Identification of an immunodominant antigenically conserved 32-kilodalton protein from Cowdria ruminantium

Recombination and purifying and balancing selection determine the evolution of major antigenic protein 1 (map 1) family genes in Ehrlichia ruminantium

Heartwater is an economically important disease of ruminants caused by the tick-borne bacterium Ehrlichia ruminantium. The disease is present throughout sub-Saharan Africa as well as on several islands in the Caribbean, where it poses a risk of spreading onto the American mainland. The dominant immune response of infected animals is directed against the variable outer membrane proteins of E. ruminantium encoded by a polymorphic multigene family. Here, we examined the full-length sequence of the major antigenic protein 1 (map1) family genes in multiple E. ruminantium isolates from different African countries and the Caribbean, collected at different time points to infer the possible role of recombination breakpoint and natural selection. A high level of recombination was found particularly in map1 and map1-2. Evidence of strong negative purifying selection in map1 and balancing selection to maintain genetic variation across these samples from geographically distinct countries suggests host-pathogen co-evolution. This co-evolution between the host and pathogen results in balancing selection by maintaining genetic diversity that could be explained by the demographic history of long-term pathogen pressure. This signifies the adaptive role and the molecular evolutionary forces underpinning E. ruminantium map1 multigene family antigenicity.

Progress and obstacles in vaccine development for the ehrlichioses

Ehrlichia are tick-borne obligately intracellular bacteria that cause significant diseases in veterinary natural hosts, including livestock and companion animals, and are now considered important zoonotic pathogens in humans. Vaccines are needed for these veterinary and zoonotic human pathogens, but many obstacles exist that have impeded their development. These obstacles include understanding genetic and antigenic variability, influence of the host on the pathogen phenotype and immunogenicity, identification of the ehrlichial antigens that stimulate protective immunity and those that elicit immunopathology, development of animal models that faithfully reflect the immune responses of the hosts and understanding molecular host-pathogen interactions involved in immune evasion or that may be blocked by the host immune response. We review the obstacles and progress in addressing barriers associated with vaccine development to protect livestock, companion animals and humans against these host defense-evasive and cell function-manipulative, vector-transmitted pathogens.

Diversity of Ehrlichia ruminantium major antigenic protein 1-2 in field isolates and infected sheep

Proteins expressed from the map1 multigene family of Ehrlichia ruminantium are strongly recognized by immune T and B cells from infected animals or from animals that were infected and have recovered from heartwater disease (although still remaining infected carriers). Analogous multigene clusters also encode the immunodominant outer membrane proteins (OMPs) in other ehrlichial species. Recombinant protein analogs of the expressed genes and DNA vaccines based on the multigene clusters have been shown to induce protective immunity, although this was less effective in heterologous challenge situations, where the challenge strain major antigenic protein 1 (MAP1) sequence differed from the vaccine strain MAP1. Recent data for several ehrlichial species show differential expression of the OMPs in mammalian versus tick cell cultures and dominant expression of individual family members in each type of culture system. However, many genes in the clusters appear to be complete and functional and to generate mRNA transcripts. Recent data also suggest that there may be a low level of protein expression from many members of the multigene family, despite primary high-level expression from an individual member. A continuing puzzle, therefore, is the biological roles of the different members of these OMP multigene families. Complete genome sequences are now available for two geographically divergent strains of E. ruminantium (Caribbean and South Africa strains). Comparison of these sequences revealed amino acid sequence diversity in MAP1 (89% identity), which is known to confer protection in a mouse model and to be the multigene family member primarily expressed in mammalian cells. Surprisingly, however, the greatest sequence diversity (79% identity) was in the less-studied map1-2 gene. We investigated here whether this map1-2 diversity was a general feature of E. ruminantium in different cultured African strains and in organisms from infected sheep. Comparison of MAP1-2s revealed amino acid identities of 75 to 100% (mean of 86%), compared to 84 to 100% (mean of 89%) for MAP1s. Interestingly, MAP1-2s varied independently of MAP1s such that E. ruminantium strains with similar MAP1s had diverse MAP1-2s and vice versa. Different MAP1-2s were found in individual infected sheep. Different regions of a protein may be subjected to different evolutionary forces because of recombination and/or selection, which results in those regions not agreeing with a phylogeny deduced from the whole molecule. This appears to be true for both MAP1 and MAP1-2, where statistical likelihood methods detect heterogeneous evolutionary rates for segments of both molecules. Sera from infected cattle recognized a MAP1-2 variable-region peptide in enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay, but less strongly and consistently than a MAP1 peptide (MAP1B). Heterologous protective immunity may depend on recognition of a complex set of varying OMP epitopes.

Molecular detection of Ehrlichia ruminantium infection in Amblyomma variegatum ticks in The Gambia

In West Africa, losses due to heartwater disease are not known because the incidence/prevalence has not been well studied or documented. To develop a diagnostic tool for molecular epidemiology, three PCR-based diagnostic assays, a nested pCS20 PCR, a nested map1 PCR and a nested reverse line blot (RLB) hybridization assay, were evaluated to determine their ability to detect infection in vector ticks, by applying them simultaneously to A. variegatum field ticks to detect Ehrlichia ruminantium, the causative agent of heartwater. The nested pCS20 PCR assay which amplified the pCS20 gene fragment showed the highest detection performance with a detection rate of 16.6%; the nested map1 PCR, which amplified the gene encoding the major antigenic protein1 (map1 gene) showed a detection rate of 11% and the RLB, based on the 16S rDNA sequence of anaplasma and ehrlichial species, detected 6.2%. The RLB, in addition, demonstrated molecular evidence of Ehrlichia ovina, Anaplasma marginale and Anaplasma ovis infections in The Gambia. Subsequently, the pCS20 assay was applied to study the prevalence and distribution of E. ruminantium tick infection rates at different sites in five divisions of The Gambia. The rates of infection in the country ranged from 1.6% to 15.1% with higher prevalences detected at sites in the westerly divisions (Western, Lower River and North Bank; range 8.3-15.1%) than in the easterly divisions (Central River and Upper River; range 1.6-7.5%). This study demonstrated a gradient in the distribution of heartwater disease risk for susceptible livestock in The Gambia which factor must be considered in the overall design of future upgrading programmes.

Development of a polyclonal competitive enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay for detection of antibodies to Ehrlichia ruminantium

A polyclonal competitive enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (PC-ELISA) is described for detection of antibodies to Ehrlichia (Cowdria) ruminantium by using a soluble extract of endothelial cell culture-derived E. ruminantium as the antigen and biotin-labeled polyclonal goat immunoglobulins as the competitor. For goats, the diagnostic sensitivity and specificity were both 100% with a cutoff of 80% inhibition (80 PI), with detection of antibodies for 550 days postinfection. For cattle, diagnostic sensitivity and specificity were 86 and 100%, respectively, with a cutoff of 50 PI and 79 and 100% with a cutoff of 70 PI. Cross-reactions with high-titer experimental or field antisera to other Ehrlichia and Anaplasma species were observed at up to 68 PI in cattle and up to 85 PI in sheep, and therefore to exclude these cross-reactions, cutoffs of 70 PI for bovine serology and 85 PI for small-ruminant serology were selected. Application of the PC-ELISA to bovine field sera from South Africa gave a higher proportion of positive results than application of the murine macrophage immunofluorescent antibody test or indirect ELISA, suggesting a better sensitivity for detection of recovered cattle, and results with bovine field sera from Malawi were consistent with the observed endemic state of heartwater and the level of tick control practiced at the sample sites. Reproducibility was high, with average standard deviations intraplate of 1.2 PI and interplate of 0.6 PI. The test format is simple, and the test is economical to perform and has a level of sensitivity for detection of low-titer positive bovine sera that may prove to be of value in epidemiological studies on heartwater.

Immunisation of cattle against heartwater by infection with Cowdria ruminantium elicits T lymphocytes that recognise major antigenic proteins 1 and 2 of the agent

There is growing evidence that immunity of cattle to Cowdria ruminantium infection is mediated by T lymphocytes. C. ruminantium antigens that stimulate these responses are therefore of considerable importance to the development of a sub-unit vaccine against the disease. We have examined T cell responses against recombinant analogues of the surface-exposed C. ruminantium major antigen 1 (MAP1) a 28.8 kDa protein and MAP2 (21 kDa) antigen in cattle immunised by infection and treatment. Vigorous and sustained proliferative responses to both antigens were observed in peripheral blood mononuclear cells from immune cattle. MAP1-specific responses were predominantly restricted to cluster of differentiation four antigen positive T cells (CD4+ T cells). Reverse transcription polymerase chain reaction (RT-PCR) analysis of cytokine expression by T cell lines derived from this population revealed strong expression of interferon gamma (IFN-gamma), interferon alpha (IFN-alpha), tumour necrosis factor alpha (TNF-alpha), tumour necrosis factor beta (TNF-beta), interleukin-2 receptor alpha (IL-2Ralpha) transcripts, and weak expression of IL-2 and IL-4. Supernatants from these T cell cultures contained IFN-gamma protein. CD4+ T cell clones specific for MAP1 were generated. Two of these clones proliferated in the presence of autologous infected endothelial cells. In contrast, the response to MAP2 was characterised largely by proliferation of gamma delta (gammadelta) T cells. RT-PCR analysis of cytokine expression by T cell lines which were dominated by gammadelta T cells revealed expression of IFN-gamma, TNF-alpha, TNF-beta, IL-2Ralpha transcripts. Supernatants of these T cell cultures also contained IFN-gamma protein. Our findings indicate that immunisation of cattle by infection with C. ruminantium results in generation of MAP1- and MAP2-specific T cell responses that may play a role in protection against the pathogen.

DNA vaccination with map1 gene followed by protein boost augments protection against challenge with Cowdria ruminantium, the agent of heartwater

A DNA vaccine encoding the immunodominant MAP1 protein of Cowdria ruminantium (Crystal Springs (CS) strain) was shown to partially protect DBA/2 mice against homologous lethal challenge. To enhance the protective capacity of this DNA vaccine, the effects of length of interval between vaccinations and of prime-boost regimes were investigated. Increasing the interval between vaccinations from 2 to 12 weeks did not result in better protection (P=0.900). However, boosting DNA vaccine-primed mice with recombinant MAP1 protein significantly augmented protection on homologous challenge in various trials from 13-27 to 53-67% (P<0.050). The augmented protection by the prime-boost regimen correlated with augmented T(H1) type immune responses that were induced by the DNA vaccine. These responses were characterized by production of IFN-gamma, IL-2 and anti-MAP1 antibodies of predominantly IgG2a isotype, and were critical for protection against C. ruminantium infection. Cytokine analyses were done at 48h after in vitro stimulation of splenocytes with C. ruminantium or control antigens. In contrast, splenocytes of DNA vector control mice produced no cytokines and these mice were fully susceptible to challenge. In addition, DBA/2 mice immunized with the recombinant MAP1 protein without DNA vaccine priming produced non-protective T(H2) type immune responses which were characterized by production of IL-4, IL-5, IL-10 and IgG1 anti-MAP1 antibodies. A second DNA vaccine containing map1 gene from the Mbizi strain of C. ruminantium also delivered by a prime-boost regime, conferred less protection against heterologous challenge. Hence, in developing DNA vaccines against heartwater that contain map1 gene, a prime-boost regimen should be adopted and gene sequence heterogeneity of field isolates should also be considered.

Ehrlichia ruminantium major antigenic protein gene (map1) variants are not geographically constrained and show no evidence of having evolved under positive selection pressure

In a search for tools to distinguish antigenic variants of Ehrlichia ruminantium, we sequenced the major antigenic protein genes (map1 genes) of 21 different isolates and found that the sequence polymorphisms were too great to permit the design of probes which could be used as markers for immunogenicity. Phylogenetic comparison of the 21 deduced MAP1 sequences plus another 9 sequences which had been previously published did not reveal any geographic clustering among the isolates. Maximum likelihood analysis of codon and amino acid changes over the phylogeny provided no statistical evidence that the gene is under positive selection pressure, suggesting that it may not be important for the evasion of host immune responses.

Antibody responses to MAP 1B and other Cowdria ruminantium antigens are down regulated in cattle challenged with tick-transmitted heartwater

Serological diagnosis of heartwater or Cowdria ruminantium infection has been hampered by severe cross-reactions with antibody responses to related ehrlichial agents. A MAP 1B indirect enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay that has an improved specificity and sensitivity for detection of immunoglobulin G (IgG) antibodies has been developed to overcome this constraint (A. H. M. van Vliet, B. A. M. Van der Zeijst, E. Camus, S. M. Mahan, D. Martinez, and F. Jongejan, J. Clin. Microbiol. 33:2405-2410, 1995). When sera were tested from cattle in areas of endemic heartwater infection in Zimbabwe, only 33% of the samples tested positive in this assay despite a high infection pressure (S. M. Mahan, S. M. Samu, T. F. Peter, and F. Jongejan, Ann. N.Y. Acad. Sci 849:85-87, 1998). To determine underlying causes for this observation, the kinetics of MAP 1B-specific IgG antibodies in cattle after tick-transmitted C. ruminantium infection and following recovery were investigated. Sera collected weekly over a period of 52 weeks from 37 cattle, which were naturally or experimentally infected with C. ruminantium via Amblyomma hebraeum ticks, were analyzed. MAP 1B-specific IgG antibody responses developed with similar kinetics in both field- and laboratory-infected cattle. IgG levels peaked at 4 to 9 weeks after tick infestation and declined to baseline levels between 14 and 33 weeks, despite repeated exposure to infected ticks and the establishment of a carrier state as demonstrated by PCR and xenodiagnosis. Some of the serum samples from laboratory, and field-infected cattle were also analyzed by immunoblotting and an indirect fluorescent-antibody test (IFAT) to determine whether this observed seroreversion was specific to the MAP 1B antigen. Reciprocal IFAT and immunoblot MAP 1-specific antibody titres peaked at 5 to 9 weeks after tick infestation but also declined between 30 and 45 weeks. This suggests that MAP 1B-specific IgG antibody responses and antibody responses to other C. ruminantium antigens are down regulated in cattle despite repeated exposure to C. ruminantium via ticks. Significantly, serological responses to the MAP 1B antigen may not be a reliable indicator of C. ruminantium exposure in cattle in areas of endemic heartwater infection.

Highly conserved regions of the immunodominant major surface protein 2 of the genogroup II ehrlichial pathogen Anaplasma marginale are rich in naturally derived CD4+ T lymphocyte epitopes that elicit strong recall responses

Genogroup II ehrlichia, including the agent of human granulocytic ehrlichiosis, Ehrlichia phagocytophila, and the bovine pathogen Anaplasma marginale, express a markedly immunodominant outer membrane protein designated major surface protein 2 (MSP2). MSP2 is encoded by a multigene family, resulting in the expression of variant B cell epitopes. MSP2 variants are sequentially expressed in the repeated cycles of rickettsemia that characterize persistent A. marginale infection and control of each rickettsemic cycle is associated with development of a variant-specific IgG response. Importantly, these persistent rickettsemic cycles are controlled at levels 100-1000 times lower than those responsible for clinical disease during acute infection. Control of rickettsemia during persistence could result from an anamnestic Th lymphocyte response to conserved regions of MSP2 that enhances the primary Ab response against newly emergent variants. Comparison of MSP2 variants reveals conserved N and C termini flanking the central, surface-exposed hypervariable region that represents the variant B lymphocyte epitopes. We demonstrate MSP2-specific CD4(+) T lymphocyte recognition of epitopes common to several strains of A. marginale and the related pathogen A. ovis. Furthermore, T lymphocyte lines from three individuals identified six to nine overlapping peptides representing a minimum of four to seven dominant or subdominant epitopes in these conserved N and C termini. Immunodominant peptides induced high levels of IFN-gamma, a cytokine associated with protection against ehrlichia and needed for rapid generation of variant-specific IgG2. The presented data support the potential importance of a strong Th lymphocyte response to invariant MSP2 epitopes in controlling rickettsemia during persistent infection to subclinical levels.

Monoclonal antibody binding to a surface-exposed epitope on Cowdria ruminantium that is conserved among eight strains

Monoclonal antibodies (MAb) binding to Cowdria ruminantium elementary bodies (EB) were identified by enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay, and surface binding of one MAb (446.15) to intact EB was determined by immunofluorescence, immunogold labeling, and transmission electron microscopy. MAb 446.15 bound an antigen of approximately 43 kDa in immunoblots of eight geographically distinct strains. The MAb did not react with Ehrlichia canis antigens or uninfected bovine endothelial cell lysate and may be useful in diagnostic assays and vaccine development.

A polarized Th1 type immune response to Cowdria ruminantium infection is detected in immune DBA/2 mice

Immune responses to Cowdria ruminantium, an intracellular organism that causes heartwater in domestic ruminants, were characterized in a DBA/2 mouse model. Immunity induced by infection and treatment was adoptively transferable by splenocytes and could be abrogated by in vivo depletion of T cells but not by inhibition of nitric oxide synthase using NG-monomethyl-L-arginine. IgG2a and IgG2b C. ruminantium-specific responses were detected in immune mice. Culture supernatants of splenocytes from immune DBA/2 mice, which were stimulated with crude C. ruminantium antigens or recombinant major antigenic proteins 1 or 2, contained significant levels of interferon (IFN)-gamma and interleukin (IL)-6, but insignificant levels of IL-1alpha, IL-2, IL-4, IL-5, IL-10, IL-12, tumor necrosis factor-alpha (TNF), and nitric oxide. A similar response was detected during primary infection, although IFN-gamma levels decreased significantly during clinical illness and then increased following natural or antibiotic-aided recovery. These data support the conclusion that protective immunity to C. ruminantium in DBA/2 mice is mediated by T cells and is associated with a polarized T helper 1 type of immune response. This murine model could be utilized to screen for protective C. ruminantium antigens that provoke Th1 type immune responses and for evaluation of these antigens in recombinant vaccines against heartwater.

Identification of Cowdria ruminantium antigens that stimulate proliferation of lymphocytes from cattle immunized by infection and treatment or with inactivated organisms

Cowdria ruminantium is an obligate intracellular pathogen that causes heartwater in ruminants. Several findings suggest that T cells play an important role in protection against the disease. In order to identify which proteins are involved in T-cell immunity, C. ruminantium proteins were fractionated by continuous-flow electrophoresis and tested for their ability to stimulate lymphocyte proliferation in vitro. C. ruminantium-infected endothelial cell lysates were fractionated at between 11 and 38 kDa and 50 and 168 kDa on 15 and 7% acrylamide gels, respectively. In an attempt to stimulate the natural infective process, peripheral blood mononuclear cells (PBMC) were obtained from two cattle rendered immune by infection and treatment and assayed in proliferation assays with fractionated proteins. In a parallel study, four cattle were immunized with inactivated C. ruminantium to determine whether their lymphocytes also responded to fractionated proteins. Proliferation assays after immunization by infection and treatment detected no C. ruminantium-specific proliferation in vitro after one vaccination. Proliferation was observed, however, between 1 and 4 weeks after challenge. This was followed by a period of no detectable response, after which the response reappeared. PBMC from animals immunized with inactivated organisms proliferated specifically in response to antigen soon after the first immunization. Only C. ruminantium proteins with low molecular masses of 11, 12, 14 to 17, and 19 to 23 kDa induced proliferative responses by lymphocytes from all six animals. These protein fractions may have potential as vaccine antigens.

Bovine CD4+ T-cells lines reactive with soluble and membrane antigens of Cowdria ruminantium

Cowdria-specific CD4+ T-cell lines generated from immunised cattle respond to both soluble and membrane proteins of the agent. Furthermore, the lines produced the Cowdria-inhibitory cytokine IFN-gamma in response to soluble antigens fractionated by gel filtration and FPLC. Activity eluted as a single peak around fraction 15 for all T-cell lines tested. This fraction induced the highest production of IFN-gamma by the lines and was shown by SDS-polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis and silver staining analysis to contain less than 10 different bands ranging from 22 to 32 kDa. Given their high sensitivity and specificity, these short-term CD4+ T-cell lines will be valuable tools for the identification of Cowdria antigens for incorporation in a subunit vaccine.

Vaccine strategies for Cowdria ruminantium infections and their application to other ehrlichial infections

Suman Mahan and co-authors review the strategies applied to develop improved vaccines for Cowdria ruminantium infections (heartwater). Inactivated vaccines using cell-cultured C. ruminantium organisms combined with an adjuvant are capable of protecting goats, sheep and cattle against lethal C. ruminantium challenge. Immune responses induced with this vaccine, or after recovery from infection, target outer membrane proteins of C. ruminantium, in particular the major antigenic protein 1 (MAP-1). Genetic immunizations with the gene encoding MAP-1 induce protective T helper cell type 1 responses against lethal challenge in a mouse model. Similarly, homologues of MAP-1 in other phylogenetically and antigenically related ehrlichial agents such as Anaplasma marginale and Ehrlichia chaffeensis are also targets of protective responses. Given the antigenic similarities between the related ehrlichial agents, common strategies of vaccine development could be applied against these agents that cause infections of importance in animals and humans.

The map1 gene of Cowdria ruminantium is a member of a multigene family containing both conserved and variable genes

Heartwater is an economically important disease of ruminants caused by the tick-transmitted rickettsia Cowdria ruminantium. The disease is present in Africa and the Caribbean and there is a risk of spread to the Americas, particularly because of a clinically asymptomatic carrier state in infected livestock and imported wild animals. The causative agent is closely related taxonomically to the human and animal pathogens Ehrlichia chaffeensis and Ehrlichia canis. A dominant immune response of infected animals or people is directed against variable outer membrane proteins of these agents known, in E. chaffeensis and E. canis, to be encoded by polymorphic multigene families. We demonstrate, by sequence analysis, that map1 encoding the major outer membrane protein of C. ruminantium is also encoded by a polymorphic multigene family. Two members of the gene family are located in tandem in the genome. The upstream member, orf2, is conserved, encoding only 2 amino acid substitutions among six different rickettsial strains from diverse locations in Africa and the Caribbean. In contrast, the downstream member, map1, contains variable and conserved regions between strains. Interestingly, orf2 is more closely related in sequence to omp1b of E. chaffeensis than to map1 of C. ruminantium. The regions that differ among orf2, map1, and omp1b correspond to previously identified variable sequences in outer membrane protein genes of E. chaffeensis and E. canis. These data suggest that diversity in these outer membrane proteins may arise by recombination among gene family members and offer a potential mechanism for persistence of infection in carrier animals.

Characterization of variable immunodominant antigens of Cowdria ruminantium by ELISA and immunoblots

Cross-immunization experiments have revealed a significant antigenic diversity of the isolate of Cowdria ruminantium which needs to be characterized for the development of vaccines. We identified polymorphic immunodominant antigens by ELISA and immunoblot. Using serum from a goat immune to the Gardel stock of Cowdria (isolated in Guadeloupe) adsorbed on antigen of the Senegal stock of this pathogen, distinct serogroups were revealed by ELISA among six isolates from different geographical origins. Furthermore, a goat serum directed against the Senegal stock and adsorbed on Gardel antigens was shown to be specific for the Senegal stock, thus confirming the existence of serotypes in Cowdria. The Major Antigenic Protein 1 (MAP1) of Cowdria was shown to have variable antigenic determinants. Also in a group of variable proteins ranging from 23 to 29 kDa, one antigen of 26-27 kDa had a determinant specific for the Gardel isolate. These polymorphic antigens may be relevant components of Cowdria ruminantium for a vaccine as the sera revealing these antigens originated from a goal surviving a lethal challenge. However, the presence of T-cell epitopes and the ability of the these antigens to confer protection to ruminants remain to be investigated. The production of a rabbit antiserum against this group of polypeptides will be of great use for their purification and for the screening of expression libraries.

The inactivated Cowdria ruminantium vaccine for heartwater protects against heterologous strains and against laboratory and field tick challenge

We previously described that an inactivated vaccine against heartwater prepared from Cowdria ruminantium (Crystal Springs strain) organisms and administered in complete Freund's adjuvant (cFA) protected sheep against homologous needle challenge. Further studies, described herein, demonstrated that this vaccine protected 100% of sheep against death on challenge with laboratory-infected ticks and with field ticks in a heartwater endemic farm, whereas a mortality rate of 44% and 62%, respectively, was recorded in the control sheep. Subsequently, the Mbizi strain of C. ruminantium was incorporated into the vaccine because of its wider cross-protective capacity, and trial data suggested that protection may be achieved against challenge with diverse geographical strains using this strain. The efficacy of five adjuvants with acceptable safety was compared with that of cFA. Against a homologous intravenous challenge, highest survival rates were observed in sheep vaccinated with inactivated C. ruminantium in either cFA, Montanide ISA 50 or Quil A. The vaccine prepared in Montanide ISA 50 protected six of seven sheep against natural challenge from field ticks on a farm in Zimbabwe where heartwater is endemic, whereas six of seven control sheep died (P = 0.029). These data support optimization of the vaccine prepared in Montanide ISA 50, followed by evaluation of its efficacy in all target domestic ruminant species and in other geographical regions where heartwater constrains livestock production.

Evaluation of the MAP-1B ELISA for cowdriosis with field sera from livestock in Zimbabwe

The Map 1B (Senegal) antigen-based indirect ELISA was evaluated in Zimbabwe with field sera from heartwater-free and heartwater-endemic areas. Of 205 sheep sera samples from a heartwater-free area, 34 were negative and 171 were positive by immunoblotting. These 171 samples were classified as false positives. Of the same 205 samples, 199 were negative and only 6 were positive by the MAP 1B ELISA. Of 72 cattle samples tested from a similar area, 71 were negative, with only 1 sample positive by MAP 1B ELISA. By immunoblotting, 43 of 72 cattle sera were negative and 29 were positive. Of the 46 goat samples tested from a heartwater-free area, only 2 were positive by the MAP 1B ELISA. Based on these results, the MAP 1B ELISA was more specific for heartwater than the immunoblotting assay. Of 96 and 282 cattle sera analyzed from heartwater-endemic farms in the lowveld and highveld of Zimbabwe, respectively, approximately 33% were positive by the MAP 1B ELISA. Goat sera from the same farms had a higher sero-prevalence (> 90%). The implications of these results for serodiagnosis of heartwater using the MAP 1B ELISA will be discussed.

A DNA vaccine protects mice against the rickettsial agent Cowdria ruminantium

A DNA vaccine (VCL1010/MAP1) containing the major antigenic protein 1 (MAP1) gene of Cowdria ruminantium, driven by the human cytomegalovirus (HCMV) enhancer-promoter, was injected intramuscularly into 8-10 week-old female DBA/2 mice after treating them with 50 microliters/muscle of 0.5% bupivacaine three days previously. Up to 75% of the immunized mice seroconverted and reacted with C. ruminantium antigen blots. Splenocytes from immunized mice, but not from control mice, proliferated in response to the recombinant MAP1 and to C. ruminantium antigens in in vitro lymphocyte proliferation tests. These proliferating cells secreted IFN-gamma and IL-2 at concentrations ranging from 610 pg/ml to 1290 pg/ml and from 152 pg/ml to 310 pg/ml, respectively. Only up to 45 pg/ml and 42 pg/ml of IFN-gamma and IL-2, respectively, were detected in supernatants of splenocytes from control mice. In experiments testing different VCL1010/MAP1 DNA vaccine dose regimens (25-100 micrograms/dose, two or four immunizations), survival rates of 23% to 88% (35/92 survivors/total in all VCL1010/MAP1 immunized groups) were observed on challenge with a lethal dose of cell culture-derived C. ruminantium organisms. In contrast, survival rates of 0% to 3% (1/144 survivors/total in all control groups) were recorded for control mice. This study demonstrates that MAP1 is a protective antigen and validates the concept of DNA vaccines against heartwater.

Evidence to show that an agent that cross-reacts serologically with Cowdria ruminantium in Zimbabwe is transmitted by ticks

The serological diagnosis of heartwater based on reactions to the immunodominant Cowdria ruminantium major antigen protein-1 (MAP-1) is impaired by the detection of false-positive reactions. In this study, the prevalence of false-positive reactions on seven heartwater-free farms in Zimbabwe was determined to be 8-94% by immunoblotting against C. ruminantium antigens. The highest prevalence of false-positives on Spring Valley Farm correlated with the presence of Rhipicephalus evertsi evertsi ticks. The other tick species found on these seven farms were Hyalomma truncatum and Hyalomma marginatum rufipes. Rhipicephalus evertsi evertsi ticks collected from Spring Valley Farm and fed on seronegative sheep caused seroconversion in one of two sheep. This sheep developed a mild febrile reaction and C. ruminantium MAP-1 antigen reactive antibodies 3 weeks after the ticks started feeding. Polymerase chain reactions (PCRs), conducted using C. ruminantium-specific primers on ticks collected from the seven farms and on some of the R. e. evertsi ticks that had caused seroconversion in one sheep, were negative. However, some of these ticks gave positive PCRs with DNA primers which amplify a 350 bp DNA fragment of the 16s rRNA gene from all ehrlichial agents indicating the presence of infection with one or more Ehrlichia species. Although attempts to isolate the cross-reacting agent from the sheep were unsuccessful, this study demonstrates that false-positive reactions with the MAP-1 C. ruminantium antigen are associated with agents transmitted by ticks.

Construction and initial analysis of a representative lambda ZAPII expression library of the intracellular rickettsia Cowdria ruminantium: cloning of map1 and three other Cowdria genes

The causative agent of heartwater, the rickettsia Cowdria ruminantium, is very poorly understood at the molecular level owing to a profound lack of suitable tools. We have developed an immunoaffinity chromatographic method to purify C. ruminantium from host cell components and the purified rickettsial cells have been used to prepare substantially pure Cowdria DNA. This DNA has been used to construct what we believe to be the first fully representative C. ruminantium expression library. A clone containing the complete Cowdria map1 gene has been isolated and sequenced. This gene has been expressed in E. coli cells from the native Cowdria promoter, suggesting that the mechanisms for gene transcription and translation are similar between these two organisms. Parts of three other Cowdria genes have also been isolated and sequenced.

Recombinant expression and use in serology of a specific fragment from the Cowdria ruminantium MAP1 protein

The major antigenic protein (MAP1) of Cowdria ruminantium was screened for immunogenic regions by expression of overlapping recombinant DNA clones of the gene encoding the MAP1 protein. Two regions, designated MAP1-A and MAP1-B, were recognized by all antisera to 9 different isolates of C. ruminantium. MAP1-A contained one or more epitopes responsible for false-positive reactions with Ehrlichia antisera in several serological tests for cowdriosis. Cross-reactivity with MAP1-B was limited to antisera to Ehrlichia chaffeensis and Ehrlichia canis. Antisera to Ehrlichia species that infect ruminants (E. bovis, E. ovina, and E. phagocytophila) did not recognize MAP1-B. The sensitivity of an indirect ELISA based on MAP1-B was found to be excellent, since all sera from animals experimentally infected with C. ruminantium (64 out of 64) reacted with MAP1-B. Validation of this ELISA was carried out with field sera obtained from sheep raised in heartwater-free areas in Zimbabwe and from several Caribbean islands. Only 9 out of 111 samples from Zimbabwe, and 1 out of 58 samples from the Caribbean islands, which were considered to be false positives by immunoblot or indirect ELISA, reacted with MAP1-B. Thus, the ELISA based on MAP1-B is at present the most specific and sensitive serological test for cowdriosis.

Use of a specific immunogenic region on the Cowdria ruminantium MAP1 protein in a serological assay

Currently available serological tests for cowdriosis (Cowdria ruminantium infection) in domestic ruminants are hampered by their low specificities because of cross-reactivity with Ehrlichia spp. The use of recombinant major antigenic protein (MAP1) of C. ruminantium for serodiagnosis was investigated. Overlapping fragments of the MAP1 protein were expressed in Escherichia coli and were reacted with sera from sheep infected with either C. ruminantium or Ehrlichia ovina. Two immunogenic regions on the MAP1 protein, designated MAP1-A and MAP1-B, were identified. MAP1-A was reactive with C. ruminantium antisera, E. ovina antisera, and three MAP1-specific monoclonal antibodies, whereas MAP1-B reacted only with C. ruminantium antisera. An indirect enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA) based on MAP1-B was further developed and validated with sera from animals experimentally infected with C. ruminantium or several Ehrlichia spp. Antibodies raised in sheep, cattle, and goats against nine isolates of C. ruminantium reacted with MAP1-B. Cross-reactivity with MAP1-B was limited to Ehrlichia canis and Ehrlichia chaffeensis, two rickettsias which do not infect ruminants. Antibodies to Ehrlichia spp. which do infect ruminants (E. bovis, E. ovina, and E. phagocytophila) did not react with MAP1-B. Antibody titers to C. ruminantium in sera from experimentally infected cattle, goats, and sheep were detectable for 50 to 200 days postinfection. Further validation of the recombinant MAP1-B-based ELISA was done with sera obtained from sheep raised in heartwater-free areas in Zimbabwe and from several Caribbean islands. A total of 159 of 169 samples which were considered to be false positive by immunoblotting or indirect ELISA did not react with MAP1-B. In conclusion, recombinant MAP1-B may be a suitable antigen for a sensitive serological test for cowdriosis, with dramatically improved specificity.

Review of the molecular biology of Cowdria ruminantium

Cowdria ruminantium is a rickettsial agent which causes heartwater, an economically important disease of livestock in the tropics and the Caribbean. Significant advances have been made in the molecular biology of C. ruminantium since its reproducible propagation in vitro in bovine endothelial cells. These advances have been targeted towards the development of improved vaccines and diagnostic tests. Several immunogenic proteins of C. ruminantium have been identified and monoclonal antibodies have been developed to some. The gene for the 21 kDa C. ruminantium protein has been cloned, characterized, sequenced and expressed to high levels to produce a recombinant analogue. This gene is conserved amongst all C. ruminantium isolates tested. The gene for the immunodominant 32 kDa protein has also been cloned recently. Analysis shows that this protein varies structurally between different C. ruminantium isolates. Recombinant protein analogues will have application in vaccine studies and subunit enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA) developments. In the field of serology, a 32 kDa protein specific competitive ELISA (cELISA) is available and a 21 kDa protein specific direct and a cELISA is being developed. Detection of C. ruminantium in Amblyomma ticks and in animals is now possible using DNA and RNA probes and the sensitivity of these nucleic acid based assays is being maximized using polymerase chain reaction (PCR). Sequencing of the 16s rRNA gene has revealed the close phylogenetic relationship of C. ruminantium to Rickettsia, Anaplasma and Ehrlichia species. The implications of these studies will be discussed.

Immunisation of sheep against heartwater with inactivated Cowdria ruminantium

The immunisation of sheep with inactivated Cowdria ruminantium organisms (the causative agent of heartwater) emulsified in Freund's adjuvant induced protective immunity against a homologous challenge with virulent cell culture-derived C ruminantium organisms. This protective immunity was associated with the development of high titres of C ruminantium-specific antibodies, a low level of rickettsiosis in brain endothelium and no mortalities. In contrast, when unimmunised sheep were challenged, they developed higher levels of rickettsiosis in brain endothelium, and some of them died. This method of immunisation against heartwater has the potential to replace the infection and treatment method that is in current use.

Size variation of the major immunodominant protein of Cowdria ruminantium

An immunodominant response is made to a polypeptide of approximately 32 kDa in animals infected with the rickettsial pathogen Cowdria ruminantium. We show here using cultured strains of the rickettsia from different geographical areas that the apparent size of this polypeptide varies with strain origin. Changes in the primary structure between strains should be considered in the design of vaccines and diagnostic tests based on this antigen.

Molecular cloning, sequence analysis, and expression of the gene encoding the immunodominant 32-kilodalton protein of Cowdria ruminantium

Cowdria ruminatium, the causative agent of heartwater disease, expresses an immunodominant and conserved 32-kilodalton protein (MAP1; formerly called Cr32), which is currently in use for serodiagnosis of the disease. The gene encoding this protein, designated map1, was detected, cloned, and characterized. The gene is conserved between four different stocks of C. ruminantium originating from Senegal, Sudan, South Africa, and Zimbabwe. Homology searches revealed MAP1 to be homologous to the Anaplasma marginale surface protein MSP4, a potential protective antigen. The MAP1 protein, expressed in Escherichia coli fused with glutathione S-transferase, is specifically recognized by sera from animals infected with seven different stocks of C. ruminantium.

Serological evidence for antigenic relationships between Ehrlichia canis and Cowdria ruminantium

The sera from dogs experimentally infected with Ehrlichia canis reacted at very similar titres in indirect fluorescent antibody (IFA) tests with E canis and Cowdria ruminantium antigen. In Western blots these sera reacted strongly with the immunodominant antigens of E canis (27 kDa) and C ruminantium (25 and 32 kDa). The dogs experimentally infected with C ruminantium showed no clinical evidence of infection, though the presence of organisms in the blood was demonstrable, for up to two weeks after inoculation, by a polymerase chain reaction. The sera from these dogs were also reactive with both organisms in the IFA tests, but the antibody titres were four- to fivefold higher with C ruminantium than with E canis antigen. In Western blots, these sera reacted strongly with the 25 and 32 kDa antigens of C ruminantium but weakly with the 27 kDa antigen of E canis. These results provide strong evidence that the immunodominant antigens of E canis and C ruminantium contain cross-reacting epitopes.

Correlation between antibodies to Cowdria ruminantium (rickettsiales) in cattle and the distribution of Amblyomma vector ticks in Zimbabwe

Cowdriosis, caused by Cowdria ruminantium, is transmitted by Amblyomma ticks, which are widely distributed in Zimbabwe. To assess the distribution of this disease in Zimbabwe, cattle either exposed to Amblyomma ticks or maintained in areas free from these ticks were tested for antibodies to Cowdria. A total of 324 sera were tested using competitive ELISA and the indirect fluorescent antibody test (IFAT). At diptanks in Amblyomma-infested areas 52% (n = 95) and 26% (n = 47) of sera were positive by cELISA and IFAT, respectively. At diptanks in Amblyomma-free areas 11% (n = 125) and 10% (n = 134) of sera were positive by cELISA and IFAT, respectively. The results were significantly different between Amblyomma-infested and tick-free areas (chi 2 = 24.73, P < or = 0.005 for IFAT and chi 2 = 57.53, P < or = 0.005 for cELISA). High background readings in field sera, possibly due to cross-reactive antibodies to Ehrlichia spp., complicated the determination of a realistic cut-off point, especially in cELISA. On the basis of the distribution of Amblyomma ticks, currently a large part of Zimbabwe can be considered endemic for the disease.

An immunoblotting diagnostic assay for heartwater based on the immunodominant 32-kilodalton protein of Cowdria ruminantium detects false positives in field sera

Heartwater, a major constraint to improved livestock production in Zimbabwe, threatens to invade areas which have been previously unaffected. To monitor its spread in Zimbabwe, an immunoblotting diagnostic assay based on the responses of animals to the immunodominant, conserved 32-kDa protein of Cowdria ruminantium was evaluated. In this assay, no false reactions were detected with sera known to be positive and negative, but sera from some cattle, sheep, and goats from heartwater-free areas of Zimbabwe reacted strongly with the 32-kDa protein, suggesting that either these animals had previous exposure to heartwater or they were false positives. To investigate the possibility of previous exposure to heartwater, 11 immunoblot-positive and 6 immunoblot-negative sheep from heartwater-free areas of Zimbabwe were compared regarding their susceptibilities to challenge with C. ruminantium. Prior to challenge, C. ruminantium could not be detected in any sheep by transmission to Amblyomma hebraeum ticks or by the polymerase chain reaction (PCR) conducted with plasma samples. All sheep were equally susceptible to the challenge, and infection was confirmed by brain biopsy, necropsy, PCR, and transmission of C. ruminantium to ticks. Our data suggest that the immunoblot-positive reactions of sera from heartwater-free areas were due not to previous C. ruminantium infection but rather to antigenic cross-reactivity between C. ruminantium and another agent(s) such as Ehrlichia species. In conclusion, the immunodominant 32-kDa protein is not antigenically specific to C. ruminantium and its use in serological diagnosis of heartwater requires reevaluation.

Distribution of heartwater in the Caribbean determined on the basis of detection of antibodies to the conserved 32-kilodalton protein of Cowdria ruminantium

A competitive enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (cELISA) was developed to detect immunoglobulin G antibodies to the major 32-kDa protein of Cowdria ruminantium. A total of 1,804 serum samples collected from cattle on 19 islands in the eastern Caribbean Basin were tested by this cELISA. A total of 133 serum samples from 10 islands (Antigua, Dominica, Grenada, Guadeloupe, Martinique, Montserrat, St. Kitts, St. Lucia, St. Martin, and St. Vincent) were found to be positive. The presence of antibodies to C. ruminantium in cattle on these islands was confirmed by immunofluorescence and Western blotting (immunoblotting). In earlier studies, C. ruminantium has been demonstrated only on Guadeloupe, Antigua, and Marie Galante. This study shows that the causative agent of heartwater is now firmly established in the Caribbean.

Antigenic diversity of Cowdria ruminantium isolates determined by cross-immunity

Antigenic diversity in five stocks of the tick-borne rickettsia Cowdria ruminantium, the causal agent of heartwater disease of ruminants, was studied by cross-immunity trials in goats and sheep. Complete absence of cross-protection was found only between the Kümm and Kwanyanga stocks, and in all other combinations there were various degrees of cross-immunity. Immunological strain differences were more pronounced in goats than in sheep.

The tribe Ehrlichieae and ehrlichial diseases

The tribe Ehrlichieae consists of gram-negative minute cocci that are obligate intracellular parasites classified in the family Rickettsiaceae. Although ehrlichial organisms have been observed in leukocytes for many years, only a few species have been cultured in quantities sufficient for biochemical and molecular analyses. Recents studies on 16S-rRNA sequence analysis and energy metabolism showed that the genus Ehrlichia is closely related to the genus Rickettsia. There is, however, no antigenic cross-reactivity between these genera. Ehrlichial organisms cause a disease called "ehrlichiosis," a noncontagious infectious disease known to be transmitted by a tick in several cases and by a fluke in one case. Ehrlichia spp. infect dogs, ruminants, horses, and humans. Recently, two new ehrlichial diseases, Potomac horse fever and human ehrlichiosis, were discovered in the United States. The etiologic agent of Potomac horse fever, Ehrlichia risticii, is closely related to the known human pathogen Ehrlichia sennetsu. The etiologic agent of human ehrlichiosis is related to Ehrlichia canis, a canine pathogen. In contrast to the genus Rickettsia, members of the tribe Ehrlichieae reside primarily in the cytoplasmic vacuoles of monocytes or granulocytes and cause hematologic abnormalities, lymphadenopathy, and other pathologic changes in the host. However, the actual mechanisms whereby Ehrlichia spp. infect leukocytes, multiply in them, and produce various forms of systemic disease have not been defined. Depending on the ehrlichial species involved, serologic or direct microscopic observation of stained blood smears is currently used to diagnose ehrlichial disease.

Competitive enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay for heartwater using monoclonal antibodies to a Cowdria ruminantium-specific 32-kilodalton protein

Hybridomas producing monoclonal antibodies (mAb) to Cowdria ruminantium were raised. Four mAbs of the IgG isotype reacted in western blots with a 32-kilodalton Cowdria protein (Cr32), which had previously been shown to be conserved and immunodominant. A fifth mAb of the IgM isotype recognized a 40-kDa Cowdria protein. The latter mAb was negative in an indirect fluorescent antibody test (IFA), whereas the other four were positive. mAb No. 4F10B4 showed the strongest signal in western blots using three different stocks of Cowdria. Immuno-gold labeling of Cowdria organisms in vitro using 4F10B4 showed that Cr32 has surface-exposed antigenic determinants. Using mAb 4F10B4, a competitive ELISA was developed which detected specific Cowdria antibodies in goat, sheep and cattle sera. Antibodies in animal sera competed with binding of mAb 4F10B4 to a crude sonicated Cowdria antigen obtained from infected endothelial cell cultures. The competition ELISA (CELISA) detected antibodies in 55 out of 70 (79%) goats experimentally infected with one of eight different Cowdria stocks. Fourteen out of the 15 sera which were shown negative in the CELISA were also negative in the IFA. Nevertheless, all 15 sera recognized some epitopes of the immunodominant Cowdria-specific 32 kDa protein as judged from their reaction with this protein in western blots. Overall, there was 89% agreement between CELISA and IFA considering all 70 goat sera. Moreover, antibodies were detected in nine out of nine sheep infected with one of three different stocks of Cowdria and in sera from calves experimentally infected by two different strains of heartwater. There were no cross-reactions with Ehrlichia phagocytophila antibodies in goat sera, nor with Anaplasma marginale antibodies in bovine sera. Lack of cross-reactivity and detection of antibodies to eight geographically widely distributed stocks of Cowdria, makes the competition ELISA a promising test for use in heartwater endemic areas.

Protective immunity to heartwater (Cowdria ruminantium infection) is acquired after vaccination with in vitro-attenuated rickettsiae

A Senegalese (S) stock of Cowdria ruminantium was passaged on bovine umbilical endothelial cells with an average interval of 13.9 days (range, 8 to 34 days) between passages. The virulence of infected bovine umbilical endothelial cultures was tested in susceptible goats and sheep by intravenous inoculation of culture supernatant from passages 2 (51 days in vitro), 3 (69 days), 11 (229 days), 14 (264 days), and 16 (291 days). Both animals inoculated with passages 2 and 3 died of heartwater. However, clinical reactions were completely absent in goats and sheep that were inoculated with C. ruminantium from passages 11, 14, and 16. High antibody titers were detected, with immunofluorescence in all vaccinated animals, and a strong signal was found against a 32-kDa Cowdria protein in Western blots (immunoblots). Moreover, the vaccinated animals proved solidly immune when challenged with virulent Cowdria sp.-infected blood stabilate (S strain), whereas all control goats died. No attenuation of a second Cowdria stock (W) was achieved after 226 days in culture, at which time passage 17 was tested in a recipient goat which died of typical heartwater. This is the first report of vaccination with live attenuated C. ruminantium. These attenuated organisms may replace vaccination with virulent blood currently in use in areas where heartwater is endemic.