An alternative helix in the 26S rRNA promotes excision and integration of the Tetrahymena intervening sequence

The long-range P3 helix of the Tetrahymena ribozyme is disrupted during folding between the native and misfolded conformations

RNAs are prone to misfolding, but how misfolded structures are formed and resolved remains incompletely understood. The Tetrahymena group I intron ribozyme folds in vitro to a long-lived misfolded conformation (M) that includes extensive native structure but is proposed to differ in topology from the native state (N). A leading model predicts that exchange of the topologies requires unwinding of the long-range, core helix P3, despite the presence of P3 in both conformations. To test this model, we constructed 16 mutations to strengthen or weaken P3. Catalytic activity and in-line probing showed that nearly all of the mutants form the M state before folding to N. The P3-weakening mutations accelerated refolding from M (3- to 30-fold) and the P3-strengthening mutations slowed refolding (6- to 1400-fold), suggesting that P3 indeed unwinds transiently. Upon depletion of Mg(2+), the mutations had analogous effects on unfolding from N to intermediates that subsequently fold to M. The magnitudes for the P3-weakening mutations were larger than in refolding from M, and small-angle X-ray scattering showed that the ribozyme expands rapidly to intermediates from which P3 is disrupted subsequently. These results are consistent with previous results indicating unfolding of native peripheral structure during refolding from M, which probably permits rearrangement of the core. Together, our results demonstrate that exchange of the native and misfolded conformations requires loss of a core helix in addition to peripheral structure. Further, the results strongly suggest that misfolding arises from a topological error within the ribozyme core, and a specific topology is proposed.

Toward a molecular understanding of RNA remodeling by DEAD-box proteins

DEAD-box proteins are superfamily 2 helicases that function in all aspects of RNA metabolism. They employ ATP binding and hydrolysis to generate tight, yet regulated RNA binding, which is used to unwind short RNA helices non-processively and promote structural transitions of RNA and RNA-protein substrates. In the last few years, substantial progress has been made toward a detailed, quantitative understanding of the structural and biochemical properties of DEAD-box proteins. Concurrently, progress has been made toward a physical understanding of the RNA rearrangements and folding steps that are accelerated by DEAD-box proteins in model systems. Here, we review the recent progress on both of these fronts, focusing on the mitochondrial DEAD-box proteins Mss116 and CYT-19 and their mechanisms in promoting the splicing of group I and group II introns.

ATP-dependent roles of the DEAD-box protein Mss116p in group II intron splicing in vitro and in vivo

The yeast DEAD-box protein Mss116p functions as a general RNA chaperone in splicing mitochondrial group I and group II introns. For most of its functions, Mss116p is thought to use ATP-dependent RNA unwinding to facilitate RNA structural transitions, but it has been suggested to assist in the folding of one group II intron (aI5γ) primarily by stabilizing a folding intermediate. Here we compare three aI5γ constructs: one with long exons, one with short exons, and a ribozyme construct lacking exons. The long exons result in slower splicing, suggesting that they misfold and/or stabilize nonnative intronic structures. Nevertheless, Mss116p acceleration of all three constructs depends on ATP and is inhibited by mutations that compromise RNA unwinding, suggesting similar mechanisms. Results of splicing assays and a new two-stage assay that separates ribozyme folding and catalysis indicate that maximal folding of all three constructs by Mss116p requires ATP-dependent RNA unwinding. ATP-independent activation is appreciable for only a subpopulation of the minimal ribozyme construct and not for constructs containing exons. As expected for a general RNA chaperone, Mss116p can also disrupt the native ribozyme, which can refold after Mss116p removal. Finally, using yeast strains with mitochondrial DNA containing only the single intron aI5γ, we show that Mss116p mutants promote splicing in vivo to degrees that correlate with their residual ATP-dependent RNA-unwinding activities. Together, our results indicate that, although DEAD-box proteins play multiple roles in RNA folding, the physiological function of Mss116p in aI5γ splicing includes a requirement for ATP-dependent local unfolding, allowing the conversion of nonfunctional RNA structure into functional RNA structure.

Roles of DEAD-box proteins in RNA and RNP Folding

RNAs and RNA-protein complexes (RNPs) traverse rugged energy landscapes as they fold to their native structures, and many continue to undergo conformational rearrangements as they function. Due to the inherent stability of local RNA structure, proteins are required to assist with RNA conformational transitions during initial folding and in exchange between functional structures. DEAD-box proteins are superfamily 2 RNA helicases that are ubiquitously involved in RNA-mediated processes. Some of these proteins use an ATP-dependent cycle of conformational changes to disrupt RNA structure nonprocessively, accelerating structural transitions of RNAs and RNPs in a manner that bears a strong resemblance to the activities of certain groups of protein chaperones. This review summarizes recent work using model substrates and tractable self-splicing intron RNAs, which has given new insights into how DEAD-box proteins promote RNA folding steps and conformational transitions, and it summarizes recent progress in identifying sites and mechanisms of DEAD-box protein activity within more complex cellular targets.

Kinetics and thermodynamics make different contributions to RNA folding in vitro and in yeast

RNAs somehow adopt specific functional structures despite the capacity to form alternative nonfunctional structures with similar stabilities. We analyzed RNA assembly during transcription in vitro and in yeast using hairpin ribozyme self-cleavage to assess partitioning between functional ribozyme structures and nonfunctional stem loops. Complementary insertions located upstream of the ribozyme inhibited ribozyme assembly more than downstream insertions during transcription in vitro, consistent with a sequential folding model in which the outcome is determined by the structure that forms first. In contrast, both upstream and downstream insertions strongly inhibited assembly of the same ribozyme variants when expressed as chimeric mRNAs in yeast, indicating that inhibitory stem loops can form even after the entire ribozyme sequence has been transcribed. Evidently, some feature unique to the intracellular environment modulates the influence of transcription polarity and enhances the contribution of thermodynamic stability to RNA folding in vivo.

Intracellular folding of the Tetrahymena group I intron depends on exon sequence and promoter choice

The Tetrahymena group I intron splices 20 to 50 times faster in Tetrahymena than in vitro, implying that the intron rapidly adopts its active conformation in the cell. The importance of cotranscriptional folding and the contribution of the rRNA exons to the stability of the active pre-RNA structure were investigated by comparing the activity of minimal pre-RNAs expressed in Escherichia coli. Pre-RNAs containing exons derived from E. coli 23 S rRNA were three to four times more active than the wild-type Tetrahymena pre-RNA. E. coli transcripts of the chimeric E. coli pre-RNA were two to eight times more active than were T7 transcripts. However, the effect of cotranscriptional folding depends on exon sequences. Unexpectedly, the unspliced pre-RNA decays more slowly than predicted from the rate of splicing. This observation is best explained by partitioning of transcripts into active and inactive pools. We propose that the active pool splices within a few seconds, whereas the inactive pool is degraded without appreciable splicing.

Distribution of rRNA introns in the three-dimensional structure of the ribosome

More than 1200 introns have been documented at over 150 unique sites in the small and large subunit ribosomal RNA genes (as of February 2002). Nearly all of these introns are assigned to one of four main types: group I, group II, archaeal and spliceosomal. This sequence information has been organized into a relational database that is accessible through the Comparative RNA Web Site (http://www.rna.icmb.utexas.edu/) While the rRNA introns are distributed across the entire tree of life, the majority of introns occur within a few phylogenetic groups. We analyzed the distributions of rRNA introns within the three-dimensional structures of the 30S and 50S ribosomes. Most sites in rRNA genes that contain introns contain only one type of intron. While the intron insertion sites occur at many different coordinates, the majority are clustered near conserved residues that form tRNA binding sites and the subunit interface. Contrary to our expectations, many of these positions are not accessible to solvent in the mature ribosome. The correlation between the frequency of intron insertions and proximity of the insertion site to functionally important residues suggests an association between intron evolution and rRNA function.

Self-induced structural switches in RNA

Many biologically active RNAs show a switch in their secondary structure, which is accompanied by changes in their function. Such changes in secondary structure often require trans-acting factors, e.g. RNA chaperones. However, several biologically active RNAs do not require trans-acting factors for this structural switch, which is therefore indicated here as a "self-induced switch". These self-induced structural switches have several characteristics in common. They all start from a metastable structure, which is maintained for some time allowing or blocking a particular function of the RNA. Hereafter, a structural element becomes available, e.g. during transcription, triggering a rapid transition into a stable conformation, which again is accompanied by either a gain or loss of function. A further common element of this type of switches is the involvement of a branch migration or strand displacement reaction, which lowers the energy barrier of the reaction sufficiently to allow rapid refolding. Here, we review a number of these self-induced switches in RNA secondary structure as proposed for several systems. A general model for this type of switches is presented, showing its importance in the biology of functionally active RNAs.

RNA folding in vivo

RNA folding in vivo is influenced by the cellular environment, the vectorial nature of transcription and translation, trans-acting factors and ion homeostasis. Specific RNA-binding proteins promote RNA folding by stabilizing the native structure or by guiding folding. In contrast, RNA chaperones, which are believed to interact nonspecifically with RNA, were proposed to resolve misfolded RNA structures and to promote intermolecular RNA-RNA annealing. Small trans-acting noncoding RNAs are thought to modulate mRNA structures, thereby regulating gene expression. So far, there is some evidence that in vitro and invivo RNA folding pathways share basic features. However, it is unclear whether the rules deduced from in vitro folding experiments generally apply to invivo conditions.

Folding problems of the 5' splice site containing the P1 stem of the group I thymidylate synthase intron: substrate binding inhibition in vitro and mis-splicing in vivo

We developed an in vitro cleaving assay for the thymidylate synthase (td) group I intron and observed that the off-rate of the substrate is faster than cleavage. From the sequence stems P1 and P2 can vary from 4 to 8 and from 6 to 10 base pairs, respectively, with folding of a long P1 stem being in competition with folding of a long P2 stem. Shorter substrates, which cannot compete with the formation of an extended P2, result in faster cleavage, suggesting that binding of the substrate indeed interferes with folding of stem P2. In vivo splicing analyses of mutants containing alterations in stems P1 and P2 indicate that the wild-type exon sequence of P1 is suboptimal for splicing. Furthermore, folding of P1 in vivo is in competition with an alternative cryptic P1 stem resulting in mis-splicing. Translation promotes splicing at the correct 5' splice site, whereas in the absence of translation, mis-splicing is favored. The combination of the in vitro and in vivo assays clearly displays the folding problems for correct splice site selection in this group I intron.

In vivo selection of better self-splicing introns in Escherichia coli: the role of the P1 extension helix of the Tetrahymena intron

In vivo selection was used to improve the activity of the Tetrahymena pre-rRNA self-splicing intron in the context of heterologous exons. The intron was engineered into a kanamycin nucleotidyltransferase gene, with the pairing between intron bases and the 5' and 3' splice sites maintained. The initial construct failed to confer kanamycin resistance on Escherichia coli, although the pre-mRNA was active in splicing in vitro. Random mutation libraries were constructed to identify active intron variants in E. coli. All the active mutants sequenced contained mutations disrupting a base-paired region above the paired region P1 (referred to as the P1 extension region or P1ex) that involves the very 5' end of the intron. Subsequent site-directed mutagenesis confirmed that these P1ex mutations are responsible and sufficient to activate the intron splicing in E. coli. Thus, it appears that too strong of a secondary structure in the P1ex element can be inhibitory to splicing in vivo. In vitro splicing assays demonstrated that two P1ex mutant constructs splice six to eight times faster than the designed construct at 40 microM GTP concentration. The relative reaction rates of the mutant constructs compared to the original design are further increased at a lower GTP concentration. Possible mechanisms by which the disrupted P1ex structure could influence splicing rates are discussed. This study emphasizes the value of using libraries of random mutations to improve the activity of ribozymes in heterologous contexts in vivo.

Coupled nucleotide covariations reveal dynamic RNA interaction patterns

Evolutionarily conserved structures in related RNA molecules contain coordinated variations (covariations) of paired nucleotides. Analysis of covariations is a very powerful approach to deduce phylogenetically conserved (i.e., functional) conformations, including tertiary interactions. Here we discuss conserved RNA folding pathways that are revealed by covariation patterns. In such pathways, structural requirements for alternative pairings cause some nucleotides to covary with two different partners. Such "coupled" covariations between three or more nucleotides were found in various types of RNAs. The analysis of coupled covariations can unravel important features of RNA folding dynamics and improve phylogeny reconstruction in some cases. Importantly, it is necessary to distinguish between multiple covariations determined by mutually exclusive structures and those determined by tertiary contacts.

Refolding of rRNA exons enhances dissociation of the Tetrahymena intron

Self-splicing of the Tetrahymena pre-rRNA is inhibited by a conserved rRNA hairpin P(-1) upstream of the 5' splice site. P(-1) inhibits self-splicing by competing with formation of the P1 splice site helix. Here we show that the P(-1) hairpin also enhances dissociation of the spliced products, which was monitored by native gel electrophoresis. Mutations that stabilize the rRNA hairpin increase the rate of dissociation approximately 10-fold, from 0.5 min(-1) for the wild-type RNA to approximately 4 min(-1) at 30 degrees C. Conversely, mutations or oligonucleotides that inhibit refolding of the exons and that stabilize the P1 helix decrease the rate of product release. The results suggest that refolding of products can be used to stimulate the turnover of ribozyme-catalyzed reactions. In the pre-rRNA, this conformational change helps shift the equilibrium of self-splicing toward the mature rRNA.

A role for upstream RNA structure in facilitating the catalytic fold of the genomic hepatitis delta virus ribozyme

Hepatitis delta virus (HDV) has a circular RNA genome that replicates by a double rolling-circle mechanism. The genomic and antigenomic versions of HDV contain a ribozyme that undergoes cis-cleavage, thereby processing the transcript into unit-length monomers. A genomic HDV transcript containing 30 nucleotides immediately upstream of the cleavage site was found to have attenuated self-cleavage. Structure mapping and site-directed mutagenesis revealed an inhibitory stretch consisting of upstream nucleotides -24 to -15 that forms a long-range pairing, termed Alt 1, with the 3' strand of P2 (P2(3')) located at the very 3'-end of the ribozyme. Two other alternative pairings were found, Alt 2, which involves upstream nucleotide-ribozyme interactions, and Alt 3, which involves ribozyme-ribozyme interactions. Self-cleavage was rescued 2700 to 20,000-fold by adding DNA oligomers, which sequester the -24/-15 inhibitory stretch in trans. Surprisingly, co-transcriptional self-cleavage occurs when the number of upstream nucleotides is increased to 54. Computer prediction and structure mapping support the existence of an unusually stable upstream hairpin involving nucleotides -54 to -18, termed P(-1)/L(-1), which sequesters the majority of the -24/-15 inhibitory stretch in cis. This hairpin is followed by a stretch of single-stranded pyrimidine-rich nucleotides, termed J(-1/1). Sequence comparison suggests that the P(-1)/L(-1)/J(-1/1) motif is conserved among known genomic HDV isolates, and that the J(-1/1) stretch is conserved among antigenomic HDV isolates. Lastly, the secondary structure of the Alt 1-containing ribozyme provides insight into possible folding intermediates of the ribozyme.

Destabilizing effect of an rRNA stem-loop on an attenuator hairpin in the 5' exon of the Tetrahymena pre-rRNA

Self-splicing of the Tetrahymena group I intron is attenuated by an rRNA stem-loop in the 5' exon, which competes with formation of the P1 splice site helix. The equilibrium between the P1 and P(-1) stem-loops is influenced by rRNA sequences upstream and downstream of the intron. To investigate the mechanism of this conformational switch, internal deletions and point mutations were introduced in the second rRNA stem-loop upstream of the 5' splice site. Nuclease protection, native gel electrophoresis, and self-splicing results show that this helix is important for maintaining self-splicing activity. Co-axial base stacking of adjacent helices in the 5' exon is proposed to enable exchange between inactive and active conformations of the pre-rRNA.

Influence of substrate structure on in vitro ribozyme activity of a group II intron

Substrate sequences surrounding catalytic RNAs but not involved in specific, conserved interactions can severely interfere with in vitro ribozyme activity. Using model group II intron precursor transcripts with truncated or randomized exon sequences, we show that unspecific sequences within the 5' exon are particularly prone to inhibit both the forward and the reverse first splicing step (branching). Using in vitro selection, we selected efficient 5' exons for the reverse branching reaction. Precursor RNAs carrying these selected 5' exons reacted more homogeneously and faster than usual model precursor transcripts. This suggests that unfavorable structures induced by the 5' exon can introduce a folding step that limits the rate of in vitro self-splicing. These results stress how critical is the choice of the sequences retained or discarded when isolating folding domains from their natural sequence environments. Moreover, they suggest that exon sequences not involved in specific interactions are more evolutionarily constrained with respect to splicing than previously envisioned.

Hierarchy and dynamics of RNA folding

The evidence showing that the self-assembly of complex RNAs occurs in discrete transitions, each relating to the folding of sub-systems of increasing size and complexity starting from a state with most of the secondary structure, is reviewed. The reciprocal influence of the concentration of magnesium ions and nucleotide mutations on tertiary structure is analyzed. Several observations demonstrate that detrimental mutations can be rescued by high magnesium concentrations, while stabilizing mutations lead to a lesser dependence on magnesium ion concentration. Recent data point to the central controlling and monitoring roles of RNA-binding proteins that can bind to the different folding stages, either before full establishment of the secondary structure or at the molten globule state before the cooperative transition to the final three-dimensional structure.

Reverse splicing of the Tetrahymena IVS: evidence for multiple reaction sites in the 23S rRNA

Group I introns in rRNA genes are clustered in highly conserved regions that include tRNA and mRNA binding sites. This pattern is consistent with insertion of group I introns by direct interaction with exposed regions of rRNA. Integration of the Tetrahymena group I intron (or intervening sequence, IVS) into large subunit rRNA via reverse splicing was investigated using E. coli 23S rRNA as a model substrate. The results show that sequences homologous to the splice junction in Tetrahymena are the preferred site of integration, but that many other sequences in the 23S rRNA provide secondary targets. Like the original splice junction, many new reaction sites are in regions of stable secondary structure. Reaction at the natural splice junction is observed in 50S subunits and to a lesser extent in 70S ribosomes. These results support the feasibility of intron transposition to new sites in rRNA genes via reverse splicing.

The mobile group I intron 3 alpha of the yeast mitochondrial COXI gene encodes a 35-kDa processed protein that is an endonuclease but not a maturase

Three mitochondrial mutants were characterized that block the splicing of aI3 alpha, a mobile group I intron of the COXI gene of yeast mtDNA. Mutant C1085 alters helical structures known to be important for splicing of group I introns. M44 and C1072 are point mutants in exon 3 that block correct splicing but allow some splicing at cryptic 5'-splice sites. M44 alters the P1 helix needed for 5'-splice site definition, while the mutation in C1072 is a new kind of mutation because it is located upstream of the exon sequence involved in the P1 helix. All three mutants accumulate novel proteins of 35 and 44 kDa (p35 and p44, respectively) detected both by labeling of mitochondrial translation products and by Western blotting. Partial protease digestions indicate that p44 and p35 are closely related, probably as precursor and processed protein. The level of the intron-encoded endonuclease activity, I-SceIII, is elevated approximately 10-fold in the mutants. Partial purification of I-SceIII from the mutants showed that most, if not all, of the activity is associated with p35. Finally, because aI3 alpha splices accurately in a petite mutant, we conclude that aI3 alpha splicing does not depend on a mtDNA-encoded maturase.

Self-splicing of the Tetrahymena pre-rRNA is decreased by misfolding during transcription

RNA processing depends in part on the ability of nascent transcripts to fold into the desired conformation. Self-splicing of the group I intron from Tetrahymena was used to assess the folded state of preribosomal RNA transcripts when synthesized in vitro. A simple method for isolating nondenatured RNA from a T7 RNA polymerase reaction was tested. The intron alone is fully active when transcribed at 30 degrees C, suggesting that the active structure is both kinetically and thermodynamically favored. Longer precursor RNAs, however, were less than completely active in self-splicing. Full activity, as judged by both the initial rate and the extent of product formation, was restored by brief incubation at 95 degrees C and rapid cooling in the presence of magnesium ion. This result did not depend on the length of the precursor RNA in any simple way, but correlated loosely with the presence of intact exon domains. When transcribed in the absence of cellular proteins, a significant portion of the pre-RNA appears to be trapped in a conformation that does not readily undergo the first step of splicing.