Chronic proximal spinal muscular atrophy of childhood and adolescence: sex influence

No significant sex differences in incidence or phenotype for the SMNΔ7 mouse model of spinal muscular atrophy

Spinal muscular atrophy (SMA) is an autosomal recessive disease that affects 1 out of every 6,000-10,000 individuals at birth, making it the leading genetic cause of infant mortality. In recent years, reports of sex differences in SMA patients have become noticeable. The SMNΔ7 mouse model is commonly used to investigate pathologies and treatments in SMA. However, studies on sex as a contributing biological variable are few and dated. Here, we rigorously investigated the effect of sex on a series of characteristics in SMA mice of the SMNΔ7 model. Incidence and lifespan of 23 mouse litters were tracked and phenotypic assessments were performed at 2-day intervals starting at postnatal day 6 for every pup until the death of the SMA pup(s) in each litter. Brain weights were also collected post-mortem. We found that male and female SMA incidence does not differ significantly, survival periods are the same across sexes, and there was no phenotypic difference between male and female SMA pups, other than for females exhibiting lesser body weights at early ages. Overall, this study ensures that sex is not a biological variable that contributes to the incidence ratio or disease severity in the SMNΔ7 mouse model.

Sex Difference in Spinal Muscular Atrophy Patients - are Males More Vulnerable?

BACKGROUND

Sex is a significant risk factor in many neurodegenerative disorders. A better understanding of the molecular mechanisms behind sex differences could help develop more targeted therapies that would lead to better outcomes. Untreated spinal muscular atrophy (SMA) is the leading genetic motor disorder causing infant mortality. SMA has a broad spectrum of severity ranging from prenatal death to infant mortality to normal lifespan with some disability. Scattered evidence points to a sex-specific vulnerability in SMA. However, the role of sex as a risk factor in SMA pathology and treatment has received limited attention.

OBJECTIVE

Systematically investigate sex differences in the incidence, symptom severity, motor function of patients with different types of SMA, and in the development of SMA1 patients.

METHODS

Aggregated data of SMA patients were obtained from the TREAT-NMD Global SMA Registry and the Cure SMA membership database by data enquiries. Data were analyzed and compared with publicly available standard data and data from published literature.

RESULTS

The analysis of the aggregated results from the TREAT-NMD dataset revealed that the male/female ratio was correlated to the incidence and prevalence of SMA from different countries; and for SMA patients, more of their male family members were affected by SMA. However, there was no significant difference of sex ratio in the Cure SMA membership dataset. As quantified by the clinician severity scores, symptoms were more severe in males than females in SMA types 2 and 3b. Motor function scores measured higher in females than males in SMA types 1, 3a and 3b. The head circumference was more strongly affected in male SMA type 1 patients.

CONCLUSIONS

The data in certain registry datasets suggest that males may be more vulnerable to SMA than females. The variability observed indicates that more investigation is necessary to fully understand the role of sex differences in SMA epidemiology, and to guide development of more targeted treatments.

Adults with spinal muscular atrophy: a large-scale natural history study shows gender effect on disease

BACKGROUND

Natural history of spinal muscular atrophy (SMA) in adult age has not been fully elucidated yet, including factors predicting disease progression and response to treatments. Aim of this retrospective, cross-sectional study, is to investigate motor function across different ages, disease patterns and gender in adult SMA untreated patients.

METHODS

Inclusion criteria were as follows: (1) clinical and molecular diagnosis of SMA2, SMA3 or SMA4 and (2) clinical assessments performed in adult age (>18 years).

RESULTS

We included 64 (38.8%) females and 101 (61.2%) males (p=0.0025), among which 21 (12.7%) SMA2, 141 (85.5%) SMA3 and 3 (1.8%) SMA4. Ratio of sitters/walkers within the SMA3 subgroup was significantly (p=0.016) higher in males (46/38) than in females (19/38). Median age at onset was significantly (p=0.0071) earlier in females (3 years; range 0-16) than in males (4 years; range 0.3-28), especially in patients carrying 4 SMN2 copies. Median Hammersmith Functional Rating Scale Expanded scores were significantly (p=0.0040) lower in males (16, range 0-64) than in females (40, range 0-62); median revised upper limb module scores were not significantly (p=0.059) different between males (24, 0-38) and females (33, range 0-38), although a trend towards worse performance in males was observed. In SMA3 patients carrying three or four SMN2 copies, an effect of female sex in prolonging ambulation was statistically significant (p=0.034).

CONCLUSIONS

Our data showed a relevant gender effect on SMA motor function with higher disease severity in males especially in the young adult age and in SMA3 patients.

Genetic architecture of motor neuron diseases

Motor neuron diseases (MNDs) are rare and frequently fatal neurological disorders in which motor neurons within the brainstem and spinal cord regions slowly die. MNDs are primarily caused by genetic mutations, and > 100 different mutant genes in humans have been discovered thus far. Given the fact that many more MND-related genes have yet to be discovered, the growing body of genetic evidence has offered new insights into the diverse cellular and molecular mechanisms involved in the aetiology and pathogenesis of MNDs. This search may aid in the selection of potential candidate genes for future investigation and, eventually, may open the door to novel interventions to slow down disease progression. In this review paper, we have summarized detailed existing research findings of different MNDs, such as amyotrophic lateral sclerosis (ALS), spinal muscular atrophy (SMA), spinal bulbar muscle atrophy (SBMA) and hereditary spastic paraplegia (HSP) in relation to their complex genetic architecture.

Observation of the natural course of type 3 spinal muscular atrophy: data from the polish registry of spinal muscular atrophy

BACKGROUND

Spinal muscular atrophy (SMA) is one of the most frequent and severe genetic diseases leading to premature death or severe motor disability. New therapies have been developed in recent years that change the natural history of the disease. The aim of this study is to describe patients included in the Polish Registry of SMA, with a focus on the course of type 3 SMA (SMA3) before the availability of disease-modifying treatments.

RESULTS

790 patients with SMA were included in the registry (173 with type 1 [SMA1], 218 with type 2 [SMA2], 393 with SMA3, and six with type 4 SMA [SMA4]), most (52%) of whom were adults. Data on SMN2 gene copy number were available for 672 (85%) patients. The mean age of onset was 5 months for SMA1, 11.5 months for SMA2, and 4.5 years for SMA3. In patients with SMA3, the first symptoms occurred earlier in those with three copies of SMN2 than in those with four copies of SMN2 (3.2 years vs. 6.7 years). The age of onset of SMA3 was younger in girls than in boys (3.1 years vs. 5.7 years), with no new cases observed in women older than 16 years. Male patients outnumbered female patients, especially among patients with SMA3b (49 female vs. 85 male patients) and among patients with SMA3 with four copies of SMN2 (30 female vs. 69 male patients). 44% of patients with SMA3 were still able to walk; in those who were not still able to walk, the mean age of immobilization was 14.0 years. Patients with SMA3a (age of onset < 3 years) and three copies of SMN2 had significantly worse prognosis for remaining ambulant than patients with SMA3b (age of onset ≥ 3 years) and four copies of SMN2.

CONCLUSIONS

The Registry of SMA is an effective tool for assessing the disease course in the real world setting. SMN2 copy number is an important prognostic factor for the age of onset and ambulation in SMA3. Sex and age of disease onset also strongly affect the course of SMA. Data supplied by this study can aid treatment decisions.

Clinical Outcomes in Patients with Spinal Muscular Atrophy Type 1 Treated with Nusinersen

BackgroundSpinal muscular atrophy type 1 (SMA1) is a motor neuron disease associated with progressive muscle weakness, ventilatory failure, and reduced survival.Objective:To report the evaluation of the nusinersen, an antisense oligonucleotide, on the motor function of SMA1.MethodsThis was a longitudinal and observational study to assess the outcomes of nusinersen therapy in SMA1 patients using the HINE-2 and CHOP-INTEND scales.ResultsTwenty-one SMA1 patients (52.4% males) were included; the mean age at first symptoms was 2.7 months (SD =±1.5), and the mean disease duration at first dose was 34.1 (SD =±36.0) months. During posttreatment, the mean gain on the CHOP-INTEND was 4.9, 5.9, 6.6, and 14 points after 6, 12, 18, and 24 months, respectively. Starting medication with a disease duration of less than 12 months and/or without invasive ventilation were predictors of response on CHOP-INTEND. Of the patients, 28.6% acquired a motor milestone or gained at least three points on the HINE-2. The daily time for ventilatory support was reduced after treatment in most of the patients with noninvasive ventilation at baseline. No change in the daytime use of ventilation was observed in most of the patients using invasive ventilation at baseline.ConclusionsNusinersen produces improvements in motor and respiratory functions, even in long-term SMA1 patients. However, patients under invasive ventilation at the beginning of the treatment experience little benefit.

The Occurrence of 275 Rare Diseases and 47 Rare Disease Groups in Italy. Results from the National Registry of Rare Diseases

Knowledge of rare diseases (RD) is often scattered among many data collections and registries of patient cohorts. Therefore, assessing the burden of RD in the general population, developing appropriate policies and planning services for the care of RD patients is difficult. This study aimed at providing a systematic picture of RD occurrence in a population as big as 60 million. Data of diagnoses were certified and collected by a network of 247 specialized centres covering the whole Italian territory. Data received (about 200,000 records) were validated according to formal criteria and, where necessary, corrected by the data sources. Data of age at onset and sex distribution are given for about 400 diseases. Incidence and/or birth prevalence are given for 275 diseases and 47 disease groups, which, altogether, comprise a substantial part of the known rare diseases. Data quality, internal consistency, and external validity of the database have also been assessed and ways to limit the impact of some discrepancies were devised. The information provided by RNMR, cutting across such a wide range of RD, represents a unique coherent basis allowing the prioritization of relevant public health measures and research activities.

Gender Effects on the Clinical Phenotype in Japanese Patients with Spinal Muscular Atrophy

BACKGROUND

Spinal muscular atrophy (SMA) is a neuromuscular disease caused by a mutation in SMN1. SMA is classified into three subtypes (types 1, 2, 3) based on achieved motor milestones. Although NAIP and SMN2 are widely accepted as SMA-modifying factors, gender-related modifying factors or gender effects on the clinical phenotype are still controversial.

METHODS

A total of 122 Japanese patients with SMA, of which SMN1 was homozygously deleted, were analyzed from the perspective of the achieved motor milestone, NAIP status and SMN2 copy number.

RESULTS

A predominance of male patients was observed in SMA type 3 (the walker group) without NAIP-deletion or with high SMN2 copy number (3 or 4 copies).

CONCLUSION

We suggest the presence of gender-related modifiers on disease severity in SMA patients. The modifiers may contribute only in the presence of NAIP and a high copy number of SMN2.

Unaffected patients with a homozygous absence of the SMN1 gene

In this report, we present three families in which we identified asymptomatic carriers of a homozygous absence of the SMN1 gene. In the first family, the bialleleic deletion was found in three of four siblings: two affected brothers (SMA type 3a and 3b) and a 25-years-old asymptomatic sister. All of them have four SMN2 copies. In the second family, four of six siblings are affected (three suffer from SMA2 and one from SMA3a), each with three SMN2 copies. The clinically asymptomatic 47-year-old father has the biallelic deletion and four SMN2 copies. In the third family, the biallelic SMN1 absence was found in a girl affected with SMA1 and in her healthy 53-years-old father who had five SMN2 copies. Our findings as well as those of other authors show that an increased number of SMN2 copies in healthy carriers of the biallelic SMN1 deletion is an important SMA phenotype modifier, but probably not the only one.

Evidence of a segregation ratio distortion of SMN1 alleles in spinal muscular atrophy

Spinal muscular atrophy (SMA) is an autosomal recessive disorder characterised by degeneration and loss of the motor neurons of the anterior horn of the spinal cord. The absence of SMN1 is determinant to have SMA and parents of SMA patients are regarded as carriers of the disease. We compared the segregation ratio of the mutated allele and the wild-type allele of all the confirmed carrier parents assuming Mendelian proportions. Results of transmissions in 235 prenatal tests and in 128 unaffected siblings showed a statistically significant deviation in favour of the wild-type SMN1 allele. The number of affected foetuses and carriers were lower than that expected. No significant differences in the sex ratio or in the progenitor origin of the transmitted allele to the carriers were found. One hypothesis that has been advanced to account for the distortion observed in affected foetuses is the negative postzygote selection due to early miscarriage. However, given that the number of carriers in our series was lower than expected, prezygote events such as meiotic drive, survival of gametes or preferential fertilisation should also be considered.

Progressive spinal muscular atrophies

Spinal muscular atrophy is the most common autosomal-recessive genetic disorder lethal to infants. It was first described in the 1890s. Since then our understanding of the disorder has progressed significantly. Progression of the disease is due to loss of anterior horn cells, thought to be caused by apoptosis. Diagnosis is based on the course of the illness, as well as certain changes seen on nerve and muscle biopsy and electrodiagnostic studies. More recently, our understanding of the genetics of this disorder has provided a noninvasive approach to diagnosis. This method of testing has its downside, but the quest for a more sensitive analysis is still underway. Even though our knowledge of this disease has come a long way since its first recognition, the therapies available to these children are still only supportive. Again, researchers eagerly look for new therapeutic interventions to allow for improved quality of life and an extended life span.

No evidence of association between apolipoprotein E genotype and phenotypic severity in childhood onset proximal spinal muscular atrophy

The survival motor neuron (SMN) gene is present in two copies on chromosome 5q13 and the evidence is now compelling that mutations in the telomeric copy (SMNt) of the gene underlie childhood onset proximal spinal muscular atrophy (SMA). There is a correlation between the number of centromeric SMN gene copies (SMNc) and the clinical severity of the disease but this relationship is not absolute. Allelic variants of the apolipoprotein E (APOE) gene encoded on chromosome 19q are known to influence the prognosis and risk in a number of neurological disorders. We have therefore genotyped 166 unrelated cases of SMA to determine whether the presence of specific APOE genotypes correlates with severity of disease. The study failed to show the influence of any particular APOE genotype on disease severity, with specifically APOE epsilon4 being no more common in the milder SMA forms and APOE epsilon2 not over represented in type I SMA. A limited study of 23 SMA families also failed to show any influence of APOE genotype on SMA disease severity. Factors other than APOE genotype must therefore be responsible for determining SMA disease severity.

A collaborative study on the natural history of childhood and juvenile onset proximal spinal muscular atrophy (type II and III SMA): 569 patients

We analyzed clinical data of 569 patients in two combined series with childhood and juvenile proximal SMA. This cohort included only patients who had achieved the ability to sit unaided (type II and III SMA). The survival rate among 240 type II patients (who sat but never walked) was 98.5% at 5 years and 68.5% at 25 years. SMA III (n = 329) (those who walked and had symptoms before age 30 years) was subdivided into those with an onset before and after age 3 years (type IIIa, n = 195; SMA IIIb, n = 134). In patients with SMA III, life expectancy is not significantly less than a normal population. The probabilities of being able to walk at 10 years after onset was 70.3%, and at 40 years, 22.0% in SMA IIa. For SMA IIIb, 96.7% were walking 10 years after onset and 58.7% at 40 years. The subdivision of type III SMA was justified by the probability of being ambulatory depending on age at onset; the prognosis differed for those with onset before or after age 3 years. The data provide a reliable basis of the natural history of proximal SMA and support a classification system that is based primarily on age at onset and the achievement of motor milestones.

Sonographic and maternal serum screening abnormalities in fetuses affected by spinal muscular atrophy

Fetuses with degenerative neurological disorders or metabolic diseases rarely exhibit sonographic abnormalities. As a result, prenatal diagnosis, when available, requires invasive testing. Prenatal diagnosis of spinal muscular atrophy (SMA) can be made by testing chorionic villi or amniocytes. Indirect genotype analysis by use of single- and multi-locus polymorphic microsatellites of the region 5q11.2-q13.3 is used. We present two cases of SMA that manifested at 11 and 16 weeks' gestation by the presence of abnormal ultrasound findings. Each case also had abnormal maternal serum screening.

Complex repetitive arrangements of gene sequence in the candidate region of the spinal muscular atrophy gene in 5q13

Childhood-onset proximal spinal muscular atrophy (SMA) is a heritable neurological disorder, which has been mapped by genetic linkage analysis to chromosome 5q13, in the interval between markers D5S435 and D5S557. Here, we present gene sequences that have been isolated from this interval, several of which show sequence homologies to exons of beta-glucuronidase. These gene sequences are repeated several times across the candidate region and are also present on chromosome 5p. The arrangement of these repetitive gene motifs is polymorphic between individuals. The high degree of variability observed may have some influence on the expression of the genes in the region. Since SMA is not inherited as a classical autosomal recessive disease, novel genomic rearrangements arising from aberrant recombination events between the complex repeats may be associated with the phenotype observed.

Spinal muscular atrophy: new thoughts on the pathogenesis and classification schema

We have established the first prospective, collaborative study of spinal muscular atrophy, the second most common neuromuscular disease of childhood. One hundred and forty-one patients have been evaluated on at least four occasions over a 3-year period. The patients have been grouped by age of onset, as well as by function at the time of initial evaluation. The muscle strength of 96 patients aged 5 years or older was evaluated at 6-month intervals using a fixed myometry system. The new observations made are: (1) The present classification schema is not valid; for example, 49 patients with onset of weakness before 6 months of age (type I or Werdnig-Hoffmann disease), whose life span is said to be only 2 to 4 years, participated in the study and are 4 months to 31 years of age. (2) Thirty-seven patients were evaluated over an 18-month period. None lost strength during this time but four lost function. Although the period of observation was short, the results suggest that the loss of function in patients with spinal muscular atrophy might be explained by a process other than cell death that allows patient strength to be maintained and simultaneously prevents the motor unit from achieving its normal adult potential.

Population data on acute infantile and chronic childhood spinal muscular atrophy in Warsaw

This study provides epidemiological data on acute infantile (ASMA) and chronic childhood spinal (CSMA) muscular atrophy in Warsaw for the period 1976-1985. All calculations are based on the assumption that ASMA and CSMA result from mutations at two different gene loci. The incidence of ASMA and CSMA was 1 in 19474 live births with a corresponding gene and carrier frequency of 714 x 10(-5) and 1 in 70, respectively. The prevalence of CSMA for the year 1985 was 1.26 x 10(-5). These figures are higher than in similar studies in other countries. This fact might be connected with the careful ascertainment in this study.

Child neuromuscular disease in southern Norway. Prevalence, age and distribution of diagnosis with special reference to "non-Duchenne muscular dystrophy"

The prevalence of child neuromuscular disease in Southern Norway by January 1st, 1983, was studied by collecting data from all available sources. All children born 1. 1. 1965 or later were included in the study. The total group consisted of 110 patients from 17 different diagnostic categories. Total prevalence on this group was found to be 24.9 X 10(5). Duchenne muscular dystrophy (DMD), with a prevalence of 10.89 X 10(5) constituted 29.2% of the total material. In the spinal muscle atrophy group (SMA), we found a significant increase in the number of boys affected, although an autosomal recessive mode of inheritance was found likely in all probands. Prevalence figures of child neuromuscular disease are hard to compare, as most studies deal with an adult population. The prevalences of common and well-known large categories of neuromuscular diseases in childhood are in agreement with previous studies. For less well known and mild diseases, our figures are low. This may be due in part to a later onset and in part to a health system not sensitive to parents' complaints.

Chronic proximal spinal muscular atrophy of childhood and adolescence: problems of classification and genetic counselling

Results obtained from a study of 354 cases of chronic proximal spinal muscular atrophy of childhood and adolescence suggest that the condition is not as homogeneous as it was previously thought. A tentative classification based on our results is proposed. Estimates of genetic risks are provided, taking into account the sex and age at clinical onset. In our opinion these factors are more reliable than the data hitherto available because they are based on a considerably larger series.