Thyroid hormone receptor can modulate retinoic acid-mediated axis formation in frog embryogenesis

Thyroid Hormone Receptor α Controls Developmental Timing and Regulates the Rate and Coordination of Tissue-Specific Metamorphosis in Xenopus tropicalis

Thyroid hormone (T3) receptors (TRs) mediate the effects of T3 on organ metabolism and animal development. There are two TR genes, TRα and TRβ, in all vertebrates. During animal development, TRα expression is activated earlier than zygotic T3 synthesis and secretion into the plasma, implicating a developmental role of TRα both in the presence and absence of T3. Using T3-dependent amphibian metamorphosis as a model, we previously proposed a dual-function model for TRs, in particular TRα, during development. That is, unliganded TR represses the expression of T3-inducible genes during premetamorphosis to ensure proper animal growth and prevent premature metamorphosis, whereas during metamorphosis, liganded TR activates target gene transcription to promote the transformation of the tadpole into a frog. To determine if TRα has such a dual function, we generated homozygous TRα-knockout animal lines. We show that, indeed, TRα knockout affects both premetamorphic animal development and metamorphosis. Surprisingly, we observed that TRα is not essential for amphibian metamorphosis, given that homozygous knockout animals complete metamorphosis within a similar time period after fertilization as their wild-type siblings. On the other hand, the timing of metamorphosis for different organs is altered by the knockout; limb metamorphosis occurs earlier, whereas intestinal metamorphosis is completed later than in wild-type siblings. Thus, our studies have demonstrated a critical role of endogenous TRα, not only in regulating both the timing and rate of metamorphosis, but also in coordinating temporal metamorphosis of different organs.

Developmental origins of a novel gut morphology in frogs

Phenotypic variation is a prerequisite for evolution by natural selection, yet the processes that give rise to the novel morphologies upon which selection acts are poorly understood. We employed a chemical genetic screen to identify developmental changes capable of generating ecologically relevant morphological variation as observed among extant species. Specifically, we assayed for exogenously applied small molecules capable of transforming the ancestral larval foregut of the herbivorous Xenopus laevis to resemble the derived larval foregut of the carnivorous Lepidobatrachus laevis. Appropriately, the small molecules that demonstrate this capacity modulate conserved morphogenetic pathways involved in gut development, including downregulation of retinoic acid (RA) signaling. Identical manipulation of RA signaling in a species that is more closely related to Lepidobatrachus, Ceratophrys cranwelli, yielded even more similar transformations, corroborating the relevance of RA signaling variation in interspecific morphological change. Finally, we were able to recover the ancestral gut phenotype in Lepidobatrachus by performing a reverse chemical manipulation to upregulate RA signaling, providing strong evidence that modifications to this specific pathway promoted the emergence of a lineage-specific phenotypic novelty. Interestingly, our screen also revealed pathways that have not yet been implicated in early gut morphogenesis, such as thyroid hormone signaling. In general, the chemical genetic screen may be a valuable tool for identifying developmental mechanisms that underlie ecologically and evolutionarily relevant phenotypic variation.

Thyroid hormone promotes neurogenesis in the Xenopus spinal cord

Three phases of neurogenesis can be recognized during Xenopus spinal cord development. An early peak during gastrulation/neurulation is followed by a phase of low level neurogenesis throughout the remaining embryonic stages and a later peak at early larval stages. We show here that several genes known to be essential for early neurogenesis (X-NGNR-1, XNeuroD, XMyT1, X-Delta-1) are also expressed during later phases of neurogenesis in the spinal cord, suggesting that they are involved in regulating spinal neurogenesis at later stages. However, additional neuronal determination genes may be important during larval stages, because X-NGNR-1 shows only scant expression in the spinal cord during larval stages. Thyroid hormone treatment of early larvae promotes neurogenesis in the spinal cord, where thyroid hormone receptor xTRalpha is expressed from early larval stages onward and results in precocious up-regulation of XNeuroD, XMyT1, and N-Tubulin expression. Similarly, thyroid hormone treatments of Xenopus embryos, which were coinjected with xTRalpha and the retinoid X receptor xRXRalpha, repeatedly resulted in increased numbers of neurons, whereas unliganded receptors repressed neurogenesis. Our findings show that thyroid hormones are sufficient to up-regulate neurogenesis in the Xenopus spinal cord.

Physiological and molecular basis of thyroid hormone action

Thyroid hormones (THs) play critical roles in the differentiation, growth, metabolism, and physiological function of virtually all tissues. TH binds to receptors that are ligand-regulatable transcription factors belonging to the nuclear hormone receptor superfamily. Tremendous progress has been made recently in our understanding of the molecular mechanisms that underlie TH action. In this review, we present the major advances in our knowledge of the molecular mechanisms of TH action and their implications for TH action in specific tissues, resistance to thyroid hormone syndrome, and genetically engineered mouse models.

Characterization of a sea bream (Sparus aurata) thyroid hormone receptor-beta clone expressed during embryonic and larval development

A clone encoding thyroid hormone receptor-beta (TR-beta) was isolated from a sea bream (Sparus aurata) ovary cDNA library. Sea bream (sb)TR-beta is closely related to its counterparts from other vertebrates and, like them, preferentially binds T3 rather than T4. However, the putative sbTR-beta protein contains a nine-amino-acid insert that is also present in the corresponding proteins from flounder and salmon but absent in TR-betas from zebrafish and terrestrial vertebrates. Semiquantitative RT-PCR analysis showed that sbTR-beta transcripts begin to accumulate during gastrulation and increase markedly in quantity up to the period around hatch (ca. 40 h postfertilization) before declining slightly. In adult tissues, TR-beta mRNA was present in approximately equal quantities in heart, intestine, brain, kidney, skeletal muscle, liver, and gill. The significance of the relatively strong expression of TR-beta during sea bream embryogenesis is discussed.

Temporal expression and T3 induction of thyroid hormone receptors alpha1 and beta1 during early embryonic and larval development in zebrafish, Danio rerio

The effects of thyroid hormones on metabolism and development are mediated by thyroid hormone receptors (TRs). We report the cloning and characterization of a TR beta1 cDNA from zebrafish. Southern blot analysis revealed that there is a single genomic locus for the TR beta gene, while the TR alpha gene potentially has two loci. Multiple TR alpha and TR beta transcripts were detected in adult tissues. Using a semiquantitative RT-PCR assay, zygotic expression of TR alpha1 and TR beta1 were shown to occur before the midblastula transition stage. In transiently transfected HeLa cells, TR alpha1 displayed constitutive transactivation in the absence of ligands, which was slightly enhanced by triiodothyronine (T3). The transactivating activity of TR beta1 was strictly ligand-dependent and repressed in the absence of T3. Finally, the T3 induction of TR alpha1 and TR beta1 mRNAs was demonstrated in zebrafish embryos and larvae. The auto-induction of TR alpha1 and TR beta1 may serve a regulatory role during the embryonic and larval development of zebrafish.

Overexpression of thyroid hormone receptor alpha 1 during zebrafish embryogenesis disrupts hindbrain patterning and implicates retinoic acid receptors in the control of hox gene expression

Nuclear receptors play key roles in anterior/posterior (A/P) axis formation during vertebrate embryogenesis. Within this gene family, retinoic acid receptors and retinoic acid itself have profound influences on the establishment of the A/P axis. Thyroid hormone receptors are expressed during early periods of development, long before the establishment of the thyroid gland, and are able to interact with retinoic acid receptors. Here we examined the ability of the thyroid hormone receptor alpha 1 to affect early embryonic development by mRNA injection of either repressor or activator forms of the thyroid hormone receptor. Overexpression of either the thyroid hormone receptor alpha 1 or a constitutive repressor form, v-erbA, caused a swelling in the rostral hindbrain. These defects were associated with disorganization and loss of rhombomere borders as well as an increase in the number of acetylcholine esterase positive cells. This phenotype correlated with a reduction in hoxa1 expression during gastrulation. Furthermore, injection of either thyroid hormone receptor alpha 1 or v-erbA mRNA repressed a reporter gene that contained a retinoic acid response element, demonstrating the ability of the thyroid hormone receptor alpha 1 to repress retinoic acid signaling during gastrulation. In contrast, embryos treated with retinoic acid alone or embryos injected with thyroid hormone receptor alpha 1 and treated with the thyroid hormone analog TRIAC displayed a similar set of defects, including loss of the midbrain-hindbrain border and severe disruption of the rostral hindbrain. These studies support the involvement of retinoic acid and its receptors in the direct control of Hox gene expression and the early patterning of the zebrafish central nervous system.

Involvement of thyroid hormone and its alpha receptor in avian neurulation

We have analyzed the expression pattern of c-erb A alpha and c-erb A beta which encode the thyroid hormone receptors (T3R alpha and T3R beta) during early chicken embryogenesis. Only c-erb A alpha expression was detected by RT-PCR and whole-mount in situ hybridization. c-erb A alpha transcripts were found to be already present at low level in embryos before egg incubation. During neurulation a marked increase was observed in neurectoderm. A reporter cell line was then constructed and used to demonstrate the release of significant amount of thyroid hormone (T3) from egg yolk by area opaca cells before gastrulation. During gastrulation T3 was found to be enriched in the primitive streak and Hensen's node. Introduction of excess T3 frequently resulted in abnormal development of anterior structures, mainly neural tube defects and anencephalia. These observations suggest that T3R alpha, like the closely related retinoic acid receptors, fulfills functions which are important for embryonic development well before the onset of thyroid gland function.

The zebrafish thyroid hormone receptor alpha 1 is expressed during early embryogenesis and can function in transcriptional repression

Nuclear receptors are a large family of ligand dependent transcription factors which participate in many diverse processes during development. In this report, we describe the cloning of the zebrafish thyroid hormone receptor alpha 1 (TR alpha 1) gene, the cellular counterpart of the viral oncogene v-erbA. TR alpha 1 is expressed during oogenesis and maternally supplied to the embryo. TR alpha 1 is expressed again after the mid blastula transition. By examining the effects of increased expression of TR alpha 1 on expression of a reporter gene which responds to both TR alpha 1 and retinoic acid receptors (RARs), we show that the zebrafish TR alpha 1 can act as a repressor during early zebrafish development before thyroid hormone is present in the embryo. In addition, our data suggest that TR alpha 1 can repress retinoic acid (RA)-signaling during early development. We propose that TR alpha 1 functions during early development as a transcriptional repressor, similar to the constitutive repressor activity of its viral counterpart v-erbA, which regulates anterior-posterior (A/P) patterning by repressing RA-signaling.

Xenopus hindbrain patterning requires retinoid signaling

We have asked how posterior neural tissue is patterned in Xenopus by assaying the involvement of endogenous retinoic acid (RA) in this process and by using the labial Hox gene, HoxD1, as a posterior marker. Although RA is able to inhibit anterior gene expression and activate expression of more posterior genes, the normal role of retinoids in anteroposterior (A/P) patterning is unclear. HoxD1 is an early posterior neurectodermal marker, expressed from midgastrula with a later anterior expression limit in the future hindbrain. We previously showed that HoxD1 was induced as an immediate early response to retinoic acid in naive ectoderm (animal caps). Here, we use a truncated RARalpha2.2 receptor (RARDelta) to dominantly interfere with retinoid signaling. In embryos injected with RARDelta expression of HoxD1 is eliminated. Conjugates of ectoderm and dorsolateral mesoderm show that retinoid receptors are required in the ectoderm for HoxD1 induction. Further, expression of Krox-20 in r3 and r5 of the presumptive hindbrain is compressed into a single stripe that suggests elimination of r5. RARalpha2.2 expression almost precisely overlaps that of HoxD1, suggesting that this receptor may normally activate HoxD1. Expression of neither more anterior genes including cement gland, forebrain, and midbrain markers nor a more posterior spinal cord marker is affected by RARDelta. These data suggest that the posterior hindbrain is the region of the nervous system most sensitive to retinoid loss. Finally, we compare the ability of RA and fibroblast growth factor (FGF) to posteriorize isolated anterior neurectoderm and show that both factors can act directly on this substrate. RA acts in a more anterior domain than does FGF; however, neither factor is equivalent to the natural posteriorizing capacity of the posterior mesoderm. We propose that endogenous retinoid and FGF signals pattern largely nonoverlapping regions along the A/P axis and that posterior neural patterning requires multiple inducers.

Role of thyroid hormone and retinoid receptors in the homeotic transformation of tails into limbs in frogs

We provide here further data on the dramatic homeotic transformation of tails into limbs which is induced by retinoids during frog tadpole tail regeneration. The effect can still be produced up to nine days after tail amputation by which time tail regeneration has essentially been completed. Complete tail amputation is needed for the effects to be manifest, partial damage of various sorts to the tail is not enough. We show that as well as retinyl palmitate, other retinoids such as all-trans-retinoic acid and TTNPB, which is a RAR specific retinoid, can induce the homeotic transformation. TTNPB has a 300 x greater potency than retinoic acid. Prolactin, which inhibits thyroid hormone production, prevents the appearance of limbs on the tail from which we conclude that thyroid hormone is needed. We present preliminary evidence from RT-PCR that all six retinoid receptors, the three retinoic acid receptors (RARs), and the three retinoid X receptors (RXRs), are present in the normal tail blastema and that after retinoid treatment RAR alpha, RXR alpha, and RXR beta may be up-regulated. Finally, we show that when RA synthesis is inhibited, normal tail regeneration is inhibited. We conclude that tail regeneration depends upon a particular endogenous level of RA, but that when this level is raised by external administration and thyroid hormone receptors are present the up-regulation of certain retinoid receptors allows novel nuclear receptor interactions which results in the induction of limb-specific genes leading to the appearance of limbs on the tail.