A different kind of day hospital--for patients with preterminal cancer and chronic disease

A survey of hospice day services in the United Kingdom & Republic of Ireland : how did hospices offer social support to palliative care patients, pre-pandemic?

INTRODUCTION

Social support is described by patients and other stakeholders to be a valuable component of palliative day care. Less is known about the range of hospice services that have been used in practice that facilitate social support. An online survey aimed to gain an overview of all hospice day services that facilitated social support for adults outside of their own homes.

METHODS

An online survey was distributed via email to people involved in managing hospice day services. Questions were asked on hospice characteristics, including staff and volunteer roles. Respondents were asked to identify services they felt offered social support to patients. Data collection took place between August 2017 and May 2018.

RESULTS

Responses were received from 103 hospices in the UK and ROI (response rate 49.5%). Results provide an overview of hospice day and outpatient services that offer social support to patients. These are: multi-component interventions, activity groups, formal support groups, befriending, and informal social activities. Multi-component interventions, such as palliative day care, were the most commonly reported. Their stated aims tend to focus on clinical aspects, but many survey respondents considered these multicomponent interventions to be the 'most social' service at their hospice. The survey also identified a huge variety of activity groups, as well as formal therapeutic support groups. Informal 'social-only' activities were present, but less common. Over a third of all the services were described as 'drop in'. Most responding hospices did not routinely use patient reported outcome measures in their 'most social' services.

CONCLUSIONS

The survey documents hospice activity in facilitating social support to be diverse and evolving. At the time of data collection, many hospices offered multiple different services by which a patient might obtain social support outside of their own home and in the presence of other patients.

Challenges for palliative care day services: a focus group study

BACKGROUND

Palliative care day services provide a safe environment for people with palliative care needs, enabling them to access a range of services while acting as a respite services for family caregivers. Viewed as marginal services, they are often under resourced and under researched. The aim of this study was to understand how palliative day care services contribute to client care from the perspective of management and hospice multidisciplinary teams.

METHODS

A descriptive qualitative study, using six focus groups conducted with staff at three United Kingdom hospices in England, Scotland and Northern Ireland. Thirty-five participants were recruited, including management and staff. Discussions were transcribed and analysed thematically.

RESULTS

Four key themes emerged: (1) variations of care, beyond heterogeneity of patients; (2) unclear referrals and inconsistent patient population; (3) recognising strengths and challenges and (4) an uncertain future. A major focus of group discussions was the model of care and the benefits of the service, however the importance of demonstrating services' effectiveness and value for money was highlighted.

CONCLUSIONS

Management and hospice staff believed day-services to be a helpful introduction to palliative care, providing both social and medical support. Economic pressures and patient demand were influencing them to move from a social model to a hybrid model. Further research is needed to understand the effectiveness of the service.

Hospice U.K. – 2000 AD

This paper examines the possible shape of the hospice movement in the year 2000 AD. The number of patients dying from cancer will be similar to today, and cancer will remain the most common disease referred to hospices. After reviewing the key developments during the past fifteen years, the effects of national policy and financial constraint on future developments are examined. Most advances will stem from better organization and more realistically staffed hospices and hospice care teams. This will encourage greater flexibility and imaginative development. Advances will be made in rehabilitation, halfway houses for the elderly frail, and greater involvement with mainstream medical services. The role of home care teams, hospital support teams and day care, coupled with the better use of volunteers will maintain more patients at home and reduce the bed norms to 25 per million. A statement on education and training is made.

The effect of Palliative Daycare on Hope: A comparison of Daycare Patients with Two Control Groups

Background: Despite expansion in palliative daycare services, research has not demonstrated an improvement in patient outcomes. This study aimed to determine the effect of palliative daycare on hope. Methods: This was a prospective cohort study that compared three groups of patients: a daycare group and two control groups, one recruited before daycare opened and a matched comparison group. Patients were interviewed at baseline and at two follow-ups using the Herth Hope Index. Results: In all, 22 daycare patients completed a baseline interview (T1); 12 a second (T2); and 9 a third (T3). Corresponding numbers were: before group (56, 34, 24) and matched group (49, 29, 19). An independent samples t-test confirmed a significant difference between the groups from T1 to T2 (mean difference=3.20, p=0.007), with the daycare group experiencing an increase in hope not seen in the other groups. However, this was not maintained. Conclusion: Daycare may effect an initial improvement in hope. The study suffered from attrition and the sample was small. Further robust evaluation of daycare is needed.

The outcomes of palliative care day services: a systematic review

This systematic review evaluates the evidence underpinning the provision of palliative day care services (PDS) to determine whether such services have a measurable effect on attendees' wellbeing. The majority of studies reviewed were qualitative and elicited individual perceptions of the benefits PDS. Although it was difficult to determine the quality of many studies, it would appear that attendance at PDS had a positive impact on attendees' quality of life. Fewer studies utilized validated outcome measures to determine the effect of PDS on attendees' wellbeing and small sample sizes combined with high attrition rates influenced the significance of some the results. However little quantitative evidence was offered to prove that PDS had an impact on attendees' quality of life or wellbeing. The review concludes that dying people find attending PDS a valuable experience that allows them to engage with others and to be supported in a restorative environment. However, further well-powered empirical studies are required to provide quality evidence to determine whether or not attendance at PDS does indeed have a positive impact on the wellbeing of attendees.

“I Come Because I Can”: Stories of Hope from the Cancer Drop in

Hospices are now the established institutionalized home of specialist palliative care practice in the United Kingdom. Despite attempts to widen access, the dominant patient group continues to be cancer sufferers. A multidisciplinary approach to the support of patients characterizes this field of health care, with both skilled professionals and volunteers attending to patients' physical, emotional, and spiritual needs. Day care, as one type of provision within hospice services, has its own practice territory with wide variations now well documented in the literature. This article reports on a participant observation study that explored the day care provision of a community hospice trust located in southern England. Drawing on the concepts of palliative care and hope in the lives of terminally ill people, findings suggest that this facility helps to counter the isolating effects of cancer and that self-comparison acts as motivation to attend day care, contributing to hope for continued survival.

Social objectives in cancer care: the example of palliative day care

Social objectives are poorly specified and evaluated in cancer care. Palliative day care is an example where social objectives are often identified but research has focused on health-care outcomes. A literature review identifies four types of social objective: emotional and spiritual care, general social care, services for families and carers and creative arts. Social objectives include: distinguishing between therapeutic work and leisure and supportive interventions, promoting service continuity, reducing social isolation, increasing social interaction, reassuring introduction to palliative care, rehearsal of reactions to illness with a sympathetic audience, integration of families and carers into care services, respite for carers and creative work for three separable objectives. It is argued that interventions to achieve social objectives may be defined and evaluated in a measurable way. Similarly, social objectives and interventions can be specified at other stages in the cancer journey.

Systematic review of specialist palliative day-care for adults with cancer

GOAL OF WORK

To inform future practice, research and policy in specialist palliative day-care by systematically reviewing the evidence for how the structure and process of this form of care relate to outcomes for adults with cancer.

PATIENTS AND METHODS

Medical, nursing and social science computerized databases were searched up until December 2003 for studies of palliative day-care reporting information on service structure, care processes or outcomes including symptom control, quality of life, social and psychological support, and patient and relative satisfaction with care. Qualitative and quantitative studies were assessed for methodological quality and graded, and the findings synthesized into the review.

MAIN RESULTS

Twelve observational studies were found that showed the difficulties of evaluating a service already operating and of recruiting a vulnerable population of patients as they deteriorated. Most services are nurse-led, but varied in the facilities, staff mix, care models, activities and places they offered. Patients attending seemed a selected group of those already receiving palliative care who were mostly white, aged over 60 years and retired, with needs for emotional and social support and pain control. There were insufficient studies to provide conclusive evidence of improved symptom control or health-related quality of life, but all qualitative studies found patients valued the social support and opportunity to take part in activities that day-care provided.

CONCLUSIONS

There is evidence for high satisfaction among patients selected into day-care, but not yet sufficient to judge whether this improves symptom control or health-related quality of life. Further research should explore selection and access into care, the most effective models of care, its cost, and potential benefits for relatives and carers. Comparison with models of care for older adults and those with mental illness would also be informative.

Day hospice care--a review of the literature

This paper traces the development and evaluation of day care hospice provision through analysis of the available literature. The CD-ROM was utilized to access and review the Medline, CINAHL and Healthstar databases. In addition, a hand search of Progress in Palliative Care was conducted. The literature describes the provision of a service within a day hospice, and access to day hospice services. Issues regarding the provision of a day hospice as a mechanism to meet consumer needs are explored. The literature reveals little evaluation of evidence-based practice or of the cost-effectiveness of day hospice provision. There is a dearth of research relating to day care, evaluation studies in particular. It is clearly important that future research compares outcomes with other models of service provision.

A telephone survey of the provision of palliative day care services

A telephone survey was conducted to gather preliminary data in order to identify the nature of palliative day care provision in the UK. A random sample of 131 day centres was taken from 17 regional locations in the UK. providing a 60% representation out of a total of 215 adult day care facilities. A combination of a structured and semistructured interview schedule was used to collect the data. The results obtained from this preliminary survey provided further information on the nature, range, and types of services that are currently provided by UK palliative day care centres; management and organizational issues; and the nature of common problems and care issues of patients attending day centres. Data from the study provided further information on the current status of day care services. The implications for future evaluative research are discussed, particularly in the area of the impact and cost-effectiveness of day care services and the potential work with regard to different models of service provision.

The effects of terminal illness on patients and their carers

As part of a larger study, this paper describes the development and design of a project looking at the experiences of the relatives and carers of terminally ill patients in one health authority, as a replication of a similar study undertaken in another area. Following a description of the problems associated with studies into the problems of dying people and of the method used here, the results indicate that there are quite important effects on the household and carers, which include the problem of obtaining a diagnosis of terminal illness, and the actual process of dying. The study also highlights some of the effects of the terminal illness on the patients and their carers. In particular the results indicate that it was usually a spouse or the daughter who bore the brunt of the care, but that most preferred to retain their independence of the services as long as possible. Often, carers (and the patients) were not fully appraised that a terminal stage had been reached. Some doctors seemed reluctant (or found it difficult) to admit that such a stage had been reached. For many, the experience of dying was a very slow, distressing and often painful period, with serious limitations on their lifestyle imposed by the illness. A number of these limitations could have been reduced if earlier diagnosis had been made or if community nursing or social services had been called in sooner.

Reducing the prevalence of unmet needs for concrete services of patients with cancer. Evaluation of a computerized telephone outreach system

A two-stage study was undertaken of outpatients with advanced cancer who were receiving chemotherapy. In Stage 1 of the study, their needs for practical services and the barriers to those needs being met were assessed. Based on these results, an intervention was designed to reduce the prevalence of patients' unmet needs. The intervention was an automated telephone needs assessment coupled with social worker follow-up. The efficacy of this intervention was evaluated using an independent sample in Stage 2 in an experimental trial. Patients in the experimental group (n = 109), who received three automated surveys, reported fewer unmet needs in a subsequent comprehensive assessment than those in the control group (n = 130). The computerized telephone outreach system proved to be a cost-effective and reliable method for the early identification of unmet patient needs soon after they emerge and efficient deployment of limited professional staff.

Adult hospice day care

This article describes the concept of adult hospice day care, argues that programs of adult hospice day care can be an important adjunct to home care and inpatient care, and provides a concrete illustration of ways in which a typical program of adult hospice day care might be implemented.

Day hospital as an alternative to inpatient care for cancer patients: a random assignment trial

A stratified, random-assignment trial of 442 cancer patients was conducted to evaluate medical, psychosocial, and financial outcomes of day hospital treatment as an alternative to inpatient care for certain cancer patients. Eligible patients required: a 4- to 8-hour treatment plan, including chemotherapy and other long-term intravenous (i.v.) treatment; a stable cardiovascular status; mental competence; no skilled overnight nursing; and a helper to assist with home care. Patients were ineligible if standard outpatient treatment was possible. No statistically significant (p less than 0.05) differences were found between the Adult Day Hospital (ADH) and Inpatient care in medical or psychosocial outcomes over the 60-day study period. The major difference was in medical costs--approximately one-third lower for ADH patients (p less than 0.001) than for the Inpatient group. The study demonstrates that day hospital care of medical oncology patients is clinically equivalent to Inpatient care, causes no negative psychosocial effects, and costs less than Inpatient care. Findings support the trend toward dehospitalization of medical treatment.

Effectiveness and application of partial hospitalization

Especially during the past 15 years, partial hospitalization (PHP) has been studied extensively. This article reviews the effectiveness and applicability of PHP. To clarify where PHP might fit into the overall mental health care system, the results of empirical research are evaluated with special attention to topics such as treated population, program evaluation, comparison of PHP with inpatient treatment, PHP as alternative to outpatient treatment, comparison of different PHP's, cost effectiveness and burden on the family. The general conclusion is that PHP can be a reasonable alternative to inpatient as well as to outpatient treatment, taking into account factors such as symptomatology, cost and family burden. PHP seems in particular to enhance social role functioning, which might be attributed to the fact that contact between patient and environment is not disturbed by hospitalization. Suggestions for further research are presented. Furthermore it is recommended in order to improve generalizability of results to differentiate the different functions PHP can fulfil in the mental health care system.

Perspectives on the pain of the hospice patient

Behind the physical disfigurement and emotional ravages of advanced malignancy, it is the pain of cancer that is most dreaded. Severe biological pain is experienced by fewer than half of patients dying from cancer. Hospice physicians have the expertise to control the pain of those cancer patients who do experience it. The cancer patient may experience other forms of pain that can be equally devastating: pain of isolation, pain of abandonment, and pain of loss of role. It is important for the occupational therapist working in a hospice setting to understand all aspects of pain management, and the occupational therapy treatment strategies which can improve the quality of life and perception of pain for the hospice patient. Through presentation of case studies, the authors illustrate applications of occupational therapy assessments and interventions in respect to two hospice patients. The occupational therapy treatment strategies effected an improvement in the quality of life for these patients and consequently their perception of pain of loss of role. Occupational therapists, as part of the hospice team, play an important part in giving patients an opportunity to live out their lives in as dignified and purposeful a manner as their disease permits.

Terminal care in the home

We report on a 16-week study of the terminal care given to 118 patients who died at home at the end of a chronic illness. We describe the clinical features of the care and how these were managed, we compare the doctors' and relatives' view of the patients' suffering and awareness of death, and we explore the implications of death at home for general practitioner, nursing and other support services and for the relatives who care for the patient.