Surgery for glue ear: the English epidemic wanes

Overuse of tympanostomy tubes in New York metropolitan area: evidence from five hospital cohort

OBJECTIVES

To compare tympanostomy tube insertion for children with otitis media in 2002 with the recommendations of two sets of expert guidelines.

DESIGN

Retrospective cohort study.

SETTING

New York metropolitan area practices associated with five diverse hospitals.

PARTICIPANTS

682 of 1046 children who received tympanostomy tubes in the five hospitals for whom charts from the hospital, primary care physician, and otolaryngologist could be accessed.

RESULTS

The mean age was 3.8 years. On average, children with acute otitis media had fewer than four infections in the year before surgery. Children with otitis media with effusion had less than 30 consecutive days of effusion at the time of surgery. Concordance with recommendations was very low: 30.3% (n=207) of all tympanostomies were concordant with the explicit criteria developed for this study and 7.5% (n=13) with the 1994 guideline from the American Academy of Pediatrics, American Academy of Family Medicine, and American Academy of Otolaryngology-Head and Neck Surgery. Children who had previously had tympanostomy tube surgery, who were having a concomitant procedure, or who had "at risk conditions" were more likely to be discordant.

CONCLUSIONS

A significant majority of tympanostomy tube insertions in the largest and most populous metropolitan area in the United States were inappropriate according to the explicit criteria and not recommended according to both guidelines. Regardless of whether current practice represents a substantial overuse of surgery or the guidelines are overly restrictive, the persistent discrepancy between guidelines and practice cannot be good for children or for people interested in improving their health care.

Paediatric otitis media surgery in Norway

CONCLUSIONS

In Norway there are large, regional differences in the incidence of surgery and combinations of surgery for otitis media.

OBJECTIVES

A descriptive study of complete national administrative data on frequency of surgery for otitis media in 2002.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

This study analysed anonymous patient data from the Norwegian patient registry for 2002 and measured rates of tympanostomy tube insertions, myringotomy and the combinations of adenoidectomies and tympanostomy tubes and myringotomy, respectively. Surgical rates were assessed by region and variations within the country were evaluated.

RESULTS

The peak age for surgical treatment of otitis media was 5 years. Tympanostomy tubes were inserted in more than half of the children treated and the analysis showed considerable regional variation in the rates and in choice of surgical treatment.

Parent versus professional views of the developmental impact of a multi-faceted condition at school age: otitis media with effusion ('glue ear')

BACKGROUND

Several aspects of children's health and development are known from empirical studies to be associated with otitis media with effusion (OME; 'glue ear'). The 'diffuse image' has been an obstacle to defining a core set of impacts about which inter-profession and parent-professional communication can be effective.

AIMS

The study quantifies similarities and differences in how the signs, symptoms, and developmental impact of OME are attributed and construed, between teachers, parents, and ear, nose, and throat (ENT)surgeons.

SAMPLE

Convenience samples were achieved of 118 teachers and 154 parents of affected children; 178 ENT surgeons from a professional sampling frame (association membership) responded.

METHOD

Questionnaires elicited the perceived frequency and concern-value of over 30 manifestations of OME--the various signs, symptoms, and behaviours suggested by the literature. Factor scores derived on the combined sample were compared between respondent groups.

RESULTS

Teachers assign high importance to education and language problems but, relative to parents, they accord lower importance to continuing hearing problems. Teachers and parents weighted behaviour and balance problems similarly, placing behaviour higher, but balance lower, than the ENT specialists did.

CONCLUSIONS

(1) A four-factor reduction of simple questionnaire items well defines the domains of impact of OME, and can express the ways in which views of impact differ between teachers, ENT specialists and parents.(2) Considerable differences of perspective exist between the groups examined. (3) In valuing a set of measured outcomes on actual children, or for other policy research, sets of weights are now available to represent the differing perspectives of parents and professionals (e.g. in testing robustness of a conclusion across differing stakeholder perspectives). (4) The research and development need in respect of teachers' involvement with OME could profitably play to existing strengths. This implies the systematic and structured acquisition and evaluation of teacher-provided impact information.

Myringotomy and tympanostomy tube placement in children with sickle cell disease

OBJECTIVE

To assess the event rate of myringotomy and tube placement (M&T) in the pediatric patient population with sickle cell disease (SCD).

METHODS

Four hundred and forty-nine children with confirmed SCD have been followed over a period of 11.5 years at two hospital-based pediatric hematology and otolaryngology offices, and three tertiary care hospitals. Children with SCD who had undergone M&T were identified via computer search of International Classification of Diseases codes by the medical records departments of the three hospitals, and from two databases of the hematology offices. The inpatient and outpatient medical records of all children identified were reviewed.

RESULTS

For the 449 patients, mean duration of SCD follow-up was 6.13 +/- 3.36 years. Of these, eight patients (four boys, four girls, mean age 9 +/- 3.5 years; four patients had hemoglobin SC disease, and four patients had sickle cell anemia type SS) underwent M&T. Two children met criteria for severe SCD. The event rate for M&T insertion was 0.29/100 person-years, 95% CI (0.15, 0.58).

CONCLUSIONS

The event rate for M&T in children with SCD, compared to a historical control group, is lower than that of the general population. Type and severity of SCD were not predictive of the need for tube insertion. Children with sickle cell disease do not have an increased rate of M&T insertion.

Speech reception in noise: an indicator of benefit from otitis media with effusion surgery

To determine possible selection criteria for ventilation tubes (VTs - grommets), in otitis media with effusion (OME), a randomized trial on 68 children was undertaken. To provide both a baseline predictor and outcome measure in auditory disability, speech-in-noise thresholds were obtained with the IHR-McCormick Automated Toy Test (SiN ATT). Children allocated to surgery (n = 32) and control (n = 36) were followed-up at 3 and 12 months postintervention. Baseline SiN ATT score provided a significant by-treatment interaction in predicting the performance at +3 months, establishing it as an evidence-based indicator. Although average benefits on hearing level score (HL) were also shown, baseline HL was not a valid indicator (no significant interaction). The 40% of the sample with worst baseline SiN experienced high benefit from VTs. In children over 3 years of age, baseline SiN performance can indicate those with OME most likely to benefit from VTs.

Reduction in the use of surgery for glue ear: did national guidelines have an impact?

BACKGROUND

It is widely accepted that the passive dissemination of national clinical guidance has little or no impact on practice.

OBJECTIVE

To assess the impact in England of an Effective Health Care bulletin on childhood surgery for glue ear issued in 1992 and to understand the reasons for any change (or lack of change) in practice that ensued.

METHOD

Time series analysis of the rate of use of surgery by children under 10 years of age from 1975 to 1997/8 in 13 English health districts.

RESULTS

Following a rise in the rate of surgery in public (National Health Service) hospitals from 1975 to 1985, the rate declined by 1.6% a year from 1986 to 1992/3. Following publication of the guidelines in November 1992, the rate of decline increased to 10.1% a year. Even after allowing for a slight increase in the use of independent (private) hospitals between 1992/3 and 1997/8, the overall rate of decline was at least 7.9%. It appears that the rate of referral of cases by primary care physicians (general practitioners) halved during this period. Several contextual factors are thought to have contributed to the effect of the guidelines, including pre-existing professional concern about the value of surgery, the introduction of an internal market into the NHS, and growing apprehension among parents fuelled by scepticism in the mass media. During this unprecedented period of rapid change in usage, staff delivering the service remained unaware of the alterations in their own practice.

CONCLUSIONS

Passive dissemination of national guidelines can accelerate an existing trend in clinical practice if the context is hospitable. Policy makers should identify and target such situations.

Infrared transtympanic temperature measurement and otitis media with effusion

Body temperature is an important clinical measurement. It can be estimated by sublingual, rectal, axillary or skin measurement. Pulmonary artery temperature measurement is the gold standard in the research setting, but is obviously inapplicable for routine clinical use. Infrared estimation of core temperature at the tympanic membrane has been proposed as an effective and accurate method. We investigate whether the common condition of childhood otitis media with effusion (OME) interferes with this mode of body temperature measurement. Ninety-five children undergoing grommet tube insertion were assessed preoperatively by axillary and transtympanic routes. The presence or absence of middle ear fluid was noted at the time of surgery. Analysis of the data showed no influence of OME on the measurement of body temperature by the transtympanic route compared with axillary measurement.

Paediatric otolaryngology--disease profile and characteristics of children in outpatient surgery

Data were collected from 178 consecutively operated children during a 6-week period at an Oslo hospital in order to study disease profile and routines for referral and treatment in outpatient otorhinolaryngologic surgery. Median time from referral to surgery was less than 4 months. The majority of the children subjected to operation for recurrent acute otitis media, tonsillitis or upper respiratory infections had suffered from the disease for 12 months or less. Obstructive symptoms were registered in 18% of the children. Hospital referrals and controls came mainly from ENT (ear, nose and throat) specialists or paediatricians. Significantly more boys were subjected to surgery. Median age at the time of surgery was 4.2 years, and there was an equal distribution of pharyngeal and middle ear surgery. The numerous combinations of middle ear surgery reflect the non-specific treatment guidelines for otitis media.

Otolaryngologists' perceptions of the indications for tympanostomy tube insertion in children

BACKGROUND

Bilateral myringotomy with insertion of tympanostomy tubes is the most common operation that children in Canada undergo. Area variations in surgical rates for this procedure have raised questions about indications used to decide about surgery. The objective of this study was to describe the factors that influence otolaryngologists to recommend tympanostomy tube insertion in children with otitis media and their level of agreement about indications for surgery.

METHODS

A survey was sent to all 227 otolaryngologists in Ontario in the fall of 1996. The influence of 17 clinical and social factors on recommendations to insert tympanostomy tubes were assessed. Case vignettes were used to determine the effect of multiple factors in decisions about the need for surgical management.

RESULTS

Surveys were returned by 138 (68.3%) of the 202 eligible otolaryngologists. There was agreement (more than 90% of respondents) about 6 indications for surgery: persistent effusion, a lack of improvement after 3 months of antibiotic therapy, a history of persistent effusion for 3 or more months per episode of otitis media, more than 7 episodes of otitis media in 6 months, a bilateral conductive hearing loss of 20 dB or more and a persistently abnormal tympanic membrane. Some respondents were more likely to recommend tube insertion if there were parental concerns about hearing problems or the frequency or severity of episodes of otitis media. Otolaryngologists agreed about the role of tympanostomy tubes in 1 of 4 case vignettes but disagreed about whether adenoidectomy should also be performed in that instance. Most viewed tympanostomy tube insertion as beneficial, with few adverse effects.

INTERPRETATION

There is a lack of consensus among practising otolaryngologists in Ontario as to which children with recurrent otitis media or persistent effusion should undergo bilateral myringotomy with tympanostomy tube insertion. These findings suggest the need to revisit clinical guidelines for this procedure.

The acceptance of hearing aids for children with otitis media with effusion

Conservative treatment for otitis media with effusion (OME) led us to consider the use of hearing aids as a way of managing the associated hearing loss. This study aimed to assess the compliance of patients and acceptance of hearing aids for the management of children with OME. Thirty-nine children who had been given binaural hearing aids to manage OME were assessed at routine follow-up after six months. A clinician who did not prescribe the aid administered a questionnaire to assess compliance, change in symptoms and acceptance of the aids. Thirty-eight parents thought the aids were easy to use and 25 (66 per cent) were completely satisfied with the management. Aided hearing improved by a mean of 17 dB (Range 10-30) over three frequencies, 0.5, 1.0, 2.0 Khz and all parents reported subjective hearing improvement in their children. The stigma of an aid was reported as minimal under the age of seven. Hearing aids provide a non-invasive way of managing the problems associated with OME which is acceptable to certain parents and children. Long-term effects of using aids need to be evaluated before they can be recommended.

Short-term benefits of grommet insertion in children

It is commonly acknowledged that otitis media with effusion (OME) can cause behavioural disturbances and that this can be relieved by grommet insertion. However, this widely-held perception has not been documented in the literature. In this study parents were asked to complete a short behavioural questionnaire on the day of the admission and 6 weeks later. A total of 32 children admitted to the Day Care Unit for insertion of grommets at The Royal National Throat, Nose and Ear Hospital, London, UK, were recruited. There was a significant behavioural change, evident by the difference in the scores before and after grommet insertion (P < 0.001).

Grommet insertion in children: a survey of parental perceptions

Grommet insertion is a widely accepted method of treatment of glue ear in children. There have been questions raised over the last few years about the indications for grommets and whether assessing the hearing alone is an efficient outcome measure. Parental pressure accounts for one of the factors that is taken into consideration when the decision to insert grommets for glue ear is made. In this paper, a prospective questionnaire is used to investigate the parental perceptions of the effectiveness of grommet insertion in children, focusing on alternative outcome measures such as general health, language, and social skills. The results of this survey suggest that grommet insertion causes improvement in many factors other than hearing and this seems to account for the parental pressure for siblings to have grommet insertion.

Developing information materials to present the findings of technology assessments to consumers. The experience of the NHS Centre for Reviews and Dissemination

We discuss some of the issues that have arisen during the development and introduction into practice of information materials for health professionals and patients that aim to promote clinical effectiveness and informed patient participation in clinical decision making.