Radiation Dose Reduction in Different Digital Radiography Systems: Impact on Assessment of Defined Bony Structures in Bearded Dragons (Pogona vitticeps)

Three different digital detector systems were used to study the effect of a defined radiation dose reduction on the image quality of digital radiographs in bearded dragons (Pogona vitticeps). A series of radiographs of seven bearded-dragon cadavers with a body mass ranging from 132 g to 499 g were taken in dorsoventral projection. The digital systems employed included two computed radiography systems (CR) (one system with a needle-based and one with a powdered-based scintillator) and one direct radiography system (DR). Three levels of the detector dose were selected: A standard dose (defined based on the recommended exposure value of the CR_P, D/100%), a half dose (D/50%), and a quarter dose (D/25%). Four image criteria and one overall assessment were defined for each of four anatomic skeletal regions (femur, rib, vertebra, and phalanx) and evaluated blinded by four veterinarians using a predefined scoring system. The results were assessed for differences between reviewers (interobserver variability), radiography systems, and dosage settings (intersystem variability). The comparison of the ratings was based on visual grading characteristic (VGC) analysis. Dose reduction led to significantly lower scores in all criteria by every reviewer, indicating a linear impairment of image quality in different skeletal structures in bearded dragons. Scores did not differ significantly between the different systems used, indicating no advantage in using a computed or direct radiography system to evaluate skeletal structures in bearded dragons. The correlation was significant (p ≤ 0.05) for interobserver variability in 100% of the cases, with correlation coefficients between 0.50 and 0.59. While demonstrating the efficacy of the use of digital radiography in bearded dragons and the similar quality in using different computed or direct radiography systems, this study also highlights the importance of the appropriate level of detector dose and demonstrates the limits of post-processing algorithm to compensate for insufficient radiation doses in bearded dragons.

Advances in multiscale image processing and its effects on image quality in skeletal radiography

Multi-frequency processing (MFP) leads to enhanced image quality (IQ) of radiographs. This study is to determine the effect of third generation MFP (M3) on IQ in comparison to standard second-generation MFP (M2). 20 cadavers were examined and post-processing of radiographs was performed with both M2 and M3. Three readers blinded to the MFP used for each image independently compared corresponding image pairs according to overall IQ and depiction of bony structures and soft tissue (+ 2: notably better > 0: equal > - 2: notably worse). A significant deviation of the median grade from grade 0 (equal) (p < 0.01) for each evaluator A, B and C speaks against an equal image quality of M2- and M3-images. M3-images were categorized with better grades (+ 1, + 2) in 87.7% for overall image quality, in 90.4% for soft tissue and 81.8% for bony structures. M3 images showed significant higher averaged SNR and CNR for all investigated lower extremities than that of M2 images (0.031 < p < 0.049). The newest generation of MFP leads to significantly better depiction of anatomical structures and overall image quality than in images processed with the preceding generation of MFP. This provides increased diagnostic accuracy and further decreased radiation exposure.

Image quality is resilient against tube voltage variations in post-mortem skeletal radiography with a digital flat-panel detector

In recent phantom studies low-contrast detectability was shown to be independent from variations in tube voltage in digital radiography (DR) systems. To investigate the transferability to a clinical setting, the lower extremities of human cadavers were exposed at constant detector doses with different tube voltages in a certain range, as proposed in the phantom studies. Three radiologists independently graded different aspects of image quality (IQ) in a comparative analysis. The grades show no correlation between IQ and kV, which means that the readers were not able to recognize a significant IQ difference at different kV. Signal-to-noise and contrast-to-noise ratios showed no significant differences in IQ despite the kV-setting variations. These findings were observed from a limited kV range setting. Higher kV-settings resulted in lowest patient exposure at constant IQ. These results confirm the potential of DR-systems to contribute to standardization of examination protocols comparable to computed tomography. This may prevent the trend to overexpose. Further investigations in other body regions and other DR-systems are encouraged to determine transferability.

Dose reduction in mammography by using imaging plate technology: A retrospective analysis

PURPOSE

Conventional mammography is a decisive tool in detecting breast cancer. Continuous efforts are undertaken in order to further improve the image quality as well as to reduce the applied doses. The purpose of our study was to compare diagnostic image quality of dose reduced computed mammography with a new needle-based detector system to full dose powder imaging plates.

METHODS

We retrospectively compared 360 randomly chosen mammographies performed on a GE Senographe DMR running the Agfa DX-M needle-based imaging plate system (NIP) with their preliminary examinations which were acquired at standard dose with the same GE mammography device and an Agfa CR85-X powdered storage phosphor imaging plate system (PIP). NIP-based mammographies were about 29.8 % dose-reduced. The preliminary examinations had to be performed not earlier than 2 years before the recent investigations. Exclusion criteria were changes in ACR level and appearance of the scored targets and not optimally positioned and exposed mammographies. The images were blinded and read separately twice by 2 mammography experts according to a 3-point score on diagnostic image quality and the visualization of parenchyma, cysts, fibroadenomas, physiologic lymph nodes, solitary microcalcifications and macrocalcifications.

RESULTS

Dose reduced NIPs showed a significantly better visualization of parenchyma at ACR II/III and solitary microcalcifications at ACR I-III mammographies (p < 0.001) whereas the difference in scoring macrocalcifications, cysts, fibroadenomas and physiologic lymph nodes was not significant. The reading showed an excellent intra- (r = 0.97/0.94) and interobserver agreement (r = 0.92).

CONCLUSION

With computed mammography using the needle-based detector system a significant dose reduction is possible without loss of diagnostic image quality.

Needle-based storage-phosphor detector radiography is superior to a conventional powder-based storage phosphor detector and a high-resolution screen-film system in small patients (budgerigars and mice)

This method comparison study used radiographs of 20 mice and 20 budgerigars to investigate comparability between computed radiography (CR) and high-resolution screen-film systems and study the effects of reduced radiation doses on image quality of digital radiographs of small patients. Exposure settings used with the mammography screen-film system (SF) were taken as baseline settings. A powder-based storage-phosphor system (CR_P) and a needle-based storage-phosphor system (CR_N) were used with the same settings (D/100%) and half the detector dose (D/50%). Using a scoring system four reviewers assessed five criteria per species covering soft tissue and bone structures. Results were evaluated for differences between reviewers (interobserver variability), systems and settings (intersystem variability, using visual grading characteristic analysis). Correlations were significant (p ≤ 0.05) for interobserver variability in 86.7% of the cases. Correlation coefficients ranged from 0.206 to 0.772. For mice and budgerigars, the CR_N system was rated as superior to the SF and CR_P system for most criteria, being significant in two cases each. Comparing the SF and CR_P system, the conventional method scored higher for all criteria, in one case significantly. For both species and both digital systems, dose reduction to 50% resulted in significantly worse scores for most criteria. In summary, the needle-based storage-phosphor technique proved to be superior compared to the conventional storage-phosphor and mammography screen-film system. Needle-based detector systems are suitable substitutes for high-resolution screen–film systems when performing diagnostic imaging of small patients. Dose reduction to 50% of the corresponding dose needed in high-resolution film-screen systems cannot be recommended.

A paediatric X-ray exposure chart

The aim of this review was to develop a radiographic optimisation strategy to make use of digital radiography (DR) and needle phosphor computerised radiography (CR) detectors, in order to lower radiation dose and improve image quality for paediatrics. This review was based on evidence-based practice, of which a component was a review of the relevant literature. The resulting exposure chart was developed with two distinct groups of exposure optimisation strategies – body exposures (for head, trunk, humerus, femur) and distal extremity exposures (elbow to finger, knee to toe). Exposure variables manipulated included kilovoltage peak (kVp), target detector exposure and milli-ampere-seconds (mAs), automatic exposure control (AEC), additional beam filtration, and use of antiscatter grid. Mean dose area product (DAP) reductions of up to 83% for anterior–posterior (AP)/posterior–anterior (PA) abdomen projections were recorded postoptimisation due to manipulation of multiple-exposure variables. For body exposures, the target EI and detector exposure, and thus the required mAs were typically 20% less postoptimisation. Image quality for some distal extremity exposures was improved by lowering kVp and increasing mAs around constant entrance skin dose. It is recommended that purchasing digital X-ray equipment with high detective quantum efficiency detectors, and then optimising the exposure chart for use with these detectors is of high importance for sites performing paediatric imaging. Multiple-exposure variables may need to be manipulated to achieve optimal outcomes.

Feasibility of dose reduction using needle-structured image plates versus powder-structured plates for computed radiography of the knee

OBJECTIVE

A newly developed computed radiography (CR) detector that uses a storage phosphor plate made of needle-shaped crystals provides improved dose efficiency. The aim of our study was to compare the image quality of standard-dose CR and dose-reduced CR achieved using needle technology for knee imaging in a clinical setting.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

We compared standard CR images obtained using a powder-structured image plate (PIP) (ADC Compact Plus) with images obtained using the new needle-structured image plate (NIP) (DX-S). In 30 consecutive patients with knee pain willing to participate in this study, anteroposterior knee radiographs were acquired with both systems at a standard dose. In addition, NIP images were obtained with approximately 75% and 50% of the standard dose (corresponding incident doses: 300, 235, and 154 μGy, respectively). Images were evaluated in a blinded, side-by-side comparison. Six radiologists determined whether there was an appreciable difference in image quality at five anatomic landmarks in regions with high and low differences of attenuation. They also assessed the delineation of selected abnormalities and ranked them using a 10-point scale. The rating scores were tested for statistical differences using an analysis of variance with repeated measures.

RESULTS

The mean overall rating scores for the evaluation of anatomic landmarks were 6.97 for NIP images obtained at full dose, 6.48 for NIP images obtained at about 75% dose, 5.47 for NIP images obtained at half dose, and 6.01 for PIP images. There was a significant difference in favor of the CR system with an NIP at the same dose level (p < 0.05). The NIP images obtained at a dose of about 75% were also ranked significantly better than the PIP images with regard to the depiction of both anatomic landmarks and abnormalities. The readers ranked half-dose NIP images inferior to the PIP images with regard to abnormalities and anatomic landmarks in areas with high attenuation, whereas in areas with low attenuation, the image quality was regarded as equivalent to the standard technique.

CONCLUSION

NIP technology allows a dose reduction of approximately 25% compared with PIP while still providing higher image quality. Even at the half-dose level, there was no relevant loss of image quality with regard to the delineation of anatomic landmarks in areas with low attenuation in anteroposterior knee images. The higher dose efficiency of the needle-detector CR technology compared with conventional CR can be used either for dose reduction or for improved image quality.

Needle image plates compared to conventional CR in chest radiography: is dose reduction possible?

PURPOSE

To compare image quality of standard-dose computed radiography and dose reduced needle-technology CR for supine CXR in a clinical setting.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

We prospectively evaluated 128 radiographs of 32 immunocompromised patients. For each patient four clinical CXR were performed within one week, two with powder image plates (PIP; Fuji ST-V) and two with needle image plates (NIP; Agfa DXS) at standard and half dose, respectively. One experienced radiologist and two residents blinded to dose level and kind of imaging system rated different anatomical structures, image noise, tubes/lines and abnormalities on a image quality scale from 1 to 10 (1=poor, 10=excellent). The rating scores were tested for statistical differences using analysis of variance with repeated measures.

RESULTS

A statistical difference (p<0.05) was found for the two systems as well as for the two dose levels. Overall rating scores were 6.5 for PIP with full dose, 6.2 for PIP with half dose, 7.6 for NIP with full dose and 7.4 for NIP with half dose. There was a significant difference in favour of the NIP system at the same dose level. Also the NIP images obtained at half dose were ranked significantly better compared to the PIP images at standard dose. The differences in ranking of anatomical structures and abnormalities were more pronounced in low absorption areas (pulmonary vessels, parenchyma) than in high absorption areas (mediastinum, spine).

CONCLUSION

For supine chest radiograms the NIP technology allows for a dose reduction of 50% while providing higher image quality.

Storage Phosphors for Medical Imaging

Computed radiography (CR) uses storage phosphor imaging plates for digital imaging. Absorbed X-ray energy is stored in crystal defects. In read-out the energy is set free as blue photons upon optical stimulation. In the 35 years of CR history, several storage phosphor families were investigated and developed. An explanation is given as to why some materials made it to the commercial stage, while others did not. The photo stimulated luminescence mechanism of the current commercial storage phosphors, BaFBr:Eu2+ and CsBr:Eu2+ is discussed. The relation between storage phosphor plate physical characteristics and image quality is explained. It is demonstrated that the morphology of the phosphor crystals in the CR imaging plate has a very significant impact on its performance.

Super-resolution variable-dose imaging in digital radiography: quality and dose reduction with a fluoroscopic flat-panel detector

PURPOSE

Super-resolution (SR) image processing produces a high-resolution image from a series of low-resolution images. The aim of this study was to evaluate SR-images based on fluoroscopic flat-detector (FD) acquisition at different frame rates.

METHODS

Fluoroscopic FD-sequences with 20 frames were obtained with varying pulse frequencies of (1) a line pair resolution phantom; (2) a low-contrast resolution phantom, and (3) a human knee specimen. Super-resolution digital radiographs (SR-Radiographs) were generated from each sequence. Variable-dose images were simulated by constructing SR-Radiographs using 6 and 12 frames from the corresponding fluoroscopic sequence. "Single Shot" and Computed Radiography (CR) images were obtained for comparison based on dynamic range and sharpness of bone detail structures. Patient-derived SR-Radiographic images were constructed to demonstrate clinical examples.

RESULTS

The spatial resolution of SR-radiographs obtained at 12.5 frames per second (fps) and 6 fps were comparable with CR and "Single Shot" images, providing ~3.5 line pairs per mm (l p/mm). Similarly, low-contrast resolution of SR-radiographs obtained at 12.5, 6, and 30 fps were equivalent to CR and "Single Shot" images. The human knee specimen SR-radiograph obtained using 12 FD images at 12.5 fps was superior to a CR image in overall image quality, with a dose reduction of 75%. Variable-dose SR-radiographic simulations suggest a dose saving potential of 90-95% when using 6 FD images at 12.5 fps or 6 fps, respectively.

CONCLUSIONS

The phantom testing images and simulation results demonstrate that diagnostic quality SR-radiographic images of skeletal extremities can be synthesized using a flat-panel detector system designed primarily for angiography. SR-images obtained with substantially reduced radiation dose are feasible, and this technology may improve digital radiography for pediatric, neonatal radiography, or mammography applications. Further testing is needed to validate super-resolution techniques in other body regions and for different flat-detector systems.