Recombination hot spot in the human beta-globin gene cluster: meiotic recombination of human DNA fragments in Saccharomyces cerevisiae

Fission yeast hotspot sequence motifs are also active in budding yeast

In most organisms, including humans, meiotic recombination occurs preferentially at a limited number of sites in the genome known as hotspots. There has been substantial progress recently in elucidating the factors determining the location of meiotic recombination hotspots, and it is becoming clear that simple sequence motifs play a significant role. In S. pombe, there are at least five unique sequence motifs that have been shown to produce hotspots of recombination, and it is likely that there are more. In S. cerevisiae, simple sequence motifs have also been shown to produce hotspots or show significant correlations with hotspots. Some of the hotspot motifs in both yeasts are known or suspected to bind transcription factors (TFs), which are required for the activity of those hotspots. Here we show that four of the five hotspot motifs identified in S. pombe also create hotspots in the distantly related budding yeast S. cerevisiae. For one of these hotspots, M26 (also called CRE), we identify TFs, Cst6 and Sko1, that activate and inhibit the hotspot, respectively. In addition, two of the hotspot motifs show significant correlations with naturally occurring hotspots. The conservation of these hotspots between the distantly related fission and budding yeasts suggests that these sequence motifs, and others yet to be discovered, may function widely as hotspots in many diverse organisms.

Interaction of genetic and environmental factors in Saccharomyces cerevisiae meiosis: the devil is in the details

One of the most important principles of scientific endeavour is that the results be reproducible from lab to lab. Although research groups rarely redo the published experiments of their colleagues, research plans almost always rely on the work of someone else. The assumption is that if the same experiment were repeated in another lab, results would be so similar that the same interpretation would be favoured. This notion allows one researcher to compare his/her own results to earlier work from other labs. An essential prerequisite for this is that the experiments are done in identical conditions and therefore the methodology must be clearly stated. While this may be scientific common sense, adherence is difficult because "standard" methods vary from one laboratory to another in subtle ways that are often not reported. More importantly, for many years the field ofyeast meiotic recombination considered typical differences to be innocuous. This chapter will highlight the documented environmental and genetic variables that are known to influence meiotic recombination in Saccharomyces cerevisiae. Other potential methodological sources of variation in meiotic experiments are also discussed. A careful assessment of the effects of these variables, has led to insights into our understanding of the control of recombination and meiosis.

Recombination Breakpoints in the Human β-Globin Gene Cluster

The human β-globin gene complex spans a region of 70 kb and contains numerous sequence variants. These variant sites form a 5′ cluster (5′ β-haplotype) and a 3′ cluster (3′ β-haplotype) with strong linkage disequilibrium among the sites within each cluster, but not between the two clusters. The 9-kb region between the 5′ and 3′ clusters has been estimated to have rates of recombination that are 3 to 30 times normal, and the region has therefore been proposed as a ‘hotspot’ of recombination. We describe three families with evidence of meiotic recombination within this ‘hotspot’ of the β-globin gene cluster and in which the cross-over breakpoints have been defined at the sequence level. In one family, the recombination has occurred in the maternal chromosome within a region of 361 bp between positions −911 and −550 5′ to the β-globin gene. In the other two families, the recombination has occurred in the paternal chromosome within a region of approximately 1,100 bp between positions −542 and +568 relative to the β-globin gene cap site. Both regions occur within the 2-kb region of replication initiation (IR) in the β-globin gene domain with no overlap. The IR region contains a consensus sequence for a protein (Pur), which binds preferentially to single-stranded DNA, a role implicated in recombination events.

Recombination Breakpoints in the Human β-Globin Gene Cluster

The human β-globin gene complex spans a region of 70 kb and contains numerous sequence variants. These variant sites form a 5′ cluster (5′ β-haplotype) and a 3′ cluster (3′ β-haplotype) with strong linkage disequilibrium among the sites within each cluster, but not between the two clusters. The 9-kb region between the 5′ and 3′ clusters has been estimated to have rates of recombination that are 3 to 30 times normal, and the region has therefore been proposed as a ‘hotspot’ of recombination. We describe three families with evidence of meiotic recombination within this ‘hotspot’ of the β-globin gene cluster and in which the cross-over breakpoints have been defined at the sequence level. In one family, the recombination has occurred in the maternal chromosome within a region of 361 bp between positions −911 and −550 5′ to the β-globin gene. In the other two families, the recombination has occurred in the paternal chromosome within a region of approximately 1,100 bp between positions −542 and +568 relative to the β-globin gene cap site. Both regions occur within the 2-kb region of replication initiation (IR) in the β-globin gene domain with no overlap. The IR region contains a consensus sequence for a protein (Pur), which binds preferentially to single-stranded DNA, a role implicated in recombination events.

The population genetics of the haemoglobinopathies

The haemoglobinopathies are the commonest single-gene disorders known, almost certainly because of the protection they provide against malaria, as attested by a number of observations. The geographical distributions of malaria and haemoglobinopathies largely overlap, and microepidemiological surveys confirm the close relationship between them. For two of the commonest disorders, haemoglobin S and alpha(+)-thalassaemia, there is also good clinical evidence for protection against malaria morbidity. However, not all the evidence appears to support this view. In some parts of the world malaria and haemoglobinopathies are not, and never have been, coexistent. It is also difficult to explain why the majority of haemoglobinopathies appear to be recent mutations and are regionally specific. Here we argue that these apparent inconsistencies in the malaria hypothesis are the result of processes such as genetic drift and migration and of demographic changes that have occurred during the past 10,000 years. When these factors are taken into account, selection by malaria remains the force responsible for the prevalence of the haemoglobinopathies.

Double-strand breaks on YACs during yeast meiosis may reflect meiotic recombination in the human genome

Meiotic recombination in the yeast Saccharomyces cerevisiae is initiated at double-strand breaks (DSBs), which occur preferentially at specific locations. Genetically mapped regions of elevated meiotic recombination ('hotspots') coincide with meiotic DSB sites, which can be identified on chromosome blots of meiotic DNA (refs 4,5; S.K. et al., manuscript submitted). The morphology of yeast artificial chromosomes (YACs) containing human DNA during the pachytene stage of meiosis resembles that of native yeast chromosomes. Homologous YAC pairs segregate faithfully and recombine at the high rates characteristic of S. cerevisiae (vs. approximately 0.4 cM/kb in S. cerevisiae versus approximately 10-3 cM/kb in humans). We have examined a variety of YACs carrying human DNA inserts for double-strand breakage during yeast meiosis. Each YAC has a characteristic set of meiotic DSB sites, as do yeast chromosomes (S.K. et al., manuscript submitted). We show that the positions of the DSB sites in the YACs depend on the human-derived DNA in the clones. The degree of double-strand breakage in yeast meiosis of the YACs in our study appears to reflect the degree of meiotic recombination in humans.

Sickle cell gene in Central India: Kinship and geography

A wide range of variation (0.00-0.14) in the frequencies of the HbS allele has been observed among 16 tribes of Orissa, Madhya Pradesh, and Maharashtra. A significant excess of SS individuals over that expected under Hardy-Weinberg equilibrium was observed among 6 of 16 populations. These populations belong to three linguistic groups and have history of heterogeneous origins. A geographical cline of increase in HbS allele frequency from east to west is apparent. This pattern can largely be explained by differential migration. The kinship coefficient (r_ij ) and paired F_ST do not show any significant correleation up to 250 km of geographical distance but beyond this distance they show an inverse releationship with increasing geographic distance. Hemoglobin levels between individuals with β^S allele and with normal HbA individuals do not differ in these. © 1995 Wiley-Liss, Inc.

Linkage disequilibrium predicts physical distance in the adenomatous polyposis coli region

To test the reliability of linkage-disequilibrium analysis for gene mapping, we compared physical distance and linkage disequilibrium among seven polymorphisms in the adenomatous polyposis coli (APC) region on chromosome 5. Three of them lie within the APC gene, and two lie within the nearby MCC (mutated in colon cancer) gene. One polymorphism lies between the two genes, and one is likely to be 5' of MCC. Five of these polymorphisms are newly reported. All polymorphisms were typed in the CEPH kindreds, yielding 179-205 unrelated two-locus haplotypes. Linkage disequilibrium between each pair of polymorphisms is highly correlated with physical distance in this 550-kb region (correlation coefficient -.80, P < .006). This result is replicated in both the Utah and non-Utah CEPH kindreds. There is a tendency for greater disequilibrium among pairs of polymorphisms located within the same gene than among other pairs of polymorphisms. Trigenic, quadrigenic, three-locus, and four-locus disequilibrium measures were also estimated, but these measures revealed much less disequilibrium than did the two-locus disequilibrium measures. A review of 19 published disequilibrium studies, including this one, shows that linkage disequilibrium nearly always correlates significantly with physical distance in genomic regions > 50-60 kb but that it does not do so in smaller genomic regions. We show that this agrees with theoretical predictions. This finding helps to resolve controversies regarding the use of disequilibrium for inferring gene order. Disequilibrium mapping is unlikely to predict gene order correctly in regions < 50-60 kb in size but can often be applied successfully in regions of 50-500 kb or so in size. It is convenient that this is the range in which other mapping techniques, including chromosome walking and linkage mapping, become difficult.

Hotspots of meiotic recombination in the mouse major histocompatibility complex

Meiotic recombination is not random in the proximal region of the mouse major histocompatibility complex (MHC). It is clustered at four restricted positions, so-called hotspots. Some of the MHC haplotypes derived from Asian wild mice enhance recombination at the hotspots in genetic crosses with standard MHC haplotypes of laboratory mouse strains. In particular, the wm7 haplotype derived from Japanese wild mouse indicated an approximately 2% recombination frequency within a 1.2 kb fragment of DNA in the interval between the Pb and Ob genes. Interestingly, this enhancement of recombination was observed only in female meiosis but not in male meiosis. Mating experiments demonstrated that the wm7 haplotype carries a genetic factor in the region proximal to the hotspot, which instigates recombination. In addition, the wm7 haplotype has a genetic factor located in the region distal to the hotspot, which suppresses recombination. From the molecular characterization of the two hotspots located in the Eb gene and the Pb-Ob interval, it appeared that there are several common molecular elements, the consensus of the middle repetitive MT-family, TCTG or CCTG tetramer repeats, and the solitary long terminal repeat (LTR) of mouse retrovirus.

Polymorphic haplotypes and recombination rates at the LDL receptor gene locus in subjects with and without familial hypercholesterolemia who are from different populations

RFLPs at the low-density lipoprotein (LDL) receptor locus for TaqI, StuI, HincII, AvaII, ApaLI (5' and 3'), PvuII, and NcoI were studied in Swiss and German families with familial hypercholesterolemia (FH). A total of 1,104 LDL receptor alleles were analyzed using Southern blotting and new PCR-based techniques for detection of the TaqI, StuI, HincII, AvaII, NcoI RFLPs. Two hundred fifty-six independent haplotypes from 368 individuals of 61 unrelated Swiss families, as well as 114 independent haplotypes from 184 subjects of 25 unrelated German families, were constructed. In 76 families, clinical diagnosis of FH was confirmed by cosegregation analysis. Of the 43 unique haplotypes consisting of seven RFLPs detected in the Swiss and Germans, only 9 were common in both population samples. Analysis of linkage disequilibrium revealed nonrandom associations between several of the investigated RFLPs. ApaLI (5'), NcoI, PvuII, TaqI, and AvaII or HincII were particularly informative (cumulative informativeness .85). Relative frequencies, heterozygosity indexes, and PICs of the RFLPs from the Swiss and Germans were compared with values calculated from reported haplotype data for Italians, Icelanders, North American Caucasians, South African Caucasians, and Japanese. Pairwise comparisons of population samples by common RFLPs demonstrated unexpected differences even between geographically adjacent populations (e.g., the Swiss and Germans). Furthermore, genetic distances from the Germans to the other Caucasians were larger than to the Japanese. An unexpected lack of correlation between linkage disequilibria and physical distances was detected for the German and Japanese data, possibly because of nonuniform recombination with excessively high rates between exon 13 and intron 15. Hence, the present study revealed a striking variety of polymorphic haplotypes and heterogeneity of RFLP frequencies and recombination rates among the seven population samples.

The population genetics of the haemoglobinopathies

The haemoglobinopathies are the commonest single gene disorders known, and are so common in some regions of the world that the majority of the population carries at least one genetic abnormality affecting the structure or synthesis of the haemoglobin molecule. The prevalence of the common haemoglobinopathies (the alpha- and beta-thalassaemias, HbS, HbC and HbE) is almost certainly a result of the protection they provide against malaria, as the epidemiological evidence reviewed in this chapter shows. World-wide, the distributions of malaria and the common haemoglobinopathies largely overlap, and micro-epidemiological surveys have confirmed the close relationship between the disorders. However, there are complications to this picture which appear to undermine the malaria hypothesis. First, in some areas, malaria and haemoglobinopathies are not coincident. Second, the malaria hypothesis does not easily explain why no two regions of the world have the same haemoglobinopathy or combination of haemoglobinopathies. The majority of mutations have arisen only once and are regionally specific. By using molecular characterization of mutations and the analysis of haplotypes on haemoglobinopathy-bearing chromosomes it is possible to show how a combination of selection by malaria, genetic drift and population movements can explain the first complication. In order to explain the second, we have argued that malaria selection has operated relatively recently on human populations (within the last 5000 years). The present distribution is then seen as the result of selection elevating sporadic mutations in local populations. In the absence of sufficient gene flow to spread all mutations to all populations, the consequence is a patchwork distribution of haemoglobinopathies. Given time, we would expect the mutations that protect and do not compromise the health of their carriers to become widely disseminated, but it is likely that human intervention will alter this process of natural selection.

Molecular characterization of the mouse agouti locus

The agouti (a) locus acts within the microenvironment of the hair follicle to regulate coat color pigmentation in the mouse. We have characterized a gene encoding a novel 131 amino acid protein that we propose is the one gene associated with the agouti locus. This gene is normally expressed in a manner consistent with a locus function, and, more importantly, its structure and expression are affected by a number of representative alleles in the agouti dominance hierarchy. In addition, we found that the pleiotropic effects associated with the lethal yellow (Ay) mutation, which include pronounced obesity, diabetes, and the development of neoplasms, are accompanied by deregulated overexpression of the agouti gene in numerous tissues of the adult animal.

Localization and genetic linkage of the human immunoglobulin heavy chain genes and the creatine kinase brain (CKB) gene: identification of a hot spot for recombination

The immunoglobulin heavy chain (IGH) gene cluster and the gene coding for the brain form of the enzyme creatine kinase (CKB) have previously been localized to chromosome 14, at 14q32.3 and 14q32, respectively. Here we report more precise regional localization of these genes by dosage studies using DNA from a child hemizygous for the region from 14q32.32 to 14qter. CKB and IGH are present in a single dose in the proband. Dosage studies in a second patient with a similar but smaller deletion due to a ring chromosome 14 show that CKB is proximal to the IGH cluster. An EcoRI restriction site polymorphism was found with probes for the CKB gene. Linkage analysis of family data indicates that CKB is closely linked to IGH. Linkage analysis also revealed unusually high recombination (beta = 3.2%) between the C delta and C gamma 3 genes of the IGH constant region, which are only 60 kb apart. This finding, in combination with a previous observation of linkage equilibrium in the region, suggests that the C delta-C gamma 3 region contains a recombination hot spot.

Decreasing gradients of gene conversion on both sides of the initiation site for meiotic recombination at the ARG4 locus in yeast

We have constructed eight restriction site polymorphisms in the DED81-ARG4 region and examined their behavior during meiotic recombination. Tetrad analysis reveals decreasing gradients of gene conversion on both sides of the initiation site for meiotic recombination at the ARG4 locus, extending on one side into the ARG4 gene, and on the other side into the adjacent DED81 gene. Gene conversion events can extend in both directions from the initiation site as the result of a single meiotic event. There is a second gradient of gene conversion in DED81, with high levels near the 5' end of the gene and low levels near the middle of the gene. The peaks of gene conversion activity for the DED81 and ARG4 gradients map to regions where double-strand breaks are found during meiosis. The implications of these results for models of meiotic gene conversion are discussed.

Allelic variations of human TCR V gene products

A central problem confronting the immune system is how to discriminate among vast numbers of antigens. Novel genetic ploys that aid the discriminative process, including complex gene rearrangements (in antibody and T-cell receptor (TCR) genes) and extensive allelic polymorphism (in major histocompatibility complex (MHC) genes), have been described. Recent evidence has suggested a further level of diversity; TCR V gene allelic variation. In this article David Posnett summarizes evidence in favour of this possibility and speculates on the possible functional consequences of TCR allelism.

A multigene deletion in the human IGH constant region locus involves highly homologous hot spots of recombination

A simultaneous absence of the IgG1, IgG2, IgG4, and IgA1 immunoglobulins (Ig) was unambiguously demonstrated in six healthy individuals of two different families (family HASS and family TOU). These individuals were shown to be homozygous for a large deletion in the immunoglobulin heavy chain constant region locus. This deletion, which encompasses the G1-EP1-A1-GP-G2-G4 genes, allowed us to predict an order for the IgCH genes and to localize GP between A1 and G2. In this paper, we study the deletion-recombination point in the IGH locus of individual EZZ from the TOU family. We show that the distance between the G3 and the E genes on the EZZ recombinant chromosome is 24.7 kb and that the multigene deletion in the IgCH locus involves two highly homologous regions (hsg3 and hsg4) which are hot spots of recombination, outside of the switch sequences.

Polymorphisms of the immunoglobulin heavy-chain delta gene and association with other constant-region genes

Polymorphisms have previously been reported for the C mu, C alpha, C epsilon, and C gamma genes of the immunoglobulin heavy-chain (IGH) gene cluster. Here we report polymorphisms of the IGH C delta gene region, observed using the enzymes ApaI, AvaII, TaqI, and XbaI. The TaqI and XbaI polymorphisms were used in an investigation of linkage disequilibrium throughout the cluster of constant-region genes. The TaqI polymorphism, located 5' to the C delta gene, is in linkage disequilibrium with a polymorphism of the C mu switch region. The XbaI polymorphism, which is in the vicinity of the C delta 2 exon, is not strongly associated with any other polymorphisms, including the TaqI polymorphism and the Gm polymorphism of C gamma 3. Although there is a high degree of association between most genes of the IGH region, there is a lack of association between C delta and C gamma 3, which may indicate a hot spot for recombination.

Hot spot of recombination within DXS164 in the Duchenne muscular dystrophy gene

The DMD gene, which spans more than 2,000 kbp, has been assigned to band Xp21 of the X chromosome. Two subclones (PERT 87-1 and PERT 87-15) of the intragenic locus DXS164 physically are separated by approximately 60 kbp. Linkage studies were done in 49 informative DMD families by using the LINKAGE program. Crossing-over between the loci studied occurred in four families. A recombination rate of 4% (support interval [Zmax-1] 1%-10%), which was 54 (support interval 14-135-fold) times higher than expected, was found with a maximum lod score of 13.50. These data suggest a hot spot for recombination within DXS164.

In vivo assessment of the Z-DNA-forming potential of d(CA.GT)n and d(CG.GC)n sequences cloned into SV40 minichromosomes

Alternating repeated d(CA.GT)n and d(CG.GC)n sequences constitute a significant proportion of the simple repeating elements found in eukaryotic genomic DNA. These sequences are known to form left-handed Z-DNA in vitro. In this paper, we have addressed the question of the in vivo determination of the Z-DNA-forming potential of such sequences in eukaryotic chromatin. For this purpose, we have investigated the ability of a d(CA.GT)30 sequence and a d(CG.GC)5 sequence to form left-handed Z-DNA when cloned into simian virus 40 (SV40) minichromosomes at two different positions: the TaqI site, which occurs in the intron of the T-antigen gene, and the HpaII site, which is located in the late promoter region within the SV40 control region. Formation of Z-DNA at the inserted repeated sequences was analyzed through the change in DNA linkage associated with the B to Z transition. Our results indicate that regardless of: (1) the site of insertion (either TaqI or HpaII), (2) the precise moment of the viral lytic cycle (from 12 h to 48 h postinfection) and (3) the condition of incorporation of the SV40 recombinants to the host cells (either as minichromosomes or as naked DNA, relaxed or negatively supercoiled), neither the d(CA.GT)30 nor the d(CG.GC)5 sequence are stable in the left-handed Z-DNA conformation in the SV40 minichromosome. The biological relevance of these results is discussed.

An initiation site for meiotic gene conversion in the yeast Saccharomyces cerevisiae

An initiation site for meiotic gene conversion has been identified in the promoter region of the ARG4 gene of Saccharomyces cerevisiae. The chromosome on which initiation occurs is the recipient of genetic information during gene conversion.

Polymorphic DNA haplotypes at the human phenylalanine hydroxylase locus and their relationship with phenylketonuria

Eight polymorphic restriction enzyme sites at the phenylalanine hydroxylase (PAH) locus were analyzed from the parental chromosomes in 33 Danish nuclear families with at least one phenylketonuric (PKU) child. Determination of haplotypes of 66 normal chromosomes and 66 chromosomes bearing mutant allele(s) demonstrated that there are at least two haplotypes which occur predominantly on PKU chromosomes and rarely otherwise. Overall, the relative frequencies of the various haplotypes are significantly different on PKU- and normal-allele bearing chromosomes, even though there is no predominantly occurring unique haplotype which can characterize the PKU chromosomes. In addition, no significant association (linkage disequilibrium) between any single polymorphic site and the mutant allele(s) was observed. The results suggest that either the phenylketonuric mutation was very ancient so that the polymorphic sites and the mutation have reached linkage equilibrium or the mutant allele(s) are the results of multiple mutations in the phenylalanine hydroxylase gene in man. Furthermore, a crude relationship between standardized linkage disequilibria and physical map distances of the polymorphic sites indicates that there is no apparent recombination hot-spot in the human phenylalanine hydroxylase gene, since the recombination rate within the locus appears to be uniform and likely to be occurring at a rate similar to that within the HLA gene cluster. The limitations of this later analysis are discussed in view of the sampling errors of disequilibrium measure used, and the potential utility of the PAH haplotypes for prenatal diagnosis and detection of PKU carriers is established.

A mutant lymphoma cell line with a defective Thy-1 glycoprotein gene

We characterized a mutant T-cell lymphoma line selected for the inability to express the Thy-1 glycoprotein. This cell line is a member of the D complementation class of Thy-1- somatic cell mutants, and it lacks detectable cell-surface Thy-1.1 glycoprotein and detectable cytoplasmic Thy-1 mRNA. Southern blot analysis using a number of probes isolated from the cloned Thy-1.2 gene demonstrated that, in the mutant, one copy of the Thy-1 gene is absent from the genome and the other has undergone rearrangement. This rearrangement results from a deletion of the 5' portion of the gene removing the first two alternate exons and promoters and a portion of the second intron. The deletion breakpoint within the mutant Thy-1 gene was localized to within 400 nucleotides by Southern blot analysis. The breakpoint is near two classes of mouse repetitive elements-a mouse B1-family repetitive element and a simple repetitive sequence-suggesting a mechanism of rearrangement leading to the mutation. Southern blot analysis demonstrated that two closely linked molecular markers on chromosome 9 are unaltered, demonstrating that the deletion in this mutant cell line is subchromosomal.

Polymorphism of human Ia antigens generated by reciprocal intergenic exchange between two DR beta loci

Class II molecules encoded by the human major histocompatibility complex (MHC) are involved in regulating T-cell response to antigens. The mechanisms for generating polymorphism in products of the MHC have been studied extensively for both the murine H-2 and the human HLA complex. Such studies indicate that point mutations plus selection have a major role in the generation of polymorphisms of class I and class II MHC genes. However, a non-reciprocal gene conversion mechanism has been proposed to explain several examples of clustered sequence variation in MHC genes. In all these examples, the proposed gene conversion event is unidirectional; that is, one of the two interacting genes acts as sequence donor and the other as sequence recipient. No examples of potential reciprocal genetic exchange (as occurs in the fungal system), in which the two interacting genes act as both donor and recipient of gene fragments, have been found in the MHC system or in other multigene families of higher organisms. We sequenced two different HLA-DR beta complementary DNAs from each of two different cells all expressing the same serologically defined determinant (DR2) but different T-cell-recognized (Dw) specificities (Dw12 and MN2). Sequence comparisons of these four cDNA clones (and two DR beta amino-acid sequences from the DR2-Dw2 subtype) suggest that new coding sequences for DR beta molecules in the DR2 haplotypes are potentially generated by reciprocal intergenic exchange.

A model for effective pairing and recombination at meiosis based on early replicating sites (R-bands) along chromosomes

A model for meiotic pairing is proposed in which early replicating sites (R-band equivalent) along chromosomes are envisaged as sites for synaptic initiation. Only within such sites will "effective" pairing for recombination be established. Pairing in later replicating (G- and C-band equivalent) regions will be "ineffective" and will not provide for the stringent requirements of the crossover process. Exchange events might be predetermined at S-phase, and possibly at junctions between early and later replicating sequences, these being seen as vulnerable sites for breakage. Temporal shifts in replication from early to late S, are postulated to produce localized pairing disruption and lowering of crossover values as regions of chromatin shift from being effectively to ineffectively paired.