Structure and function of conjugative pili: inducible synthesis of functional F pili by Escherichia coli K-12 containing a lac-tra operon fusion

Fluorescence assays for F-pili and their application

Conjugative pili are extracellular filaments elaborated by Gram-negative bacteria expressing certain type IV secretion systems. They are required at the earliest stages of conjugal DNA transfer to establish specific and secure cell-cell contacts. Conjugative pili also serve as adsorption organelles for both RNA and DNA bacteriophages. Beyond these facts, the structure, formation and function of these filaments are poorly understood. This paper describes a rapid, quantitative assay for F-pili encoded by the F plasmid type IV secretion system. The assay is based on the specific lateral adsorption of icosahedral RNA bacteriophage R17 by F-pili. Bacteriophage particles conjugated with a fluorescent dye, Alexa 488, and bound to F-pili defined filaments visible by immunofluorescence microscopy. F-pili attached to F+ cells and free F-pili were both visible by this method. For quantification, cell-bound bacteriophage were separated from free bacteriophage particles by sedimentation and released by suspending cell pellets in 0.1 % SDS. Fluorescence in cell-free supernatant fractions was measured by fluorometry. The authors present a characterization of this assay and its application to F-pilus formation by cells carrying mutations in the gene for the F-pilus subunit F-pilin. Each mutation introduced a cysteine, which F-pilin normally lacks, at a different position in its primary structure. Cysteine residues in the N-terminal domain I abolished filament formation as measured by fluorescent R17 binding. This was confirmed by measurements of DNA donor activity and filamentous DNA bacteriophage infection. With one exception (G53C), cysteines elsewhere in the F-pilin primary structure did not abolish filament formation, although some mutations differentially affected F-pilus functions.

Tra proteins characteristic of F-like type IV secretion systems constitute an interaction group by yeast two-hybrid analysis

Using yeast two-hybrid screens, we have defined an interaction group of six Tra proteins encoded by the F plasmid and required by F(+) cells to elaborate F pili. The six proteins are TraH, TraF, TraW, TraU, TrbI, and TrbB. Except for TrbI, these proteins were all identified as hallmarks of F-like type IV secretion systems (TFSSs), with no homologues among TFSS genes of P-type or I-type systems (T. Lawley, W. Klimke, M. Gubbins, and L. Frost, FEMS Microbiol. Lett. 224:1-15, 2003). Also with the exception of TrbI, which is an inner membrane protein, the remaining proteins are or are predicted to be periplasmic. TrbI consists of one membrane-spanning segment near its N terminus and an 88-residue, hydrophilic domain that extends into the periplasm. Hence, the proteins of this group probably form a periplasmic cluster in Escherichia coli. The interaction network identifies TraH as the most highly connected node, with two-hybrid links to TrbI, TraU, and TraF. As measured by transcriptional activation of lacZ, the TrbI-TraH interaction in Saccharomyces cerevisiae requires the TraH amino acid segment from residues 193 to 225. The TraU and TraF interactions are localized to C-terminal segments of TraH (amino acids 315 to 458 for TraF and amino acids 341 to 458 for TraU). The TrbI-TraH interaction with full-length (less the signal peptide) TraH is weak but increases 40-fold with N-terminal TraH deletions; the first 50 amino acids appear to be critical for inhibiting TrbI binding in yeast. Previous studies by others have shown that, with the exception of trbB mutations, which do not affect the elaboration or function of F pili under laboratory conditions, a mutation in any of the other genes in this interaction group alters the number or length distribution of F pili. We propose a model whereby one function of the TraH interaction group is to control F-pilus extension and retraction.

An active type IV secretion system encoded by the F plasmid sensitizes Escherichia coli to bile salts

F(+) strains of Escherichia coli infected with donor-specific bacteriophage such as M13 are sensitive to bile salts. We show here that this sensitivity has two components. The first derives from secretion of bacteriophage particles through the cell envelope, but the second can be attributed to expression of the F genes required for the formation of conjugative (F) pili. The latter component was manifested as reduced or no growth of an F(+) strain in liquid medium containing bile salts at concentrations that had little or no effect on the isogenic F(-) strain or as a reduced plating efficiency of the F(+) strain on solid media; at 2% bile salts, plating efficiency was reduced 10(4)-fold. Strains with F or F-like R factors were consistently more sensitive to bile salts than isogenic, plasmid-free strains, but the quantitative effect of bile salts depended on both the plasmid and the strain. Sensitivity also depended on the bile salt, with conjugated bile salts (glycocholate and taurocholate) being less active than unconjugated bile salts (deoxycholate and cholate). F(+) cells were also more sensitive to sodium dodecyl sulfate than otherwise isogenic F(-) cells, suggesting a selectivity for amphipathic anions. A mutation in any but one F tra gene required for the assembly of F pili, including the traA gene encoding F pilin, substantially restored bile salt resistance, suggesting that bile salt sensitivity requires an active system for F pilin secretion. The exception was traW. A traW mutant was 100-fold more sensitive to cholate than the tra(+) strain but only marginally more sensitive to taurocholate or glycocholate. Bile salt sensitivity could not be attributed to a generalized change in the surface permeability of F(+) cells, as judged by the effects of hydrophilic and hydrophobic antibiotics and by leakage of periplasmic beta-lactamase into the medium.

Evidence that F-plasmid proteins TraV, TraK and TraB assemble into an envelope-spanning structure in Escherichia coli

We have examined the role of the F-plasmid TraV outer membrane lipoprotein in the assembly of F-pili. Yeast two-hybrid analysis with a traV bait repeatedly identified traK, which is predicted to encode a periplasmic protein, among positive prey plasmids. A traK bait in turn identified traV and traB, which is predicted to encode an inner membrane protein. A traB bait exclusively identified traK preys. Several additional observations support the hypothesis that TraV, TraK and TraB form a complex in Escherichia coli that spans the cell envelope from the outer membrane (TraV) through the periplasm (TraK) to the inner membrane (TraB). First, two-hybrid analyses indicated that TraV and TraB bind to different TraK segments, as required if TraK bridges a ternary complex. Secondly, all three proteins fractionated with the E. coli outer membrane in tra+ cells. In contrast, TraB fractionated with the inner membrane in traV or traK mutant cells, and TraK appeared in the osmotic shock fluid from the traV mutant. These results are consistent with a TraV-TraK-TraB complex anchored to the outer membrane via the TraV lipoprotein. Further, in traK mutant cells, TraV failed to accumulate to a detectable level, and the TraB level was significantly reduced, suggesting that TraV and TraB must interact with TraK for either protein to accumulate to its normal level. Both TraK and TraV accumulated in traB2[Am] cells; however, the TraB2 amber fragment could be detected by Western blot, and sequence analysis indicated that the fragment retained the TraK-binding domain suggested by yeast two-hybrid analysis. We propose that TraV is the outer membrane anchor for a trans-envelope, Tra protein structure required for the assembly of F-pili and possibly for other events of conjugal DNA transfer.

Interaction between the F plasmid TraA (F-pilin) and TraQ proteins

Elaboration of conjugative (F) pili by F+ strains of Escherichia coli requires the activities of over a dozen F-encoded DNA transfer (Tra) proteins. The organization and functions of these proteins are largely unknown. Using the yeast two-hybrid assay, we have begun to analyse binary interactions among the Tra proteins required for F-pilus formation. We focus here on interactions involving F-pilin, the only known F-pilus subunit. Using a library of F tra DNA fragments that contained all the F genes required for F pilus formation in a yeast GAL4 activation domain vector (pACTII), we transformed yeast containing a plasmid (pAS1CYH2traA) encoding a GAL4 DNA-binding domain-F-pilin fusion. Doubly transformed cells were screened for GAL4-dependent gene expression. This screen repeatedly identified only a single Tra protein, TraQ, previously identified as a likely F-pilin chaperone. The F-pilin-TraQ interaction appeared to be specific, as no transcriptional activation was detected in yeast transformants containing pACTIItraQ plasmids and the Salmonella typhi pED208 traA gene cloned in pAS1CYH2. Two traQ segments isolated in the screen against F-pilin were tested for complementation of a traQ null allele in E. coli. One, lacking the first 11 (of 94) TraQ amino acids, restored DNA donor activity, donor-specific bacteriophage sensitivity and membrane F-pilin accumulation to wild-type levels. The second, lacking the first 21 amino acids, was much less effective in these assays. Both TraQ polypeptides accumulated in E. coli as transmembrane proteins. The longer, biologically active segment was fused to the GAL4 DNA-binding domain gene of pAS1CYH2 and used to screen the tra fragment library. The only positives from this screen identified traA segments. The fusion sites between the traA and GAL4 segments identified the hydrophobic, C-terminal domain IV of F-pilin as sufficient for the interaction. As TraQ is the only Tra protein required for the accumulation of inner membrane F-pilin, the interaction probably reflects a specific, chaperone-like function for TraQ in E. coli. Attempts to isolate an F-pilin-TraQ complex from E. coli were unsuccessful, suggesting that the interaction between the two is normally transient, as expected from previous studies of the kinetics of TraA membrane insertion and processing to F-pilin.

Spontaneous cAMP-dependent derepression of gene expression in stationary phase plays a role in recombinant expression instability

E. coli recombinant expression systems that utilize lac operon control elements to modulate gene expression are known to produce some amount of uninduced (leaky) gene expression. Previously, we showed that high levels of uninduced gene expression was a major cause of instability in the pET expression system. We show here that the pET system, in which the phage T7 RNA polymerase gene is expressed via lac operon control elements, exhibits leaky expression that increases markedly as cells grown in complex medium enter stationary phase. Moreover, we found that this phenomenon occurs with the chromosomal lac operon as well. Further investigation revealed that stationary phase leaky expression requires cyclic AMP, and that substantial leaky expression could be effected in log phase cells by adding cyclic AMP and acetate at pH6.0. Finally, a comparison of otherwise isogenic cya and wild-type hosts showed that expression stability and plasmid maintenance in the cya host is greatly enhanced, even when cells are passaged repeatedly in non-selection medium. These findings both provide a method to enhance the stability of lac-based recombinant expression systems, and suggest that derepression of the lac operon in the absence of inducer may be part of a general cellular response to nutrient limitation.

Selective phage infection mediated by epitope expression on F pilus

Proteins and peptides can be displayed on bacterial and bacteriophage surfaces as fusions to bacterial integral membrane proteins or phage coat proteins. We now report on the expression of peptide antigens on the surface of F pili, elaborated by F+ strains of Escherichia coli. The peptides were expressed as fusions to F pilin, the building block of the F pilus that is encoded by the traA gene on the F plasmid. Filamentous bacteriophage infection of E. coli is normally mediated by phage binding to pilin at the F pili tip. Expression of 13 to 15 amino acid long peptides on the F pilus completely blocked infection by derivatives of wild-type infectious M13 phage. However, when a phage displaying a specific recombinant antibody fragment was allowed to interact with F pili displaying an antigenic peptide a bacterial infection could be demonstrated. This infection, mediated by the antibody-antigen interaction, resulted in bacterial cells containing plasmids encoding both the protein and the ligand. In a model library, where a scFv antibody against the human cytomegalovirus AD-2 epitope was selected we achieved an enrichment of 2500 of phage carrying the specific antibody, indicating an efficient selective infection.

Effect of traY amber mutations on F-plasmid traY promoter activity in vivo

We have examined the effect of the F plasmid TraY protein on tra gene expression in vivo. Expression was assayed as alkaline phosphatase activity in cells containing a traY phi(traA'-'phoA)hyb operon under traY promoter control. Amber mutations in traY significantly reduced alkaline phosphatase activity. Since nonsense polarity effects were minimal, if they occurred at all, these data provide the first direct evidence that TraY regulates tra gene expression.

Analysis of the sequence and gene products of the transfer region of the F sex factor

Bacterial conjugation results in the transfer of DNA of either plasmid or chromosomal origin between microorganisms. Transfer begins at a defined point in the DNA sequence, usually called the origin of transfer (oriT). The capacity of conjugative DNA transfer is a property of self-transmissible plasmids and conjugative transposons, which will mobilize other plasmids and DNA sequences that include a compatible oriT locus. This review will concentrate on the genes required for bacterial conjugation that are encoded within the transfer region (or regions) of conjugative plasmids. One of the best-defined conjugation systems is that of the F plasmid, which has been the paradigm for conjugation systems since it was discovered nearly 50 years ago. The F transfer region (over 33 kb) contains about 40 genes, arranged contiguously. These are involved in the synthesis of pili, extracellular filaments which establish contact between donor and recipient cells; mating-pair stabilization; prevention of mating between similar donor cells in a process termed surface exclusions; DNA nicking and transfer during conjugation; and the regulation of expression of these functions. This review is a compendium of the products and other features found in the F transfer region as well as a discussion of their role in conjugation. While the genetics of F transfer have been described extensively, the mechanism of conjugation has proved elusive, in large part because of the low levels of expression of the pilus and the numerous envelope components essential for F plasmid transfer. The advent of molecular genetic techniques has, however, resulted in considerable recent progress. This summary of the known properties of the F transfer region is provided in the hope that it will form a useful basis for future comparison with other conjugation systems.

The Escherichia coli K-12 F plasmid gene traX is required for acetylation of F pilin

The Escherichia coli F plasmid gene required for amino-terminal acetylation of F-pilin subunits was identified. Using Western blots (immunoblots), we assayed the reaction of monoclonal antibodies with F-pilin polypeptides in inner membrane preparations from various F mutant strains. It was known that JEL92 recognizes an internal pilin epitope and JEL93 recognizes the acetylated amino-terminal sequence (L.S. Frost, J.S. Lee, D.G. Scraba, and W. Paranchych, J. Bacteriol. 168:192-198, 1986). As expected, neither antibody reacted with inner membranes from F- cells or Flac derivatives that do not synthesize pilin. Mutations that affected the individual activities of F tra genes traA, -B, -C, -D, -E, -F, -G, -H, -I, -J, -K, -L, -M, -N, -P, -R, -U, -V and -W or trb genes trbA, -B, -C, -D, -E, -G, -H, and -I did not prevent JEL92 or JEL93 recognition of membrane pilin. However, Hfr deletion mutants that lacked the most-distal transfer region genes did not express pilin that reacted with JEL93. Nevertheless, all strains that retained traA and traQ did express JEL92-reactive pilin polypeptides. Analysis of strains expressing cloned tra segments showed that traA and traQ suffice for synthesis of JEL92-reactive pilin, but synthesis of JEL93-reactive pilin is additionally dependent on traX. We concluded that the traX product is required for acetylation of F pilin. Interestingly, our data also showed that TraA+ TraQ+ cells synthesize two forms of pilin which migrate at approximately 7 and 8 kDa. In TraX+ cells, both become acetylated and react with JEL93. Preparations of wild-type F-pilus filaments contain both types of subunits.

Sequence alterations affecting F plasmid transfer gene expression: a conjugation system dependent on transcription by the RNA polymerase of phage T7

We constructed derivatives of the Escherichia coli conjugative plasmid F that carry altered sequences in place of the major transfer operon promoter, PY. Replacement of PY with a promoter-deficient sequence resulted in a transfer-deficient, F-pilus-specific phage-resistant plasmid (pOX38-tra701) that could still express TraJ and TraT; TraY, F-pilin, TraD, and TraI were not detectable on Western blots. On a second plasmid (pOX38-tra715) we replaced PY with a phage T7 late promoter sequence. In hosts carrying a lacUV5-promoter-regulated T7 RNA polymerase gene, all transfer-associated properties of pOX38-tra715 could be regulated with IPTG. After induction, pOX38-tra715 transferred at the wild-type frequency, expressed normal numbers of F-pili and conferred sensitivity to pilus-specific phages. No adverse effects on cell viability were apparent, and additional mutations could easily be crossed onto pOX38-tra715. A traJ deletion (pOX38-tra716) had no effect on the IPTG-induced transfer phenotype. Insertion of cam into trbC, resulted in a mutant (pOX38-tra715trbC33) which, after induction, exhibited the same phenotype associated with other trbC mutants; it could also be complemented by expression of trbC in trans. With pOX38-tra715 or its derivatives, we were able to label specifically the products of tra genes located throughout the long tra operon, by using rifampicin. This feature can be used to investigate transfer protein interactions and to follow changes in these proteins that are associated with conjugal mating events.

FinOP repression of the F plasmid involves extension of the half-life of FinP antisense RNA by FinO

The transfer operon of the F plasmid is positively regulated by the traJ gene product, expression of which, in turn, is regulated by both an antisense RNA, FinP, and the FinO protein (the FinOP system). A finP- F plasmid, pSFL20, was constructed by site-directed mutagenesis and was found to produce wild-type levels of pili encoded by the transfer operon. Transcription of the traJ gene was decreased by a factor of 3-5 fold in the presence of FinOP with no accumulation of a stable RNA duplex between the FinP RNA and the portion of the traJ mRNA which is complementary to finP. Stabilization of FinP RNA by FinO occurs in the absence of traJ transcripts, suggesting that FinO may interact directly with FinP to prevent its degradation.

Arc and Sfr functions of the Escherichia coli K-12 arcA gene product are genetically and physiologically separable

The Escherichia coli arcA gene product regulates chromosomal gene expression in response to deprivation of oxygen (Arc function; Arc stands for aerobic respiration control) and is required for expression of the F plasmid DNA transfer (tra) genes (Sfr function; Sfr stands for sex factor regulation). Using appropriate lacZ fusions, we have examined the relationship between these two genetic regulatory functions. Arc function in vivo was measured by anaerobic repression of a chromosomal sdh-lacZ operon fusion (sdh stands for succinate dehydrogenase). Sfr function was measured by activation of a plasmid traY-lacZ gene fusion. An eight-codon insertion near the 5' terminus of arcA, designated arcA1, abolished Arc function, as previously reported by S. Iuchi and E.C.C. Lin (Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 85:1888-1892, 1988), but left Sfr function largely (greater than or equal to 60%) intact. Similarly, the arcB1 mutation, which depressed sdh expression and is thought to act by abolishing the signal input that elicits ArcA function, had little effect (less than or equal to 20%) on the Sfr function of the arcA+ gene product. Conversely, a valine-to-methionine mutation at codon 203 (the sfrA5 allele) essentially abolished Sfr activity without detectably altering Arc activity. These data indicate that Sfr and Arc functions are separately expressed and regulated properties of the same protein.

Regulation of the F plasmid traY promoter in Escherichia coli K12 as a function of sequence context

TraJ and SfrA are, respectively, plasmid and host (Escherichia coli)-encoded proteins normally required for F plasmid traY promoter function. Beginning with plasmids in which a traY-lacZ fusion gene, designated phi (traY'-'lacZ)hyb, and lacY are expressed from the F plasmid traY promoter, we isolated mutants in which lac gene expression was SfrA or TraJ-independent. A total of 45 of 50 SfrA-independent isolates obtained after 2-aminopurine mutagenesis proved to have chromosomal mutations, whereas four out of four isolates obtained without mutagenesis had plasmid mutations. All of 17 isolates selected for TraJ-independent expression after mutagenesis had plasmid mutations. By restriction endonuclease digestions, 25 of 26 SfrA-independent and TraJ-independent plasmid mutations were insertions. Four of the former and three of the latter were examined further. By sequence analysis, all seven proved to be IS1 or IS2 insertions defining five insertion sites between base-pairs -49 and -82 with respect to the major traY transcription initiation site. In two cases, the same insertion allele was obtained from the two selection schemes. All three of the mutants selected for TraJ-independent gene expression manifested SfrA-independent expression as well, and levels of beta-galactosidase in different plasmid mutant strains lacking TraJ and SfrA were indistinguishable. By primer extension analysis, transcription initiation sites for traY mRNA synthesis were unaltered by the mutations. Replacing the tra sequence upstream from base-pair -78, without genetic selection, increased beta-galactosidase activity in the absence of TraJ and SfrA greater than tenfold. Activity increased two- to threefold more in a traJ+ sfrA mutant strain, and fivefold more in a traJ+ sfrA+ strain. Activity was unaltered in an sfrA+ strain without TraJ. By primer extension analysis, the traY promoter was utilized under all conditions. The data indicate that regulation of traY promoter activity is strongly dependent on sequence context.

Regulation of the F plasmid traY promoter in Escherichia coli by host and plasmid factors

F plasmid DNA transfer (tra) gene expression in Escherichia coli is regulated by chromosome- and F-encoded gene products. To study the relationship among these regulatory factors, we constructed low-copy plasmids containing a phi(traY'-'lacZ)hyb gene that couples beta-galactosidase and Lac permease synthesis to the F plasmid traY promoter. Wild-type transformants maintained high levels of beta-galactosidase over a broad range of culture densities. Primer extension analysis of tra mRNA from F'lac and phi(traY'-'lacZ)hyb strains indicated very similar, though not identical, transcription initiation sites. Moreover, phi(traY'-'lacZ)hyb gene expression required both TraJ and SfrA, as does tra gene expression in F+ strains. beta-Galactosidase activity was reduced approximately 30-fold in the absence of TraJ, which could be supplied in cis or in trans. In a two-plasmid system in which TraJ was supplied in trans by a lac-traJ operon fusion, phi(traY'-'lacZ)hyb expression was a linear, saturable function of traJ expression. Enzyme activity was reduced approximately tenfold in sfrA mutants. That reduction could not be attributed to an effect on the TraJ level. Several other cellular or environmental variables had only a modest effect on phi(traY'-'lacZ)hyb expression. Hyperexpression was observed at high cell density (twofold) and in anaerobic cultures (1.2- to 1.5-fold). In contrast, expression was reduced twofold in integration host factor mutants.

Structure and function of conjugative pili: monoclonal antibodies as probes for structural variants of F pili

The lac-tra operon fusion plasmid pTG801 contains the known F plasmid DNA transfer (tra) genes required by Escherichia coli to elaborate functional F pili (T. Grossman and P. M. Silverman, J. Bacteriol. 171:650-656, 1989). Here, we show that these pili are actually structural variants of normal F pili and that the F plasmid must contain additional genes that affect pilus structure and function. We confirmed a previous report that two monoclonal antibodies that recognize epitopes at and near the amino terminus of F pilin do not decorate the sides of normal F pili, as determined by immunogold electron microscopy. However, both antibodies laterally decorated pTG801 pili. The epitope for one of the antibodies has been shown to include the amino-terminal acetyl group of F pilin, which must therefore also be present on pTG801 pilin. Normal antibody staining was restored to pTG801 pili when cells contained, in addition to pTG801, the compatible plasmid pRS31, which must therefore include at least one gene affecting F-pilus structure. One candidate, traD, was excluded as the sole such gene, since traD+ derivatives of a pTG801 strain still elaborated pili that could be laterally decorated with antibody. Moreover, although traD alone restored RNA bacteriophage R17 infectivity to pTG801 cells, as expected, it did not mimic pRS31 in restoring to pTG801 pili other characteristics of normal F pili. We conclude that pRS31 contains as yet uncharacterized genes required for elaboration of structurally normal F pili. Finally, we identified vesicular material, especially abundant in cultures of pTG801 transformants, that stained heavily with the anti-F-pilin monoclonal antibodies. This material may reflect the inner membrane pool of F pilin.