Does sulphoxidation state predict gold toxicity in rheumatoid arthritis?

Phenylalanine 4-monooxygenase: the "sulfoxidation polymorphism"

1. Consistent differences in the proportion of an orally administered dose of S-carboxymethyl-l-cysteine subsequently excreted in the urine as S-oxide metabolites were reported 40 years ago. This observation suggested the existence of inter-individual variation in the ability to undertake the enzymatic S-oxygenation of this compound. Pedigree studies and investigations employing twin pairs indicated a genetically controlled phenomenon overlaid with environmental influences. It was reproducible and not related to gender or age.2. Studies undertaken in several healthy volunteer cohorts always provided similar results that were not significantly different when statistically analysed. However, when compared to these healthy populations, a preponderance of subjects exhibiting the characteristic of poor sulfoxidation of S-carboxymethyl-l-cysteine was found within groups of patients suffering from various disease conditions. The most striking of these associations were witnessed amongst subjects diagnosed with neurodegenerative disorders; although, underlying mechanisms were unknown.3. Exhaustive investigation has identified the enzyme responsible for this S-oxygenation reaction as the tetrahydrobiopterin-dependent aromatic amino acid hydroxylase, phenylalanine 4-monooxygenase classically assigned the sole function of converting phenylalanine to tyrosine. The underlying principle is discussed that enzymes traditionally associated solely with intermediary metabolism may have as yet unrecognised alternative roles in protecting the organism from potential toxic assault.

Gold causes genetically determined autoimmune and immunostimulatory responses in mice

Natrium aurothiomaleate (GSTM) is a useful disease-modifying anti-rheumatic drug, but causes a variety of immune-mediated adverse effects in many patients. A murine model was used to study further the interaction of GSTM with the immune system, including induction of systemic autoimmunity. Mice were given weekly intramuscular injections of GSTM and controls equimolar amounts of sodium thiomaleate. The effects of gold on lymphocyte subpopulations were determined by flow cytometry. Humoral autoimmunity was measured by indirect immunofluorescence and immunoblotting, and deposition of immunoglobulin and C3 used to assess immunopathology. Gold, in the form of GSTM, stimulated the murine immune system causing strain-dependent lymphoproliferation and autoimmunity, including a major histocompatibility complex (MHC)-restricted autoantibody response against the nucleolar protein fibrillarin. GSTM did not cause glomerular or vessel wall IgG deposits. However, it did elicit a strong B cell-stimulating effect, including both T helper 1 (Th1)- and Th2-dependent isotypes. All these effects on the immune system were dependent on the MHC genotype, emphasizing the clinical observations of a strong genetic linkage for the major adverse immune reactions seen with GSTM treatment.

Phenotypic variation in xenobiotic metabolism and adverse environmental response: focus on sulfur-dependent detoxification pathways

Proper bodily response to environmental toxicants presumably requires proper function of the xenobiotic (foreign chemical) detoxification pathways. Links between phenotypic variations in xenobiotic metabolism and adverse environmental response have long been sought. Metabolism of the drug S-carboxymethyl-L-cysteine (SCMC) is polymorphous in the population, having a bimodal distribution of metabolites, 2.5% of the general population are thought to be nonmetabolizers. The researchers developing this data feel this implies a polymorphism in sulfoxidation of the amino acid cysteine to sulfate. While this interpretation is somewhat controversial, these metabolic differences reflected may have significant effects. Additionally, a significant number of individuals with environmental intolerance or chronic disease have impaired sulfation of phenolic xenobiotics. This impairment is demonstrated with the probe drug acetaminophen and is presumably due to starvation of the sulfotransferases for sulfate substrate. Reduced metabolism of SCMC has been found with increased frequency in individuals with several degenerative neurological and immunological conditions and drug intolerances, including Alzheimer's disease, Parkinson's disease, motor neuron disease, rheumatoid arthritis, and delayed food sensitivity. Impaired sulfation has been found in many of these conditions, and preliminary data suggests that it may be important in multiple chemical sensitivities and diet responsive autism. In addition, impaired sulfation may be relevant to intolerance of phenol, tyramine, and phenylic food constituents, and it may be a factor in the success of the Feingold diet. These studies indicate the need for the development of genetic and functional tests of xenobiotic metabolism as tools for further research in epidemiology and risk assessment.

Management of adverse effects of disease-modifying antirheumatic drugs

Therapy with disease modifying antirheumatic agents (DMARDs) is often complicated by the occurrence of adverse effects. Although risk factors for several DMARDs have been reported, the prediction of adverse drug reactions is not yet possible. Therefore regular monitoring remains mandatory. Monitoring for adverse effects to DMARDs usually includes one or more of the following: blood count, liver, kidney, urine or ophthalmologic tests. Since most adverse reactions occur during the first few months of treatment, monitoring should be more intense and frequent in this initial phase. Some adverse effects are dose-dependent, and therefore dosage reduction may help alleviate these. Others are idiosyncratic, and often necessitate drug withdrawal. Except for (hydroxy)chloroquine-induced retinopathy and methotrexate-induced liver cirrhosis, most adverse reactions to DMARDs are fortunately reversible.

Genetically determined adverse drug reactions involving metabolism

Genetic factors represent an important source of interindividual variation in drug response. Relatively few adverse drug effects with a pharmacodynamic basis are known, and most of the well characterised inherited traits take the form of genetic polymorphisms of drug metabolism. Monogenic control of N-acetylation, S-methylation and cytochrome P450-catalysed oxidation of drugs can have important clinical consequences. Individuals who inherit an impaired ability to perform one or more of these reactions may be at an increased risk of concentration-related toxicity. There is a strong case for phenotyping before starting treatment with a small number of drugs that are polymorphically N-acetylated or S-methylated. However, the issue of clinical significance is perhaps most relevant for the debrisoquine oxidation polymorphism, which is mediated by cytochrome CYP2D6 and which determines the pharmacokinetics of many commonly used drugs. Phenotypic poor metabolisers of debrisoquine (8% of Caucasian populations) taking standard doses of some tricyclic antidepressants, neuroleptics or antiarrhythmic drugs may be particularly prone to adverse reactions. Similarly, clinically relevant drug interactions between these drugs and other substrates of cytochrome CYP2D6 may occur in the majority of the population who are extensive metabolisers. However, it is clear that in the majority of cases there is a need for controlled prospective studies to determine clinical significance. Accordingly, routine debrisoquine phenotyping or genotyping before beginning drug treatment is difficult to justify at present, although it may be helpful in individual cases. When prescribing drugs whose metabolism is polymorphic alone or in combination, careful titration of the dose in both phenotypic groups is prudent. In some cases it will be preferable to use alternative therapy to avoid the risk of adverse drug reactions.

Management of early inflammatory arthritis. Genetic factors predicting persistent disease: the role of defective enzyme systems

In this chapter, we investigate the use of non-toxic 'probe drugs' to give information about basic biochemical pathways. We have examined the hypothesis that a major factor in RA is defective metabolism of sulphur-containing compounds. At least two pathways have been shown to be abnormal in RA. Generally, patients have reduced capacity to metabolize and detoxify thiol compounds by methylation, and have increased levels of plasma cysteine. They also have a lower capacity for S-oxidation of cysteine and its derivatives, with reduced amounts of plasma sulphate. The raised cysteine resulting from less effective metabolism may lead to reduced clearance of immune complexes and a raised inflammatory response in RA patients. Lower plasma sulphate, however, leads to defective tissue synthesis, and makes adequate repair of damaged joints less feasible. The co-existence of defects in these two interacting endogenous pathways serves to perpetuate the disease process, leading to chronic inflammation and tissue destruction. These enzyme defects have been shown to be predictive of persistent disease.

Increased prevalence of poor sulphoxidation in patients with rheumatoid arthritis: effect of changes in the acute phase response and second line drug treatment

A minority of normal subjects have an impaired ability to oxidise sulphur, which is associated with an increased risk of side effects when they receive sulphur containing drugs. In 114 patients with rheumatoid arthritis a greatly increased prevalence of poor sulphoxidation was found in 82 (72%) patients compared with 70/200 (35%) healthy controls, 45/121 (37%) controls matched for age, and 4/35 (11%) of the normal aged general population. In a longitudinal study of 37 patients there was no significant alteration in sulphoxidation status after the introduction of a second line drug or with marked changes in the acute phase response. It seems, therefore, that the poor sulphoxidation status in patients with RA is not an epiphenomenon and may be an important factor in determining the clinical features of rheumatoid disease.

The search for laboratory measures of outcome in rheumatoid arthritis

A large number of laboratory tests have been developed within the past decade to measure factors involved in the immune inflammation of RA. These can be divided into genetic markers, general measures of inflammation, autoantibodies and tissue-specific markers. In general, it is simpler to prove the power of a certain test to measure the disease process than to predict outcome. Apart from RF positivity and CRP/ESR, few, if any, tests have proven to be of importance in independent studies from different centres. Among the promising candidates for future work are detailed analysis of the HLA-D region genes, sulphoxidation status, the autoantibody against RA33 nuclear antigen, soluble IL-2 receptor measuring lymphocyte activity, hyaluronate/hyaluronan or PIIINP from synovial tissue, the combined use of COMP and proteoglycan epitope tests for cartilage matrix, and pyrodinoline cross-linking for collagen from bone and cartilage. The ideal setting for testing such markers are prospective cohort studies starting early in the disease, and since many such studies have been initiated recently, one can expect much new information in coming years. Attention needs to be devoted to the kinetics of marker metabolism, since many are degraded or removed at very fast rates from the circulation, making serum assays less informative.

Comparison of the single dose pharmacokinetics of sulphasalazine in rheumatoid arthritis and inflammatory bowel disease

The pharmacokinetics of sulphasalazine and its principal metabolites in rheumatoid arthritis (RA) and inflammatory bowel disease (IBD) were compared. Patients with RA had a significantly greater concentration of plasma sulphapyridine than patients with IBD (medians 14.0 micrograms/ml and 7.4 micrograms/ml respectively). Patients with RA also tended to maintain a higher plasma sulphapyridine concentration with time, as determined by the area under the curve (AUC), but a lower plasma sulphasalazine AUC than patients with IBD. It is suggested that more sulphasalazine may be presented to the lower bowel for cleavage to sulphapyridine and 5-aminosalicylic acid in patients with RA than in IBD. Patients with RA may also have impaired metabolism of sulphapyridine as a consequence of their disease. Together these factors may contribute to higher peak circulating sulphapyridine concentrations and may be responsible for the higher incidence of side effects of sulphasalazine treatment in patients with RA than in patients with IBD.

The relationship of sulfoxidation status to efficacy and toxicity of penicillamine in the treatment of rheumatoid arthritis

Penicillamine shows some structural similarities to carbocysteine. The ability to oxidize carbocysteine, i.e., the sulfoxidation status, shows a bimodal distribution in the general population. In this study, sulfoxidation status was determined in 50 of 60 rheumatoid arthritis patients receiving penicillamine. We found that poor sulfoxidation status, compared with good sulfoxidation status, was associated with a 3.9 times higher incidence of toxicity.

The natural course of gold and penicillamine nephropathy: a longterm study of 54 patients

To elucidate the natural course of gold and penicillamine nephropathy and to facilitate appropriate clinical management 54 patients with rheumatoid arthritis who developed proteinuria during treatment with intramuscular gold thiomalate (21) or oral D penicillamine (33) were studied in detail throughout the whole of their renal illnesses. Renal biopsy was performed and creatinine clearance and proteinuria were measured serially for a median period of 60 months (range 16-130 months) in the gold treated and 74 months (range 13-158 months) in the penicillamine treated patients. During gold (penicillamine) treatment 48% (43%), 71% (82%) and 86% (91%) of patients had presented with proteinuria by 6, 12 and 24 months of treatment. After stopping gold (penicillamine) treatment proteinuria reached a median maximum of 2.1 g/day (4.2 g/day) at 2 months (1 month) before resolving spontaneously so that by 6, 12 and 18 months 38% (36%), 62% (64%) and 76% (88%) of patients were free of proteinuria. The median initial and most recent creatinine clearances of the gold (penicillamine) treated patients were 77 ml/min (80 ml/min) and 59 ml/min (78 ml/min) respectively and no patients died from or needed treatment for chronic renal failure. HLA B8 and/or DR3 alloantigens were identified in 64% of the gold treated and 56% of the penicillamine treated patients. In the gold (penicillamine) treated patients renal biopsy revealed membranous glomerulonephritis (GN) in 72% (88%), an immune complex mesangial glomerulonephritis in 10% (6%), minimal change nephropathy in 10% (6%) and no significant glomerular abnormalities in 8% (0%). The study has demonstrated the close similarity between gold and penicillamine nephropathy. It has also demonstrated that some 75% of cases develop during the first year of treatment, the proteinuria resolves completely when treatment is withdrawn, progressive deterioration of renal function is most uncommon, corticosteroid therapy is unnecessary and several different types of glomerulonephritis are associated with gold and penicillamine treatment.

Pharmacogenetics of the S-oxidation of S-carboxymethyl-L-cysteine

The pharmacogenetics of S-carboxymethyl-L-cysteine (SCMC) have been studied in detail. When results from administration of SCMC to 200 volunteers were analysed, there was seen to be a wide interindividual variation in the percentage of sulphoxide metabolites excreted. Computer assisted analysis suggested that the population distribution observed could be most economically represented as two overlapping Gaussian distributions with the smaller mode representing poor sulphoxidisers. This phenomenon appears to be largely genetic in origin and to behave as though controlled by one autosomal recessive gene, but environmental factors may also be important. Poor sulphoxidisers seem to be overrepresented in certain patient populations with chronic diseases. These findings are discussed in terms of oxidative metabolism of sulphur-containing compounds.

The natural course of gold nephropathy: long term study of 21 patients

To clarify the natural course of gold nephropathy and thereby facilitate its clinical management 21 patients with rheumatoid arthritis who developed proteinuria during treatment with intramuscular sodium aurothiomalate were studied in detail throughout their renal illnesses. Renal biopsies were performed, and creatinine clearance and proteinuria were measured serially for 60 months (range 16-130 months). Ten patients developed proteinuria after six months' treatment, 15 after 12 months, and 18 after 24 months. When treatment was stopped the proteinuria reached a median peak of 2.1 g/day (range 0.7-30.7 g/day) at two months (range 1-13 months) before resolving spontaneously, in eight patients by six months, in 13 by 12 months, and in 18 by 24 months. All patients were free of proteinuria by 39 months, the median duration being 11 months. The median first and last measurements of creatinine clearance showed no significant change (77 ml/minute and 59 ml/minute, respectively), and no patient died from or needed treatment for renal failure. HLA-B8 or DR3 alloantigens, or both, were identified in seven patients. Renal biopsy specimens showed membranous glomerulonephritis in 15 patients, a minimal change nephropathy in two, mesangial electron dense deposits in two, and no appreciable glomerular changes in two. In these 21 patients the proteinuria of gold nephropathy resolved completely when treatment was withdrawn. Renal function did not deteriorate, corticosteroids were unnecessary, and several different renal lesions were seen.