Homology dependence of targeted recombination at the Chinese hamster APRT locus

The homologous recombination protein RAD51D protects the genome from large deletions

Homologous recombination (HR) is a DNA double-strand break (DSB) repair pathway that protects the genome from chromosomal instability. RAD51 mediator proteins (i.e. paralogs) are critical for efficient HR in mammalian cells. However, how HR-deficient cells process DSBs is not clear. Here, we utilized a loss-of-function HR-reporter substrate to simultaneously monitor HR-mediated gene conversion and non-conservative mutation events. The assay is designed around a heteroallelic duplication of the Aprt gene at its endogenous locus in isogenic Chinese hamster ovary cell lines. We found that RAD51D-deficient cells had a reduced capacity for HR-mediated gene conversion both spontaneously and in response to I-SceI-induced DSBs. Further, RAD51D-deficiency shifted DSB repair toward highly deleterious single-strand annealing (SSA) and end-joining processes that led to the loss of large chromosomal segments surrounding site-specific DSBs at an exceptionally high frequency. Deletions in the proximity of the break were due to a non-homologous end-joining pathway, while larger deletions were processed via a SSA pathway. Overall, our data revealed that, in addition to leading to chromosomal abnormalities, RAD51D-deficiency resulted in a high frequency of deletions advancing our understanding of how a RAD51 paralog is involved in maintaining genomic stability and how its deficiency may predispose cells to tumorigenesis.

A comparison of synthetic oligodeoxynucleotides, DNA fragments and AAV-1 for targeted episomal and chromosomal gene repair

Background

Current strategies for gene therapy of inherited diseases consist in adding functional copies of the gene that is defective. An attractive alternative to these approaches would be to correct the endogenous mutated gene in the affected individual. This study presents a quantitative comparison of the repair efficiency using different forms of donor nucleic acids, including synthetic DNA oligonucleotides, double stranded DNA fragments with sizes ranging from 200 to 2200 bp and sequences carried by a recombinant adeno-associated virus (rAAV-1). Evaluation of each gene repair strategy was carried out using two different reporter systems, a mutated eGFP gene or a dual construct with a functional eGFP and an inactive luciferase gene, in several different cell systems. Gene targeting events were scored either following transient co-transfection of reporter plasmids and donor DNAs, or in a system where a reporter construct was stably integrated into the chromosome.

Results

In both episomal and chromosomal assays, DNA fragments were more efficient at gene repair than oligonucleotides or rAAV-1. Furthermore, the gene targeting frequency could be significantly increased by using DNA repair stimulating drugs such as doxorubicin and phleomycin.

Conclusion

Our results show that it is possible to obtain repair frequencies of 1% of the transfected cell population under optimized transfection protocols when cells were pretreated with phleomycin using rAAV-1 and dsDNA fragments.

A caveat in mouse genetic engineering: ectopic gene targeting in ES cells by bidirectional extension of the homology arms of a gene replacement vector carrying human PARP-1

Here we report an approach to generate a knock-in mouse model using an 'ends-out' gene replacement vector to substitute the murine Parp-1 (mParp-1) coding sequence (32 kb) with its human orthologous sequence (46 kb). Unexpectedly, examination of mutant ES cell clones and mice revealed that site-specific homologous recombination was mimicked in three independently generated ES cell clones by bidirectional extension of the vector homology arms using the endogenous mParp-1-flanking sequences as templates. This was followed by adjacent integration of the targeting vector, thus leaving the endogenous mParp-1 locus functional. A related phenomenon termed 'ectopic gene targeting' has so far only been described for 'ends-in' integration-type vectors in non-ES cell gene targeting. We provide reliable techniques to detect such ectopic gene targeting which represents an unexpected caveat in mouse genetic engineering that should be considered in the design and validation strategy of future gene knock-in approaches.

Increased gene targeting in Ku70 and Xrcc4 transiently deficient human somatic cells

The insertion of foreign DNA at a specific genomic locus directed by homologous DNA sequences, or gene targeting, is an inefficient process in mammalian somatic cells. Given the key role of non-homologous end joining (NHEJ) pathway in DNA double-strand break (DSB) repair in mammalian cells, we investigated the effects of decreasing NHEJ protein levels on gene targeting. Here we demonstrate that the transient knockdown of integral NHEJ proteins, Ku70 and Xrcc4, by RNAi in human HCT116 cells has a remarkable effect on gene targeting/random insertions ratios. A timely transfection of an HPRT-based targeting vector after RNAi treatment led to a 70% reduction in random integration events and a 33-fold increase in gene targeting at the HPRT locus. These findings bolster the role of NHEJ proteins in foreign DNA integration in vivo, and demonstrate that their transient depletion by RNAi is a viable approach to increase the frequency of gene targeting events. Understanding how foreign DNA integrates into a cell's genome is important to advance strategies for biotechnology and genetic medicine.

Biallelic gene knockouts in Chinese hamster ovary cells

Chinese hamster ovary (CHO) cells are the most common host cells and are widely used in the manufacture of approved recombinant therapeutics. They represent a major new class of universal hosts in biopharmaceutical production. However, there remains room for improvement to create more ideal host cells that can add greater value to therapeutic recombinant proteins at reduced production cost. A promising approach to this goal is biallelic gene knockout in CHO cells, as it is the most reliable and effective means to permanent phenotypic change, owing to the complete removal of gene function. In this chapter, we describe a biallelic gene knockout process in CHO cells, as exemplified by the successful targeted disruption of both FUT8 alleles encoding alpha-1,6-fucosyltransferase gene in CHO/DG44 cells. Wild-type alleles are sequentially disrupted by homologous recombination using two targeting vectors to generate homozygous disruptants, and the drug-resistance gene cassettes remaining on the alleles are removed by a Cre/loxP recombination system so as not to leave the extraphenotype except for the functional loss of the gene of interest.

Artificial chromosome-based transgenes in the study of genome function

The transfer of large DNA fragments to the mouse genome in the form of bacterial, yeast or phage artificial chromosomes is an important process in the definition of transcription units, the modeling of inherited disease states, the dissection of candidate regions identified by linkage analysis and the construction of in vivo reporter genes. However, as with small recombinant transgenes, the transferred sequences are usually integrated randomly often with accompanying genomic alterations and variable expression of the introduced genes due to the site of integration and/or copy number. Therefore, alternative methods of integrating large genomic transgenes into the genome have been developed to avoid the variables associated with random integration. This review encourages the reader to imagine the large variety of applications where artificial chromosome transgenes can facilitate in vivo and ex vivo studies in the mouse and provides a context for making the necessary decisions regarding the specifics of experimental design.

A trial of somatic gene targeting in vivo with an adenovirus vector

Background

Gene targeting in vivo provides a potentially powerful method for gene analysis and gene therapy. In order to sensitively detect and accurately measure designed sequence changes, we have used a transgenic mouse system, MutaMouse, which has been developed for detection of mutation in vivo. It carries bacteriophage lambda genome with lacZ⁺ gene, whose change to lacZ-negative allele is detected after in vitro packaging into bacteriophage particles. We have also demonstrated that gene transfer with a replication-defective adenovirus vector can achieve efficient and accurate gene targeting in vitro.

Methods

An 8 kb long DNA corresponding to the bacteriophage lambda transgene with one of two lacZ-negative single-base-pair-substitution mutant allele was inserted into a replication-defective adenovirus vector. This recombinant adenovirus was injected to the transgenic mice via tail-vein. Twenty-four hours later, genomic DNA was extracted from the liver tissue and the lambda::lacZ were recovered by in vitro packaging. The lacZ-negative phage was detected as a plaque former on agar with phenyl-beta-D-galactoside.

Results

The mutant frequency of the lacZ-negative recombinant adenovirus injected mice was at the same level with the control mouse (~1/10000). Our further restriction analysis did not detect any designed recombinant.

Conclusion

The frequency of gene targeting in the mouse liver by these recombinant adenoviruses was shown to be less than 1/20000 in our assay. However, these results will aid the development of a sensitive, reliable and PCR-independent assay for gene targeting in vivo mediated by virus vectors and other means.

Establishment ofFUT8 knockout Chinese hamster ovary cells: An ideal host cell line for producing completely defucosylated antibodies with enhanced antibody-dependent cellular cytotoxicity

To generate industrially applicable new host cell lines for antibody production with optimizing antibody-dependent cellular cytotoxicity (ADCC) we disrupted both FUT8 alleles in a Chinese hamster ovary (CHO)/DG44 cell line by sequential homologous recombination. FUT8 encodes an alpha-1,6-fucosyltransferase that catalyzes the transfer of fucose from GDP-fucose to N-acetylglucosamine (GlcNAc) in an alpha-1,6 linkage. FUT8(-/-) cell lines have morphology and growth kinetics similar to those of the parent, and produce completely defucosylated recombinant antibodies. FUT8(-/-)-produced chimeric anti-CD20 IgG1 shows the same level of antigen-binding activity and complement-dependent cytotoxicity (CDC) as the FUT8(+/+)-produced, comparable antibody, Rituxan. In contrast, FUT8(-/-)-produced anti-CD20 IgG1 strongly binds to human Fcgamma-receptor IIIa (FcgammaRIIIa) and dramatically enhances ADCC to approximately 100-fold that of Rituxan. Our results demonstrate that FUT8(-/-) cells are ideal host cell lines to stably produce completely defucosylated high-ADCC antibodies with fixed quality and efficacy for therapeutic use.

[Homologous recombination and gene targeting]

Gene therapy and the production of mutated cell lines or model animals both require the development of efficient, controlled gene-targeting strategies. Classical approaches are based on the ability of cells to use homologous recombination to integrate exogenous DNA into their own genome. The low frequency of homologous recombination in mammalian cells leads to inefficient targeting. Here, we review the limiting steps of classical approaches and the new strategies developed to improve the efficiency of homologous recombination in gene-targeting experiments.

XRCC3 controls the fidelity of homologous recombination: roles for XRCC3 in late stages of recombination

XRCC3 is a RAD51 paralog that functions in the repair of DNA double-strand breaks (DSBs) by homologous recombination (HR). XRCC3 mutation causes severe chromosome instability. We find that XRCC3 mutant cells display radically altered HR product spectra, with increased gene conversion tract lengths, increased frequencies of discontinuous tracts, and frequent local rearrangements associated with HR. These results indicate that XRCC3 function is not limited to HR initiation, but extends to later stages in formation and resolution of HR intermediates, possibly by stabilizing heteroduplex DNA. The results further demonstrate that HR defects can promote genomic instability not only through failure to initiate HR (leading to nonhomologous repair) but also through aberrant processing of HR intermediates. Both mechanisms may contribute to carcinogenesis in HR-deficient cells.

Gene targeting is enhanced in human cells overexpressing hRAD51

The ideal therapy for single gene disorders would be repair of the mutated disease genes. Homologous recombination is one of several cellular mechanisms for the repair of DNA damage. Recombination between exogenous DNA and homologous chromosomal loci (gene targeting) can be used to repair an endogenous gene, but the low efficiency of this process is a serious barrier to its therapeutic potential. Recent progress in the isolation and characterisation of mammalian genes and proteins involved in DNA recombination has raised the possibility that the cellular biochemistry of recombination can be manipulated to improve the efficiency of gene targeting. As an initial test of this approach, we have overexpressed the gene encoding hRAD51, a protein with homologous DNA pairing and strand exchange activities, in human cells and measured its effect on gene targeting. We report a two- to three-fold increase in gene targeting, and enhanced resistance to ionising radiation in hRAD51-overexpressing cells with no obvious detrimental effects. These observations provide valuable genetic evidence for the involvement of hRAD51 in both gene targeting and DNA repair in human cells. Our data also establish overexpression of recombination genes as a viable approach to improving gene targeting efficiencies.

Homology requirements for targeting heterologous sequences during P-induced gap repair in Drosophila melanogaster

The effect of homology on gene targeting was studied in the context of P-element-induced double-strand breaks at the white locus of Drosophila melanogaster. Double-strand breaks were made by excision of P-w(hd), a P-element insertion in the white gene. A nested set of repair templates was generated that contained the 8 kilobase (kb) yellow gene embedded within varying amounts of white gene sequence. Repair with unlimited homology was also analyzed. Files were scored phenotypically for conversion of the yellow gene to the white locus. Targeting of the yellow gene was abolished when all of the 3' homology was removed. Increases in template homology up to 51 base pairs (bp) did not significantly promote targeting. Maximum conversion was observed with a construct containing 493 bp of homology, without a significant increase in frequency when homology extended to the tips of the chromosome. These results demonstrate that the homology requirements for targeting a large heterologous insertion are quite different than those for a point mutation. Furthermore, heterologous insertions strongly affect the homology requirements for the conversion of distal point mutations. Several aberrant conversion tracts, which arose from templates that contained reduced homology, also were examined and characterized.

Homologous junctions formed between a vector and human genomic repetitive LINE-1 elements as a result of one-sided invasion

Studies on homologous recombination in mammalian cells between an exogenous DNA molecule containing a double-strand break and a homologous genomic sequence have indicated that there were at least two distinct types of homologous recombination processes, one that involved the formation of two homologous junctions and another that involved the formation of one homologous junction and one illegitimate junction. Both types of events are produced in gene targeting experiments. We have proposed a model to account for the later process called one-sided invasion. One-sided invasion has now been reported in numerous species belonging to different phyla and appears to be a universal mechanism. It has also been observed in normal human germ cells. The role of one-sided invasion is still unknown. Using a recombination assay between LINE-1 elements from the human genome and exogenous LINE-1 sequences, we have characterized the process of homologous junction formation in one-sided invasion. We found that at each of the homologous junctions, variable lengths of the vector L1 sequences had been replaced by genomic L1 sequences. We also found a homologous junction that involved three partners, suggesting that the homologous end could be released and become available for a second round of interaction.

Enrichment for gene targeting in mammalian cells by inhibition of poly(ADP-ribosylation)

Inhibition of poly(ADP-ribosylation) reduces random genomic integration of transfected DNA and mildly stimulates intrachromosomal homologous recombination in mammalian cells. We investigated the effect of inhibition of poly(ADP-ribosylation) on the efficiency of gene targeting in Chinese hamster ovary (CHO) cell line ATS-49tg. This cell line is hemizygous for a defective adenine phosphoribosyltransferase (aprt) gene and is hypoxanthine phosphoribosyltransferase (hprt) deficient. Plasmid pAG100 contains a portion of the CHO aprt gene sufficient to correct the defect in ATS-49tg cells via gene targeting; pAG100 also contains an Escherichia coli guanine phosphoribosyltransferase (gpt) gene. Following transfection of ATS-49tg cells with pAG100, selection for gpt-positive transfectants allowed recovery of cells that had randomly integrated pAG100 while selection for aprt-positive cells allowed recovery of cells that had undergone gene targeting at the endogenous aprt locus. Treatment of cells with 3 mM 3-methoxybenzamide (3-MB), an inhibitor of poly(ADP-ribose) polymerase, decreased random integration and gene targeting of electroporated pAG100 about 5-fold. In contrast, treatment with 3 mM 3-MB during calcium phosphate transfection could reduce random integration more than 150-fold while reducing gene targeting less than two-fold. Therefore, as much as a 100-fold enrichment for gene targeting was achieved with calcium phosphate transfection.

Mutations in the elongation factor 2 gene which confer resistance to diphtheria toxin and Pseudomonas exotoxin A. Genetic and biochemical analyses

Both diphtheria toxin and Pseudomonas exotoxin A inhibit eukaryotic protein synthesis by ADP-ribosylating diphthamide, a posttranslationally modified histidine residue present in the elongation factor 2 (EF-2) protein. Elongation factor 2 cannot be ADP-ribosylated by the toxins unless this histidine is modified. In this report we identify three new point mutations in toxin-resistant alleles of the Chinese hamster ovary cell elongation factor 2 gene. The mutations resulted in amino acid substitutions at positions 584 (serine to glycine), 714 (isoleucine to asparagine), and 719 (glycine to aspartic acid). All three amino acid substitutions prevented the biosynthesis of diphthamide. The amount by which the toxins reduced protein synthesis in each of these mutant cell strains suggested that all three mutations also either impaired the function of EF-2 or reduced its steady state level in the cytoplasm. Western blot analysis showed that equal amounts of EF-2 were present in each of the cell strains, indicating that the mutations impaired the catalytic function of EF-2.