Host-dependent evolution of the Sindbis virus promoter for subgenomic mRNA synthesis

Alphavirus RNA replication in vertebrate cells

Alphaviruses are positive-strand RNA viruses, typically transmitted by mosquitoes between vertebrate hosts. They encode four essential replication proteins, the non-structural proteins nsP1-4, which possess the enzymatic activities of RNA capping, RNA helicase, site-specific protease, ADP-ribosyl removal and RNA polymerase. Alphaviruses have been key models in the study of membrane-associated RNA replication, which is a conserved feature among the positive-strand RNA viruses of animals and plants. We review new structural and functional information on the nsPs and their interaction with host proteins and membranes, as well as with viral RNA sequences. The dodecameric ring structure of nsP1 is likely to be one of the evolutionary innovations that facilitated the success of the progenitors of current positive-strand RNA viruses.

Subgenomic messenger RNAs: mastering regulation of (+)-strand RNA virus life cycle

Many (+)-strand RNA viruses use subgenomic (SG) RNAs as messengers for protein expression, or to regulate their viral life cycle. Three different mechanisms have been described for the synthesis of SG RNAs. The first mechanism involves internal initiation on a (−)-strand RNA template and requires an internal SGP promoter. The second mechanism makes a prematurely terminated (−)-strand RNA which is used as template to make the SG RNA. The third mechanism uses discontinuous RNA synthesis while making the (−)-strand RNA templates. Most SG RNAs are translated into structural proteins or proteins related to pathogenesis: however other SG RNAs regulate the transition between translation and replication, function as riboregulators of replication or translation, or support RNA–RNA recombination. In this review we discuss these functions of SG RNAs and how they influence viral replication, translation and recombination.

In vitro synthesis of Sindbis virus genomic and subgenomic RNAs: influence of nsP4 mutations and nucleoside triphosphate concentrations

Two positive-strand mRNAs are made in Sindbis virus-infected cells, the genomic (G) RNA and the subgenomic (SG) RNA. In mosquito cells infected with wild-type (wt) Sindbis virus, the latter is made in excess over the former; however, in cells infected with SVpzf or SVcpc more G RNA is made than SG RNA. Use was made of in vitro systems to investigate the effects of the SVpzf and SVcpc mutations on the synthesis of SG and G RNAs. Our findings indicate that under standard reaction conditions, the SG/G RNA ratio in vitro reflects the ratio of SG to G RNA made in infected mosquito cells. We observed further that the RNA patterns seen in vitro are affected not only by the SVpzf and SVcpc mutations but also by the nucleoside triphosphate concentrations in the reaction mixtures and that introduction of these mutations into nsP4 and the promoter/template change the relative amounts of SG and G RNAs that are made, likely through the choice of promoter. We conclude that with respect to the SVpzf and SVcpc mutations, it is mainly the nucleotide changes in the SG promoter, not the amino acid changes in nsP4, that determine the SG/G RNA ratio that results. Further, it was observed that the SVpzf mutations enhance the in vitro synthesis of SG RNA at the lowest concentrations of UTP/CTP and that the single SVcpc mutation enhances the synthesis of G RNA at the lowest concentrations of CTP tested. We also identified three Arg residues in nsP4, R545, R546, and R547, that are needed for the synthesis of G RNA but not SG RNA.

Properties and use of novel replication-competent vectors based on Semliki Forest virus

Background

Semliki Forest virus (SFV) has a positive strand RNA genome and infects different cells of vertebrates and invertebrates. The 5' two-thirds of the genome encodes non-structural proteins that are required for virus replication and synthesis of subgenomic (SG) mRNA for structural proteins. SG-mRNA is generated by internal initiation at the SG-promoter that is located at the complementary minus-strand template. Different types of expression systems including replication-competent vectors, which represent alphavirus genomes with inserted expression units, have been developed. The replication-competent vectors represent useful tools for studying alphaviruses and have potential therapeutic applications. In both cases, the properties of the vector, such as its genetic stability and expression level of the protein of interest, are important.

Results

We analysed 14 candidates of replication-competent vectors based on the genome of an SFV4 isolate that contained a duplicated SG promoter or an internal ribosomal entry site (IRES)-element controlled marker gene. It was found that the IRES elements and the minimal -21 to +5 SG promoter were non-functional in the context of these vectors. The efficient SG promoters contained at least 26 residues upstream of the start site of SG mRNA. The insertion site of the SG promoter and its length affected the genetic stability of the vectors, which was always higher when the SG promoter was inserted downstream of the coding region for structural proteins. The stability also depended on the conditions used for vector propagation. A procedure based on the in vitro transcription of ligation products was used for generation of replication-competent vector-based expression libraries that contained hundreds of thousands of different genomes, and maintained genetic diversity and the ability to express inserted genes over five passages in cell culture.

Conclusion

The properties of replication-competent vectors of alphaviruses depend on the details of their construction. In the case of SFV4, such vectors should contain the SG promoter with structural characteristics for this isolate. The main factor for instability of SFV4-based replication-competent vectors was the deletion of genes of interest, since the resulting shorter genomes had a growth advantage over the original vector.

Synthesis of genomic and subgenomic RNA in mosquito cells infected with two Sindbis virus nsP4 mutants: influence of intracellular nucleoside triphosphate concentrations

Cells infected with Sindbis virus (SV) make two positive-strand RNAs, a genomic-length RNA (G) RNA and a subgenomic (SG) RNA. In cells infected with SVstd, and in general in cells infected with wt alphaviruses, more SG RNA is made than G RNA. How the balance between synthesis of G RNA and SG RNA is regulated is not known. SVpzf and SVcpc are nsP4 mutants of SV which, in mosquito cells, make more G RNA than SG RNA. When low concentrations of pyrazofurin (inhibits the synthesis of UTP and CTP) were added to SVpzf-infected cells, the yield of virus was increased, and the ratio of SG/G RNA was changed from <1 to >1. These effects were reversed by uridine. In SVcpc-infected cells, but not in SVstd-infected cells, synthesis of viral RNA was inhibited by the addition of either uridine or cytidine, and viral yields were lowered. Our findings suggest that the activities of the viral RNA-synthesizing complexes in cells infected with SVpzf or SVcpc, in contrast to those in SVstd-infected cells, are sensitive to high concentrations of UTP or CTP. Using a cell-free system that synthesizes both SG and G RNA, we measured viral RNA synthesis as a function of the UTP/CTP concentrations. The results indicated that the presence of the SVpzf mutations in nsP4 and the SG promoter produced a pattern quite different from that seen with the SVstd nsP4 and SG promoter. As the UTP/CTP concentrations were increased, the SVpzf system, in contrast to the SVstd system, made more G RNA than SG RNA, reflecting the situation in cells infected with SVpzf.

Evolutionary influences in arboviral disease

Arthropod-borne viruses (arboviruses) generally require horizontal transmission by arthropod vectors among vertebrate hosts for their natural maintenance. This requirement for alternate replication in disparate hosts places unusual evolutionary constraints on these viruses, which have probably limited the evolution of arboviruses to only a few families of RNA viruses (Togaviridae, Flaviviridae, Bunyaviridae, Rhabdoviridae, Reoviridae, and Orthomyxoviridae) and a single DNA virus. Phylogenetic studies have suggested the dominance of purifying selection in the evolution of arboviruses, consistent with constraints imposed by differing replication environments and requirements in arthropod and vertebrate hosts. Molecular genetic studies of alphaviruses and flaviviruses have also identified several mutations that effect differentially the replication in vertebrate and mosquito cells, consistent with the view that arboviruses must adopt compromise fitness characteristics for each host. More recently, evidence of positive selection has also been obtained from these studies. However, experimental model systems employing arthropod and vertebrate cell cultures have yielded conflicting conclusions on the effect of alternating host infections, with host specialization inconsistently resulting in fitness gains or losses in the bypassed host cells. Further studies using in vivo systems to study experimental arbovirus evolution are critical to understanding and predicting disease emergence, which often results from virus adaptation to new vectors or amplification hosts. Reverse genetic technologies that are now available for most arbovirus groups should be exploited to test assumptions and hypotheses derived from retrospective phylogenetic approaches.

A cell-free system for the synthesis of Sindbis virus subgenomic RNA: importance of the concentration of the initiating NTP

We describe here an in vitro system for template-dependent initiation and synthesis of a Sindbis virus (SV) subgenomic (SG) RNA transcript. The critical components of this system were (1) a minus-strand promoter-template corresponding to the region of the SV genome from nt 7441 to nt 7772 (-157 to +175 relative to the SG RNA transcription initiation site at nt 7598), and (2) a p15 fraction from cells infected with recombinant vaccinia viruses expressing the SV nonstructural proteins, P123 and nsP4 (the nsP2 coding region in P123 contained a mutation which results in more rapid than normal processing of P123). Our data indicate that the SG RNA transcript is of the expected size, of positive polarity, and is initiated at the expected site. Changing the +1 nt from A to G, U, or C resulted in decreased synthesis of the SG RNA transcript. However, in each case, increasing the concentration of the initiating NTP restored synthesis of the transcript to the wild-type level. This is the first demonstration of an in vitro synthesis of an alphavirus SG RNA transcript which is dependent on the addition of an exogenous promoter-template. As such, it will make possible new approaches for learning how the synthesis of SG RNA is regulated.

Effect of alternating passage on adaptation of sindbis virus to vertebrate and invertebrate cells

Mosquito-borne alphaviruses, which replicate alternately and obligately in mosquitoes and vertebrates, appear to experience lower rates of evolution than do many RNA viruses that replicate solely in vertebrates. This genetic stability is hypothesized to result from the alternating host cycle, which constrains evolution by imposing compromise fitness solutions in each host. To test this hypothesis, Sindbis virus was passaged serially, either in one cell type to eliminate host alteration or alternately between vertebrate (BHK) and mosquito (C6/36) cells. Following 20 to 50 serial passages, mutations were identified and changes in fitness were assessed using competition assays against genetically marked, surrogate parent viruses. Specialized viruses passaged in a single cell exhibited more mutations and amino acid changes per passage than those passaged alternately. Single host-adapted viruses exhibited fitness gains in the cells in which they specialized but fitness losses in the bypassed cell type. Most but not all viruses passaged alternately experienced lesser fitness gains than specialized viruses, with fewer mutations per passage. Clonal populations derived from alternately passaged viruses also exhibited adaptation to both cell lines, indicating that polymorphic populations are not required for simultaneous fitness gains in vertebrate and mosquito cells. Nearly all passaged viruses acquired Arg or Lys substitutions in the E2 envelope glycoprotein, but enhanced binding was only detected for BHK cells. These results support the hypothesis that arbovirus evolution may be constrained by alternating host transmission cycles, but they indicate a surprising ability for simultaneous adaptation to highly divergent cell types by combinations of mutations in single genomes.

Restriction of a Sindbis virus mutant in BHK cells and relief of the restriction by the addition of adenosine

SV(PZF) is a mutant of Sindbis virus (SV) which we selected on the basis of its ability to replicate in mosquito cells treated with pyrazofurin (PZF), a drug which inhibits pyrimidine nucleotide biosynthesis (Lin et al., 2000, Virology 272, 61-71). Three mutations, A6627U, A7543U, and C7593A, were identified in the nsP4 (the viral RNA polymerase) coding region, which were required for the PZF-resistant phenotype. We report here that SV(PZF) has a second phenotype. Its replication in BHK cells is severely restricted; yields of SV(PZF) from BHK cells are 100- to 1000-fold lower than the yields of standard SV (SV(STD)). However, addition of adenosine to the SV(PZF)-infected cultures completely relieves this restriction and results in yields comparable to those observed with SV(STD). Adenosine has no effect on the yield of SV(STD) from BHK cells. Synthesis of the viral structural proteins is markedly depressed in SV(PZF)-infected BHK cells, as is synthesis of the viral subgenomic (SG) RNA from which these proteins are translated. In contrast, normal amounts of genomic RNA are made. Experiments with mutagenized viruses indicated that the SV(PZF) mutation, C7593A, by itself, was sufficient to produce the restriction phenotype. However, this mutation not only changes Pro 609 of nsP4 to Thr, it also changes the nucleotide at the minus sign5 position of the SG promoter. To evaluate the relative contributions of the change in nsP4 and the change in the SG promoter to the restriction phenotype, we made use of double SG viruses, in which nsP4 and the promoter for the SG RNA which encodes the structural proteins can be changed independent of each other. Our results indicated that both the change in nsP4 and the change in the SG promoter were required to produce the full restriction phenotype. We suggest that the changes in nsP4 and the SG promoter destabilize the RNA initiation complex assembled at the SG promoter and that since ATP is the initiating nucleotide in the SG RNA transcript, the increased level of ATP resulting from the addition of adenosine is able to compensate for this destabilization and restore the synthesis of SG RNA to normal levels.

Differential evolution of eastern equine encephalitis virus populations in response to host cell type

Arthropod-borne viruses (arboviruses) cycle between hosts in two widely separated taxonomic groups, vertebrate amplifying hosts and invertebrate vectors, both of which may separately or in concert shape the course of arbovirus evolution. To elucidate the selective pressures associated with virus replication within each portion of this two-host life cycle, the effects of host type on the growth characteristics of the New World alphavirus, eastern equine encephalitis (EEE) virus, were investigated. Multiple lineages of an ancestral EEE virus stock were repeatedly transferred through either mosquito or avian cells or in alternating passages between these two cell types. When assayed in both cell types, derived single host lineages exhibited significant differences in infectivity, growth pattern, plaque morphology, and total virus yield, demonstrating that this virus is capable of host-specific evolution. Virus lineages grown in alternation between the two cell types expressed intermediate phenotypes consistent with dual adaptation to both cellular environments. Both insect-adapted and alternated lineages greatly increased in their ability to infect insect cells. These results indicate that different selective pressures exist for virus replication within each portion of the two-host life cycle, and that alternation of hosts selects for virus populations well adapted for replication in both host systems.

Sequence requirements for Sindbis virus subgenomic mRNA promoter function in cultured cells

The Sindbis virus minimal subgenomic mRNA promoter (spanning positions -19 to +5 relative to the subgenomic mRNA start site) is approximately three- to sixfold less active than the fully active -98 to +14 promoter region. We identified two elements flanking the -19 to +5 region which increase its transcription to levels comparable to the -98 to +14 region. These elements span positions -40 to -20 and +6 to +14 and act synergistically to enhance transcription. Nine different virus libraries were constructed containing blocks of five randomized nucleotides at various positions in the -40 to +14 region. On passaging these libraries in mosquito cells, a small subset of the viruses came to dominate the population. Sequence analysis at the population level and for individual clones revealed that in general, wild-type bases were preferred for positions -15 to +5 of the minimal promoter. Base mutagenesis experiments indicated that the selection of wild-type bases in this region was primarily due to requirements for subgenomic mRNA transcription. Outside of the minimal promoter, the -35 to -29 region contained four positions which also preferred wildtype bases. However, the remaining positions generally preferred non-wild-type bases. On passaging of the virus libraries on hamster cells, the -15 to +5 region again preferred the wild-type base but most of the remaining positions exhibited almost no base preference. The promoter thus consists of an essential central region from -15 to +5 and discrete flanking sites that render it fully active, depending on the host environment.

A novel viral RNA species in Sindbis virus-infected cells

Sindbis virus (SIN), the type alphavirus, has been studied extensively to identify the viral cis-acting sequences and proteins involved in RNA transcription and replication. However, very little is known about how these processes are coordinated. For example, synthesis of the genomic RNA and the subgenomic mRNA depends on the minus strand. Do these activities occur independently on different templates, or can replication and transcription take place simultaneously on the same template? We describe the appearance of a SIN-specific, plus-sense RNA that is intermediate in size between the genomic and subgenomic RNA species. This RNA, designated RNA II, is observed in a number of different cell lines, both early and late in infection. The number of RNA II species, their sizes, and their abundances are influenced by the subgenomic promoter. We have mapped the 3' end of RNA II to a site within the subgenomic promoter, four nucleotides before the initiation site of the subgenomic mRNA. Our results indicate that the appearance of RNA II is correlated with subgenomic mRNA transcription, such that strong or active promoters tend to increase the abundance of RNA II, relative to weak or less active promoters. RNA II is most abundantly detected with the full promoter and is at much lower abundance with the minimal promoter. The possible origins of RNA II are discussed.

Evolution of the Sindbis virus subgenomic mRNA promoter in cultured cells

Transcription of the subgenomic mRNA of alphaviruses initiates at an internal site, called the promoter, which is highly conserved. To determine the functional significance of this conservation, we used an approach that randomizes positions -13 to -9 of the promoter to generate a library containing all possible sequences within this region, including the wild-type sequence. Viruses in the mixed population with more-efficient promoters were selected for during passaging in mammalian (BHK-21) cells. Results from early passage populations indicate that a large number of different promoters are functionally active. Analysis of eight individual viruses found that although each contained a promoter with different degrees of sequence identity to the wild-type sequence, all eight viruses produced progeny. This suggests that the mechanism for transcription allows for a diversity of sequences to serve as promoters. Further passaging of the viral library led to a population consensus sequence that increasingly resembled the wild-type sequence, despite the fact that these promoters are not constrained by the need to encode the carboxyl terminus of the nsP4 protein. Thus, conservation of the region of the promoter from -13 to -9 is in large part due to selection for promoter function, and the wild-type sequence and sequences closely similar to it seem to be optimal for promoter function in BHK-21 cells.