The very low penetrance of cystic fibrosis for the R117H mutation: a reappraisal for genetic counselling and newborn screening

Genetic counseling access and service delivery in New York State is variable for parents of infants with complex CFTR genotypes conferring uncertain phenotypes

BACKGROUND

New York State (NYS) utilizes a three-tiered cystic fibrosis newborn screening (CFNBS) algorithm that includes cystic fibrosis transmembrane conductance regulator (CFTR) gene sequencing. Infants with >1 CFTR variant of potential clinical relevance, including variants of uncertain significance or varying clinical consequence are referred for diagnostic evaluation at NYS cystic fibrosis (CF) Specialty Care Centers (SCCs).

AIMS

As part of ongoing quality improvement efforts, demographic, screening, diagnostic, and clinical data were evaluated for 289 CFNBS-positive infants identified in NYS between December 2017 and November 2020 who did not meet diagnostic criteria for CF and were classified as either: CFTR-related metabolic syndrome/CF screen positive, inconclusive diagnosis (CRMS/CFSPID) or CF carriers.

RESULTS

Overall, 194/289 (67.1%) had CFTR phasing to confirm whether the infant's CFTR variants were in cis or in trans. Eighteen complex alleles were identified in cis; known haplotypes (p.R117H+5T, p.F508del+p.L467F, and p.R74W+p.D1270N) were the most common identified. Thirty-two infants (16.5%) with all variants in cis were reclassified as CF carriers rather than CRMS/CFSPID. Among 263 infants evaluated at an NYS SCC, 70.3% were reported as having received genetic counseling about their results by any provider, with 96/263 (36.5%) counseled by a certified genetic counselor.

CONCLUSION

Given the particularly complex genetic interpretation of results generated by CFNBS algorithms including sequencing analysis, additional efforts are needed to ensure families of infants with a positive CFNBS result have CFTR phasing when needed to distinguish carriers from infants with CRMS/CFSPID, and access to genetic counseling to address implications of CFNBS results.

The dominant findings of a recessive man: from Mendel's kid pea to kidney

The research of Mendel, born two centuries ago, still has many direct implications for our everyday clinical work. He introduced the terms "dominant" and "recessive" characters and determined their 3:1 ratio in the offspring of heterozygous "hybrid" plants. This distribution allowed calculation of the number of the phenotype-determining "elements," i.e., the alleles, and has been used ever since to prove the monogenic origin of a disorder. The Mendelian inheritance of monogenic kidney disorders is still of great help in distinguishing them from those with multifactorial origin in clinical practice. Inheritance of most monogenic kidney disorders fits to Mendel's observations: the equal contribution of the two parents and the complete penetrance or the direct correlation between the frequency of the recessive character and the degree of inbreeding. Nevertheless, beyond the truth of these basic concepts, several observations have expanded their genetic characteristics. The extreme genetic heterogeneity, the pleiotropy of the causal genes and the role of modifiers in ciliopathies, the digenic inheritance and parental imprinting in some tubulopathies, and the incomplete penetrance and eventual interallelic interactions in podocytopathies, reflect this expansion. For all these reasons, the transmission pattern in a natural setting may depend not only on the "character" but also on the causal gene and the variant. Mendel's passion for research combined with his modest personality and meticulous approach can still serve as an example in the work required to understand the non-Mendelian universe of genetics.

Recommendations for risk allele evidence curation, classification, and reporting from the ClinGen Low Penetrance/Risk Allele Working Group

PURPOSE

Genetic variants at the low end of the penetrance spectrum have historically been challenging to interpret because their high population frequencies exceed the disease prevalence of the associated condition, leading to a lack of clear segregation between the variant and disease. There is currently substantial variation in the classification of these variants, and no formal classification framework has been widely adopted. The Clinical Genome Resource Low Penetrance/Risk Allele Working Group was formed to address these challenges and promote harmonization within the clinical community.

METHODS

The work presented here is the product of internal and community Likert-scaled surveys in combination with expert consensus within the Working Group.

RESULTS

We formally recognize risk alleles and low-penetrance variants as distinct variant classes from those causing highly penetrant disease that require special considerations regarding their clinical classification and reporting. First, we provide a preferred terminology for these variants. Second, we focus on risk alleles and detail considerations for reviewing relevant studies and present a framework for the classification these variants. Finally, we discuss considerations for clinical reporting of risk alleles.

CONCLUSION

These recommendations support harmonized interpretation, classification, and reporting of variants at the low end of the penetrance spectrum.

Optimization of performance of Dutch newborn screening for cystic fibrosis

BACKGROUND

Dutch newborn screening (NBS) for Cystic Fibrosis (CF) introduced in 2011 showed a sensitivity of 90% and a positive predictive value (PPV) of 63%. We describe a study including an optimization phase and evaluation of the modified protocol.

METHODS

Dutch protocol consists of four steps: determination of immunoreactive trypsinogen (IRT) and pancreatitis-associated protein (PAP), DNA analysis by INNO-LiPA and extended gene analysis (EGA). For the optimization phase we used results of 556,952 newborns screened between April 2011 and June 2014 to calculate effects of 13 alternative protocols on sensitivity, specificity, PPV, ratios of CF to other diagnoses, and costs. One alternative protocol was selected based on calculated sensitivity, PPV and costs and was implemented on 1st July 2016. In this modified protocol DNA analysis is performed in samples with a combination of IRT ≥60 µg/l and PAP ≥3.0 µg/l, IRT ≥100 µg/l and PAP ≥1.2 µg/l or IRT ≥124 µg/l and PAP not relevant. Results of 599,137 newborns screened between 1st July 2016 and 31st December 2019 were similarly evaluated as in the optimization phase.

RESULTS

The modified protocol showed a sensitivity of 95%, PPV of 76%, CF to CF transmembrane conductance regulator-related metabolic syndrome/CF screen positive, inconclusive diagnoses (CRMS/CFSPID) ratio 12/1, CF/CF carrier ratio 4/1. Costs per screened newborn were slightly higher. Eleven children, of whom five with classic CF, would not have been referred with the previous protocol.

CONCLUSIONS

The modified protocol results in acceptable sensitivity (95%) and good PPV of 76% with minimal increase in costs.

The Effect of Complex Alleles of the CFTR Gene on the Clinical Manifestations of Cystic Fibrosis and the Effectiveness of Targeted Therapy

The authors of this article analyzed the available literature with the results of studying the prevalence of complex alleles of the CFTR gene among patients with cystic fibrosis, and their pathogenicity and influence on targeted therapy with CFTR modulators. Cystic fibrosis (CF) is a multisystemic autosomal recessive disease caused by a defect in the expression of the CFTR protein, and more than 2000 genetic variants are known. Clinically significant variants are divided into seven classes. Information about the frequency of complex alleles appears in a number of registers, along with the traditional presentation of data on genetic variants. Complex alleles (those with the presence of more than two nucleotide variants on one allele) can complicate the diagnosis of the disease, and change the clinical manifestations of cystic fibrosis and the response to treatment, since each variant in the complex allele can contribute to the functional activity of the CFTR protein, changing it both in terms of increasing and decreasing function. The role of complex alleles is often underestimated, and their frequency has not been studied. At the moment, characteristic frequently encountered complex alleles have been found for several populations of patients with cystic fibrosis, but the prevalence and pathogenicity of newly detected complex alleles require additional research. In this review, more than 35 complex alleles of the CFTR gene from existing research studies were analyzed, and an analysis of their influence on the manifestations of the disease and the effectiveness of CFTR modulators was also described.

Delayed identification of compound heterozygous (Phe508del/Arg117His) cystic fibrosis variants in a patient awaiting liver transplantation

A man in his 60s undergoing liver transplant assessment was referred to the respiratory team after a thoracic CT scan revealed diffuse tree-in-bud changes. He had a history of infertility, chronic pancreatitis and liver cirrhosis with portal hypertension. Broncho-alveolar lavage was positive for Pseudomonas aeruginosa Genetic screening found two cystic fibrosis transmembrane conductance regulator variants: Phe508del and Arg117His-7T. The patient was referred to the regional cystic fibrosis (CF) centre for follow-up but died from hepatobiliary complications. The atypical presentation with relatively late onset of pulmonary disease and hepatobiliary disease predominance created a diagnostic challenge. This case is a reminder that while CF is a monogenic disorder, its manifestation, natural history and extent can be highly variable. Taking a thorough medical history of any chronic illness is essential, and patients with the appropriate clinical presentation, regardless of age, should be investigated for CF.

A Case of Severe Hepatitis in Infant Twins With COVID-19

We report a case of nine-month-old twins who presented with bright green diarrhea along with progressively worsening jaundice over one week. On initial evaluation, they were found to have significantly elevated liver enzymes, bilirubin, and alkaline phosphatase levels but without signs of liver failure. They were tested for multiple causes of liver injury including autoimmune and infectious etiologies, which were negative as well. Both twins were incidentally found to be positive for COVID-19 on testing per hospital protocol but did not have any respiratory symptoms. They were monitored closely during their hospital stay and showed clinical stability but with only slight improvement in abnormal lab levels. Ultimately, they were discharged with close outpatient follow-up. They demonstrated full resolution of all lab abnormalities and symptoms two months post discharge.

Gradual increase in sweat chloride concentration is associated with a higher risk of CRMS/CFSPID to CF reclassification

OBJECTIVES

Universal implementation of cystic fibrosis (CF) newborn screening (NBS) has led to the diagnostic dilemma of infants with CF screen-positive, inconclusive diagnosis (CFSPID), with limited guidance regarding prognosis and standardized care. Rates of reclassification from CFSPID to CF vary and risk factors for reclassification are not well established. We investigated whether clinical characteristics are associated with the risk of reclassification from CFSPID to a CF diagnosis.

METHODS

Children with a positive CF NBS were recruited from two sites in California. Retrospective, longitudinal, and cross-sectional data were collected. A subset of subjects had nasal epithelial cells collected for CF transmembrane conductance regulator (CFTR) functional assessment. Multivariate logistic regression was used to assess the risk of reclassification.

RESULTS

A total of 112 children completed the study (CF = 53, CFSPID = 59). Phenotypic characteristics between groups showed differences in pancreatic insufficiency prevalence, immunoreactive trypsinogen (IRT) levels, and Pseudomonas aeruginosa (PSA) colonization. Spirometry measures were not different between groups. Nasal epithelial cells from 10 subjects showed 7%-30% of wild-type (WT)-CFTR (wtCFTR) function in those who reclassified and 27%-67% of wtCFTR function in those who retained the CFSPID designation. Modeling revealed that increasing sweat chloride concentration (sw[Cl^- ]) and PSA colonization were independent risk factors for reclassification to CF.

CONCLUSION

Increasing sw[Cl^- ] and a history of PSA colonization are associated with the risk of reclassification from CFSPID to CF in a population with high IRT and two CFTR variants. A close follow-up to monitor phenotypic changes remains critical in this population. The role of CFTR functional assays in this population requires further exploration.

Impact of Pancreatitis-Associated Protein on Newborn Screening Outcomes and Detection of CFTR-Related Metabolic Syndrome (CRMS)/Cystic Fibrosis Screen Positive, Inconclusive Diagnosis (CFSPID): A Monocentric Prospective Pilot Experience

Pancreatitis-Associated Protein (PAP)-based Cystic Fibrosis (CF) newborn bloodspot screening (NBS) protocols detect less CFTR-Related Metabolic Syndrome (CRMS)/CF Screen Positive, Inconclusive Diagnosis (CFSPID). We prospectively evaluated the impact of PAP as the second step of the CF NBS protocol, before the CFTR genetic analysis, on NBS outcomes and CRMS/CFSPID detection in the Tuscany region, Italy. In parallel to the usual protocol (IRT/DNA, protocol 1), PAP was analyzed in IRT-positive infants (IRT/PAP/DNA, protocol 2) from 1 June 2020 until 31 May 2022. We defined an infant as NBS positive if PAP was >1.8 μg/L for IRT value 99th percentile-100 μg/L or >0.6 μg/L for IRT value >100 μg/L. To increase the positive predictive value (PPV) of protocol 2, we retrospectively lowered the upper IRT range value from 100 to 90 μg/L (modified protocol 2). We identified 8 CF and 13 CRMS/CFSPID with protocol 1, 5 CF and 5 CRMS/CFSPID with protocol 2 and 8 CF and 5 CRMS/CFSPID with modified protocol 2. With the PAP-based protocols, we observed a reduction of sweat tests, healthy carrier detection and a significant increase in PPV to 15.38%. Further data are needed in order to evaluate the outcomes of CRMS/CFSPID after a long follow-up.

Determination of Cystic Fibrosis Mutation Frequency in Preterm and Term Neonates with Respiratory Tract Problems

Cystic fibrosis (CF) is an autosomal recessive disease. The genetic transition occurs with CF transmembrane conductance regulator (CFTR) gene mutation. We aimed to determine the frequency of CF mutations and also new mutations in the CFTR gene in neonates with respiratory distress. Newborn babies hospitalized due to respiratory distress were included in the patient group. The control group consisted of infants who had no respiratory distress. The CFTR genes of both groups were analyzed using polymerase chain reaction (PCR) and restriction fragment length polymorphism (RFLP) methods. A total of 40 patients (20 in the patient group and 20 in the control group) were evaluated. The CFTR gene analysis was normal in 16 neonates in the patient group, whereas in others: A46D (c.137C>A) (n = 1), D1312G (c.3935A>G) (n = 1), R117H (c.350G>A) (n = 1), S1426P (c.4276T>C) (n = 1) heterozygotes were detected; CFTR gene analysis was normal at 14 neonates in the control group, whereas in others: E1228G (c.3683A>G) (n = 1), E217G (c.650A>G) (n = 1), E632TfsX9 (c1894_1895delAG) (n = 1), I807M (c.2421 A>G) (n = 2), S573F (c.1718C>T) (n = 1) heterozygotes were detected. There was no significant difference in the patient and control groups’ CFTR gene analysis (p = 0.340). This study demonstrates the importance of CFTR gene analysis in asymptomatic newborn infants for follow-up and early diagnosis of CFTR-related disorders. In this study, a c.1894_1895delAG (E632TfsX9) heterozygous mutation detected in the CFTR gene in an asymptomatic newborn infant, was first encountered in the literature.

Reclassifying inconclusive diagnosis after newborn screening for cystic fibrosis. Moving forward

BACKGROUND

Newborn screening for Cystic Fibrosis (CF) is associated with situations where the diagnosis of CF or CFTR related disorders (CFTR-RD) cannot be clearly ruled out.

MATERIALS/PATIENTS AND METHODS

We report a case series of 23 children with unconclusive diagnosis after newborn screening for CF and a mean follow-up of 7.7 years (4-13). Comprehensive investigations including whole CFTR gene sequencing, in vivo intestinal current measurement (ICM), nasal potential difference (NPD), and in vitro functional studies of variants of unknown significance, helped to reclassify the patients.

RESULTS

Extensive genetic testing identified, in trans with a CF causing mutation, variants with varying clinical consequences and 3 variants of unknown significance (VUS). Eighteen deep intronic variants were identified by deep resequencing of the whole CFTR gene in 13 patients and were finally considered as non-pathogenic. All patients had normal CFTR dependent chloride transport in ICM. NPD differentiated 3 different profiles: CF-like tracings qualifying the patients as CF, such as F508del/D1152H patients; normal responses, suggesting an extremely low likelihood of developing a CFTR-RD such as F508del/TG11T5 patients; partial CFTR dysfunction above 20% of the normal, highlighting a remaining risk of developing CFTR-RD such as F508del/F1052V patients. The 3 VUS were reclassified as variant with defective maturation (D537N), defective expression (T582I) or with no clinical consequence (M952T).

CONCLUSION

This study demonstrates the usefulness of combining genetic and functional investigations to assess the possibility of evolving to CF or CFTR-RD in babies with inconclusive diagnosis at neonatal screening.

Outcomes of Cystic Fibrosis Screening-Positive Infants With Inconclusive Diagnosis at School Age

BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVES

Cystic fibrosis (CF) screen-positive infants with an inconclusive diagnosis (CFSPID) are infants in whom sweat testing and genetic analysis does not resolve a CF diagnosis. Lack of knowledge about the health outcome of these children who require clinical follow-up challenges effective consultation. Early predictive biomarkers to delineate the CF risk would allow a more targeted approach to these children.

METHODS

Prospective, longitudinal, multicenter, Canada-wide cohort study of CF positive-screened newborns with 1 to 2 cystic fibrosis transmembrane conductance regulator gene variants, of which at least 1 is not known to be CF-causing and/or a sweat chloride between 30 and 59 mmol/L. These were monitored for conversion to a CF diagnosis, pulmonary, and nutritional outcomes.

RESULTS

The mean observation period was 7.7 (95% confidence interval 7.1 to 8.4) years. A CF diagnosis was established for 24 of the 115 children with CFSPID (21%) either because of reinterpretation of the cystic fibrosis transmembrane conductance regulator genotype or because of increase in sweat chloride concentration ≥60 mmol/L. An initial sweat chloride of ≥40 mmol/l predicted conversion to CF on the basis of sweat testing. The 91 remaining children with CFSPID were pancreatic sufficient and showed normal growth until school age. Pulmonary function as well as lung clearance index in a subgroup of children with CFSPID were similar to that of healthy controls.

CONCLUSIONS

Children with CFSPID have good nutritional and pulmonary outcomes at school age, but rates of reclassifying the diagnosis are high. The initial sweat chloride test can be used as a biomarker to predict the risk for CF in CFSPID.

Identification of incompletely penetrant variants and interallelic interactions in autosomal recessive disorders by a population-genetic approach

We aimed to identify incompletely penetrant (IP) variants and interallelic interactions in autosomal recessive disorders by a population-genetic approach. Genotype and clinical data were collected from 9038 patients of European origin with ASL, ATP7B, CAPN3, CFTR, CTNS, DHCR7, GAA, GALNS, GALT, IDUA, MUT, NPHS1, NPHS2, PAH, PKHD1, PMM2, or SLC26A4-related disorders. We calculated the relative allele frequency of each pathogenic variant (n = 1936) to the loss-of-function (LOF) variants of the corresponding gene in the patient ( A C p t V / A C p t L O F ) and the general population ( AC gnomAD V / AC gnomAD LOF ) and estimated the penetrance of each variant by calculating their ratio: ( A C p t V / A C p t L O F ) ( A C g n o m A D V / A C g n o m A D L O F ) (V/LOF ratio). We classified all variants as null or hypomorphic based on the associated clinical phenotype. We found 25 variants, 29% of the frequent 85 variants, to be underrepresented in the patient population (V/LOF ratio <30% with p < 7.22 × 10^-5 ), including 22 novel ones in the ASL, CAPN3, CFTR, GAA, GALNS, PAH, and PKHD1 genes. In contrast to the completely penetrant variants (CP), the majority of the IP variants were hypomorphic (IP: 16/18, 88%; CP: 177/933, 19.0%; p = 5.12 × 10^-10 ). Among them, only the NPHS2 R229Q variant was subject to interallelic interactions. The proposed algorithm identifies frequent IP variants and estimates their penetrance and interallelic interactions in large patient cohorts.

Elucidating clinical phenotypic variability associated with the polyT tract and TG repeats in CFTR

Biallelic pathogenic variants in CFTR manifest as cystic fibrosis (CF) or other CFTR-related disorders (CFTR-RDs). The 5T allele, causing alternative splicing and reduced protein activity, is modulated by the adjacent TG repeat element, though previous data have been limited to small, selective cohorts. Here, the risk and spectrum of phenotypes associated with the CFTR TG-T5 haplotype variants (TG11T5, TG12T5, and TG13T5) in the absence of the p.Arg117His variant are evaluated. Individuals who received physician-ordered next-generation sequencing of CFTR were included. TG[11-13]T5 variant frequencies (biallelic or with another CF-causing variant [CFvar]) were calculated. Clinical information reported by the ordering provider or the individual was examined. Among 548,300 individuals, the T5 minor allele frequency (MAF) was 4.2% (TG repeat distribution: TG11 = 68.1%, TG12 = 29.5%, TG13 = 2.4%). When present with a CFvar, each TG[11-13]T5 variant was significantly enriched in individuals with a high suspicion of CF or CFTR-RD (personal/family history of CF/CFTR-RD) compared to those with a low suspicion for CF or CFTR-RD (hereditary cancer screening, CFTR not requisitioned). Compared to CFvar/CFvar individuals, those with TG[11-13]T5/CFvar generally had single-organ involvement, milder symptoms, variable expressivity, and reduced penetrance. These data improve our understanding of disease risks associated with TG[11-13]T5 variants and have important implications for reproductive genetic counseling.

[Newborn screening for cystic fibrosis in France]

Neonatal screening for cystic fibrosis has optimised the prognosis for patients allowing very early multidisciplinary care. Over the past 20 years, screening programmes have undergone major international expansion. The performances of the French neonatal cystic fibrosis screening programme, established in 2002, has met European guideline standards, with positive predictive value of 0.31 (against a minimum of 0.30) and sensitivity value of 0.95 (against a minimum of 0.95). It is also important to highlight the very high percentage of sweat tests performed (95.5%), of mutations identified (96.6%), the 9:1 ratio of cystic fibrosis cases to cases of inconclusive diagnosis achieved and the effectiveness of the strategy implemented for the detection of false negative cases. A new organisation for cystic fibrosis neonatal screening has now been established in France. It is vital that effectiveness is maintained throughout the process, from newborn maternity care to diagnosis in cystic fibrosis care centres, and that further knowledge is gained through exhaustive data collection and validation.

Cystic fibrosis newborn screening: the importance of bloodspot sample quality

OBJECTIVE

Wales has an immunoreactive trypsin (IRT)-DNA cystic fibrosis (CF) newborn screening (NBS) programme. Most CF NBS false negative cases are due to an IRT concentration below the screening threshold. The accuracy of IRT results is dependent on the quality of the dried bloodspot (DBS) sample. The aim of this study was to determine the cause of false negative cases in CF NBS and their relationship to DBS quality.

DESIGN

Longitudinal birth cohort.

SETTING

Wales 1996-2016.

PATIENTS

Children with CF.

INTERVENTIONS

Identification of all CF patients with triangulation of multiple data sources to detect false negative cases.

MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES

False negative cases.

RESULTS

Over 20 years, 673 952 infants were screened and 239 were diagnosed with CF (incidence 1:2819). The sensitivity of the programme was 0.958, and positive predictive value was 0.476. Eighteen potential false negatives were identified, of whom eight were excluded: four screened outside Wales, two had complex comorbidities, no identified cystic fibrosis transmembrane conductance regulator (CFTR) variants on extended analysis and thus not considered to have CF and two were diagnosed after their 16th birthday. Of the 10 false negatives, 9 had a low DBS IRT and at least one common CFTR variant and thus should have received a sweat test under the programme. DBS cards were available for inspection for five of the nine false negative cases-all were classified as small/insufficient or poor quality.

CONCLUSIONS

The majority of false negatives had a low bloodspot IRT, and this was associated with poor quality DBS. The optimal means to improve the sensitivity of our CF NBS programme would be to improve DBS sample quality.

Cystic Fibrosis Polymorphic Variants in a Russian Population

Purpose

Cystic fibrosis (CF) is one of the most common monogenic diseases with an autosomal recessive inheritance. Carrier screening leads to a reduction in the number of children born with CF disease. The aim of this study was to develop the custom panel for the diagnosis of heterozygous carriage of polymorphic variants in the CFTR gene and to establish their allelic frequencies (AF) in one of the Russian regions where ethnic Russians predominate.

Patients and Methods

The diagnostic panel was designed on the basis of data from the register of CF patients in Russia for 2017 and validated on 22 blood samples of patients with previously genetically established CF. The study participants (n=642) for CF variants estimation were randomly selected from the population-based cohort study ESSE-Vologda. Genotypes were determined by real-time PCR on the QuantStudio 12K Flex Real-Time PCR System. Data processing was performed using the TaqMan Genotyper Software.

Results

The proposed diagnostic panel allowed simultaneous analysis of 60 variants of the CFTR gene. A total of 23 carriers of the following variants were identified among 642 participants: F508del (rs113993960) with a frequency of 2.02%, L138ins (rs397508686) and 394delTT (rs121908769) – 0.47%, CFTRdele2.3 (c.54–5940_273+10250del21080; p.S18Rfs*16) – 0.31%, R117H (rs78655421), and G542X (rs113993959) – 0.16%. The frequency of heterozygotes in the Russian population was 3.58% or 1:28 (CI95%: 2.28–5.33% by Clopper–Pearson exact method).

Conclusion

High frequency of heterozygous CFTR variants carriers and availability of highly productive diagnostic panel for detection of CFTR variants suggest the prospect of carrier screening for some common CF variants among Russian population.

Newborn screening for CF in France: An exemplary national experience

Newborn screening (NBS) for cystic fibrosis (CF) was implemented throughout France since 2002, with a 3-tiered strategy consisting in an immunoreactive trypsinogen (IRT) measurement at day-3, a search for the most common mutations responsible for CF when the IRT value is above the cut-off level, and, if necessary, a safetynet retesting of IRT at day-21. Coordination and follow-up are ensured at the national level and NBS is carried out through a regional organization involving NBS centers, biochemical and molecular genetics laboratories. Sweat testing and comprehensive mutation gene analysis are then performed according to a defined algorithm. Between 2002 and 2014, screening for the 30 most common mutations identified 87% of the alleles and comprehensive mutation gene analysis performed when applicable identified more than 300 additional mutations and resulted in a detection rate of 99.8% of the mutated alleles. Program surveillance ensured at a national level allowed to carry out adaptation of cut-off levels and removal of the p.Arg117His mutation. Thanks to these modifications, the performance of the French NBS program for CF meets the European guideline standards regarding positive predictive values, sensitivity and time to initial visit at the CF center, thus making the strategy effective. © 2020 French Society of Pediatrics. Published by Elsevier Masson SAS. All rights reserved.

Updated guidance on the management of children with cystic fibrosis transmembrane conductance regulator-related metabolic syndrome/cystic fibrosis screen positive, inconclusive diagnosis (CRMS/CFSPID)

Over the past two decades there has been considerable progress with the evaluation and management of infants with an inconclusive diagnosis following Newborn Screening (NBS) for cystic Fibrosis (CF). In addition, we have an increasing amount of evidence on which to base guidance on the management of these infants and, importantly, we have a consistent designation being used across the globe of CRMS/CFSPID. There is still work to be undertaken and research questions to answer, but these infants now receive more consistent and appropriate care pathways than previously. It is clear that the majority of these infants remain healthy, do not convert to a diagnosis of CF in childhood, and advice on management should reflect this. However, it is also clear that some will convert to a CF diagnosis and monitoring of these infants should facilitate their early recognition. Those infants that do not convert to a CF diagnosis have some potential of developing a CFTR-RD later in life. At present, it is not possible to quantify this risk, but families need to be provided with clear information of what to look out for. This paper contains a number of changes from previous guidance in light of developing evidence, but the major change is the recommendation of a detailed assessment of the child with CRMS/CFSPID in the sixth year of age, including respiratory function assessment and imaging. With these data, the CF team can discuss future care arrangements with the family and come to a shared decision on the best way forward, which may include discharge to primary care with appropriate information. Information is key for these families, and we recommend consideration of a further appointment when the individual is a young adult to directly communicate the implications of the CRMS/CFSPID designation.

Neonatal screening programme for CF: Results from the Irish Comparative Outcomes Study (ICOS)

The introduction of NBS in Ireland in July 2011, provided a unique opportunity to investigate clinical outcomes using a comparative historical cohort study. Clinical cohort: children clinically diagnosed with CF born 1 July 2008 to 30 June 2011, and NBS cohort: children diagnosed with CF through NBS born 1 July 2011 to 30 June 2016. Clinical data were collected from the CF Registry of Ireland, medical charts, and data on weight/height before diagnosis from public health nurses and family doctors. SPSS was used for analysis. A total of 232 patients were recruited (response 93%) (93 clinically diagnosed, 139 NBS-detected). Following exclusions of meconium ileus (MI) (40), diagnosis outside Ireland (4), and being designated as CFSPID (2), a total of 77 clinically diagnosed patients and 109 NBS detected children were included in analysis. Over half were homozygous for F508del mutation. Being clinically diagnosed was independently associated with hospitalization for infective exacerbation of CF < 36 months (OR, 2.80; 95%CI 1.24-6.29). Diagnosis to first acquisition of Pseudomonas aeruginosa was significantly longer in NBS than clinically detected; from birth there was no significant difference. Weight and length/height were significantly greater in NBS cohort at 6 and 12 months. We provide evidence of improved growth, reduced hospitalization for acute exacerbations, and delayed P. aeruginosa acquisition (from diagnosis) to age 3 for the NBS cohort. Screening practices likely account for the non-significant difference in P. aeruginosa acquisition from birth.

Laboratory reporting on the clinical spectrum of CFTR p.Arg117His: Still room for improvement

BACKGROUND

The clinical spectrum associated with cystic fibrosis transmembrane conductance regulator (CFTR) variant p.Arg117His is highly variable, ranging from full-blown cystic fibrosis (CF) in a small number of cases to CFTR-related disorders (CFTR-RDs) or no symptoms at all. Therefore, taking into account phenotype variability is essential for interpretation. External quality assessment (EQA) schemes can help laboratories to objectively assess the quality of genotyping and reporting by the laboratory.

METHODS

We performed a retrospective longitudinal data analysis on laboratory performance regarding the interpretation of p.Arg117His during CF EQA scheme participation. Completeness and accuracy of reporting on two mock clinical cases were each compared over time (case 1: 2005, 2007 and 2012; case 2: 2015 and 2018). These cases concerned subjects compound heterozygous for p.Phe508del and p.Arg117His in cis with 7T, but with different clinical backgrounds (family planning (case 1) versus diagnostic testing for a child (case 2)). Furthermore, we analyzed the influence of previous participations, annual test volume, accreditation status and laboratory setting on overall performance.

RESULTS

Overall performance improved over time, except during the 2007 CF EQA scheme. In addition, previous participations had a beneficial effect on laboratory performance. Accreditation status, annual test volume and laboratory setting did not significantly influence total interpretation scores.

CONCLUSIONS

In general, laboratories performed well on both cases, although reporting on the variable clinical spectrum of p.Arg117His in cis with 7T and on the disease liability of individual CFTR variants can still improve. Moreover, this study underlined the educational role of CF EQA schemes.

Molecular Diagnosis and Genetic Counseling of Cystic Fibrosis and Related Disorders: New Challenges

Identification of the cystic fibrosis transmembrane conductance regulator (CFTR) gene and its numerous variants opened the way to fantastic breakthroughs in diagnosis, research and treatment of cystic fibrosis (CF). The current and future challenges of molecular diagnosis of CF and CFTR-related disorders and of genetic counseling are here reviewed. Technological advances have enabled to make a diagnosis of CF with a sensitivity of 99% by using next generation sequencing in a single step. The detection of heretofore unidentified variants and ethnic-specific variants remains challenging, especially for newborn screening (NBS), CF carrier testing and genotype-guided therapy. Among the criteria for assessing the impact of variants, population genetics data are insufficiently taken into account and the penetrance of CF associated with CFTR variants remains poorly known. The huge diversity of diagnostic and genetic counseling indications for CFTR studies makes assessment of variant disease-liability critical. This is especially discussed in the perspective of wide genome analyses for NBS and CF carrier screening in the general population, as future challenges.

Evidence for penetrance in patients without a family history of disease: a systematic review

Family-based penetrance is frequently cited as a major challenge for translating penetrance estimates from familial populations to asymptomatic populations. A systematic review was performed to assess the literature evidencing penetrance estimates in patients without a family history of disease, following the Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses (PRISMA) framework. Initially 1592 papers were identified, which were filtered to a final nine, through application of inclusion and exclusion criteria. Fundamental differences in the identified papers prevented combination of papers using meta-analysis, so thematic analysis to produce a narrative synthesis was performed. Key themes included disease risk modifiers, evidence, study limitations and bias. A methodological appraisal too was used to assess quality of included studies. It is evident from the findings that the evidence base for penetrance estimates in individuals without a family history of disease is limited. Future work is needed to refine design of penetrance studies and the impact of incorrect estimates.

Penetrance is a critical parameter for assessing the disease liability of CFTR variants

BACKGROUND

Major issues of newborn screening (NBS) for CF are the assessment of disease liability of variants and of the penetrance of clinical CF, notably in inconclusive diagnosis. The penetrance of CF is defined as the risk of a particular genotype to lead to a CF phenotype.

METHODS

We aimed to get insight into the penetrance of CF for fifteen CFTR variants: 5 frequent CF-causing and 10 classified as of varying clinical consequence (VCC) or associated with a CFTR-related disorder (CFTR-RD) in CFTR2 or CFTR-France databases. The penetrance was approached by: (1) comparison of variant allelic frequencies in CF patients (CFTR2) and in the general population; (2) estimation of the likelihood of a positive NBS test for the 14 compound heterozygous with F508del and the F508del homozygous genotypes, defined as the ratio of detected/expected number of neonates with a given genotype in the 2002-2017 period.

RESULTS

A full penetrance was observed for severe CF-causing variants. Five variants were more frequently found in the general population than in CF patients: TG11T5, TG12T5, TG13T5, L997F and R117H;T7. The likelihood of a positive NBS test was 0.03% for TG11T5, 0.3% for TG12T5, 1.9% for TG13T5, 0.6% for L997F, 11.7% for D1152H, and 17.8% for R117H;T7. Penetrance varied greatly for variants with discrepant classification between CFTR2 and CFTR-France: 5.1% for R117C, 12.3% for T338I, 43.5% for D110H and 52.6% for L206W.

CONCLUSION

These results illustrate the contribution of genetics population data to assess the disease liability of variants for diagnosis and genetic counselling purposes.

Phenotype of children with inconclusive cystic fibrosis diagnosis after newborn screening

OBJECTIVE

To characterize the phenotypic expression of children with conductance regulator-related metabolic syndrome (CRMS)/cystic fibrosis screen positive inconclusive diagnosis (CFSPID) designation after positive newborn screening, reassign labeling if applicable and better define these children's prognosis.

METHODS

A multicenter cohort with CRMS/CFSPID designation was matched with cystic fibrosis (CF)-diagnosed cohort. Cohorts were prospectively compared on baseline characteristics, cumulative data and when they reached 6 to 7 years at endpoint assessment.

RESULTS

Compared to infants with CF (n = 63), the CRMS/CFSPID cohort (n = 63) had initially lower immunoreactive trypsinogen (IRT) and sweat chloride (SC) values, delayed visits, less symptoms, and better nutritional status; during follow-up, they had fewer hospitalizations, Pseudomonas aeruginosa and methicillin-resistant Staphylococcus aureus identification, CF comorbidities, and treatment burden. At endpoint assessment, they presented a milder pulmonary phenotype on Brody computed tomography scores (0.0[0.0; 2.0] vs 13[2.0; 31.0]; P < .0001, respectively), Wisconsin and Brasfield chest radiograph scores, pulmonary function tests, and improved nutritional status. Among the inconclusive CF diagnosis cohort, 28 cases (44%) converted to CF diagnosis based on genotype (44%), SC (28%) or both (28%); yet, comparing those with or without final CF diagnosis, we found no differences, possibly related to their young age and mild degree of lung disease. In the total cohort, we found significant associations between Brody scores and IRT, SC values, genotype, Wisconsin and Brasfield score and spirometry.

CONCLUSIONS

The matched CRMS/CFSPID and CF cohorts showed differences in outcomes. By a mean age of 7.6 years, a high proportion of the CRMS/CFSPID cohort converted to CF. Our results highlight that monitoring at CF clinics until at least 6 years is needed as well as further studies.

The CFTR variant profile of Hispanic patients with cystic fibrosis: Impact on access to effective screening, diagnosis, and personalized medicine

Hispanic patients comprise an appreciable and increasing proportion of patients with cystic fibrosis (CF) in the United States (US). Hispanic patients with CF are known to have increased morbidity and mortality compared to non-Hispanic white patients with CF, and ongoing investigations are underway to identify contributing factors amenable to intervention in order to address the disparate health outcomes. One contributing factor is the different CF transmembrane conductance regulator (CFTR) variant profile observed in Hispanic patients with CF. The most common CFTR variant, p.Phe508del (legacy name F508del), is proportionally underrepresented in Hispanic patients with CF. This difference has implications for prenatal screening, newborn screening (NBS), and CFTR variant-specific therapeutic options. In particular, the recent approval of a highly effective CFTR modulator for patients carrying at least one copy of F508del, elexacaftor/tezacaftor/ivacaftor triple combination therapy, underscores the potential for unequal access to personalized treatment for Hispanic patients with CF. We report the CFTR variant profiles of Hispanic patients with CF and non-CF Hispanic infants with a false-positive New York State CF NBS at a single center in New York City over a 5-year study period, as an opportunity to address the racial and ethnic disparities that currently exist in CF screening, diagnosis, and treatment. In addition to the previously documented disparate prevalence of the CFTR variant F508del in Hispanic patients, we observed two CFTR variants, p.His609Arg (legacy name H609R) and p.Thr1036Asn (legacy name T1036N), frequently identified in our Hispanic patients of Ecuadorian and Mexican ancestry, respectively, that are not well-described in the US population. The presence of population-specific and individually rare CFTR variants in Hispanic patients with CF further accentuates the disparity in health outcomes, as these CFTR variants are often absent from prenatal and NBS CFTR variant panels, potentially delaying diagnosis, and without an approved CFTR variant-specific therapy.

The Role of Extended CFTR Gene Sequencing in Newborn Screening for Cystic Fibrosis

There has been considerable progress in the implementation of newborn screening (NBS) programs for cystic fibrosis (CF), with DNA analysis being part of an increasing number of strategies. Thanks to advances in genomic sequencing technologies, CFTR-extended genetic analysis (EGA) by sequencing its coding regions has become affordable and has already been included as part of a limited number of core NBS programs, to the benefit of admixed populations. Based on results analysis of existing programs, the values and challenges of EGA are reviewed in the perspective of its implementation on a larger scale. Sensitivity would be increased at best by using EGA as a second tier, but this could be at the expense of positive predictive value, which improves, however, if EGA is applied after testing a variant panel. The increased detection of babies with an inconclusive diagnosis has proved to be a major drawback in programs using EGA. The lack of knowledge on pathogenicity and penetrance associated with numerous variants hinders the introduction of EGA as a second tier, but EGA with filtering for all known CF variants with full penetrance could be a solution. The issue of incomplete knowledge is a real challenge in terms of the implemention of NBS extended to many genetic diseases.

Frequency of Cystic Fibrosis Transmembrane Conductance Regulator Variants in Individuals Evaluated for Primary Ciliary Dyskinesia

OBJECTIVE

To evaluate whether cystic fibrosis transmembrane conductance regulator (CFTR) variants are more common among individuals tested for primary ciliary dyskinesia (PCD) compared with controls.

STUDY DESIGN

Data were studied from 1021 individuals with commercial genetic testing for suspected PCD and 91 777 controls with genetic testing at the same company (Invitae) for symptoms/diseases unrelated to PCD or CFTR testing. The prevalence of CFTR variants was compared between controls and each of 3 groups of individuals tested for PCD (PCD-positive, -uncertain, and -negative molecular diagnosis).

RESULTS

The prevalence of 1 pathogenic CFTR variant was similar among the individual groups. When combining the PCD-uncertain and PCR-negative molecular diagnosis groups, there was a higher prevalence of single pathogenic CFTR variants compared with controls (P = .03). Importantly, >1% of individuals who had negative genetic testing results for PCD had 2 pathogenic CFTR variants (8 of 723), and the incidence of cystic fibrosis (CF) (2 pathogenic variants) is roughly 1 in 3000 individuals of Caucasian ethnicity (∼0.03%). This incidence was also greater than that of 2 pathogenic CFTR variants in the control population (0.09% [84 of 91 777]; P = 9.60 × 10^-16). These variants correlate with mild CFTR-related disease.

CONCLUSIONS

Our results suggest that a single pathogenic CFTR variant is not likely to be a PCD-mimetic, but ongoing studies are needed in individuals in whom PCD is suspected and genetic testing results are uncertain or negative. Furthermore, CF may be misdiagnosed as PCD, reflecting phenotypic overlap. Among individuals evaluated for PCD, CF should be considered in the differential even in the CF newborn screening era.

Newborn screening for cystic fibrosis: Is there benefit for everyone?

Newborn screening for cystic fibrosis (CF) has become a widely accepted and endorsed public health strategy in economically developed countries, although there is little consensus on optimal screening methods and gene panels. Increasing understanding of CFTR genetics and consequent unpredictability of phenotypic and clinical outcomes lead to diagnostic uncertainty, and emergence of Cystic Fibrosis Screen Positive Inconclusive Diagnosis (CF-SPID). Many of these children are clinically well or have a mild phenotype yet may still experience the psychosocial impact of a CF diagnosis. This questions the role of newborn screening and how best to manage those it identifies with CF-SPID.

Secondary actionable findings identified by exome sequencing: expected impact on the organisation of care from the study of 700 consecutive tests

With exome/genome sequencing (ES/GS) integrated into the practice of medicine, there is some potential for reporting incidental/secondary findings (IFs/SFs). The issue of IFs/SFs has been studied extensively over the last 4 years. In order to evaluate their implications in care organisation, we retrospectively evaluated, in a cohort of 700 consecutive probands, the frequency and burden of introducing the search for variants in a maximum list of 244 medically actionable genes (genes that predispose carriers to a preventable or treatable disease in childhood/adulthood and genes for genetic counselling issues). We also focused on the 59 PharmGKB class IA/IB pharmacogenetic variants. We also compared the results in different gene lists. We identified variants (likely) affecting protein function in genes for care in 26 cases (3.7%) and heterozygous variants in genes for genetic counselling in 29 cases (3.8%). Mean time for the 700 patients was about 6.3 min/patient for medically actionable genes and 1.3 min/patient for genes for genetic counselling, and a mean time of 37 min/patients for the reinterpreted variants. These results would lead to all 700 pre-test counselling sessions being longer, to 55 post-test genetic consultations and to 27 secondary specialised medical evaluations. ES also detected 42/59 pharmacogenetic variants or combinations of variants in the majority of cases. An extremely low metabolizer status in genes relevant for neurodevelopmental disorders (CYP2C9 and CYP2C19) was found in 57/700 cases. This study provides information regarding the need to anticipate the implementation of genomic medicine, notably the work overload at various steps of the process.

Cystic fibrosis screen positive inconclusive diagnosis (CFSPID): Experience in Tuscany, Italy

OBJECTIVE

The implementation of cystic fibrosis (CF) newborn screening (NBS) has led to identification of infants with a positive NBS test but inconclusive diagnosis classified as "CF screen positive, inconclusive diagnosis" (CFSPID). We retrospectively evaluated the prevalence and clinical outcome of CFSPID infants diagnosed by 2 NBS algorithms in the period from 2011 to 2016 in the Tuscany region of Italy.

METHODS

In 2011-2016, we assessed the diagnostic impact of DNA analysis on the NBS 4-tier algorithm [immunoreactive trypsin (IRT) - meconium lactase - IRT2 - sweat chloride (SC)]. All CFSPID patients repeated SC testing every 6 months, and CFTR gene analysis was performed (detection rate 98%). We reclassified children as: CF diagnosis in presence of at least 2 pathological SC results; healthy carrier or healthy in presence of at least 2 normal SC results for age and either 1 or 0 CF-causing mutations, respectively.

RESULTS

We identified 32 CF and 50 CFSPID cases: 20/50 (40%) were diagnosed only by the IRT-DNA-SC algorithm and 16/50 (32%) only by IRT-meconium lactase-IRT2-SC. Both protocols identified the remaining 14 cases (28%). Thirty-seven of 50 (74%) CFSPID patients had a conclusive diagnosis on December 31, 2017:5 (10%) CF, 17 (34%) healthy and 15 (30%) healthy carriers; 13/50 (26%) cases were asymptomatic with persistent intermediate SC and followed as CFSPID (CF:CFSPID ratio 2.85:1).

CONCLUSIONS

In 6 years, the CF:CFSPID ratio modified from 0.64:1 to 2.85:1, and 10% of CFSPID cases progressed to CF. Genetic analysis improved positive predictive value and identified a higher number of CFSPID infants progressing to CF.

Use of ivacaftor in late diagnosed cystic fibrosis monozygotic twins heterozygous for F508del and R117H-7T - a case report

BACKGROUND

CFTR modulator therapy with ivacaftor is a treatment option for Cystic Fibrosis (CF) patients with at least one copy of a R117H-7T mutation in the CFTR gene. Desirable effects of this therapy are improvement of lung function, decrease in exacerbation rate, normalization or reduction of sweat chloride and weight gain. Monogenetic CF-twins carry identical genetic information, so therapy response and side effects are expected to be nearly identical under this specific therapy.

CASE PRESENTATION

In monozygotic twins, at the age of 55, two pathogenic variants in the CFTR gene (F508del and R117H-7T) were detected. Both patients presented with a borderline sweat test (30-59 mmol/L) and despite the same genetic information and similar life circumstances the disease proceeds completely different. While one patient has severe pulmonary involvement with chronic P. aeruginosa infection, her twin sister is almost unimpaired. Liver or pancreatic involvement was not seen in either patient. Due to the presence of one copy of a R117H-7T mutation, CFTR modulator therapy with ivacaftor was initiated in both. Response and side effects were significantly different. In the less affected patient, we observed an improvement in lung function and a normalization of sweat chloride. In the severely affected patient, no functional response to treatment was seen, but stabilization of the disease state with a decrease in exacerbation and hospitalization rate and weight gain as well as a normalization of sweat chloride. There was an increase in liver enzymes in the less affected patient, which normalized after halving the dose of ivacaftor, while the therapeutic effect was maintained.

CONCLUSIONS

Despite nearly identical genetic information, as in monogenetic twins, therapy response and onset of side effects of CFTR modulating therapy are very different. In patients with late diagnosis and severe pulmonary involvement, ivacaftor does not seem to improve lung function, whereas in patients with late diagnosis and low disease severity a relevant therapy response was obtained. In addition to lung function, additional clinical parameters such as reduction of exacerbation and hospitalization rate and weight gain should be used to assess therapy response, especially in severely affected patients.

Genetic backgrounds and hidden trait complexity in natural populations

Dissecting the genetic basis of natural phenotypic variation is a major goal in biology. We know that most traits are strongly heritable. However, their genetic architecture is a long-standing question, which is unfortunately confounded by the lack of complete knowledge of the genetic components as well as their phenotypic effect in a specific genetic background. Many genetic variants are known to affect phenotypes but the same functional variant can have a different effect on the phenotype in different individuals of the same species. Understanding the impact of genetic background on the expressivity of a given phenotype is essential because this effect complicates our ability to predict phenotype from genotype. Here, we briefly review recent progress on the exploration of the effect of genetic background and we discuss how a deeper characterization of the inheritance, expressivity and genetic interactions hidden behind the phenotypic landscape of natural variation could provide a better understanding of the relationship between genotype and phenotype.

Guidelines for the clinical management and follow-up of infants with inconclusive cystic fibrosis diagnosis through newborn screening

Neonatal screening for cystic fibrosis (CF) can detect infants with elevated immunoreactive trypsinogen (IRT) levels and inconclusive sweat tests and/or CFTR DNA results. These cases of uncertain diagnosis are defined by (1) either the presence of at most one CF-associated cystic fibrosis transmembrane conductance regulator (CFTR) mutation with sweat chloride values between 30 and 59mmol/L or (2) two CFTR mutations with at least one of unknown pathogenic potential and a sweat chloride concentration below 60mmol/L. This encompasses various clinical situations whose progression cannot be predicted. In these cases, a sweat chloride test has to be repeated at 12 months, and if possible at 6 and 24 months of life along with extended CFTR sequencing to detect rare mutations. When the diagnosis is not definite, CFTR functional explorations may provide a better understanding of CFTR dysfunction. The initial evaluation of these infants must be conducted in dedicated CF reference centers and should include bacteriological sputum analysis, chest radiology, and fecal elastase assay. The primary care physicians in charge of these patients should be familiar with the current management of CF and should work in collaboration with CF centers. A follow-up should be performed in a CF reference center at 3, 6, and 12 months of life and every year thereafter. Any symptom indicative of CF requires immediate reevaluation of the diagnosis. These guidelines were established by the "neonatal screening and difficult diagnoses" working group of the French CF society. Their objective is to standardize the management of infants with unclear diagnosis.

Lung function decline is delayed but not decreased in patients with cystic fibrosis and the R117H gene mutation

BACKGROUND

Patients with cystic fibrosis (CF) experience variable lung disease phenotypes. The R117H mutation is often associated with preserved lung function. Our objective was to compare the rate of lung function decline in patients with the R117H mutation and patients homozygous for the F508del mutation.

METHODS

Rate of decline in percentage-of-predicted FEV₁ (ppFEV₁) was analyzed using the 2006-2010 US CF Foundation Patient Registry.

RESULTS

4-year rate of decline was slower in 156 R117H patients compared with 6251 F508del patients (-0.61 vs -2.03 ppFEV₁/year, P<0.001). Rates of decline in children were slower in R117H vs F508del patients (6-12-year-olds: +0.73 vs -1.91 ppFEV₁/year, P<0.001 and 13-17-year-olds: -1.55 vs -2.66 ppFEV₁/year, P=0.046), whereas rates in adults were not significantly different (18-24-year-olds: -1.52 vs -2.12, P=0.26 and ≥25-year-olds: -1.17 vs -1.40, P=0.33).

CONCLUSIONS

These findings are consistent with a delayed onset, but ultimately similar progression, of lung disease in R117H compared with homozygous F508del patients.

The diagnosis of cystic fibrosis

Establishing the diagnosis of cystic fibrosis (CF) is straight forward in the majority of patients: they present with a clear clinical picture (most frequently chronic respiratory symptoms plus malabsorption), the sweat chloride value is>60mmol/L and two known disease causing CFTR mutations are identified. In less than 5% of subjects, mainly those with a milder or limited phenotype, the diagnostic process is more complex, because initial diagnostic test results are inconclusive: sweat chloride concentration in the intermediate range, less than 2 CF causing mutations identified or both. These patients should be referred to expert centers where bioassays of CFTR function like nasal potential difference measurement or intestinal current measurement can be done. Still, in some patients, despite symptoms compatible with CF and some indication of CFTR dysfunction (e.g. only intermediate sweat chloride value), diagnostic criteria are not met (e.g. only 1 CFTR mutation identified). For these subjects, the term CFTR related disorder (CFTR-RD) is used. Patients with disseminated bronchiectasis, congenital bilateral absence of the vas deferens and acute or recurrent pancreatitis may fall in this category. CF has a very wide disease spectrum and increasingly the diagnosis is being made during adult life, mainly in subjects with milder phenotypes. In many countries, nationwide CF newborn screening (NBS) has been introduced. In screen positive babies, the diagnosis of CF must be confirmed by a sweat test demonstrating a sweat chloride concentration above 60mmol/L. To achieve the benefit of NBS, every baby in whom the diagnosis of CF is confirmed must receive immediate follow-up and treatment in a CF reference center. CF NBS is not full proof: some diagnoses will be missed and in some babies the diagnosis cannot be confirmed nor ruled out with certainty. Screening algorithms that include gene sequencing will detect a high number of such babies that are screen positive with an inconclusive diagnosis (CFSPID). Even in 2016, the most reliable and widely available diagnostic test for CF is the measurement of chloride concentration in sweat. The method of choice is sweat induction by pilocarpine iontophoresis, followed by sweat collection on a gauze or filter paper or in a Macroduct coil. Since mutation specific therapies have become available, it is important to identify the mutations responsible for CF in each individual patient.

[Management of infants whose diagnosis is inconclusive at neonatal screening for cystic fibrosis]

Neonatal screening for cystic fibrosis (CF) may detect infants with elevated immunoreactive trypsinogen (IRT) levels but with inconclusive sweat tests and/or DNA results. This includes cases associating (1) either the presence of at most one CF-causing mutation and sweat chloride values between 30 and 59mmol/L or (2) two CFTR mutations with at least one of unknown pathogenicity and a sweat chloride below 60mmol/L. This encompasses different clinical situations whose progression cannot be predicted. These cases require redoing the sweat test at 12 months and if possible at 6 and 24 months of life. This must be associated with extended genotyping. CFTR functional explorations can also help by investigating CFTR dysfunction. These infants must be initially evaluated in dedicated CF centers including bacteriological sputum analysis, chest radiology and fecal elastase dosage. A home practitioner must be informed of the specificity of follow-up. These infants will be reviewed in the CF center at 3, 6 and 12 months and every year. Any CF-related symptom requires reevaluation of the diagnosis. These guidelines were established by the "neonatal screening and difficult diagnoses" working group of the French CF Society. They aim to standardize management of infants with unclear diagnosis in French CF centers.

Diagnosis of Cystic Fibrosis in Screened Populations

OBJECTIVE

Cystic fibrosis (CF) can be difficult to diagnose, even when newborn screening (NBS) tests yield positive results. This challenge is exacerbated by the multitude of NBS protocols, misunderstandings about screening vs diagnostic tests, and the lack of guidelines for presumptive diagnoses. There is also confusion regarding the designation of age at diagnosis.

STUDY DESIGN

To improve diagnosis and achieve standardization in definitions worldwide, the CF Foundation convened a committee of 32 experts with a mission to develop clear and actionable consensus guidelines on diagnosis of CF with an emphasis on screened populations, especially the newborn population. A comprehensive literature review was performed with emphasis on relevant articles published during the past decade.

RESULTS

After reviewing the common screening protocols and outcome scenarios, 14 of 27 consensus statements were drafted that apply to screened populations. These were approved by 80% or more of the participants.

CONCLUSIONS

It is recommended that all diagnoses be established by demonstrating dysfunction of the CF transmembrane conductance regulator (CFTR) channel, initially with a sweat chloride test and, when needed, potentially with newer methods assessing membrane transport directly, such as intestinal current measurements. Even in babies with 2 CF-causing mutations detected via NBS, diagnosis must be confirmed by demonstrating CFTR dysfunction. The committee also recommends that the latest classifications identified in the Clinical and Functional Translation of CFTR project [http://www.cftr2.org/index.php] should be used to aid with CF diagnosis. Finally, to avoid delays in treatment, we provide guidelines for presumptive diagnoses and recommend how to determine the age of diagnosis.

Applying Cystic Fibrosis Transmembrane Conductance Regulator Genetics and CFTR2 Data to Facilitate Diagnoses

OBJECTIVE

As a Mendelian disease, genetics plays an integral role in the diagnosis of cystic fibrosis (CF). The identification of 2 disease-causing mutations in the CF transmembrane conductance regulator (CFTR) in an individual with a phenotype provides evidence that the disease is CF. However, not all variations in CFTR always result in CF. Therefore, for CFTR genotype to provide the same level of evidence of CFTR dysfunction as shown by direct tests such as sweat chloride or nasal potential difference, the mutations identified must be known to always result in CF. The use of CFTR genetics in CF diagnosis, therefore, relies heavily on mutation interpretation.

STUDY DESIGN

Progress that has been made on mutation interpretation and annotation was reviewed at the recent CF Foundation Diagnosis Consensus Conference. A modified Delphi method was used to identify consensus statements on the use of genetic analysis in CF diagnosis.

RESULTS

The largest recent advance in CF genetics has come through the Clinical and Functional Translation of CFTR (CFTR2) project. This undertaking seeks to characterize CFTR mutations from patients with CF around the world. The project also established guidelines for the clinical, functional, and population/penetrance criteria that can be used to interpret mutations not yet included in CFTR2's review.

CONCLUSIONS

The use of CFTR genetics to aid in diagnosis of CF requires that the mutations identified have a known disease liability. The demonstration of 2 in trans mutations known to always result in CF is satisfactory evidence of CFTR dysfunction. However, if the identified mutations are known to be associated with variable outcomes, or have unknown consequence, that genotype may not result in a CF phenotype. In these cases, other tests of CFTR function may help.

Diagnosis of Cystic Fibrosis: Consensus Guidelines from the Cystic Fibrosis Foundation

OBJECTIVE

Cystic fibrosis (CF), caused by mutations in the CF transmembrane conductance regulator (CFTR) gene, continues to present diagnostic challenges. Newborn screening and an evolving understanding of CF genetics have prompted a reconsideration of the diagnosis criteria.

STUDY DESIGN

To improve diagnosis and achieve standardized definitions worldwide, the CF Foundation convened a committee of 32 experts in CF diagnosis from 9 countries to develop clear and actionable consensus guidelines on the diagnosis of CF and to clarify diagnostic criteria and terminology for other disorders associated with CFTR mutations. An a priori threshold of ≥80% affirmative votes was required for acceptance of each recommendation statement.

RESULTS

After reviewing relevant literature, the committee convened to review evidence and cases. Following the conference, consensus statements were developed by an executive subcommittee. The entire consensus committee voted and approved 27 of 28 statements, 7 of which needed revisions and a second round of voting.

CONCLUSIONS

It is recommended that diagnoses associated with CFTR mutations in all individuals, from newborn to adult, be established by evaluation of CFTR function with a sweat chloride test. The latest mutation classifications annotated in the Clinical and Functional Translation of CFTR project (http://www.cftr2.org/index.php) should be used to aid in diagnosis. Newborns with a high immunoreactive trypsinogen level and inconclusive CFTR functional and genetic testing may be designated CFTR-related metabolic syndrome or CF screen positive, inconclusive diagnosis; these terms are now merged and equivalent, and CFTR-related metabolic syndrome/CF screen positive, inconclusive diagnosis may be used. International Statistical Classification of Diseases and Related Health Problems, 10th Revision codes for use in diagnoses associated with CFTR mutations are included.

Lung function and disease severity in cystic fibrosis patients heterozygous for p.Arg117His

Expression of p.Arg117His cystic fibrosis (CF) transmembrane conductance regulator is influenced by a polythymidine (poly-T) tract and a thymidine-guanine (TG) repeat on intron 9, which vary in length and affect exon 10 skipping. We compared clinical characteristics and the rate of progression of lung disease of CF patients carrying the p.Arg117His mutation with different intron 9 varying sequences (poly-T) and mutation classes in trans. Data were collected from patients in Northern Ireland, UK, including diagnostic features, sweat chloride, nutritional status, sputum microbiology, CF-related complications and lung function. Poly-T and TG repeats were determined by PCR. Forced expiratory volume in 1 s (FEV1) decline was determined from linear regression of FEV1 measurements of patients over time. We identified 62 patients with p.Arg117His, 55 with a class I/II mutation in trans and six with p.Arg117His/p.Gly551Asp. 42 patients had 5T and 13 had 7T. All patients had 12 TG repeats. Patients with p.Arg117His-5T had greater lung function decline, sweat chloride concentrations, pancreatic insufficiency and prevalence of Pseudomonas aeruginosa infection compared with patients with p.Arg117His-7T. Lung function decline and disease severity in p.Arg117His is determined by the poly-T tract length and identity of the mutation in trans. Patients with p.Arg117His-5T and a second class I/II mutation have a severity similar to p.Phe508del homozygous patients, although lung function decline is delayed to an older age. There may be linkage disequilibrium between p.Arg117His and 12 TG repeats.

CFTR Modulator Therapies in Pediatric Cystic Fibrosis: Focus on Ivacaftor

INTRODUCTION

Mutations in the cystic fibrosis transmembrane conductance regulator protein (CFTR) cause cystic fibrosis (CF), a disease with life threatening pulmonary and gastrointestinal manifestations. Recent breakthrough therapies restore function to select disease-causing CFTR mutations. Ivacaftor is a small molecule that increases the open channel probability of certain CFTR mutations, producing clear evidence of bioactivity and efficacy in pediatric CF patients. CFTR modulators represent a significant advancement in CF treatment. Extending these therapies to young CF patients is proposed to have the greatest long term impact, potentially preventing later disease.

AREAS COVERED

Here we summarize the research experience of CFTR modulators in pediatrics, focusing on ivacaftor and highlighting challenges in pediatric studies. As a result of these studies, ivacaftor has been approved in CF patients age 2 years and older who have one of ten CFTR mutations.

EXPERT OPINION

Conducting studies in young CF patients presents unique challenges, including small numbers of patients and difficulty selecting sensitive biomarkers and meaningful outcome measures. Adverse events may be more pronounced in children and deserve special attention. Ongoing efforts must focus on expanding and validating new biomarkers, innovative study design, and thorough monitoring of adverse events in children treated with CFTR modulators.

Cystic Fibrosis Papers of the Year 2015

Studies published in the last year have expanded our knowledge of potential disease modifying agents in the treatment of class II, III and IV CFTR mutations, and included the first report of an efficacious gene therapy for CF. There is also an important message on increasing use of conventional chronic therapies even in milder disease, and the pernicious effect of chronic infection on pulmonary function.