strains. Interestingly, the LHR-harboring strains seem to have evolved further from their primary animal host to adapt to their secondary habitat, as reflected by fewer genes involved in virulence and epithelial attachment. The phylogenetic relationships among the isolates point toward multiple mechanisms for acquisition of LHR by E. coli, likely prior to its being deposited on meat.

Inconsistent PCR detection of Shiga toxin-producing Escherichia coli: Insights from whole genome sequence analyses

Shiga toxin-producing Escherichia coli (STEC) have been linked to food-borne disease outbreaks. As PCR is routinely used to screen foods for STEC, it is important that factors leading to inconsistent detection of STEC by PCR are understood. This study used whole genome sequencing (WGS) to investigate causes of inconsistent PCR detection of stx1, stx2, and serogroup-specific genes. Fifty strains isolated from Alberta feedlot cattle from three different studies were selected with inconsistent or consistent detection of stx and serogroup by PCR. All isolates were initially classified as STEC by PCR. Sequencing was performed using Illumina MiSeq® with sample library by Nextera XT. Virtual PCRs were performed using Geneious and bacteriophage content was determined using PHASTER. Sequencing coverage ranged from 47 to 102x, averaging 74x, with sequences deposited in the NCBI database. Eleven strains were confirmed by WGS as STEC having complete stxA and stxB subunits. However, truncated stx fragments occurred in twenty-two other isolates, some having multiple stx fragments in the genome. Isolates with complete stx by WGS had consistent stx1 and stx2 detection by PCR, although one also having a stx2 fragment had inconsistent stx2 PCR. For all STEC and 18/39 non-STEC, serogroups determined by PCR agreed with those determined by WGS. An additional three WGS serotypes were inconclusive and two isolates were Citrobacter spp. Results demonstrate that stx fragments associated with stx-carrying bacteriophages in the E. coli genome may contribute to inconsistent detection of stx1 and stx2 by PCR. Fourteen isolates had integrated stx bacteriophage but lacked complete or fragmentary stx possibly due to partial bacteriophage excision after sub-cultivation or other unclear mechanisms. The majority of STEC isolates (7/11) did not have identifiable bacteriophage DNA in the contig(s) where stx was located, likely increasing the stability of stx in the bacterial genome and its detection by PCR.

Horizontal Transmission of Stress Resistance Genes Shape the Ecology of Beta- and Gamma-Proteobacteria

The transmissible locus of stress tolerance (tLST) is found mainly in beta- and gamma-Proteobacteria and confers tolerance to elevated temperature, pressure, and chlorine. This genomic island, previously referred to as transmissible locus of protein quality control or locus of heat resistance likely originates from an environmental bacterium thriving in extreme habitats, but has been widely transmitted by lateral gene transfer. Although highly conserved, the gene content on the island is subject to evolution and gene products such as small heat shock proteins are present in several functionally distinct sequence variants. A number of these genes are xenologs of core genome genes with the gene products to widen the substrate spectrum and to be highly (complementary) expressed thus their functionality to become dominant over core genome genes. In this review, we will present current knowledge of the function of core tLST genes and discuss current knowledge on selection and counter-selection processes that favor maintenance of the tLST island, with frequent acquisition of gene products involved in cyclic di-GMP signaling, in different habitats from the environment to animals and plants, processed animal and plant products, man-made environments, and subsequently humans.