Reply to Lovley, "Untangling Geobacter sulfurreducens Nanowires"

Electron Transfer Beyond the Outer Membrane: Putting Electrons to Rest

Extracellular electron transfer (EET) is the physiological process that enables the reduction or oxidation of molecules and minerals beyond the surface of a microbial cell. The first bacteria characterized with this capability were Shewanella and Geobacter, both reported to couple their growth to the reduction of iron or manganese oxide minerals located extracellularly. A key difference between EET and nearly every other respiratory activity on Earth is the need to transfer electrons beyond the cell membrane. The past decade has resolved how well-conserved strategies conduct electrons from the inner membrane to the outer surface. However, recent data suggest a much wider and less well understood collection of mechanisms enabling electron transfer to distant acceptors. This review reflects the current state of knowledge from Shewanella and Geobacter, specifically focusing on transfer across the outer membrane and beyond-an activity that enables reduction of highly variable minerals, electrodes, and even other organisms.

Assessing Thermal Response of Redox Conduction for Anti-Arrhenius Kinetics in a Microbial Cytochrome Nanowire

A micrometers-long helical homopolymer of the outer-membrane cytochrome type S (OmcS) from Geobacter sulfurreducens is proposed to transport electrons to extracellular acceptors in an ancient respiratory strategy of biogeochemical and technological significance. OmcS surprisingly exhibits higher conductivity upon cooling (anti-Arrhenius kinetics), an effect previously attributed to H-bond restructuring and heme redox potential shifts. Herein, the temperature sensitivity of redox conductivity is more thoroughly examined with conventional and constant-redox and -pH molecular dynamics and quantum mechanics/molecular mechanics. A 30 K drop in temperature constituted a weak perturbation to electron transfer energetics, changing electronic couplings (⟨H_mn⟩), reaction free energies (ΔG_mn), reorganization energies (λ_mn), and activation energies (E_a) by at most |0.002|, |0.050|, |0.120|, and |0.045| eV, respectively. Changes in ΔG_mn reflected -0.07 ± 0.03 V shifts in redox potentials that were caused in roughly equal measure by altered electrostatic interactions with the solvent and protein. Changes in intraprotein H-bonding reproduced the earlier observations. Single-particle diffusion and multiparticle steady-state flux models, parametrized with Marcus theory rates, showed that biologically relevant incoherent hopping cannot qualitatively or quantitatively describe electrical conductivity measured by atomic force microscopy in filamentous OmcS. The discrepancy is attributed to differences between solution-phase simulations and solid-state measurements and the need to model intra- and intermolecular vibrations explicitly.