Validation of the beat to beat measurement of blood velocity in the human ascending aorta by a new high temporal resolution Doppler ultrasound spectral analyser

Cardiac output measurements via echocardiography versus thermodilution: A systematic review and meta-analysis

Echocardiography, as a noninvasive hemodynamic evaluation technique, is frequently used in critically ill patients. Different opinions exist regarding whether it can be interchanged with traditional invasive means, such as the pulmonary artery catheter thermodilution (TD) technique. This systematic review aimed to analyze the consistency and interchangeability of cardiac output measurements by ultrasound (US) and TD. Five electronic databases were searched for studies including clinical trials conducted up to June 2019 in which patients’ cardiac output was measured by ultrasound techniques (echocardiography) and TD. The methodological quality of the included studies was evaluated by two independent reviewers who used the Quality Assessment of Diagnostic Accuracy Studies-2 (QUADAS-2), which was tailored according to our systematic review in Review Manager 5.3. A total of 68 studies with 1996 patients were identified as eligible. Meta-analysis and subgroup analysis were used to compare the cardiac output (CO) measured using the different types of echocardiography and different sites of Doppler use with TD. No significant differences were found between US and TD (random effects model: mean difference [MD], -0.14; 95% confidence interval, -0.30 to 0.02; P = 0.08). No significant differences were observed in the subgroup analyses using different types of echocardiography and different sites except for ascending aorta (AA) (random effects model: mean difference [MD], -0.37; 95% confidence interval, -0.74 to -0.01; P = 0.05) of Doppler use. The median of bias and limits of agreement were -0.12 and ±0.94 L/min, respectively; the median of correlation coefficient was 0.827 (range, 0.140–0.998). Although the difference in CO between echocardiography by different types or sites and TD was not entirely consistent, the overall effect of meta-analysis showed that no significant differences were observed between US and TD. The techniques may be interchangeable under certain conditions.

Comparison of pulse contour, aortic Doppler ultrasound and bioelectrical impedance estimates of stroke volume during rapid changes in blood pressure

NEW FINDINGS

What is the central question of this study? Pulse contour analysis of the finger arterial pressure by Windkessel modelling is commonly used to estimate stroke volume continuously. But is it valid during dynamic changes in blood pressure? What is the main finding and its importance? Second-by-second analysis revealed that pulse contour analysis underestimated stroke volume by up to 25% after standing from a squat, and 16% after standing thigh-cuff release, when compared with aortic Doppler ultrasound estimates. These results reveal that pulse contour analysis of stroke volume should be interpreted with caution during rapid changes in physiological state.

ABSTRACT

Dynamic measurements of stroke volume (SV) and cardiac output provide an index of central haemodynamics during transitional states, such as postural changes and onset of exercise. The most widely used method to assess dynamic fluctuations in SV is the Modelflow method, which uses the arterial blood pressure waveform along with age- and sex-specific aortic properties to compute beat-to-beat estimates of aortic flow. Modelflow has been validated against more direct methods in steady-state conditions, but not during dynamic changes in physiological state, such as active orthostatic stress testing. In the present study, we compared the dynamic SV responses from Modelflow (SV_MF ), aortic Doppler ultrasound (SV_U/S ) and bioelectrical impedance analysis (SV_BIA ) during two different orthostatic stress tests, a squat-to-stand (S-S) transition and a standing bilateral thigh-cuff release (TCR), in 15 adults (six females). Second-by-second analysis revealed that when compared with estimates of SV by aortic Doppler ultrasound, Modelflow underestimated SV by up to 25% from 3 to 11 s after standing from the squat position and by up to 16% from 3 to 7 s after TCR (P < 0.05). The SV_MF and SV_BIA were similar during the first minute of the S-S transition, but were different 3 s after TCR and at intermittent time points between 34 and 44 s (P < 0.05). These findings indicate that the physiological conditions elicited by orthostatic stress testing violate some of the inherent assumptions of Modelflow and challenge models used to interpret bioelectrical impedance responses, resulting in an underestimation in SV during rapid changes in physiological state.

Adaptive spectral estimators for fast flow-profile detection

In multigate spectral Doppler (MSD) analysis, hundreds of small sample volumes (SVs) aligned along a pulse wave-line can be simultaneously investigated. The so-called spectral profile, reporting the scatterers' velocity distribution in a vessel, is obtained by estimating the frequency content of the echoes detected from each SV. The preferred frequency estimator is the Welch method, which is robust and fast, but requires an observation window (OW) of at least 64 to 128 samples to guarantee adequate spectral resolution. The blood amplitude and phase estimator (BAPES) and the blood iterative adaptive approach (BIAA) are alternative methods which were recently proven to be capable of producing good spectrograms from one SV using shorter OWs. This paper shows that BAPES and BIAA can be successfully applied to MSD estimations. The use of short OWs can be exploited to produce spectral profiles with high temporal resolution and/or to perform simultaneous investigations at multiple sites. Two in vivo examples of application are reported: in the first, the blood velocity distribution during the fast systolic acceleration in a carotid artery is detailed with high temporal resolution; in the second, four spectral profiles are simultaneously detected at different sites of the carotid bifurcation.

In-vivo validation of fast spectral velocity estimation techniques

Spectrograms in medical ultrasound are usually estimated with Welch's method (WM). WM is dependent on an observation window (OW) of up to 256 emissions per estimate to achieve sufficient spectral resolution and contrast. Two adaptive filterbank methods have been suggested to reduce the OW: Blood spectral Power Capon (BPC) and the Blood Amplitude and Phase EStimation method (BAPES). Ten volunteers were scanned over the carotid artery. From each data set, 28 spectrograms were produced by combining four approaches (WM with a Hanning window (W.HAN), WM with a boxcar window (W.BOX), BPC and BAPES) and seven OWs (128, 64, 32, 16, 8, 4, 2). The full-width-at-half-maximum (FWHM) and the ratio between main and side-lobe levels were calculated at end-diastole for each spectrogram. Furthermore, all 280 spectrograms were randomized and presented to nine radiologists for visual evaluation: useful/not useful. BAPES and BPC compared to WM had better resolution (lower FWHM) for all OW<128 while only BAPES compared to WM had improved contrast (higher ratio). According to the scores given by the radiologists, BAPES, BPC and W.HAN performed equally well (p>0.05) at OW 128 and 64, while W.BOX scored less (p<0.05). At OW 32, BAPES and BPC performed better than WM (p<0.0001) and BAPES was significantly superior to BPC at OW 16 (p=0.0002) and 8 (p<0.0001). BPC at OW 32 performed as well as BPC at OW 128 (p=0.29) and BAPES at OW 16 as BAPES at OW 128 (p=0.55). WM at OW 16 and 8 failed as all four methods at OW 4 and 2. The intra-observer variability tested for three radiologist showed on average good agreement (90%, kappa=0.79) and inter-observer variability showed moderate agreement (78%, kappa=0.56). The results indicated that BPC and BAPES had better resolution and BAPES better contrast than WM, and that OW can be reduced to 32 using BPC and 16 using BAPES without reducing the usefulness of the spectrogram. This could potentially increase the temporal resolution of the spectrogram or the frame-rate of the interleaved B-mode images.

Evaluation of noninvasive methods to assess wave reflection and pulse transit time from the pressure waveform alone

Accurate quantification of pressure wave reflection requires separation of pressure in forward and backward components to calculate the reflection magnitude as the ratio of the amplitudes backward and forward pressure. To do so, measurement of aortic flow in addition to the pressure wave is mandatory, a limitation that can be overcome by replacing the unknown flow wave by an (uncalibrated) triangular estimate. Another extended application of this principle is the derivation of aortic pulse transit time from a single pulse recording. We verified these approximation techniques for reflection magnitude and transit time using carotid pressure and aortic flow waveforms measured noninvasively in the Asklepios Study (>2500 participants; 35 to 55 years of age). A triangular flow approximation using timing information from the measured aortic flow waveform yielded moderate agreement between reference and estimated reflection magnitude (R(2)=0.55). Approximating the flow by a more physiological waveform significantly improved these results (R(2)=0.74). Aortic transit time was assessed using pressure and measured or approximated flow waveforms, and results were compared with carotid-femoral transit times measured by Doppler ultrasound. Agreement between estimated and reference transit times was moderate (R(2)<0.29). Both for reflection magnitude and transit time, agreement between reference and approximated values further decreased when the approximated flow waveform was obtained using timing information from the pressure waveform. We conclude that, in our Asklepios population, results from pressure-based approximative methods to derive reflection magnitude or aortic pulse transit time differ substantially from the values obtained when using both measured pressure and flow information.

Comparisons between electromagnetic and X-beam transit-time flow measurements for evaluating drug actions on cardiac output in the conscious dog

INTRODUCTION

Cardiac output remains an important preclinical measurement for evaluating the cardiovascular effects of drugs. We evaluated the performance of the Triton Active Redirection Transit-Time, ART(2), which represents a new class of X-beam flow systems and compared it in vivo and in vitro to an electromagnetic flow (EMF) system for measuring large vessel flow.

METHODS

In vivo, simultaneous aortic flow measurements were obtained during alpha- and beta-adrenergic receptor stimulation in 5 conscious dogs instrumented with both ART(2) and EMF probes on their ascending aortas. In vitro, simultaneous measurements of volume flow using the ART(2), EMF, and timed-volume collection were made using a novel benchtop flow apparatus that ensured probe alignment and precise timed-volume flow measurements. Accuracy and sensitivity of both systems were assessed by recording flow measurements while varying rates, temperature and hematocrit.

RESULTS

In vivo aortic flow measurements between ART(2) and EMF were closely correlated (linear regression r(2) values ranged from 0.84 to 0.99), with the ART(2) system recording lower flow values than the EMF. In vitro ART(2) flow rates were in excellent agreement with timed-volume flow, while EMF flow rates were lower (p<0.05) and exhibited more variation and dependency upon temperature or hematocrit than the ART(2). Saline flows measured by ART(2) and EMF averaged 97+/-2% and 91+/-5% accuracy, respectively, over the temperature range 32 degrees C to 42 degrees C. For blood hematocrit values between 35% and 45%, ART(2) accuracy averaged 98+/-2%, compared to 89+/-5% accuracy with the EMF.

DISCUSSION

The ART(2) flow measurements in conscious dogs correlated closely to concurrent measurements obtained with the EMF over a wide range of flow rates, even though the absolute aortic flow values differed. Since it accurately measured flow in vitro, the ART(2) system is an appropriate alternative for evaluating cardiovascular effects of disease progression or drug administration in experimental animals.

Spontaneous beat-by-beat fluctuations of total peripheral and cerebrovascular resistance in response to tilt

Beat-by-beat estimates of total peripheral resistance (TPR) can be obtained from continuous measurements of cardiac output by using Doppler ultrasound and noninvasive mean arterial blood pressure (MAP). We employed transfer function analysis to study the heart rate (HR) and vascular response to spontaneous changes in blood pressure from the relationships of systolic blood pressure (SBP) to HR (SBP→HR), MAP to total peripheral resistance (TPR) and cerebrovascular resistance index (CVRi) (MAP→TPR and MAP→CVRi), as well as stroke volume (SV) to TPR in nine healthy subjects in supine and 45° head-up tilt positions. The gain of the SBP→HR transfer function was reduced with tilt in both the low- (0.03–0.15 Hz) and high-frequency (0.15–0.35 Hz) regions. In contrast, MAP→TPR transfer function gain was not affected by head-up tilt, but it did increase from low- to high-frequency regions. The phase relationships between MAP→TPR were unaffected by head-up tilt, but, consistent with an autoregulatory system, changes in MAP were followed by directionally similar changes in TPR, just as observed for the MAP→CVRi. The SV→TPR had high coherence with a constant phase of 150–160°. Together, these data that showed changes in MAP preceded changes in TPR, as well as a possible link between SV and TPR, are consistent with complex interactions between the vascular component of the arterial and cardiopulmonary baroreflexes and intrinsic properties such as the myogenic response of the resistance arteries.

The time course of haemodynamic, autonomic and skeletal muscle metabolic abnormalities following first extensive myocardial infarction in man

We investigated the time course of genesis of skeletal muscle dysfunction and sympatho-vagal imbalance after myocardial infarction. We studied 22 normal controls, 22 patients with >6 months stable chronic heart failure and 10 patients after a first massive myocardial infarction at 1-3 weeks (the "early" period), 6-8 weeks ("mid") and 6-9 months ("late") following their infarct. Four patients developed overt heart failure. Forearm muscle metabolism was studied using (31)P magnetic resonance spectroscopy (MRS). Sympatho-vagal balance was assessed by heart rate variability and radiolabelled norepinephrine kinetics. Increased norepinephrine spillover (0.55+/-0.02 v 0.27+/-0.04 mg/min/m(2); P<0.01) and decreased heart rate variability were confined to those post-myocardial infarction patients who subsequently developed heart failure. Resting cardiac output was normal in all the post-myocardial infarction patients, although the response of cardiac output to supine bicycle exercise at the "mid" study point was less in the group who subsequently developed heart failure (9+/-1 v 41+/-8 %; P<0.005). In the MRS studies, there were no detectable differences between those who did or did not develop heart failure. The initial rate of ATP turnover, calculated from initial-exercise changes in pH and phosphocreatine (PCr), was increased in established chronic heart failure, but in the post-myocardial infarction patients a numerically similar increase reached statistical significance only in the early group (19+/-3 v 11+/-1 mM/min; P<0.005). The apparent maximum rate of oxidative ATP synthesis, calculated from post-exercise PCr recovery kinetics, was lower than control in the late post-myocardial infarction and established chronic heart failure groups 34+/-5 v 55+/-4 mM/min; P<0.03 and 38+/-3 v 55+/-4 mM/min; P<0.003, respectively). Skeletal muscle metabolism and autonomic function become abnormal after an extensive myocardial infarction. While skeletal muscle abnormalities are relatively slow to develop and unrelated to the degree of failure, excessive neurohormonal activation and impaired cardiac output response to exercise seem from an early stage to characterize patients who subsequently develop chronic heart failure.

Effects of pulsed beta-stimulant therapy on beta-adrenoceptors and chronotropic responsiveness in chronic heart failure

In animals, intermittent sympathomimetic stimulation with dobutamine produces benefits analogous to those of physical conditioning. Longer intermittent or continuous beta-stimulant therapies have not, however, been successful in managing patients with chronic heart failure. We have investigated the role of beta-receptor stimulants in patients with severe chronic heart failure by changing the method of administration to intermittent, very short-duration pulsed intrope therapy (PIT). We studied 10 patients (mean age 64 [SE 2] years) with stable moderate to severe chronic heart failure (ejection fraction 23 [3]%) who received PIT, and 10 control patients matched for age and severity. We infused sufficient dobutamine to raise heart rate to 70-80% maximum for 30 min per day, 4 days per week for 3 weeks. PIT increased exercise tolerance (from 10.4 [1.2] min at baseline to 13.0 [1.5] min at 3 weeks; p < 0.001, 95% CI for difference 1.6 to 3.9) and lowered peripheral vascular resistance (19.8 [3.1] to 17.7 [2.4] mm Hg.min.L-1; p < 0.05, -4.1 to -0.1). PIT produced significant increases in lymphocyte beta-receptor density (502 [110] to 1200 [219] per cell, p < 0.02, 258 to 1138) and chronotropic responsiveness to exercise (change in heart rest to peak exercise 51.0 [3.2] to 57.5 [3.9] beats per min; p < 0.01, 2.9-10.1). Plasma noradrenaline concentrations (2.39 [0.28] to 1.65 [0.19] nmol/L, p < 0.05) were reduced. The patients' symptoms were also improved. By contrast, no change in autonomic function or exercise capacity was seen in the control group. Short-duration PIT induces pharmacological conditioning with improved symptoms, autonomic balance, exercise tolerance, beta-receptor up-regulation, and enhanced chronotropic responsiveness in chronic heart failure.

Time course of haemodynamic changes after maximal exercise

The haemodynamic changes during 4 h following maximal upright bicycle exercise were evaluated in six normals in a randomized controlled crossover design. Total peripheral resistance was reduced to 2 h (-6.7 mmHg min l-1, P < 0.05); exercising and non-exercising vascular beds were vasodilated for 2 h (-24.1 and -23.8 mmHg min ml-1 100 ml-1 tissue, respectively, P < 0.05), associated with reductions in systolic (-5.8 mmHg, P < 0.05) and diastolic pressure (-8.3 mmHg, P < 0.05). Rise in cardiac index for 1 h (+0.51 min-1 m-2, P < 0.05) was accounted for by an elevated heart rate (+14.4 beats min-1, P < 0.01) as stroke volume was unchanged. Body temperature was elevated until 40 min (+0.20 degrees C, P < 0.05). The return of all haemodynamic variables to control by 3 h suggests a 3 h limit for a hypotensive effect of exercise. Rise in body temperature is not the only factor responsible for the hypotension.

Load dependence of changes in forearm and peripheral vascular resistance after acute leg exercise in man

1. It is known that acute exercise is often followed by a reduction in arterial blood pressure. Little is known about the time course of the recovery of the blood pressure or the influence of the intensity of the exercise on this response. Controversy exists, in particular, concerning the changes in peripheral resistance that occur during this period. 2. Eight normal volunteers performed, in random order on separate days, voluntary upright bicycle exercise of three different intensities (maximal, moderate and minimal load) and, on another day, a control period of sitting on a bicycle. They were monitored for 60 min after each test. 3. Diastolic pressure fell after maximal exercise at 5 min (-15.45 mmHg) and 60 min (-9.45 mmHg), compared with the control day. Systolic and mean pressure also fell (non-significantly) after 45 min; heart rate was significantly elevated for the whole hour of recovery (at 60 min, +7.23 beats min-1). No changes in post-exercise blood pressure and heart rate were observed on the days of moderate and minimal exercises. 4. An increase in cardiac index was observed after maximal exercise compared with control (at 60 min, 2.6 +/- 0.3 vs. 1.9 +/- 0.2 l min-1 m-2). This was entirely accounted for by the persistent increase in heart rate, with no significant alteration in stroke volume after exercise on any day.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

Hemodynamic effects of captopril and isosorbide mononitrate started early in acute myocardial infarction: a randomized placebo-controlled study

OBJECTIVES

The aim of this study was to study the hemodynamic effects of orally administered captopril and isosorbide mononitrate in suspected acute myocardial infarction.

BACKGROUND

Early treatment with converting enzyme inhibitors and nitrates in acute myocardial infarction may limit infarct expansion and prevent left ventricular dilation.

METHODS

In a double-blind study, 81 patients were randomized within 36 h of the onset of symptoms of suspected acute myocardial infarction to 1 month of oral captopril (6.25 mg initial dose, followed 2 h later by 12.5 mg and continuing with 12.5 mg three times daily), isosorbide mononitrate (initial dose 20 mg followed by 20 mg three times daily) or matching placebo. The effects of treatment on changes from baseline in mean arterial blood pressure, heart rate, stroke volume, cardiac output and systemic vascular resistance were assessed noninvasively using Doppler echocardiography 1 h after the first dose, 1 week after infarction and at 6 weeks (that is, 2 weeks after the scheduled end of trial treatment).

RESULTS

One hour after the start of treatment, blood pressure was reduced by approximately 10% with both captopril and isosorbide mononitrate, but this difference did not persist at 1 week. Captopril was associated with a significant increase in cardiac output compared with placebo of 13 +/- 3% at 1 h (p < 0.01), 23 +/- 5% at 1 week (p < 0.001) and 22 +/- 6% (p < 0.05) at 6 weeks (2 weeks after the end of trial treatment). This increase in cardiac output with captopril was mainly due to a substantial and sustained increase in stroke volume, although there was also a small increase in heart rate at 1 week. Both captopril and isosorbide mononitrate reduced systemic vascular resistance within 1 h of the start of treatment, but only the effect of captopril was sustained (perhaps because the three-times daily nitrate regimen induced tolerance). Study treatment was well tolerated, and the incidence of withdrawal of study treatment for hypotension was not significantly different from that with placebo.

CONCLUSIONS

This study indicates that the hemodynamic effects of both captopril and isosorbide mononitrate are well tolerated in the acute phase of myocardial infarction and that captopril favorably influences cardiac function.