Phenotypic variation in a genetically identical population of mice

Protein coding variation in the J:ARC and J:DO outbred laboratory mouse stocks provides a molecular basis for distinct research applications

Outbred laboratory mice (Mus musculus) are readily available and have high fecundity, making them a popular choice in biomedical research, especially toxicological and pharmacological applications. Direct high throughput genome sequencing (HTS) of these widely used research animals is an important genetic quality control measure that enhances research reproducibility. HTS data have been used to confirm the common origin of outbred stocks and to molecularly define distinct outbred populations. But these data have also revealed unexpected population structure and homozygosity in some populations; genetic features that emerge when outbred stocks are not properly maintained. We used exome sequencing to discover and interrogate protein-coding variation in a newly established population of Swiss-derived outbred stock (J:ARC) that is closely related to other, commonly used CD-1 outbred populations. We used these data to describe the genetic architecture of the J:ARC population including heterozygosity, minor allele frequency, LD decay, and we defined novel, protein-coding sequence variation. These data reveal the expected genetic architecture for a properly maintained outbred stock and provide a basis for the on-going genetic quality control. We also compared these data to protein-coding variation found in a multiparent outbred stock, the Diversity Outbred (J:DO). We found that the more recently derived, multiparent outbred stock has significantly higher interindividual variability, greater overall genetic variation, higher heterozygosity, and fewer novel variants than the Swiss-derived J:ARC stock. However, among the novel variants found in the J:DO stock, significantly more are predicted to be protein-damaging. The fact that individuals from this population can tolerate a higher load of potentially damaging variants highlights the buffering effects of allelic diversity and the differing selective pressures in these stocks. While both outbred stocks offer significant individual heterozygosity, our data provide a molecular basis for their intended applications, where the J:DO are best suited for studies requiring maximum, population-level genetic diversity and power for mapping, while the J:ARC are best suited as a general-purpose outbred stock with robust fecundity, relatively low allelic diversity, and less potential for extreme phenotypic variability.

Premature ovarian insufficiency in the XO female mouse on the C57BL/6J genetic background

In humans, all but 1% of monosomy 45.X embryos die in utero and those who reach term suffer from congenital abnormalities and infertility termed Turner's syndrome (TS). By contrast, XO female mice on various genetic backgrounds show much milder physical defects and normal fertility, diminishing their value as an animal model for studying the infertility of TS patients. In this article, we report that XO mice on the C57BL/6J (B6) genetic background showed early oocyte loss, infertility or subfertility and high embryonic lethality, suggesting that the effect of monosomy X in the female germline may be shared between mice and humans. First, we generated XO mice on either a mixed N2(C3H.B6) or B6 genetic background and compared the number of oocytes in neonatal ovaries; N2.XO females retained 45% of the number of oocytes in N2.XX females, whereas B6.XO females retained only 15% of that in B6.XX females. Second, while N2.XO females were as fertile as N2.XX females, both the frequency of delivery and the total number of pups delivered by B6.XO females were significantly lower than those by B6.XX females. Third, after mating with B6 males, both N2.XO and B6.XO females rarely produced XO pups carrying paternal X chromosomes, although a larger percentage of embryos was found to be XO before implantation. Furthermore, B6.XO females delivered 20% XO pups among female progeny after mating with C3H males. We conclude that the impact of monosomy X on female mouse fertility depends on the genetic background.

Factors that influence outcome in experimental osteoarthritis

OBJECTIVE

Osteoarthritis (OA) is the most common joint disease but an effective pharmacological therapy has not been developed yet. To identify targets for treatment and ways to interfere with OA development and progression both spontaneous and induced OA models are still needed. In this narrative review it is discussed what variables can be identified that lead to variation in OA animal model studies.

DESIGN

Literature was screened (Pubmed) with the following terms; OA animal models in combination with species, age, strain, gender/sex, housing, diet, fighting, circadian rhythm, transgenic. Relevant articles were selected and additional papers were searched for and read for specific subtopics.

RESULTS

Studies with OA models are subject to a multitude of variables, stimuli and conditions that can influence the outcome of an animal experiment. Outcome will depend on amongst others; the model used, species and strain, age, gender, diet, housing conditions, circadian rhythm, timing of intervention, stress levels and activity. Variations in these variables can account for discrepancies between OA model experiments, intervention studies and conclusions.

CONCLUSION

To improve OA animal model research, investigators should be aware of all the stimuli and conditions that can interfere with disease development and disease intervention and take these into account in their study design and execution.

Genomic landscapes of endogenous retroviruses unveil intricate genetics of conventional and genetically-engineered laboratory mouse strains

Laboratory strains of mice, both conventional and genetically engineered, have been introduced as critical components of a broad range of studies investigating normal and disease biology. Currently, the genetic identity of laboratory mice is primarily confirmed by surveying polymorphisms in selected sets of "conventional" genes and/or microsatellites in the absence of a single completely sequenced mouse genome. First, we examined variations in the genomic landscapes of transposable repetitive elements, named the TREome, in conventional and genetically engineered mouse strains using murine leukemia virus-type endogenous retroviruses (MLV-ERVs) as a probe. A survey of the genomes from 56 conventional strains revealed strain-specific TREome landscapes, and certain families (e.g., C57BL) of strains were discernible with defined patterns. Interestingly, the TREome landscapes of C3H/HeJ (toll-like receptor-4 [TLR4] mutant) inbred mice were different from its control C3H/HeOuJ (TLR4 wild-type) strain. In addition, a CD14 knock-out strain had a distinct TREome landscape compared to its control/backcross C57BL/6J strain. Second, an examination of superantigen (SAg, a "TREome gene") coding sequences of mouse mammary tumor virus-type ERVs in the genomes of the 46 conventional strains revealed a high diversity, suggesting a potential role of SAgs in strain-specific immune phenotypes. The findings from this study indicate that unexplored and intricate genomic variations exist in laboratory mouse strains, both conventional and genetically engineered. The TREome-based high-resolution genetics surveillance system for laboratory mice would contribute to efficient study design with quality control and accurate data interpretation. This genetics system can be easily adapted to other species ranging from plants to humans.

Prenatal Exposure to DEHP Affects Spermatogenesis and Sperm DNA Methylation in a Strain-Dependent Manner

Di-(2-ethylhexyl)phtalate (DEHP) is a plasticizer with endocrine disrupting properties found ubiquitously in the environment and altering reproduction in rodents. Here we investigated the impact of prenatal exposure to DEHP on spermatogenesis and DNA sperm methylation in two distinct, selected, and sequenced mice strains. FVB/N and C57BL/6J mice were orally exposed to 300 mg/kg/day of DEHP from gestation day 9 to 19. Prenatal DEHP exposure significantly decreased spermatogenesis in C57BL/6J (fold-change = 0.6, p-value = 8.7*10^-4), but not in FVB/N (fold-change = 1, p-value = 0.9). The number of differentially methylated regions (DMRs) by DEHP-exposure across the entire genome showed increased hyper- and decreased hypo-methylation in C57BL/6J compared to FVB/N. At the promoter level, three important subsets of genes were massively affected. Promoters of vomeronasal and olfactory receptors coding genes globally followed the same trend, more pronounced in the C57BL/6J strain, of being hyper-methylated in DEHP related conditions. In contrast, a large set of micro-RNAs were hypo-methylated, with a trend more pronounced in the FVB/N strain. We additionally analyze both the presence of functional genetic variations within genes that were associated with the detected DMRs and that could be involved in spermatogenesis, and DMRs related with the DEHP exposure that affected both strains in an opposite manner. The major finding in this study indicates that prenatal exposure to DEHP can decrease spermatogenesis in a strain-dependent manner and affects sperm DNA methylation in promoters of large sets of genes putatively involved in both sperm chemotaxis and post-transcriptional regulatory mechanisms.

The use of mouse models to study epigenetics

Much of what we know about the role of epigenetics in the determination of phenotype has come from studies of inbred mice. Some unusual expression patterns arising from endogenous and transgenic murine alleles, such as the Agouti coat color alleles, have allowed the study of variegation, variable expressivity, transgenerational epigenetic inheritance, parent-of-origin effects, and position effects. These phenomena have taught us much about gene silencing and the probabilistic nature of epigenetic processes. Based on some of these alleles, large-scale mutagenesis screens have broadened our knowledge of epigenetic control by identifying and characterizing novel genes involved in these processes.

Genetic background affects human glial fibrillary acidic protein promoter activity

The human glial fibrillary acidic protein (hGFAP) promoter has been used to generate numerous transgenic mouse lines, which has facilitated the analysis of astrocyte function in health and disease. Here, we evaluated the expression levels of various hGFAP transgenes at different ages in the two most commonly used inbred mouse strains, FVB/N (FVB) and C57BL/6N (B6N). In general, transgenic mice maintained on the B6N background displayed weaker transgene expression compared with transgenic FVB mice. Higher level of transgene expression in B6N mice could be regained by crossbreeding to FVB wild type mice. However, the endogenous murine GFAP expression was equivalent in both strains. In addition, we found that endogenous GFAP expression was increased in transgenic mice in comparison to wild type mice. The activities of the hGFAP transgenes were not age-dependently regulated. Our data highlight the importance of proper expression analysis when non-homologous recombination transgenesis is used.

Standing genetic variation and compensatory evolution in transgenic organisms: a growth-enhanced salmon simulation

Genetically modified strains usually are generated within defined genetic backgrounds to minimize variation for the engineered characteristic in order to facilitate basic research investigations or for commercial application. However, interactions between transgenes and genetic background have been documented in both model and commercial agricultural species, indicating that allelic variation at transgene-modifying loci are not uncommon in genomes. Engineered organisms that have the potential to allow entry of transgenes into natural populations may cause changes to ecosystems via the interaction of their specific phenotypes with ecosystem components and services. A transgene introgressing through natural populations is likely to encounter a range of natural genetic variation (among individuals or sub-populations) that could result in changes in phenotype, concomitant with effects on fitness and ecosystem consequences that differ from that seen in the progenitor transgenic strain. In the present study, using a growth hormone transgenic salmon example, we have modeled selection of modifier loci (single and multiple) in the presence of a transgene and have found that accounting for genetic background can significantly affect the persistence of transgenes in populations, potentially reducing or reversing a "Trojan gene" effect. Influences from altered life history characteristics (e.g., developmental timing, age of maturation) and compensatory demographic/ecosystem controls (e.g., density dependence) also were found to have a strong influence on transgene effects. Further, with the presence of a transgene in a population, genetic backgrounds were found to shift in non-transgenic individuals as well, an effect expected to direct phenotypes away from naturally selected optima. The present model has revealed the importance of understanding effects of selection for background genetics on the evolution of phenotypes in populations harbouring transgenes.

Metastable epialleles in mammals

There are some mammalian alleles that display the unusual characteristic of variable expressivity in the absence of genetic heterogeneity. It has recently become evident that this is because the activity of these alleles is dependent on their epigenetic state. Interestingly, the epigenetic state is somewhat labile, resulting in phenotypic mosaicism between cells (variegation) and also between individuals (variable expressivity). The establishment of the epigenetic state occurs during early embryogenesis and is a probabilistic event that is influenced by whether the allele is carried on the paternal or maternal alleles. In addition, the epigenetic state determines whether these alleles are dominant. We propose that mammalian alleles with such characteristics should be termed metastable epialleles to distinguish them from traditional alleles. At this stage, it is unclear how common these alleles are, but an appreciation of their existence will aid in their identification.

A complex duplication created by gene targeting at the imprinted H19 locus results in two classes of methylation and correlated Igf2 expression phenotypes

Imprinting of the mouse H19 and Igf2 genes is dependent on the presence of an intervening imprinting control region (ICR) situated 2 kb upstream of H19 and approximately 70 kb downstream of Igf2. Several recent studies have provided substantial evidence that the unmethylated maternal ICR acts as an insulator that prevents activation of Igf2 by a suite of enhancers downstream of the H19 gene. The methylated paternal ICR and H19 promoter have no activity, allowing sole activation of Igf2 expression. We have produced mice in which a duplication of the H19/Igf2 ICR produces, in each generation, two classes of methylation levels that correlated with two Igf2 imprinting phenotypes. One hypermethylated class also shows activation of the normally silent Igf2 gene, whereas the other hypomethylated class shows only slight activation of Igf2, in agreement with methylation's role in ICR function. This study describes a rare, possibly unique type of mutation that induces two distinct phenotypes in each generation.

Epigenetic targeting in the mouse zygote marks DNA for later methylation: a mechanism for maternal effects in development

The transgenic sequences in the mouse line TKZ751 are demethylated on a DBA/2 inbred strain background but become highly methylated at postimplantation stages in offspring of a cross with a BALB/c female. In the reciprocal cross the transgene remains demethylated suggesting that imprinted BALB/c methylation modifiers or egg cytoplasmic factors are responsible for this striking maternal effect on de novo methylation. Reciprocal pronuclear transplantation experiments were carried out to distinguish between these mechanisms. The results indicate that a maternally-derived oocyte cytoplasmic factor from BALB/c marks the TKZ751 sequences at fertilization; this mark and postzygotic BALB/c modifiers are both required for de novo methylation of the target sequences at postimplantation stages. Using genetic linkage analyses we mapped the maternal effect to a locus on chromosome 17. Moreover, seven postzygotic modifier loci were identified that increase the postimplantation level of methylation. Analysis of interactions between the maternal and the postzygotic loci shows that both are needed for de novo methylation in the offspring. The combined experiments thus reveal a novel epigenetic marking process at fertilization which targets DNA for later methylation in the foetus. The most significant consequence is that the genotype of the mother can influence the epigenotype of the offspring by this marking process. A number of parental and imprinting effects may be explained by this epigenetic marking.

A dominant modifier of transgene methylation is mapped by QTL analysis to mouse chromosome 13

The single-copy hepatitis B virus transgene in the E36 transgenic mouse strain undergoes methylation changes in a parent-of-origin, tissue, and strain-specific fashion. In a C57BL/6 background, the paternally transmitted transgene is methylated in 30% of cells, whereas it is methylated in more than 80% of cells in (BALB/c x C57BL/6) F1 mice. We established previously that several genetic factors were likely to contribute to the transgene methylation profile, some with demethylating and some with de novo methylating activities. Using quantitative trait loci (QTL) mapping, we have now localized one major modifier locus on chromosome 13 (Mod13), which explains a 30% increase in the methylation level of this transgene with no effect on the flanking endogenous sequences. No other QTL could be identified, except for a demethylating activity of low significance located on chromosome 12. Recombinant inbred mice containing a BALB/c allele of Mod13 were then used to show that the presence of Mod13 is sufficient to induce de novo methylation. A segregation between de novo methylation and repression of transgene expression was uncovered, suggesting that this genetic system is also useful for the identification of factors that interpret methylation patterns in the genome.

Epigenetic and genotype-specific effects on the stability of de novo imposed methylation patterns in transgenic mice

The chloramphenicol acetyltransferase gene under the control of the late E2A promoter of adenovirus type 2 (Ad2) was introduced as transgene into the B6D2F1 mouse strain with mixed genetic background and became extensively de novo methylated. The methylation of this pAd2E2AL-CAT (7-1A) transgene was regulated in a strain-specific manner apparently depending on the site of integration. Transmission of the 7-1A transgene into an inbred DBA/2, 129/sv, or FVB/N genetic background led to a significant loss of methylation in the transgene, whereas C57BL/6, CB20, and Balb/c backgrounds favored the de novo methylation in very specific patterns. The newly established patterns of de novo methylation were transmitted to the offspring and remained stable for many generations, regardless of the heterozygosity of strain-specific DNA sequences present in these mouse strains. Segregation analyses showed a non-mendelian transmission of methylation phenotypes and suggested the involvement of dominant modifiers of methylation. The genotype-specific modifications of the transgene were followed for 11 backcross generations. These observations reflect an evolutionarily conserved mechanism directed against foreign, e.g. viral or bacterial, DNA at least in the chromosomal location of the 7-1A transgene. In seven additional mouse lines carrying the same transgene in different chromosomal locations, strain-specific alterations of methylation patterns were not observed.

Complex patterns of inheritance of an imprinted murine transgene suggest incomplete germline erasure

Here we report a transgenic mouse line that exhibits significant deviations from a classic pattern of parental imprinting. When the transgene is passed through the female germline, it is completely silenced in some offspring while in others expression is reduced. This variable expressivity does not appear to be the result of differences in the presence of unlinked modifiers. Female transmission of the transgene is associated with hypermethylation. The transgene is generally reactivated on passage through the male germline. Extended pedigrees reveal complex patterns of inheritance of the phenotype. The most likely explanation for this result is that the imprint is not completely erased and reset when passed through the germline of either sex. FISH analysis reveals that the transgene has integrated into chromosome 3 band E3, a region not known to carry imprinted genes, and the integration site shows no sign of allele-specific differential methylation. These findings, in conjunction with other recent work, raise the possibility that the introduction of foreign DNA into the mammalian genome, either through retrotransposition or transgenesis, may be associated with parental imprinting that is not always erased and reset during meiosis.

Parental alleles of an imprinted mouse transgene replicate synchronously

Molecular features of imprinted genes include differences in expression, methylation, and the timing of DNA replication between parental alleles. Whereas methylation differences always seem to be associated with differences in expression, differences in the timing of replication between parental homologs are not always seen at imprinted loci. These observations raise the possibility that differences in replication timing may not be an essential feature underlying genomic imprinting. In this study, we examined the timing of replication of the two alleles of the imprinted RSVIgmyc transgene in individual embryonic cells using fluorescence in situ hybridization (FISH). The cis-acting signals for RSVIgmyc imprinting are within RSVIgmyc itself. Thus, allele-specific differences in replication, if they indeed govern RSVIgmyc imprinting, should be found in RSVIgmyc sequences. We found that the parental alleles of RSVIgmyc, which exhibit differences in methylation, replicated at the same time. Synchronous replication was also seen in embryonic cells containing a modified version of RSVIgmyc that exhibited parental allele differences in both methylation and expression. These findings indicate that maintenance of expression and methylation differences between alleles does not require a difference in replication timing. The differences in replication timing of endogenous imprinted alleles detected by FISH might therefore reflect structural differences between the two alleles that could be a consequence of imprinting or, alternatively, could be unrelated to imprinting.

The undermethylated state of a CpG island region in igf2 transgenes is dependent on the H19 enhancers

CpG islands are GC-rich regions located in the promoter regions of housekeeping genes and many tissue-specific genes. While most CpG islands are normally unmethylated, island methylation can occur and is associated with silencing of the corresponding gene. Experiments with transgenic mice and DNA transfection in pluripotential embryonic cells have led to the conclusion that the information required for protecting the islands from methylation is contained within the CpG islands themselves and have identified Sp1 binding sites as an important element in establishing and/or maintaining the methylation-free state of CpG islands. To examine the generality of these observations, we analyzed the methylation of one of the mouse Igf2 CpG islands and its flanks in transgenic mice. We observed that the undermethylated state of this region is dependent on the presence of a separate cis-regulatory element, the H19 enhancers. These tissue-specific enhancers had a ubiquitous, non-tissue-specific effect on island region methylation. Structural alterations outside of the island and these enhancers also affected this region's methylation. These findings indicate that the methylation of some CpG island-containing regions is more sensitive than previously believed to the activity of distant cis-regulatory elements and to structural alterations in nonisland sequences in cis.

Myopia, intelligence, and the expanding human neocortex: behavioral influences and evolutionary implications

The first two parts of this monograph document that areas of the human neocortex heavily used to cope with a complex, language-driven society have been expanding rapidly and suggest strongly that this is linked with the huge upsurge that's occurred in myopia, and with the large gradual 20th-century increase in measured intelligence. Part III proposes mechanisms capable of supporting such rapid changes, without violating the basic precepts of Darwin's thinking. Part IV discusses the social and evolutionary ramifications of our apparent proclivity for rapid, progressive, adaptive neocortical change, and suggests areas for productive research.

cis-Acting signal for inheritance of imprinted DNA methylation patterns in the preimplantation mouse embryo

The inheritance of gametic methylation patterns is a critical event in the imprinting of genes. In the case of the imprinted RSVIgmyc transgene, the methylation pattern in the unfertilized egg is maintained by the early mouse embryo, whereas the sperm's methylation pattern is lost in the early embryo. To investigate the cis-acting requirements for this preimplantation stage of genomic imprinting, we examined the fate of different RSVIgmyc methylation patterns, preimposed on RSVIgmyc and introduced into the mouse zygote by pronuclear injection. RSVIgmyc methylation patterns with a low percentage of methylated CpG dinucleotides, generated by using bacterial cytosine methylases with four-base recognition sequences, were lost in the early embryo. In contrast, methylation was maintained when all CpG dinucleotides were methylated with the bacterial SssI (CpG) methylase. This singular maintenance of RSVIgmyc methylation preimposed with SssI methylase appears to be specific to the early, undifferentiated embryo; differentiated NIH 3T3 fibroblasts transfected with methylated versions of RSVIgmyc maintained all methylation patterns, independent of the level of preimposed methylation. The methylation pattern of the RSVIgmyc allele in adult founder transgenic mice that was produced by pronuclear injection of an SssI-methylated construct could not be distinguished from the maternal RSVIgmyc methylation pattern. Thus, a highly methylated allele in adult mice, normally generated by transmission of RSVIgmyc through the female germ line, was also produced in founder transgenic mice by bypassing gametogenesis and introducing a highly methylated RSVIgmyc into the mouse zygote. These results suggest that RSVIgmyc methylation itself is a cis-acting signal for the preimplantation maintenance of the oocyte's methylation pattern and, therefore, a cis-acting signal for RSVIgmyc imprinting. Furthermore, our inability to identify a sequence element within RSVIgmyc that was absolutely required for its imprinting suggests that the extent of RSVIgmyc methylation, rather than a particular pattern of methylation, is the principal feature of this imprinting signal.