Efficacy of patent foramen ovale closure for treating migraine: a prospective follow-up study

Rationale and design of the SPRING trail: effectivity and safety of Pfo closuRe vs medIcine in alleviatiNg migraine, a multicenter, randomized and open-label trail

BACKGROUND

Migraine is a leading cause of disability worldwide. Several retrospective studies have suggested that the closure of the Patent Foramen Ovale (PFO) may provide relief from migraines. However, three randomized controlled trials did not meet their primary endpoints regarding migraine cessation, reduction in monthly migraine days, and responder rates.

METHODS

The SPRING study is a multicenter, prospective, randomized, and open-label trial designed to compare the effectiveness and safety of PFO closure versus medication in the relief of migraines. The primary endpoint is the total cessation of migraines, as recorded in patient headache diaries during the follow-up period. Additional diagnostic tools include echocardiography with agitated saline contrast, transcranial Doppler, and routine laboratory measurements.

CONCLUSION

The SPRING trial aims to assess the effectiveness and safety of PFO closure versus medication in mitigating migraines in real-world settings. (Clinical Trails ID: NCT04946734).

Predictors of recurrent cerebral ischemia after patent foramen ovale closure: A single center observational study

OBJECTIVES

Transcatheter patent foramen ovale closure lowers recurrent stroke in patients with cryptogenic stroke or transient ischemic attack with an indication for closure. However, the incidence of recurrent stroke is not negligible and underlying pathophysiology remains largely unknown. We sought to evaluate the prevalence of recurrent ischemic neurological events and to assess its predictors after transcatheter patent foramen ovale closure.

METHODS

We enrolled consecutive patients who underwent patent foramen ovale closure for secondary prevention of neurological ischemic events at the University Hospital of Parma between 2006 and 2021. Clinical and procedure-related features were collected for each patient. The incidence of recurrent ischemic neurological events was assessed at follow-up.

RESULTS

We enrolled a total of 169 patients with mean Risk of Paradoxical Embolism score at hospital admission of 6.4 ± 1.5. The primary indication was previous cryptogenic stroke (94 [55.6 %] subjects), followed by transient ischemic attack (75 [44.4 %]). Among patients with complete outcome data (n= 154), after a median follow-up of 112 months, recurrent cerebral ischemia occurred in 13 [8.4 %], with an annualized rate of 0.92/100 patients. The presence of obesity [OR 5.268, p = 0.018], Risk of Paradoxical Embolism score < 7 [OR 5.991, p = 0.035] and migraine [OR = 5.932 p = 0.012] were independent positive predictors of recurrent stroke/ transient ischemic attack after patent foramen ovale closure.

CONCLUSIONS

The presence of obesity, Risk of Paradoxical Embolism score < 7 and migraine were independent positive predictors of recurrent ischemic neurological events after patent foramen ovale closure.

Efficacy and safety of transesophageal ultrasound-guided patent foramen ovale closure for migraine in adolescents

Objective

This retrospective analysis aims to assess the efficacy of transesophageal ultrasound-guided patent foramen ovale (PFO) closure in treating migraine in adolescents and compare the therapeutic outcomes of PFO closure for migraine with and without aura.

Methods

We conducted a retrospective analysis of 86 cases of adolescents (12-20 years old) who underwent PFO closure for migraine at our institution over the past 3 years. The efficacy was evaluated using the visual analogue scale (VAS), headache impact test (HIT)-6, and pediatric migraine disability assessment (PedMIDAS) scores, as well as by assessing the monthly frequency of migraine attacks, duration of each attack, and overall migraine burden. The patients were divided into two groups: an aura group (55 cases) and a non-aura group (31 cases) to investigate difference in therapeutic efficacy between the groups. The effect of residual shunt on migraine burden was assessed.

Results

Among the 86 patients, 46 (54%) experienced complete remission of migraine, while 71 (83%) achieved a >50% reduction in migraine burden during the one-year follow-up period. Patients in the aura group showed more significant improvements in VAS, HIT-6, and PedMIDAS scores, as well as in monthly migraine attack frequency, duration of each attack, and overall migraine burden, than patients in the non-aura group. Moreover, patients with residual shunt did not exhibit statistically significant differences in therapeutic efficacy compared to patients with complete closure.

Conclusion

PFO closure can effectively alleviate migraine symptoms in adolescents with migraine with concomitant PFO. The therapeutic efficacy is particularly pronounced for migraine with aura. Furthermore, minor levels of residual shunt have no effect on the improvement in migraine symptoms.

The Influence of Patent Foramen Ovale on the Clinical Features of Migraine without Aura: A Cross-Sectional Study

Objective

To investigate the influence of patent foramen ovale (PFO) on the clinical features of migraine without aura (MoA).

Methods

We consecutively enrolled 390 MoA patients and compared the frequency of headache, episode duration, and the Visual Analogue Scale (VAS), Headache Impact Test 6 (HIT-6), and European Health Interview Survey-Quality of Life 8-item index (EUROHIS-QOL8) scores of patients with and without PFO, those with the mild right-to-left shunt (RLS) and moderate to large RLS, and those with permanent RLS and latent RLS using a nonparametric Mann-Whitney U-test. In addition, we analyzed the clinical features of migraine in 39 MoA patients before and after PFO closure treatment using the paired Wilcoxon test.

Results

The prevalence of PFO in the 390 MoA patients was 44.4%. Patients with PFO had significantly higher frequency of headaches, VAS scores, HIT-6 scores, and incidence of white matter lesions than those without PFO (all p< 0.05). Patients with moderate to large RLS had significantly higher VAS scores than those with mild RLS (p = 0.002). Additionally, 39 MoA patients underwent PFO closure, which remarkably decreased their frequency of headache, episode duration, VAS scores, and HIT-6 scores, and increased their EUROHIS-QOL8 scores.

Conclusion

The migraine features in MoA patients could be influenced by PFO, especially in patients with moderate to large shunt, in whom PFO closure improved the symptoms.

A study on the correlation of the asymmetric regulation between the periaqueductal gray and the bilateral trigeminal nucleus caudalis in migraine male rats

BACKGROUND

The study was designed to explore the correlation of the asymmetric regulation between periaqueductal gray (PAG) and bilateral trigeminal nucleus caudalis (TNC) in migraine rats through studying the changes of metabolites in pain regulatory pathway of acute migraine attack.

METHODS

Thirty male Sprague-Dawley (SD) rats were randomly divided into three groups: blank, control, model groups. Then, blank group was intraperitoneally injected with ultrapure water, while control group injected with saline and model group injected with Glyceryl Trinitrate (GTN). Two hours later, PAG and bilateral TNC were removed respectively, and metabolite concentrations of PAG, Left-TNC, Right-TNC were obtained. Lastly, the differences of metabolite among three brain tissues were compared.

RESULTS

The relative concentrations of rNAA, rGlu, rGln, rTau, rMI in PAG or bilateral TNC had interaction effects between groups and sites. The concentration of rLac of three brain tissues increased in migraine rats, however, the rLac of LTNC and RTNC increased more than that of PAG. Besides, the concentrations of rNAA and rGln increased in RTNC, while rGABA decreased in RTNC.

CONCLUSIONS

There is correlation between PAG, LTNC and RTNC in regulation of pain during acute migraine attack, and the regulation of LTNC and RTNC on pain is asymmetric.

Effect of Interventional Therapy Unexplained Dizziness and Relationship Between Dizziness Handicap Inventory and Right-to-Left Shunt Grading

Objective

Unexplained dizziness remains a clinical challenge. Our previous studies have shown that unexplained dizziness may be related to patent foramen ovale (PFO). This study aims to explore whether the degree of shunt is correlated with the degree of unexplained dizziness and looking for the possible clinical intervention for patients with unexplained dizziness.

Methods

This study was a large single-center, prospective, controlled study. From March 2019 to March 2022, patients with unexplained dizziness and explained dizziness and healthy controls were recruited. Contrast-enhanced transcranial Doppler sonography (c-TCD) was performed to detect the existence of right-to-left shunt (RLS) and shunt grading. The dizziness handicap inventory (DHI) was completed to evaluate the dizziness. Unexplained dizziness patients with large amount of PFO were volunteered to receive medication treatment and transcatheter PFO closure and followed up six months.

Results

A total of 387 patients (132 unexplained, 123 explained and 132 controls) were enrolled. There was a statistical difference in the RLS grading with three groups (p < 0.001). The Spearman correlation coefficient of RLS grading and DHI scores in unexplained dizziness patients (r=0.122, p=0.163) and explained dizziness patients (r=0.067, p=0.460). In the unexplained group, there were 49 cases with massive grading RLS. Of which 25 patients received percutaneous PFO closure treatment and 24 cases received medication treatment. Followed up six months after treatment, the amount of DHI scores change in patients who received the percutaneous PFO closure was significantly higher than that in the medication treatment group (p < 0.001).

Conclusion

RLS may play an important role in unexplained dizziness. For unexplained dizziness patients, PFO closure may contribute to better outcomes. In the future, large-scale randomized controlled studies are still needed.

Patent Foramen Ovale Closure for Treating Migraine: A Meta-Analysis

Background

Observational studies have shown percutaneous patent foramen ovale (PFO) closure to be a safe means of reducing the frequency and duration of migraine.

Objective

This study evaluated the efficacy and safety of PFO closure in patients with migraine using evidence-based medicine.

Methods

The Pubmed (MEDLINE), Embase, and Cochrane Library databases were searched for randomized controlled trials (RCTs), cohort studies, and retrospective case series from January 1, 2001, to February 30, 2021. The Jadad scale and R 4.1.0 software were used to assess the quality of the literature and meta-analysis, respectively.

Results

In total, three randomized controlled trials, one pooled study, and eight retrospective case series including 1,165 participants were included in the meta-analysis. Compared with control intervention in migraine, PFO closure could significantly reduce headache frequency (OR = 1.5698, 95% CI: 1.0465–2.3548, p=0.0293) and monthly migraine attacks and monthly migraine days (OR = 0.2594, 95% CI: 0.0790–0.4398, p=0.0048). Subgroup analysis of patients who all completed PFO surgery showed resolution of migraine headache for migraines with aura (OR = 1.5856, 95% CI: 1.0665–2.3575, p=0.0227).

Conclusions

Treatment with PFO closure could reduce the frequency of headaches and monthly migraine days and is an efficient treatment for migraine attacks with aura.