Mutational analysis of a transmembrane segment in a bacterial chemoreceptor

Discovery of a New Chemoeffector for Escherichia coli Chemoreceptor Tsr and Identification of a Molecular Mechanism of Repellent Sensing

Motile bacteria use chemotaxis to search for nutrients and escape from harmful chemicals. While the sensing mechanisms for chemical attractants are well established, the molecular details of chemorepellent detection are poorly understood. Here, by using combined computational and experimental approaches to screen potential chemoeffectors for the Escherichia coli chemoreceptor Tsr, we identified a specific chemorepellent, 1-aminocyclohexanecarboxylic acid (ACHC). Our study strongly suggests that ACHC directly binds to the periplasmic sensory domain of Tsr and competes with l-serine, the amino acid attractant of Tsr. We further characterized the binding features of l-serine, ACHC, and l-leucine (a natural repellent that binds Tsr) and found that Asn68 plays a key role in mediating chemotactic response. Mutating Asn68 to Ala inverted the response to l-leucine from a repellent to an attractant. Our study provides important insights into the molecular mechanisms of ligand sensing via bacterial chemoreceptors.

Transmembrane helix dynamics of bacterial chemoreceptors supports a piston model of signalling

Transmembrane α-helices play a key role in many receptors, transmitting a signal from one side to the other of the lipid bilayer membrane. Bacterial chemoreceptors are one of the best studied such systems, with a wealth of biophysical and mutational data indicating a key role for the TM2 helix in signalling. In particular, aromatic (Trp and Tyr) and basic (Arg) residues help to lock α-helices into a membrane. Mutants in TM2 of E. coli Tar and related chemoreceptors involving these residues implicate changes in helix location and/or orientation in signalling. We have investigated the detailed structural basis of this via high throughput coarse-grained molecular dynamics (CG-MD) of Tar TM2 and its mutants in lipid bilayers. We focus on the position (shift) and orientation (tilt, rotation) of TM2 relative to the bilayer and how these are perturbed in mutants relative to the wildtype. The simulations reveal a clear correlation between small (ca. 1.5 Å) shift in position of TM2 along the bilayer normal and downstream changes in signalling activity. Weaker correlations are seen with helix tilt, and little/none between signalling and helix twist. This analysis of relatively subtle changes was only possible because the high throughput simulation method allowed us to run large (n = 100) ensembles for substantial numbers of different helix sequences, amounting to ca. 2000 simulations in total. Overall, this analysis supports a swinging-piston model of transmembrane signalling by Tar and related chemoreceptors.

Mutational analysis of the control cable that mediates transmembrane signaling in the Escherichia coli serine chemoreceptor

During transmembrane signaling by Escherichia coli Tsr, changes in ligand occupancy in the periplasmic serine-binding domain promote asymmetric motions in a four-helix transmembrane bundle. Piston displacements of the signaling TM2 helix in turn modulate the HAMP bundle on the cytoplasmic side of the membrane to control receptor output signals to the flagellar motors. A five-residue control cable joins TM2 to the HAMP AS1 helix and mediates conformational interactions between them. To explore control cable structural features important for signal transmission, we constructed and characterized all possible single amino acid replacements at the Tsr control cable residues. Only a few lesions abolished Tsr function, indicating that the chemical nature and size of the control cable side chains are not individually critical for signal control. Charged replacements at I214 mimicked the signaling consequences of attractant or repellent stimuli, most likely through aberrant structural interactions of the mutant side chains with the membrane interfacial environment. Prolines at residues 214 to 217 also caused signaling defects, suggesting that the control cable has helical character. However, proline did not disrupt function at G213, the first control cable residue, which might serve as a structural transition between the TM2 and AS1 helix registers. Hydrophobic amino acids at S217, the last control cable residue, produced attractant-mimic effects, most likely by contributing to packing interactions within the HAMP bundle. These results suggest a helix extension mechanism of Tsr transmembrane signaling in which TM2 piston motions influence HAMP stability by modulating the helicity of the control cable segment.

Ligand-induced conformational changes in the Bacillus subtilis chemoreceptor McpB determined by disulfide crosslinking in vivo

Previously, we characterized the organization of the transmembrane (TM) domain of the Bacillus subtilis chemoreceptor McpB using disulfide crosslinking. Cysteine residues were engineered into serial positions along the two helices through the membrane, TM1 and TM2, as well as double mutants in TM1 and TM2, and the extent of crosslinking determined to characterize the organization of the TM domain. In this study, the organization of the TM domain was studied in the presence and absence of ligand to address what ligand-induced structural changes occur. We found that asparagine caused changes in crosslinking rate on all residues along the TM1-TM1' helical interface, whereas the crosslinking rate for almost all residues along the TM2-TM2' interface did not change. These results indicated that helix TM1 rotated counterclockwise and that TM2 did not move in respect to TM2' in the dimer on binding asparagine. Interestingly, intramolecular crosslinking of paired substitutions in 34/280 and 38/273 were unaffected by asparagine, demonstrating that attractant binding to McpB did not induce a "piston-like" vertical displacement of TM2 as seen for Trg and Tar in Escherichia coli. However, these paired substitutions produced oligomeric forms of receptor in response to ligand. This must be due to a shift of the interface between different receptor dimers, within previously suggested trimers of dimers, or even higher order complexes. Furthermore, the extent of disulfide bond formation in the presence of asparagine was unaffected by the presence of the methyl-modification enzymes, CheB and CheR, or the coupling proteins, CheW and CheV, demonstrating that these proteins must have local structural effects on the cytoplasmic domain that is not translated to the entire receptor. Finally, disulfide bond formation was also unaffected by binding proline to McpC. We conclude that ligand-binding induced a conformational change in the TM domain of McpB dimers as an excitation signal that is likely propagated within the cytoplasmic region of receptors and that subsequent adaptational events do not affect this new TM domain conformation.

Position and ionization state of Asp in the core of membrane-inserted alpha helices control both the equilibrium between transmembrane and nontransmembrane helix topography and transmembrane helix positioning

The behavior of model-membrane-inserted polyLeu-rich peptides containing Asp residues located at various positions in their hydrophobic core was investigated. The topography of the bilayer-inserted alpha helices formed by these peptides was evaluated by measuring the emission lambda(max) and quenching the fluorescence of a Trp at the center of the peptide sequence. When Asp residues were protonated (at low pH), peptides that were incorporated into vesicles composed of dioleoylphosphatidylcholine (DOPC) adopted a topography in which the polyLeu sequence predominantly formed a normal transmembrane (TM) helix. When Asp residues were ionized (at neutral or high pH), topography was altered in a manner that would allow the charged Asp residues to reside near the bilayer surface. In DOPC vesicles, most peptides repositioned so that the longest segment of consecutive hydrophobic residues (12 residue minimum) formed a truncated/shifted TM structure. However, peptides with one or two charged Asp residues close to the center of the hydrophobic sequence and thus lacking even a 12-residue continuous hydrophobic segment, formed a helical non-TM state locating near the bilayer surface. At low pH, incorporation of the peptides into thicker bilayers composed of dierucoylphosphatidylcholine (DEuPC) resulted in the formation of a mixture of the normal TM state and the non-TM helical state located near the bilayer surface. In DEuPC vesicles at high pH, the non-TM state tended to predominate. How Asp-ionization-dependent shifts in helix topography may regulate the function of membrane proteins exposed to environments with differing pH in vivo (e.g., endosomes) is discussed.

Site-directed spin labeling of a bacterial chemoreceptor reveals a dynamic, loosely packed transmembrane domain

We used site-directed spin labeling and electron paramagnetic resonance spectroscopy to investigate dynamics and helical packing in the four-helix transmembrane domain of the homodimeric bacterial chemoreceptor Trg. We focused on the first transmembrane helix, TM1, particularly on the nine-residue sequence nearest the periplasm, because patterns of disulfide formation between introduced cysteines had identified that segment as the region of closest approach among neighboring transmembrane helices. Along this sequence, mobility and accessibility of the introduced spin label were characteristic of loosely packed or solvent-exposed side chains. This was also the case for eight additional positions around the circumference and along the length of TM1. For the continuous nine-residue sequence near the periplasm, mobility and accessibility varied only modestly as a function of position. We conclude that side chains of TM1 that face the interior of the four-helix domain interact with neighboring helices but dynamic movement results in loose packing. Compared to transmembrane segments of other membrane proteins reconstituted into lipid bilayers and characterized by site-directed spin labeling, TM1 of chemoreceptor Trg is the most dynamic and loosely packed. A dynamic, loosely packed chemoreceptor domain can account for many experimental observations about the transmembrane domains of chemoreceptors.

Attractant regulation of the aspartate receptor-kinase complex: limited cooperative interactions between receptors and effects of the receptor modification state

The manner by which the bacterial chemotaxis system responds to a wide range of attractant concentrations remains incompletely understood. In principle, positive cooperativity between chemotaxis receptors could explain the ability of bacteria to respond to extremely low attractant concentrations. By utilizing an in vitro receptor-coupled kinase assay, the attractant-dependent response curve has been measured for the Salmonella typhimurium aspartate chemoreceptor. The attractant chosen, alpha-methyl aspartate, was originally used to quantitate high receptor sensitivity at low attractant concentrations by Segall, Block, and Berg [(1986) Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U.S.A. 83, 8987-8991]. The attractant response curve exhibits limited positive cooperativity, yielding a Hill coefficient of 1.7-2.4, and this Hill coefficient is relatively independent of both the receptor modification state and the mole ratio of CheA to receptor. These results disfavor models in which there are strong cooperative interactions between large numbers of receptor dimers in an extensive receptor array. Instead, the results are consistent with cooperative interactions between a small number of coupled receptor dimers. Because the in vitro receptor-coupled kinase assay utilizes higher than native receptor densities arising from overexpression, the observed positive cooperativity may overestimate that present in native receptor populations. Such positive cooperativity between dimers is fully compatible with the negative cooperativity previously observed between the two symmetric ligand binding sites within a single dimer. The attractant affinity of the aspartate receptor is found to depend on the modification state of its covalent adaptation sites. Increasing the the level of modification decreases the apparent attractant affinity at least 10-fold in the in vitro receptor-coupled kinase assay. This observation helps explain the ability of the chemotaxis pathway to respond to a broad range of attractant concentrations in vivo.

Mutational analysis of ligand recognition by tcp, the citrate chemoreceptor of Salmonella enterica serovar typhimurium

The chemoreceptor Tcp mediates taxis to citrate. To identify citrate-binding residues, we substituted cysteine for seven basic or polar residues that are chosen based on the comparison of Tcp with the well-characterized chemoreceptors. The results suggest that Arg-63, Arg-68, Arg-72, Lys-75, and Tyr-150 (and probably other unidentified residues) are involved in the recognition of citrate.

A receptor scaffold mediates stimulus-response coupling in bacterial chemotaxis

The mechanism of stimulus-response coupling in bacterial chemotaxis has emerged as a paradigm for understanding general features of intracellular signal transduction both in bacterial and eukaryotic cells. Until recently it was thought that the mechanism involved reversible stochastic interactions between dimeric receptors freely diffusing in the cytoplasmic membrane and several soluble signal transduction proteins within the cytoplasm. Recent results have shown that this view is an oversimplification. The receptors and most of the signal transduction proteins are organized together in a higher ordered structure at one pole of the bacterial cell. The scaffolding network within this structure appears to be composed of C-terminal alpha-helical extensions of the membrane chemoreceptor proteins held together in a lattice by tandem SH3-like domains. Results suggest that stimuli are detected through the perturbations they induce in scaffolding architecture.

Signaling domain of the aspartate receptor is a helical hairpin with a localized kinase docking surface: cysteine and disulfide scanning studies

Cysteine and disulfide scanning has been employed to probe the signaling domain, a highly conserved motif found in the cytoplasmic region of the aspartate receptor of bacterial chemotaxis and related members of the taxis receptor family. Previous work has characterized the N-terminal section of the signaling domain [Bass, R. B., and Falke, J. J. (1998) J. Biol. Chem. 273, 25006-25014], while the present study focuses on the C-terminal section and the interactions between these two regions. Engineered cysteine residues are incorporated at positions Gly388 through Ile419 in the signaling domain, thereby generating a library of receptors each containing a single cysteine per receptor subunit. The solvent exposure of each cysteine is ascertained by chemical reactivity measurements, revealing a periodic pattern of buried hydrophobic and exposed polar residues characteristic of an amphipathic alpha-helix, denoted helix alpha8. The helix begins between positions R392 and Val401, then continues through the last residue scanned, Ile419. Activity assays carried out both in vivo and in vitro indicate that both the buried and exposed faces of this amphipathic helix are critical for proper receptor function and the buried surface is especially important for kinase downregulation. Patterns of disulfide bond formation suggest that helix alpha8, together with the immediately N-terminal helix alpha7, forms a helical hairpin that associates with a symmetric hairpin from the other subunit of the homodimer, generating an antiparallel four helix bundle containing helices alpha7, alpha7', alpha8, and alpha8'. Finally, the protein-interactions-by-cysteine-modification (PICM) method suggests that the loop between helices alpha7 and alpha8 interacts with the kinase CheA and/or the coupling protein CheW, expanding the receptor surface implicated in kinase docking.

Inversion of thermosensing property of the bacterial receptor Tar by mutations in the second transmembrane region

The aspartate chemoreceptor Tar of Escherichia coli serves as a warm sensor that produces attractant and repellent signals upon increases and decreases in temperature, respectively. However, increased levels of methylation of the cytoplasmic domain of Tar resulting from aspartate binding convert Tar to a cold sensor with the opposite signaling behavior. Detailed analyses of the methylation sites, which are located in two separate alpha-helices (MH1 and MH2), have suggested that intra- and/or intersubunit interactions of MH1 and MH2 play a critical role in thermosensing. These interactions may be influenced by binding of aspartate, which could trigger some displacement of MH1 through the second transmembrane region (TM2). As an initial step toward understanding the role of TM2 in thermosensing, we have examined the thermosensing properties of 43 mutant Tar receptors with randomized TM2 sequences (residues 190-210). Among them, we identified one mutant receptor (Tar-I2) that functioned as a cold sensor in the absence of aspartate. This is the first example of attractant-independent inversion of thermosensing in Tar. Further analyses identified the minimal essential divergence from the wild-type Tar sequence (Q191V-W192R-Q193C) required for the inverted response. Thus, displacements of TM2 seem to influence the thermosensing function of Tar.

Chemotaxis receptors: a progress report on structure and function

Recent biochemical and structural studies have provided many new insights into the structure and function of bacterial chemoreceptors. Aspects of their ligand binding, conformational changes, and interactions with other members of the signaling pathway are being defined at the structural level. It is anticipated that the combined effort will soon provide a detailed, unified view of an entire response system.

Intersubunit interaction between transmembrane helices of the bacterial aspartate chemoreceptor homodimer

The transmembrane domain that connects the extracellular and intracellular domains of cell-surface receptors must play a critical role in signal transduction. Here, we report studies of the interaction between the transmembrane helices (TM1 and TM2) of the Escherichia coli aspartate chemoreceptor (Tar). Tar exists as a homodimer regardless of its state of ligand occupancy. A particular residue substitution in TM1 (A19K) abolishes the signaling ability of Tar. This signaling defect can be suppressed by single residue substitutions in TM2 (W192R, A198E, V201E, and V202L). We have found that these suppressors can be divided into two groups. A198E and V201E (class 1) almost completely suppress the defects caused by A19K, and this suppression occurs between two subunits of the Tar dimer. In contrast, W192R and V202L (class 2) fail to suppress some signaling defects, and their suppression does not occur between subunits. Because disulfide-crosslinking studies predict that residues 198 and 201 point toward residue 19 of the partner subunit, we propose that the class 1 suppressors form an intersubunit salt bridge with Lys-19. Indeed, A19K was suppressed by several additional aspartate or glutamate substitutions on the same face of TM2 occupied by residues 198 and 201. None of these intersubunit salt bridges perturb signaling function, suggesting that the mechanism of transmembrane signal propagation does not involve large displacements (such as extensive rotation) of the TM1 and TM2 helices relative to each other.

Cysteine and disulfide scanning reveals two amphiphilic helices in the linker region of the aspartate chemoreceptor

The transmembrane aspartate receptor of E. coli and S. typhimurium mediates cellular chemotaxis toward aspartate by regulating the activity of the cytoplasmic histidine kinase, CheA. Ligand binding results in transduction of a conformational signal through the membrane to the cytoplasmic domain where both kinase regulation and adaptation occur. Of particular interest is the linker region, E213 to Q258, which connects and transduces the conformational signal between the cytoplasmic end of the transmembrane signaling helix (alpha 4/TM2) and the major methylation helix of the cytoplasmic domain (alpha 6). This linker is crucial for stable folding and function of the homodimeric receptor. The present study uses cysteine and disulfide scanning mutagenesis to investigate the secondary structure and packing surfaces within the linker region. Chemical reactivity assays reveal that the linker consists of three distinct subdomains: two alpha-helices termed alpha 4 and alpha 5 and, between them, an ordered region of undetermined secondary structure. When cysteine is scanned through the helices, characteristic repeating patterns of solvent exposure and burial are observed. Activity assays, both in vivo and in vitro, indicate that each helix possesses a buried packing face that is crucial for proper receptor function. The interhelical subdomain is at least partially buried and is also crucial for proper receptor function. Disulfide scanning places helix alpha 4 distal to the central axis of the homodimer, while helix alpha 5 is found to lie at the subunit interface. Finally, sequence alignments suggest that all three linker subdomains are highly conserved among the large subfamily of histidine kinase-coupled sensory receptors that possess methylation sites for use in covalent adaptation.

Signal transduction in bacteria: molecular mechanisms of stimulus-response coupling

In bacteria, adaptive responses to changing environmental conditions are mediated by signal transduction systems that involve modular protein domains. Despite great diversity in the integration of domains into different systems, studies of individual components have revealed molecular strategies that are widely applicable. Studies of receptors have advanced our understanding of how information is transmitted across membranes, the determination of three-dimensional structures of domains of histidine protein kinase domains and response regulator proteins has begun to reveal the molecular basis of signaling via two-component phosphoryltransfer pathways, and the description of 'eukaryotic-like' protein domains involved in bacterial signaling has emphasized the universality of intracellular signaling mechanisms.

Missense mutations that inactivate Escherichia coli lac permease

Although missense mutations that inactivate integral membrane proteins cause a variety of diseases, the mechanisms by which they act are poorly understood. To establish a model for investigating this issue, we identified 51 missense mutations arising in vivo that inactivate Escherichia coli lac permease, a well-characterized membrane transport protein. The mutants were isolated using a genetic screening procedure which eliminates mutations that block expression of the lac permease gene, such as nonsense and frameshift mutations. The majority of the 51 missense mutations caused highly non-conservative changes in membrane-spanning sequences, such as the introduction of charged residues. Nevertheless, the greatest clustering of substitutions occurred in the two regions of lac permease thought to be most important for transport function. The existence of this clustering indicates that even highly non-conservative substitutions may cause relatively localized structural defects. Conservative inactivating substitutions were scattered throughout lac permease and may affect residues that make contacts required for normal folding. Two unexpected phenotypes were observed in the collection of mutants: about 20% of the substitutions led to cold-sensitive lactose utilization, and one substitution made the mutant lac permease toxic to cells. This relatively unbiased collection of mutants should provide a resource for further studies of how missense mutations inactivate membrane proteins in vivo.

Cysteine and disulfide scanning reveals a regulatory alpha-helix in the cytoplasmic domain of the aspartate receptor

The transmembrane, homodimeric aspartate receptor of Escherichia coli and Salmonella typhimurium controls the chemotactic response to aspartate, an attractant, by regulating the activity of a cytoplasmic histidine kinase. The cytoplasmic domain of the receptor plays a central role in both kinase regulation and sensory adaptation, although its structure and regulatory mechanisms are unknown. The present study utilizes cysteine and disulfide scanning to probe residues Leu-250 through Gln-309, a region that contains the first of two adaptive methylation segments within the cytoplasmic domain. Following the introduction of consecutive cysteine residues by scanning mutagenesis, the measurement of sulfhydryl chemical reactivities reveals an alpha-helical pattern of exposed and buried positions spanning residues 270-309. This detected helix, termed the "first methylation helix," is strongly amphiphilic; its exposed face is highly anionic and possesses three methylation sites, while its buried face is hydrophobic. In vivo and in vitro assays of receptor function indicate that inhibitory cysteine substitutions are most prevalent on the buried face of the first methylation helix, demonstrating that this face is involved in a critical packing interaction. The buried face is further analyzed by disulfide scanning, which reveals three "lock-on" disulfides that covalently trap the receptor in its kinase-activating state. Each of the lock-on disulfides cross-links the buried faces of the two symmetric first methylation helices of the dimer, placing these helices in direct contact at the subunit interface. Comparative sequence analysis of 56 related receptors suggests that the identified helix is a conserved feature of this large receptor family, wherein it is likely to play a general role in adaptation and kinase regulation. Interestingly, the rapid rates and promiscuous nature of disulfide formation reactions within the scanned region reveal that the cytoplasmic domain of the full-length, membrane-bound receptor has a highly dynamic structure. Overall, the results demonstrate that cysteine and disulfide scanning can identify secondary structure elements and functionally important packing interfaces, even in proteins that are inaccessible to other structural methods.

3D structural information as a guide to protein engineering using genetic selection

A great variety of protein systems have been investigated in the past year using structure-guided evolutionary strategies. On the basis of available 3D structural information, critical regions of proteins have been targeted for randomizing mutagenesis and active variants of the corresponding genes have been selected. These approaches help characterize structural and mechanistic features of proteins and have important implications for design.

Detecting the conformational change of transmembrane signaling in a bacterial chemoreceptor by measuring effects on disulfide cross-linking in vivo

Transmembrane signaling by bacterial chemoreceptors is thought to involve relative movement among the four transmembrane helices of the homodimer. We assayed that movement by measuring effects of ligand occupancy on rates of oxidative cross-linking between cysteines introduced into neighboring helices of the transmembrane domain of chemoreceptor Trg from Escherichia coli. Measurements were done on chemoreceptors in their native environment, intact cells that were motile and chemotactically responsive. Receptor occupancy did not appear to cause drastic rearrangement of the four-helix structure since, among 67 cysteine pairs tested, the same 19 exhibited oxidative cross-linking in the presence or absence of saturating chemoattractant. However, occupancy did cause subtle changes that were detected as effects on rates of cross-linking. Among the seven disulfides appropriate for measurements of initial rates of formation, ligand occupancy had significant and different effects on all three cross-links that connected the two helices within a subunit but had minimal effects on the four that spanned the packing interface between subunits. This constitutes direct evidence that the conformational change of transmembrane signaling involves significant movement within a subunit and minimal movement between subunits, a pattern deduced from several previous studies and now documented directly. Among possible modes of movement between the two helices of a subunit, axial sliding of one helix relative to the other was the conformational change that best accounted for the observed effects on cross-linking.