Click-evoked vestibular activation in the Tullio phenomenon

A Review of Neural Data and Modelling to Explain How a Semicircular Canal Dehiscence (SCD) Causes Enhanced VEMPs, Skull Vibration Induced Nystagmus (SVIN), and the Tullio Phenomenon

Angular acceleration stimulation of a semicircular canal causes an increased firing rate in primary canal afferent neurons that result in nystagmus in healthy adult animals. However, increased firing rate in canal afferent neurons can also be caused by sound or vibration in patients after a semicircular canal dehiscence, and so these unusual stimuli will also cause nystagmus. The recent data and model by Iversen and Rabbitt show that sound or vibration may increase firing rate either by neural activation locked to the individual cycles of the stimulus or by slow changes in firing rate due to fluid pumping ("acoustic streaming"), which causes cupula deflection. Both mechanisms will act to increase the primary afferent firing rate and so trigger nystagmus. The primary afferent data in guinea pigs indicate that in some situations, these two mechanisms may oppose each other. This review has shown how these three clinical phenomena-skull vibration-induced nystagmus, enhanced vestibular evoked myogenic potentials, and the Tullio phenomenon-have a common tie: they are caused by the new response of semicircular canal afferent neurons to sound and vibration after a semicircular canal dehiscence.

Inter-trial coherence as a measure of synchrony in cervical vestibular evoked myogenic potentials

BACKGROUND

Cervical vestibular evoked myogenic potentials (cVEMPs) are surface-recorded responses that reflect saccular function. Analysis of cVEMPs has focused, nearly exclusively, on time-domain waveform measurements such as amplitude and latency of response peaks, but synchrony-based measures have not been previously reported.

NEW METHOD

Time-frequency analyses were used to apply an objective response-detection algorithm and to quantify response synchrony. These methods are new to VEMP literature and have been adapted from previous auditory research. Air-conducted cVEMPs were elicited using a 500Hz tone burst in twenty young, healthy participants.

RESULTS

Time-frequency characteristics of cVEMPs and time-frequency boundaries for response energy were established. An inter-trial coherence analysis approach revealed highly synchronous responses with representative inter-trial coherence values of approximately 0.7.

COMPARISON WITH EXISTING METHODS

Inter-trial coherence measures were highly correlated with conventional amplitude measures in this group of young, healthy adults (R² = 0.91 - 0.94), although the frequencies at which these measures had their largest magnitude were unrelated (R² =.02). Conventional measures of peak-to-peak amplitude and latency were consistent with previous literature. Interaural asymmetry ratios were comparable between amplitude- and synchrony-based measures.

CONCLUSIONS

Synchrony-based time-frequency analyses were successfully applied to cVEMP data and this type of analysis may be helpful to differentiate synchrony from amplitude in populations with disrupted neural synchrony.

Understanding motor control in health and disease: classic single (n = 1) observations

The field of neuroscience is increasingly dominated by a preferred use of big data, where analysis of large numbers has become an essential area of development. We here draw attention to the importance of smaller numbers, and more specifically, to the historical and continued importance of detailed and judiciously performed studies in single healthy volunteers or single patients with a unique clinical presentation, as an important approach to study normal functions of the nervous system, and to understand the pathophysiology underlying neurological movement disorders. We illustrate this by discussing several historical examples and by summarising Professor John Rothwell's impressive body of work in single-patient studies, highlighting some of his seminal n = 1 studies that have had a great impact on the field. In doing so, we hope to provide a powerful incentive for the next generation of neuroscientists to keep appreciating the value of detailed analyses of single observations.

Vestibular Evoked Myogenic Potential (VEMP) Testing for Diagnosis of Superior Semicircular Canal Dehiscence

Superior semicircular canal dehiscence is a bony defect of the superior semicircular canal, which can lead to a variety of auditory and vestibular symptoms. The diagnosis of superior semicircular canal dehiscence (SCD) can be challenging, time consuming, and costly. The clinical presentation of SCD patients resembles that of other otologic disease, necessitating objective diagnostics. Although temporal bone CT imaging provides excellent sensitivity for SCD detection, it lacks specificity. Because the treatment of SCD is surgical, it is crucial to use a highly specific test to confirm the diagnosis and avoid false positives and subsequent unnecessary surgery. This review provides an update on recent improvements in vestibular evoked myogenic potential (VEMP) testing for SCD diagnosis. Combining audiometric and conventional cervical VEMP results improves SCD diagnostic accuracy. High frequency VEMP testing is superior to all other methods described to date. It is highly specific for the detection of SCD and may be used to guide decision-making regarding the need for subsequent CT imaging. This algorithmic sequential use of testing can substantially reduce radiation exposure as well as cost associated with SCD diagnosis.

Ocular vestibular evoked myogenic potential (VEMP) reveals mesencephalic HTLV-1-associated neurological disease

Purpose

Vestibular Myogenic Evoked Potential (VEMP) evaluates vestibulo-ocular and vestibulo-collic reflexes involved in the function of the otolithic organs and their afferent pathways. We compared the results of cervical and ocular VEMP in HTLV-1 associated myelopathy (HAM) and HTLV-1-asymptomatic infection.

Participants and methods

This cross-sectional study included 52 HTLV-1-infected individuals (26 HAM and 26 asymptomatic carriers) and 26 seronegative controls. The groups were similar regarding age and gender. Participants underwent simultaneous ocular and cervical VEMP. The stimulus to generate VEMP was a low-frequency tone burst sound tone burst, with an intensity of 120 decibels normalized hearing level, bandpass filter from 10 to 1,500 Hertz (Hz), with 100 stimuli at 500 Hz and 50 milliseconds recording time. The latencies of the electrophysiological waves P13 and N23 for cervical VEMP and N10 and P15 waves for ocular VEMP were compared among the groups. The absence or delay of the electrophysiological waves were considered abnormal results.

Results

Ocular VEMP was similar among the groups for N10 (p = 0.375) and different for P15 (p≤0.001). Cervical VEMP was different for P13 (p = 0.001) and N23 (p = 0.003). About ocular VEMP, in the HTLV-1-asymptomatic group, normal waves were found in 23(88.5%) individuals; in HAM group, normal waves were found in 7(26.9%). About cervical VEMP, 18(69.2%) asymptomatic carriers presented normal waves and only 3(11.5%) patients with HAM presented normal waves. Abnormalities in both VEMPs were found in 1(3.8%) asymptomatic carrier and in 16(61.5%) patients with HAM.

Conclusion

Neurological impairment in HAM was not restricted to the spinal cord. The mesencephalic connections, tested by ocular VEMP, have been also altered. Damage of the oculomotor system, responsible for eye stabilization during head and body movements, may explain why dizziness is such a frequent complaint in HAM.

Third Window Syndrome: Surgical Management of Cochlea-Facial Nerve Dehiscence

Objective: This communication is the first assessment of outcomes after surgical repair of cochlea-facial nerve dehiscence (CFD) in a series of patients. Pre- and post-operative quantitative measurement of validated survey instruments, symptoms, diagnostic findings and anonymous video descriptions of symptoms in a cohort of 16 patients with CFD and third window syndrome (TWS) symptoms were systematically studied. Study design: Observational analytic case-control study. Setting: Quaternary referral center. Patients: Group 1 had 8 patients (5 children and 3 adults) with CFD and TWS who underwent surgical management using a previously described round window reinforcement technique. Group 2 had 8 patients (2 children and 6 adults) with CFD who did not have surgical intervention. Interventions: The Dizziness Handicap Inventory (DHI) and Headache Impact Test (HIT-6) were administered pre-operatively and post-operatively. In addition, diagnostic findings of comprehensive audiometry, cervical vestibular evoked myogenic potential (cVEMP) thresholds and electrocochleography (ECoG) were studied. Symptoms before and after surgical intervention were compared. Main outcome measures: Pre- vs. post-operative DHI, HIT-6, and audiometric data were compared statistically. The thresholds and amplitudes for cVEMP in symptomatic ears, ears with cochlea-facial nerve dehiscence and ears without CFD were compared statistically. Results: There was a highly significant improvement in DHI and HIT-6 at pre- vs. post-operative (p < 0.0001 and p < 0.001, respectively). The age range was 12.8-52.9 years at the time of surgery (mean = 24.7 years). There were 6 females and 2 males. All 8 had a history of trauma before the onset of their symptoms. The mean cVEMP threshold was 75 dB nHL (SD 3.8) for the operated ear and 85.7 dB (SD 10.6) for the unoperated ear. In contrast to superior semicircular canal dehiscence, where most ears have abnormal ECoG findings suggestive of endolymphatic hydrops, only 1 of 8 operated CFD ears (1 of 16 ears) had an abnormal ECoG study. Conclusions: Overall there was a marked improvement in DHI, HIT-6 and symptoms post-operatively. Statistically significant reduction in cVEMP thresholds was observed in patients with radiographic evidence of CFD. Surgical management with round window reinforcement in patients with CFD was associated with improved symptoms and outcomes measures.

About the pathophysiology of acute unilateral vestibular deficit - vestibular neuritis (VN) or peripheral vestibulopathy (PVP)?

OBJECTIVE

To determine whether patients with acute unilateral peripheral vestibulopathy (PVP), often called "vestibular neuritis/neuronitis or neuropathy" (VN) have a vestibular lesion pattern consistent with the distribution of the neurological afferents.

BACKGROUND

Much is known about the clinical nature of PVP, however less so about its etiology and pathogenesis. Due to the frequency with which VN is used to describe the syndrome, an inflammation of the vestibular nerve or of one of its branches is often assumed to be the cause of PVP, though there is insufficient data so far to support this assumption.

METHODS

We conducted a retrospective study of 25 patients who had presented to our clinic with PVP and had all vestibular receptor organs tested shortly after start of symptoms. We analysed their vestibular lesion patterns in order to determine whether they were consistent with the neuritis hypothesis (NH).

RESULTS

The lesion patterns varied conspicuously. 76% did not follow an innervation pattern, thereby contradicting the NH and only 24% had a lesion pattern that either definitely (16%) or probably (8%) supported the NH.

CONCLUSION

These results should remind us to be careful before jumping to quick conclusions about the pathogenetic nature of PVP. With any reason to question VN as the only cause of PVP, we should reconsider the treatment approach to PVP. If the cause probably or even possibly lies inside the vestibular labyrinth, an intratympanic steroid injection might prove to be a more effective measure, even in first-line treatment. If the etiology is unsure, a combination of systemic and intratympanic steroid treatment may be adequate.

Superior Canal Dehiscence Syndrome: Lessons from the First 20 Years

Superior semicircular canal dehiscence syndrome was first reported by Lloyd Minor and colleagues in 1998. Patients with a dehiscence in the bone overlying the superior semicircular canal experience symptoms of pressure or sound-induced vertigo, bone conduction hyperacusis, and pulsatile tinnitus. The initial series of patients were diagnosed based on common symptoms, a physical examination finding of eye movements in the plane of the superior semicircular canal when ear canal pressure or loud tones were applied to the ear, and high-resolution computed tomography imaging demonstrating a dehiscence in the bone over the superior semicircular canal. Research productivity directed at understanding better methods for diagnosing and treating this condition has substantially increased over the last two decades. We now have a sound understanding of the pathophysiology of third mobile window syndromes, higher resolution imaging protocols, and several sensitive and specific diagnostic tests. Furthermore, we have a treatment (surgical occlusion of the superior semicircular canal) that has demonstrated efficacy. This review will highlight some of the fundamental insights gained in SCDS, propose diagnostic criteria, and discuss future research directions.

Cervical vestibular evoked myogenic potentials in children

Introduction

Cervical vestibular evoked myogenic potential is a test used in neurotological examination. It verifies the integrity of vestibular function through a muscular response evoked by an acoustic stimulation which activates the saccular macula. Normal standards in adults have been established, however, there are few published data on the normal responses in children.

Objective

To establish normal standards for vestibular myogenic responses in children without neurotological complaints.

Methods

This study's design is a cohort with cross-sectional analysis. The sample consisted of 30 subjects, 15 females (50%) and 15 males (50%).

Results

The age of the subjects ranged between 8 and 13 years, with a mean of 10.2 (± 1.7). P1 peak showed an average latency of 17.26 (± 1.78) ms and a mean amplitude of 49.34 (± 23.07) μV, and the N2 peak showed an average latency of 24.78 (± 2.18) ms and mean amplitude of 66.23 (± 36.18) μV. P1–N2 mean amplitude was 115.6 (± 55.7) μV. There were no statistically significant differences when comparing by gender or by laterality.

Conclusion

We established normal values of cervical myogenic vestibular responses in children between 8 and 13 years without neurotological complaints.

Superior semicircular canal dehiscence syndrome as assessed by oVEMP and temporal bone computed tomography imaging

To evaluate the role of oVEMP and multidetector CT scan in patients with superior canal dehiscence syndrome. Prospective study was conducted on nine patients with superior canal dehiscence syndrome (5 females, 4 males) age ranged 19-49 with mean age of 32.7 ± 9.3 years, complaining of intolerance to loud sounds and/or oscillopsia. The mean duration of illness was 18.7 ± 6.9 months, nine normal individuals as control (age and gender matched) were also included in the study. All of them underwent oVEMP and MDCT scan. Patients were of bilateral normal hearing sensitivity with no conductive impairment. All of the studied subjects (patients and controls) had identifiable contralateral oVEMP responses. MDCT scan showed dehiscence in all the patients. The dehiscence was unilateral (n = 7) and bilateral [n = 2 the other ear had a defect of 2 mm and thus was excluded from the study for fear or false diagnosis of Superior semicircular canal dehiscence syndrome (SCDS)]. Unlike the normal subject (nI = 0.94 µV ± 0.03 and pI = -0.42 µV ± 0.09), with stimulation of the affected side in SCDS, there were augmented amplitude responses (nI = 2.64 µV ± 0.35 and pI = -3.10 µV ± 0.44) in the eye contralateral to the stimulus "contralateral to the lesion". Mean oVEMP threshold for SCDS ears were 82.5 ± 7.55 dBnHL compared to 100 ± 5.77 dBnHL of the control ears. We concluded that combination of physiological and anatomical information from oVEMP and MDCT increased accuracy for diagnosis of dehiscence of superior semicircular canal.

Comparison of vestibular evoked myogenic potentials elicited by click and short duration tone burst stimuli

Introduction:

Vestibular evoked myogenic potentials are short latency electrical impulses that are produced in response to higher level acoustic stimuli. They are used clinically to diagnose sacculocollic pathway dysfunction.

Aim:

This study aimed to compare the vestibular evoked myogenic potential responses elicited by click stimuli and short duration tone burst stimuli, in normal hearing individuals.

Method:

Seventeen subjects participated. In all subjects, we assessed vestibular evoked myogenic potentials elicited by click and short duration tone burst stimuli.

Results and conclusion:

The latency of the vestibular evoked myogenic potential responses (i.e. the p13 and n23 peaks) was longer for tone burst stimuli compared with click stimuli. The amplitude of the p13–n23 waveform was greater for tone burst stimuli than click stimuli. Thus, the click stimulus may be preferable for clinical assessment and identification of abnormalities as this stimulus has less variability, while a low frequency tone burst stimulus may be preferable when assessing the presence or absence of vestibular evoked myogenic potential responses.

Vestibular evoked myogenic potentials: past, present and future

Since the first description of sound-evoked short-latency myogenic reflexes recorded from neck muscles, vestibular evoked myogenic potentials (VEMPs) have become an important part of the neuro-otological test battery. VEMPs provide a means of assessing otolith function: stimulation of the vestibular system with air-conducted sound activates predominantly saccular afferents, while bone-conducted vibration activates a combination of saccular and utricular afferents. The conventional method for recording the VEMP involves measuring electromyographic (EMG) activity from surface electrodes placed over the tonically-activated sternocleidomastoid (SCM) muscles. The "cervical VEMP" (cVEMP) is thus a manifestation of the vestibulo-collic reflex. However, recent research has shown that VEMPs can also be recorded from the extraocular muscles using surface electrodes placed near the eyes. These "ocular VEMPs" (oVEMPs) are a manifestation of the vestibulo-ocular reflex. Here we describe the historical development and neurophysiological properties of the cVEMP and oVEMP and provide recommendations for recording both reflexes. While the cVEMP has documented diagnostic utility in many disorders affecting vestibular function, relatively little is known as yet about the clinical value of the oVEMP. We therefore outline the known cVEMP and oVEMP characteristics in common central and peripheral disorders encountered in neuro-otology clinics.

Sound evoked triceps myogenic potentials

OBJECTIVE

To determine if a sound evoked myogenic potential could be obtained from the triceps with the recording and stimulus parameters routinely used to obtain a vestibular evoked myogenic potential (VEMP) from the sternocleidomastoid.

STUDY DESIGN

Prospective study of myogenic potentials recorded from the triceps in healthy subjects. We used a monaural acoustic stimulus and measured the unrectified myogenic potential using surface electromyography electrodes, using response-triggered averaging, on the triceps of 18 subjects.

SETTING

University-affiliated otoneurology clinic.

PATIENTS

Eighteen healthy adult volunteers (11 women and 7 men), age ranging between 27 and 36 years.

MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES

Latencies and amplitudes of the first two waves of the evoked response.

RESULTS

: The P1 latency was 36.83 +/- 8.42 ms (range, 26.34-57.99 ms; 95% confidence interval [CI], 33.53-40.14 ms), the N1 latency was 43.74 +/- 8.80 ms (range, 34.67-66.32 ms; 95% CI, 40.29-47.19 ms), the P1-N1 interlatency was 6.90 +/- 1.23 ms (range, 5.21-9.79 ms; 95% CI, 6.42-7.39 ms), and the P1-N1 interamplitude was 93.23 +/- 51.25 microV (range, 16.33-206.62 microV; 95% CI, 73.14-113.32 V).

CONCLUSION

A monaural sound stimulus elicits a robust and reproducible surface myogenic potential in triceps muscles.

Vestibular evoked myogenic potentials in normal mice and Phex mice with spontaneous endolymphatic hydrops

OBJECTIVE AND BACKGROUND

Vestibular evoked myogenic potentials (VEMPs) have been recorded from the neck musculature and the cervical spinal cord in humans and a limited number of laboratory animals in response to loud sound. However, the mouse VEMP has yet to be described. Evaluation of the sacculocollic pathway via VEMPs in mice can set the stage for future evaluations of mutant mice that now play an important role in research regarding human auditory and vestibular dysfunction.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Sound-evoked potentials were recorded from the neck extensor muscles and the cervical spinal cord in normal adult mice and in circling Phex(Hyp-Duk/y) mice with known vestibular abnormalities, including endolymphatic hydrops (ELH).

RESULTS

Biphasic potentials were recorded from all normal animals. The mean threshold of the VEMP response in normal adult mice was 60 dB normal hearing level with a mean peak latency of 6.25 +/- 0.46 and 7.95 +/- 0.42 milliseconds for p1 and n1 peaks, respectively. At the maximum sound intensity used (100 dB normal hearing level), 4 of 5 Phex mice did not exhibit VEMP responses, and 1 showed an elevated threshold, but normal response, with regard to peak latency and amplitude. The histologic findings in all of these Phex mice were consistent with distended membranous labyrinth, displaced Reissner membrane, ganglion cell loss, and ELH.

CONCLUSION

This is the first report of VEMP recordings in mice and the first report of abnormal VEMPs in a mouse model with ELH. The characteristics of these potentials such as higher response threshold in comparison to auditory brainstem response, myogenic nature of the response, and latency correlation with the cervical recording (accessory nerve nucleus) were similar to those of VEMPs in humans, guinea pigs, cats, and rats, suggesting that the mouse may be used as an animal model in the study of VEMPs. The simplicity and reliability of these recordings make the VEMP a uniquely informative test for assessing vestibular function, and these results suggest that they may be informative in mice with various mutations. However, further investigation is necessary.

The diagnostic value of vestibular-evoked myogenic potential in patients with vestibular schwannoma

OBJECTIVE

This study examined the diagnostic value of the vestibular-evoked myogenic potential (VEMP) in comparison with the caloric test in patients with vestibular schwannoma (VS).

METHODS

Data were retrospectively collected from 803 consecutive patients who visited our vertigo clinic and underwent vestibular tests. Amongst them, 78 patients were diagnosed as having untreated unilateral VS. VEMP was performed using click and short-tone burst stimulation. The caloric test was performed using ice water. The sensitivity and specificity of each test were evaluated.

RESULTS

Of the 78 patients with VS, 63 had abnormal VEMPs as well as abnormal caloric responses. Of the 725 patients without VS, 382 had normal VEMPs and 416 had normal caloric responses. The sensitivity and specificity of VEMP were 80.8% (95% CI: 72.0-89.5%) and 52.7% (95% CI: 49.1-56.3%), respectively; those of the caloric test were 80.8% (95% CI: 72.0-89.5%) and 57.4% (95% CI: 53.8-61.0%), respectively.

CONCLUSIONS

The sensitivity and specificity of VEMP and the caloric test showed no significant differences.

SIGNIFICANCE

In patients with VS, although the specificity of VEMP was not very high, its sensitivity was high and comparable to that of the caloric test.

Potencial evocado miogênico vestibular (Vemp): avaliação das respostas em indivíduos normais

TEMA: o Potencial Evocado Miogênico Vestibular (Vemp) é formado por respostas miogênicas ativadas por estimulação sonora de alta intensidade. Essas respostas são registradas por eletromiografia de superfície sobre a musculatura cervical na presença de contração muscular, ativando a mácula, o nervo vestibular inferior e as vias vestíbulo-espinhais descendentes. OBJETIVO: descrever as respostas evocadas do Vemp em uma população normal. MÉTODO: selecionaram-se 30 sujeitos adultos, sendo 13 homens e 17 mulheres, sem queixas otoneurológicas. Utilizou-se 200 estímulos tone burst com freqüência de 1Hz e intensidade de 118dB Na, filtro passa-banda de 10Hz a 1500Hz. Os traçados obtidos foram analisados em relação ao primeiro potencial bifásico composto por P13 e N23. RESULTADOS: não houve diferença estatisticamente significativa entre o lado da estimulação em relação a latência e amplitude, porém foi encontrada diferença estatisticamente significativa em relação à amplitude do potencial entre os sexos. CONCLUSÃO: Vemp demonstrou ser uma ferramenta confiável na avaliação da função vestibular.

Testing of vibratory thresholds as a clinical examination for patients with unsteadiness due to somatosensory disorders

The somatosensory system is an important component for balance control. Disorders of this system are characterized by postural unsteadiness and could be assessed by vibratory sensation. However, the measurement of vibratory thresholds (VTs) has been rarely employed as a clinical test for patients with unsteadiness. This study aimed to evaluate the difference in vibratory thresholds between patients with somatosensory disorders and healthy volunteers, and to provide a means for evaluating somatosensory disorders in patients with balance problems. Using a vibrometer and a force-measuring platform, VTs and postural balance in 108 healthy volunteers (age, 17-79) and 19 patients with somatosensory disorders (age, 60-79) were examined. VTs of the plantar surface, as well as total length of the path and envelope area (ENV) of posturograms, in patients with somatosensory disorders were significantly larger than those in healthy volunteers. Regression analyses showed that VTs> or =28dB (peak-to-peak amplitude, 24 microm) of the plantar surface at 125Hz and ENV> or =10 cm(2) were significant indices for unsteadiness due to somatosensory disorders. VT testing of the plantar surface as well as posturography appears to be useful as a clinical examination for patients with unsteadiness.

VEMP responses are not affected in non-insulin-dependent diabetes mellitus patients with or without polyneuropathy

CONCLUSION

Vestibular evoked myogenic responses (VEMPs) are not affected in non-insulin-dependent diabetes mellitus (NIDDM) patients with or without polyneuropathy.

OBJECTIVE

To compare VEMP responses of NIDDM patients and healthy subjects.

SUBJECTS AND METHODS

VEMP responses were collected from 25 NIDDM patients with polyneuropathy (PNP), 13 NIDDM patients without PNP and 21 healthy subjects using click stimulation. After excluding ears with hearing loss (HL) (worse than 25 dB) the VEMP responses (p13 and n21 latencies and amplitude) recorded in 105 dB stimulus intensity were compared.

RESULTS

There was no statistically significant difference between groups. VEMP responses were found to be normal in NIDDM patients with or without PNP.

Vestibulär evozierte myogene Potenziale

The recording of vestibular evoked myogenic potentials is a relatively new neuro-otologic method which gives specific information about the function of the sacculus and the inferior vestibular nerve on each side separately. The main indications for this method are vestibular schwannoma and fistula of the labyrinth, involvement of the sacculus or the inferior vestibular nerve in Menière's disease and vestibular neuritis, vertigo of unknown etiology, and forensic questions.

Vestibular Responses to Sound

Research into vestibular responses to sound has evolved in four stages. The first, largely the work of Tullio in the 1920s, involved inspection of the eye, head, and postural responses to sound of alert animals with surgical fenestrae into various parts of the bony labyrinth. The second, begun in 1964 by Bickford and his group and continued by our group and then by others in the last 10 years, involves the measurement of evoked myogenic potentials to air-conducted and bone-conducted clicks and tones in normal humans. The third, begun by Mikaelian at about the same time as Bickford and continued by McCue, our group, and others, involves electrophysiological recordings of primary vestibular afferent neuron responses to sound in anesthetized animals. The fourth involves measurements of vestibulo-ocular responses to sound in humans with the Tullio phenomenon. It was begun by Minor and his group in 1998 with the observation that sound-induced nystagmus in humans, the Tullio phenomenon, aligned with the rotation axis of the superior semicircular canal. They then showed a defect in the temporal bone between the apex of the superior semicircular canal and the middle cranial fossa, which was the cause of most, if not all, cases of sound-induced nystagmus. Here some of the key observations made in each of these four stages are reviewed.

Clinical Manifestations of Superior Semicircular Canal Dehiscence

OBJECTIVES/HYPOTHESES

To determine the symptoms, signs, and findings on diagnostic tests in patients with clinical manifestations of superior canal dehiscence. To investigate hypotheses about the effects of superior canal dehiscence. To analyze the outcomes in patients who underwent surgical repair of the dehiscence.

STUDY DESIGN

Review and analysis of clinical data obtained as a part of the diagnosis and treatment of patients with superior canal dehiscence at a tertiary care referral center.

METHODS

Clinical manifestations of superior semicircular canal dehiscence were studied in patients identified with this abnormality over the time period of May 1995 to July 2004. Criteria for inclusion in this series were identification of the dehiscence of bone overlying the superior canal confirmed with a high-resolution temporal bone computed tomography and the presence of at least one sign on physiologic testing indicative of superior canal dehiscence. There were 65 patients who qualified for inclusion in this study on the basis of these criteria. Vestibular manifestations were present in 60 and exclusively auditory manifestations without vestibular symptoms or signs were noted in 5 patients.

RESULTS

For the 60 patients with vestibular manifestations, symptoms induced by loud sounds were noted in 54 patients and pressure-induced symptoms (coughing, sneezing, straining) were present in 44. An air-bone on audiometry in these patients with vestibular manifestations measured (mean +/- SD) 19 +/- 14 dB at 250 Hz; 15 +/- 11 dB at 500 Hz; 11 +/- 9 dB at 1,000 Hz; and 4 +/- 6 dB at 2,000 Hz. An air-bone gap 10 dB or greater was present in 70% of ears with superior canal dehiscence tested at 250 Hz, 68% at 500 Hz, 64% at 1,000 Hz, and 21% at 2,000 Hz. Similar audiometric findings were noted in the five patients with exclusively auditory manifestations of dehiscence. The threshold for eliciting vestibular-evoked myogenic potentials from affected ears was (mean +/- SD) 81 +/- 9 dB normal hearing level. The threshold for unaffected ears was 99 +/- 7 dB, and the threshold for control ears was 98 +/- 4 dB. The thresholds in the affected ear were significantly different from both the unaffected ear and normal control thresholds (P < .001 for both comparisons). There was no difference between thresholds in the unaffected ear and normal control (P = .2). There were 20 patients who were debilitated by their symptoms and underwent surgical repair of superior canal dehiscence through a middle cranial fossa approach. Canal plugging was performed in 9 and resurfacing of the canal without plugging of the lumen in 11 patients. Complete resolution of vestibular symptoms and signs was achieved in 8 of the 9 patients after canal plugging and in 7 of the 11 patients after resurfacing.

CONCLUSIONS

Superior canal dehiscence causes vestibular and auditory symptoms and signs as a consequence of the third mobile window in the inner ear created by the dehiscence. Surgical repair of the dehiscence can achieve control of the symptoms and signs. Canal plugging achieves long-term control more often than does resurfacing.

Vestibular Evoked Myogenic Potentials

Vestibular evoked myogenic potential (VEMP) testing is a relatively new diagnostic tool that is in the process of being investigated in patients with specific vestibular disorders. In this review, we will outline the history and provide a current review of VEMP research. Briefly, the VEMP is a biphasic response elicited by loud clicks or tone bursts recorded from the tonically contracted sternocleidomastoid muscle. Current data suggest that the VEMP is a vestibulo-collic reflex whose afferent limb arises from acoustically sensitive cells in the saccule, with signals conducted via the inferior vestibular nerve. We will review the history of the response and detail the anatomy and physiology associated with the test. We will discuss specific VEMP applications in the diagnosis of Meniere's disease, vestibular schwannoma, vestibular hypersensitivity disorders, vestibular neuritis, multiple sclerosis, and other brainstem lesions.

Dehiscence of bone overlying the superior semicircular canal as a cause of an air-bone gap on audiometry: a case study

Dehiscence of bone overlying the superior semicircular canal can result in a syndrome of vertigo and oscillopsia induced by loud noises or by maneuvers that change middle ear or intracranial pressure. Patients with this disorder can also experience a heightened sensitivity to bone-conducted sounds in the presence of normal middle ear function. High-resolution CT scans of the temporal bones demonstrate the dehiscence. The authors describe a patient with bilateral superior canal dehiscence who had bilateral low-frequency conductive hearing loss, normal middle ear function, intact acoustic reflexes, and intact vestibular-evoked myogenic potentials. These findings would not be expected on the basis of a middle ear cause of the conductive hearing loss. A high-resolution CT scan of the temporal bones in this patient revealed bilateral superior canal dehiscence. Normal acoustic immittance findings in the presence of conductive hearing loss should alert clinicians to the possibility of inner ear cause of an air-bone gap due to superior canal dehiscence.

Clinical usefulness of glycerol vestibular-evoked myogenic potentials: preliminary report

The detection of intense sound-induced vestibular-evoked myogenic potentials (VEMPs) on the sternocleidomastoid muscle comprises the basis of the saccular function test. In order to evaluate the endolymphatic hydrops (EH) of the saccule of the inner ear, a glycerol VEMP (GVEMP) test was performed in 15 patients with unilateral typical Ménière's disease (UMD) and 7 with delayed endolymphatic hydrops (DEH). Using the GVEMP test, 8 of the 15 patients (53%) with UMD were evaluated as being abnormal. In addition, a greater number of patients (67%) were judged to be abnormal when the results of the GVEMP test were combined with those from a glycerol dehydration test, trans-tympanic electrocochleography (ECochG) or furosemide vestibulo-ocular reflex test (FVOR). Four of the 7 patients with DEH (57%) showed abnormal results in the GVEMP test. In particular, in patients with the ipsilateral type of DEH, only the GVEMP test was able to detect the affected side. These findings suggest that the GVEMP test is a new and useful test for EH, and that a test battery comprising the GVEMP test together with one of the other three tests is useful for diagnosing EH of the inner ear.

Vestibular-evoked myogenic potentials in the diagnosis of superior canal dehiscence syndrome

Patients with superior canal dehiscence (SCD) syndrome have vertigo and oscillopsia induced by loud noises and by stimuli that result in changes in middle ear or intracranial pressure. We recorded vestibular-evoked myogenic potentials (VEMP responses) in 10 patients with SCD syndrome. The diagnosis had been confirmed in each case by evoked eye movements and by high-resolution CT scans of the temporal bones that showed a dehiscence overlying the affected superior canal. For the 8 patients without prior middle ear disease, the VEMP threshold from the dehiscent ears measured 72 +/- 8 dB NHL (normal hearing level) whereas the threshold from normal control subjects was 96 +/- 5 dB NHL (p < 0.0001). The VEMP threshold measured from the contralateral ear in patients with unilateral dehiscence was 98 +/- 4 dB NHL (p > 0.9 with respect to normal controls). Two patients with apparent conductive hearing loss from middle ear disease, and SCD, had VEMP responses from the affected ears. In the absence of dehiscence, VEMP responses would not have been expected in the setting of conductive hearing loss. These findings confirm earlier studies demonstrating that patients with SCD syndrome have lowered VEMP thresholds. Conditions other than SCD syndrome may also lead to lowered VEMP thresholds. Rather than being based upon a single test, the diagnosis of SCD syndrome is best established when the characteristic symptoms, signs, VEMP response, and CT imaging all indicate SCD.

Sound-evoked postural responses in normal subjects

A pattern of sound-induced paroxysms of the eye and head and other spinal motor neuron synkinesis (Tullio's phenomenon) in human subjects always implies either a pathological contiguity of the tympano-ossicular chain and membranous labyrinth or a dehiscence of the bone overlying the superior semicircular canal. However, it has become clear in the last decade that sound-evoked vestibular stimulation is not only a sign of disease but also a physiological phenomenon, The examination of such physiologically sound-induced vestibular (saccular) responses contributes today to the clinical testing of the vestibular organ, mainly in the form of vestibular-evoked myogenic potentials. In this study it was observed that, in a group of 20 normal subjects, a 500 Hz tonal stimulus of high intensity (105 dB HL = 118.5 dB SPL), applied monoaurally, elicited postural responses. Each subject was studied under 4 different conditions: (i) head facing forwards, eyes open; (ii) head facing forwards, eyes closed; (iii) head rotated approximately 90 degrees to the right, eyes closed: and (iv) head rotated approximately 90 degrees to the left, eyes closed. Body sway, measured using a force platform, was recorded in all subjects, with eyes either open or closed. Postural responses, which were also elicited with a 250 Hz tonal stimulus, were not observed with a tone of 2000 Hz, with legs slightly flexed or with binaural stimulation. The postural sway (head facing forwards, eyes open or closed) was in a lateral direction towards the stimulated ear: with the stimulus applied to the right ear the subject had postural sway towards the right, with the stimulus applied to the left ear towards the left. When the head was rotated approximately 90 degrees sideways and the stimulus was given facing forwards (i.e. head rotated contralaterally to stimulated ear) the postural sway was in a forward direction; when the head was rotated approximately 90 degrees sideways and the stimulus was given facing backwards (i.e. head rotated ipsilaterally to stimulated ear) the postural sway was in a backward direction. The mean values (mm) of body sway obtained with the head facing forwards and the eyes closed were higher than those with the eyes open (21.7 and 22.8 vs 15.7 and 14.7 for the right and left ears, respectively); higher mean values were obtained with the head turned to the side contralateral to the ear stimulated and the eyes closed (29.3 and 24.8 for the right and left ears, respectively). Under this condition the body sway was mainly in a forward direction. The sound-evoked vestibulopostural reflex seems to be a useful test for exploring the saccular function and, as a click-evoked vestibulocollic reflex, can be considered a physiological Tullio phenomenon.

Symptoms, findings and treatment in patients with dehiscence of the superior semicircular canal

Recently Minor and co-workers described patients with sound- and pressure-induced vertigo due to dehiscence of the superior semicircular canal. Identifying patients with this 'new' vestibular entity is important, not only because the symptoms are sometimes very incapacitating, but also because they can be treated. We present symptoms and findings in eight such patients, all of whom reported pressure-induced vertigo that increased during periods of upper respiratory infections. Pulse-synchronous tinnitus and gaze instability during head movements were also common complaints. All patients lateralized Weber's test to the symptomatic ear. In some of the patients the audiogram also revealed a small conductive hearing loss. However, the stapedius reflexes were always normal. A vertical/torsional eye movement related to the superior semicircular canal was seen in most of the patients in response to pressure changes and/or sound stimulation. One patient also had superior canal-related positioning nystagmus. Testing vestibular evoked myogenic potentials revealed in all patients a vestibular hypersensitivity to sounds. In the coronal high-resolution 1-mm section CT scans the dehiscence was visible on 1 to 4 sections. Moreover, the skull base was rather thin in this area and cortical bone separating the middle ear and the antrum from the middle cranial fossa was absent in many of the patients. Two of the patients have undergone plugging of the superior semicircular canal using a transmastoid approach and both patients were relieved of the pressure-induced symptoms.

Vestibular-evoked myogenic potentials in patients with dehiscence of the superior semicircular canal

Recently Minor and co-workers described patients with sound- and pressure-induced vertigo due to dehiscence of bone overlying the superior semicircular canal. Identifying patients with this "new" vestibular entity is important, not only because the symptoms can be very incapacitating, but also because they are surgically treatable. We present symptoms and findings for three such patients. On exposure to sounds, especially in the frequency range 0.5-1 kHz, they showed vertical/torsional eye movements analogous to a stimulation of the superior semicircular canal. They also showed abnormally large sound-induced vestibular-evoked myogenic potentials (VEMP), i.e. the short latency sternomastoid muscle response considered to be of saccular origin. The VEMP also had a low threshold, especially in the frequency range 0.5-1 kHz. However, in response to saccular stimulation by skull taps, i.e. when the middle ear route was bypassed, the VEMP were not enlarged. This suggests that the relation between the sound-induced and the skull tap-induced responses can differentiate a large but normal VEMP from an abnormally large response due to dehiscence of bone overlying the labyrinth, because only the latter would produce large sound-induced VEMP compared to those induced by skull taps.

Relationship of the utriculus and sacculus to the stapes footplate: anatomic implications for sound-and/or pressure-induced otolith activation

One hundred thirty human temporal bones that were sectioned in the vertical plane were examined to evaluate the relationship between the stapes footplate and the otolith organs. The shortest distance between the footplate and the utriculus was 0.58+/-0.10 mm in the posterior third of the oval window, 1.04+/-0.20 mm in the middle third, and 1.51+/-0.20 mm in the anterior third. The distance from the sacculus to the footplate was 1.33+/-0.20 mm in the middle third of the oval window and 1.31+/-0.18 mm in the anterior third. Membranous connections extending between the utriculus and the footplate were found in 26% of temporal bones. These membranous connections in coexistence with additional anatomic factors such as stapes hypermobility and/or dehiscence of bone within labyrinthine structures may predispose patients to sound- and/or pressure-induced otolith activation. The findings may have implications for different causes of the Tullio phenomenon.

Effect of conductive hearing loss on the vestibulo-collic reflex

The vestibulo-collic reflex represents a promising test for evaluating the integrity of otolith function. We have investigated the threshold of this response in a group of normal subjects, and the effect of a conductive hearing loss. A positive response was recorded in 31 of 32 normal subjects. The threshold of the vestibulo-collic reflex varied from 80 to 97 dBHL in these subjects with a 95% response rate at a threshold at 96 dBHL. A total of 23 ears with a conductive hearing loss in 17 patients were also investigated. The average conductive hearing loss (at 0.5, 1, 2 and 4 kHz) ranged from 8.75 to 40 dBHL (average 24.46 dBHL). A positive response was recorded in only two ears. Therefore, the vestibulo-collic reflex has a high stimulus threshold which is dependant on reliable transmission of the click stimulus to the inner ear thus limiting is clinical use.

Clinical testing of otolith function

The subjective visual horizontal and vestibular-evoked myogenic potentials are simple, robust, and reproducible tests of otolith dysfunction that can prove clinically useful diagnostic information in patients with vertigo and other balance disorders. While they appear to have high specificity for unilateral otolith dysfunction, further clinical research will be required to establish their sensitivity.

Vestibular evoked myogenic potentials in humans: a review

The human vestibule has preserved an ancestral sound sensitivity and it has been suggested that a reflex could originate from this property, thus inducing cervical muscle microcontractions secondary to strong acoustic stimulations. This reflex is assumed to originate in the saccule, the afferent pathways being either the vestibulocochlear nerve or the inferior vestibular nerve, and the efferent pathways the vestibulospinal tract. Averaging these muscular responses allows vestibular evoked myogenic potentials (VEMPs) to be obtained. The responses consist of two alternatively positive and negative successive waves (p13-n23, p33-n43). The characteristics of this reflex are defined in the literature as follows: it has been established that VEMP amplitude depends on muscular tension. All studies give concording evidence that in healthy subjects the first component of VEMP is more consistent than the second. Binaural stimulation is always responsible for responses of greater amplitude than those obtained from monaural stimulation. Following monaural stimulation, however, VEMPs are either of greater amplitude on the muscle ipsilateral to the stimulation or of the same amplitude on both muscles. There is consensus in the literature demonstrating that VEMP amplitude depends on stimulus intensity: the threshold of VEMP occurrence is clearly above auditory level but varies from one individual to the next. In the 1970s, recordings performed in cases of specific audiovestibular defects suggested that the reflex receptor could be the saccule. More recent studies suggest that the cochlea too could be involved in the response. Likewise, while a number of studies tend to demonstrate that VEMPs depend on vestibular integrity, others suggest that afferent pathways could be of both cohlear and vestibular origin. Finally, while it has been suggested that VEMP efferent pathways travel through the vestibulospinal tract, whether it is the lateral or the medial vestibulospinal tract that is concerned remains to be clarified. A few points regarding VEMP receptors and afferent and efferent pathways call for further investigation. They are inaccurate for use in routine vestibular examination. Once precise receptor localization and pathways are clarified, VEMP recording will provide both a straightforward non-invasive exploration of each vestibule independently and an attractive method by which to explore otolithic receptors and vestibulospinal pathways.

Vestibular hypersensitivity to clicks is characteristic of the Tullio phenomenon

OBJECTIVES

The frequency of pathologically reduced click thresholds for vestibular activation was explored in patients with the Tullio phenomenon (sound induced vestibular activation).

METHODS

Seven patients (eight affected ears) with symptoms of oscillopsia and unsteadiness in response to loud external sounds or to the patient's own voice were examined. In all but one patient, vestibular hypersensitivity to sound was confirmed by the fact that eye movements could be produced by pure tones of 110 dB intensity or less. Conventional diagnostic imaging was normal in all cases and three of the patients had normal middle ears at surgical exploration. Thresholds for click evoked vestibulocollic reflexes were compared with those of a group of normal subjects. Galvanic stimulation was used as a complementary method of examining the excitability of vestibular reflexes.

RESULTS

All the patients showed a reduced threshold for click activation of vestibulocollic reflexes arising from the affected ear. Short latency EMG responses to clicks were also present in posterior neck and leg muscles, suggesting that these muscles receive vestibular projections. Galvanic stimulation produced a normal pattern of body sway in four of the five patients tested.

CONCLUSIONS

A pathologically reduced threshold to click activation (< or = 70 dB NHL (average normal hearing level)) seems to be a consistent feature of the Tullio phenomenon and a useful diagnostic criterion. This in turn is most likely to be due to an increased effectiveness of the transmission of sound energy to saccular receptors. Activation of these receptors probably contributed to the vestibular symptoms experienced by the patients.

Investigations of disorders of balance

Images

Responses of guinea pig primary vestibular neurons to clicks

Responses of single neurons in the vestibular nerve to high-intensity clicks were studied by extracellular recording in anaesthetised guinea pigs. One hundred and two neurons in the posterior division of the superior branch or in the inferior branch of the vestibular nerve were activated at short latency by intense clicks. The latency of activation was short (median 0.9 ms) and the threshold was high: the click intensity for evoking the response of these cells was around 60 dB above the auditory brainstem response threshold. Animals were tilted and rotated to identify physiologically the sensory region of the labyrinth from which the activated neurons originated. Seventeen neurons responded to static tilt as well as clicks. These results show that vestibular receptors, probably the otoliths, respond to clicks at intensities corresponding to those used in a new clinical test of the vestibulo-collic pathway.