TolC-dependent modulation of host cell death by the Francisella tularensis live vaccine strain

Francisella tularensis disrupts TLR2-MYD88-p38 signaling early during infection to delay apoptosis of macrophages and promote virulence in the host

Francisella tularensis is a zoonotic pathogen and the causative agent of tularemia. F. tularensis replicates to high levels within the cytosol of macrophages and other host cells while subverting the host response to infection. Critical to the success of F. tularensis is its ability to delay macrophage apoptosis to maintain its intracellular replicative niche. However, the host-signaling pathway(s) modulated by F. tularensis to delay apoptosis are poorly characterized. The outer membrane channel protein TolC is required for F. tularensis virulence and its ability to suppress apoptosis and cytokine expression during infection of macrophages. We took advantage of the F. tularensis ∆tolC mutant phenotype to identify host pathways that are important for activating macrophage apoptosis and that are disrupted by the bacteria. Comparison of macrophages infected with wild-type or ∆tolC F. tularensis revealed that the bacteria interfere with TLR2-MYD88-p38 signaling at early times post infection to delay apoptosis, dampen innate host responses, and preserve the intracellular replicative niche. Experiments using the mouse pneumonic tularemia model confirmed the in vivo relevance of these findings, revealing contributions of TLR2 and MYD88 signaling to the protective host response to F. tularensis, which is modulated by the bacteria to promote virulence. IMPORTANCE Francisella tularensis is a Gram-negative intracellular bacterial pathogen and the causative agent of the zoonotic disease tularemia. F. tularensis, like other intracellular pathogens, modulates host-programmed cell death pathways to ensure its replication and survival. We previously identified the outer membrane channel protein TolC as required for the ability of F. tularensis to delay host cell death. However, the mechanism by which F. tularensis delays cell death pathways during intracellular replication is unclear despite being critical to pathogenesis. In the present study, we address this gap in knowledge by taking advantage of ∆tolC mutants of F. tularensis to uncover signaling pathways governing host apoptotic responses to F. tularensis and which are modulated by the bacteria during infection to promote virulence. These findings reveal mechanisms by which intracellular pathogens subvert host responses and enhance our understanding of the pathogenesis of tularemia.

Contributions of TolC Orthologs to Francisella tularensis Schu S4 Multidrug Resistance, Modulation of Host Cell Responses, and Virulence

Francisella tularensis is a Gram-negative, facultative intracellular pathogen and the causative agent of tularemia. Previous studies with the attenuated live vaccine strain (LVS) identified a role for the outer membrane protein TolC in modulation of host cell responses during infection and virulence in the mouse model of tularemia. TolC is an integral part of efflux pumps that export small molecules and type I secretion systems that export a range of bacterial virulence factors. In this study, we analyzed TolC and its two orthologs, FtlC and SilC, present in the fully virulent F. tularensis Schu S4 strain for their contributions to multidrug efflux, suppression of innate immune responses, and virulence. We found that each TolC ortholog participated in multidrug efflux, with overlapping substrate specificities for TolC and FtlC and a distinct substrate profile for SilC. In contrast to their shared roles in drug efflux, only TolC functioned in the modulation of macrophage apoptotic and proinflammatory responses to Schu S4 infection, consistent with a role in virulence factor delivery to host cells. In agreement with previous results with the LVS, the Schu S4 ΔtolC mutant was highly attenuated for virulence in mice by both the intranasal and intradermal routes of infection. Unexpectedly, FtlC was also critical for Schu S4 virulence, but only by the intradermal route. Our data demonstrate a conserved and critical role for TolC in modulation of host immune responses and Francisella virulence and also highlight strain- and route-dependent differences in the pathogenesis of tularemia.

Temporal Manipulation of Mitochondrial Function by Virulent Francisella tularensis To Limit Inflammation and Control Cell Death

Francisella tularensis subsp. tularensis is a highly pathogenic intracellular bacterium that suppresses host inflammation by impairing the metabolic shift from oxidative phosphorylation to glycolysis. Decreased mitochondrial metabolism is central to initiating a metabolic shift to glycolysis and regulating inflammation, but F. tularensis subsp. tularensis manipulation of host mitochondrial function has not been explored. We demonstrate, using extracellular flux analysis, that F. tularensis subsp. tularensis infection initially improves host macrophage mitochondrial bioenergetics in a capsule-dependent manner. Enhancement of mitochondrial function by F. tularensis subsp. tularensis allowed for modest replication and inhibition of apoptosis early after infection. However, using live cell imaging, we found that F. tularensis subsp. tularensis facilitated the loss of mitochondrial function at later time points during infection in a capsule-independent fashion. This loss of function was paired with oncosis and rapid bacterial replication. Inhibition of oncosis reduced intracellular bacterial numbers, underscoring the requirement for this process during F. tularensis subsp. tularensis infection. These findings establish that temporal mitochondrial manipulation by F. tularensis subsp. tularensis is critical for maintenance of a noninflammatory environment and subsequently aids in optimal replication and dissemination of this pathogenic organism.

Phagocytes from Mice Lacking the Sts Phosphatases Have an Enhanced Antifungal Response to Candida albicans

Mice lacking expression of the homologous phosphatases Sts-1 and Sts-2 (Sts^−/− mice) are resistant to disseminated candidiasis caused by the fungal pathogen Candida albicans. To better understand the immunological mechanisms underlying the enhanced resistance of Sts^−/− mice, we examined the kinetics of fungal clearance at early time points. In contrast to the rapid C. albicans growth seen in normal kidneys during the first 24 h postinfection, we observed a reduction in kidney fungal CFU within Sts^−/− mice beginning at 12 to 18 h postinfection. This corresponds to the time period when large numbers of innate leukocytes enter the renal environment to counter the infection. Because phagocytes of the innate immune system are important for host protection against pathogenic fungi, we evaluated responses of bone marrow leukocytes. Relative to wild-type cells, Sts^−/− marrow monocytes and bone marrow-derived dendritic cells (BMDCs) displayed a heightened ability to inhibit C. albicans growth ex vivo. This correlated with significantly enhanced production of reactive oxygen species (ROS) by Sts^−/− BMDCs downstream of Dectin-1, a C-type lectin receptor that plays a critical role in stimulating host responses to fungi. We observed no visible differences in the responses of other antifungal effector pathways, including cytokine production and inflammasome activation, despite enhanced activation of the Syk tyrosine kinase downstream of Dectin-1 in Sts^−/− cells. Our results highlight a novel mechanism regulating the immune response to fungal infections. Further understanding of this regulatory pathway could aid the development of therapeutic approaches to enhance protection against invasive candidiasis.

Systemic candidiasis caused by fungal Candida species is becoming an increasingly serious medical problem for which current treatment is inadequate. Recently, the Sts phosphatases were established as key regulators of the host antifungal immune response. In particular, genetic inactivation of Sts significantly enhanced survival of mice infected intravenously with Candida albicans. The Sts^−/−in vivo resistance phenotype is associated with reduced fungal burden and an absence of inflammatory lesions. To understand the underlying mechanisms, we studied phagocyte responses. Here, we demonstrate that Sts^−/− phagocytes have heightened responsiveness to C. albicans challenge relative to wild-type cells. Our data indicate the Sts proteins negatively regulate phagocyte activation via regulating selective elements of the Dectin-1–Syk tyrosine kinase signaling axis. These results suggest that phagocytes lacking Sts respond to fungal challenge more effectively and that this enhanced responsiveness partially underlies the profound resistance of Sts^−/− mice to systemic fungal challenge.

RtxA like protein contributes to infection of Francisella novicida in silkworm and human macrophage THP-1

Tularemia is a zoonosis caused by CDC-declared Tier 1 threat agent Francisella tularensis. F. tularensis subsp. novicida (F. novicida) is virulent in mice but non-pathogenic in immunocompetent humans and serves as a potential surrogate organism. In a recent study, we established a silkworm (Bombyx mori) model of infection for F. novicida. Francisella secretes its virulence factors through various mechanisms that modify the intracellular environment to ensure its replication and survival. To identify new pathogenic factors, we focused on the type I secretory system (T1SS) of Francisella. In silico analysis revealed a RtxA (Repeats-in-toxin) like protein in the Francisella genome. The characteristics of RtxA like protein were investigated using mutant analysis. Firstly, the role of rtxA in silkworms was investigated by infecting them with F. novicida strains into the hemocoel. The rtxA mutant failed to kill the silkworms, whereas F. novicida wild-type (WT) strain killed silkworms within 3-7 days post infection. The arrested growth of the mutant strain in silkworms was observed using a whole-body CFU count assay. We also investigated the growth characteristics of the rtxA mutant in hemocytes, one of the primary multiplication sites of Francisella within silkworms. Interrupted growth of the rtxA mutant with significantly reduced cytotoxicity was observed in hemocytes via confocal microscopy. Next, we analyzed the effect of rtxA in human monocyte cell line THP-1. The mutant strain showed significantly decreased growth and reduced cytotoxicity compared with its parental strain in THP-1 cells. This study newly identified RtxA like protein of F. novicida as an important lethal pathogenic factor in silkworm and mammalian cells.

Characterization of a Unique Outer Membrane Protein Required for Oxidative Stress Resistance and Virulence of Francisella tularensis

Francisella tularensis, the causative agent of tularemia, lacks typical bacterial virulence factors and toxins but still exhibits extreme virulence. The bacterial multidrug efflux systems consist of an inner membrane, a transmembrane membrane fusion protein, and an outer membrane (OM) component that form a contiguous channel for the secretion of a multitude of bacterial products. Francisella contains three orthologs of the OM proteins; two of these, termed TolC and FtlC, are important for tularemia pathogenesis. The third OM protein, SilC, is homologous to the silver cation efflux protein of other bacterial pathogens. The silC gene (FTL_0686) is located on an operon encoding an Emr-type multidrug efflux pump of F. tularensis The role of SilC in tularemia pathogenesis is not known. In this study, we investigated the role of SilC in secretion and virulence of F. tularensis by generating a silC gene deletion (ΔsilC) mutant and its transcomplemented strain. Our results demonstrate that the ΔsilC mutant exhibits increased sensitivity to antibiotics, oxidants, silver, diminished intramacrophage growth, and attenuated virulence in mice compared to wild-type F. tularensis However, the secretion of antioxidant enzymes of F. tularensis is not impaired in the ΔsilC mutant. The virulence of the ΔsilC mutant is restored in NADPH oxidase-deficient mice, indicating that SilC resists oxidative stress in vivo Collectively, this study demonstrates that the OM component SilC serves a specialized role in virulence of F. tularensis by conferring resistance against oxidative stress and silver.IMPORTANCEFrancisella tularensis, the causative agent of a fatal human disease known as tularemia, is a category A select agent and a potential bioterror agent. The virulence mechanisms of Francisella are not completely understood. This study investigated the role of a unique outer membrane protein, SilC, of a multidrug efflux pump in the virulence of F. tularensis This is the first report demonstrating that the OM component SilC plays an important role in efflux of silver and contributes to the virulence of F. tularensis primarily by providing resistance against oxidative stress. Characterization of these unique virulence mechanisms will provide an understanding of the pathogenesis of tularemia and identification of potential targets for the development of effective therapeutics and prophylactics for protection from this lethal disease.

Bacterial lipoproteins and other factors released by Francisella tularensis modulate human neutrophil lifespan: Effects of a TLR1 SNP on apoptosis inhibition

Francisella tularensis infects several cell types including neutrophils, and aberrant neutrophil accumulation contributes to tissue destruction during tularaemia. We demonstrated previously that F. tularensis strains Schu S4 and live vaccine strain markedly delay human neutrophil apoptosis and thereby prolong cell lifespan, but the bacterial factors that mediate this aspect of virulence are undefined. Herein, we demonstrate that bacterial conditioned medium (CM) can delay apoptosis in the absence of direct infection. Biochemical analyses show that CM contained F. tularensis surface factors as well as outer membrane components. Our previous studies excluded roles for lipopolysaccharide and capsule in apoptosis inhibition, and current studies of [¹⁴C] acetate‐labelled bacteria argue against a role for other bacterial lipids in this process. At the same time, studies of isogenic mutants indicate that TolC and virulence factors whose expression requires FevR or MglA were also dispensable, demonstrating that apoptosis inhibition does not require Type I or Type VI secretion. Instead, we identified bacterial lipoproteins (BLPs) as active factors in CM. Additional studies of isolated BLPs demonstrated dose‐dependent neutrophil apoptosis inhibition via a TLR2‐dependent mechanism that is significantly influenced by a common polymorphism, rs5743618, in human TLR1. These data provide fundamental new insight into pathogen manipulation of neutrophil lifespan and BLP function.

Necroptotic debris including damaged mitochondria elicits sepsis-like syndrome during late-phase tularemia

Infection with Francisella tularensis ssp. tularensis (Ft) strain SchuS4 causes an often lethal disease known as tularemia in rodents, non-human primates, and humans. Ft subverts host cell death programs to facilitate their exponential replication within macrophages and other cell types during early respiratory infection (⩽72 h). The mechanism(s) by which cell death is triggered remains incompletely defined, as does the impact of Ft on mitochondria, the host cell’s organellar ‘canary in a coal mine’. Herein, we reveal that Ft infection of host cells, particularly macrophages and polymorphonuclear leukocytes, drives necroptosis via a receptor-interacting protein kinase 1/3-mediated mechanism. During necroptosis mitochondria and other organelles become damaged. Ft-induced mitochondrial damage is characterized by: (i) a decrease in membrane potential and consequent mitochondrial oncosis or swelling, (ii) increased generation of superoxide radicals, and (iii) release of intact or damaged mitochondria into the lung parenchyma. Host cell recognition of and response to released mitochondria and other damage-associated molecular patterns engenders a sepsis-like syndrome typified by production of TNF, IL-1β, IL-6, IL-12p70, and IFN-γ during late-phase tularemia (⩾72 h), but are absent early during infection.

Complement C3 as a Prompt for Human Macrophage Death during Infection with Francisella tularensis Strain SCHU S4

Tularemia is caused by the Gram-negative bacterial pathogen Francisella tularensis Infection of macrophages and their subsequent death are believed to play important roles in the progression of disease. Because complement is a particularly effective opsonin for Francisella, we asked whether complement-dependent uptake of F. tularensis strain SCHU S4 affects the survival of primary human macrophages during infection. Complement component C3 was found to be an essential opsonin in human serum not only for greatly increased uptake of SCHU S4 but also for the induction of macrophage death. Single-cell analysis also revealed that macrophage death did not require a high intracellular bacterial burden. In the presence of C3, macrophage death was observed at 24 h postinfection in a quarter of the macrophages that contained only 1 to 5 bacterial cells. Macrophages infected in the absence of C3 rarely underwent cell death, even when they contained large numbers of bacteria. The need for C3, but not extensive replication of the pathogen, was confirmed by infections with SCHU S4 ΔpurMCD, a mutant capable of phagosome escape but of only limited cytosolic replication. C3-dependent Francisella uptake alone was insufficient to induce macrophage death, as evidenced by the failure of the phagosome escape-deficient mutant SCHU S4 ΔfevR to induce cell death despite opsonization with C3. Together, these findings indicate that recognition of C3-opsonized F. tularensis, but not extensive cytosolic replication, plays an important role in regulating macrophage viability during intracellular infections with type A F. tularensis.

Increased Resistance to Intradermal Francisella tularensis LVS Infection by Inactivation of the Sts Phosphatases

The Suppressor of TCR signaling proteins (Sts-1 and Sts-2) are two homologous phosphatases that negatively regulate signaling pathways in a number of hematopoietic lineages, including T lymphocytes. Mice lacking Sts expression are characterized by enhanced T cell responses. Additionally, a recent study demonstrated that Sts^-/- mice are profoundly resistant to systemic infection by Candida albicans, with resistance characterized by enhanced survival, more rapid fungal clearance in key peripheral organs, and an altered inflammatory response. To investigate the role of Sts in the primary host response to infection by a bacterial pathogen, we evaluated the response of Sts^-/- mice to infection by a Gram-negative bacterial pathogen. Francisella tularensis is a facultative bacterial pathogen that replicates intracellularly within a variety of cell types and is the causative agent of tularemia. Francisella infections are characterized by a delayed immune response, followed by an intense inflammatory reaction that causes widespread tissue damage and septic shock. Herein, we demonstrate that mice lacking Sts expression are significantly resistant to infection by the live vaccine strain (LVS) of F. tularensis Resistance is characterized by reduced lethality following high-dose intradermal infection, an altered cytokine response in the spleen, and enhanced bacterial clearance in multiple peripheral organs. Sts^-/- bone marrow-derived monocytes and neutrophils, infected with F. tularensis LVS ex vivo, display enhanced restriction of intracellular bacteria. These observations suggest the Sts proteins play an important regulatory role in the host response to bacterial infection, and they underscore a role for Sts in regulating functionally relevant immune response pathways.

Evaluation of immunogenicity and protective efficacy of recombinant outer membrane proteins of Haemophilus parasuis serovar 5 in a murine model

Glässer’s disease is an economically important infectious disease of pigs caused by Haemophilus parasuis. Few vaccines are currently available that could provide effective cross-protection against various serovars of H. parasuis. In this study, five OMPs (OppA, TolC, HxuC, LppC, and HAPS_0926) identified by bioinformatic approaches, were cloned and expressed as recombinant proteins. Antigenicity of the purified proteins was verified through Western blotting, and primary screening for protective potential was evaluated in vivo. Recombinant TolC (rTolC), rLppC, and rHAPS_0926 proteins showing marked protection of mice against H. parasuis infection, and were further evaluated individually or in combination. Mice treated with these three OMPs produced humoral and host cell-mediated responses, with a significant rise in antigen-specific IgG titer and lymphoproliferative response in contrast with the mock-immunized group. Significant increases were noted in CD4⁺, CD8⁺ T cells, and three cytokines (IL-2, IL-4, and IFN-γ) in vaccinated animals. The antisera against candidate antigens could efficiently impede bacterial survival in whole blood bactericidal assay against H. parasuis infection. The multi-protein vaccine induced more pronounced immune responses and offered better protection than individual vaccines. Our findings indicate that these three OMPs are promising antigens for the development of multi-component subunit vaccines against Glässer's disease.

Strategies Used by Bacteria to Grow in Macrophages

Intracellular bacteria are often clinically relevant pathogens that infect virtually every cell type found in host organisms. However, myeloid cells, especially macrophages, constitute the primary cells targeted by most species of intracellular bacteria. Paradoxically, macrophages possess an extensive antimicrobial arsenal and are efficient at killing microbes. In addition to their ability to detect and signal the presence of pathogens, macrophages sequester and digest microorganisms using the phagolysosomal and autophagy pathways or, ultimately, eliminate themselves through the induction of programmed cell death. Consequently, intracellular bacteria influence numerous host processes and deploy sophisticated strategies to replicate within these host cells. Although most intracellular bacteria have a unique intracellular life cycle, these pathogens are broadly categorized into intravacuolar and cytosolic bacteria. Following phagocytosis, intravacuolar bacteria reside in the host endomembrane system and, to some extent, are protected from the host cytosolic innate immune defenses. However, the intravacuolar lifestyle requires the generation and maintenance of unique specialized bacteria-containing vacuoles and involves a complex network of host-pathogen interactions. Conversely, cytosolic bacteria escape the phagolysosomal pathway and thrive in the nutrient-rich cytosol despite the presence of host cell-autonomous defenses. The understanding of host-pathogen interactions involved in the pathogenesis of intracellular bacteria will continue to provide mechanistic insights into basic cellular processes and may lead to the discovery of novel therapeutics targeting infectious and inflammatory diseases.

An Immature Myeloid/Myeloid-Suppressor Cell Response Associated with Necrotizing Inflammation Mediates Lethal Pulmonary Tularemia

Inhalation of Francisella tularensis (Ft) causes acute and fatal pneumonia. The lung cytokine milieu favors exponential Ft replication, but the mechanisms underlying acute pathogenesis and death remain unknown. Evaluation of the sequential and systemic host immune response in pulmonary tularemia reveals that in contrast to overwhelming bacterial burden or cytokine production, an overt innate cellular response to Ft drives tissue pathology and host mortality. Lethal infection with Ft elicits medullary and extra-medullary myelopoiesis supporting recruitment of large numbers of immature myeloid cells and MDSC to the lungs. These cells fail to mature and die, leading to subsequent necrotic lung damage, loss of pulmonary function, and host death that is partially dependent upon immature Ly6G+ cells. Acceleration of this process may account for the rapid lethality seen with Ft SchuS4. In contrast, during sub-lethal infection with Ft LVS the pulmonary cellular response is characterized by a predominance of mature neutrophils and monocytes required for protection, suggesting a required threshold for lethal bacterial infection. Further, eliciting a mature phagocyte response provides transient, but dramatic, innate protection against Ft SchuS4. This study reveals that the nature of the myeloid cell response may be the primary determinant of host mortality versus survival following Francisella infection.

Identification of novel vaccine candidates against Acinetobacter baumannii using reverse vaccinology

Acinetobacter baumannii (Ab) is a global emerging bacterium causing nosocomial infections such as pneumonia, meningitis, bacteremia and soft tissue infections especially in intensive care units. Since Ab is resistant to almost all conventional antibiotics, it is now one of the 6 top-priorities of the dangerous microorganisms listed by the Infectious Disease Society of America. The development of vaccine is one of the most promising and cost-effective strategies to prevent infections. In this study, we identified potential protective vaccine candidates using reverse vaccinology. We have analyzed 14 on-line available Ab genome sequences and found 2752 homologous core genes. Using information obtained from immuno-proteomic experiments, published proteomic information and the bioinformatics PSORTb v3.0 software to predict the location of extracellular and/or outer membrane proteins, 77 genes were identified and selected for further studies. After excluding those antigens have been used as vaccine candidates reported by the in silico search-engines of PubMed and Google Scholar, 13 proteins could potentially be vaccine candidates. We have selected and cloned the genes of 3 antigens that were further expressed and purified. These antigens were found to be highly immunogenic and conferred partial protection (60%) in a pneumonia animal model. The strategy described in the present study incorporates the advantages of reverse vaccinology, bioinformatics and immuno-proteomic platform technologies and is easy to perform to identify novel immunogens for multi-component vaccines development.

Francisella Inflammasomes: Integrated Responses to a Cytosolic Stealth Bacterium

Francisella tularensis is a facultative intracellular bacterium causing tularemia, a zoonotic disease. Francisella replicates in the macrophage cytosol and eventually triggers cytosolic immune responses. In murine macrophages, Francisella novicida and Francisella tularensis live vaccine strain lyse in the host cytosol and activate the cytosolic DNA receptor Aim2. Here, we review the mechanisms leading or contributing to Aim2 inflammasome activation, including the role of TLRs and of IFN signaling and the implication of the guanylate-binding proteins 2 and 5 in triggering cytosolic bacteriolysis. Furthermore, we present how this cytosolic Gram-negative bacterium escapes recognition by caspase-11 but can trigger a non-canonical caspase-8 inflammasome. In addition, we highlight the differences in inflammasome activation in murine and human cells with pyrin, NLRP3, and AIM2 involved in sensing Francisella in human phagocytes. From a bacterial prospective, we describe the hiding strategy of Francisella to escape recognition by innate sensors and to resist to bacteriolysis in the host cytosol. Finally, we discuss the inability of the inflammasome sensors to detect F. tularensis subspecies tularensis strains, making them highly pathogenic stealth microbes.

From the Outside-In: The Francisella tularensis Envelope and Virulence

Francisella tularensis is a highly-infectious bacterium that causes the rapid, and often lethal disease, tularemia. Many studies have been performed to identify and characterize the virulence factors that F. tularensis uses to infect a wide variety of hosts and host cell types, evade immune defenses, and induce severe disease and death. This review focuses on the virulence factors that are present in the F. tularensis envelope, including capsule, LPS, outer membrane, periplasm, inner membrane, secretion systems, and various molecules in each of aforementioned sub-compartments. Whereas, no single bacterial molecule or molecular complex single-handedly controls F. tularensis virulence, we review here how diverse bacterial systems work in conjunction to subvert the immune system, attach to and invade host cells, alter phagosome/lysosome maturation pathways, replicate in host cells without being detected, inhibit apoptosis, and induce host cell death for bacterial release and infection of adjacent cells. Given that the F. tularensis envelope is the outermost layer of the bacterium, we highlight herein how many of these molecules directly interact with the host to promote infection and disease. These and future envelope studies are important to advance our collective understanding of F. tularensis virulence mechanisms and offer targets for future vaccine development efforts.

Macrophage cell death upon intracellular bacterial infection

Macrophage-pathogen interaction is a complex process and the outcome of this tag-of-war for both sides is to live or die. Without attempting to be comprehensive, this review will discuss the complexity and significance of the interaction outcomes between macrophages and some facultative intracellular bacterial pathogens as exemplified by Francisella, Salmonella, Shigella and Yersinia. Upon bacterial infection, macrophages can die by a variety of ways, such as apoptosis, autophagic cell death, necrosis, necroptosis, oncosis, pyronecrosis, pyroptosis etc, which is the focus of this review.