P nucleotides in V(D)J recombination: a fine-structure analysis

T cell clonality assessment: past, present and future

T cell clonality testing has important clinical and research value, providing a specific and reproducible assessment of clonal diversity in T cell proliferations. Here we review the conceptual foundations of T cell clonality assays, including T cell ontogeny and T cell receptor structure and function; we also provide an introduction to T cell receptor genomics and the concept of the T cell clonotype. This is followed by a review of historical and current methods by which T cell clonality may be assayed, including current assay limitations. Some of these assay limitations have been overcome by employing next-generation sequencing (NGS)-based technologies that are becoming a mainstay of modern molecular pathology. In this vein, we provide an introduction to NGS technologies, including a review of the preanalytical, analytical and postanalytical technologies relevant to T cell clonality NGS assays.

The mouse antibody heavy chain repertoire is germline-focused and highly variable between inbred strains

The human and mouse antibody repertoires are formed by identical processes, but like all small animals, mice only have sufficient lymphocytes to express a small part of the potential antibody repertoire. In this study, we determined how the heavy chain repertoires of two mouse strains are generated. Analysis of IgM- and IgG-associated VDJ rearrangements generated by high-throughput sequencing confirmed the presence of 99 functional immunoglobulin heavy chain variable (IGHV) genes in the C57BL/6 genome, and inferred the presence of 164 IGHV genes in the BALB/c genome. Remarkably, only five IGHV sequences were common to both strains. Compared with humans, little N nucleotide addition was seen in the junctions of mouse VDJ genes. Germline human IgG-associated IGHV genes are rare, but many murine IgG-associated IGHV genes were unmutated. Together these results suggest that the expressed mouse repertoire is more germline-focused than the human repertoire. The apparently divergent germline repertoires of the mouse strains are discussed with reference to reports that inbred mouse strains carry blocks of genes derived from each of the three subspecies of the house mouse. We hypothesize that the germline genes of BALB/c and C57BL/6 mice may originally have evolved to generate distinct germline-focused antibody repertoires in the different mouse subspecies.

Chromosomal Loop Domains Direct the Recombination of Antigen Receptor Genes

RAG initiates antibody V(D)J recombination in developing lymphocytes by generating "on-target" DNA breaks at matched pairs of bona fide recombination signal sequences (RSSs). We employ bait RAG-generated breaks in endogenous or ectopically inserted RSS pairs to identify huge numbers of RAG "off-target" breaks. Such breaks occur at the simple CAC motif that defines the RSS cleavage site and are largely confined within convergent CTCF-binding element (CBE)-flanked loop domains containing bait RSS pairs. Marked orientation dependence of RAG off-target activity within loops spanning up to 2 megabases implies involvement of linear tracking. In this regard, major RAG off-targets in chromosomal translocations occur as convergent RSS pairs at enhancers within a loop. Finally, deletion of a CBE-based IgH locus element disrupts V(D)J recombination domains and, correspondingly, alters RAG on- and off-target distributions within IgH. Our findings reveal how RAG activity is developmentally focused and implicate mechanisms by which chromatin domains harness biological processes within them.

Discrimination of T-cell subsets and T-cell receptor repertoire distribution

Flow cytometry-based analysis of T-cell receptor (TCR) repertoires is an essential tool for the detection of clonal T-cell expansions in physiologic and pathologic conditions. Individual T-cell subsets can be investigated based on their surface properties. The aims of our study were to provide reference values for various disease settings and delineate the contribution of individual TCR repertoires to the human T-cell differentiation pathway. We analyzed blood of 66 healthy subjects aged 0 (cord blood) to 72 years. Lymphocyte subpopulations and TCR repertoires were simultaneously explored using antibodies specific to CD3, CD4, CD8, CD45RA, CCR7, CD27, CD57 and a set of 25 antibodies detecting human TCR-Vβ chains. Statistical analysis included Wilcoxon, paired t and ANOVA tests. Initially, TCR expansion values were calculated based on the analysis of TCR-Vβ distribution on CD4+ and CD8+ T cells. We then established gating strategies and an algorithm for data analysis allowing for discrimination of T-cell subsets and TCR distribution. Dominant TCR expansions were present within effector as opposed to central/effector memory or naive cells, e.g., median TCR-Vβ expansion rate was highest on CD45RA+/CCR7- effector CD4+/8+ cells (eight and 11-fold, respectively). Remarkably, TCR expansions were missing (0) or very low (0.5) on CD4+ and CD8+ central memory population, respectively. No significant gender-related variability of TCR repertoires was identified, and significant impact of chronic cytomegalovirus infection was shown. Our results serve as reference for future studies elucidating clonal TCR dominance of T-cell subsets.

Role of TRAV locus in low caries experience

Caries is the most common chronic, multifactorial disease in the world today; and little is still known about the genetic factors influencing susceptibility. Our previous genome-wide linkage scan has identified five loci related to caries susceptibility: 5q13.3, 13q31.1, 14q11.2, 14q 24.3, and Xq27. In the present study, we fine mapped the 14q11.2 locus to identify genetic contributors to caries susceptibility. Four hundred seventy-seven subjects from 72 pedigrees with similar cultural and behavioral habits and limited access to dental care living in the Philippines were studied. An additional 387 DNA samples from unrelated individuals were used to determine allele frequencies. For replication purposes, a total of 1,446 independent subjects from four different populations were analyzed based on their caries experience (low versus high). Forty-eight markers in 14q11.2 were genotyped using TaqMan chemistry. Transmission disequilibrium test was used to detect over transmission of alleles in the Filipino families, and Chi-square, Fisher's exact and logistic regression were used to test for association between low caries experience and variant alleles in the replication data sets. We finally assessed the mRNA expression of TRAV4 in the saliva of 143 study subjects. In the Filipino families, statistically significant associations were found between low caries experience and markers in TRAV4. We were able to replicate these results in the populations studied that were characteristically from underserved areas. Direct sequencing of 22 subjects carrying the associated alleles detects one missense mutation (Y30R) that is predicted to be probably damaging. Finally, we observed higher expression in children and teenagers with low caries experience, correlating with specific alleles in TRAV4. Our results suggest that TRAV4 may have a role in protecting against caries.

Reconstructing a B-cell clonal lineage. I. Statistical inference of unobserved ancestors

One of the key phenomena in the adaptive immune response to infection and immunization is affinity maturation, during which antibody genes are mutated and selected, typically resulting in a substantial increase in binding affinity to the eliciting antigen. Advances in technology on several fronts have made it possible to clone large numbers of heavy-chain light-chain pairs from individual B cells and thereby identify whole sets of clonally related antibodies. These collections could provide the information necessary to reconstruct their own history - the sequence of changes introduced into the lineage during the development of the clone - and to study affinity maturation in detail. But the success of such a program depends entirely on accurately inferring the founding ancestor and the other unobserved intermediates. Given a set of clonally related immunoglobulin V-region genes, the method described here allows one to compute the posterior distribution over their possible ancestors, thereby giving a thorough accounting of the uncertainty inherent in the reconstruction.

I demonstrate the application of this method on heavy-chain and light-chain clones, assess the reliability of the inference, and discuss the sources of uncertainty.

Palindromic nucleotide analysis in human T cell receptor rearrangements

Diversity of T cell receptor (TCR) genes is primarily generated by nucleotide insertions upon rearrangement from their germ line-encoded V, D and J segments. Nucleotide insertions at V-D and D-J junctions are random, but some small subsets of these insertions are exceptional, in that one to three base pairs inversely repeat the sequence of the germline DNA. These short complementary palindromic sequences are called P nucleotides. We apply the ImmunoSeq deep-sequencing assay to the third complementarity determining region (CDR3) of the β chain of T cell receptors, and use the resulting data to study P nucleotides in the repertoire of naïve and memory CD8⁺ and CD4⁺ T cells. We estimate P nucleotide distributions in a cross section of healthy adults and different T cell subtypes. We show that P nucleotide frequency in all T cell subtypes ranges from 1% to 2%, and that the distribution is highly biased with respect to the coding end of the gene segment. Classification of observed palindromic sequences into P nucleotides using a maximum conditional probability model shows that single base P nucleotides are very rare in VDJ recombination; P nucleotides are primarily two bases long. To explore the role of P nucleotides in thymic selection, we compare P nucleotides in productive and non-productive sequences of CD8⁺ naïve T cells. The naïve CD8⁺ T cell clones with P nucleotides are more highly expanded.

Comprehensive assessment of potential multiple myeloma immunoglobulin heavy chain V-D-J intraclonal variation using massively parallel pyrosequencing

Multiple myeloma (MM) is characterized by the accumulation of malignant plasma cells (PCs) in the bone marrow (BM). MM is viewed as a clonal disorder due to lack of verified intraclonal sequence diversity in the immunoglobulin heavy chain variable region gene (IGHV). However, this conclusion is based on analysis of a very limited number of IGHV subclones and the methodology employed did not permit simultaneous analysis of the IGHV repertoire of non-malignant PCs in the same samples. Here we generated genomic DNA and cDNA libraries from purified MM BMPCs and performed massively parallel pyrosequencing to determine the frequency of cells expressing identical IGHV sequences. This method provided an unprecedented opportunity to interrogate the presence of clonally related MM cells and evaluate the IGHV repertoire of non-MM PCs. Within the MM sample, 37 IGHV genes were expressed, with 98.9% of all immunoglobulin sequences using the same IGHV gene as the MM clone and 83.0% exhibiting exact nucleotide sequence identity in the IGHV and heavy chain complementarity determining region 3 (HCDR3). Of interest, we observed in both genomic DNA and cDNA libraries 48 sets of identical sequences with single point mutations in the MM clonal IGHV or HCDR3 regions. These nucleotide changes were suggestive of putative subclones and therefore were subjected to detailed analysis to interpret: 1) their legitimacy as true subclones; and 2) their significance in the context of MM. Finally, we report for the first time the IGHV repertoire of normal human BMPCs and our data demonstrate the extent of IGHV repertoire diversity as well as the frequency of clonally-related normal BMPCs. This study demonstrates the power and potential weaknesses of in-depth sequencing as a tool to thoroughly investigate the phylogeny of malignant PCs in MM and the IGHV repertoire of normal BMPCs.

Different molecular mechanisms causing 9p21 deletions in acute lymphoblastic leukemia of childhood

Deletion of chromosome 9p21 is a crucial event for the development of several cancers including acute lymphoblastic leukemia (ALL). Double strand breaks (DSBs) triggering 9p21 deletions in ALL have been reported to occur at a few defined sites by illegitimate action of the V(D)J recombination activating protein complex. We have cloned 23 breakpoint junctions for a total of 46 breakpoints in 17 childhood ALL (9 B- and 8 T-lineages) showing different size deletions at one or both homologous chromosomes 9 to investigate which particular sequences make the region susceptible to interstitial deletion. We found that half of 9p21 deletion breakpoints were mediated by ectopic V(D)J recombination mechanisms whereas the remaining half were associated to repeated sequences, including some with potential for non-B DNA structure formation. Other mechanisms, such as microhomology-mediated repair, that are common in other cancers, play only a very minor role in ALL. Nucleotide insertions at breakpoint junctions and microinversions flanking the breakpoints have been detected at 20/23 and 2/23 breakpoint junctions, respectively, both in the presence of recombination signal sequence (RSS)-like sequences and of other unspecific sequences. The majority of breakpoints were unique except for two cases, both T-ALL, showing identical deletions. Four of the 46 breakpoints coincide with those reported in other cases, thus confirming the presence of recurrent deletion hotspots. Among the six cases with heterozygous 9p deletions, we found that the remaining CDKN2A and CDKN2B alleles were hypermethylated at CpG islands.

Violations of the 12/23 rule at the mouse immunoglobulin kappa locus, including V kappa-V kappa rearrangement

Classically, recombination between immunoglobulin gene segments uses a pair of recombination signal sequences (RSSs) with dissimilar spacers (the "12/23 rule"). Using a series of different genotyping assays, four different kinds of atypical rearrangements were identified at the murine kappa locus: (1) V kappa to V kappa, (2) J kappa to J kappa, (3) V kappa to iRS, a heptameric sequence found in the J kappa C kappa intron, and (4) a possible by-product of a rearrangement between a V kappa and the hypothetical 12-RSS side of a pre-existing signal joint. The novel V kappa-V kappa structure prompted further characterization. Sequence analysis of 14 different V kappa-V kappa rearrangements cloned from murine splenocytes and hybridomas revealed a V kappa 4 family member as one participant in 13 rearrangements, but no rearrangements contained two V kappa 4 genes. The V kappa 4 partner in the V kappa-V kappa rearrangement exhibited more trimming of nucleotides at the V kappa-V kappa junction. A signal joint derived from the inversional rearrangement of two neighboring V kappas was also recovered. These data suggest that the V kappa-V kappa structures arise via RAG-mediated, intrachromosomal recombination.

Immunoglobulin diversity gene usage predicts unfavorable outcome in a subset of chronic lymphocytic leukemia patients

Survival of patients with B cell chronic lymphocytic leukemia (B-CLL) can be predicted by analysis of mutations in the immunoglobulin heavy chain variable gene (IGHV). Patients without mutations (unmutated [UM]) are at greater risk for disease progression and death than patients with mutations (M). Despite this broad prognostic difference, there remains wide intragroup variation in the clinical outcome of UM patients, especially those with low/intermediate Rai risk disease. We evaluated UM B-CLL patients with low/intermediate Rai risk to determine the relationship between IGHV, IGH diversity (IGHD), and IGH joining (IGHJ) gene usage and time to treatment (TTT). Irrespective of IGHV usage, UM patients whose B-CLL cells expressed the IGHD3-3 gene had a significantly shorter TTT than other UM B-CLL patients, and specifically, use of the IGHD3-3 gene in reading frame 2 (RF2) predicted shorter TTT. As expected, Rai risk was the best single prognostic factor for TTT; however, IGHD usage was also a significant variable for TTT. Therefore, both IGHD gene and IGHD RF usage have prognostic relevance in UM B-CLL patients with low/intermediate Rai risk disease. In addition, these data support the concept that antigen-driven selection of specific Ig receptors plays a role in the clinical course of B-CLL.

Identifying highly mutated IGHD genes in the junctions of rearranged human immunoglobulin heavy chain genes

The reliable identification of IGHD genes within human immunoglobulin heavy chains is challenging with up to one third of rearrangements having no identifiable IGHD gene. The short, mutated IGHD genes are generally assumed to be indistinguishable from the N-REGIONS of non-template encoded nucleotides that surround them. In this study we have characterised N-REGIONS, demonstrating the importance of nucleotide composition biases in the addition process, including the formation of homopolymer tracts. We then use a simulation approach to determine the likelihood of misidentification of highly mutated IGHD genes among the JUNCTION nucleotides. These likelihoods provide general rules for the identification of mutated D-REGIONs, and suggest that longer D-REGIONs (>25 nucleotides) with as many as ten mutations can be identified with a low risk of error. Shorter D-REGIONs (>16 nucleotides) with as many as four mutations are also identifiable. The reliability of different alignments is dependent upon the junction length (combined N-REGIONs and D-REGION). Data is presented that can guide the alignment of sequences with junction lengths from 5 to 50 nucleotides, including explicit selection between two D-REGION possibilities. The use of such a statistically-based approach to the alignment of IGHD genes will improve the reliability of the partitioning of immunoglobulin sequences, and this in turn will facilitate the study of the many processes that contribute to the diversity of the immunoglobulin repertoire.

Models for antigen receptor gene rearrangement: CDR3 length

Despite the various processing steps involved in V(D)J recombination, which could potentially introduce many biases in the length distribution of complementarity determining region 3 (CDR3) segments, the observed CDR3 length distributions for complete repertoires are very close to a normal-like distribution. This raises the question of whether this distribution is simply a result of the random steps included in the process of gene rearrangement, or has been optimized during evolution. We have addressed this issue by constructing a simulation of gene rearrangement, which takes into account the DNA modification steps included in the process, namely hairpin opening, nucleotide additions, and nucleotide deletions. We found that the near-Gaussian- shape of CDR3 length distribution can only be obtained under a relatively narrow set of parameter values, and thus our model suggests that specific biases govern the rearrangement process. In both B-cell receptor (BCR) heavy chain and T-cell receptor beta chain, we obtained a Gaussian distribution using identical parameters, despite the difference in the number and the lengths of the D segments. Hence our results suggest that these parameters most likely reflect the optimal conditions under which the rearrangement process occurs. We have subsequently used the insights gained in this study to estimate the probability of occurrence of two exactly identical BCRs over the course of a human lifetime. Whereas identical rearrangements of the heavy chain are highly unlikely to occur within one human lifetime, for the light chain we found that this probability is not negligible, and hence the light chain CDR3 alone cannot serve as an indicator of B-cell clonality.

No evidence for the use of DIR, D-D fusions, chromosome 15 open reading frames or VH replacement in the peripheral repertoire was found on application of an improved algorithm, JointML, to 6329 human immunoglobulin H rearrangements

Antibody diversity is created by imprecise joining of the variability (V), diversity (D) and joining (J) gene segments of the heavy and light chain loci. Analysis of rearrangements is complicated by somatic hypermutations and uncertainty concerning the sources of gene segments and the precise way in which they recombine. It has been suggested that D genes with irregular recombination signal sequences (DIR) and chromosome 15 open reading frames (OR15) can replace conventional D genes, that two D genes or inverted D genes may be used and that the repertoire can be further diversified by heavy chain V gene (VH) replacement. Safe conclusions require large, well-defined sequence samples and algorithms minimizing stochastic assignment of segments. Two computer programs were developed for analysis of heavy chain joints. JointHMM is a profile hidden Markow model, while JointML is a maximum-likelihood-based method taking the lengths of the joint and the mutational status of the VH gene into account. The programs were applied to a set of 6329 clonally unrelated rearrangements. A conventional D gene was found in 80% of unmutated sequences and 64% of mutated sequences, while D-gene assignment was kept below 5% in artificial (randomly permutated) rearrangements. No evidence for the use of DIR, OR15, multiple D genes or VH replacements was found, while inverted D genes were used in less than 1 per thousand of the sequences. JointML was shown to have a higher predictive performance for D-gene assignment in mutated and unmutated sequences than four other publicly available programs. An online version 1.0 of JointML is available at http://www.cbs.dtu.dk/services/VDJsolver.

Diverse immunoglobulin light chain organizations in fish retain potential to revise B cell receptor specificities

We have characterized the genomic organization of the three zebrafish L chain isotypes and found they all differed from those reported in other teleost fishes. Two of the zebrafish L chain isotypes are encoded by two loci, each carrying multiple V gene segments. To understand the derivation of these L chain genes and their organizations, we performed phylogenetic analyses and show that IgL organization can diverge considerably among closely related species. Except in zebrafish, the teleost fish IgL each contain only two to four recombinogenic components (one to three V, one J) and exist in multiple copies. BCR heterogeneity can be generated, but this arrangement apparently provides neither combinatorial diversification nor an opportunity for the secondary rearrangements that, in mammals, take place during receptor editing, a process crucial to the promotion of tolerance in developing lymphocytes. Examination of the zebrafish IgL recombination possibilities gave insight into how the suppression of self-reactivity by receptor editing might be managed, including in miniloci. We suggest that, despite the diverse IgL organizations in early and higher vertebrates, two elements essential to generating the Ab repertoire are retained: the numerous genes/loci for ligand-binding diversification and the potential for correcting unwanted specificities that arise.

Shark Ig Light Chain Junctions Are as Diverse as in Heavy Chains

We have characterized a small family of four genes encoding one of the three nurse shark Ig L chain isotypes, called NS5. All NS5 cDNA sequences are encoded by three loci, of which two are organized as conventional clusters, each consisting of a V and J gene segment that can recombine and one C region exon; the third contains a germline-joined VJ in-frame and the fourth locus is a pseudogene. This is the second nurse shark L chain type where both germline-joined and split V-J organizations have been found. Since there are only two rearranging Ig loci, it was possible for the first time to examine junctional diversity in defined fish Ig genes, comparing productive vs nonproductive rearrangements. N region addition was found to be considerably more extensive in length and in frequency than any other vertebrate L chain so far reported and rivals that in H chain. We put forth the speculation that the unprecedented efficiency of N region addition (87-93% of NS5 sequences) may be a result not only of simultaneous H and L chain rearrangement in the shark but also of processing events that afford greater accessibility of the V or J gene coding ends to terminal deoxynucleotidyltransferase.

Utilization of Ig heavy chain variable, diversity, and joining gene segments in children with B-lineage acute lymphoblastic leukemia: implications for the mechanisms of VDJ recombination and for pathogenesis

Sequence analysis of the immunoglobulin heavy chain genes (IgH) has demonstrated preferential usage of specific variable (V), diversity (D), and joining (J) genes at different stages of B-cell development and in B-cell malignancies, and this has provided insight into B-cell maturation and selection. Knowledge of the association between rearrangement patterns based on updated databases and clinical characteristics of pediatric acute lymphoblastic leukemia (ALL) is limited. We analyzed 381 IgH sequences identified at presentation in 317 children with B-lineage ALL and assessed the V(H)D(H)J(H) gene utilization profiles. The D(H)J(H)-proximal V(H) segments and the D(H)2 gene family were significantly overrepresented. Only 21% of V(H)-J(H) joinings were potentially productive, a finding associated with a trend toward an increased risk of relapse. These results suggest that physical location at the V(H) locus is involved in preferential usage of D(H)J(H)-proximal V(H) segments whereas D(H) and J(H) segment usage is governed by position-independent molecular mechanisms. Molecular pathophysiology appears relevant to clinical outcome in patients who have only productive rearrangements, and specific rearrangement patterns are associated with differences in the tumor biology of childhood ALL.

The V(D)J recombinase efficiently cleaves and transposes signal joints

V(D)J recombination generates two types of products: coding joints, which constitute the rearranged variable regions of antigen receptor genes, and signal joints, which often form on immunologically irrelevant, excised circular molecules that are lost during cell division. It has been widely believed that signal joints simply convert reactive broken DNA ends into safe, inert products. Yet two curious in vivo observations made us question this assumption: signal ends are far more abundant than coding ends, and signal joints form only after RAG expression is downregulated. In fact, we find that signal joints are not at all inert; they are cleaved quite efficiently in vivo and in vitro by a nick-nick mechanism and form an excellent substrate for RAG-mediated transposition in vitro, possibly explaining how genomic stability in lymphocytes may be compromised.

DNA polymerase beta is not essential for the formation of palindromic (P) region of T cell receptor gene

Formation of palindromic (P) region at the variable (V)-diversity (D)-joining (J) junction in DNA polymerase beta (pol-beta) deficient mice were investigated by sequencing of reverse transcriptase-polymerase chain reaction (RT-PCR) products of mRNAs encoding the beta chain of T cell receptor (TCR). Total 42 and 43 cDNA clones encoding V(beta8)-D(beta)-J(beta)-C(beta) from E18.5 embryonic thymocytes of pol-beta gene knocked-out and wild type control mouse, respectively, were sequenced. Among them five and six clones from pol-beta knocked-out and wild type, respectively, have P insertions of two nucleotides. This result unequivocally indicates that pol-beta, which is one of the repair-type DNA polymerases most abundantly expressed in thymus and spleen, is not essential for the formation of P region.

Joining-deficient RAG1 mutants block V(D)J recombination in vivo and hairpin opening in vitro

The RAG proteins cleave at V(D)J recombination signal sequences then form a postcleavage complex with the broken ends. The role of this complex in end processing and joining, if any, is undefined. We have identified two RAG1 mutants proficient for DNA cleavage but severely defective for coding and signal joint formation, providing direct evidence that RAG1 is critical for joining in vivo and strongly suggesting that the postcleavage complex is important in end joining. We have also identified a RAG1 mutant that is severely defective for both hairpin opening in vitro and coding joint formation in vivo. These data suggest that the hairpin opening activity of the RAG proteins plays an important physiological role in V(D)J recombination.

VHD rearrangements in human immunoglobulin heavy chain minilocus transgenic mice

Typically, immunoglobulin VHDJH recombination is performed in two steps with D to JH rearrangement preceding VH to DJH rearrangement. Using a human immunoglobulin heavy chain transgenic minilocus, we previously demonstrated that a non-conventional human D gene segment termed DIR2 could be recombined to a VH gene segment to form VHD rearrangements. Here, we demonstrate that VHD rearrangements involve conventional D gene segments as well. VHD rearrangements are easily detected and are diverse. Similarly to DJH rearrangements, VHD rearrangements occur by deletion and inversion. They occur approximately 1000 times less frequently than DJH rearrangements. VHD rearrangements can constitute intermediates for the formation of VHDDJH rearrangements.

Characterization of the T cell receptor repertoire of neonatal T cells by RT-PCR and single strand conformation polymorphism analysis

We have analyzed by reverse transcriptase-polymerase chain reaction (RT-PCR) the individual non-germ line configurations of the T cell receptor (TCR) Vbeta chains expressed by T cells from eight individual cord blood specimens. cDNA from each cord blood was amplified using a common primer coupled with a primer specific for each of 22 variable elements of the Vbeta chain family and the amplified fragments were separated under high resolution conditions. With cDNA from adult blood (as a control), all of the TCR chains were amplified as a smear consistent with the extensive polyclonality of adult T cells. In contrast, a heterogeneous pattern of amplification was observed with cDNAs from cord blood: only 26.7+/-21.9% of the 22 Vbeta chains analyzed were amplified as a smear. The majority of them were amplified as a discrete number of bands (up to 10) (in 68.2 +/-18.7% of samples) and some of them as a single fragment (4.0+/-7.8%). Only one of the eight samples analyzed expressed the majority (72.7%) of its Vbeta chains as a smear, consistent with an adult-like TCR repertoire. In conclusion, cord blood expressed, on average, a less complex TCR repertoire than adult blood.

Evidence that terminal deoxynucleotidyltransferase expression plays a role in Ig heavy chain gene segment utilization

TdT is a nuclear enzyme that catalyzes the addition of random nucleotides at Ig and TCR V(D)J junctions. In this paper we analyze human IgH rearrangements generated from transgenic minilocus mice in the presence or absence of TdT. In the absence of TdT, the pseudo-VH gene segment present in the minilocus is rearranged dramatically more frequently. Additionally, JH6 gene segment utilization is increased as well as the number of rearrangements involving only VH and JH gene segments. Thus, the recombination of IgH gene segments that are flanked by 23-nt spacer recombination signal sequences may be influenced by TdT expression. Extensive analysis indicates that these changes are independent of antigenic selection and cannot be explained by homology-mediated recombination. Thus, the role played by TdT may be more extensive than previously thought.

Unexpected rearrangement and expression of the immunoglobulin lambda1 locus in scid mice

In severe combined immunodeficient (scid) mice, V(D)J recombination is severely impaired due to a recessive mutation (scid). Thus, we were surprised to find in this study that Vlambda1-Jlambda1 rearrangement is routinely detectable in scid fetal liver, adult bone marrow, and spleen in the apparent absence of completed VH-DJH and Vkappa-Jkappa rearrangements. Particularly surprising, we found the level of Vlambda1-Jlambda1 rearrangement in scid fetal liver to be comparable to that in fetal liver of wild-type mice. The majority of scid Vlambda1-Jlambda1 rearrangements contained abnormal deletions at the VJ junction, consistent with the known effect of scid. However, approximately 15% of Vlambda1-Jlambda1 rearrangements lacked abnormal deletions. Productive lambda1 transcripts resulting from in-frame rearrangements were readily detectable in scid adult bone marrow and spleen, consistent with our ability to detect lambda1-expressing cells by flow cytometry in the spleens of bcl-2-transgenic scid mice. Strikingly, lambda1 transcripts from individual scid mice often showed VJ junctional sequences with the same recurring palindromic (P) additions of three, four, or five nucleotides. To account for these findings, we suggest that (a) nonhomologous end joining of Vlambda1 and Jlambda1 coding ends in fetal B lineage cells may not be (severely) impaired by scid; (b) recurring P additions in scid lambda1 transcripts may reflect certain molecular constraints imposed by scid on the resolution of Vlambda1 and Jlambda1 hairpin coding ends; and (c), scid lymphocytes with productively rearranged Vlambda1 and Jlambda1 elements may differentiate into recombinase-inactive cells and emigrate from bone marrow to spleen.

Repertoire analysis in human immunoglobulin heavy chain minilocus transgenic, muMT/muMT mice

Mice transgenic for the human immunoglobulin heavy chain minilocus pHCl were developed several years ago to help better understand the mechanisms of VDJ recombination and antibody response. Interestingly, these minilocus transgenic mice develop a polyclonal, extremely diverse mu human immunoglobulin heavy chain repertoire, but when immunized, they exclusively use murine immunoglobulin heavy chains. Here, the data shows that when the minilocus is transferred by cross-breeding onto the muMT background, the resulting mice (HCl-muMT/muMT mice) develop polyclonal, extremely diverse mu and gamma1 human immunoglobulin heavy chain repertoires. Our data indicates that if no antigen specific antibodies are detected in pHCl transgenic mice, it is essentially due to competition with endogenous immunoglobulin heavy chain gene segments. Moreover, the data shows that despite the presence of only one functional V(H) gene segment and despite mu and gamma1 repertoires similar to the early pre-immune human repertoire, HCl-muMT/muMT mice, can develop immune responses against proteins and haptens. Finally, the data shows that in aged HC1-muMT/muMT mice, the generation of new B-cells may be impaired and old mice may mainly rely on B-cell generated earlier in life to mount immune responses.

Irradiation-Induced Rescue of Thymocyte Differentiation and V(D)J Recombination in Mice Lacking the Catalytic Subunit of DNA-Dependent Protein Kinase

Scid mice express a truncated form of the catalytic subunit of the DNA-dependent protein kinase (DNA-PKcs) and are unable to properly rearrange their Ig and TCR genes, resulting in a severe combined immunodeficiency that is characterized by arrested differentiation of B and T lymphocytes. Treatment of scid mice with low doses of gamma irradiation rescues rearrangements at several TCR loci and promotes limited thymocyte differentiation. The machinery responsible for sensing DNA damage and the mechanism by which irradiation compensates for the scid defect in TCR recombination remain unknown. Because DNA-PKcs is present in scid thymocytes, it may mediate some or all of the irradiation effects. To test this hypothesis, we examined the effects of irradiation on DNA-PKcs-deficient (slip) mice. Our data provide the first evidence that DNA-PKcs is not required for limited rescue of thymocyte differentiation or TCR rearrangements.

Increased junctional diversity in fetal B cells results in a loss of protective anti-phosphorylcholine antibodies in adult mice

Fetal Igs are less diverse than adult Igs, largely because of the lack of N addition in the absence of Tdt. To test whether the absence of Tdt is essential, we generated Tg mice that express Tdt and add N regions in fetal B cells. When challenged as adults with PC-containing Streptococcus pneumoniae, these mice fail to make the hallmark T15 anti-PC Ab encoded by canonical rearrangements of Ig H and L chain genes. The anti-PC Abs from these mice are altered by premature N addition and do not protect against death from virulent pneumococcal infection. These results show that maintenance of lower Ig diversity in early life is essential for the acquisition of a complete functional adult repertoire.

Hairpin coding end opening is mediated by RAG1 and RAG2 proteins

Despite the importance of hairpin opening in antigen receptor gene assembly, the molecular machinery that mediates this reaction has not been defined. Here, we show that RAG1 plus RAG2 can open DNA hairpins. Hairpin opening by RAGs is not sequence specific, but in Mg2+, hairpin opening occurs only in the context of a regulated cleavage complex. The chemical mechanism of hairpin opening by RAGs resembles RSS cleavage and 3' end processing by HIV integrase and Mu transposase in that these reactions can proceed through alcoholysis. Mutations in either RAG1 or RAG2 that interfere with RSS cleavage also interfere with hairpin opening, suggesting that RAGs have a single active site that catalyzes several distinct DNA cleavage reactions.

Co-existence of somatic hypermutation and gene conversion in hypervariable regions of single Igkappa clones

In the rabbit, recent investigations have provided evidence that gene conversion leads to the generation of diversity of heavy chain rearranged VH-DH-JH genes. No data have been published on a similar mechanism for rabbit light chains. In our laboratory, we initially infected rabbits with Trypanosoma brucei, which stimulates B-cell hyperplasia and hypergammaglobulinaemia. The heterozygous rabbits exhibited the Ckappa1 b4 and b9 kappa light chain allotypes. After reverse transcription of mRNA, and cloning and sequencing of cDNA, the Vkappa-Jkappa-Ckappa genes provided evidence for both somatic hypermutation and gene conversion. We saw that in each of the b4 and b9 kappa light chain cDNA, CDR1 and CDR3 carried both point mutation and provisional gene conversion traits. In the CDR2 region, point mutation and gene conversion inserts were observed in the b4 genes, with only gene conversion in two b9 genes. In the CDR regions, although some genes exhibited only somatic hypermutation or gene conversion, others showed linkage of both somatic hypermutation and gene conversion in the same sequence. This also marks the first time that somatic hypermutation and gene conversion in the same cloned CDR region has been observed in Vkappa1 genes; however, it has been seen earlier in rabbit heavy chain VH sequences. Furthermore, the addition of several codons to the CDR3 segment by gene conversion may have provided a mechanism for length variation. In addition, we demonstrated that Jkappa and framework region segments contained examples of somatic hypermutation. Confirmation of gene conversion necessitates that donor sequences be identified as providing the templated inserts. Thus after cloning two pseudogenes we found putative CDR3 donor segments for two CDR3 rearranged genes. The results offer additional mechanisms for the generation of diversity among rearranged rabbit kappa light chain genes. Whether there is a relationship or influence of gene conversion upon somatic hypermutation or vice versa is not discernable at present.

V(D)J recombination intermediates and non-standard products in XRCC4-deficient cells

V(D)J recombination assembles immunoglobulin (Ig) and T cell receptor (TCR) gene segments during lymphocyte development. Recombination is initiated by the RAG-1 and RAG-2 proteins, which introduce double-stranded DNA breaks (DSB) adjacent to the Ig and TCR gene segments. The broken ends are joined by the DSB repair machinery, which includes the XRCC4 protein. While XRCC4 is essential for both DSB repair and V(D)J recombination, the functions of this protein remain enigmatic. Because the rare V(D)J recombination products isolated from XRCC4-deficient cells generally show evidence of excessive nucleotide loss, it was hypothesized that XRCC4 may function to protect broken DNA ends. Here we report the first examination of V(D)J recombination intermediates in XRCC4-deficient cells. We found that both types of intermediates, signal ends and coding ends, are abundant in the absence of XRCC4. Furthermore, the signal ends are full length. We also showed that alternative V(D)J recombination products, hybrid joints, form with normal efficiency and without excessive deletion in XRCC4-deficient cells. These data indicate that impaired formation of V(D)J recombination products in XRCC4-deficient cells does not result from excessive degradation of recombination intermediates. Potential roles of XRCC4 in the joining reaction are discussed.

V(D)J recombination in Ku86-deficient mice: distinct effects on coding, signal, and hybrid joint formation

Ku, a heterodimer of 70 and 86 kDa subunits, plays a critical but poorly understood role in V(D)J recombination. Although Ku86-deficient mice are defective in coding and signal joint formation, rare recombination products have been detected by PCR. Here, we report nucleotide sequences of 99 junctions from Ku86-deficient mice. Over 90% of the coding joints, but not signal or hybrid joints, exhibit short sequence homologies, indicating that homology is required to join coding ends in the absence of Ku86. Our results suggest that Ku86 may normally have distinct functions in the formation of these different types of junctions. Furthermore, Ku86(-/-) joints are unexpectedly devoid of N-region diversity, suggesting a novel role for Ku in the addition of N nucleotides by terminal deoxynucleotidyl transferase.

Direct assessment of junctional diversity in rearranged T cell receptor beta chain encoding genes by combined heteroduplex and single strand conformation polymorphism (SSCP) analysis

In order to define the extent of T cell heterogeneity and clonality, unique DNA sequences in the junctional region in rearranged T cell receptor (TcR) genes can be studied. For this purpose we have adapted a non-denaturing nucleic acid gel electrophoresis procedure to detect TcR junctional diversity. Detection of junctional diversity is based upon electrophoretic separation of single stranded (ss) and double stranded (ds) DNA molecules via mobility shifts due to nucleotide sequence polymorphism. To examine the capacity of this nucleic acid gel electrophoresis procedure to detect nucleotide sequence polymorphism in the CDR 3 region within TcR V beta gene family sequences polymerase chain reaction (PCR) amplified TcR V beta 5.1/5.4 and V beta 14 cDNA sequences were analyzed. The results of this study showed that (1) the single strand conformation polymorphism (SSCP) procedure has a low capacity to discriminate between diverse TcR V beta cDNA sequences due to comigration of the ssDNA molecules, which results in an underestimation of the heterogeneity in a given T cell population; (2) comigrating ssDNA and/or dsDNA (homoduplex) molecules can be separated by the formation of heteroduplex molecules; these heteroduplex molecules provide essential additional information on the degree of nucleotide sequence polymorphism in the CDR 3 region within the TcR V beta cDNA sequences; (3) the double strand conformation polymorphism (DSCP) procedure provides a fast and reliable procedure to detect junctional diversity within the sequences tested. Using DSCP a more detailed assessment of amplified TcR V beta cDNA sequences can be obtained as compared with SSCP analysis only. Data obtained by gel analysis were very similar to those obtained by conventional bacterial cloning and DNA sequencing procedures on the corresponding cDNA clones. In conclusion, this new gel electrophoresis procedure allows a direct assessment of the extent of T cell heterogeneity and clonality by screening junctional diversity in TcR chain encoding sequences in clinical conditions with (oligo)clonal expansion of T lymphocytes.

Mechanism of V(D)J recombination

V(D)J recombination can be separated into two basic operations: DNA cleavage and joining of broken ends. Our understanding of both reactions has increased substantially in the past year. Major advances include the development of a cell-free system capable of cleavage and the identification of several proteins involved in both V(D)J recombination and double-strand break repair.

Immunoglobulin diversity: rearranging by cutting and repairing

The recombination process that assembles antigen-receptor genes is now understood in some biochemical detail. The initial steps reflect a common theme seen in retroviral integration and prokaryotic transposition, and the later steps involve the enzymatic machinery for double-strand break DNA repair.

Estimating allelic diversity generated by excision of different transposon types

Methods are presented for calculating the number and type of different DNA sequences generated by base excision and insertion events at a given site in a known DNA sequence. We calculate, for example, that excision of the Mu1 transposon from the bz1::Mu1 allele of maize should generate more than 500,000 unique alleles given the extent of base deletion (up to 34 bases removed) and base insertion (0-5 bases) observed thus far in sequenced excision alleles. Analysis of this universe of potential alleles can, for example, be used to predict the frequency of creation of stop codons or repair-generated duplications. In general, knowledge of the distribution of alleles can be used to evaluate models of both excision and repair by determining whether particular events occur more frequently than expected. Such quantitative analysis complements the qualitative description provided by the DNA sequence of individual events. Similar methods can be used to evaluate the outcome of other cases of DNA breakage and repair such as programmed V(D)J recombination in immunoglobin genes.

Multiple sclerosis: limited diversity of the V delta 2-J delta 3 T-cell receptor in chronic active lesions

T lymphocytes bearing the gamma delta T-cell receptor have been found in the central nervous system of patients with multiple sclerosis in association with demyelinated lesions. Although the biological function of these cells remains to be established, it has been proposed that they are involved in the response to highly conserved antigens, such as heat shock proteins (hsp), expressed during tissue damage and thus may contribute to the development of an autoimmune response. Using polymerase chain reaction, we probed for the presence of T-cell receptor gamma delta cells in fresh-frozen early autopsy brain tissue from patients with multiple sclerosis and patients with non-multiple sclerosis conditions. The results demonstrated the presence of two major V-J combinations of the T-cell receptor delta chain--V delta 2-J delta 3, V delta 2-J delta 1--and we used a direct sequencing technique to determine whether this gamma delta T-cell population was clonal or diverse. In chronic-active plaques from 9 patients with multiple sclerosis, we found a striking predominant gene rearrangement within the V delta 2-J delta 3 T-cell receptor population that was not present in central nervous system tissue from patients with other neurological diseases. In contrast, within the V delta 2-J delta 1 T-cell receptor population, a predominant rearrangement pattern was detected in only 1 of the multiple sclerosis patients. The sequence of the predominant V delta 2-J delta 3 gene rearrangement was confirmed by cloning and sequencing the gene products from 1 multiple sclerosis patient.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

Characterization of coding ends in thymocytes of scid mice: implications for the mechanism of V(D)J recombination

We previously identified possible intermediates in V(D)J recombination at the TCR delta locus and characterized molecules with signal ends and with covalently sealed (hairpin) coding ends in thymocytes of scid mice by Southern blotting. Here, we use a sensitive ligation-mediated PCR assay to demonstrate that all coding ends detected in scid thymocytes are covalently sealed. Neither coding nor signal ends exhibit loss or addition of nucleotides. These data imply that hairpin formation is coupled to the initial cleavage at the signal/coding border, and that the cleavage step in V(D)J recombination is conservative. In scid/+ or wild-type thymocytes, hairpin coding ends are at least 1000-fold less abundant than signal ends. These results provide insight into the mechanism of V(D)J recombination.

Striking sequence similarity over almost 100 kilobases of human and mouse T-cell receptor DNA

We report here the comparative DNA sequence analysis of nearly 100 kilobases of contiguous DNA in the C delta to C alpha region of the alpha/delta T cell receptor loci (TCRAC/TCRDC) of mouse and man. This analysis--the largest genomic sequence comparison so far--provides new insights into the functions of the T cell receptor genes as well as the surrounding chromosome structure through the identification of actively conserved DNA sequences. In this comparison we have identified a very high level of organizational and noncoding sequence similarity (approximately 71%) in contrast to previous findings in the beta-globin gene cluster. This observation begins to question the notion that much of the chromosomal non-coding sequence is junk.

The SCID mouse: relevance as an animal model system for studying human disease

The simultaneous description some 5 years ago of two methods for the partial reconstitution of a human immune system in severe combined immune-deficient (SCID) mice (collectively, human:SCID mice) was met with great enthusiasm. At the time, it was hoped that human:SCID mice would provide experimental animal model systems for studying human disease and the human immune system. Many of these hopes have been borne out. Importantly, the experimental results obtained from these chimeric human/animal studies appear to be relevant to human disease and immune function. In spite of these glowing achievements, the SCID mouse may not represent the optimal experimental system with which to address these questions. The incomplete penetrance ("leakiness") of the scid mutation and the recent discovery that the mutation is not lymphoid specific, but rather affects a general DNA repair pathway, will only serve to complicate the interpretation of already complex biological interactions. Recently other immune-deficient mice have been described that appear to overcome one or both of these problems and thus these mice could represent improved hosts for the adaptive transfer of a human immune system. The current status of the SCID mouse in light of these new findings is discussed.