Expression of Kirsten murine sarcoma virus in transformed nonproducer and revertant NIH/3T3 cells: evidence for cell-mediated resistance to a viral oncogene in phenotypic reversion

Transformation effector and suppressor genes

Much has been learned about the molecular basis of cancer from the study of the dominantly acting viral and cellular oncogenes and their normal progenitors, the proto-oncogenes. More recent studies have resulted in the isolation and characterization of several genes prototypic of a second class of cancer genes. Whereas oncogenes act to promote the growth of cells, members of this latter class of genes act to inhibit cellular growth and are believed to contribute to the tumorigenic phenotype only when their activities are absent. This new class of cancer genes is referred to by a number of different names including; anti-oncogenes, recessive oncogenes, growth suppressor genes, tumor suppressor genes and emerogenes. Although only a few of these cancer genes have been identified, to date, it is likely that many additional genes of this class await identification. A third class of genes, necessary for the development of the cancer phenotype, is comprised of the transformation effector genes. These are normal cellular genes that encode proteins that cooperate with or activate oncogene functions and thereby induce the development of the neoplastic phenotype. The inactivation of transformation effector functions would therefore inhibit the ability of certain dominantly acting oncogenes to transform cells. The approaches outlined here describe functional assays for the isolation and molecular characterization of transformation effector and suppressor genes.

Revertants of v-fos-transformed rat fibroblasts: suppression of transformation is dominant

Phenotypic revertants of Finkel-Biskis-Riley (FBR)-murine sarcoma virus-transformed rat fibroblasts were isolated on the basis of their adherence to plastic tissue culture dishes in the absence of divalent cations. Some revertants had sustained deletions or inactivating mutations of the v-fos gene. However, two revertants expressed a functional v-fos gene at levels equal to that in the transformed parental cells, and therefore phenotypic reversion was due to mutations in nonviral genes. These revertants were considered nontransformed according to four criteria: (i) they were flat and had a nontransformed morphology, (ii) they were contact inhibited when grown to confluence, (iii) they did not display anchorage-independent growth in soft agar, and (iv) they did not form tumors in nude mice. Somatic-cell hybrids between the revertants and the transformed parental cells were nontransformed, suggesting that the revertants had sustained an activating mutation of a gene capable of suppressing transformation. The expression of c-jun, junB, and junD was not altered in the revertants, and they could not be transformed by transfection with a c-jun expression vector. The revertants were resistant to transformation by an activated c-Ha-ras gene but were susceptible to transformation by simian virus 40. Our results demonstrate the existence of a class of revertants that harbor genes capable of suppressing transformation by v-fos and some other oncogenes. This contrasts with previously described revertants of transformation by v-fos that contain recessive mutations.

Revertants of v-fos-transformed rat fibroblasts: suppression of transformation is dominant

Phenotypic revertants of Finkel-Biskis-Riley (FBR)-murine sarcoma virus-transformed rat fibroblasts were isolated on the basis of their adherence to plastic tissue culture dishes in the absence of divalent cations. Some revertants had sustained deletions or inactivating mutations of the v-fos gene. However, two revertants expressed a functional v-fos gene at levels equal to that in the transformed parental cells, and therefore phenotypic reversion was due to mutations in nonviral genes. These revertants were considered nontransformed according to four criteria: (i) they were flat and had a nontransformed morphology, (ii) they were contact inhibited when grown to confluence, (iii) they did not display anchorage-independent growth in soft agar, and (iv) they did not form tumors in nude mice. Somatic-cell hybrids between the revertants and the transformed parental cells were nontransformed, suggesting that the revertants had sustained an activating mutation of a gene capable of suppressing transformation. The expression of c-jun, junB, and junD was not altered in the revertants, and they could not be transformed by transfection with a c-jun expression vector. The revertants were resistant to transformation by an activated c-Ha-ras gene but were susceptible to transformation by simian virus 40. Our results demonstrate the existence of a class of revertants that harbor genes capable of suppressing transformation by v-fos and some other oncogenes. This contrasts with previously described revertants of transformation by v-fos that contain recessive mutations.

A cell mutant that exhibits temperature-dependent sensitivity to transformation by various oncogenes

We previously isolated a Fisher rat fibroblast mutant, B812, that has the unique property of temperature-dependent transformation by various oncogenic retroviruses. At the permissive temperature (35 degrees C), this mutant was sensitive to oncogenic transformation and formed foci on a dish at the same frequency as did the parental fibroblast cell line. When Kirsten murine sarcoma virus (Ki-MSV) was applied to the cells, the frequency of focus formation decreased more than 25-fold at the nonpermissive temperature (39 degrees C), whereas the cells expressed nearly the same level of the ras transcript as well as the ras protein. The temperature-restricted focus formation was fully reversible and was completely suppressed upon fusion with the wild-type parent cell. In addition to ras, the mos, fos, src, and erbB-2 oncogenes transformed this mutant with the same temperature dependence as described above; polyomavirus middle T antigen, adenovirus type 12, and human papillomavirus 16-E67 also transformed, but without temperature dependence. These results suggest that ras, fos, mos, src, and erbB-2 use a common cellular pathway for transforming cells.

A common cellular pathway for v-mos and v-Ki-ras is not required for v-Ki-ras-induced tumorigenicity in a nonmalignant, v-mos-expressing revertant cell

A revertant cell line was selected from Moloney sarcoma virus-transformed BALB/c cells after long-term treatment with type I interferon. Despite an actively transcribed and transfectable v-mos gene, these revertant cells were nontumorigenic in nude mice. The functionality of the mos protein was investigated, focusing on the alpha 2(1) collagen promoter regulation, which is known to be affected by mos-induced trans-acting factors. Both in transient expression assays and after stable integration into the cellular genome, the transfected alpha 2(1) collagen promoter fused to the cat reporter gene was activated in the revertant while being downregulated in the original transformed cells. In retransformation assays of the revertant by Moloney sarcoma virus strains homologous to the original transforming virus, no detectable change was noted in the in vitro phenotype or in tumorigenicity. These results reveal that the mos-directed factors were no longer effective on their specific targets. Thus, the R.MSVIF cell could be either an oncoprotein-deficient or a target-related revertant. Attempts at retransformation with unrelated sarcoma viruses bearing v-sis, v-fms, or v-fos oncogenes were also negative. In contrast, tumorigenicity was obtained with the unrelated Kirsten sarcoma virus without any change in the revertant morphology or collagen expression. These findings showed that the common pathway blocked by the reversion and shared by v-mos and v-ras was not required for ras-induced tumorigenicity.

A cell mutant that exhibits temperature-dependent sensitivity to transformation by various oncogenes

We previously isolated a Fisher rat fibroblast mutant, B812, that has the unique property of temperature-dependent transformation by various oncogenic retroviruses. At the permissive temperature (35 degrees C), this mutant was sensitive to oncogenic transformation and formed foci on a dish at the same frequency as did the parental fibroblast cell line. When Kirsten murine sarcoma virus (Ki-MSV) was applied to the cells, the frequency of focus formation decreased more than 25-fold at the nonpermissive temperature (39 degrees C), whereas the cells expressed nearly the same level of the ras transcript as well as the ras protein. The temperature-restricted focus formation was fully reversible and was completely suppressed upon fusion with the wild-type parent cell. In addition to ras, the mos, fos, src, and erbB-2 oncogenes transformed this mutant with the same temperature dependence as described above; polyomavirus middle T antigen, adenovirus type 12, and human papillomavirus 16-E67 also transformed, but without temperature dependence. These results suggest that ras, fos, mos, src, and erbB-2 use a common cellular pathway for transforming cells.

Resistance to oncogenic transformation in revertant R1 of human ras-transformed NIH 3T3 cells

A flat revertant, R1, was isolated from human activated c-Ha-ras-1 (hu-ac-Ha-ras) gene-transformed NIH 3T3 cells (EJ-NIH 3T3) treated with mutagens. R1 contained unchanged transfected hu-ac-Ha-ras DNA and expressed high levels of hu-ac-Ha-ras-specific mRNA and p21 protein. Transfection experiments revealed that NIH 3T3 cells could be transformed by DNA from R1 cells but R1 cells could not be retransformed by Kirsten sarcoma virus, DNA from EJ-NIH 3T3 cells, hu-ac-Ha-ras, v-src, v-mos, simian virus 40 large T antigen, or polyomavirus middle T antigen. Somatic cell hybridization studies showed that R1 was not retransformed by fusion with NIH 3T3 cells and suppressed anchorage independence of EJ-NIH 3T3 and hu-ac-Ha-ras gene-transformed rat W31 cells in soft agar. These results suggest that the reversion and resistance to several oncogenes in R1 is due not to cellular defects in the production of the transformed phenotype but rather to enhancement of cellular mechanisms that suppress oncogenic transformation.

Resistance to oncogenic transformation in revertant R1 of human ras-transformed NIH 3T3 cells

A flat revertant, R1, was isolated from human activated c-Ha-ras-1 (hu-ac-Ha-ras) gene-transformed NIH 3T3 cells (EJ-NIH 3T3) treated with mutagens. R1 contained unchanged transfected hu-ac-Ha-ras DNA and expressed high levels of hu-ac-Ha-ras-specific mRNA and p21 protein. Transfection experiments revealed that NIH 3T3 cells could be transformed by DNA from R1 cells but R1 cells could not be retransformed by Kirsten sarcoma virus, DNA from EJ-NIH 3T3 cells, hu-ac-Ha-ras, v-src, v-mos, simian virus 40 large T antigen, or polyomavirus middle T antigen. Somatic cell hybridization studies showed that R1 was not retransformed by fusion with NIH 3T3 cells and suppressed anchorage independence of EJ-NIH 3T3 and hu-ac-Ha-ras gene-transformed rat W31 cells in soft agar. These results suggest that the reversion and resistance to several oncogenes in R1 is due not to cellular defects in the production of the transformed phenotype but rather to enhancement of cellular mechanisms that suppress oncogenic transformation.

Reversion to normal phenotype induced by SV40 in a spontaneously transformed malignant Chinese hamster cell line

By using a selection procedure that excluded the transforming effect of SV40, reversions to several properties of normal phenotype were for the first time obtained in a transformed Chinese hamster cell line after SV40 infection. The value of induction to recovery of contact inhibition was typical for SV40-induced reverse gene mutations. Thirteen of 15 isolated revertant clones were T-antigen positive, thus synthesizing the product of viral oncogene. Therefore, in the majority of clones reversion occurred in spite of the presence of viral transforming protein. Dot hybridization revealed the presence of SV40 DNA in all revertants including those expressing no T antigen. The virus rescued from one T-antigen positive and two negative clones proved to be infectious. Reversion to contact inhibition was followed by reversion as regards serum requirements and growth in soft agar. However, in all cases reversion was partial. Karyologic analysis of revertant clones showed that six clones maintained the hypodiploid karyotype of the parental clone, six revertants were near-tetraploid, and one was near triploid. The possible events underlying the SV40-induced reversions to normal phenotype and the role of virus-induced mutations in viral carcinogenesis are discussed.

AP1, a composite transcription factor implicated in abnormal growth control

Growth factors activate cascades of intracellular events, some of which result in altered gene expression. A series of recent discoveries have highlighted the role of the transcription factor AP1 as a mediator of the effects of growth factors, as well as those of oncogenes and the tumour promoter TPA. We discuss the molecular composition of AP1, how its activity is thought to be regulated, and the evidence that AP1 activation is involved in transformation.

A recessive cellular mutation in v-fes-transformed mink cells restores contact inhibition and anchorage-dependent growth

A contact-inhibited revertant of mink cells transformed by the Gardner-Arnstein strain of feline sarcoma virus was isolated by fluorescence-activated sorting of cells stained with the mitochondria-specific dye rhodamine 123. The revertant cell line exhibited a decrease in its proliferative rate and saturation density and a complete loss of its capacity for anchorage-independent growth, but it remained tumorigenic when inoculated into nude mice. The revertant cells retained a rescuable Gardner-Arnstein feline sarcoma provirus, expressed high levels of the v-fes oncogene product and its associated tyrosine kinase activity, manifested elevated levels of phosphotyrosine-containing cellular proteins similar to those observed in v-fes-transformed cells, and were refractory to retransformation by retroviruses containing the v-fes, v-fms, and v-ras oncogenes. Fusion of the revertant and parental cells generated somatic cell hybrids which formed colonies in semisolid medium, indicating that the block in transformation was recessive. These data together with the observation that the revertant phenotype is unstable in continuous culture suggest that the loss of transformation is due to the presence of limiting quantities of a gene product which functions downstream of the v-fes-coded kinase in the mitogenic pathway.

Transforming but not immortalizing oncogenes activate the transcription factor PEA1

The transcription factor PEA1 (a homologue of AP1 and c-jun) is highly active in several fibroblast cell lines, compared to its low activity in a myeloma and an embryo-carcinoma (EC) cell line. Serum components are essential to attain these high levels of PEA1 activity in fibroblasts. This serum requirement is abrogated by transformation with the oncogenes c-Ha-ras, v-src and polyoma middle T (Py-MT) but not by immortalization with polyoma large T (Py-LT), v-myc, c-myc or SV40 large T (SV40T). Expression in myeloma cells of the same transforming oncogenes, as well as v-mos and c-fos, activates PEA1, whereas expression of the same immortalizing oncogenes and EIA does not. These results suggest that a common target for transforming oncogenes is PEA1. Serum components have no effect on PEA1 activity in the myeloma and EC cell lines. In contrast, retinoic acid treatment of F9 EC cells augments PEA1 activity. These results suggest that transforming oncogene expression compensates for the absence of cell type-specific factors which are required to activate PEA1. Activation of PEA1 may lead to altered transcription of a set of transformation-related genes.

A recessive cellular mutation in v-fes-transformed mink cells restores contact inhibition and anchorage-dependent growth

A contact-inhibited revertant of mink cells transformed by the Gardner-Arnstein strain of feline sarcoma virus was isolated by fluorescence-activated sorting of cells stained with the mitochondria-specific dye rhodamine 123. The revertant cell line exhibited a decrease in its proliferative rate and saturation density and a complete loss of its capacity for anchorage-independent growth, but it remained tumorigenic when inoculated into nude mice. The revertant cells retained a rescuable Gardner-Arnstein feline sarcoma provirus, expressed high levels of the v-fes oncogene product and its associated tyrosine kinase activity, manifested elevated levels of phosphotyrosine-containing cellular proteins similar to those observed in v-fes-transformed cells, and were refractory to retransformation by retroviruses containing the v-fes, v-fms, and v-ras oncogenes. Fusion of the revertant and parental cells generated somatic cell hybrids which formed colonies in semisolid medium, indicating that the block in transformation was recessive. These data together with the observation that the revertant phenotype is unstable in continuous culture suggest that the loss of transformation is due to the presence of limiting quantities of a gene product which functions downstream of the v-fes-coded kinase in the mitogenic pathway.

Activated N-ras controls the transformed phenotype of HT1080 human fibrosarcoma cells

To investigate whether the activated N-ras oncogene of HT1080 human fibrosarcoma cells contributes to the expression of the transformed phenotype, we have isolated flat revertants. In two independent revertant lines, an increase in chromosomal ploidy occurred without a concomitant increase in the number of copies of the N-ras transforming allele. Immunoprecipitation confirms that the level of the mutant N-ras p21 gene product in the revertants is correspondingly lower than in HT1080. Analysis of sporadic tumors derived from the revertant cells reveals an increased dosage of the transforming allele. The revertants also retransform after transfection of cloned activated ras oncogenes. These results imply direct participation of an N-ras oncogene in maintaining the transformed phenotype of a human tumor cell line.

Revertants of v-fos-transformed fibroblasts have mutations in cellular genes essential for transformation by other oncogenes

Morphologic revertants of FBJ murine sarcoma virus (v-fos)-transformed rat-1 fibroblasts were isolated using a novel selection procedure based on prolonged retention of rhodamine 123 within mitochondria of v-fos-transformed versus normal fibroblasts. Two classes of revertants were isolated: class I revertants have sustained mutations in cellular genes, and a class II revertant has a nonfunctional v-fos provirus. Somatic-cell hybridization studies suggested that the revertant phenotype was recessive to the transformed phenotype. Class I revertants were also resistant to retransformation by v-gag-fos-fox, v-Ha-ras, v-abl, and v-mos, but could be retransformed by the trk oncogene and polyoma virus middle T antigen. These results suggest that the class I revertants sustained mutations in one or more cellular genes essential for transformation by some, but not all, oncogenes. Our data suggest the existence of common biochemical pathways for transformation.

Interferon-induced revertants of ras-transformed cells: resistance to transformation by specific oncogenes and retransformation by 5-azacytidine

Prolonged alpha/beta interferon (IFN-alpha/beta) treatment of NIH 3T3 cells transformed by a long terminal repeat-activated Ha-ras proto-oncogene resulted in revertants that maintained a nontransformed phenotype long after IFN treatment had been discontinued. Cloned persistent revertants (PRs) produced large amounts of the ras-encoded p21 and were refractile to transformation by EJras DNA and by transforming retroviruses which carried the v-Ha-ras, v-Ki-ras, v-abl, or v-fes oncogene. Transient treatment either in vitro or in vivo with cytidine analogs that alter gene expression by inhibiting DNA methylation resulted in transformation of PR, but not of NIH 3T3, cells. The PR retransformants reverted again with IFN, suggesting that DNA methylation is involved in IFN-induced persistent reversion.

Interferon-induced revertants of ras-transformed cells: resistance to transformation by specific oncogenes and retransformation by 5-azacytidine

Prolonged alpha/beta interferon (IFN-alpha/beta) treatment of NIH 3T3 cells transformed by a long terminal repeat-activated Ha-ras proto-oncogene resulted in revertants that maintained a nontransformed phenotype long after IFN treatment had been discontinued. Cloned persistent revertants (PRs) produced large amounts of the ras-encoded p21 and were refractile to transformation by EJras DNA and by transforming retroviruses which carried the v-Ha-ras, v-Ki-ras, v-abl, or v-fes oncogene. Transient treatment either in vitro or in vivo with cytidine analogs that alter gene expression by inhibiting DNA methylation resulted in transformation of PR, but not of NIH 3T3, cells. The PR retransformants reverted again with IFN, suggesting that DNA methylation is involved in IFN-induced persistent reversion.

Expression and transmission of a rodent retrovirus-like (VL30) gene family

A transcriptionally active sub-set of the dispersed mouse VL30 family of proviral genetic elements was shown to be highly transmissible as a murine leukaemia virus pseudotype. Newly acquired VL30 proviruses (present at 1 to 2 copies per cell) were shown to be transcriptionally active. These data substantiate the hypothesis that this process of duplicative transposition may have played a major role in the evolution of the gene family and also demonstrate that VL30 elements would be capable of mediating oncogene activation by a promoter-insertion-type mechanism during leukaemia virus-induced tumourgenesis.

Suppression of tumorigenicity in hybrids of normal and oncogene-transformed CHEF cells

Somatic cell hybridization experiments were carried out to determine whether normal cells have the ability to suppress the transforming effects of a defined oncogene. A nontransformed Chinese hamster embryo fibroblast cell line (CHEF/18-dm2) was used as the normal parent, and a CHEF/18 transfectant carrying the human mutant c-Ha-ras (EJ) oncogene was used as the tumorigenic parent. Selected hybrids (L318 cell lines) were assayed for the presence of EJ DNA, for the p21 product of the c-Ha-ras gene, and for various indices of cell transformation. These hybrids exhibited a fibroblastic morphology similar to the normal parent, although they contained the EJ gene and expressed its p21 protein product at levels comparable with the transformed parent. They had a reduced capacity for anchorage-independent growth (plating efficiency in methylcellulose of less than 0.3-13%, as compared with greater than 90% for the transformed parent) and decreased tumor-forming ability in athymic mice. These findings show that normal CHEF/18 cells contain suppressor genes capable of inhibiting expression of the transformed phenotype, and tumor-forming ability, in the presence of an activated EJ oncogene.