RNA Repair: Hiding in Plain Sight

Potent inhibitors of the human RNA ligase Rlig1 highlights its role in RNA integrity maintenance under oxidative cellular stress

Human RNA ligase 1 (Rlig1) catalyzes the ligation of 5'-phosphate to 3'-hydroxyl ends via a conserved three-step mechanism. Rlig1-deficient HEK293 cells exhibit reduced cell viability and RNA integrity under oxidative stress, suggesting Rlig1's role in RNA repair maintenance. Reactive oxygen species (ROS) are linked to various diseases, including neurodegenerative disorders and cancer, where RNA damage has significant effects. This study identifies and characterizes Rlig1 inhibitors to elucidate its role in RNA metabolism. We developed a fluorescence resonance energy transfer (FRET)-based assay to monitor RNA ligation and screened a library of 13 026 bioactive small molecules. SGI-1027 emerged as a promising lead compound, and structure-activity relationship (SAR) studies revealed that the terminal residues play a key role in its inhibitory effect. In total 22 SGI-1027 derivatives were synthesized and tested, providing insights into the structural requirements for effective Rlig1 inhibition. Three derivatives showed low micromolar IC50 values and minimal cytotoxicity in HEK293 cells under physiological conditions. The combination of Rlig1 inhibition and oxidative stress led to reduced cell viability and compromised RNA integrity, reinforcing Rlig1's role in RNA maintenance. These findings provide a foundation for developing novel therapeutics aimed at targeting RNA maintenance pathways in conditions of dysregulated ROS levels.

Identification, characterization, and structure of a tRNA splicing enzyme RNA 5'-OH kinase from the pathogenic fungi Mucorales

Fungal Trl1 is an essential tRNA splicing enzyme composed of C-terminal cyclic phosphodiesterase and central polynucleotide kinase end-healing domains that convert the 2',3'-cyclic-PO4 and 5'-OH ends of tRNA exons into the 3'-OH,2'-PO4 and 5'-PO4 termini required for sealing by an N-terminal ATP-dependent ligase domain. Trifunctional Trl1 enzymes are present in most human fungal pathogens and are untapped targets for antifungal drug discovery. Mucorales species, deemed high-priority human pathogens by WHO, elaborate a noncanonical tRNA splicing apparatus in which a stand-alone monofunctional RNA ligase enzyme joins 3'-OH,2'-PO4 and 5'-PO4 termini. Here we identify a stand-alone Mucor circinelloides polynucleotide kinase (MciKIN) and affirm its biological activity in tRNA splicing by genetic complementation in yeast. Recombinant MciKIN catalyzes magnesium-dependent phosphorylation of 5'-OH RNA and DNA ends in vitro. MciKIN displays a strong preference for GTP as the phosphate donor in the kinase reaction, a trait shared with the stand-alone RNA kinase homologs from Mucorales species Rhizopus azygosporus (RazKIN) and Lichtheimia corymbifera (LcoKIN) and with the kinase domains of fungal Trl1 enzymes. We report a 1.65 Å crystal structure of RazKIN in complex with GDP•Mg2+ that illuminates the basis for guanosine nucleotide specificity.

Biochemical and structural insights into a 5' to 3' RNA ligase reveal a potential role in tRNA ligation

ATP-grasp superfamily enzymes contain a hand-like ATP-binding fold and catalyze a variety of reactions using a similar catalytic mechanism. More than 30 protein families are categorized in this superfamily, and they are involved in a plethora of cellular processes and human diseases. Here, we identify C12orf29 (RLIG1) as an atypical ATP-grasp enzyme that ligates RNA. Human RLIG1 and its homologs autoadenylate on an active site Lys residue as part of a reaction intermediate that specifically ligates RNA halves containing a 5'-phosphate and a 3'-hydroxyl. RLIG1 binds tRNA in cells and can ligate tRNA within the anticodon loop in vitro. Transcriptomic analyses of Rlig1 knockout mice revealed significant alterations in global tRNA levels in the brains of female mice, but not in those of male mice. Furthermore, crystal structures of a RLIG1 homolog from Yasminevirus bound to nucleotides revealed a minimal and atypical RNA ligase fold with a conserved active site architecture that participates in catalysis. Collectively, our results identify RLIG1 as an RNA ligase and suggest its involvement in tRNA biology.

Chemical synthesis of 2″OMeNAD+ and its deployment as an RNA 2'-phosphotransferase (Tpt1) 'poison' that traps the enzyme on its abortive RNA-2'-PO4-(ADP-2″OMe-ribose) reaction intermediate

RNA 2'-phosphotransferase Tpt1 catalyzes the removal of an internal RNA 2'-PO4 via a two-step mechanism in which: (i) the 2'-PO4 attacks NAD+ C1″ to form an RNA-2'-phospho-(ADP-ribose) intermediate and nicotinamide; and (ii) transesterification of the ADP-ribose O2″ to the RNA 2'-phosphodiester yields 2'-OH RNA and ADP-ribose-1″,2″-cyclic phosphate. Although Tpt1 enzymes are prevalent in bacteria, archaea, and eukarya, Tpt1 is uniquely essential in fungi and plants, where it erases the 2'-PO4 mark installed by tRNA ligases during tRNA splicing. To identify a Tpt1 'poison' that arrests the reaction after step 1, we developed a chemical synthesis of 2″OMeNAD+, an analog that cannot, in principle, support step 2 transesterification. We report that 2″OMeNAD+ is an effective step 1 substrate for Runella slithyformis Tpt1 (RslTpt1) in a reaction that generates the normally undetectable RNA-2'-phospho-(ADP-ribose) intermediate in amounts stoichiometric to Tpt1. EMSA assays demonstrate that RslTpt1 remains trapped in a stable complex with the abortive RNA-2'-phospho-(ADP-2″OMe-ribose) intermediate. Although 2″OMeNAD+ establishes the feasibility of poisoning and trapping a Tpt1 enzyme, its application is limited insofar as Tpt1 enzymes from fungal pathogens are unable to utilize this analog for step 1 catalysis. Analogs with smaller 2″-substitutions may prove advantageous in targeting the fungal enzymes.

Kinetic and structural insights into the requirement of fungal tRNA ligase for a 2'-phosphate end

Fungal RNA ligase (LIG) is an essential tRNA splicing enzyme that joins 3'-OH,2'-PO4 and 5'-PO4 RNA ends to form a 2'-PO4,3'-5' phosphodiester splice junction. Sealing entails three divalent cation-dependent adenylate transfer steps. First, LIG reacts with ATP to form a covalent ligase-(lysyl-Nζ)-AMP intermediate and displace pyrophosphate. Second, LIG transfers AMP to the 5'-PO4 RNA terminus to form an RNA-adenylate intermediate (A5'pp5'RNA). Third, LIG directs the attack of an RNA 3'-OH on AppRNA to form the splice junction and displace AMP. A defining feature of fungal LIG vis-à-vis canonical polynucleotide ligases is the requirement for a 2'-PO4 to synthesize a 3'-5' phosphodiester bond. Fungal LIG consists of an N-terminal adenylyltransferase domain and a unique C-terminal domain. The C-domain of Chaetomium thermophilum LIG (CthLIG) engages a sulfate anion thought to be a mimetic of the terminal 2'-PO4 Here, we interrogated the contributions of the C-domain and the conserved sulfate ligands (His227, Arg334, Arg337) to ligation of a pRNA2'p substrate. We find that the C-domain is essential for end-joining but dispensable for ligase adenylylation. Mutations H227A, R334A, and R337A slowed the rate of step 2 RNA adenylation by 420-fold, 120-fold, and 60-fold, respectively, vis-à-vis wild-type CthLIG. An R334A-R337A double-mutation slowed step 2 by 580-fold. These results fortify the case for the strictly conserved His-Arg-Arg triad as the enforcer of the 2'-PO4 end-specificity of fungal tRNA ligases and as a target for small molecule interdiction of fungal tRNA splicing.

Identification of small molecules that are synthetically lethal upon knockout of the RNA ligase Rlig1 in human cells

Rlig1 is the first RNA ligase identified in humans utilising a classical 5'-3' ligation mechanism. It is a conserved enzyme in all vertebrates and is mutated in various cancers. During our initial research on Rlig1, we observed that Rlig1-knockout (KO) HEK293 cells are more sensitive to the stress induced by menadione than their WT counterpart, representing a type of chemical synthetic lethality. To gain further insight into the biological pathways in which Rlig1 may be involved, we aimed at identifying new synthetically lethal small molecules. To this end, we conducted a high-throughput screening with a compound library comprising over 13 000 bioactive small molecules. This approach led to the identification of compounds that exhibited synthetic lethality in combination with Rlig1-KO. In addition to the aforementioned novel compounds that diverge structurally from menadione, we also tested multiple small molecules containing a naphthoquinone scaffold.

Biochemical and structural insights into a 5' to 3' RNA ligase reveal a potential role in tRNA ligation

ATP-grasp superfamily enzymes contain a hand-like ATP-binding fold and catalyze a variety of reactions using a similar catalytic mechanism. More than 30 protein families are categorized in this superfamily, and they are involved in a plethora of cellular processes and human diseases. Here we identify C12orf29 as an atypical ATP-grasp enzyme that ligates RNA. Human C12orf29 and its homologs auto-adenylate on an active site Lys residue as part of a reaction intermediate that specifically ligates RNA halves containing a 5'-phosphate and a 3'-hydroxyl. C12orf29 binds tRNA in cells and can ligate tRNA within the anticodon loop in vitro. Genetic depletion of c12orf29 in female mice alters global tRNA levels in brain. Furthermore, crystal structures of a C12orf29 homolog from Yasminevirus bound to nucleotides reveal a minimal and atypical RNA ligase fold with a unique active site architecture that participates in catalysis. Collectively, our results identify C12orf29 as an RNA ligase and suggest its involvement in tRNA biology.

Fungi of the order Mucorales express a "sealing-only" tRNA ligase

Some eukaryotic pre-tRNAs contain an intron that is removed by a dedicated set of enzymes. Intron-containing pre-tRNAs are cleaved by tRNA splicing endonuclease, followed by ligation of the two exons and release of the intron. Fungi use a "heal and seal" pathway that requires three distinct catalytic domains of the tRNA ligase enzyme, Trl1. In contrast, humans use a "direct ligation" pathway carried out by RTCB, an enzyme completely unrelated to Trl1. Because of these mechanistic differences, Trl1 has been proposed as a promising drug target for fungal infections. To validate Trl1 as a broad-spectrum drug target, we show that fungi from three different phyla contain Trl1 orthologs with all three domains. This includes the major invasive human fungal pathogens, and these proteins can each functionally replace yeast Trl1. In contrast, species from the order Mucorales, including the pathogens Rhizopus arrhizus and Mucor circinelloides, have an atypical Trl1 that contains the sealing domain but lacks both healing domains. Although these species contain fewer tRNA introns than other pathogenic fungi, they still require splicing to decode three of the 61 sense codons. These sealing-only Trl1 orthologs can functionally complement defects in the corresponding domain of yeast Trl1 and use a conserved catalytic lysine residue. We conclude that Mucorales use a sealing-only enzyme together with unidentified nonorthologous healing enzymes for their heal and seal pathway. This implies that drugs that target the sealing activity are more likely to be broader-spectrum antifungals than drugs that target the healing domains.

Characterization of tRNA splicing enzymes RNA ligase and tRNA 2'-phosphotransferase from the pathogenic fungi Mucorales

Fungal Trl1 is an essential trifunctional tRNA splicing enzyme that heals and seals tRNA exons with 2',3'-cyclic-PO4 and 5'-OH ends. Trl1 is composed of C-terminal cyclic phosphodiesterase and central polynucleotide kinase end-healing domains that generate the 3'-OH,2'-PO4 and 5'-PO4 termini required for sealing by an N-terminal ATP-dependent ligase domain. Trl1 enzymes are present in many human fungal pathogens and are promising targets for antifungal drug discovery because their domain structures and biochemical mechanisms are unique compared to the mammalian RtcB-type tRNA splicing enzyme. Here we report that Mucorales species (deemed high-priority human pathogens by WHO) elaborate a noncanonical tRNA splicing apparatus in which a monofunctional RNA ligase enzyme is encoded separately from any end-healing enzymes. We show that Mucor circinelloides RNA ligase (MciRNL) is active in tRNA splicing in vivo in budding yeast in lieu of the Trl1 ligase domain. Biochemical and kinetic characterization of recombinant MciRNL underscores its requirement for a 2'-PO4 terminus in the end-joining reaction, whereby the 2'-PO4 enhances the rates of RNA 5'-adenylylation (step 2) and phosphodiester synthesis (step 3) by ∼125-fold and ∼6200-fold, respectively. In the canonical fungal tRNA splicing pathway, the splice junction 2'-PO4 installed by RNA ligase is removed by a dedicated NAD+-dependent RNA 2'-phosphotransferase Tpt1. Here we identify and affirm by genetic complementation in yeast the biological activity of Tpt1 orthologs from three Mucorales species. Recombinant M. circinelloides Tpt1 has vigorous NAD+-dependent RNA 2'-phosphotransferase activity in vitro.

Fungi of the order Mucorales express a "sealing-only" tRNA ligase

Some eukaryotic pre-tRNAs contain an intron that is removed by a dedicated set of enzymes. Intron-containing pre-tRNAs are cleaved by tRNA splicing endonuclease (TSEN), followed by ligation of the two exons and release of the intron. Fungi use a "heal and seal" pathway that requires three distinct catalytic domains of the tRNA ligase enzyme, Trl1. In contrast, humans use a "direct ligation" pathway carried out by RTCB, an enzyme completely unrelated to Trl1. Because of these mechanistic differences, Trl1 has been proposed as a promising drug target for fungal infections. To validate Trl1 as a broad-spectrum drug target, we show that fungi from three different phyla contain Trl1 orthologs with all three domains. This includes the major invasive human fungal pathogens, and these proteins each can functionally replace yeast Trl1. In contrast, species from the order Mucorales, including the pathogens Rhizopus arrhizus and Mucor circinelloides, contain an atypical Trl1 that contains the sealing domain, but lack both healing domains. Although these species contain fewer tRNA introns than other pathogenic fungi, they still require splicing to decode three of the 61 sense codons. These sealing-only Trl1 orthologs can functionally complement defects in the corresponding domain of yeast Trl1 and use a conserved catalytic lysine residue. We conclude that Mucorales use a sealing-only enzyme together with unidentified non-orthologous healing enzymes for their heal and seal pathway. This implies that drugs that target the sealing activity are more likely to be broader-spectrum antifungals than drugs that target the healing domains.