Hearing loss in brainstem disorders

Neuroaudiological Considerations for the Auditory Brainstem Response and Middle Latency Response Revisited: Back to the Future

The auditory brainstem response (ABR) and middle latency response (MLR) are two sets of evoked potentials that have made major contributions to the field of diagnostic audiology. Many of these contributions were guided by clinical research audiologists. Though many of these auditory evoked potentials (AEPs) are still being used diagnostically by audiologists, there has been a steep decline in their popularity both clinically and in the research laboratory. This is indeed most unfortunate because these AEPs could and should be advancing our field and benefitting many patients. In this article, some critical research is overviewed that addresses some of the reasons why these AEPs (ABR and MLR) are not being utilized as frequently as they should be for neuroauditory assessments. Reflecting on our past when ABR and MLR were more commonly used can serve as a model for our future. Multiple applications and the diagnostic value of these AEPs are presented in an effort to convince audiologists that these electrophysiologic procedures should be revisited and reapplied in the clinic and research settings. It is argued that the dwindling use of ABR and MLR (and AEPs in general) in the field of audiology is not only remarkably premature but also lacks good scientific grounding. While on the other hand, if applied clinically, the value of these AEPs is both substantial and promising.

Effectiveness of Brainstem Auditory Evoked Potentials Scoring in Evaluating Brainstem Dysfunction and Disability Among Individuals With Multiple Sclerosis

Purpose The brainstem dysfunction in multiple sclerosis (MS) often causes significant functional impairment leading to disability. This study aims to explore modified brainstem auditory evoked potential (BAEP) scores based on the pattern of BAEP abnormalities and relate with brainstem symptoms, brainstem functional system scores (BFSS), brainstem lesions, and disability. Method Forty-five participants with relapsing-remitting MS and 45 age- and gender-matched healthy controls underwent case history assessment, otoscopic examination, pure-tone audiometry, and BAEP testing. Also, neurological examination (Expanded Disability Status Scale, FSS scales) and magnetic resonance imaging were carried out on MS participants. Patterns of BAEP abnormalities were categorized and converted to BAEP scores. Results Out of 45 participants' brainstem symptoms, BFSS > 1, brainstem lesions (magnetic resonance imaging), and BAEP abnormalities were observed in 75.6%, 42.2%, 62.2%, and 55.56% of participants, respectively. Waves V and III abnormalities were more common among MS participants and showed a significant difference from the control group in the Mann-Whitney U test. Chi-square test did not show a significant association of BAEP abnormalities with brainstem symptoms and lesions but showed significant association with BFSS. The mean and standard deviation of BAEP scores in MS participants were 1.73 + 2.37. All healthy controls showed BAEP scores of 0. BAEP scores in MS participants showed significant correlation with BFSS scores and predict Expanded Disability Status Scale scores. Conclusion BAEP scores based on the pattern of BAEP abnormality can be a valid and useful measure in evaluating brainstem functions and predicting disability in MS.

Audiovestibular Evolution in a Patient with Multiple Sclerosis

Multiple sclerosis is characterized by the presence of multiple plaques within the central nervous system, manifesting as remission and exacerbation of neurologic dysfunction over variable time courses. We present the case of a 20-year-old woman. Before treatment, her auditory brain stem response (ABR) test revealed bilateral prolongation. A caloric test showed canal paresis of the right ear and a normal response on the left. A vestibular evoked myogenic potential (VEMP) test displayed an absent response in the right ear and a delayed response in the left. A magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) scan demonstrated multiple diffuse high signal lesions in the hemispheres, brain stem, and cerebellum. Six months after treatment, the demyelinating plaques were shown to have resolved spontaneously on MRI. Recovery of caloric responses was anticipated. Bilateral prolongation of ABRs remained, but the VEMP test disclosed a normal response in the right ear and a delayed response in the left. Accordingly, in addition to MRI, caloric tests and ABR and VEMP tests are useful in monitoring the evolution of audiovestibular function in patients with multiple sclerosis.

Hearing disorders in brainstem lesions

Auditory processing can be disrupted by brainstem lesions. It is estimated that approximately 57% of brainstem lesions are associated with auditory disorders. However diseases of the brainstem usually involve many structures, producing a plethora of other neurologic deficits, often relegating "auditory symptoms in the background." Lesions below or within the cochlear nuclei result in ipsilateral auditory-processing abnormalities detected in routine testing; disorders rostral to the cochlear nuclei may result in bilateral abnormalities or may be silent. Lesions in the superior olivary complex and trapezoid body show a mixture of ipsilateral, contralateral, and bilateral abnormalities, whereas lesions of the lateral lemniscus, inferior colliculus, and medial geniculate body do not affect peripheral auditory processing and result in predominantly subtle contralateral abnormalities that may be missed by routine auditory testing. In these cases psychophysical methods developed for the evaluation of central auditory function should be employed (e.g., dichotic listening, interaural time perception, sound localization). The extensive connections of the auditory brainstem nuclei not only are responsible for binaural interaction but also assure redundancy in the system. This redundancy may explain why small brainstem lesions are sometimes clinically silent. Any disorder of the brainstem (e.g., neoplasms, vascular disorders, infections, trauma, demyelinating disorders, neurodegenerative diseases, malformations) that involves the auditory pathways and/or centers may produce hearing abnormalities.

Pure-tone auditory thresholds are not chronically elevated in multiple sclerosis

Despite the fact that acute cases of multiple sclerosis (MS)-related pure-tone hearing loss have been reported in the literature, consensus is lacking as to the chronic influences of MS on pure-tone thresholds. Most studies examining such influences have been limited by small sample sizes, lack of statistical comparisons between patients and controls, and confounding of the hearing measure with influences from sex and age. To date, associations between pure-tone thresholds and central MS-related brain lesions have not been assessed. In this study, pure-tone thresholds ranging from 0.5 to 8 kHz were measured in 73 MS patients and 73 individually age- and gender-matched normal controls. In 63 MS patients, correlations were computed between the threshold values and MRI-determined lesion activity in 26 central brain regions. Although thresholds were strongly influenced by sex, age, and tonal frequency, no meaningful influences of MS were discerned. Moreover, no significant association between the threshold values and central MS-related lesion activity was evident in any brain region evaluated. This study, the largest on this topic to use carefully matched control subjects and the sole study to assess relationships between auditory thresholds and central MS-related lesions, strongly suggests that (a) MS is not chronically associated with pure-tone hearing loss and (b) pure-tone thresholds are unrelated to MS lesion activity in higher brain regions. These findings, along with general reports from the literature, support the concept that when MS-related hearing threshold deficits are found, they are episodic and primarily dependent on lesions within the eighth nerve or brainstem.

Sensorineural Hearing Loss and Word Deafness Caused by a Mesencephalic Lesion: Clinicoelectrophysiologic Correlations

OBJECTIVE

To assess the role of inferior colliculi as a generator of Wave V of brainstem auditory evoked potentials and in modulating the olivocochlear efferent auditory system.

STUDY DESIGN

Case review.

SETTING

University and tertiary referral centers.

PATIENTS

Case report of a patient with word deafness caused by mesencephalic hemorrhage according to audiologic and electrophysiologic findings.

RESULTS

The patient is a 48-year-old woman who suffered word deafness caused by hemorrhage localized at the quadrigeminal plate (including the inferior colliculi). At a follow-up visit, her pure-tone audiogram revealed symmetric severe sensorineural hearing loss that had partially resolved, whereas speech audiometry showed persistent word deafness. Acoustic reflexes were elicited, with normal thresholds bilaterally. Transient evoked otoacoustic emissions were recorded from both ears, with normal response and signal-to-noise ratio, but there was a failure for their amplitude to be suppressed with contralateral sound stimulation. Brainstem auditory evoked potentials were of normal amplitude and latencies bilaterally.

CONCLUSION

The finding of normal brainstem auditory evoked potentials supports the view that the neural generator of Wave V lies caudally to the inferior colliculi. Moreover, the abnormal suppression of transient evoked otoacoustic emissions indicates that descending collicular input is capable of modulating levels of excitability within the olivary nucleus and the cochlea.

Pineal region tumor manifesting initially as hearing impairment

An 18-year-old male presented with a pineal region germinoma with hearing impairment as the chief complaint. Magnetic resonance image demonstrated a well-enhanced multi-cystic tumor extending into the upper fourth ventricle and wall of the bilateral lateral ventricles. Audiometry revealed bilateral mild hearing impairment in the low frequencies. Auditory brainstem response recording showed low amplitudes in all waves (IV-V/I ratio < 1) with prolong latencies (I-V and III-V) on the right but no discernable wave at 60 dB clicks on left. Hearing impairment and audiometric findings were improved after ventriculoperitoneal shunt operation. The hearing impairment appeared to be a mixed (conductive and sensorineural) type. The tumor was responsible for the sensorineural deafness because of invasion and compression of the central auditory structures. The inferior brachium was maximally compressed anterolaterally by the dilated bilateral lateral ventricles and posteromedially by the tumor. Hydrocephalus caused conductive deafness by halting or arresting the footplate of stapes movement, as a consequence of high-pressure transmission through the cochlear aqueduct.

Auditory deficits and hearing loss associated with focal brainstem haemorrhage

Four cases of central pontine haemorrhage are described in which auditory dysfunction was documented. Two cases had a hearing loss, in one of which there was recovery of the low frequencies. This case provides support for the tonotopic organization of the auditory pathways in the caudal pontine area, with the lowest frequencies being encoded medially. In all cases, there were abnormalities of the auditory brainstem responses, wave V being consistently involved, while wave III was abnormal in only one patient. In three cases, the masking level differences and crossed acoustic reflex thresholds were abnormal. The ipsilateral reflex thresholds were normal at least on one side in all cases. In the patient with the most significant hearing loss, loudness recruitment, assessed both psychophysically and with the acoustic reflex thresholds, was evident. These data are interpreted in terms of there being damage to the medial superior olivary nuclei and trapezoid body involving both afferent and efferent fibres.

Stapedius reflex in multiple sclerosis

The stapedius reflex (StR) was studied in humans by impedance audiometry. Ipsilateral and contralateral reflexes, obtained from 48 multiple sclerosis (MS) patients and 26 controls, were analysed. MS patients showed smaller reflex amplitudes, longer onset latencies and higher contralateral reflex thresholds. Using onset latencies, 33% of all MS patients had at least two abnormal ipsi- and/or contralateral StRs. If the diagnosis was MS of the definite type, this figure was 39%. The StR is therefore a useful tool for detecting a subclinical lesion in the brainstem and can contribute to the early diagnosis of MS.

Brain stem auditory evoked potentials and blink reflexes in multiple sclerosis

Brain stem auditory evoked potentials (BAEP) and the blink reflex (BR) were recorded from 50 patients with a wide spectrum of multiple sclerosis, to determine whether the combination of the two tests of brain stem function would yield a higher rate of abnormality than each test performed alone. Sixty-four per cent of patients had a BAEP abnormality and fifty-two per cent had an abnormal BR, but when the results were combined, seventy-six per cent were abnormal. The blink reflex was abnormal in all patients with symptoms suggestive of trigemino-facial pathology.

The acute deafness of definite multiple sclerosis: BAEP patterns

Of 705 patients with or suspected of multiple sclerosis who underwent evoked potential recording during a 5 year period, 12 patients with definite multiple sclerosis experienced an acute hearing loss during a relapse of the demyelinating disease. Hearing loss was unilateral in all of the 12 cases but one; tinnitus was associated with hearing loss in 9 of the 12 patients. Deafness is an unfrequent symptom in the course of multiple sclerosis, being estimated to be no more than 3% in large series of multiple sclerosis. Brain-stem auditory evoked potentials were recorded in all 12 patients, during the relapse with acute hearing loss in 4 of them, after the relapse with hearing loss in the 8 others. During the relapse with hearing loss, BAEP abnormalities were present ipsilateral to the hearing loss in all 4 patients, wave I being absent in 2 of them. BAEPs were drastically improved when recorded after the relapse with hearing loss in 2 of the 3 patients in whom repeated records were made. BAEPs were abnormal on the side of the previous hearing loss in 5 out of the 8 patients recorded after the relapse with hearing loss. Clinical and BAEP data suggest that, in accordance with the anatomical organization of the auditory pathways, the lesion causing unilateral hearing loss in multiple sclerosis could be situated in the cochlear nerve or close to its entry zone in the brain-stem. However, dissociation between unilateral hearing loss and a normal peak I and I-III interval may occur.

The effect of multiple sclerosis on pure tone thresholds

The pure tone audiograms of 44 multiple sclerosis (MS) and 44 matched neurological control patients were studied with a view to finding out whether demyelinating disease is associated with decreased acuity to pure tones. The results show that MS patients have essentially normal hearing but auditory acuity at some of the low frequencies was found to be significantly worse in the MS group compared to the control patients. No correlation was found between the affected frequencies and the patients' age, sex and duration of the disease. The differences in thresholds between the control and MS patients were confined to the 25 patients who had clinical evidence of brain stem lesions suggesting that the cause of the abnormality in thresholds is in the brain stem.

Auditory deficits in multiple sclerosis: a review

This article reviews available clinical and psychophysical data concerning the effects of multiple sclerosis (MS) on basic auditory processes. On the basis of the data, it is suggested that the presence of auditory deficits should be sought in MS patients. This is especially important in light of recent psychophysical evidence suggesting that subtle auditory problems present in affected individuals may not always be detectable via conventional clinical testing. These data also provide an alternate means of interpreting various aspects of impaired auditory functioning in MS patients, and aid in generating new hypotheses regarding the possible consequences of demyelination on normal auditory perception. Finally, new ways of testing such hypotheses are proposed, and possible directions for future research are suggested.