Characterization of the vaccinia virus A35R protein and its role in virulence

Mpox vaccine and infection-driven human immune signatures: an immunological analysis of an observational study

BACKGROUND

Monkeypox virus has recently infected more than 88 000 people, raising concerns about our preparedness against this emerging viral pathogen. Licensed and approved for mpox, the JYNNEOS vaccine has fewer side-effects than previous smallpox vaccines and has shown immunogenicity against monkeypox in animal models. This study aims to elucidate human immune responses to JYNNEOS vaccination compared with mpox-induced immunity.

METHODS

Peripheral blood mononuclear cells and sera were obtained from ten individuals vaccinated with one or two doses of JYNNEOS and six individuals diagnosed with monkeypox virus infection. Samples were obtained from seven individuals before vaccination to serve as a baseline. We examined the polyclonal serum (ELISA) and single B-cell (heavy chain gene and transcriptome data) antibody repertoires and T-cell responses (activation-induced marker and intracellular cytokine staining assays) induced by the JYNNEOS vaccine versus monkeypox virus infection.

FINDINGS

All participants were men between the ages of 21 and 60 years, except for one woman in the group of mpox-convalescent individuals, and none had previous orthopoxvirus exposure. All mpox cases were mild. Vaccinee samples were collected 6-33 days after the first dose and 5-40 days after the second dose. Mpox-convalescent samples were collected 20-102 days after infection. In vaccine recipients, gene-level plasmablast and antibody responses were negligible and sera displayed moderate binding to recombinant orthopoxviral proteins (A29L, A35R, E8L, A30L, A27L, A33R, B18R, and L1R) and native proteins from the 2022 monkeypox outbreak strain. By contrast, recent monkeypox virus infection (within 20-102 days) induced robust serum antibody responses to monkeypox virus proteins and to native monkeypox virus proteins from a viral isolate obtained during the 2022 outbreak. JYNNEOS vaccine recipients presented robust orthopoxviral CD4+ and CD8+ T-cell responses.

INTERPRETATION

Infection with monkeypox virus resulted in robust B-cell and T-cell responses, whereas immunisation with JYNNEOS elicited more robust T-cell responses. These data can help to inform vaccine design and policies for preventing mpox in humans.

FUNDING

National Cancer Institute (National Institutes of Health), National Institute of Allergy and Infectious Diseases (National Institutes of Health), and Icahn School of Medicine.

Selective events at individual sites underlie the evolution of monkeypox virus clades

In endemic regions (West Africa and the Congo Basin), the genetic diversity of monkeypox virus (MPXV) is geographically structured into two major clades (Clades I and II) that differ in virulence and host associations. Clade IIb is closely related to the B.1 lineage, which is dominating a worldwide outbreak initiated in 2022. Lineage B.1 has however accumulated mutations of unknown significance that most likely result from apolipoprotein B mRNA editing catalytic polypeptide-like 3 (APOBEC3) editing. We applied a population genetics-phylogenetics approach to investigate the evolution of MPXV during historical viral spread in Africa and to infer the distribution of fitness effects. We observed a high preponderance of codons evolving under strong purifying selection, particularly in viral genes involved in morphogenesis and replication or transcription. However, signals of positive selection were also detected and were enriched in genes involved in immunomodulation and/or virulence. In particular, several genes showing evidence of positive selection were found to hijack different steps of the cellular pathway that senses cytosolic DNA. Also, a few selected sites in genes that are not directly involved in immunomodulation are suggestive of antibody escape or other immune-mediated pressures. Because orthopoxvirus host range is primarily determined by the interaction with the host immune system, we suggest that the positive selection signals represent signatures of host adaptation and contribute to the different virulence of Clade I and II MPXVs. We also used the calculated selection coefficients to infer the effects of mutations that define the predominant human MPXV1 (hMPXV1) lineage B.1, as well as the changes that have been accumulating during the worldwide outbreak. Results indicated that a proportion of deleterious mutations were purged from the predominant outbreak lineage, whose spread was not driven by the presence of beneficial changes. Polymorphic mutations with a predicted beneficial effect on fitness are few and have a low frequency. It remains to be determined whether they have any significance for ongoing virus evolution.

Mpox vaccine and infection-driven human immune signatures

Background

Mpox (formerly known as monkeypox) outbreaks outside endemic areas peaked in July 2022, infecting > 85,000 people and raising concerns about our preparedness against this emerging viral pathogen. Licensed and approved for mpox, the JYNNEOS vaccine has fewer side effects than previous smallpox vaccines and demonstrated efficacy against mpox infection in humans. Comparing JYNNEOS vaccine- and mpox-induced immunity is imperative to evaluate JYNNEOS' immunogenicity and inform vaccine administration and design.

Methods

We examined the polyclonal serum (ELISA) and single B cell (heavy chain gene and transcriptome data) antibody repertoires and T cells (AIM and ICS assays) induced by the JYNNEOS vaccine as well as mpox infection.

Findings

Gene-level plasmablast and antibody responses were negligible and JYNNEOS vaccinee sera displayed minimal binding to recombinant mpox proteins and native proteins from the 2022 outbreak strain. In contrast, recent mpox infection (within 20-102 days) induced robust serum antibody responses to A29L, A35R, A33R, B18R, and A30L, and to native mpox proteins, compared to vaccinees. JYNNEOS vaccine recipients presented comparable CD4 and CD8 T cell responses against orthopox peptides to those observed after mpox infection.

Interpretation

JYNNEOS immunization does not elicit a robust B cell response, and its immunogenicity may be mediated by T cells.

Funding

Research reported in this publication was supported, in part, by the National Cancer Institute of the National Institutes of Health under Award Number U54CA267776, U19AI168631(VS), as well as institutional funds from the Icahn School of Medicine.

Gene amplification acts as a molecular foothold to facilitate cross-species adaptation and evasion of multiple antiviral pathways

Cross-species spillover events are responsible for many of the pandemics in human history including COVID-19; however, the evolutionary mechanisms that enable these events are poorly understood. We have previously modeled this process using a chimeric vaccinia virus expressing the rhesus cytomegalovirus-derived protein kinase R (PKR) antagonist RhTRS1 in place of its native PKR antagonists: E3L and K3L (VACVΔEΔK + RhTRS1). Using this virus, we demonstrated that gene amplification of rhtrs1 occurred early during experimental evolution and was sufficient to fully rescue virus replication in partially resistant African green monkey (AGM) fibroblasts. Notably, this rapid gene amplification also allowed limited virus replication in otherwise completely non-permissive human fibroblasts, suggesting that gene amplification may act as a 'molecular foothold' to facilitate viral adaptation to multiple species. In this study, we demonstrate that there are multiple barriers to VACVΔEΔK + RhTRS1 replication in human cells, mediated by both PKR and ribonuclease L (RNase L). We experimentally evolved three AGM-adapted virus populations in human fibroblasts. Each population adapted to human cells bimodally, via an initial 10-fold increase in replication after only two passages followed by a second 10-fold increase in replication by passage 9. Using our Illumina-based pipeline, we found that some single nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs) which had evolved during the prior AGM adaptation were rapidly lost, while thirteen single-base substitutions and short indels increased over time, including two SNPs unique to human foreskin fibroblast (HFF)-adapted populations. Many of these changes were associated with components of the viral RNA polymerase, although no variant was shared between all three populations. Taken together, our results demonstrate that rhtrs1 amplification was sufficient to increase viral tropism after passage in an 'intermediate species' and subsequently enabled the virus to adopt different, species-specific adaptive mechanisms to overcome distinct barriers to viral replication in AGM and human cells.

Gene amplification acts as a molecular foothold to facilitate cross-species adaptation and evasion of multiple antiviral pathways

Cross-species spillover events are responsible for many of the pandemics in human history including COVID-19; however, the evolutionary mechanisms that enable these events are poorly understood. We have previously modeled this process using a chimeric vaccinia virus expressing the rhesus cytomegalovirus-derived PKR antagonist RhTRS1 in place of its native PKR antagonists; E3L and K3L (VACVΔEΔK+RhTRS1). Using this virus, we demonstrated that gene amplification of rhtrs1 occurred early during experimental evolution and was sufficient to fully rescue virus replication in partially resistant African green monkey (AGM) fibroblasts. Notably, this rapid gene amplification also allowed limited virus replication in otherwise completely non-permissive human fibroblasts, suggesting that gene amplification may act as a "molecular foothold" to facilitate viral adaptation to multiple species. In this study, we demonstrate that there are multiple barriers to VACVΔEΔK+RhTRS1 replication in human cells, mediated by both PKR and RNase L. We experimentally evolved three AGM-adapted virus populations in human fibroblasts. Each population adapted to human cells bimodally, via an initial 10-fold increase in replication after only two passages followed by a second 10-fold increase in replication by passage nine. Using our Illumina-based pipeline, we found that some SNPs which had evolved during the prior AGM adaptation were rapidly lost, while 13 single-base substitutions and short indels increased over time, including two SNPs unique to HFF adapted populations. Many of these changes were associated with components of the viral RNA polymerase, although no variant was shared between all three populations. Taken together, our results demonstrate that rhtrs1 amplification was sufficient to increase viral tropism after passage in an "intermediate species" and subsequently enabled the virus to adopt different, species-specific adaptive mechanisms to overcome distinct barriers to viral replication in AGM and human cells.

Enhancing the Immunogenicity of Vaccinia Virus

The conventional live smallpox vaccine based on the vaccinia virus (VACV) cannot be widely used today because it is highly reactogenic. Therefore, there is a demand for designing VACV variants possessing enhanced immunogenicity, making it possible to reduce the vaccine dose and, therefore, significantly eliminate the pathogenic effect of the VACV on the body. In this study, we analyzed the development of the humoral and T cell-mediated immune responses elicited by immunizing mice with low-dose VACV variants carrying the mutant A34R gene (which increases production of extracellular virions) or the deleted A35R gene (whose protein product inhibits antigen presentation by the major histocompatibility complex class II). The VACV LIVP strain, which is used as a smallpox vaccine in Russia, and its recombinant variants LIVP-A34R*, LIVP-dA35R, and LIVP-A34R*-dA35R, were compared upon intradermal immunization of BALB/c mice at a dose of 10⁴ pfu/animal. The strongest T cell-mediated immunity was detected in mice infected with the LIVP-A34R*-dA35R virus. The parental LIVP strain induced a significantly lower antibody level compared to the strains carrying the modified A34R and A35R genes. Simultaneous modification of the A34R gene and deletion of the A35R gene in VACV LIVP synergistically enhanced the immunogenic properties of the LIVP-A34R*-dA35R virus.

Vaccinia Virus: From Crude Smallpox Vaccines to Elaborate Viral Vector Vaccine Design

Various vaccinia virus (VACV) strains were applied during the smallpox vaccination campaign to eradicate the variola virus worldwide. After the eradication of smallpox, VACV gained popularity as a viral vector thanks to increasing innovations in genetic engineering and vaccine technology. Some VACV strains have been extensively used to develop vaccine candidates against various diseases. Modified vaccinia virus Ankara (MVA) is a VACV vaccine strain that offers several advantages for the development of recombinant vaccine candidates. In addition to various host-restriction genes, MVA lacks several immunomodulatory genes of which some have proven to be quite efficient in skewing the immune response in an unfavorable way to control infection in the host. Studies to manipulate these genes aim to optimize the immunogenicity and safety of MVA-based viral vector vaccine candidates. Here we summarize the history and further work with VACV as a vaccine and present in detail the genetic manipulations within the MVA genome to improve its immunogenicity and safety as a viral vector vaccine.

Mosquito-infecting virus Espirito Santo virus inhibits replication and spread of dengue virus

The primary vector of dengue virus (DENV) is Aedes aegypti. The mosquito-infecting virus, Espirito Santo virus (ESV), does not infect Vero (mammalian) cells and grows in mosquito (C6/36) cells without cytopathic effects. Effects of ESV infection on replication of DENV were explored in vitro and in vivo, analyzing protein, RNA genome expression, and plaque formation. ESV and DENV simultaneous coinfection did not block protein synthesis from either virus but did result in inhibition of DENV replication in mosquito cells. Furthermore, ESV superinfected with DENV resulted in inhibition of DENV replication and spread in A. aegypti, thus reducing vector competence. Tissue culture experiments on viral kinetics of ESV and DENV coinfection showed that neither virus significantly affects the replication of the other in Vero, HeLa, or HEK cells. Hence, ESV blocks DENV replication in insect cells, but not the mammalian cells evaluated here. Our study provides new insights into ESV-induced suppression of DENV, a globally important pathogen impacting public health.

Species-Specific Conservation of Linear Antigenic Sites on Vaccinia Virus A27 Protein Homologs of Orthopoxviruses

The vaccinia virus (VACV) A27 protein and its homologs, which are found in a large number of members of the genus Orthopoxvirus (OPXV), are targets of viral neutralization by host antibodies. We have mapped six binding sites (epitopes #1A: aa 32–39, #1B: aa 28–33, #1C: aa 26–31, #1D: 28–34, #4: aa 9–14, and #5: aa 68–71) of A27 specific monoclonal antibodies (mAbs) using peptide arrays. MAbs recognizing epitopes #1A–D and #4 neutralized VACV Elstree in a complement dependent way (50% plaque-reduction: 12.5–200 µg/mL). Fusion of VACV at low pH was blocked through inhibition of epitope #1A. To determine the sequence variability of the six antigenic sites, 391 sequences of A27 protein homologs available were compared. Epitopes #4 and #5 were conserved among most of the OPXVs, while the sequential epitope complex #1A–D was more variable and, therefore, responsible for species-specific epitope characteristics. The accurate and reliable mapping of defined epitopes on immuno-protective proteins such as the A27 of VACV enables phylogenetic studies and insights into OPXV evolution as well as to pave the way to the development of safer vaccines and chemical or biological antivirals.

Construction of an attenuated Tian Tan vaccinia virus strain by deletion of TA35R and TJ2R genes

rVTT-TA35-TJ, an attenuated vaccinia virus Tian Tan strain (VTT), was constructed by knocking out two non-essential gene fragments (TA35R and TJ2R) related to virulence, immunomodulation, and host range; and by combining double marker screening with exogenous and endogenous selectable marker knock-out techniques. Here, the shuttle plasmids pSK-TA35 and pSK-TJ were constructed, containing two pairs of recombinant arms: early and late strong promoter pE/L and EGFP as an exogenous selectable marker. The recombinant vaccinia virus rVTT-TA35-TJ without exogenous selection markers was then obtained through homologous recombination technology and the Cre/loxP system. Knocking out the two gene fragments does not affect the replication ability of the virus and displays a good genetic stability. Furthermore, a series of in vivo and in vitro experiments demonstrate that although virulence of rVTT-TA35-TJ is attenuated significantly, high immunogenicity was maintained. These results support the potential development of rVTT-TA35-TJ as a safe viral vector or vaccine.

Modulating Vaccinia Virus Immunomodulators to Improve Immunological Memory

The increasing frequency of monkeypox virus infections, new outbreaks of other zoonotic orthopoxviruses and concern about the re-emergence of smallpox have prompted research into developing antiviral drugs and better vaccines against these viruses. This article considers the genetic engineering of vaccinia virus (VACV) to enhance vaccine immunogenicity and safety. The virulence, immunogenicity and protective efficacy of VACV strains engineered to lack specific immunomodulatory or host range proteins are described. The ultimate goal is to develop safer and more immunogenic VACV vaccines that induce long-lasting immunological memory.

Development of improved therapeutic mesothelin-based vaccines for pancreatic cancer

Pancreatic cancer is the 5^th leading cause of cancer deaths, and there are no effective treatments. We developed a poxvirus platform vaccine with improved immunogenicity and inserted the mesothelin gene to create an anti-mesothelin cancer vaccine. Mesothelin expression is mostly restricted to tumors in adult mammals and thus may be a good target for cancer treatment. We show here that the modified vaccinia virus Ankara (MVA) virus expressing mesothelin and the enhanced MVA virus missing the immunosuppressive A35 gene and expressing mesothelin were both safe in mice and were able to induce IFN-gamma secreting T cells in response to mesothelin expressing tumor cells. In addition, the MVA virus has oncolytic properties in vitro as it can replicate in and kill Panc02 pancreatic adenocarcinoma cell line tumor cells, even though it is unable to replicate in most mammalian cells. Deletion of the A35 gene in MVA improved T cell responses as expected. However, we were unable to demonstrate inhibition of Panc02 tumor growth in immunocompetent mice with pre-vaccination of mice, boosts, or even intratumoral injections of the recombinant viruses. Vaccine efficacy may be limited by shedding of mesothelin from tumor cells thus creating a protective screen from the immune system.

The effects of diets enriched in omega-3 polyunsaturated fatty acids on systemic vaccinia virus infection

Omega-3 polyunsaturated fatty acids (PUFA, n-3 fatty acids), the key components of fish and flaxseed oils, are increasingly consumed by the public because of their potential health benefits and are available by prescription for hypertriglyceridemia. However, numerous studies have shown that these compounds are immunoregulatory and immunosuppressive and thus may increase susceptibility to infection. In this study, we tested the effects of the amount of fat and the types of fatty acid in the diet on infection by vaccinia virus, an acute infection that begins in the respiratory tract and spreads by viremia to internal organs. Male C57Bl6 mice (~5 week old) were fed for 3 weeks prior to infection and continuing during infection and recovery one of the following: 1) a normal low fat (13% kcal) diet, 2) a low fat diet containing n-3 PUFAs, 3) a high fat (41% kcal) diet rich in n-3 PUFAs, 4) a high fat n-6 PUFA diet, or 5) a high fat monounsaturated diet. We found no statistically significant differences in the susceptibility of mice to viral infection, morbidity, viral organ titers, recovery time, or mortality with these diets, indicating that, over this approximately 6-week time period, dietary fats did not substantially affect responses to poxviral infection.

Generation of an Attenuated Tiantan Vaccinia Virus Strain by Deletion of Multiple Genes

An attenuated vaccinia virus-MVTT_EAB-was constructed by deletion of non-essential gene segments related to the immunomodulatory and virulence functions of the vaccinia virus Tiantan strain (VVTT). The shuttle plasmids pTC-EGFP, pTE-EGFP, pTA35-EGFP, pTB-EGFP, and pTA66-EGFP were constructed and combined with the early and late strong promoter pE/L and EGFP as an exogenous selectable marker. Then, through the homologous recombination technology and Cre/loxP system, the following gene fragments were gradually knocked out one by one: TC7L-TK2L, TE3L, TA35R, TB13R, and TA66R. Ultimately, the five-segment-deleted attenuated strain MVTT_EAB was obtained. Knockout of these segments and genetic stability of MVTT_EAB were confirmed, and it was also shown that knockout of these segments did not affect the replication ability of the virus. Further, a series of in vivo and in vitro experiments demonstrated that the virulence of MVTT_EAB was attenuated significantly, but at same time, high immunogenicity was maintained. These results indicate that MVTT_EAB has potential for clinical use as a safe viral vector or vaccine with good attenuation and immunogenicity.

Ectromelia virus accumulates less double-stranded RNA compared to vaccinia virus in BS-C-1 cells

Most orthopoxviruses, including vaccinia virus (VACV), contain genes in the E3L and K3L families. The protein products of these genes have been shown to combat PKR, a host defense pathway. Interestingly, ectromelia virus (ECTV) contains an E3L ortholog but does not possess an intact K3L gene. Here, we gained insight into how ECTV can still efficiently evade PKR despite lacking K3L. Relative to VACV, we found that ECTV-infected BS-C-1 cells accumulated considerably less double-stranded (ds) RNA, which was due to lower mRNA levels and less transcriptional read-through of some genes by ECTV. The abundance of dsRNA in VACV-infected cells, detected using a monoclonal antibody, was able to activate the RNase L pathway at late time points post-infection. Historically, the study of transcription by orthopoxviruses has largely focused on VACV as a model. Our data suggest that there could be more to learn by studying other members of this genus.

Poxvirus Safety Analysis in the Pregnant Mouse Model, Vaccinia, and Raccoonpox Viruses

Poxviruses cause many diseases in humans and animals worldwide, and there is a need for vaccines with improved safety and good efficacy. In addition, poxvirus vectors are widely used as recombinant vaccines for various infectious diseases and as recombinant and oncolytic vaccines for cancer. One concern with poxvirus vaccine vectors is that some poxviruses can infect a developing fetus and cause fetal loss or congenital disease. This can be an issue both for patients receiving a vaccine and for pregnant health care providers, including doctors, nurses, and veterinarians, who might receive accidental exposure to the poxvirus by injection or during patient care. We describe here a method for analyzing the safety of virus exposure in pregnant mammals using a mouse model testing vaccinia, canarypox, and raccoonpox virus vectors.

Seven major genomic deletions of vaccinia virus Tiantan strain are sufficient to decrease pathogenicity

Attenuated strain TTVAC7, as a multi-gene-deleted vaccinia virus Tiantan strain (VTT), was constructed by knocking out parts of non-essential genes related to virulence, host range and immunomodulation of VTT, and by combining double marker screening with exogenous selectable marker knockout techniques. In this study, shuttle vector plasmids pTC-EGFP, pTA35-EGFP, pTA66-EGFP, pTE-EGFP, pTB-EGFP, pTI-EGFP and pTJ-EGFP were constructed, which contained seven pairs of recombinant arms linked to the early and late strong promoter pE/L, as well as to enhanced green fluorescent protein (EGFP) as an exogenous selectable marker. BHK cells were co-transfected/infected successively with the above plasmids and VTT or gene-deleted VTT, and homologous recombination and fluorescence plaque screening methods were used to knock out the gene fragments (TC: TC7L ∼ TK2L; TA35: TA35L; TA66: TA66R; TE: TE3L ∼ TE4L; TB: TB13R; TI: TI4L; TJ: TJ2R). The Cre/LoxP system was then applied to knock out the exogenous selectable marker, and ultimately the gene-deleted attenuated strain TTVAC7 was obtained. A series of in vivo and in vitro experiments demonstrated that not only the host range of TTVAC7 could be narrowed and its toxicity weakened significantly, but its high immunogenicity was maintained at the same time. These results support the potential of TTVAC7 to be developed as a safe viral vector or vaccine.

Experimental Evolution Identifies Vaccinia Virus Mutations in A24R and A35R That Antagonize the Protein Kinase R Pathway and Accompany Collapse of an Extragenic Gene Amplification

Most new human infectious diseases emerge from cross-species pathogen transmissions; however, it is not clear how viruses adapt to productively infect new hosts. Host restriction factors represent one species-specific barrier that viruses may initially have little ability to inhibit in new hosts. For example, viral antagonists of protein kinase R (PKR) vary in their ability to block PKR-mediated inhibition of viral replication, in part due to PKR allelic variation between species. We previously reported that amplification of a weak PKR antagonist encoded by rhesus cytomegalovirus, rhtrs1, improved replication of a recombinant poxvirus (VVΔEΔK+RhTRS1) in several resistant primate cells. To test whether amplification increases the opportunity for mutations that improve virus replication with only a single copy of rhtrs1 to evolve, we passaged rhtrs1-amplified viruses in semipermissive primate cells. After passage, we isolated two viruses that contained only a single copy of rhtrs1 yet replicated as well as the amplified virus. Surprisingly, rhtrs1 was not mutated in these viruses; instead, we identified mutations in two vaccinia virus (VACV) genes, A24R and A35R, either of which was sufficient to improve VVΔEΔK+RhTRS1 replication. Neither of these genes has previously been implicated in PKR antagonism. Furthermore, the mutation in A24R, but not A35R, increased resistance to the antipoxviral drug isatin-β-thiosemicarbazone, suggesting that these mutations employ different mechanisms to evade PKR. This study supports our hypothesis that gene amplification may provide a "molecular foothold," broadly improving replication to facilitate rapid adaptation, while subsequent mutations maintain this efficient replication in the new host without requiring gene amplification.

IMPORTANCE

Understanding how viruses adapt to a new host may help identify viruses poised to cross species barriers before an outbreak occurs. Amplification of rhtrs1, a weak viral antagonist of the host antiviral protein PKR, enabled a recombinant vaccinia virus to replicate in resistant cells from humans and other primates. After serial passage of rhtrs1-amplified viruses, there arose in two vaccinia virus genes mutations that improved viral replication without requiring rhtrs1 amplification. Neither of these genes has previously been associated with inhibition of the PKR pathway. These data suggest that gene amplification can improve viral replication in a resistant host species and facilitate the emergence of novel adaptations that maintain the foothold needed for continued replication and spread in the new host.

Genome sequence and comparative virulence of raccoonpox virus: the first North American poxvirus sequence

We report here the complete genome sequence of raccoonpox virus (RCNV), a naturally occurring North American poxvirus. This is the first such North American sequence to the best of our knowledge, and the data showed that RCNV forms a new phylogenetic branch between orthopoxviruses and Yoka poxvirus. RCNV shared overall similarity in genome organization with orthopoxviruses, and the proteins in the central conserved region shared approximately 90  % amino acid identity with orthopoxviruses. RCNV proteins shared approximately 81  % amino acid identity with Yokapox virus proteins. RCNV is missing 10 genes normally conserved in orthopoxviruses, most of which are implicated in virulence. These gene deletions may explain the attenuated phenotype of RCNV in mammals. RCNV contained one unique genome region containing approximately 1 kb of DNA sequence that is not present in any reported poxvirus. It contained a unique ORF predicted to encode a protein with a transmembrane domain. RCNV replicates well in mammalian cells, is naturally attenuated and has been shown to be effective as a vaccine vector platform, so we further tested its safety. We showed here that RCNV is substantially more attenuated than even the highly attenuated VACV-A35Del mutant virus in pregnant, nude and severe combined immunodeficient (SCID) mouse models. RCNV was much safer in pregnant mice and was cleared rapidly from tissues, even in immunocompromised animals, whereas the VACV-A35Del mutant retains virulence and persists in tissues. Thus, RCNV is expected to be a superior vaccine vector for infectious diseases and cancer due to its excellent safety profile, reported vaccine efficacy and ability to replicate in mammalian cells.

Vaccinia virus immune evasion: mechanisms, virulence and immunogenicity

Virus infection of mammalian cells is sensed by pattern recognition receptors and leads to an innate immune response that restricts virus replication and induces adaptive immunity. In response, viruses have evolved many countermeasures that enable them to replicate and be transmitted to new hosts, despite the host innate immune response. Poxviruses, such as vaccinia virus (VACV), have large DNA genomes and encode many proteins that are dedicated to host immune evasion. Some of these proteins are secreted from the infected cell, where they bind and neutralize complement factors, interferons, cytokines and chemokines. Other VACV proteins function inside cells to inhibit apoptosis or signalling pathways that lead to the production of interferons and pro-inflammatory cytokines and chemokines. In this review, these VACV immunomodulatory proteins are described and the potential to create more immunogenic VACV strains by manipulation of the gene encoding these proteins is discussed.

Attenuation of vaccinia Tian Tan strain by removal of viral TC7L-TK2L and TA35R genes

Vaccinia Tian Tan (VTT) was attenuated by deletion of the TC7L-TK2L and TA35R genes to generate MVTT3. The mutant was generated by replacing the open reading frames by a gene encoding enhanced green fluorescent protein (EGFP) flanked by loxP sites. Viruses expressing EGFP were then screened for and purified by serial plaque formation. In a second step the marker EGFP gene was removed by transfecting cells with a plasmid encoding cre recombinase and selecting for viruses that had lost the EGFP phenotype. The MVTT3 mutant was shown to be avirulent and immunogenic. These results support the conclusion that TC7L-TK2L and TA35R deletion mutants can be used as safe viral vectors or as platform for vaccines.

Antigen presentation assays to investigate uncharacterized immunoregulatory genes

Antigen presentation to T lymphocytes is the seminal triggering event of the specific immune response, and poxviruses encode immunomodulatory genes that disrupt this process. Discovery of viral proteins that interfere with steps in the antigen presentation process requires a robust, easily manipulated antigen-presenting and T lymphocyte response system. Use of fresh primary antigen-presenting cells (APC) is preferable because cell lines that can present antigen in vitro are often not representative of APC in vivo and are typically weak stimulators. To study immunomodulatory poxvirus genes, we have used infected primary rat macrophages to present a model antigen, the myelin basic protein peptide, to a cognate CD4+ RsL11 T cell clone. Using this system, viruses can be assessed for difference in immunomodulation, and viral gene functions may also be assayed by comparing effects of wild type virus and mutant viruses (e.g., a deletion in the putative immunomodulatory gene). While antigen presentation can be thought of as a single event, it can also be considered as a larger process comprising multiple steps including: antigen acquisition, antigen processing, peptide loading onto MHC molecules, transport to the surface, MHC binding to T cell receptor, interaction of costimulatory molecules, cell signaling, cytokine synthesis by both cells, and proliferation of antigen specific T lymphocytes. This system allows for the initial determination of whether there is a phenotype and then also allows the stepwise deconstruction of the system to analyze this process at several points to focus in on the mechanism of immunomodulation. We have used this model system to elucidate the function of a highly conserved but previously uncharacterized poxvirus gene that we showed was important for virulence in rodents. The experimental system developed should be broadly applicable to analyzing viral effects on immunity.

Deletion of the A35 gene from Modified Vaccinia Virus Ankara increases immunogenicity and isotype switching

We show here that the immunogenicity of the Modified Vaccinia Ankara MVA vaccine strain can be improved by deletion of the A35 gene, without diminishing the ability of the virus to replicate. Deletion of the A35 gene resulted in increased virus-specific immunoglobulin production, class switching to IgG isotypes, and virus-specific IFNγ-secreting splenocytes. The MVA35 deletion virus provided excellent protective efficacy against virulent virus challenge. These results suggest that A35 deletion mutant strains will have superior vaccine performance for poxvirus vaccines as well as platform vaccines for other infectious diseases and cancer.

Vaccinia virus decreases major histocompatibility complex (MHC) class II antigen presentation, T-cell priming, and peptide association with MHC class II

Vaccinia virus (VACV) is the current live virus vaccine used to protect humans against smallpox and monkeypox, but its use is contraindicated in several populations because of its virulence. It is therefore important to elucidate the immune evasion mechanisms of VACV. We found that VACV infection of antigen-presenting cells (APCs) significantly decreased major histocompatibility complex (MHC) II antigen presentation and decreased synthesis of 13 chemokines and cytokines, suggesting a potent viral mechanism for immune evasion. In these model systems, responding T cells were not directly affected by virus, indicating that VACV directly affects the APC. VACV significantly decreased nitric oxide production by peritoneal exudate cells and the RAW macrophage cell line in response to lipopolysaccharide (LPS) and interferon (IFN)-gamma, decreased class II MHC expression on APCs, and induced apoptosis in macrophages and dendritic cells. However, VACV decreased antigen presentation by 1153 B cells without apparent apoptosis induction, indicating that VACV differentially affects B lymphocytes and other APCs. We show that the key mechanism of VACV inhibition of antigen presentation may be its reduction of antigenic peptide loaded into the cleft of MHC class II molecules. These data indicate that VACV evades the host immune response by impairing critical functions of the APC.

The poxvirus A35 protein is an immunoregulator

It was shown previously that the highly conserved vaccinia virus A35 gene is an important virulence factor in respiratory infection of mice. We show here that A35 is also required for full virulence by the intraperitoneal route of infection. A virus mutant in which the A35 gene has been removed replicated normally and elicited improved antibody, gamma interferon-secreting cell, and cytotoxic T-lymphocyte responses compared to wild-type virus, suggesting that A35 increases poxvirus virulence by immunomodulation. The enhanced immune response correlated with an improved control of viral titers in target organs after the development of the specific immune response. Finally, the A35 deletion mutant virus also provided protection from lethal challenge (1,000 50% lethal doses) equal to that of the wild-type virus. Together, these data suggest that A35 deletion viruses will make safer and more efficacious vaccines for poxviruses. In addition, the A35 deletion viruses will serve as improved platform vectors for other infectious diseases and cancer and will be superior vaccine choices for postexposure poxvirus vaccination, as they also provide improved kinetics of the immune response.

Vaccinia virus A35R inhibits MHC class II antigen presentation

The Vaccinia virus gene A35R (Copenhagen designation) is highly conserved in mammalian-tropic poxviruses and is an important virulence factor, but its function was unknown. We show herein that A35 does not affect viral infectivity, apoptosis induction, or replication; however, we found that A35 significantly inhibited MHC class II-restricted antigen presentation, immune priming of T lymphocytes, and subsequent chemokine and cytokine synthesis. A35 localized to endosomes and reduced the amount of a model antigenic peptide displayed in the cleft of class II MHC. In addition, A35 decreased VV specific T cell responses in vivo. Thus, this is the first report identifying a function for the A35 protein in virulence as well as the first report identifying a VV gene that inhibits peptide antigen presentation.

Recombination-mediated genetic engineering of a bacterial artificial chromosome clone of modified vaccinia virus Ankara (MVA)

The production, manipulation and rescue of a bacterial artificial chromosome clone of Vaccinia virus (VAC-BAC) in order to expedite construction of expression vectors and mutagenesis of the genome has been described (Domi & Moss, 2002, PNAS99 12415–20). The genomic BAC clone was ‘rescued’ back to infectious virus using a Fowlpox virus helper to supply transcriptional machinery. We apply here a similar approach to the attenuated strain Modified Vaccinia virus Ankara (MVA), now widely used as a safe non-replicating recombinant vaccine vector in mammals, including humans. Four apparently full-length, rescuable clones were obtained, which had indistinguishable immunogenicity in mice. One clone was shotgun sequenced and found to be identical to the parent. We employed GalK recombination-mediated genetic engineering (recombineering) of MVA-BAC to delete five selected viral genes. Deletion of C12L, A44L, A46R or B7R did not significantly affect CD8⁺ T cell immunogenicity in BALB/c mice, but deletion of B15R enhanced specific CD8⁺ T cell responses to one of two endogenous viral epitopes (from the E2 and F2 proteins), in accordance with published work (Staib et al., 2005, J. Gen. Virol.86, 1997–2006). In addition, we found a higher frequency of triple-positive IFN-γ, TNF-α and IL-2 secreting E3-specific CD8+ T-cells 8 weeks after vaccination with MVA lacking B15R. Furthermore, a recombinant vaccine capable of inducing CD8⁺ T cells against an epitope from Plasmodium berghei was created using GalK counterselection to insert an antigen expression cassette lacking a tandem marker gene into the traditional thymidine kinase locus of MVA-BAC. MVA continues to feature prominently in clinical trials of recombinant vaccines against diseases such as HIV-AIDS, malaria and tuberculosis. Here we demonstrate in proof-of-concept experiments that MVA-BAC recombineering is a viable route to more rapid and efficient generation of new candidate mutant and recombinant vaccines based on a clinically deployable viral vector.

A guide to viral inclusions, membrane rearrangements, factories, and viroplasm produced during virus replication

Virus replication can cause extensive rearrangement of host cell cytoskeletal and membrane compartments leading to the “cytopathic effect” that has been the hallmark of virus infection in tissue culture for many years. Recent studies are beginning to redefine these signs of viral infection in terms of specific effects of viruses on cellular processes. In this chapter, these concepts have been illustrated by describing the replication sites produced by many different viruses. In many cases, the cellular rearrangements caused during virus infection lead to the construction of sophisticated platforms in the cell that concentrate replicase proteins, virus genomes, and host proteins required for replication, and thereby increase the efficiency of replication. Interestingly, these same structures, called virus factories, virus inclusions, or virosomes, can recruit host components that are associated with cellular defences against infection and cell stress. It is possible that cellular defence pathways can be subverted by viruses to generate sites of replication. The recruitment of cellular membranes and cytoskeleton to generate virus replication sites can also benefit viruses in other ways. Disruption of cellular membranes can, for example, slow the transport of immunomodulatory proteins to the surface of infected cells and protect against innate and acquired immune responses, and rearrangements to cytoskeleton can facilitate virus release.

Smallpox antiviral drug development: satisfying the animal efficacy rule

Concerns over the potential use of variola virus as a biological weapon have prompted new interest in the development of small molecule therapeutics to prevent and treat smallpox infection. Since smallpox is no longer endemic, human clinical trials designed to link antiviral efficacy to clinical outcome have been supplanted by antiviral efficacy evaluations in animal models of orthopoxvirus disease. This poses a unique challenge for drug development; how can animal efficacy data with a surrogate virus be used to establish clinical correlates predictive of human disease outcome? This review will examine the properties of selected animal models that are being used to evaluate poxvirus antiviral drug candidates, and discuss how data from these models can be used to link drug efficacy to clinical correlates of human disease.