Uterus hyperplasia and increased carcinogen-induced tumorigenesis in mice carrying a targeted mutation of the Chk2 phosphorylation site in Brca1

Brca1 Mouse Models: Functional Insights and Therapeutic Opportunities

Brca1 mouse models were first reported in the mid-1990's shortly after cloning the human gene. Since then, many mouse models with a range of mutations have been generated, some mimic patient mutations, others are designed to probe specific protein domains and functions. In this review, we discuss early and recent studies using engineered Brca1 mouse alleles, and their implications for understanding Brca1 protein function in the context of DNA repair, tumorigenesis, and anti-cancer therapeutics.

Genetically engineered mouse models for hereditary cancer syndromes

Advances in molecular diagnostics have led to improved diagnosis and molecular understanding of hereditary cancers in the clinic. Improving the management, treatment, and potential prevention of cancers in carriers of predisposing mutations requires preclinical experimental models that reflect the key pathogenic features of the specific syndrome associated with the mutations. Numerous genetically engineered mouse (GEM) models of hereditary cancer have been developed. In this review, we describe the models of Lynch syndrome and hereditary breast and ovarian cancer syndrome, the two most common hereditary cancer predisposition syndromes. We focus on Lynch syndrome models as illustrative of the potential for using mouse models to devise improved approaches to prevention of cancer in a high-risk population. GEM models are an invaluable tool for hereditary cancer models. Here, we review GEM models for some hereditary cancers and their potential use in cancer prevention studies.

Phosphorylation of BRCA1 by ATM upon double-strand breaks impacts ATM function in end-resection: A potential feedback loop

BRCA1 maintains genome stability by promoting homologous recombination (HR)-mediated DNA double-strand break (DSB) repair. Mutation of mouse BRCA1-S1152, corresponding to an ATM phosphorylation site in its human counterpart, resulted in increased genomic instability and tumor incidence. In this study, we report that BRCA1-S1152 is part of a feedback loop that sustains ATM activity. BRCA1-S1152A mutation impairs recruitment of the E3 ubiquitin ligase SKP2. This in turn attenuates NBS1-K63 ubiquitination by SKP2 at DSB, impairs sustained ATM activation, and ultimately leads to deficient end resection, the commitment step in the HR repair pathway. Auto-phosphorylation of human ATM at S1981 is known to be important for its kinase activation; we mutated the corresponding amino acid residue in mouse ATM (S1987A) to characterize potential roles of mouse ATM-S1987 in the BRCA1-SKP2-NBS1-ATM feedback loop. Unexpectedly, MEFs carrying the ATM-S1987A knockin mutation maintain damage-induced ATM kinase activation, suggesting a species-specific function of human ATM auto-phosphorylation.

Brca1 L63X /+ rat is a novel model of human BRCA1 deficiency displaying susceptibility to radiation‐induced mammary cancer

Women who are heterozygous for deleterious BRCA1 germline mutations harbor a high risk of hereditary breast cancer. Previous Brca1‐heterozygous animal models do not recapitulate the breast cancer phenotype, and thus all currently used knockout models adopt conditional, mammary‐specific homozygous Brca1 loss or addition of Trp53 deficiency. Herein, we report the creation and characterization of a novel Brca1 mutant rat model harboring the germline L63X mutation, which mimics a founder mutation in Japan, through CRISPR‐Cas9–based genome editing. Homozygotes (Brca1^L63X/L63X) were embryonic lethal, whereas heterozygotes (Brca1^L63X/+) showed apparently normal development. Without carcinogen exposure, heterozygotes developed mammary carcinoma at a comparable incidence rate with their wild‐type (WT) littermates during their lifetime. Intraperitoneal injection of 1‐methyl‐1‐nitrosourea (25 or 50 mg/kg) at 7 weeks of age induced mammary carcinogenesis at comparable levels among the heterozygotes and their littermates. After exposure to ionizing radiation (0.1–2 Gy) at 7 weeks of age, the heterozygotes, but not WT littermates, displayed dose‐dependent mammary carcinogenesis with 0.8 Gy⁻¹ excess in hazard ratio during their middle age; the relative susceptibility of the heterozygotes was more prominent when rats were irradiated at 3 weeks of age. The heterozygotes had tumors with a lower estrogen receptor α immunopositivity and no evidence of somatic mutations of the WT allele. The Brca1^L63X/+ rats thus offer the first single‐mutation, heterozygous model of BRCA1‐associated breast cancer, especially with exposure to a DNA break‐inducing carcinogen. This implies that such carcinogens are causative and a key to breast cancer prevention in individuals who carry high‐risk BRCA1 mutations.

Mouse Models for Deciphering the Impact of Homologous Recombination on Tumorigenesis

Homologous recombination (HR) is a fundamental evolutionarily conserved process that plays prime role(s) in genome stability maintenance through DNA repair and through the protection and resumption of arrested replication forks. Many HR genes are deregulated in cancer cells. Notably, the breast cancer genes BRCA1 and BRCA2, two important HR players, are the most frequently mutated genes in familial breast and ovarian cancer. Transgenic mice constitute powerful tools to unravel the intricate mechanisms controlling tumorigenesis in vivo. However, the genes central to HR are essential in mammals, and their knockout leads to early embryonic lethality in mice. Elaborated strategies have been developed to overcome this difficulty, enabling one to analyze the consequences of HR disruption in vivo. In this review, we first briefly present the molecular mechanisms of HR in mammalian cells to introduce each factor in the HR process. Then, we present the different mouse models of HR invalidation and the consequences of HR inactivation on tumorigenesis. Finally, we discuss the use of mouse models for the development of targeted cancer therapies as well as perspectives on the future potential for understanding the mechanisms of HR inactivation-driven tumorigenesis in vivo.

A heterozygous hypomorphic mutation of Fanca causes impaired follicle development and subfertility in female mice

Reduced fertility is a common clinical feature of the individuals with Fanconi anemia (FA), a rare autosomal recessive disorder due to deficiency in FA pathway during DNA repair. Our previous study reported that the heterozygous pathogenic variants in FANCA (Fanconi anemia complementation group A) induced premature ovarian insufficiency (POI). However, the genotype-phenotype correlation in POI caused by FANCA variants remains considerably uncertain. Herein, a heterozygous non-frameshift Fanca-mutated mouse strain (Fanca^+/hypo) carrying a 9-bp deletion (c.3581del9, p.QEA1194-1196del) was generated. The mutant mice exhibited slightly decreased Fanca protein level in ovaries, suggesting the non-frameshift deletion mutant is hypomorphic. Female fertility test showed decreased number of litters, litter sizes and prolonged litter interval time in the female Fanca^+/hypo mice compared to wild-type mice. Follicle counting revealed a consistent decreasing pattern of follicle numbers in Fanca^+/hypo females compared to that in wild-type mice with aging. Furthermore, embryonic fibroblasts of Fanca^+/hypo mice were hyper-responsive to Mitomycin C in vitro, demonstrating a partial loss of function of this hypomorphic Fanca mutant in DNA repair. Collectively, our experimental observations suggest that the hypomorphic Fanca allele is sufficient to reduce female fertility in mice, providing new insights into the genetic counseling of FANCA variants in subfertile women.

Molecular contribution of BRCA1 and BRCA2 to genome instability in breast cancer patients: review of radiosensitivity assays

BACKGROUND

DNA repair pathways, cell cycle arrest checkpoints, and cell death induction are present in cells to process DNA damage and prevent genomic instability caused by various extrinsic and intrinsic ionizing factors. Mutations in the genes involved in these pathways enhances the ionizing radiation sensitivity, reduces the individual's capacity to repair DNA damages, and subsequently increases susceptibility to tumorigenesis.

BODY

BRCA1 and BRCA2 are two highly penetrant genes involved in the inherited breast cancer and contribute to different DNA damage pathways and cell cycle and apoptosis cascades. Mutations in these genes have been associated with hypersensitivity and genetic instability as well as manifesting severe radiotherapy complications in breast cancer patients. The genomic instability and DNA repair capacity of breast cancer patients with BRCA1/2 mutations have been analyzed in different studies using a variety of assays, including micronucleus assay, comet assay, chromosomal assay, colony-forming assay, γ -H2AX and 53BP1 biomarkers, and fluorescence in situ hybridization. The majority of studies confirmed the enhanced spontaneous & radiation-induced radiosensitivity of breast cancer patients compared to healthy controls. Using G2 micronucleus assay and G2 chromosomal assay, most studies have reported the lymphocyte of healthy carriers with BRCA1 mutation are hypersensitive to invitro ionizing radiation compared to non-carriers without a history of breast cancer. However, it seems this approach is not likely to be useful to distinguish the BRCA carriers from non-carrier with familial history of breast cancer.

CONCLUSION

In overall, breast cancer patients are more radiosensitive compared to healthy control; however, inconsistent results exist about the ability of current radiosensitive techniques in screening BRCA1/2 carriers or those susceptible to radiotherapy complications. Therefore, developing further radiosensitivity assay is still warranted to evaluate the DNA repair capacity of individuals with BRCA1/2 mutations and serve as a predictive factor for increased risk of cancer mainly in the relatives of breast cancer patients. Moreover, it can provide more evidence about who is susceptible to manifest severe complication after radiotherapy.

BRCA1 and homologous recombination: implications from mouse embryonic development

As an important player in DNA damage response, BRCA1 maintains genomic stability and suppresses tumorigenesis by promoting DNA double-strand break (DSB) repair through homologous recombination (HR). Since the cloning of BRCA1 gene, many Brca1 mutant alleles have been generated in mice. Mice carrying homozygous Brca1 mutant alleles are embryonic lethal, suggesting that BRCA1's functions are important for embryonic development. Studies of embryonic development in Brca1 mutant mice not only reveal the physiological significance of BRCA1's known function in HR, but also lead to the discovery of BRCA1's new function in HR: regulation of DSB repair pathway choice.

BRCA1/P53: Two strengths in cancer chemoprevention

Increasing emphasis has been given to prevention as a feasible approach to reduce the cancer burden. However, for its clinical success, further advances are required to identify effective chemopreventive agents. This review affords a critical and up-to-date discussion of issues related to cancer prevention, including an in-depth knowledge on BRCA1 and p53 tumor suppressor proteins as key molecular players. Indeed, it compiles the most recent advances on the topic, highlighting the unique potential of BRCA1 and p53 germline mutations as molecular biomarkers for risk assessment and targets for chemoprevention. Relevant evidences are herein provided supporting the effectiveness of distinct pharmacological agents in cancer prevention, by targeting BRCA1 and p53. Moreover, the rationale for using germline mutant BRCA1- or p53-related cancer syndromes as model systems to investigate effective chemopreventive agents is also addressed. Altogether, this work provides an innovative conception about the dependence on p53 and BRCA1 co-inactivation in tumor formation and development, emphasizing the relationship between these two proteins as an encouraging direction for future personalized pharmacological interventions in cancer prevention.

Induced in vivo knockdown of the Brca1 gene in skeletal muscle results in skeletal muscle weakness

KEY POINTS

Breast cancer 1 early onset gene codes for the DNA repair enzyme, breast cancer type 1 susceptibility protein (BRCA1). The gene is prone to mutations that cause a loss of protein function. BRCA1/Brca1 has recently been found to regulate several cellular pathways beyond DNA repair and is expressed in skeletal muscle. Skeletal muscle specific knockout of Brca1 in mice caused a loss of muscle quality, identifiable by reductions in muscle force production and mitochondrial respiratory capacity. Loss of muscle quality was associated with a shift in muscle phenotype and an accumulation of mitochondrial DNA mutations. These results demonstrate that BRCA1 is necessary for skeletal muscle function and that increased mitochondrial DNA mutations may represent a potential underlying mechanism.

ABSTRACT

Recent evidence suggests that the breast cancer 1 early onset gene (BRCA1) influences numerous peripheral tissues, including skeletal muscle. The present study aimed to determine whether induced-loss of the breast cancer type 1 susceptibility protein (Brca1) alters skeletal muscle function. We induced genetic ablation of exon 11 in the Brca1 gene specifically in the skeletal muscle of adult mice to generate skeletal muscle-specific Brca1 homozygote knockout (Brca1KOsmi ) mice. Brca1KOsmi exhibited kyphosis and decreased maximal isometric force in limb muscles compared to age-matched wild-type mice. Brca1KOsmi skeletal muscle shifted toward an oxidative muscle fibre type and, in parallel, increased myofibre size and reduced capillary numbers. Unexpectedly, myofibre bundle mitochondrial respiration was reduced, whereas contraction-induced lactate production was elevated in Brca1KOsmi muscle. Brca1KOsmi mice accumulated mitochondrial DNA mutations and exhibited an altered mitochondrial morphology characterized by distorted and enlarged mitochondria, and these were more susceptible to swelling. In summary, skeletal muscle-specific loss of Brca1 leads to a myopathy and mitochondriopathy characterized by reductions in skeletal muscle quality and a consequent kyphosis. Given the substantial impact of BRCA1 mutations on cancer development risk in humans, a parallel loss of BRCA1 function in patient skeletal muscle cells would potentially result in implications for human health.

Cyclin B1 stability is increased by interaction with BRCA1, and its overexpression suppresses the progression of BRCA1-associated mammary tumors

Germline BRCA1 mutations predispose women to breast and ovarian cancer. BRCA1, a large protein with multiple functional domains, interacts with numerous proteins involved in many important biological processes and pathways. However, to date, the role of BRCA1 interactions at specific stages in the progression of mammary tumors, particularly in relation to cell cycle regulation, remains elusive. Here, we demonstrate that BRCA1 interacts with cyclin B1, a crucial cell cycle regulator, and that their interaction is modulated by DNA damage and cell cycle phase. In DNA-damaged mitotic cells, BRCA1 inhibits cytoplasmic transportation of cyclin B1, which prevents cyclin B1 degradation. Moreover, restoration of cyclin B1 in BRCA1-deficient cells reduced cell survival in association with induction of apoptosis. We further demonstrate that treatment of Brca1-mutant mammary tumors with vinblastine, which induces cyclin B1, significantly reduced tumor progression. In addition, a correlation analysis of vinblastine responses and gene expression profiles in tumors at baseline revealed 113 genes that were differentially expressed between tumors that did and did not respond to vinblastine treatment. Further analyses of protein–protein interaction networks revealed gene clusters related to vinblastine resistance, including nucleotide excision repair, epigenetic regulation, and the messenger RNA surveillance pathway. These findings enhance our understanding of how loss of BRCA1 disrupts mitosis regulation through dysregulation of cyclin B1 and provide evidence suggesting that targeting cyclin B1 may be useful in BRCA1-associated breast cancer therapy.

The role of disrupted activity of the protein BRCA1 in the progression of breast cancer has been clarified, suggesting that targeting another protein with which it interacts could offer a new route to treatment. Mutations of BRCA1 are known to predispose women to both breast and ovarian cancers. Researchers led by Sang Soo Kim (National Cancer Center, South Korea) and Rui-Hong Wang (University of Macau, China) studied the interaction with a protein called cyclin B1 that controls cell growth and division. They found that, in mitosis, BRCA1 interacts with and stabilizes cyclin B1, explaining why the loss of BRCA1 can disrupt the G2/M cell cycle control and accumulate the genetic instability. Treatment of Brca1-mutant mammary tumors with vinblastine, which alters cyclin B1 level, significantly reduced tumor progression with reduction of survival and induction of apoptosis.

Inhibiting homologous recombination decreases extrachromosomal amplification but has no effect on intrachromosomal amplification in methotrexate-resistant colon cancer cells

Gene amplification, which involves the two major topographical structures double minutes (DMs) and homegeneously stained region (HSR), is a common mechanism of treatment resistance in cancer and is initiated by DNA double‐strand breaks. NHEJ, one of DSB repair pathways, is involved in gene amplification as we demonstrated previously. However, the involvement of homologous recombination, another DSB repair pathway, in gene amplification remains to be explored. To better understand the association between HR and gene amplification, we detected HR activity in DM‐ and HSR‐containing MTX‐resistant HT‐29 colon cancer cells. In DM‐containing MTX‐resistant cells, we found increased homologous recombination activity compared with that in MTX‐sensitive cells. Therefore, we suppressed HR activity by silencing BRCA1, the key player in the HR pathway. The attenuation of HR activity decreased the numbers of DMs and DM‐form amplified gene copies and increased the exclusion of micronuclei and nuclear buds that contained DM‐form amplification; these changes were accompanied by cell cycle acceleration and increased MTX sensitivity. In contrast, BRCA1 silencing did not influence the number of amplified genes and MTX sensitivity in HSR‐containing MTX‐resistant cells. In conclusion, our results suggest that the HR pathway plays different roles in extrachromosomal and intrachromosomal gene amplification and may be a new target to improve chemotherapeutic outcome by decreasing extrachromosomal amplification in cancer.

What's new?

Double‐strand DNA breaks (DSBs) initiate gene amplification, a phenomenon associated with therapeutic resistance in cancer that involves two topographical structures, double minutes (DMs) and homogeneously staining regions (HSRs). Whether DSB repair pathways, particularly homologous recombination (HR), also influence gene amplification is unknown. Here, in methotrexate‐resistant colon cancer cells, HR inhibition effectively reduced gene amplification, specifically the DM‐form, by blocking DM formation and promoting DM exclusion via micronuclei. HR inhibition had no influence on the HSR‐form of gene amplification. Loss of gene amplification by HR inhibition, through partial reversal of methotrexate resistance, may contribute to improved chemotherapeutic outcome.

Functions and therapeutic potential of protein phosphatase 1: Insights from mouse genetics

Protein phosphatase 1 (PP1) catalyzes more than half of all phosphoserine/threonine dephosphorylation reactions in mammalian cells. In vivo PP1 does not exist as a free catalytic subunit but is always associated with at least one regulatory PP1-interacting protein (PIP) to generate a large set of distinct holoenzymes. Each PP1 complex controls the dephosphorylation of only a small subset of PP1 substrates. We screened the literature for genetically engineered mouse models and identified models for all PP1 isoforms and 104 PIPs. PP1 itself and at least 49 PIPs were connected to human disease-associated phenotypes. Additionally, phenotypes related to 17 PIPs were clearly linked to altered PP1 function, while such information was lacking for 32 other PIPs. We propose structural reverse genetics, which combines structural characterization of proteins with mouse genetics, to identify new PP1-related therapeutic targets. The available mouse models confirm the pleiotropic action of PP1 in health and diseases.

•

Four protein phosphatases 1 (PP1) isoforms and >200 PP1-interacting proteins (PIPs)

•

Genetically engineered mice of 49 PIPs display human disease-associated phenotypes.

•

The use of structural reverse genetics to identify the PP1-dependent phenotypes

•

Various interaction sites in PP1:PIP complexes suit for therapeutic targeting.

Damage-induced BRCA1 phosphorylation by Chk2 contributes to the timing of end resection

The BRCA1 tumor suppressor plays an important role in homologous recombination (HR)-mediated DNA double-strand-break (DSB) repair. BRCA1 is phosphorylated by Chk2 kinase upon γ-irradiation, but the role of Chk2 phosphorylation is not understood. Here, we report that abrogation of Chk2 phosphorylation on BRCA1 delays end resection and the dispersion of BRCA1 from DSBs but does not affect the assembly of Mre11/Rad50/NBS1 (MRN) and CtIP at DSBs. Moreover, we show that BRCA1 is ubiquitinated by SCF(Skp2) and that abrogation of Chk2 phosphorylation impairs its ubiquitination. Our study suggests that BRCA1 is more than a scaffold protein to assemble HR repair proteins at DSBs, but that Chk2 phosphorylation of BRCA1 also serves as a built-in clock for HR repair of DSBs. BRCA1 is known to inhibit Mre11 nuclease activity. SCF(Skp2) activity appears at late G1 and peaks at S/G2, and is known to ubiquitinate phosphodegron motifs. The removal of BRCA1 from DSBs by SCF(Skp2)-mediated degradation terminates BRCA1-mediated inhibition of Mre11 nuclease activity, allowing for end resection and restricting the initiation of HR to the S/G2 phases of the cell cycle.

BRCA1 and p53 tumor suppressor molecules in Alzheimer's disease

Tumor suppressor molecules play a pivotal role in regulating DNA repair, cell proliferation, and cell death, which are also important processes in the pathogenesis of Alzheimer’s disease. Alzheimer’s disease is the most common neurodegenerative disorder, however, the precise molecular events that control the death of neuronal cells are unclear. Recently, a fundamental role for tumor suppressor molecules in regulating neurons in Alzheimer’s disease was highlighted. Generally, onset of neurodegenerative diseases including Alzheimer’s disease may be delayed with use of dietary neuro-protective agents against oxidative stresses. Studies suggest that dietary antioxidants are also beneficial for brain health in reducing disease-risk and in slowing down disease-progression. We summarize research advances in dietary regulation for the treatment of Alzheimer’s disease with a focus on its modulatory roles in BRCA1 and p53 tumor suppressor expression, in support of further therapeutic research in this field.

Mouse models of BRCA1 and their application to breast cancer research

Germline mutations of human breast cancer-associated gene 1 (BRCA1) predispose women to breast and ovarian cancers. In mice, over 20 distinct mutations, including null, hypomorphic, isoform, conditional, and point mutations, have been created to study functions of Brca1 in mammary development and tumorigenesis. Analyses using these mutant mice have yielded an enormous amount of information that greatly facilitates our understanding of the gender- and tissue-specific tumor suppressor functions of BRCA1, as well as enriches our insights into applying these preclinical models of disease to breast cancer research. Here, we review features of these mutant mice and their applications to cancer prevention and therapeutic treatment.

The role of BRCA1 in homologous recombination repair in response to replication stress: significance in tumorigenesis and cancer therapy

Germ line mutations in breast cancer gene 1 (BRCA1) predispose women to breast and ovarian cancers. Although BRCA1 is involved in many important biological processes, the function of BRCA1 in homologous recombination (HR) mediated repair is considered one of the major mechanisms contributing to its tumor suppression activity, and the cause of hypersensitivity to poly(ADP-ribose) polymerase (PARP) inhibitors when BRCA1 is defective. Mounting evidence suggests that the mechanism of repairing DNA double strand breaks (DSBs) by HR is different than the mechanism operating when DNA replication is blocked. Although BRCA1 has been recognized as a central component in HR, the precise role of BRCA1 in HR, particularly under replication stress, has remained largely unknown. Given the fact that DNA lesions caused by replication blockages are the primary substrates for HR in mitotic cells, functional analysis of BRCA1 in HR repair in the context of replication stress should benefit our understanding of the molecular mechanisms underlying tumorigenesis associated with BRCA1 deficiencies, as well as the development of therapeutic approaches for cancer patients carrying BRCA1 mutations or reduced BRCA1 expression. This review focuses on the current advances in this setting and also discusses the significance in tumorigenesis and cancer therapy.

Role of the checkpoint clamp in DNA damage response

DNA damage occurs during DNA replication, spontaneous chemical reactions, and assaults by external or metabolism-derived agents. Therefore, all living cells must constantly contend with DNA damage. Cells protect themselves from these genotoxic stresses by activating the DNA damage checkpoint and DNA repair pathways. Coordination of these pathways requires tight regulation in order to prevent genomic instability. The checkpoint clamp complex consists of Rad9, Rad1 and Hus1 proteins, and is often called the 9-1-1 complex. This PCNA (proliferating cell nuclear antigen)-like donut-shaped protein complex is a checkpoint sensor protein that is recruited to DNA damage sites during the early stage of the response, and is required for checkpoint activation. As PCNA is required for multiple pathways of DNA metabolism, the checkpoint clamp has also been implicated in direct roles in DNA repair, as well as in coordination of the pathways. Here we discuss roles of the checkpoint clamp in DNA damage response (DDR).

BRCA1 and BRCA2: different roles in a common pathway of genome protection

The proteins encoded by the two major breast cancer susceptibility genes, BRCA1 and BRCA2, work in a common pathway of genome protection. However, the two proteins work at different stages in the DNA damage response (DDR) and in DNA repair. BRCA1 is a pleiotropic DDR protein that functions in both checkpoint activation and DNA repair, whereas BRCA2 is a mediator of the core mechanism of homologous recombination. The links between the two proteins are not well understood, but they must exist to explain the marked similarity of human cancer susceptibility that arises with germline mutations in these genes. As discussed here, the proteins work in concert to protect the genome from double-strand DNA damage during DNA replication.

Wild-type BRCA1, but not mutated BRCA1, regulates the expression of the nuclear form of beta-catenin

BRCA1 is an essential caretaker protein in the surveillance of DNA damage, is mutated in approximately 50% of all hereditary breast cancer cases, and its expression is frequently decreased in sporadic breast cancer. beta-Catenin is a multifunctional protein that forms adhesion complex with E-cadherins, alpha-catenin, and actin, and plays a central role in Wnt signaling through its nuclear translocation and activation of beta-catenin-responsive genes. Although significant progress has been made in understanding the Wnt/beta-catenin and BRCA1 signaling cascades, it is not known whether there is a link between beta-catenin and BRCA1. We observed that the expression of the active nuclear form of beta-catenin (also known as ABC, Ser37/Thr41-nonphosphorylated beta-catenin, dephosphorylated beta-catenin) was lower or absent in the nucleus in most BRCA1 familial breast cancer tissues (17 cases) compared with sporadic breast cancer (14 samples) and normal breast tissues. Wild-type-BRCA1, but not mutated BRCA1, interacted with beta-catenin and increased the levels of beta-catenin protein expression in vitro. Furthermore, H(2)O(2) induced the interaction of the nuclear form of beta-catenin with BRCA1. The active form of beta-catenin protein was downregulated upon exposure to H(2)O(2) in the nucleus of BRCA1-deficient HCC1937 breast cancer cells, whereas reconstitution of WT-BRCA1 in HCC1937 cells inhibited this downregulation. This study provides evidence of a novel interaction between BRCA1 and beta-catenin, and that loss of BRCA1 leads to impaired expression of the nuclear form of beta-catenin, which may contribute to the pathogenesis of breast cancer.

BRCA1 deficient mouse models to study pathogenesis and therapy of triple negative breast cancer

Genetically engineered mice along with allograft and xenograft models can be used to effectively model triple negative breast cancer both for studies of pathophysiology as well as preclinical prevention and therapeutic drug studies. In this review eight distinct genetically engineered mouse models of BRCA1 deficiency are discussed in relationship to the generation of triple negative mammary cancer. Allograft models derived from some of these genetically engineered mice are considered and xenograft models derived from breast cancers that developed from BRCA1 mutation are presented. Examples of the use of genetically engineered, allograft and xenografts models for preventive and therapeutic studies are presented.

Impaired skin and mammary gland development and increased gamma-irradiation-induced tumorigenesis in mice carrying a mutation of S1152-ATM phosphorylation site in Brca1

The tumor suppressor BRCA1 interacts with many proteins and undergoes multiple modifications on DNA damage. ATM, a key molecule of the DNA damage response, phosphorylates S1189 of BRCA1 after gamma-irradiation. S1189 of BRCA1 is known as a unique ATM phosphorylation site in BRCA1 exon 11. To study the functions of ATM-dependent phosphorylation of BRCA1-S1189, we generated a mouse model carrying a mutation of S1152A (S1152 in mouse Brca1 corresponds to S1189 in human BRCA1) by gene targeting. Brca1(S1152A/S1152A) mice were born at the expected ratio, unlike that seen in previous studies of Brca1-null mice. However, 36% of Brca1(S1152A/S1152A) mice exhibited aging-like phenotypes including growth retardation, skin abnormalities, and delay of the mammary gland morphogenesis, with an increase in apoptosis. Mutant mice were hypersensitive to high doses of gamma-irradiation, displaying shortened life span and reduction in intestinal villus size, associated with increased apoptosis. Aging-unaffected 18-month-old Brca1(S1152A/S1152A) female mice also showed mammary gland abnormalities with increased levels of cyclin D1 and phospho-ER-alpha, such as Brca1-Delta11 mutation. On low-dose gamma-irradiation, they suffered a marked increase in tumor formation with an abnormal coat pattern. Furthermore, Brca1(S1152A/S1152A) embryonic fibroblasts failed to accumulate p53 on gamma-irradiation with delayed phosphorylation of p53-S23. These observations indicate that ATM-mediated phosphorylation of S1189 is required for BRCA1 functions in the modulation of DNA damage response and in the suppression of tumor formation by regulating p53 and apoptosis.

Taking the time to make important decisions: the checkpoint effector kinases Chk1 and Chk2 and the DNA damage response

The cellular DNA damage response (DDR) is activated by many types of DNA lesions. Upon recognition of DNA damage by sensor proteins, an intricate signal transduction network is activated to coordinate diverse cellular outcomes that promote genome integrity. Key components of the DDR in mammalian cells are the checkpoint effector kinases Chk1 and Chk2 (referred to henceforth as the effector kinases; orthologous to spChk1 and spCds1 in the fission yeast S. pombe and scChk1 and scRad53 in the budding yeast S. cerevisiae). These evolutionarily conserved and structurally divergent kinases phosphorylate numerous substrates to regulate the DDR. This review will focus on recent advances in our understanding of the structure, regulation, and functions of the effector kinases in the DDR, as well as their potential roles in human disease.

Genetic and functional analysis of CHEK2 (CHK2) variants in multiethnic cohorts

The CHEK2-1100delC mutation is recurrent in the population and is a moderate risk factor for breast cancer. To identify additional CHEK2 mutations potentially contributing to breast cancer susceptibility, we sequenced 248 cases with early-onset disease; functionally characterized new variants and conducted a population-based case-control analysis to evaluate their contribution to breast cancer risk. We identified 1 additional null mutation and 5 missense variants in the germline of cancer patients. In vitro, the CHEK2-H143Y variant resulted in gross protein destabilization, while others had variable suppression of in vitro kinase activity using BRCA1 as a substrate. The germline CHEK2-1100delC mutation was present among 8/1,646 (0.5%) sporadic, 2/400 (0.5%) early-onset and 3/302 (1%) familial breast cancer cases, but undetectable amongst 2,105 multiethnic controls, including 633 from the US. CHEK2-positive breast cancer families also carried a deleterious BRCA1 mutation. 1100delC appears to be the only recurrent CHEK2 mutation associated with a potentially significant contribution to breast cancer risk in the general population. Another recurrent mutation with attenuated in vitro function, CHEK2-P85L, is not associated with increased breast cancer susceptibility, but exhibits a striking difference in frequency across populations with different ancestral histories. These observations illustrate the importance of genotyping ethnically diverse groups when assessing the impact of low-penetrance susceptibility alleles on population risk. Our findings highlight the notion that clinical testing for rare missense mutations within CHEK2 may have limited value in predicting breast cancer risk, but that testing for the 1100delC variant may be valuable in phenotypically- and geographically-selected populations.

Haploinsufficiency of Parp1 accelerates Brca1-associated centrosome amplification, telomere shortening, genetic instability, apoptosis, and embryonic lethality

The breast tumor associated gene-1 (BRCA1) and poly(ADP-ribose) polymerase-1 (PARP1) are both involved in DNA-damage response and DNA-damage repair. Recent investigations have suggested that inhibition of PARP1 represents a promising chemopreventive/therapeutic approach for specifically treating BRCA1- and BRCA2-associated breast cancer. However, studies in mouse models reveal that Parp1-null mutation results in genetic instability and mammary tumor formation, casting significant doubt on the safety of PARP1 inhibition as a therapy for the breast cancer. To study the genetic interactions between Brca1 and Parp1, we interbred mice carrying a heterozygous deletion of full-length Brca1 (Brca1(+/Delta11)) with Parp1-null mice. We show that Brca1(Delta11/Delta11);Parp1(-/-) embryos die before embryonic (E) day 6.5, whereas Brca1(Delta11/Delta11) embryos die after E12.5, indicating that absence of Parp1 dramatically accelerates lethality caused by Brca1 deficiency. Surprisingly, haploinsufficiency of Parp1 in Brca1(Delta11/Delta11) embryos induces a severe chromosome aberrations, centrosome amplification, and telomere dysfunction, leading to apoptosis and accelerated embryonic lethality. Notably, telomere shortening in Brca1(Delta11/Delta11);Parp1(+/-) MEFs was correlated with decreased expression of Ku70, which plays an important role in telomere maintenance. Thus, haploid loss of Parp1 is sufficient to induce lethality of Brca1-deficient cells, suggesting that partial inhibition of PARP1 may represent a practical chemopreventive/therapeutic approach for BRCA1-associated breast cancer.

Mouse models of BRCA1 and BRCA2 deficiency: past lessons, current understanding and future prospects

Germline mutations in BRCA1 and BRCA2 are responsible for a large proportion of hereditary breast and ovarian cancers. Soon after the identification of both genes in the mid-1990s, investigators set out to develop mouse models for the associated disease. Whereas conventional Brca1 and Brca2 mouse mutants did not reveal a strong phenotype in a heterozygous setting, most homozygous mutations caused embryonic lethality. Consequently, development of mouse models for BRCA-associated tumorigenesis required the generation of tissue-specific conditional knockout animals. In this review, we give an overview of the conventional and the conditional mouse models of BRCA1 and BRCA2 deficiency generated over the last decade, as well as the contribution of these models to our understanding of the biological and molecular functions of BRCA1 and BRCA2. The most advanced mouse models for BRCA1- and BRCA2-associated tumorigenesis mimic human disease to the extent that they can be used in studies addressing clinically relevant questions. These models will help to resolve yet unanswered questions and to translate our increasing knowledge of BRCA1 and BRCA2 biology into clinical practice.

Hyperplasia and spontaneous tumor development in the gynecologic system in mice lacking the BRCA1-Delta11 isoform

Alternative splicing in the BRCA1 locus generates multiple protein products including BRCA1-Delta11, which is identical to the BRCA1 full-length isoform (BRCA1-FL) except for the absence of exon 11. Mutation analysis using gene targeting to create null mutations or disrupt BRCA-FL has provided much of our understanding of BRCA1 functions; however, targeted mutation of specific short forms of BRCA1 has not been reported. To understand the physiologic functions of BRCA1-Delta11, we used a knock-in approach that blocks alternative splicing between exons 10 and 12 to prevent the formation of this form of BRCA1. We showed that homozygous mutant mice (Brca1(FL/FL)) were born at a Mendelian ratio without obvious developmental defects. However, the majority of Brca1(FL/FL) female mice showed mammary gland abnormalities and uterine hyperplasia after one year of age with spontaneous tumor formation. Cultured Brca1(FL/FL) cells exhibited abnormal centrosome amplification and reduction of G(1) population that was accompanied by accumulation of cyclin E and cyclin A. Accumulation of cyclin E was also found in epithelial layers of dilated ducts and hyperproliferative lobular regions in the mammary glands of Brca1(FL/FL) mice. These observations provide evidence that BRCA1 splicing variants are involved in BRCA1 functions in modulating G(1)/S transition, centrosome duplication, and repressing tumor formation.

PARP-1 inhibitors: are they the long-sought genetically specific drugs for BRCA1/2-associated breast cancers?

Recent studies demonstrated that PARP-1 [poly(ADP-ribose) polymerase-1] inhibitors kill breast cancer associated gene-1 and -2 (BRCA1/2) deficient cells with extremely high efficiency while BRCA+/- and BRCA+/+ cells are relatively non-responsive to the treatment. It was therefore proposed that PARP-1 inhibitors might be the long-sought genetically specific drugs that are both safe and effective for treating BRCA1/2-associated breast cancers. However, a report published in a recent issue of the International Journal of Biological Sciences revealed that PARP-1 inhibitors, although able to kill naïve BRCA1 mutant cells with high specificity both in vitro and in vivo, exhibit minimal specificity in inhibiting the growth of mouse mammary tumor cells irrespective of their BRCA1 status in allograft nude mice. Non-specific inhibition in human BRCA1+/+, BRCA1+/-, and BRCA1-/- breast cancer cells by PARP-1 inhibitors was also observed. Additional mutations occurring during cancer progression may be a culprit, although the exact cause for the resistance of BRCA1-/- breast cancer cells to PARP-1 inhibitors remains elusive. These findings suggest that PARP inhibition may serve as an approach for the prevention of BRCA related breast cancer and may be useful in combination with other chemotherapeutic agents in the treatment of breast cancer.

BRCA1--a good predictive marker of drug sensitivity in breast cancer treatment?

There are currently only two predictive markers of response to chemotherapy for breast cancer in routine clinical use, namely the Estrogen receptor-alpha and the HER2 receptor. The breast and ovarian cancer susceptibility gene BRCA1 is an important genetic factor in hereditary breast and ovarian cancer and there is increasing evidence of an important role for BRCA1 in the sporadic forms of both cancer types. Our group and numerous others have shown in both preclinical and clinical studies that BRCA1 is an important determinant of chemotherapy responses in breast cancer. In this review we will outline the current understanding of the role of BRCA1 as a determinant of response to DNA damaging and microtubule damaging chemotherapy. We will then discuss how the known functions of this multifaceted protein may provide mechanistic explanations for its role in chemotherapy responses.

Mammary tumorigenesis following transgenic expression of a dominant negative CHK2 mutant

A truncating allele of the cell cycle checkpoint kinase CHK2 is present in 1% of the population, conferring a moderate increase in breast cancer risk, and inactivation of chk2 enhances mammary tumorigenesis in mice with targeted inactivation of brca1. We used the mouse mammary tumor virus (MMTV) promoter to target expression of a kinase-dead CHK2 allele (D347A). Mammary tumors, of predominantly micropapillary histology, developed in 40% of MMTV-CHK2-D347A transgenic mice with an average latency of 20 months. Tumors metastasized to lung and spleen; tumor-derived cell lines were frequently aneuploid and showed suppression of irradiation-induced p53 function. Primary hematopoietic malignancies were also observed in the spleen, another site of MMTV expression. The increased rate of tumor formation in MMTV-CHK2-D347A mice, compared with the relatively low incidence in chk2-null mice, provides a model to study modifiers of CHK2-dependent transformation.

BRCA1: cell cycle checkpoint, genetic instability, DNA damage response and cancer evolution

Germline mutations of the breast cancer associated gene 1 (BRCA1) predispose women to breast and ovarian cancers. BRCA1 is a large protein with multiple functional domains and interacts with numerous proteins that are involved in many important biological processes/pathways. Mounting evidence indicates that BRCA1 is involved in all phases of the cell cycle and regulates orderly events during cell cycle progression. BRCA1 deficiency, consequently causes abnormalities in the S-phase checkpoint, the G(2)/M checkpoint, the spindle checkpoint and centrosome duplication. The genetic instability caused by BRCA1 deficiency, however, also triggers cellular responses to DNA damage that blocks cell proliferation and induces apoptosis. Thus BRCA1 mutant cells cannot develop further into full-grown tumors unless this cellular defense is broken. Functional analysis of BRCA1 in cell cycle checkpoints, genome integrity, DNA damage response (DDR) and tumor evolution should benefit our understanding of the mechanisms underlying BRCA1 associated tumorigenesis, as well as the development of therapeutic approaches for this lethal disease.

BACH1 is a DNA repair protein supporting BRCA1 damage response

The link between defects in BRCA1 and breast cancer development may be best understood by deciphering the role of associated proteins. BRCA1 associated C-terminal helicase (BACH1) interacts directly with the BRCA1 C-terminal BRCT repeats, which are important for BRCA1 DNA repair and are mutated in the majority of BRCA1 familial cancers. Thus, BACH1 is a likely candidate for mediating BRCA1 DNA repair and tumor suppression functions. Although previous evidence using overexpression of a dominant negative BACH1 has suggested that BACH1 is involved in BRCA1-DNA repair function, our results using BACH1 deficient cells provide direct evidence for involvement of BACH1 in DNA repair as well as for localizing BRCA1. Following DNA damage BACH1 is modified by phosphorylation, displays a BRCA1-like nuclear foci pattern and colocalizes with gamma-H2AX. Given that the BACH1/BRCA1 complex is unaltered by DNA damage and the intensity of BRCA1 foci is diminished in BACH1 deficient cells, BACH1 may serve to not only facilitate DNA repair, but also maintain BRCA1 in DNA damage foci.

Multifactorial contributions to an acute DNA damage response by BRCA1/BARD1-containing complexes

The BRCA1 gene product and its stoichiometric binding partner, BARD1, play a vital role in the cellular response to DNA damage. However, how they acquire specific biochemical functions after DNA damage is poorly understood. Following exposure to genotoxic stress, DNA damage-specific interactions were observed between BRCA1/BARD1 and the DNA damage-response proteins, TopBP1 and Mre11/Rad50/NBS1. Two distinct DNA damage-dependent super complexes emerged; their activation was dependent, in part, on the actions of specific checkpoint kinases, and each super complex contributed to a distinctive aspect of the DNA damage response. The results support a new, multifactorial model that describes how genotoxic stress enables BRCA1 to execute a diverse set of DNA damage-response functions.