Mutations in pts cause catabolite-resistant sporulation and altered regulation of spo0H in Bacillus subtilis

An overview and future prospects of recombinant protein production in Bacillus subtilis

Bacillus subtilis is a well-characterized Gram-positive bacterium and a valuable host for recombinant protein production because of its efficient secretion ability, high yield, and non-toxicity. Here, we comprehensively review the recent studies on recombinant protein production in B. subtilis to update and supplement other previous reviews. We have focused on several aspects, including optimization of B. subtilis strains, enhancement and regulation of expression, improvement of secretion level, surface display of proteins, and fermentation optimization. Among them, optimization of B. subtilis strains mainly involves undirected chemical/physical mutagenesis and selection and genetic manipulation; enhancement and regulation of expression comprises autonomous plasmid and integrated expression, promoter regulation and engineering, and fine-tuning gene expression based on proteases and molecular chaperones; improvement of secretion level predominantly involves secretion pathway and signal peptide screening and optimization; surface display of proteins includes surface display of proteins on spores or vegetative cells; and fermentation optimization incorporates medium optimization, process condition optimization, and feeding strategy optimization. Furthermore, we propose some novel methods and future challenges for recombinant protein production in B. subtilis.Key points• A comprehensive review on recombinant protein production in Bacillus subtilis.• Novel techniques facilitate recombinant protein expression and secretion.• Surface display of proteins has significant potential for different applications.

Construction and development of an auto-regulatory gene expression system in Bacillus subtilis

BACKGROUND

Bacillus subtilis is an all-important Gram-positive bacterium of valuable biotechnological utility that has been widely used to over-produce industrially and pharmaceutically relevant proteins. There are a variety of expression systems in terms of types of transcriptional patterns, among which the auto-inducible and growth-phase-dependent promoters are gaining increasing favor due to their inducer-independent feature, allowing for the potential to industrially scale-up. To expand the applicability of the auto-inducible expression system, a novel auto-regulatory expression system coupled with cell density was constructed and developed in B. subtilis using the quorum-sensing related promoter srfA (PsrfA).

RESULTS

The promoter of the srf operon was used to construct an expression plasmid with the green fluorescent protein (GFP) downstream of PsrfA. The expression displayed a cell-density-dependent pattern in that GFP had a fairly low expression level at the early exponential stage and was highly expressed at the late exponential as well as the stationary stages. Moreover, the recombinant system had a similar expression pattern in wild-type B. subtilis 168, WB600, and WB800, as well as in B. subtilis 168 derivative strain 1681, with the complete deletion of PsrfA, indicating the excellent compatibility of this system. Noticeably, the expression strength of PsrfA was enhanced by optimizing the -10 and -35 core sequence by substituting both sequences with consensus sequences. Importantly, the expression pattern was successfully developed in an auto-regulatory cell-density coupling system by the simple addition of glucose in which GFP could not be strongly expressed until glucose was depleted, resulting in a greater amount of the GFP product and increased cell density. The expression system was eventually tested by the successful over-production of aminopeptidase to a desired level.

CONCLUSION

The auto-regulatory cell density coupling system that is mediated by PsrfA is a novel expression system that has an expression pattern that is split between cell-growth and over-expression, leading to an increase in cell density and elevating the overall expression levels of heterologously expressed proteins. The broad applicability of this system and inducer-free expression property in B. subtilis facilitate the industrial scale-up and medical applications for the over-production of a variety of desired proteins.

Activity of the Bacillus thuringiensis NprR-NprX cell-cell communication system is co-ordinated to the physiological stage through a complex transcriptional regulation

NprR is a quorum sensor of the RNPP family found in bacteria of the Bacillus cereus group. In association with its cognate peptide NprX, NprR controls the expression of genes essential for survival and sporulation of Bacillus thuringiensis during its necrotrophic development in insects. Here, we report that the nprR-nprX genes are not autoregulated and are co-transcribed from a σ(A) -dependent promoter (PA ) located upstream from nprR. The transcription from PA starts at the onset of the stationary phase and is controlled by two transcriptional regulators: CodY and PlcR. The nutritional repressor CodY represses nprR-nprX transcription during the exponential growth phase and the quorum sensor PlcR activates nprR-nprX transcription at the onset of stationary phase. We show that nprX is also transcribed independently of nprR from two promoters, PH and PE , dependent on the sporulation-specific sigma factors, σ(H) and σ(E) respectively. Both promoters ensure nprX transcription during late stationary phase while transcription from PA has decreased. These results show that the activity of the NprR-NprX quorum sensing system is tightly co-ordinated to the physiological stage throughout the developmental process of the Bacillus.

The threshold level of the sensor histidine kinase KinA governs entry into sporulation in Bacillus subtilis

Sporulation in Bacillus subtilis is controlled by a complex gene regulatory circuit that is activated upon nutrient deprivation. The initial process is directed by the phosphorelay, involving the major sporulation histidine kinase (KinA) and two additional phosphotransferases (Spo0F and Spo0B), that activates the master transcription factor Spo0A. Little is known about the initial event and mechanisms that trigger sporulation. Using a strain in which the synthesis of KinA is under the control of an IPTG (isopropyl-beta-d-thiogalactopyranoside)-inducible promoter, here we demonstrate that inducing the synthesis of the KinA beyond a certain level leads to the entry of the irreversible process of sporulation irrespective of nutrient availability. Moreover, the engineered cells expressing KinA under a sigma(H)-dependent promoter that is similar to but stronger than the endogenous kinA promoter induce sporulation during growth. These cells, which we designated COS (constitutive sporulation) cells, exhibit the morphology and properties of sporulating cells and express sporulation marker genes under nutrient-rich conditions. Thus, we created an engineered strain displaying two cell cycles (growth and sporulation) integrated into one cycle irrespective of culture conditions, while in the wild type, the appropriate cell fate decision is made depending on nutrient availability. These results suggest that the threshold level of the major sporulation kinase acts as a molecular switch to determine cell fate and may rule out the possibility that the activity of KinA is regulated in response to the unknown signal(s).

Genome-wide analysis of the stationary-phase sigma factor (sigma-H) regulon of Bacillus subtilis

Sigma-H is an alternative RNA polymerase sigma factor that directs the transcription of many genes that function at the transition from exponential growth to stationary phase in Bacillus subtilis. Twenty-three promoters, which drive transcription of 33 genes, are known to be recognized by sigma-H-containing RNA polymerase. To identify additional genes under the control of sigma-H on a genome-wide basis, we carried out transcriptional profiling experiments using a DNA microarray containing >99% of the annotated B. subtilis open reading frames. In addition, we used a bioinformatics-based approach aimed at the identification of promoters recognized by RNA polymerase containing sigma-H. This combination of approaches was successful in confirming most of the previously described sigma-H-controlled genes. In addition, we identified 26 putative promoters that drive expression of 54 genes not previously known to be under the direct control of sigma-H. Based on the known or inferred function of most of these genes, we conclude that, in addition to its previously known roles in sporulation and competence, sigma-H controls genes involved in many physiological processes associated with the transition to stationary phase, including cytochrome biogenesis, generation of potential nutrient sources, transport, and cell wall metabolism.

Glucose uptake in Clostridium beijerinckii NCIMB 8052 and the solvent-hyperproducing mutant BA101

Glucose uptake and accumulation by Clostridium beijerinckii BA101, a butanol hyperproducing mutant, were examined during various stages of growth. Glucose uptake in C. beijerinckii BA101 was repressed 20% by 2-deoxyglucose and 25% by mannose, while glucose uptake in C. beijerinckii 8052 was repressed 52 and 28% by these sugars, respectively. We confirmed the presence of a phosphoenolpyruvate (PEP)-dependent phosphotransferase system (PTS) associated with cell extracts of C. beijerinckii BA101 by glucose phosphorylation by PEP. The PTS activity associated with C. beijerinckii BA101 was 50% of that observed for C. beijerinckii 8052. C. beijerinckii BA101 also demonstrated lower PTS activity for fructose and glucitol. Glucose phosphorylation by cell extracts derived from both C. beijerinckii BA101 and 8052 was also dependent on the presence of ATP, a finding consistent with the presence of glucokinase activity in C. beijerinckii extracts. ATP-dependent glucose phosphorylation was predominant during the solventogenic stage, when PEP-dependent glucose phosphorylation was dramatically repressed. A nearly twofold-greater ATP-dependent phosphorylation rate was observed for solventogenic stage C. beijerinckii BA101 than for solventogenic stage C. beijerinckii 8052. These results suggest that C. beijerinckii BA101 is defective in PTS activity and that C. beijerinckii BA101 compensates for this defect with enhanced glucokinase activity, resulting in an ability to transport and utilize glucose during the solventogenic stage.

Do bacteria have sex?

Do bacteria have genes for genetic exchange? The idea that the bacterial processes that cause genetic exchange exist because of natural selection for this process is shared by almost all microbiologists and population geneticists. However, this assumption has been perpetuated by generations of biology, microbiology and genetics textbooks without ever being critically examined.

Developmental gene expression in Bacillus subtilis crsA47 mutants reveals glucose-activated control of the gene for the minor sigma factor sigma(H)

The presence of excess glucose in growth media prevents normal sporulation of Bacillus subtilis. The crsA47 mutation, located in the gene for the vegetative phase sigma factor (sigma(A)) results in a glucose-resistant sporulation phenotype. As part of a study of the mechanisms whereby the mutation in sigma(A) overcomes glucose repression of sporulation, we examined the expression of genes involved in sporulation initiation in the crsA47 background. The crsA47 mutation had a significant impact on a variety of genes. Changes to stage II gene expression could be linked to alterations in the expression of the sinI and sinR genes. In addition, there was a dramatic increase in the expression of genes dependent on the minor sigma factor sigma(H). This latter change was paralleled by the pattern of spo0H gene transcription in cells with the crsA47 mutation. In vitro analysis of RNA polymerase containing sigma(A47) indicated that it did not have unusually high affinity for the spo0H gene promoter. The in vivo pattern of spo0H expression is not predicted by the known regulatory constraints on spo0H and suggests novel regulation mechanisms that are revealed in the crsA47 background.

Analysis of tnrA alleles which result in a glucose-resistant sporulation phenotype in Bacillus subtilis

Bacillus subtilis cells cannot sporulate in the presence of catabolites such as glucose. During the analysis of Tn10-generated mutants, we found that deletion of the C-terminal region of the tnrA gene, which encodes a global regulator that positively regulates a number of genes in response to nitrogen limitation, results in a catabolite-resistant sporulation phenotype. Analyses of nrg-lacZ and nasB-lacZ, which are activated by TnrA under nitrogen limitation, showed that C-terminally truncated TnrA activates nitrogen-regulated genes constitutively. The relief of catabolite repression of sporulation may result from the uncontrolled expression of the TnrA-regulated genes.

The ClpX protein of Bacillus subtilis indirectly influences RNA polymerase holoenzyme composition and directly stimulates sigma-dependent transcription

In Bacillus subtilis, several processes associated with the onset of stationary phase, including the initiation of sporulation, require the activity of the minor sigmaH form of RNA polymerase (RNAP). The induction of sigmaH-dependent gene transcription requires the regulatory ATPase, ClpX. The ClpX-dependent post-exponential increase in sigmaH activity is not dependent on the activator of sporulation gene expression, Spo0A. By determining the level of sigmaH and sigmaA in whole-cell extracts and RNAP preparations, evidence is presented that clpX does not influence the concentration of sigma subunits, but is required for the stationary phase reduction in sigmaA-RNAP holoenzyme. This is probably an indirect consequence of ClpX activity, because the ClpX-dependent decrease in sigmaA-RNAP concentration does not occur in a spo0A abrB mutant. The addition of ClpX to in vitro transcription reactions resulted in the stimulation of RNAP holoenzyme activity, but sigmaH-RNAP was observed to be more sensitive to ClpX-dependent stimulation than sigmaA-RNAP. No difference in transcriptional activity was observed in single-cycle in vitro transcription reactions, suggesting that ClpX acted at a step in transcription initiation after closed- and open-promoter complex formation. ClpX is proposed to function indirectly in the displacement of sigmaA from core RNAP and to act directly in the stimulation of sigmaH-dependent transcription in sporulating B. subtilis cells.

Function of a principal Na(+)/H(+) antiporter, ShaA, is required for initiation of sporulation in Bacillus subtilis

ShaA (sodium/hydrogen antiporter, previously termed YufT [or NtrA]), which is responsible for Na(+)/H(+) antiporter activity, is considered to be the major Na(+) excretion system in Bacillus subtilis. We found that a shaA-disrupted mutant of B. subtilis shows impaired sporulation but normal vegetative growth when the external Na(+) concentration was increased in a low range. In the shaA mutant, sigma(H)-dependent expression of spo0A (P(S)) and spoVG at an early stage of sporulation was sensitive to external NaCl. The level of sigma(H) protein was reduced by the addition of NaCl, while the expression of spo0H, which encodes sigma(H), was little affected, indicating that posttranscriptional control of sigma(H) rather than spo0H transcription is affected by the addition of NaCl in the shaA mutant. Since this mutant is considered to have a diminished ability to maintain a low internal Na(+) concentration, an increased level of internal Na(+) may affect posttranscriptional control of sigma(H). Bypassing the phosphorelay by introducing the sof-1 mutation into this mutant did not restore spo0A (P(S)) expression, suggesting that disruption of shaA affects sigma(H) accumulation, but does not interfere with the phosphorylation and phosphotransfer reactions of the phosphorelay. These results suggest that ShaA plays a significant role at an early stage of sporulation and not only during vegetative growth. Our findings raise the possibility that fine control of cytoplasmic ion levels, including control of the internal Na(+) concentration, may be important for the progression of the sporulation process.

Role of lon and ClpX in the post-translational regulation of a sigma subunit of RNA polymerase required for cellular differentiation in Bacillus subtilis

The RNA polymerase sigma subunit, sigmaH (Spo0H) of Bacillus subtilis, is essential for the transcription of genes that function in sporulation and genetic competence. Although spo0H is transcriptionally regulated by the key regulatory device that controls sporulation initiation, the Spo0 phosphorelay, there is considerable evidence implicating a mechanism of post-translational control that governs the activity and concentration of sigmaH. Post-translational control of spo0H is responsible for the reduced expression of genes requiring sigmaH under conditions of low environmental pH. It is also responsible for heightened sigmaH activity upon relief of acid stress and during nutritional depletion. In this study, the ATP-dependent proteases LonA and B and the regulatory ATPase ClpX were found to function in the post-translational control of sigmaH. Mutations in lonA and lonB result in elevated sigmaH protein concentrations in low-pH cultures. However, this is not sufficient to increase sigmaH-dependent transcription. Activation of sigmaH-dependent transcription upon raising medium pH and in cells undergoing sporulation requires clpX, as shown by measuring the expression of lacZ fusions that require sigmaH for transcription and by complementation of a clpX null mutation. A hypothesis is presented that low environmental pH results in the Lon-dependent degradation of sigmaH, but the activity of sigmaH in sporulating cells and in cultures at neutral pH is stimulated by a ClpX-dependent mechanism in response to nutritional stress.

Thermo-labile stability of sigmaH (Spo0H) in temperature-sensitive spo0H mutants of Bacillus subtilis can be suppressed by mutations in RNA polymerase beta subunit

We isolated novel temperature-sensitive mutants of spo0H, spo0H1 and spo0H5, having E61K and G30E amino-acid substitutions within the sigmaH protein, respectively, and located in the highly conserved region, "2", among prokaryotic sigma factors that participates in binding to core enzyme of RNA polymerase. These mutants showed a sporulation-deficient phenotype at 43 degrees C. Moreover, we successfully isolated suppressor mutants that were spontaneously generated from the spo0H mutants. Our genetic analysis of these suppressor mutations revealed that the suppressor mutations are within the rpoB gene coding for the beta subunit of RNA polymerase. The mutations caused single amino-acid substitutions, E857A and P1055S, in rpoB18 and rpoB532 mutants that were generated from spo0H1 and spo0H5, respectively. Whereas the sigmaH-dependent expression of a spo0A-bgaB fusion was greatly reduced in both spo0H mutants, their expression was partially restored in the suppressor mutants at 43 degrees C. Western blot analysis showed that the level of sigmaH protein in the wild type increased between T0 and T2 and decreased after T3, while the level of sigmaH protein in spo0H mutants was greatly reduced throughout growth, indicating that the mutant sigmaH proteins were rapidly degraded by some unknown proteolytic enzyme(s). The analysis of the half-life of sigmaH protein showed that the short life of sigmaH in spo0H mutants is prolonged in the suppressor mutants. These findings suggest that, at least to some extent, the process of E-sigmaH formation may be involved in stabilization of sigmaH at the onset of sporulation.

The yvyD gene of Bacillus subtilis is under dual control of sigmaB and sigmaH

During a search by computer-aided inspection of two-dimensional (2D) protein gels for sigmaB-dependent general stress proteins exhibiting atypical induction profiles, a protein initially called Hst23 was identified as a product of the yvyD gene of Bacillus subtilis. In addition to the typical sigmaB-dependent, stress- and starvation-inducible pattern, yvyD is also induced in response to amino acid depletion. By primer extension of RNA isolated from the wild-type strain and appropriate mutants carrying mutations in the sigB and/or spo0H gene, two promoters were mapped upstream of the yvyD gene. The sigmaB-dependent promoter drives expression of yvyD under stress conditions and after glucose starvation, whereas a sigmaH-dependent promoter is responsible for yvyD transcription following amino acid limitation. Analysis of Northern blots revealed that yvyD is transcribed monocistronically and confirmed the conclusions drawn from the primer extension experiments. The analysis of the protein synthesis pattern in amino acid-starved wild-type and relA mutant cells showed that the YvyD protein is not synthesized in the relA mutant background. It was concluded that the stringent response plays a role in the activation of sigmaH. The yvyD gene product is homologous to a protein which might modify the activity of sigma54 in gram-negative bacteria. The expression of a sigmaL-dependent (sigmaL is the equivalent of sigma54 in B. subtilis) levD-lacZ fusion is upregulated twofold in a yvyD mutant. This indicates that the yvyD gene product, being a member of both the sigmaB and sigmaH regulons, might negatively regulate the activity of the sigmaL regulon. We conclude that (i) systematic, computer-aided analysis of 2D protein gels is appropriate for the identification of genes regulated by multiple transcription factors and that (ii) YvyD might form a junction between the sigmaB and sigmaH regulons on one side and the sigmaL regulon on the other.

Altered srf expression in Bacillus subtilis resulting from changes in culture pH is dependent on the Spo0K oligopeptide permease and the ComQX system of extracellular control

The expression of the srf operon of Bacillus subtilis, encoding surfactin synthetase and the competence regulatory protein ComS, was observed to be reduced when cells were grown in a rich glucose- and glutamine-containing medium in which late-growth culture pH was 5.0 or lower. The production of the surfactin synthetase subunits and of surfactin itself was also reduced. Raising the pH to near neutrality resulted in dramatic increases in srf expression and surfactin production. This apparent pH-dependent induction of srf expression required spo0K, which encodes the oligopeptide permease that functions in cell-density-dependent control of sporulation and competence, but not CSF, the competence-inducing pheromone that regulates srf expression in a Spo0K-dependent manner. Both ComP and ComA, the two-component regulatory pair that stimulates cell-density-dependent srf transcription, were required for optimal expression of srf at low and high pHs, but ComP was not required for pH-dependent srf induction. The known negative regulators of srf, RapC and CodY, were found not to function significantly in pH-dependent srf expression. Late-growth culture supernatants at low pH were not active in inducing srf expression in cells of low-density cultures but were rendered active when their pH was raised to near neutrality. ComQ (and very likely the srf-inducing pheromone ComX) and Spo0K were found to be required for the extracellular induction of srf-lacZ at neutral pH. The results suggest that srf expression, in response to changes in culture pH, requires Spo0K and another, as yet unidentified, extracellular factor. The study also provides evidence consistent with the hypothesis that ComP acts both positively and negatively in the regulation of ComA and that both activities are controlled by the ComX pheromone.

Characterization of the presumptive phosphorylation sites of the Bacillus subtilis glucose permease by site-directed mutagenesis: implication in glucose transport and catabolite repression

Bacillus subtilis utilizes glucose as the preferred source of carbon and energy. Glucose is transported and concomitantly phosphorylated by the glucose permease (PtsG) of the phosphoenolpyruvate:sugar phosphotransferase system. The phosphate is transferred from enzyme I via HPr and domains IIA and IIB of the glucose permease to the sugar. In this study mutants affected in the putative phosphorylation sites of glucose permease were constructed and the effect on sugar transport and glucose repression tested. Phosphorylation of both domains IIAGlc and IIBGlc is required for efficient glucose transport and repression of beta-xylosidase and the bglPH operon.

Regulation of Bacillus subtilis sigmaH (spo0H) and AbrB in response to changes in external pH

The RNA polymerase sigma subunit, sigmaH, of Bacillus subtilis is required for the transcription of genes that are induced in late-growth cultures at high cell density, including genes that function in sporulation. The expression of sigmaH-controlled genes is repressed when nutrient broth sporulation medium (Difco sporulation medium [DSM]) is supplemented with high concentrations of glucose and glutamine (DSM-GG), preferred carbon and nitrogen sources of B. subtilis. Under these conditions, the pH of the DSM-GG medium decreases to approximately 5. Raising the pH by the addition of morpholinepropanesulfonic acid (MOPS) or Tris-HCl (pH 7.5) results in a dramatic increase in the expression of lacZ fusions to sigmaH-dependent promoters. Correspondingly, the level of sigmaH protein was higher in cells of late-growth DSM-GG cultures treated with a pH stabilizer. When sigmaH-dependent gene expression was examined in cells bearing a mutation in abrB, encoding the transition state regulator that negatively controls genes transcribed by the sigmaH form of RNA polymerase, derepression was observed as well as an increase in medium pH. Reducing the pH with acetic acid resulted in repression, suggesting that AbrB was not functioning directly in pH-dependent repression but was required to maintain the low medium pH in DSM-GG. AbrB protein levels were high in late-growth, DSM-GG cultures but significantly lower when the pH was raised by Tris-HCl addition. An active tricarboxylic acid (TCA) cycle was required to obtain maximum derepression of sigmaH-dependent transcription, and transcription of the TCA cycle enzyme gene citB was repressed in DSM-GG but derepressed when the pH was artificially raised. The negative effect of low pH on sigmaH-dependent lacZ expression was also observed in unbuffered minimal medium and appeared to be exerted posttranslationally with respect to spo0H expression. However, the addition of amino acids to the medium caused pH-independent repression of both sigmaH-dependent transcription and spo0H-lacZ expression. These results suggest that spo0H transcription or translation is repressed by a mechanism responding to the availability of amino acids whereas spo0H is posttranslationally regulated in response to external pH.

Expression of kinA and accumulation of sigma H at the onset of sporulation in Bacillus subtilis

Induction of the Bacillus subtilis kinA gene, which codes for a major kinase of the phosphorelay pathway, required the spo0H gene, coding for the sigma H protein, but not the genes spo0A, spo0B, and spo0F at the onset of sporulation. Also, the levels of sigma H in spo0A, spo0B, and spo0F mutants were increased at the onset of sporulation, though induction of spo0H transcription in all of these mutants was appreciably inhibited. In addition, kinA expression was almost completely eliminated in a medium supplemented with excess glucose and glutamine, even though the usual stationary-phase-associated increase in sigma H was observed under these conditions.