Effects of intracoronary and intravenous amrinone infusions in patients with cardiac failure and patients with near normal cardiac function

Davids versus Goliaths: Pharma and academia threats to individual scientists and clinicians

Background

We previously described experiences of clinicians who published adverse drug reaction reports. We now report on threats and intimidations leveled against clinicians and scientists who received publicly documented threats after communicating safety, efficacy, or data integrity findings contrary to corporate interests.

Methods

Data on threats and intimidations were obtained from transcripts of governmental hearings or agencies, university-affiliated reports, media interviews, and investigative journalism articles. Content and timing of threats and intimidation, subsequent harms, numbers of persons seriously injured or who died from individual toxicities, financial payments from sponsors related to safety, efficacy, or data integrity concerns, and civil settlements and criminal findings were evaluated.

Findings

Twenty-six individuals who communicated safety, efficacy, or data integrity concerns were targets of threats and intimidation from corporate employees (twenty-three individuals) or regulatory personnel (three). Seventeen individuals identified instances where pharmaceutical sponsors submitted fraudulent data in support of regulatory approval of a drug or device. Scientist and clinician communications were followed by drug/device withdrawals (fourteen drugs/devices), black box warnings (six drugs), withdrawal of a sponsor’s application for regulatory approval (one device), and delay of approval of a sponsor’s application for regulatory approval (one drug). Actions mainly occurred after persons communicated with pharmaceutical employees (fourteen). Intimidation efforts by corporate personnel included threats of lawsuits (eighteen individuals), hiring private investigators (nine), and public disparagement at conferences (eleven). Related intimidation efforts carried out by academia or regulatory agency superiors included threats of: loss of positions (six), loss of grant funding (two), delays in decisions regarding tenure (two); or reassignment to a low-level position (one). Academic harms included lost: hospital or university appointments (nine and six, respectively), grant funding (two), chairperson title of an international clinical trial group (one), and journal editorial board position (one). Corporate harms included payment of $1 million to defense attorneys in three cases filed against clinicians.

Interpretation

Threats and intimidation carried out by corporate employees and/or academic supervisors followed public communication of concerns regarding patient safety, drug efficacy, or data integrity, including instances where sponsors were identified as having submitted fraudulent data to regulatory or government agencies. Consideration should be given to filing criminal charges against pharmaceutical executives who are discovered by scientists or clinicians to have knowingly submitted fraudulent data to regulatory or governmental agencies, rather than causing the scientists and clinicians who submit such reports to risk losing their reputations and occupations.

A comparison of the hemodynamic effects of amrinone and sodium nitroprusside in infants after cardiac surgery

The phosphodiesterase inhibitor amrinone (AMR) increases cardiac output in children after cardiac surgery. In vitro, amrinone has both positive inotropic and vasodilatory effects. However the relative contribution of these effects to the increases in cardiac output observed clinically is unclear, and it has not been demonstrated that amrinone offers a hemodynamic advantage above that of pure vasodilators in infants. We compared the hemodynamic effects of AMR and sodium nitroprusside (SNP) in 10 infants after cardiac surgery. Cardiac index (CI) was measured by thermodilution after SNP administration, titrated to decrease mean blood pressure (MBP) by 20%, and then after a 1.5-mg/kg bolus dose of AMR. Each patient served as his or her own control. Preload, as measured by left atrial pressure and transesophageal echocardiography (in eight patients), was kept constant throughout the protocol. Both SNP and AMR caused significant decreases in MBP and systemic vascular resistance index (SVRI). However, only AMR resulted in a significant increase in CI. The ratio of fractional increase in CI to fractional absolute decrease in MBP was significantly greater for AMR than SNP, indicating greater efficacy for AMR in the treatment of low cardiac output syndrome and suggesting that, in infants after cardiac surgery, AMR has clinically relevant positive inotropic effects.

The direct and interactive effects of phosphodiesterase inhibition and beta-adrenergic stimulation on myocyte contractile function after hypothermic cardioplegic arrest

The direct and interactive effects of phosphodiesterase inhibition (PDEI) and beta-adrenergic receptor (beta AR) stimulation on isolated myocyte contractile function were examined after hypothermic, hyperkalemic, cardioplegic arrest (HHCA) and under normothermic conditions. Left ventricular (LV) myocytes were isolated from porcine hearts and myocyte contractile function was measured under normothermic conditions (37 degrees C in standard media) and after HHCA (2 h at 4 degrees C in Ringer's solution with 24 mEq KCl) with subsequent rewarming. Myocytes were then randomly assigned to treatment with the beta AR agonist isoproterenol (25 nM), the phosphodiesterase inhibitor amrinone (50 microM), or a combination of these compounds and contractile function measurements repeated. Baseline myocyte contractile function was reduced by 32% after HHCA. Isoproternol alone increased myocyte contractile function more than 100% under both normothermic conditions and after HHCA, whereas amrinone alone significantly (60%) improved myocyte contractile function only after HHCA. Amrinone preincubation followed by isoproterenol improved contractile function after HHCA to a greater extent than all other treatment protocols. In contrast, combination treatment under normothermic conditions did not augment myocyte contractile function relative to isoproterenol alone. These findings suggest that amrinone has differential effects on contractile processes. Moreover, the marked improvement of contractile function after HHCA with PDEI pretreatment followed by beta AR stimulation may have implications in treatment strategies for improving myocardial function after cardiopulmonary bypass and provide insight into contractile dysfunction after HHCA.

Effects of amrinone on cardiac contraction and relaxation in isolated, perfused rat heart

The effects of amrinone on cardiac contraction and relaxation were assessed in isolated, perfused rat hearts. It was found that the left ventricular developed pressure (LVDP), dp/dtmax and -da/dtmax did not significantly increase, and the time constant (tau) did not markedly shorten with perfusion of low concentration (1 nmol/L, 100 nmol/L) of amrinone. The perfusion with higher concentration (1000 nmol/L) of amrinone reduced LVDP (P < 0.01), dp/dtmax (P < 0.01), -dp/dtmax (P < 0.01), and prolonged tau (P < 0.05) significantly. It was assumed that amrinone has no direct positive inotropic effect, and can not improve cardiac relaxation. On the contrary, the cardiac contraction and relaxation will be inhibited at higher concentration of amrinone.

Phosphodiesterase inhibitors. Do the risks outweight the benefits?

Despite the justifiable concern about the use of oral cyclic adenosine monophosphate phosphodiesterase (cAMP PDE) inhibitors, the intravenous preparations are clearly effective in the treatment of acute heart failure, whether it occurs de novo or complicating chronic congestive heart failure (CHF), and in low output states following cardiac surgery. There are no grounds to curtail their use in these areas, though any advantages over conventional agents such as dobutamine need further investigation with regard to end-points other than haemodynamic parameters. The long term use of oral cAMP PDE inhibitors in the treatment of chronic CHF should remain restricted by the increase in mortality now confirmed in severe CHF. However, in view of the distressing nature of the condition there remain subgroups of patients in whom the benefits may outweight the risks.

Amrinone and dobutamine as primary treatment of low cardiac output syndrome following coronary artery surgery: a comparison of their effects on hemodynamics and outcome

This study was undertaken in order to compare the effectiveness of amrinone and dobutamine as primary treatment of a low cardiac output (CO) after coronary artery bypass graft (CABG) surgery. Thirty patients with preoperative left ventricular dysfunction participated in this open-label randomized study. Patients were included if they failed to separate from cardiopulmonary bypass (CPB) without inotropic support or if they had a cardiac index (CI) less than 2.4 L/min/m2 after CPB regardless of the blood pressure, in the presence of adequate filling pressures. The treatment objectives were to separate from CPB and achieve a CI > or = 2.4 L/min/m2 and a mean arterial pressure > or = 70 mmHg. Patients treated with amrinone received 0.75 mg/kg followed by 10 micrograms/kg/min; when the objectives were not achieved within five minutes, another 0.75 mg/kg was given. Patients treated with dobutamine received an initial infusion of 5 micrograms/kg/min increased stepwise to 15 micrograms/kg/min if necessary. Eleven of 15 amrinone versus 6 of 15 dobutamine patients achieved the predefined treatment objectives with the test drug alone (P = NS). Comparisons of hemodynamics in patients treated solely with amrinone (n = 7) or dobutamine (n = 6) after CPB showed no significant differences between the treatment groups. The incidence of myocardial ischemia as detected by Holter monitor was 36% with amrinone and 33% with dobutamine. Two patients suffered ventricular fibrillation and two had significant supraventricular tachyarrhythmias (heart rate > 130/min) during treatment with dobutamine alone, whereas no significant arrhythmias occurred in the amrinone group (P = NS). Six dobutamine patients (40%) had postoperative myocardial infarction (MI) as opposed to none among the amrinone patients (P = 0.017). These results indicate that amrinone compares favorably with dobutamine as a primary treatment of low CO after CABG. Further study in a larger number of patients will be required in order to determine if the lower incidence of MI in the amrinone group was due to the treatment drug.

Amrinone before termination of cardiopulmonary bypass: haemodynamic variables and oxygen utilization in the postbypass period

One hundred patients were randomly allocated to receive saline or amrinone, 0.75 mg.kg-1, ten minutes before separation from cardiopulmonary bypass (CPB) after elective coronary artery bypass grafting, in order to determine the effects of this agent on haemodynamic variables and O2 utilization. Anaesthesia and CPB were managed in a standard fashion. Before induction of anaesthesia, at pericardiotomy, then at 1, 10, 20 and 30 min after CPB, haemodynamic profiles, haematocrit, and O2 saturation of arterial and mixed venous blood were measured. Incremental doses of ephedrine or phenylephrine, or an infusion of norepinephrine with phentolamine were administered when required. The groups were demographically similar and surgical variables were also similar. Haemodynamic measurements were similar between groups at all times; however, a higher dose of phenylephrine was given immediately before weaning from CPB in the amrinone group, and more patients in this group received phenylephrine in the first 30 min after CPB. Mixed venous saturation (SvO2) was higher in the amrinone patients at all times after CPB, leading to lower calculated oxygen consumption (VO2) (P less than 0.05). Insufficient dosage may explain the lack of haemodynamic effect, while possible reasons for the higher SvO2 and lower VO2 are either reduced whole body VO2 or peripheral shunting.

Interactive effects of isoflurane and amrinone in the feline intestinal and renal circulation

Interactive effects of the phosphodiesterase-III inhibitor amrinone and isoflurane were investigated in cats. Cardiac output (thermodilution method), and intestinal (IBF) and renal (RBF) blood flows (optical flowmetry) were measured. Intestinal (IVR) and renal (RVR) vascular resistances were derived. To discriminate between pressure-related local myogenic vascular responses and primary vascular drug effects, intestinal and renal perfusion pressures (50 mmHg; 6.7 kPa) were controlled. The protocol included steady-state recordings with and without isoflurane in a randomized order, both before and after the administration of amrinone (2 mg.kg-1 i.v. + 2 mg.kg-1.h-1 i.v.. Amrinone induced no significant changes in IVR or RVR during basal chloralose anesthesia. During administration of 0.8% isoflurane, amrinone produced decreases in IVR and RVR, which were more pronounced than the vasodilator responses induced by this dose of isoflurane alone. On the other hand, with 1.6% isoflurane, amrinone did not add to the vasodilation. The cardiac effects of isoflurane and amrinone were small. Our data indicate that the vascular tone before administration of amrinone could be crucial for the vascular response of the drug and that isoflurane can significantly influence the regional circulatory effects of amrinone.

Dobutamine potentiates amrinone's beneficial effects in moderate but not in advanced heart failure. 31P-MRS in isolated hamster hearts

There is controversy as to whether potent inotropic agents are beneficial or detrimental in moderate to severe heart failure. Accordingly, we studied the effects of amrinone, amrinone plus dobutamine, and dobutamine alone on mechanical performance, myocardial oxygen consumption, and high energy phosphate metabolism in different stages of congestive heart failure in the cardiomyopathic Syrian hamster. In hearts with moderate heart failure, administration of amrinone, amrinone plus dobutamine, and dobutamine alone increased developed pressure significantly, whereas the phosphorylation potential increased significantly only with amrinone and amrinone plus dobutamine. In hearts with advanced heart failure, administration of amrinone and amrinone plus dobutamine increased developed pressure significantly, whereas dobutamine alone had no effect. The phosphorylation potential improved significantly only with amrinone. Thus, amrinone improved mechanical performance and mitochondrial activity in both heart failure states. Dobutamine potentiated amrinone's beneficial effects in moderate heart failure, but negated the positive inotropic effect of amrinone in advanced heart failure. Therefore, hearts responded differently to potent inotropic agents depending on the severity of heart failure.

Amrinone: is it the inotrope of choice?

In the treatment of acute heart failure, conventional therapy with epinephrine, norepinephrine, dopamine, and dobutamine may be used effectively to treat inotropic abnormalities. However, the addition of a vasodilator to catecholamine therapy may be needed to help improve lusitropic function. Because it seems to exert positive inotropic and lusitropic effects, the phosphodiesterase inhibitor amrinone may be a valuable addition to the anesthesiologist's armamentarium for the treatment of acute heart failure. When used as adjunctive therapy with catecholamines, amrinone has been shown to exert a significant additive and synergistic effect. Amrinone may also be the inotrope of choice in patients who are refractory to therapy with conventional inotropes, due to its positive inotropic and lusitropic effects, combined with its vasodilating effects. Because of its broad pharmacodynamic spectrum, amrinone may effectively control all of the major elements involved in myocardial performance--preload, afterload, contractility, and heart rate.

Comparison of the effects of captopril and enoximone in patients with severe heart failure: a placebo controlled double-blind study

The effects of enoximone, a new cyclic adenosine monophosphate phosphodiesterase inhibitor, were compared with those of captopril in a double-blind study in a group of 10 patients with severe heart failure. Four weeks treatment with enoximone improved symptom-limited exercise tolerance from a mean value of 11.33 to 13.36 minutes (P less than 0.05) and 4 weeks of captopril treatment from 11.01 to 13.92 minutes (P less than 0.05). Four of the patients had a greater exercise tolerance taking enoximone, the remaining 6 while taking captopril. Both drugs reduced perceived exertion during submaximal exercise. Minute ventilation measured at rest and during submaximal exercise was also reduced by both drugs. Resting and post exercise calf blood flow was increased to a similar extent with captopril (P less than 0.03) and enoximone (P less than 0.005). There was no difference in calf blood flow and calf vascular resistance between the drugs suggesting that the peripheral haemodynamic effects of enoximone are due to peripheral vasodilatation. Enoximone is a useful drug for the treatment of patients with severe heart failure.

Effect of a single oral dose of milrinone on left ventricular diastolic performance in the failing human heart

In 14 patients with severe congestive heart failure, left ventricular pressure (measured by tip manometer) and derived variables were measured before and every 10 minutes after administration of oral milrinone (10 mg) for 50 minutes along with measurements of coronary sinus blood flow and drug plasma levels. Arterial and coronary sinus catecholamines were measured only before and 50 minutes after milrinone. Left ventricular pressure, volume (as determined by angiography) and derived indexes were simultaneously assessed at matched atrial paced heart rate before and 60 minutes after milrinone. Three patients who did not achieve a therapeutic plasma level (less than 150 ng/ml) were excluded. Peak negative first derivative of left ventricular pressure (-dP/dt) progressively and significantly increased (10%) together with a decrease in the two exponential time constants of relaxation, namely, Tau 1 (19%) and Tau 2 (22%), which represent the fit for and after the first 40 ms, respectively. Coronary flow significantly increased by 43% within 30 minutes, whereas the decrease (-13%) in coronary vascular resistance failed to be statistically significant. No change occurred in catecholamine concentrations after milrinone. Peak filling rate significantly increased by 15%. Pressure-volume curves showed a leftward and, in four patients, a downward shift; a significant decrease in minimal left ventricular diastolic and end-diastolic pressures (by 55 and 38%, respectively) and in end-diastolic volume (18%) occurred. The constant of elastic chamber stiffness measured by the simple elastic model tended to decrease, but failed to achieve a statistically significant level. Thus, oral milrinone improved left ventricular early relaxation and filling as well as chamber distensibility. This global improvement of diastolic function makes milrinone a potentially useful drug in the oral treatment of heart failure.

Combined hemodynamic and scintigraphic assessment of piroximone (MDL 19,205) and comparison with dobutamine and nitroprusside

The acute hemodynamic responses to intravenous infusion of piroximone (MDL 19,205), a nonglycoside, noncatecholamine agent with positive inotropic activity in vitro, were compared with those of intravenous dobutamine and sodium nitroprusside, respectively, in 2 groups of patients with New York Heart Association class III or IV symptoms. Each drug was titrated to optimal dosage (dobutamine, 12.5 +/- 3.9 micrograms/kg/min; nitroprusside, 2.5 +/- 0.6 micrograms/kg/min; piroximone 1.4 +/- 0.6 mg/kg) and simultaneous hemodynamic and scintigraphic values were measured. In group 1, the increase in cardiac index was slightly greater with piroximone than with dobutamine (from 1.6 +/- 0.5 to 2.7 +/- 0.6 vs 2.4 +/- 0.6 liters/min/m2, p less than 0.025) and only piroximone significantly decreased left ventricular (LV) filling pressure (from 29 +/- 7 to 22 +/- 8 mm Hg, p less than 0.05). Both agents increased heart rate and systolic blood pressure. In group 2, cardiac index increased similarly with nitroprusside and piroximone (1.5 +/- 0.6 to 2.6 +/- 0.8 and 1.6 +/- 0.5 to 2.6 +/- 0.5 liters/min/m2, difference not significant), whereas LV filling pressure decreased slightly less with piroximone (29 +/- 7 to 24 +/- 10 vs 30 +/- 7 to 20 +/- 11 mm Hg, difference not significant). Only nitroprusside reduced mean arterial pressure (88 +/- 13 to 72 +/- 12 mm Hg, p less than 0.001 between drugs). In group 1, systolic blood pressure to end-systolic volume ratio increased in 9 of 10 patients taking both piroximone and dobutamine, whereas in group 2, this ratio increased in 7 of 8 patients taking piroximone and declined in 7 of 8 taking nitroprusside.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

The rational selection of inotropic drugs in cardiac surgery

Despite improvements in surgical technique and intraoperative myocardial protection, certain patients have need for inotropic drug support after cardiac surgery. This review examines drugs that are currently in use for inotropic support of the heart, including calcium, epinephrine, dopamine, dobutamine, isoproterenol, and amrinone. Patient factors that may have an impact on the selection of appropriate drugs are also examined. Application of these data to specific patients must be guided by the particular hemodynamic derangements present. Careful analysis of the specific hemodynamic disorder and tailoring of inotropic therapy to these abnormalities are crucial. Such a rational approach to the selection of inotropic agents requires continuous hemodynamic assessment and recognition that the patient's condition and needs may change rapidly early after heart surgery dictating adjustment of subsequent therapy.