Specificity of the mutator effect caused by disruption of the RAD1 excision repair gene of Saccharomyces cerevisiae

Mutational signatures and increased retrotransposon insertions in xeroderma pigmentosum variant skin tumors

Xeroderma pigmentosum variant (XP-V) is an autosomal recessive disease with an increased risk of developing cutaneous neoplasms in sunlight-exposed regions. These cells are deficient in the translesion synthesis (TLS) DNA polymerase eta, responsible for bypassing different types of DNA lesions. From the exome sequencing of 11 skin tumors of a genetic XP-V patients' cluster, classical mutational signatures related to sunlight exposure, such as C>T transitions targeted to pyrimidine dimers, were identified. However, basal cell carcinomas also showed distinct C>A mutation spectra reflecting a mutational signature possibly related to sunlight-induced oxidative stress. Moreover, four samples carry different mutational signatures, with C>A mutations associated with tobacco chewing or smoking usage. Thus, XP-V patients should be warned of the risk of these habits. Surprisingly, higher levels of retrotransposon somatic insertions were also detected when the tumors were compared with non-XP skin tumors, revealing other possible causes for XP-V tumors and novel functions for the TLS polymerase eta in suppressing retrotransposition. Finally, the expected high mutation burden found in most of these tumors renders these XP patients good candidates for checkpoint blockade immunotherapy.

The XPF-ERCC1 Complex Is Essential for Genome Stability and Is Involved in the Mechanism of Gene Targeting in Physcomitrella patens

The XPF-ERCC1 complex, a highly conserved structure-specific endonuclease, functions in multiple DNA repair pathways that are pivotal for maintaining genome stability, including nucleotide excision repair, interstrand crosslink repair, and homologous recombination. XPF-ERCC1 incises double-stranded DNA at double-strand/single-strand junctions, making it an ideal enzyme for processing DNA structures that contain partially unwound strands. Here, we have examined the role of the XPF-ERCC1 complex in the model bryophyte Physcomitrella patens which exhibits uniquely high gene targeting frequencies. We undertook targeted knockout of the Physcomitrella ERCC1 and XPF genes. Mutant analysis shows that the endonuclease complex is essential for resistance to UV-B and to the alkylating agent MMS, and contributes to the maintenance of genome integrity but is also involved in gene targeting in this model plant. Using different constructs we determine whether the function of the XPF-ERCC1 endonuclease complex in gene targeting was removal of 3' non-homologous termini, similar to SSA, or processing of looped-out heteroduplex intermediates. Interestingly, our data suggest a role of the endonuclease in both pathways and have implications for the mechanism of targeted gene replacement in plants and its specificities compared to yeast and mammalian cells.

Contrasting properties of gene-specific regulatory, coding, and copy number mutations in Saccharomyces cerevisiae: frequency, effects, and dominance

Genetic variation within and between species can be shaped by population-level processes and mutation; however, the relative impact of “survival of the fittest” and “arrival of the fittest” on phenotypic evolution remains unclear. Assessing the influence of mutation on evolution requires understanding the relative rates of different types of mutations and their genetic properties, yet little is known about the functional consequences of new mutations. Here, we examine the spectrum of mutations affecting a focal gene in Saccharomyces cerevisiae by characterizing 231 novel haploid genotypes with altered activity of a fluorescent reporter gene. 7% of these genotypes had a nonsynonymous mutation in the coding sequence for the fluorescent protein and were classified as “coding” mutants; 2% had a change in the S. cerevisiae TDH3 promoter sequence controlling expression of the fluorescent protein and were classified as “cis-regulatory” mutants; 10% contained two copies of the reporter gene and were classified as “copy number” mutants; and the remaining 81% showed altered fluorescence without a change in the reporter gene itself and were classified as “trans-acting” mutants. As a group, coding mutants had the strongest effect on reporter gene activity and always decreased it. By contrast, 50%–95% of the mutants in each of the other three classes increased gene activity, with mutants affecting copy number and cis-regulatory sequences having larger median effects on gene activity than trans-acting mutants. When made heterozygous in diploid cells, coding, cis-regulatory, and copy number mutant genotypes all had significant effects on gene activity, whereas 88% of the trans-acting mutants appeared to be recessive. These differences in the frequency, effects, and dominance among functional classes of mutations might help explain why some types of mutations are found to be segregating within or fixed between species more often than others.

Genetic dissection of phenotypic differences within and between species has shown that mutations affecting either the expression or function of a gene product can contribute to phenotypic evolution; mutations that alter gene copy number have also been shown to be an important source of phenotypic variation. Predicting when and why one type of mutation is more likely to underlie a phenotypic change than another remains a pressing challenge for evolution biology. Understanding the relative frequency and properties of different types of mutations will help resolve this issue. To this end, we isolated 231 mutants with altered activity of a focal gene. Mutants were classified into one of four functional classes (i.e., coding, cis-regulatory, trans-acting, or copy number) based on the location and nature of mutation(s), or lack thereof, within the focal gene. Mutant effects on focal gene activity were assessed in both haploid and diploid cells. These data identified differences in the frequency, effects, and dominance (relative to the wild-type allele) among functional classes of mutants that help explain patterns of genetic variation within and between species.

Too many mutants with multiple mutations

It has recently become clear that the classical notion of the random nature of mutation does not hold for the distribution of mutations among genes: most collections of mutants contain more isolates with two or more mutations than predicted by the mutant frequency on the assumption of a random distribution of mutations. Excesses of multiples are seen in a wide range of organisms, including riboviruses, DNA viruses, prokaryotes, yeasts, and higher eukaryotic cell lines and tissues. In addition, such excesses are produced by DNA polymerases in vitro. These "multiples" appear to be generated by transient, localized hypermutation rather than by heritable mutator mutations. The components of multiples are sometimes scattered at random and sometimes display an excess of smaller distances between mutations. As yet, almost nothing is known about the mechanisms that generate multiples, but such mutations have the capacity to accelerate those evolutionary pathways that require multiple mutations where the individual mutations are neutral or deleterious. Examples that impinge on human health may include carcinogenesis and the adaptation of microbial pathogens as they move between individual hosts.

The spectrum of spontaneous mutations caused by deficiency in proteasome maturase Ump1 in Saccharomyces cerevisiae

Ump1 is responsible for maturation of the catalytic core of the 26S proteasome. Dysfunction of Ump1 causes an increase in the frequency of spontaneous mutations in Saccharomyces cerevisiae. In this study we analyze the spectrum of mutations occurring spontaneously in yeast deficient in Ump1 by use of the SUP4-o system. Single base substitutions predominate among the mutations analyzed (73 of the 91 alterations examined). Two major classes are GC to TA transversions and GC to AT transitions ( approximately 50 and approximately 30% of base substitutions, respectively). Besides base substitutions, almost all the major types of sequence alterations are represented. The specificity and distribution of mutations occurring in the ump1 strain are unique compared to the spectra previously established for other yeast mutators. However, the profile of mutations arising in this strain is similar to that observed in wild type. The same similarity has previously been reported for yeast deficient in Mms2, a protein involved in Rad6-dependent postreplication DNA repair (PRR). The specificity of the mutator effect caused by ump1 is discussed in light of the proposed role of the proteasome activity in the regulation of the PRR mechanisms.

The relative roles of three DNA repair pathways in preventing Caenorhabditis elegans mutation accumulation

Mutation is a central biological process whose rates and spectra are influenced by a variety of complex and interacting forces. Although DNA repair pathways are generally known to play key roles in maintaining genetic stability, much remains to be understood about the relative roles of different pathways in preventing the accumulation of mutations and the extent of heterogeneity in pathway-specific repair efficiencies across different genomic regions. In this study we examine mutation processes in base excision repair-deficient (nth-1) and nucleotide excision repair-deficient (xpa-1) Caenorhabditis elegans mutation-accumulation (MA) lines across 24 regions of the genome and compare our observations to previous data from mismatch repair-deficient (msh-2 and msh-6) and wild-type (N2) MA lines. Drastic variation in both average and locus-specific mutation rates, ranging two orders of magnitude for the latter, was detected among the four sets of repair-deficient MA lines. Our work provides critical insights into the relative roles of three DNA repair pathways in preventing C. elegans mutation accumulation and provides evidence for the presence of pathway-specific DNA repair territories in the C. elegans genome.

Clusters of mutations from transient hypermutability

Collections of mutants usually contain more mutants bearing multiple mutations than expected from the mutant frequency and a random distribution of mutations. This excess is seen in a variety of organisms and also after DNA synthesis in vitro. The excess is unlikely to originate in mutator mutants but rather from transient hypermutability resulting from a perturbation of one of the many transactions that maintain genetic fidelity. The multiple mutations are sometimes clustered and sometimes randomly distributed. We model some spectra as populations comprising a majority with a low mutation frequency and a minority with a high mutation frequency. In the case of mutants produced in vitro by a bacteriophage RB69 mutator DNA polymerase, mutants with two mutations are in approximately 10-fold excess and mutants with three mutations are in even greater excess. However, phenotypically undetectable mutations seen only as hitchhikers with detectable mutations are approximately 5-fold more frequent than mutants bearing detectable mutations, indicating that they arose in a subpopulation with a higher mutation frequency. Excess multiple mutations may contribute critically to carcinogenesis and to adaptive mutation, including the adaptations of pathogens as they move from host to host. In the case of the rapidly mutating riboviruses, the viral population appears to be composed of a majority with a mutation frequency substantially lower than the average and a minority with a huge mutational load.

Detection of Arabidopsis thaliana AtRAD1 cDNA variants and assessment of function by expression in a yeast rad1 mutant

The Saccharomyces cerevisiae RAD1 and human XPF genes encode a subunit of a nucleotide excision repair endonuclease that also is implicated in some forms of homologous recombination. An Arabidopsis thaliana gene (AtRAD1) encoding the orthologous plant protein has been identified recently. Here we report the isolation of three structurally distinct AtRAD1 cDNAs from A. thaliana leaf tissue RNA. One of the isolates (AtRAD1-1) corresponds to the cDNA previously shown to encode the full-length AtRad1 protein, whereas the other two (AtRAD1-2, AtRAD1-3) differ slightly in size due to variations at the 5' end of exon 6 or the 3' end of exon 7, respectively. The sequence differences argue that these cDNAs were probably templated by mRNAs generated via alternative splicing. Diagnostic polymerase chain reaction pointed to the presence of the AtRAD1-1 and AtRAD1-2 but not AtRAD1-3 transcripts in bud and root tissue, and to a fourth transcript (AtRAD1-4), having both alterations identified in AtRAD1-2 and AtRAD1-3, in root tissue. However, the low frequency of detection of AtRAD1-3 and AtRAD1-4 makes the significance of these tissue-specific patterns unclear. The predicted AtRad1-2, AtRad1-3 and AtRad1-4 proteins lack part of the region likely required for endonuclease complex formation. Expression of AtRAD1-2 and AtRAD1-3 in a yeast rad1 mutant did not complement the sensitivity to ultraviolet radiation or the recombination defect associated with the rad1 mutation. These results suggest that alternative splicing may modulate the levels of functional AtRad1 protein.

Activation of Ty transposition by mutagens

The induction of Ty1 transposition by mutagens (MMS and 4NQO) in asynchronous cultures and cells blocked in G1 and G2/M suggested G1 dependence of activation of Ty1 element by DNA damage. Northern blot analysis revealed immediate five-fold increase in levels of Ty1 transcript after 20min incubation of cells with 1 microg/ml 4NQO and four-fold increase in Ty1 RNA after treatment the cells with 0.1% MMS. Western blot analysis showed no difference in TyA protein in treated and untreated with mutagen cells. Quantitative mutagenicity assay and Northern blot analysis demonstrated dependence of induction of Ty1 element by DNA-damaging agents on the function of RAD9 gene and independence on DUN1 gene.

Mutational spectrum analysis of RNase H(35) deficient Saccharomyces cerevisiae using fluorescence-based directed termination PCR

Mutational spectrum analysis has become an informative genetic tool to understand those protein functions involved in mutation avoidance pathways since specific types of mutations are often associated with particular protein defects involved in DNA replication and repair. In this study, we describe a novel, fluorescence-based procedure for direct determination of deletions and insertions with 100% accuracy. We performed two complementary directed termination PCR with near infrared dye-labeled primers, followed by visualization of termination fragments using an automated Li-cor DNA sequencer. This method is used for rapid analysis of mutational spectra generated in nuclease-defective strains of Saccharomyces cerevisiae to elucidate the role of RNase H(35) in RNA primer removal during DNA replication and in mutation avoidance. Strains deficient in RNH35 displayed a distinct spontaneous mutation spectrum of deletions characterized by a unique 4 bp deletion in a lys2-Bgl allele. This was in sharp contrast to strains deficient in rad27 that displayed duplication mutations. Further analysis of mutations in a rnh35/rad27 double mutant revealed a mixed spectrum. These results indicate that RNase H(35) may participate in a redundant pathway in Okazaki fragment processing and that mutational spectra caused by protein deficiencies may be more intermediate-specific than pathway-specific.

Physical interaction between components of DNA mismatch repair and nucleotide excision repair

Nucleotide excision repair (NER) and DNA mismatch repair are required for some common processes although the biochemical basis for this requirement is unknown. Saccharomyces cerevisiae RAD14 was identified in a two-hybrid screen using MSH2 as "bait," and pairwise interactions between MSH2 and RAD1, RAD2, RAD3, RAD10, RAD14, and RAD25 subsequently were demonstrated by two-hybrid analysis. MSH2 coimmunoprecipitated specifically with epitope-tagged versions of RAD2, RAD10, RAD14, and RAD25. MSH2 and RAD10 were found to interact in msh3 msh6 and mlh1 pms1 double mutants, suggesting a direct interaction with MSH2. Mutations in MSH2 increased the UV sensitivity of NER-deficient yeast strains, and msh2 mutations were epistatic to the mutator phenotype observed in NER-deficient strains. These data suggest that MSH2 and possibly other components of DNA mismatch repair exist in a complex with NER proteins, providing a biochemical and genetical basis for these proteins to function in common processes.

Differences in the mutational specificities of sunlight and UVB radiation suggest a role for transversion-inducing DNA damage in solar photocarcinogenesis

Mutations induced by UVB radiation and natural sunlight in a plasmid-borne yeast (Saccharomyces cerevisiae) tRNA gene (SUP4-o) were characterised by DNA sequencing. For both agents, the majority (> 90%) of the total mutations analysed were single base-pair substitutions, but tandem substitutions and single base-pair deletions also were detected. Each agent induced all six types of base-pair change but the tandem substitutions involved exclusively G.C-->A.T transitions. However, the fractions of single and tandem G.C-->A.T transitions were reduced by about 50%, and the fraction of transversions at G.C pairs was increased by 11-fold for sunlight relative to UVB. Comparisons of the site and strand specificities of the substitutions suggested that dipyrimidine adducts were responsible for the transitions, and that other lesions induced by sunlight may have given rise to the transversions. The relevance of these findings to skin cancer is discussed.

Yeast Ty1 retrotransposition is stimulated by a synergistic interaction between mutations in chromatin assembly factor I and histone regulatory proteins

A screen for host mutations which increase the rate of transposition of Ty1 and Ty2 into a chromosomal target was used to identify factors influencing retroelement transposition. The fortuitous presence of a mutation in the CAC3 gene in the strain in which this screen was undertaken enabled us to discover that double mutaions of cac3 and hir3, but neither of the two single mutations, caused a dramatic increase in the rate of retrotransposition. We further showed that this effect was not due to an increase in the overall level of Ty1 mRNA. Two subtle cac3 phenotypes, slight methyl methanesulfonate (MMS) sensitivity and reduction of telomeric silencing, were significantly enhanced in the cac3 hir3 double mutant. In addition, the growth rate of the double mutant was reduced. HIR3 belongs to a class of HIR genes that regulate the transcription of histones, while Cac3p, together with Cac1p and Cac2p, forms chromatin assembly factor I. Other combinations of mutations in cac and hir genes (cac3 hir1, cac3 hir2, and cac2 hir3) also increase Ty transposition and MMS sensitivity and reduce the growth rate. A model explaining the synergistic interaction between cac and hir mutations in terms of alterations in chromatin structure is proposed.

DNA sequence analysis of spontaneous mutagenesis in Saccharomyces cerevisiae

To help elucidate the mechanisms involved in spontaneous mutagenesis, DNA sequencing has been applied to characterize the types of mutation whose rates are increased or decreased in mutator or antimutator strains, respectively. Increased spontaneous mutation rates point to malfunctions in genes that normally act to reduce spontaneous mutation, whereas decreased rates are associated with defects in genes whose products are necessary for spontaneous mutagenesis. In this article, we survey and discuss the mutational specificities conferred by mutator and antimutator genes in the budding yeast Saccharomyces cerevisiae. The implications of selected aspects of the data are considered with respect to the mechanisms of spontaneous mutagenesis.

Trinucleotide insertions, deletions, and point mutations in glucose transporters confer K+ uptake in Saccharomyces cerevisiae

Deletion of TRK1 and TRK2 abolishes high-affinity K+ uptake in Saccharomyces cerevisiae, resulting in the inability to grow on typical synthetic growth medium unless it is supplemented with very high concentrations of potassium. Selection for spontaneous suppressors that restored growth of trk1delta trk2delta cells on K+-limiting medium led to the isolation of cells with unusual gain-of-function mutations in the glucose transporter genes HXT1 and HXT3 and the glucose/galactose transporter gene GAL2. 86Rb uptake assays demonstrated that the suppressor mutations conferred increased uptake of the ion. In addition to K+, the mutant hexose transporters also conferred permeation of other cations, including Na+. Because the selection strategy required such gain of function, mutations that disrupted transporter maturation or localization to the plasma membrane were avoided. Thus, the importance of specific sites in glucose transport could be independently assessed by testing for the ability of the mutant transporter to restore glucose-dependent growth to cells containing null alleles of all of the known functional glucose transporter genes. Twelve sites, most of which are conserved among eukaryotic hexose transporters, were revealed to be essential for glucose transport. Four of these have previously been shown to be essential for glucose transport by animal or plant transporters. Eight represented sites not previously known to be crucial for glucose uptake. Each suppressor mutant harbored a single mutation that altered an amino acid(s) within or immediately adjacent to a putative transmembrane domain of the transporter. Seven of 38 independent suppressor mutations consisted of in-frame insertions or deletions. The nature of the insertions and deletions revealed a striking DNA template dependency: each insertion generated a trinucleotide repeat, and each deletion involved the removal of a repeated nucleotide sequence.

Induction of Ty recombination in yeast by cDNA and transcription: role of the RAD1 and RAD52 genes

In the yeast Saccharomyces cerevisiae ectopic recombination has been shown to occur at high frequencies for artificially created repeats, but at relatively low frequencies for a natural family of repeated sequences, the Ty family. Little is known about the mechanism(s) that prevent recombination between repeated sequences. We have previously shown that nonreciprocal recombination (gene conversion) of a genetically marked Ty can be induced either by the presence of high levels of Ty cDNA or by transcription of the marked Ty from a GAL1 promoter. These two kinds of induction act in a synergistic manner. To further characterize these two kinds of Ty recombination, we have investigated the role played by the RAD52 and RAD1 genes. We have found that the RAD52 and RAD1 gene products are essential to carry out transcription-induced Ty conversion whereas cDNA-mediated conversion can take place in their absence.

Specificities of the Saccharomyces cerevisiae rad6, rad18, and rad52 mutators exhibit different degrees of dependence on the REV3 gene product, a putative nonessential DNA polymerase

The Saccharomyces cerevisiae rad6, rad18, and rad52 mutants exhibit DNA repair deficiencies and distinct mutator phenotypes. DNA replication past unrepaired spontaneous damage might contribute to the specificities of these mutators. Because REV3 is thought to encode a DNA polymerase that specializes in translesion synthesis, we determined the REV3 dependence of the rad mutator specificities. Spontaneous mutagenesis at a plasmid-borne SUP4-o locus was examined in isogenic strains having combinations of normal or mutant REV3 and RAD6, RAD18, or RAD52 alleles. For the rad6 and rad18 mutators, the mutation rate increase relied largely, but not exclusively, on REV3 whereas the rad52 mutator was entirely REV3 dependent. The influence of REV3 on the specificity of the rad6 mutator differed markedly depending on the mutational class examined. However, the requirement of rev3 for the production of G.C-->T.A transversions by the rad18 mutator, which induces only these substitutions, was similar to that for rad6-mediated G.C-->T.A transversion. This supports a role for the Rad6-Rad18 protein complex in the control of spontaneous mutagenesis. The available data imply that the putative Rev3 polymerase can process a variety of spontaneous DNA lesions that normally are substrates for error-free repair.

Failure to detect an antimutator phenotype following disruption of the Saccharomyces cerevisiae DDR48 gene

The antimutator phenotype, reportedly conferred by disruption of the Saccharomyces cerevisiae DDR48 gene, was suggested to affect only a specific spontaneous mutational pathway. We attempted to identify the types of mutation that are DDR48-dependent by determining the specificity of the ddr48 antimutator. However, disruption of DDR48 did not decrease the rates of spontaneous forward mutation in a plasmid-borne copy of the yeast SUP4-o gene, the reversion or suppression of the lys2-1 allele, or forward mutation at the CAN1 locus. Interestingly, the latter gene had been reported previously to be subject to the antimutator effect. DNA sequence analysis of spontaneous SUP4-o mutations arising in DDR48 and ddr48 backgrounds provided no evidence for a reduction in the rates of individual mutational classes. Thus, we were unable to verify that disruption of DDR48 causes an antimutator phenotype.

A mutation in the gene encoding the Saccharomyces cerevisiae single-stranded DNA-binding protein Rfa1 stimulates a RAD52-independent pathway for direct-repeat recombination

In the yeast Saccharomyces cerevisiae, recombination between direct repeats is synergistically reduced in rad1 rad52 double mutants, suggesting that the two genes define alternate recombination pathways. Using a classical genetic approach, we searched for suppressors of the recombination defect in the double mutant. One mutation that restores wild-type levels of recombination was isolated. Cloning by complementation and subsequent physical and genetic analysis revealed that it maps to RAF1. This locus encodes the large subunit of the single-stranded DNA-binding protein complex, RP-A, which is conserved from S. cerevisiae to humans. The rfa1 mutation on its own causes a 15-fold increase in direct-repeat recombination. However, unlike most other hyperrecombination mutations, the elevated levels in rfa1 mutants occur independently of RAD52 function. Additionally, rfa1 mutant strains grow slowly, are UV sensitive, and exhibit decreased levels of heteroallelic recombination. DNA sequence analysis of rfa1 revealed a missense mutation that alters a conserved residue of the protein (aspartic acid 228 to tyrosine [D228Y]). Biochemical analysis suggests that this defect results in decreased levels of RP-A in mutant strains. Overexpression of the mutant subunit completely suppresses the UV sensitivity and partially suppresses the recombination phenotype. We propose that the defective complex fails to interact properly with components of the repair, replication, and recombination machinery. Further, this may permit the bypass of the recombination defect of rad1 rad52 mutants by activating an alternative single-stranded DNA degradation pathway.

Interactions among mutations affecting spontaneous mutation, mitotic recombination, and DNA repair in yeast

The mutant alleles mms9-1, mms13-1, or mms21-1 of Saccharomyces cerevisiae confer pleiotropic effects, including sensitivity to the alkylating agent methyl methanesulfonate, elevations in spontaneous mutation and mitotic recombination, defects in meiosis, and cross-sensitivity to radiation. We constructed double-mutant strains containing an mms mutation and a defect in either excision repair, mutagenic repair, or recombinational repair and measured the levels of spontaneous mutation and mitotic recombination. Double mutants lacking excision repair show elevations in spontaneous mutation but with predominantly unchanged levels of mitotic recombination. RAD52 function was required for the expression of the hyper-recombination phenotype of the mms9-1, mms13-1, and mms21-1 alleles; double mutants displayed the very low recombination levels characteristic of rad52 mutants. Phenotypes of double mutants containing one of the mms alleles and either of the hyper-recombination/mutator rad6-1 or rad3-102 alleles suggest that the mutagenic lesions in mms strains may not be identical to the recombinogenic lesions.

Excision repair and gene orientation modulate the strand specificity of UV mutagenesis in a plasmid-borne yeast tRNA gene

Ultraviolet (UV) mutagenesis in a plasmid-borne Saccharomyces cerevisiae tRNA gene (SUP4-o) occurs preferentially at sites where the pyrimidine in the base pair is part of a dipyrimidine sequence on the transcribed strand. In this study, we examined whether excision repair, or strand identity with respect to DNA replication, influences this strand bias. The specificity of UV mutagenesis was determined for a wild type (RAD) strain and an isogenic excision repair-deficient (rad1) derivative, each carrying SUP4-o on the vector YCpMP2, or another vector (YCpJA1) that differed only in the orientation of SUP4-o with respect to a unique origin of replication. Most (> or = 90%) of the SUP4-o mutations induced by UV in these strains were single base pair substitutions, predominantly (> 87%) transitions. The rad1 defect and inversion of SUP4-o in the RAD strain eliminated the strand preference, whereas inversion of SUP4-o in the rad1 strain caused it to reappear. Both conditions also altered the distribution of frequently mutated sites and the relative fraction of transitions at TT sequences. These results suggest that excision repair and gene orientation can be important determinants for the strand and site specificities of UV mutagenesis in SUP4-o on YCpMP2 and YCpJA1. We consider several possible explanations for our observations, including potential roles for transcription by RNA polymerase II, sequence context effects on the efficiency of excision repair, and inherent differences in strand mutability or translesion synthesis by the leading and lagging strand DNA replication complexes.

Spontaneous mutation at the mtr locus in neurospora: the molecular spectrum in wild-type and a mutator strain

Sequence analysis of 34 mtr mutations has yielded the first molecular spectrum of spontaneous mutants in Neurospora crassa. The great majority of the mutations are base substitutions (48%) or deletions (35%). In addition, sequence analysis of the entire mtr region, including the 1472-base pair open reading frame and 1205 base pairs of flanking DNA, was performed in both the Oak Ridge and Mauriceville strains of Neurospora, which are known to be divergent at the DNA level. Sixteen sequence differences between these two strains have been found in the mtr region, with 13 of these in DNA flanking the open reading frame. The differences consisted of base substitutions and small frameshifts at monotonic runs. This set of sequence differences has allowed a comparison of mutations in unselected DNA to those mutations that produce a phenotypic signal. We have isolated a mutator strain (mut-1) of Neurospora in which the spontaneous mutation rate at various loci is as much as 80-fold higher than in the non-mutator (wild type). Twenty-one mtr mutations in the mutator background have been sequenced and compared to the non-mutator spectrum, revealing a striking increase in -1 frameshift mutations. These frameshifts occur exclusively within or adjacent to monotonic runs and can be explained by small slippage events during DNA replication. This argues for a role of the mut-1 gene in this process.

Specificity of the mutator caused by deletion of the yeast structural gene (APN1) for the major apurinic endonuclease

The loss of bases from cellular DNA occurs via both spontaneous and mutagen-induced reactions. The resulting apurinic/apyrimidinic (AP) sites are cytotoxic and mutagenic but are counteracted by repair initiated by AP endonucleases. Previously, in vitro and bacterial transfection studies suggested that AP sites often prompt insertion of dAMP residues during replication, the A-rule. Dissimilar results have been obtained by transfecting DNA into eukaryotic cells. It seemed possible that these differences might be due to idiosyncrasies of transfection or aberrant replication of the transecting DNA. The observation that AP endonuclease-deficient strains of the yeast Saccharomyces cerevisiae have elevated spontaneous mutation rates allowed us to determine the mutational specificity of endogenously generated AP sites in nuclear DNA. With the yeast SUP4-o gene as a mutational target, we found that a deficiency in the major yeast AP endonuclease, Apn1, provoked mainly single base-pair substitution; the rate of transposon Ty insertion was also enhanced. The rate of transversion to a G.C pair was increased 10-fold in Apn1-deficient yeast, including a 59-fold increase in the rate of A.T-->C.G events. In contrast, the rate of transversion to an A.T pair was increased by only 3-fold. A deficiency in N3-methyladenine glycosylase offset these substitution rate increases, indicating that they are due primarily to AP sites resulting from glycosylase action. Thus, the A-rule does not seem to apply to the mutagenic processing of endogenous abasic sites in S. cerevisiae. Other results presented here show that AP endonuclease-deficient Escherichia coli exhibit a mutator phenotype consistent with the A-rule.

Unrepaired heteroduplex DNA in Saccharomyces cerevisiae is decreased in RAD1 RAD52-independent recombination

A direct repeat recombination assay between SUP4 heteroalleles detects unrepaired heteroduplex DNA (hDNA) as sectored colonies. The frequency of unrepaired heteroduplex is dependent on the mismatch and is highest in a construct that generates C:C or G:G mispairs and lowest in one that generates T:G or C:A mispairs. In addition, unrepaired hDNA increases for all mismatches tested in pms1 mismatch repair-deficient strains. These results support the notion that hDNA is formed across the SUP4 repeats during the recombination event and is then subject to mismatch repair. The effects of various repair and recombination defective mutations on this assay were examined. Unrepaired heteroduplex increases significantly only in rad52 mutant strains. In addition, direct repeat recombination is reduced 2-fold in rad52 mutant strains, while in rad51, rad54, rad55 and rad57 mutants direct repeat recombination is increased 3-4-fold. Mutations in the excision repair gene, RAD1, do not affect the frequency of direct repeat recombination. However, the level of unrepaired heteroduplex is slightly decreased in rad1 mutant strains. Similar to previous studies, rad1 rad52 double mutants show a synergistic reduction in direct repeat recombination (35-fold). Interestingly, unrepaired heteroduplex is reduced 4-fold in the double mutants. Experiments with shortened repeats suggest that the reduction in unrepaired heteroduplex is due to decreased hDNA tract length in the double mutant strain.

Mutational specificity of thymine nucleotide depletion in yeast

Relative to normal growth conditions for a wild-type strain of the yeast Saccharomyces cerevisiae, withholding thymidylate (dTMP) severely diminished the dTTP pool but elevated the dATP, dGTP and dCTP levels (120-, 8.5- and 3.6-fold, respectively) in an isogenic dTMP auxotroph. This treatment also increased the frequency of mutations in a tRNA gene (SUP4-o) by 15-fold. Single base-pair events accounted for 97% of the 89 SUP4-o mutations characterized by DNA sequencing and the ratio of transversions to transitions was 3-fold greater than that for spontaneous substitutions in the wild-type strain. This difference was due to decreases in the fractions of transitions and an increase in the proportion of A.T-->T.A transversions. The largest increases in mutation frequency were observed for transversions at A.T pairs, consistent with dATP and dGTP being incorporated in place of dTTP during DNA replication. Similarly, misinsertion of dATP and dGTP could have promoted the single base-pair deletions and insertion detected. Analysis of the distributions of substitutions indicated no preference for dATP misinsertion to occur at sites flanked by a specific 5' or 3' base or on the transcribed or nontranscribed strands. However, the presence of mutational hotspots and site-specific variations in the substitution frequencies implied a role for DNA sequence context in the mutational specificity of dTTP depletion.

Bridge-building between mathematical theory and molecular biology: the REV2 gene as paradigm

The DNA damage-repair theory of R.H. Haynes anticipated the possibility of dose-dependent repair processes. The mathematical formalism developed by Haynes and coworkers on the basis of this theory provided tools to probe for the existence of inducible components of mutation or recombination by analysis of dose-response curves. Subsequently, we found that biological and molecular analysis of the Saccharomyces cerevisiae REV2 gene supported the validity of the postulates derived from the mathematical analysis. In this article, we briefly review the foregoing and summarize evidence that the REV2 gene product might function in DNA damage-inducible repair and mutation processes.

Differential repair and recombination of psoralen damaged plasmid DNA in Saccharomyces cerevisiae

Psoralen photoreaction with DNA produces interstrand crosslinks, which require the activity of excision and recombinational pathways for repair. Yeast replicating plasmids, carrying the HIS3, TRP1, and URA3 genes, were photoreacted with psoralen in vitro and transfected into Saccharomyces cerevisiae cells. Repair was assayed as the relative transformation efficiency. A recombination-deficient rad52 strain was the least efficient in the repair of psoralen-damaged plasmids; excision repair-deficient rad1 and rad3 strains had repair efficiencies intermediate between those of rad52 and RAD cells. The level of repair also depended on the conditions of transformant selection; repair was more efficient in medium lacking tryptophan than in medium from which either histidine or uracil was omitted. The plasmid repair differential between these selective media was greatest in rad1 cells, and depended on RAD52. Plasmid-chromosome recombination was stimulated by psoralen damage, and required RAD52 function. Chromosome to plasmid gene conversion was seen most frequently at the HIS3 locus. In RAD and rad3 cells, the majority of the conversions were associated with plasmid integration, while in rad1 cells most were non-crossover events. Plasmid to chromosome gene conversion was observed most frequently at the TRP1 locus, and was accompanied by plasmid loss.

Influence of DNA repair defects (rad1, rad52) on nitrogen mustard mutagenesis in yeast

Nitrogen mustard (HN2) mutagenesis of a plasmid-borne copy of the Saccharomyces cerevisiae SUP4-o gene was examined in a repair-proficient yeast strain and isogenic derivatives defective for excision (rad1) or DNA double-strand break (rad52) repair. The excision repair deficiency sensitized the cells to killing by HN2 and abolished mutation induction. Inactivation of RAD52 had no influence on the lethality of HN2 treatment but diminished the induced mutation frequency by 50% at all doses tested. DNA sequence analysis of HN2-induced SUP4-o mutations suggested that RAD52 contributed to the production of basepair substitutions at G.C sites. The rad52 defect appeared to alter the distribution of G.C-->A.T transitions in SUP4-o relative to the distribution for the wild-type strain. This difference did not seem to be due to an effect of RAD52 on the relative fractions of HN2-induced transitions at localized (flanked by A.T pairs) or contiguous (flanked by at least one G.C pair) G.C sites but instead to an influence on the strand specificity of HN2 mutagenesis. In the repair-proficient strain, the transitions showed a small bias for sites having the guanine on the transcribed strand and this preference was eliminated by inactivation of RAD52.

Excision repair influences the site and strand specificity of sunlight mutagenesis in yeast

A collection of 384 mutations recovered in a tRNA gene (SUP4-o) following exposure of isogenic excision-repair-proficient (RAD1) or deficient (rad1) strains of the yeast Saccharomyces cerevisiae to sunlight was characterized by DNA sequencing. In each case, greater than 90% of the mutations were single base-pair substitutions with events at G.C pairs constituting most of the changes. However, more than half of these substitutions were transversions in the RAD1 strain whereas transitions predominated in the rad1 strain. Tandem double substitutions were recovered in both strains and the individual changes were exclusively G.C----A.T transitions. The majority of single substitutions, and all tandem double changes, were at base-pairs where the pyrimidine(s) was part of a dipyrimidine sequence and the site specificities were consistent with cyclobutane dimers and/or pyrimidine (6-4) pyrimidone photoproducts contributing to sunlight mutagenesis. Yet, the data also pointed to an important role for lesions that form at G.C pairs and give rise to transversions. Analysis of the strand specificity of sunlight mutagenesis indicated that transitions or transversions at G.C pairs occurred preferentially in SUP4-o at sites where a dipyrimidine or a guanine, respectively, was on the transcribed strand. These biases required a functional excision-repair system.

Inactivation of the RAD1 excision-repair gene does not affect correction of mismatches on heteroduplex plasmid DNA in yeast

The efficiency and direction of mismatch correction in the Saccharomyces cerevisiae SUP4-o gene were not altered by an excision-repair defect (rad1). Although excision-repair functions remove methylated adenine from yeast, adenine methylation at a GAC sequence in SUP4-o did not direct the correction of mismatches via excision repair.

Elimination of the yeast RAD6 ubiquitin conjugase enhances base-pair transitions and G.C----T.A transversions as well as transposition of the Ty element: implications for the control of spontaneous mutation

The RAD6 gene of the yeast Saccharomyces cerevisiae encodes an enzyme that conjugates ubiquitin to other proteins. Defects in RAD6 confer a mutator phenotype due, in part, to an increased rate of transposition of the yeast Ty element. To further delineate the role of protein ubiquitination in the control of spontaneous mutagenesis in yeast, we have characterized 202 mutations that arose spontaneously in the SUP4-o gene carried on a centromere vector in a RAD6 deletion strain. The resulting mutational spectrum was compared to that for 354 spontaneous SUP4-o mutations isolated in the isogenic wild-type parent. This comparison revealed that the rad6 mutator enhanced the rate of single base-pair substitution, as well as Ty insertion, but did not affect the rates of the other mutational classes detected. Relative to the wild-type parent, Ty inserted at considerably more SUP4-o positions in the rad6 strain with a significantly smaller fraction detected at a transposition hotspot. These findings suggest that, in addition to the rate of transposition, protein ubiquitination might influence the target site specificity of Ty insertion. The increase in the substitution rate accounted for approximately 90% of the rad6 mutator effect but only the two transitions and the G. C----T.A transversion were enhanced. Analysis of the distribution of these events within SUP4-o suggested that the site specificity of the substitutions was influenced by DNA sequence context. Transformation of heteroduplex plasmid DNAs into the two strains demonstrated that the rad6 mutator did not reduce the efficiency of correcting mismatches that could give rise to the transitions or transversion nor did it bias restoration of the mismatches to the incorrect base-pairs. These results are discussed in relation to possible mechanisms that might link ubiquitination of proteins to spontaneous mutation rates.

The spectrum of spontaneous mutations in a Saccharomyces cerevisiae uracil-DNA-glycosylase mutant limits the function of this enzyme to cytosine deamination repair

Uracil-DNA-glycosylase has been proposed to function as the first enzyme in strand-directed mismatch repair in eukaryotic organisms, through removal of uracil from dUMP residues periodically inserted into the DNA during DNA replication (Aprelikova, O. N., V. M. Golubovskaya, T. A. Kusmin, and N. V. Tomilin, Mutat. Res. 213:135-140, 1989). This hypothesis was investigated with Saccharomyces cerevisiae. Mutation frequencies and spectra were determined for an ung1 deletion strain in the target SUP4-o tRNA gene by using a forward selection scheme. Mutation frequencies in the SUP4-o gene increased about 20-fold relative to an isogenic wild-type S. cerevisiae strain, and the mutator effect was completely suppressed in the ung1 deletion strain carrying the wild-type UNG1 gene on a multicopy plasmid. Sixty-nine independently derived mutations in the SUP4-o gene were sequenced. All but five of these were due to GC----AT transitions. From this analysis, we conclude that the mutator phenotype of the ung1 deletion strain is the result of a failure to repair spontaneous cytosine deamination events occurring frequently in S. cerevisiae and that the UNG1 gene is not required for strand-specific mismatch repair in S. cerevisiae.

Mutational specificity of DNA precursor pool imbalances in yeast arising from deoxycytidylate deaminase deficiency or treatment with thymidylate

Disruption of the dCMP deaminase (DCD1) gene, or provision of excess dTMP to a nucleotide-permeable strain, produced dramatic increases in the dCTP or dTTP pools, respectively, in growing cells of the yeast Saccharomyces cerevisiae. The mutation rate of the SUP4-o gene was enhanced 2-fold by the dCTP imbalance and 104-fold by the dTTP imbalance. 407 SUP4-o mutations that arose under these conditions, and 334 spontaneous mutations recovered in an isogenic strain having balanced DNA precursor levels, were characterized by DNA sequencing and the resulting mutational spectra were compared. Significantly more (greater than 98%) of the changes resulting from nucleotide pool imbalance were single base-pair events, the majority of which could have been due to misinsertion of the nucleotides present in excess. Unexpectedly, expanding the dCTP pool did not increase the fraction of A.T----G.C transitions relative to the spontaneous value nor did enlarging the dTTP pool enhance the proportion of G.C----A.T transitions. Instead, the elevated levels of dCTP or dTTP were associated primarily with increases in the fractions of G.C----C.G or A.T----T.A. transversions, respectively. Furthermore, T----C, and possibly A----C, events occurred preferentially in the dcd1 strain at sites where dCTP was to be inserted next. C----T and A----T events were induced most often by dTMP treatment at sites where the next correct nucleotide was dTTP or dGTP (dGTP levels were also elevated by dTMP treatment). Finally, misinsertion of dCTP or dTTP did not exhibit a strand bias. Collectively, our data suggest that increased levels of dCTP and dTTP induced mutations in yeast via nucleotide misinsertion and inhibition of proofreading but indicate that other factors must also be involved. We consider several possibilities, including potential roles for the regulation and specificity of proofreading and for mismatch correction.

A constant rate of spontaneous mutation in DNA-based microbes

In terms of evolution and fitness, the most significant spontaneous mutation rate is likely to be that for the entire genome (or its nonfrivolous fraction). Information is now available to calculate this rate for several DNA-based haploid microbes, including bacteriophages with single- or double-stranded DNA, a bacterium, a yeast, and a filamentous fungus. Their genome sizes vary by approximately 6500-fold. Their average mutation rates per base pair vary by approximately 16,000-fold, whereas their mutation rates per genome vary by only approximately 2.5-fold, apparently randomly, around a mean value of 0.0033 per DNA replication. The average mutation rate per base pair is inversely proportional to genome size. Therefore, a nearly invariant microbial mutation rate appears to have evolved. Because this rate is uniform in such diverse organisms, it is likely to be determined by deep general forces, perhaps by a balance between the usually deleterious effects of mutation and the physiological costs of further reducing mutation rates.

The yeast rad18 mutator specifically increases G.C----T.A transversions without reducing correction of G-A or C-T mismatches to G.C pairs

Inactivation of the Saccharomyces cerevisiae RAD18 gene confers a mutator phenotype. To determine the specificity of this effect, a collection of 212 spontaneous SUP4-o mutants arising in a rad18 strain was characterized by DNA sequencing. Comparison of the resulting mutational spectrum with that for an isogenic wild-type (RAD18) strain revealed that the rad18 mutator specifically enhanced the frequency of single base pair substitutions. Further analysis indicated that an increase in the frequency of G.C----T.A transversions accounted for the elevated SUP4-o mutation frequency. Thus, rad18 is the first eucaryotic mutator found to generate only a particular base pair substitution. The majority of G.C pairs that were not mutated in the rad18 background were at sites where G.C----T.A events can be detected in SUP4-o, suggesting that DNA sequence context influences the rad18 mutator effect. Transformation of heteroduplex plasmid DNAs into the two strains demonstrated that the rad18 mutator did not reduce the efficiency of correcting G-A or C-T mismatches to G.C pairs or preferentially correct the mismatches to A.T pairs. We propose that the RAD18 gene product might contribute to the fidelity of DNA replication in S. cerevisiae by involvement in a process that serves to limit the formation of G-A and C-T mismatches at template guanine and cytosine sites during DNA synthesis.

The yeast rad18 mutator specifically increases G.C----T.A transversions without reducing correction of G-A or C-T mismatches to G.C pairs

Inactivation of the Saccharomyces cerevisiae RAD18 gene confers a mutator phenotype. To determine the specificity of this effect, a collection of 212 spontaneous SUP4-o mutants arising in a rad18 strain was characterized by DNA sequencing. Comparison of the resulting mutational spectrum with that for an isogenic wild-type (RAD18) strain revealed that the rad18 mutator specifically enhanced the frequency of single base pair substitutions. Further analysis indicated that an increase in the frequency of G.C----T.A transversions accounted for the elevated SUP4-o mutation frequency. Thus, rad18 is the first eucaryotic mutator found to generate only a particular base pair substitution. The majority of G.C pairs that were not mutated in the rad18 background were at sites where G.C----T.A events can be detected in SUP4-o, suggesting that DNA sequence context influences the rad18 mutator effect. Transformation of heteroduplex plasmid DNAs into the two strains demonstrated that the rad18 mutator did not reduce the efficiency of correcting G-A or C-T mismatches to G.C pairs or preferentially correct the mismatches to A.T pairs. We propose that the RAD18 gene product might contribute to the fidelity of DNA replication in S. cerevisiae by involvement in a process that serves to limit the formation of G-A and C-T mismatches at template guanine and cytosine sites during DNA synthesis.

Site and strand specificity of UVB mutagenesis in the SUP4-o gene of yeast

DNA sequencing was used to characterize 208 mutations induced in the SUP4-o tRNA gene of the yeast Saccharomyces cerevisiae by UVB (285-320 nm) radiation. The results were compared to those for an analysis of 211 SUP4-o mutations induced by 254-nm UVC light. In each case, greater than 90% of the mutations were single base-pair changes but G.C----A.T transitions predominated and accounted for more of the mutations induced by UVB than UVC. Double substitutions, single base-pair deletions, and more complex events were also recovered. However, UVB induced 3-fold more tandem substitutions than UVC and nontandem double events were detected only after irradiation with UVC. Virtually all induced substitutions occurred at sites where the pyrimidine of the base pair was part of a dipyrimidine sequence. Although the site specificities were consistent with roles for cyclobutane dimers and pyrimidine-pyrimidone(6-4) lesions in mutation induction, preliminary photoreactivation data implicated cyclobutane dimers as the major form of premutational DNA damage for both agents. Intriguingly, there was a preference for both UVB- and UVC-induced mutations to occur at sites where the dipyrimidine was on the transcribed strand.