Plus-strand strong-stop DNA synthesis in retrotransposon Ty1

Novel transcript truncating function of Rap1p revealed by synthetic codon-optimized Ty1 retrotransposon

Extensive mutagenesis via massive recoding of retrotransposon Ty1 produced a synthetic codon-optimized retrotransposon (CO-Ty1). CO-Ty1 is defective for retrotransposition, suggesting a sequence capable of down-regulating retrotransposition. We mapped this sequence to a critical ~20-bp region within CO-Ty1 reverse transcriptase (RT) and confirmed that it reduced Ty1 transposition, protein, and RNA levels. Repression was not Ty1 specific; when introduced immediately downstream of the green fluorescent protein (GFP) stop codon, GFP expression was similarly reduced. Rap1p mediated this down-regulation, as shown by mutagenesis and chromatin immunoprecipitation. A regular threefold drop is observed in different contexts, suggesting utility for synthetic circuits. A large reduction of RNAP II occupancy on the CO-Ty1 construct was observed 3' to the identified Rap1p site and a novel 3' truncated RNA species was observed. We propose a novel mechanism of transcriptional regulation by Rap1p whereby it serves as a transcriptional roadblock when bound to transcription unit sequences.

Ty1 reverse transcriptase does not read through the proposed 2',5'-branched retrotransposition intermediate in vitro

2',5'-branched RNA was recently proposed as a key Ty1 retrotransposition intermediate, for which cleavage by lariat debranching enzyme (Dbr1p) enables reverse transcription to continue synthesizing the complete Ty1 cDNA. Because dbr1 cells can produce substantial Ty1 cDNA despite lacking Dbr1p, the obligatory intermediacy of branched RNA would require that Ty1 reverse transcriptase (RT) can read through the proposed branch site with considerable efficiency. Here we have used deoxyribozyme-synthesized 2',5'-branched RNA corresponding exactly to the proposed Ty1 branch site for a direct test of this read-through ability. Using an in vitro assay that incorporates all components known to be required for Ty1 cDNA synthesis (including the TyA chaperone protein), Ty1 RT can elongate up to the branch site. Strand transfer from the 2'-arm to the 3'-arm of the branch is observed when the Ty1 RT is RNase H+ (i.e., wild-type) but not when the Ty1 RT is RNase H-. When elongating from either the 2'-arm or the 3'-arm, Ty1 RT reads through the branch site with <or=0.3% efficiency. This is at least 60-fold lower than would be necessary to explain in vivo Ty1 cDNA synthesis in dbr1 cells, because others have reported 18% cDNA synthesis relative to wild-type cells. Our finding that Ty1 RT cannot efficiently read through the proposed Ty1 branch site is inconsistent with the hypothesis that branched RNA is an obligatory Ty1 retrotransposition intermediate. This suggests that Dbr1p acts as other than a 2',5'-phosphodiesterase during Ty1 retrotransposition.

Mn2+ suppressor mutations and biochemical communication between Ty1 reverse transcriptase and RNase H domains

Ty1 reverse transcriptase/RNase H (RT/RH) is exquisitely sensitive to manganese concentrations. Elevated intracellular free Mn(2+) inhibits Ty1 retrotransposition and in vitro Ty1 RT-polymerizing activity. Furthermore, Mn(2+) inhibition is not limited to the Ty1 RT, as this ion similarly inhibits the activities of both avian myeloblastosis virus and human immunodeficiency virus type 1 RTs. To further characterize Mn(2+) inhibition, we generated RT/RH suppressor mutants capable of increased Ty1 transposition in pmr1 Delta cells. PMR1 codes for a P-type ATPase that regulates intracellular calcium and manganese ion homeostasis, and pmr1 mutants accumulate elevated intracellular manganese levels and display 100-fold less transposition than PMR1(+) cells. Mapping of these suppressor mutations revealed, surprisingly, that suppressor point mutations localize not to the RT itself but to the RH domain of the protein. Furthermore, Mn(2+) inhibition of in vitro RT activity is greatly reduced in all the suppressor mutants, whereas RH activity and cleavage specificity remain largely unchanged. These intriguing results reveal that the effect of these suppressor mutations is transmitted to the polymerase domain and suggest biochemical communication between these two domains during reverse transcription.

Reverse transcriptase and integrase of the Saccharomyces cerevisiae Ty1 element

Integrase (IN) and reverse transcriptase (RT) play a central role in transposition of retroelements. The mechanism of integration by IN and the steps of the replication process mediated by RT are briefly described here. Recently, active recombinant forms of Ty1 IN and RT have been obtained. This has allowed a more detailed understanding of their biochemical and structural properties and has made possible combined in vitro and in vivo analyses of their functions. A focus of this review is to discuss some of the results obtained thus far with these two recombinant proteins and to propose future directions.

DBR1 siRNA inhibition of HIV-1 replication

Background

HIV-1 and all retroviruses are related to retroelements of simpler organisms such as the yeast Ty elements. Recent work has suggested that the yeast retroelement Ty1 replicates via an unexpected RNA lariat intermediate in cDNA synthesis. The putative genomic RNA lariat intermediate is formed by a 2'-5' phosphodiester bond, like that found in pre-mRNA intron lariats and it facilitates the minus-strand template switch during cDNA synthesis. We hypothesized that HIV-1 might also form a genomic RNA lariat and therefore that siRNA-mediated inhibition of expression of the human RNA lariat de-branching enzyme (DBR1) expression would specifically inhibit HIV-1 replication.

Results

We designed three short interfering RNA (siRNA) molecules targeting DBR1, which were capable of reducing DBR1 mRNA expression by 80% and did not significantly affect cell viability. We assessed HIV-1 replication in the presence of DBR1 siRNA and found that DBR1 knockdown led to decreases in viral cDNA and protein production. These effects could be reversed by cotransfection of a DBR1 cDNA indicating that the inhibition of HIV-1 replication was a specific effect of DBR1 underexpression.

Conclusion

These data suggest that DBR1 function may be needed to debranch a putative HIV-1 genomic RNA lariat prior to completion of reverse transcription.

Functional genomics reveals relationships between the retrovirus-like Ty1 element and its host Saccharomyces cerevisiae

Retroviruses and their relatives, the long terminal repeat (LTR) retrotransposons, carry out complex life cycles within the cells of their hosts. We have exploited a collection of gene deletion mutants developed by the Saccharomyces Genome Deletion Project to perform a functional genomics screen for host factors that influence the retrovirus-like Ty1 element in yeast. A total of 101 genes that presumably influence many different aspects of the Ty1 retrotransposition cycle were identified from our analysis of 4483 homozygous diploid deletion strains. Of the 101 identified mutants, 46 had significantly altered levels of Ty1 cDNA, whereas the remaining 55 mutants had normal levels of Ty1 cDNA. Thus, approximately half of the mutants apparently affected the early stages of retrotransposition leading up to the assembly of virus-like particles and cDNA replication, whereas the remaining half affected steps that occur after cDNA replication. Although most of the mutants retained the ability to target Ty1 integration to tRNA genes, 2 mutants had reduced levels of tRNA gene targeting. Over 25% of the gene products identified in this study were conserved in other organisms, suggesting that this collection of host factors can serve as a starting point for identifying host factors that influence LTR retroelements and retroviruses in other organisms. Overall, our data indicate that Ty1 requires a large number of cellular host factors to complete its retrotransposition cycle efficiently.

A nucleocapsid functionality contained within the amino terminus of the Ty1 protease that is distinct and separable from proteolytic activity

Ty1 is the most successful of the five endogenous yeast retrotransposons. The life cycle of Ty1 dictates that a number of nucleocapsid (NC)-facilitated events occur although the protein(s) responsible for these events has not been identified. The positioning of the NC peptide is conserved at the carboxy terminus of the Gag protein among most long terminal repeat (LTR)-containing retroelements. An analogous region of Ty1 that simultaneously encodes part of Gag, protease (PR), and the C-terminal p4 peptide was mutagenized. Some of these mutations result in smaller-than-normal virus-like particles (VLPs). The mutants were also found to impair an NC-like functionality contained within the amino terminus of the protease that is distinct and separable from its proteolytic activity. Remarkably, these mutants have distinct defects in reverse transcription.

The yeast retrotransposons Ty1 and Ty3 require the RNA Lariat debranching enzyme, Dbr1p, for efficient accumulation of reverse transcripts

A mutant screen has been initiated to identify host genes important for the replication of retrotransposons in Saccharomyces cerevisiae. Two mutants were identified that undergo Ty1 and Ty3 transposition at <10% of the wild-type frequency. Both these mutants have deficiencies in the accumulation of full-length Ty1 and Ty3 cDNAs, although Ty proteins (including reverse transcriptase) accumulate at wild-type levels. The DBR1 gene, encoding the yeast debranching enzyme, complements both mutants. This suggests that Dbr1p is important for either reverse transcription or the stability of Ty cDNA, roles that have not been previously reported for this protein. The deficiency in accumulation of Ty cDNAs in dbr1 mutants is apparent when engineered Ty elements are expressed for short time periods (6-10 h) but is not apparent following long expression periods (>24 h).

Patching broken chromosomes with extranuclear cellular DNA

Chromosomal double-strand breaks (DSBs) can be repaired by either homology-dependent or homology-independent pathways. Using a novel intron-based genetic assay to identify rare homology-independent DNA rearrangements associated with repair of a chromosomal DSB in S. cerevisiae, we observed that approximately 20% of rearrangements involved endogenous DNA insertions at the break site. We have analyzed 37 inserts and find they fall into two distinct classes: Ty1 cDNA intermediates varying in length from 140 bp to 3.4 kb and short mitochondrial DNA fragments ranging in size from 33 bp to 219 bp. Several inserts consist of multiple noncontiguous mitochondrial DNA segments. These results demonstrate an ongoing mechanism for genome evolution through acquisition of organellar and mobile DNAs at DSB sites.

Reverse transcription of the yeast Ty1 retrotransposon: the mode of first strand transfer is either intermolecular or intramolecular

Replication of the yeast Ty1 retrotransposon occurs by a mechanism similar to that of retroviruses. According to the current model of retroviral reverse transcription, two strand transfers (the so-called minus-strand and plus-strand strong-stop DNA transfers) are required to produce full-length preintegrative DNA. Because two genomic RNA molecules are packaged inside the viral particles, the strand transfers can be either intra- or intermolecular. To study the mode of transfer of minus-strand strong-stop DNA during reverse transcription of the yeast Ty1 retrotransposon, we have analyzed the cDNA products that accumulate in the cytoplasmic virus-like particles of yeast cells harboring two marked Ty1 elements. Our results indicate that Ty1 minus-strand transfer occurs in a random manner with approximately similar frequencies of intra- and intermolecular transfer. It has been observed recently that intra- and intermolecular minus-strand transfer occur at similar frequencies during replication of a complex retrovirus such as HIV-1. These results together with the observation that genetic recombination occurs with a high frequency during minus-strand synthesis suggest that both packaged RNA molecules are needed for the synthesis of one minus-strand DNA.

Temporal coordination between initiation of HIV (+)-strand DNA synthesis and primer removal

In this study, we have analyzed the interdependence between the polymerase and RNase H active sites of human immunodeficiency virus-1 reverse transcriptase (RT) using an in vitro system that closely mimics the initiation of (+)-strand DNA synthesis. Time course experiments show that RT pauses after addition of the 12th DNA residue, and at this stage the RNase H activity starts to cleave the RNA primer from newly synthesized DNA. Comparison of cleavage profiles obtained with 3'- and 5'-end-labeled primer strands indicates that RT now translocates in the opposite direction, i.e. in the 5' direction of the RNA strand. DNA synthesis resumes again in the 3' direction, after the RNA-DNA junction was efficiently cleaved. Moreover, we further characterized complexes generated before, during, and after position +12, by treating these with Fe2+ to localize the RNase H active site on the DNA template. Initially, when RT binds the RNA/DNA substrate, oxidative strand breaks were seen at a distance of 18 base pairs upstream from the primer terminus, whereas 17 base pairs were observed at later stages when the enzyme binds more and more DNA/DNA. These data show that the initiation of (+)-strand synthesis is accompanied by a conformational change of the polymerase-competent complex.

In vivo Ty1 reverse transcription can generate replication intermediates with untidy ends

Ty1 retrotransposition, like retroviral replication, is a complex series of events requiring reverse transcription of an RNA intermediate, RNA-primed minus- and plus-strand DNA synthesis, multiple strand transfers, and precise cleavages of the template and primers by RNase H. In this report, we examine the structure of in vivo Ty1 replication intermediates, specifically with regard to the behavior of reverse transcriptase upon reaching template ends and to the precision with which RNase H might generate these ends. While the expected 3' termini were always identified, terminal nontemplated bases were also observed at all of the RNA and DNA template ends examined. Nontemplated A residues were most common at all 3' ends, although C residues were preferentially added to minus-strand termini paused at the 5' end of capped Ty1 RNA. In addition, we observed that RNase H removal of the tRNA primer and of the polypurine tract was not always precise or efficient. Finally, we noted numerous instances of Ty1 reverse transcriptase transferring from normal Ty1 template ends to various tRNA templates, with continued synthesis to specific modified bases. A similar pattern was obtained for Ty2, indicating that template ends offer unique opportunities for these two related reverse transcriptases to generate errors.

Identification of a sequence element immediately upstream of the polypurine tract that is essential for replication of simian immunodeficiency virus

A short stretch of T-rich sequences immediately upstream of the polypurine tract (PPT) is highly conserved in the proviral genomes of human and simian immunodeficiency viruses (HIV and SIV). To investigate whether this 'U-box' influences SIVmac239 replication, we analyzed the properties of mutants with changes in this region of the viral genome. All mutants were either retarded in their growth (up to one month delay) or did not replicate detectably in CEMx174 cells. When U-box mutants did replicate detectably, compensatory changes were consistently observed in the viral genome. The most common compensatory change was the acquisition of thymidines immediately upstream of the PPT, but marked expansion in the length of the PPT was also observed. U-box mutants produced transiently by transfection were severely impaired in their ability to produce reverse transcripts in infectivity assays. Analysis of transiently produced mutant virus revealed no defect in RNA packaging or virus assembly. These results identify a new structural element important for an early step in the viral life cycle that includes reverse transcription.

Extended minus-strand DNA as template for R-U5-mediated second-strand transfer in recombinational rescue of primer binding site-modified retroviral vectors

We have previously demonstrated recombinational rescue of primer binding site (PBS)-impaired Akv murine leukemia virus-based vectors involving initial priming on endogenous viral sequences and template switching during cDNA synthesis to obtain PBS complementarity in second-strand transfer of reverse transcription (Mikkelsen et al., J. Virol. 70:1439-1447, 1996). By use of the same forced recombination system, we have now found recombinant proviruses of different structures, suggesting that PBS knockout vectors may be rescued through initial priming on endogenous virus RNA, read-through of the mutated PBS during minus-strand synthesis, and subsequent second-strand transfer mediated by the R-U5 complementarity of the plus strand and the extended minus-strand DNA acceptor template. Mechanisms for R-U5-mediated second-strand transfer and its possible role in retrovirus replication and evolution are discussed.

Invading the yeast nucleus: a nuclear localization signal at the C terminus of Ty1 integrase is required for transposition in vivo

Retrotransposon Ty1 faces a formidable cell barrier during transposition--the yeast nuclear membrane which remains intact throughout the cell cycle. We investigated the mechanism by which transposition intermediates are transported from the cytoplasm (the presumed site of Ty1 DNA synthesis) to the nucleus, where they are integrated into the genome. Ty1 integrase has a nuclear localization signal (NLS) at its C terminus. Both full-length integrase and a C-terminal fragment localize to the nucleus. C-terminal deletion mutants in Ty1 integrase were used to map the putative NLS to the last 74 amino acid residues of integrase. Mutations in basic segments within this region decreased retrotransposition at least 50-fold in vivo. Furthermore, these mutant integrase proteins failed to localize to the nucleus. Production of virus-like particles, reverse transcriptase activity, and complete in vitro Ty1 integration resembled wild-type levels, consistent with failure of the mutant integrases to enter the nucleus.

Replication errors during in vivo Ty1 transposition are linked to heterogeneous RNase H cleavage sites

We previously identified a mutational hotspot upstream of the Ty1 U5-primer binding site (PBS) border and proposed a novel mechanism to account for this phenomenon during Ty1 replication. In this report, we verify key points of our model and show that in vivo RNase H cleavage of Ty1 RNA during minus-strand strong-stop synthesis creates heterogeneous 5' RNA ends. The preferred cleavage sites closest to the PBS are 6 and 3 bases upstream of the U5-PBS border. Minus-strand cDNA synthesis terminates at multiple sites determined by RNase H cleavage, and DNA intermediates frequently contain 3'-terminal sequence changes at or near their template ends. These data indicate that nontemplated terminal base addition during reverse transcription is a real in vivo phenomenon and suggest that this mechanism is a major source of sequence variability among retrotransposed genetic elements.

Plus-strand strong-stop DNA transfer in yeast Ty retrotransposons

The yeast Ty1 LTR retrotransposon replicates by reverse transcription and integration; the process shows many similarities to the retroviral life cycle. However, we show that plus strand strong-stop DNA transfer in yeast Ty1 elements differs from the analogous retroviral process. By analysis of the native structure of the Ty1 primer binding site and by a series of manipulations of this region and assessment of the effects on retrotransposition, we show that primer binding site inheritance is not from the tRNA primer, which is inconsistent with classical retroviral models. This unusual inheritance pattern holds even when the Ty1 primer binding site is lengthened in order to be more retrovirus-like. Finally, the distantly related Ty3 element has an inheritance pattern like Ty1, indicating evolutionary conservation of the alternative pathway used by Ty1. Based on these results we arrive at a plus strand primer recycling model that explains Ty1 plus strand strong-stop DNA transfer and inheritance patterns in the primer binding site.

Maintenance of an unusual polypurine tract in HIV-2: stability to passage in culture

A stretch of purine residues, the polypurine tract (PPT), is found in all retroviruses and is used to initiate plus-strand DNA synthesis. While the PPT of most lentiviruses is a homogeneous sequence of purine residues, the PPT of some isolates of the human and simian immunodeficiency viruses is interrupted with a single pyrimidine residue. The ROD strain of human immunodeficiency virus type 2 (HIV-2) has such a pyrimidine-containing variant PPT. Virus generated from an infectious molecular clone, pROD10, was used to infect two CD4-positive T-cell lines, H9 and CEM. The sequence of the PPT was determined after two passages. From both cell lines, the variant PPT was retained, demonstrating that the presence of a pyrimidine in the PPT was fully functional and that there was no strong selection for an all-purine PPT.

Heterogeneous terminal structure of Ty1 and Ty3 reverse transcripts

A specific terminal structure of preintegrative DNA is required for transposition of retroviruses and LTR-retrotransposons. We have used an anchored PCR technique to map the 3'ends of DNA intermediates synthesized inside yeast Ty1 and Ty3 retrotransposon virus-like particles. We find that, unlike retroviruses, Ty1 replicated DNA does not have two extra base pairs at its 3'ends. In contrast some Ty3 preintegrative DNA molecules have two extra nucleotides at the 3'end of upstream and downstream long terminal repeats. Moreover we find that some molecules of replicated Ty3 DNA have more than two extra nucleotides at the 3'end of the upstream LTR. This observation could be accounted for by imprecise RNAse H cutting of the PPT sequence. The site of Ty1 and Ty3 plus-strand strong-stop DNA termination was also examined. Our results confirm that the prominent Ty1 and Ty3 plus-strand strong-stop molecules harbor 12 tRNA templated bases but also show that some Ty1 and Ty3 plus-strand strong-stop DNA molecules harbor less tRNA templated bases. We propose that these less than full length plus-strand molecules could be active intermediates in Ty retrotransposon replication.

Retrovirus-like end processing of the tobacco Tnt1 retrotransposon linear intermediates of replication

The tobacco retrotransposon Tnt1 can transpose through an RNA intermediate in the heterologous host Arabidopsis thaliana. We report here the identification and characterization of extrachromosomal linear and circular DNA forms of Tnt1 in this heterologous host. Our results demonstrate that Tnt1 linear intermediates possess two extra base pairs at each end compared with Tnt1's integrated forms. Prior to integration into the host genome, the two terminal nucleotides at the 3' end of these linear intermediates are removed, as in the case of the yeast Ty3 retrotransposon and of retroviruses. Our data, together with those from recent studies of Ty3, reinforce the idea that 3' dinucleotide cleavage is not restricted to retroviral integrases and is probably a feature shared by many different retrotransposons' enzymes.

Increased length of long terminal repeats inhibits Ty1 transposition and leads to the formation of tandem multimers

The Ty1 retrotransposon of Saccharomyces cerevisiae is bounded by long-terminal repeats (LTRs). We have constructed a variety of Ty1 elements in which the LTR length has been increased from the normal length of 334 bp to > 2 kb. Although small insertions in the LTR have minimal effects on transposition frequency, larger insertions dramatically reduce it. Nevertheless, elements with long LTRs are incorporated into the genome at a low frequency. Most of these rare insertion events represent Ty1 tandem (head to tail) multimers.