Industrially Applicable De Novo Lager Yeast Hybrids with a Unique Genomic Architecture: Creation and Characterization

Understanding brewing trait inheritance in de novo Lager yeast hybrids

Hybridization between Saccharomyces cerevisiae and Saccharomyces eubayanus resulted in the emergence of S. pastorianus, a crucial yeast for lager fermentation. However, our understanding of hybridization success and hybrid vigor between these two species remains limited due to the scarcity of S. eubayanus parental strains. Here, we explore hybridization success and the impact of hybridization on fermentation performance and volatile compound profiles in newly formed lager hybrids. By selecting parental candidates spanning a diverse array of lineages from both species, we reveal that the Beer and PB-2 lineages exhibit high rates of hybridization success in S. cerevisiae and S. eubayanus, respectively. Polyploid hybrids were generated through a spontaneous diploid hybridization technique (rare-mating), revealing a prevalence of triploids and diploids over tetraploids. Despite the absence of heterosis in fermentative capacity, hybrids displayed phenotypic variability, notably influenced by maltotriose consumption. Interestingly, ploidy levels did not significantly correlate with fermentative capacity, although triploids exhibited greater phenotypic variability. The S. cerevisiae parental lineages primarily influenced volatile compound profiles, with significant differences in aroma production. Interestingly, hybrids emerging from the Beer S. cerevisiae parental lineages exhibited a volatile compound profile resembling the corresponding S. eubayanus parent. This pattern may result from the dominant inheritance of the S. eubayanus aroma profile, as suggested by the over-expression of genes related to alcohol metabolism and acetate synthesis in hybrids including the Beer S. cerevisiae lineage. Our findings suggest complex interactions between parental lineages and hybridization outcomes, highlighting the potential for creating yeasts with distinct brewing traits through hybridization strategies.

IMPORTANCE

Our study investigates the principles of lager yeast hybridization between Saccharomyces cerevisiae and Saccharomyces eubayanus. This process gave rise to the lager yeast Saccharomyces pastorianus. By examining how these novel hybrids perform during fermentation and the aromas they produce, we uncover the genetic bases of brewing trait inheritance. We successfully generated polyploid hybrids using diverse strains and lineages from both parent species, predominantly triploids and diploids. Although these hybrids did not show improved fermentation capacity, they exhibited varied traits, especially in utilizing maltotriose, a key sugar in brewing. Remarkably, the aroma profiles of these hybrids were primarily influenced by the S. cerevisiae parent, with Beer lineage hybrids adopting aroma characteristics from their S. eubayanus parent. These insights reveal the complex genetic interactions in hybrid yeasts, opening new possibilities for crafting unique brewing yeasts with desirable traits.

Modifying flavor profiles of Saccharomyces spp. for industrial brewing using FIND-IT, a non-GMO approach for metabolic engineering of yeast

Species of Saccharomyces genus have played an irreplaceable role in alcoholic beverage and baking industry for centuries. S. cerevisiae has also become an organism of choice for industrial production of alcohol and other valuable chemicals and a model organism shaping the rise of modern genetics and genomics in the past few decades. Today´s brewing industry faces challenges of decreasing consumption of traditional beer styles and increasing consumer demand for new styles, flavors and aromas. The number of currently used brewer's strains and their genetic diversity is yet limited and implementation of more genetic and phenotypic variation is seen as a solution to cope with the market challenges. This requires modification of current production strains or introduction of novel strains from other settings, e.g. industrial or wild habitats into the brewing industry. Due to legal regulation in many countries and negative customer perception of GMO organisms, the production of food and beverages requires non-GMO production organisms, whose development can be difficult and time-consuming. Here, we apply FIND-IT (Fast Identification of Nucleotide variants by DigITal PCR), an ultrafast genome-mining method, for isolation of novel yeast variants with varying flavor profiles. The FIND-IT method uses combination of random mutagenesis, droplet digital PCR with probes that target a specific desired mutation and a sub-isolation of the mutant clone. Such an approach allows the targeted identification and isolation of specific mutant strains with eliminated production of certain flavor and off-flavors and/or changes in the strain metabolism. We demonstrate that the technology is useful for the identification of loss-of function or gain of function mutations in unrelated industrial and wild strains differing in ploidy. Where no other phenotypic selection exists, this technology serves together with standard breeding techniques as a modern tool facilitating a modification of (brewer's) yeast strains leading to diversification of the product portfolio.

Evaluating the Genome-Based Average Nucleotide Identity Calculation for Identification of Twelve Yeast Species

Classifying a yeast strain into a recognized species is not always straightforward. Currently, the taxonomic delineation of yeast strains involves multiple approaches covering phenotypic characteristics and molecular methodologies, including genome-based analysis. The aim of this study was to evaluate the suitability of the Average Nucleotide Identity (ANI) calculation through FastANI, a tool created for bacterial species identification, for the assignment of strains to some yeast species. FastANI, the alignment of in silico-extracted D1/D2 sequences of LSU rRNA, and multiple alignments of orthologous genes (MAOG) were employed to analyze 644 assemblies from 12 yeast genera, encompassing various species, and on a dataset of hybrid Saccharomyces species. Overall, the analysis showed high consistency between results obtained with FastANI and MAOG, although, FastANI proved to be more discriminating than the other two methods applied to genomic sequences. In particular, FastANI was effective in distinguishing between strains belonging to different species, defining clear boundaries between them (cutoff: 94-96%). Our results show that FastANI is a reliable method for attributing a known yeast species to a particular strain. Moreover, although hybridization events make species discrimination more complex, it was revealed to be useful in the identification of these cases. We suggest its inclusion as a key component in a comprehensive approach to species delineation. Using this approach with a larger number of yeasts would validate it as a rapid technique to identify yeasts based on whole genome sequences.

Assess different fermentation characteristics of 54 lager yeasts based on group classification

Saccharomyces pastorianus, hybrids of Saccharomyces cerevisiae and Saccharomyces eubayanus, were generally regarded as authentic lager beer yeasts. In recent years, with more new findings of other Saccharomyces genus hybrids, yeasts used in lager beer brewing have been proved much more complicated than previous cognition. In this study, we analyzed the different fermentation characteristics of 54 yeast strains used for lager brewing in normal and very high gravity brewing based on group classification. The difference between Group Ⅰ and Group Ⅱ lager yeasts were more striking in very high gravity brewing. However, during our research progress, we realized that some yeasts used in this study were actually hybrids of S. cerevisiae and Saccharomyces kudriavzevii. Features of these hybrids could be beneficial to very high gravity brewing. We further discussed about the mechanism behind their outstanding characteristics and the reason why group classification methods of lager beer yeasts had limitations. Hybridization in yeasts is constantly getting richer. Lager yeasts could have more possibilities based on better understandings of their genetic background and roles of other Saccharomyces genus hybrids. Their heterosis shed light on innovation in brewing and other diverse fermentation industries.

Improving CRISPR-Cas9 mediated genome integration in interspecific hybrid yeasts

Saccharomyces pastorianus is not a classical taxon, it is an interspecific hybrid resulting from the cross of Saccharomyces cerevisiae and Saccharomyces eubayanus. Exhibiting heterosis for phenotypic traits such as wort α-oligosaccharide consumption and fermentation at low temperature, it has been domesticated to become the main workhorse of the brewing industry. Although CRISPR-Cas9 has been shown to be functional in S. pastorianus, repair of CRISPR- induced double strand break is unpredictable and preferentially uses the homoeologous chromosome as template, preventing targeted introduction of the desired repair construct. Here, we demonstrate that lager hybrids can be edited with near 100% efficiency at carefully selected landing sites on the chimeric SeScCHRIII. The landing sites were systematically selected and evaluated for (i) absence of loss of heterozygosity upon CRISPR-editing, (ii) efficiency of the gRNA, and (iii) absence of effect on strain physiology. Successful examples of highly efficient single and double gene integration illustrated that genome editing can be applied in interspecies hybrids, paving the way to a new impulse to lager yeast strain development. DATA AVAILABILITY: Data underlying graphs and figures found in this manuscript are deposited at the 4TU research dat center (https://data.4tu.nl/info/en/) and available through the doi: 10.4121/21648329.

The genome sequence of the Champagne Epernay Geisenheim wine yeast reveals its hybrid nature

Lager yeasts are hybrids between Saccharomyces cerevisiae and S. eubayanus. Wine yeast biodiversity, however, has only recently been discovered to include besides pure S. cerevisiae strains also hybrids between different Saccharomyces yeasts as well as introgressions from non-Saccharomyces species. Here, we analysed the genome of the Champagne Epernay Geisenheim (CEG) wine yeast. This yeast is an allotetraploid (4n - 1) hybrid of S. cerevisiae harbouring a substantially reduced S. kudriavzevii genome contributing only 1/3 of a full genome equivalent. We identified a novel oligopeptide transporter gene, FOT4, in CEG located on chromosome XVI. FOT genes were originally derived from Torulaspora microellipsoides and FOT4 arose by non-allelic recombination between adjacent FOT1 and FOT2 genes. Fermentations of CEG in Riesling and Müller-Thurgau musts were compared with the S. cerevisiae Geisenheim wine yeast GHM, which does not carry FOT genes. At low temperature (10°C), CEG completed fermentations faster and produced increased levels of higher alcohols (e.g. isoamyl alcohol). At higher temperature (18°C), CEG produced higher amounts of the pineapple-like alkyl esters i-butyric and propionic acid ethyl esters compared to GHM. The hybrid nature of CEG thus provides advantages in grape must fermentations over S. cerevisiae wine yeasts, especially with regard to aroma production.

Compensatory Genetic and Transcriptional Cytonuclear Coordination in Allopolyploid Lager Yeast (Saccharomyces pastorianus)

Cytonuclear coordination between biparental-nuclear genomes and uniparental-cytoplasmic organellar genomes in plants is often resolved by genetic and transcriptional cytonuclear responses. Whether this mechanism also acts in allopolyploid members of other kingdoms is not clear. Additionally, cytonuclear coordination of interleaved allopolyploid cells/individuals within the same population is underexplored. The yeast Saccharomyces pastorianus provides the opportunity to explore cytonuclear coevolution during different growth stages and from novel dimensions. Using S. pastorianus cells from multiple growth stages in the same environment, we show that nuclear mitochondria-targeted genes have undergone both asymmetric gene conversion and growth stage-specific biased expression favoring genes from the mitochondrial genome donor (Saccharomyces eubayanus). Our results suggest that cytonuclear coordination in allopolyploid lager yeast species entails an orchestrated and compensatory genetic and transcriptional evolutionary regulatory shift. The common as well as unique properties of cytonuclear coordination underlying allopolyploidy between unicellular yeasts and higher plants offers novel insights into mechanisms of cytonuclear evolution associated with allopolyploid speciation.

The evolutionary and ecological potential of yeast hybrids

Recent findings in yeast genetics and genomics have advanced our understanding of the evolutionary potential unlocked by hybridization, especially in the genus Saccharomyces. We now have a clearer picture of the prevalence of yeast hybrids in the environment, their ecological and evolutionary history, and the genetic mechanisms driving (and constraining) their adaptation. Here, we describe how the instability of hybrid genomes determines fitness across large evolutionary scales, highlight new hybrid strain engineering techniques, and review tools for comparative hybrid genome analysis. The recent push to take yeast research back 'into the wild' has resulted in new genomic and ecological resources. These provide an arena for quantitative genetics and allow us to investigate the architecture of complex traits and mechanisms of adaptation to rapidly changing environments. The vast genetic diversity of hybrid populations can yield insights beyond those possible with isogenic lines. Hybrids offer a limitless supply of genetic variation that can be tapped for industrial strain improvement but also, combined with experimental evolution, can be used to predict population responses to future climate change - a fundamental task for biologists.

Patterns of Genomic Instability in Interspecific Yeast Hybrids With Diverse Ancestries

The genomes of hybrids often show substantial deviations from the features of the parent genomes, including genomic instabilities characterized by chromosomal rearrangements, gains, and losses. This plastic genomic architecture generates phenotypic diversity, potentially giving hybrids access to new ecological niches. It is however unclear if there are any generalizable patterns and predictability in the type and prevalence of genomic variation and instability across hybrids with different genetic and ecological backgrounds. Here, we analyzed the genomic architecture of 204 interspecific Saccharomyces yeast hybrids isolated from natural, industrial fermentation, clinical, and laboratory environments. Synchronous mapping to all eight putative parental species showed significant variation in read depth indicating frequent aneuploidy, affecting 44% of all hybrid genomes and particularly smaller chromosomes. Early generation hybrids with largely equal genomic content from both parent species were more likely to contain aneuploidies than introgressed genomes with an older hybridization history, which presumably stabilized the genome. Shared k-mer analysis showed that the degree of genomic diversity and variability varied among hybrids with different parent species. Interestingly, more genetically distant crosses produced more similar hybrid genomes, which may be a result of stronger negative epistasis at larger genomic divergence, putting constraints on hybridization outcomes. Mitochondrial genomes were typically inherited from the species also contributing the majority nuclear genome, but there were clear exceptions to this rule. Together, we find reliable genomic predictors of instability in hybrids, but also report interesting cross- and environment-specific idiosyncrasies. Our results are an important step in understanding the factors shaping divergent hybrid genomes and their role in adaptive evolution.

Lager Yeast Design Through Meiotic Segregation of a Saccharomyces cerevisiae × Saccharomyces eubayanus Hybrid

Yeasts in the lager brewing group are closely related and consequently do not exhibit significant genetic variability. Here, an artificial Saccharomyces cerevisiae × Saccharomyces eubayanus tetraploid interspecies hybrid was created by rare mating, and its ability to sporulate and produce viable gametes was exploited to generate phenotypic diversity. Four spore clones obtained from a single ascus were isolated, and their brewing-relevant phenotypes were assessed. These F1 spore clones were found to differ with respect to fermentation performance under lager brewing conditions (15°C, 15 °Plato), production of volatile aroma compounds, flocculation potential and temperature tolerance. One spore clone, selected for its rapid fermentation and acetate ester production was sporulated to produce an F2 generation, again comprised of four spore clones from a single ascus. Again, phenotypic diversity was introduced. In two of these F2 clones, the fermentation performance was maintained and acetate ester production was improved relative to the F1 parent and the original hybrid strain. Strains also performed well in comparison to a commercial lager yeast strain. Spore clones varied in ploidy and chromosome copy numbers, and faster wort fermentation was observed in strains with a higher ploidy. An F2 spore clone was also subjected to 10 consecutive wort fermentations, and single cells were isolated from the resulting yeast slurry. These isolates also exhibited variable fermentation performance and chromosome copy numbers, highlighting the instability of polyploid interspecific hybrids. These results demonstrate the value of this natural approach to increase the phenotypic diversity of lager brewing yeast strains.

Potential for Lager Beer Production from Saccharomyces cerevisiae Strains Isolated from the Vineyard Environment

Saccharomyces pastorianus, genetic hybrids of Saccharomyces cerevisiae and the Saccharomyces eubayanus, is one of the most widely used lager yeasts in the brewing industry. In recent years, new strategies have been adopted and new lines of research have been outlined to create and expand the pool of lager brewing starters. The vineyard microbiome has received significant attention in the past few years due to many opportunities in terms of biotechnological applications in the winemaking processes. However, the characterization of S. cerevisiae strains isolated from winery environments as an approach to selecting starters for beer production has not been fully investigated, and little is currently available. Four wild cryotolerant S. cerevisiae strains isolated from vineyard environments were evaluated as potential starters for lager beer production at laboratory scale using a model beer wort (MBW). In all tests, the industrial lager brewing S. pastorianus Weihenstephan 34/70 was used as a reference strain. The results obtained, although preliminary, showed some good properties of these strains, such as antioxidant activity, flocculation capacity, efficient fermentation at 15 °C and low diacetyl production. Further studies will be carried out using these S. cerevisiae strains as starters for lager beer production on a pilot scale in order to verify the chemical and sensory characteristics of the beers produced.

Improving the Utilization of Isomaltose and Panose by Lager Yeast Saccharomyces pastorianus

Approximately 25% of all carbohydrates in industrial worts are poorly, if at all, fermented by brewing yeast. This includes dextrins, β-glucans, arabinose, xylose, disaccharides such as isomaltose, nigerose, kojibiose, and trisaccharides such as panose and isopanose. As the efficient utilization of carbohydrates during the wort’s fermentation impacts the alcohol yield and the organoleptic traits of the product, developing brewing strains with enhanced abilities to ferment subsets of these sugars is highly desirable. In this study, we developed Saccharomyces pastorianus laboratory yeast strains with a superior capacity to grow on isomaltose and panose. First, we designed a plasmid toolbox for the stable integration of genes into lager strains. Next, we used the toolbox to elevate the levels of the α-glucoside transporter Agt1 and the major isomaltase Ima1. This was achieved by integrating synthetic AGT1 and IMA1 genes under the control of strong constitutive promoters into defined genomic sites. As a result, strains carrying both genes showed a superior capacity to grow on panose and isomaltose, indicating that Ima1 and Agt1 act in synergy to consume these sugars. Our study suggests that non-GMO strategies aiming to develop strains with improved isomaltose and panose utilization could include identifying strains that overexpress AGT1 and IMA1.