Therapeutic effect of Gag-nuclease fusion protein on retrovirus-infected cell cultures

Targeting the Virus Capsid as a Tool to Fight RNA Viruses

Several strategies have been developed to fight viral infections, not only in humans but also in animals and plants. Some of them are based on the development of efficient vaccines, to target the virus by developed antibodies, others focus on finding antiviral compounds with activities that inhibit selected virus replication steps. Currently, there is an increasing number of antiviral drugs on the market; however, some have unpleasant side effects, are toxic to cells, or the viruses quickly develop resistance to them. As the current situation shows, the combination of multiple antiviral strategies or the combination of the use of various compounds within one strategy is very important. The most desirable are combinations of drugs that inhibit different steps in the virus life cycle. This is an important issue especially for RNA viruses, which replicate their genomes using error-prone RNA polymerases and rapidly develop mutants resistant to applied antiviral compounds. Here, we focus on compounds targeting viral structural capsid proteins, thereby inhibiting virus assembly or disassembly, virus binding to cellular receptors, or acting by inhibiting other virus replication mechanisms. This review is an update of existing papers on a similar topic, by focusing on the most recent advances in the rapidly evolving research of compounds targeting capsid proteins of RNA viruses.

Capsid-Targeted Viral Inactivation: A Novel Tactic for Inhibiting Replication in Viral Infections

Capsid-targeted viral inactivation (CTVI), a conceptually powerful new antiviral strategy, is attracting increasing attention from researchers. Specifically, this strategy is based on fusion between the capsid protein of a virus and a crucial effector molecule, such as a nuclease (e.g., staphylococcal nuclease, Barrase, RNase HI), lipase, protease, or single-chain antibody (scAb). In general, capsid proteins have a major role in viral integration and assembly, and the effector molecule used in CTVI functions to degrade viral DNA/RNA or interfere with proper folding of viral key proteins, thereby affecting the infectivity of progeny viruses. Interestingly, such a capsid-enzyme fusion protein is incorporated into virions during packaging. CTVI is more efficient compared to other antiviral methods, and this approach is promising for antiviral prophylaxis and therapy. This review summarizes the mechanism and utility of CTVI and provides some successful applications of this strategy, with the ultimate goal of widely implementing CTVI in antiviral research.

Evaluation of a system to screen for stimulators of non-specific DNA nicking by HIV-1 integrase: application to a library of 50,000 compounds

BACKGROUND

In addition to activities needed to catalyse integration, retroviral integrases exhibit non-specific endonuclease activity that is enhanced by certain small compounds, suggesting that integrase could be stimulated to damage viral DNA before integration occurs.

METHODS

A non-radioactive, plate-based, solution phase, fluorescence assay was used to screen a library of 50,080 drug-like chemicals for stimulation of non-specific DNA nicking by HIV-1 integrase.

RESULTS

A semi-automated workflow was established and primary hits were readily identified from a graphic output. Overall, 0.6% of the chemicals caused a large increase in fluorescence (the primary hit rate) without also having visible colour that could have artifactually caused this result. None of the potential stimulators from this moderate-size library, however, passed a secondary test that included an inactive integrase mutant that assessed whether the increased fluorescence depended on the endonuclease activity of integrase.

CONCLUSIONS

This first attempt at identifying integrase stimulator compounds establishes the necessary logistics and workflow required. The results from this study should encourage larger scale high-throughput screening to advance the novel antiviral strategy of stimulating integrase to damage retroviral DNA.

A nonradioactive plate-based assay for stimulators of nonspecific DNA nicking by HIV-1 integrase and other nucleases

Retroviral integrase enzymes have a nonspecific endonuclease activity that is stimulated by certain compounds, suggesting that integrase could be manipulated to damage viral DNA. To identify integrase stimulator (IS) compounds as potential antiviral agents, we have developed a nonradioactive assay that is suitable for high-throughput screening. The assay uses a 49-mer oligonucleotide that is 5'-labeled with a fluorophore, 3'-tagged with a quencher, and designed to form a hairpin that mimics radioactive double-stranded substrates in gel-based nicking assays. Reactions in 384-well plates are analyzed on a real-time PCR machine after a single heat denaturation and subsequent cooling to a point between the melting temperatures of unnicked substrate and nicked products (no cycling is required). Under these conditions, unnicked DNA reforms the hairpin and quenches fluorescence, whereas completely nicked DNA yields a large signal. The assay was linear with time, stimulator concentration, and amount of integrase, and 20% concentrations of the solvent used for many chemical libraries did not interfere with the assay. The assay had an excellent Z' factor, and it reliably detected known IS compounds. This assay, which is adaptable to other nonspecific nucleases, will be useful for identifying additional IS compounds to develop the novel antiviral strategy of stimulating integrase to destroy retroviral DNA.

Dimerization of the erythropoietin receptor transmembrane domain in micelles

Erythropoietin receptor (EpoR) homodimerization is an initial regulatory step in erythrocyte formation. Receptor dimers form before ligand binding, suggesting that association between receptor proteins is dependent on the receptor itself. EpoR dimerization is an essential step in erythropoiesis, and misregulation of this dimerization has been implicated in several disease states, including multi-lineage leukemias; nevertheless, how EpoR regulates its own dimerization is unclear. In vivo experiments suggest the single-pass transmembrane helix is the strongest candidate for driving ligand-independent association. To address the self-association potential of this transmembrane segment, we studied its interaction energetics in micelles by utilizing a previously successful Staphylococcal nuclease (SN-EpoR TM) fusion protein. This fusion protein strategy allows expression of the EpoR transmembrane domain in Escherichia coli independent of the other EpoR domains. Sedimentation equilibrium analytical ultracentrifugation of the detergent-solubilized SN-EpoR TM demonstrated that the murine EpoR transmembrane domain self-associates to form dimers. Although this interaction is not as stable as the dimerization of the well-studied glycophorin A transmembrane dimer, the murine EpoR transmembrane domain dimer is more stable than the interactions of the colon carcinoma kinase 4 transmembrane domain. The same experiments with the human EpoR transmembrane domain, which differs from the mouse sequence by only three residues, revealed a less favorable interaction than that of the murine sequence and is only slightly more favorable than that expected for non-preferential binding. These results suggest that the mouse and human receptor proteins may differ in the roles they play in signaling.

Gene therapy for HIV infection: what does it need to make it work?

The efficacy of antiviral drug therapy for HIV infection is limited by toxicity and viral resistance. Thus, alternative therapies need to be explored. Several gene therapeutic strategies for HIV infection have been developed, but in clinical testing therapeutically effective levels of the transgene product were not achieved. This review focuses on the determinants of therapeutic efficacy and discusses the potential and also the limits of current gene therapy approaches for HIV infection.

Capsid-targeted viral inactivation can destroy dengue 2 virus from within in vitro

Capsid-targeted viral inactivation (CTVI) has emerged as a conceptually powerful antiviral strategy that exploits viral structural proteins to target a destructive enzyme specifically into progeny virions. We have recently demonstrated the principle of CTVI against dengue virus infection and observed a modest therapeutic effect in vitro (Arch Virol 2005, 150: 659-669). Here we tested a prophylactic model of CTVI, in which mammalian cells stably expressing the dengue 2 virus capsid protein fused to a nuclease were infected with dengue virus and determined the effects on progeny virion infectivity. CTVI efficiently destroyed dengue 2 virus from within and decreased the infectious titers by 10(3)- to 10(4)-fold, suggesting that CTVI has potential in the prophylactic application for dengue virus infection.

Targeted ribonuclease can inhibit replication of hepatitis B virus

AIM: To study the effect of a novel targeted ribonuclease (TN), the fusion protein of HBVc and human eosinophil-derived neurotoxin (hEDN), on the HBV replication in vitro.

METHODS: The gene encoding the targeted ribonuclease was cloned into pcDNA3.1 (-) to form recombinant eukaryotic expression vector p/TN. Control plasmids, including p/hEDN, p/HBVc, and p/TNmut in which a Lys113→Arg mutation was introduced by sequential PCR to eliminate the ribonuclease activity of hEDN, were also constructed. Liposome-mediated transfection of 2.2.15 cells by p/TN, p/TNmut, p/hEDN, p/HBVc, and pcDNA3.1 (-), or mock transfection was performed. After that, RT-PCR was used to verify the transgene expression. Morphology of the transfected cells was observed and MTT assay was performed to detect the cytotoxicity of transgene expression. Concentration of HBsAg in the supernatant of the transfected cells was measured using solid-phase radioimmunoassay.

RESULTS: Transgenes were successfully expressed in 2.2.15 cells. No obvious cytotoxic effect of transgene expression on 2.2.15 cells was found. The HBsAg concentration in the p/TN transfected cells was reduced by 58% compared with that of mock transfected cells. No such an effect was found in all other controls.

CONCLUSION: The targeted ribonuclease can inhibit HBV replication in vitro while it has no cytotoxicity on host cells. The targeted ribonuclease may be used as a novel antiviral agent for human HBV infection.

Therapeutic effect of a Gag-nuclease fusion protein against retroviral infection in vivo

Recently, remarkable progress has been made in developing effective combination drug therapies that can control but not cure retroviral replication. Even when effective, these drug regimens are toxic, they require demanding administration schedules, and resistant viruses can emerge. Thus the need for new gene-based therapies continues. In one such approach, capsid-targeted viral inactivation (CTVI), nucleases fused to viral coat proteins are expressed in infected cells and become incorporated during virion assembly. CTVI can eliminate infectious murine retrovirus titer in tissue culture. Here we describe transgenic mice expressing fusions of the Moloney murine leukemia virus (Mo-MuLV) Gag protein to staphylococcal nuclease. This work tests the protective effect and demonstrates in vivo proof-of-principle of CTVI in transgenic mice expressing endogenous proviral copies of Mo-MuLV. The antiviral protein-expressing mice are phenotypically normal, attesting to the lack of toxicity of the fusion protein. The Mo-MuLV infection was much less virulent in transgenic littermates than in nontransgenic littermates. Gag-nuclease expression reduced infectious titers in blood up to 10-fold, decreased splenomegaly and leukemic infiltration, and increased life spans up to 2.5-fold in transgenic relative to nontransgenic infected animals. These results suggest that gene therapies based on similar fusion proteins, designed to attack human immunodeficiency virus or other retroviruses, could provide substantial therapeutic benefits.

Significant interference with hepatitis B virus replication by a core-nuclease fusion protein

Hepatitis B virus (HBV), a small DNA containing virus that replicates via reverse transcription, causes acute and chronic B-type hepatitis in humans. The limited success of current therapies for chronic infection has prompted exploration of alternative strategies. Capsid-targeted viral inactivation is a conceptually powerful approach that exploits virion structural proteins to target a degradative enzyme specifically into viral particles. Its principal feasibility has been demonstrated in retroviral model systems but not yet for a medically relevant virus outside the retrovirus family. Recently, we found that C proximal fusion to the HBV capsid protein of the Ca(2+)-dependent nuclease (SN) from Staphylococcus aureus yields a chimeric protein, coreSN, that in Escherichia coli coassembles with the wild-type capsid protein into particles with internal SN domains. Here we show that, in HBV co-transfected human hepatoma cells, less than 1 coreSN protein per 10 wild-type core protein subunits reduced titers of enveloped DNA containing virions by more than 95%. The antiviral effect depends on both an enzymatically active SN and on the core domain. CoreSN does not block assembly of RNA containing nucleocapsids but interferes with proper synthesis of viral DNA inside the capsid, or leads to rapid DNA degradation. Our data suggest an intracellular nuclease activation that, owing to the characteristics of HBV morphogenesis, is nonetheless highly virus specific. HBV may therefore be particularly vulnerable to the capsid-targeted viral inactivation approach.

Capsid-targeted viral inactivation can eliminate the production of infectious murine leukemia virus in vitro

Capsid-targeted viral inactivation (CTVI), a promising gene-based antiviral strategy against retroviruses, was designed to disrupt the retroviral life cycle by incorporating a degradative enzyme (e.g., nuclease) into viral particles during assembly, thereby reducing or eliminating the production of infectious virus. The experimental system used to develop the CTVI strategy for retroviruses is designed to block the production of infectious Moloney murine leukemia virus (Mo-MLV). Two nucleases, Escherichia coli ribonulease HI and Staphylococcus nuclease, have been shown to be tolerated by the cell as Mo-MLV Gag-nuclease fusion polyproteins and still be active in the viral particles. The goal of this study was to determine what cellular and viral factors limit CTVI in cultured cells. The avian DF-1 cell line greatly expanded our ability to test the antiviral efficacy of CTVI in long-term assays and to determine the mechanism(s) of CTVI action. The CTVI antiviral effect is dependent on the level of Mo-MLV Gag-nuclease fusion polyprotein expressed. The Mo-MLV Gag-nuclease polyproteins produce a long-term prophylactic antiviral effect after a low- or high-dose Mo-MLV challenge. The Mo-MLV Gag-nuclease fusions have a significant therapeutic effect ( approximately 1000-fold) on the production of infectious Mo-MLV. The therapeutic CTVI effect can be improved by a second delivery of the CTVI fusion gene. Both the prophylactic and the therapeutic CTVI antiviral approaches can virtually eliminate the production of infectious Mo-MLV in vitro and are only limited by the number of cells in the population that do not express adequate levels of the CTVI fusion polyprotein.

Dominant negative mutants of the duck hepatitis B virus core protein interfere with RNA pregenome packaging and viral DNA synthesis

Dominant negative (DN) mutants of the hepadnaviral core protein are potent inhibitors of viral replication. We have previously shown that fusion of sequences derived from the duck hepatitis B virus (DHBV) polymerase (Pol), DHBV small surface protein (S), bacterial beta-galactosidase (lacZ), or green fluorescent protein (GFP) to the carboxy terminus of the DHBV core protein yields DN mutants that inhibit viral replication at the posttranslational level. To elucidate the mechanism(s) of their antiviral action, we analyzed the effect of the DN mutants on RNA pregenome packaging and nucleocapsid assembly. Core-Pol and core-S, but not core-lacZ or core-GFP, markedly interfered with RNA pregenome packaging. Nucleocapsid formation was not affected by any of the mutants. The DN core-GFP fusion protein formed mixed particles with wild-type core protein in the cytoplasm of cotransfected cells and interfered with reverse transcription of the viral pregenome. A subpopulation of chimeric nucleocapsids, however, was shown to overcome the block in DNA synthesis and produce mature viral DNA. Thus, at least 2 steps within the viral life cycle can be targeted by DN DHBV core proteins: 1) packaging of the viral pregenome; and 2) reverse transcription within mixed particles. The fact that some mixed particles retain replication competence demonstrates a high structural flexibility of nucleocapsids and indicates a possible mechanism of viral escape.

The biochemistry of gene therapy for AIDS

Gene therapy has enormous potential and could in the near future involve the clinical biochemist in monitoring its efficacy. The involvement of clinical biochemists in this field could be not only in evaluating the impact of a gene-based strategy on disease progression, but also in measuring the expression of the products of therapeutic genes in treated individuals. Indeed, gene therapy presents new possibilities for the treatment of many diseases and, in particular, merits consideration in the treatment of a fatal disease like AIDS. The aim of this paper is to review the biochemical basis and clinical relevance of the gene therapy approaches directed towards the inhibition of human immunodeficiency virus type-1. We discuss the goals which have been achieved, the problems which have occurred and the efforts that are being made to solve them. In this regard, particular attention is paid to new strategies targeting 'therapeutic' enzymes to human immunodeficiency virus type-1 nucleic acids.

Expression of a murine leukemia virus Gag-Escherichia coli RNase HI fusion polyprotein significantly inhibits virus spread

The antiviral strategy of capsid-targeted viral inactivation (CTVI) was designed to disable newly produced virions by fusing a Gag or Gag-Pol polyprotein to a degradative enzyme (e.g., a nuclease or protease) that would cause the degradative enzyme to be inserted into virions during assembly. Several new experimental approaches have been developed that increase the antiviral effect of the CTVI strategy on retroviral replication in vitro. A Moloney murine leukemia virus (Mo-MLV) Gag-Escherichia coli RNase HI fusion has a strong antiviral effect when used prophylactically, inhibiting the spread of Mo-MLV and reducing virus titers 1,500- to 2,500-fold. A significant (approximately 100-fold) overall improvement of the CTVI prophylactic antiviral effect was produced by a modification in the culture conditions which presumably increases the efficiency of delivery and expression of the Mo-MLV Gag fusion polyproteins. The therapeutic effect of Mo-MLV Gag-RNase HI polyproteins is to reduce the production of infectious Mo-MLV up to 18-fold. An Mo-MLV Gag-degradative enzyme fusion junction was designed that can be cleaved by the Mo-MLV protease to release the degradative enzyme.

Destroying retroviruses from within

One strategy for neutralizing retroviral infectivity is to induce the incorporation of lethal fusion proteins, such as capsid protein-nuclease fusions, into the virion during the normal viral assembly process. Genes encoding such antiviral fusion proteins must be nontoxic to the host, lethal to the virus, and must be efficiently delivered to, and expressed in, appropriate target cells.