Mechanical advantage of the canine diaphragm

Differential activation of the human costal and crural diaphragm during voluntary and involuntary breaths

Simultaneous electromyographic recordings from the human costal and crural diaphragm during voluntary augmented breathing and involuntary rebreathing show that the increase in inspiratory crural diaphragm activity was ~60% of the increase in costal diaphragm activity. However costal to crural diaphragm activation did not differ between the two tasks. The dissociation in the amplitude of activation of the costal and crural diaphragm becomes apparent only as the drive to breathe increases above tidal breathing.

Regional diaphragm volume displacement is heterogeneous in dogs

Muscle shortening and volume displacement (VD) are critical determinants of the pressure-generating capacity of the diaphragm. The present study was designed to test the hypothesis that diaphragm VD is heterogeneous and that distribution of VD is dependent on regional muscle shortening, posture, and the level of muscle activation. Radioopaque markers were sutured along muscle bundles of the peritoneal surface of the crural, dorsal costal, midcostal, and ventral costal regions of the left hemidiaphragm in four dogs. The markers were followed by biplanar video fluoroscopy during quiet spontaneous breathing, passive inflation to total lung capacity (TLC), and inspiratory efforts against an occluded airway at three lung volumes spanning the vital capacity [functional residual capacity, functional residual capacity + ½ inspiratory capacity, and TLC in both the prone and supine postures]. Our data show the ventral costal diaphragm had the largest VD and contributed nearly two times to the total diaphragm VD compared with the dorsal costal portion. In addition, the ventral costal diaphragm contributed nearly half of the total VD in the prone position, whereas it only contributed a quarter of the total VD in the supine postition. During efforts against an occluded airway and during passive inflation to TLC in the supine position, the crural diaphragm displaced volume equivalent to that of the midcostal portion. Regional muscle shortening closely matched regional VD. We conclude that the primary force generator of the diaphragm is primarily dominated by the contribution of the ventral costal region to its VD.

Chronic intrinsic transient tracheal occlusion elicits diaphragmatic muscle fiber remodeling in conscious rodents

BACKGROUND

Although the prevalence of inspiratory muscle strength training has increased in clinical medicine, its effect on diaphragm fiber remodeling is not well-understood and no relevant animal respiratory muscle strength training-rehabilitation experimental models exist. We tested the postulate that intrinsic transient tracheal occlusion (ITTO) conditioning in conscious animals would provide a novel experimental model of respiratory muscle strength training, and used significant increases in diaphragmatic fiber cross-sectional area (CSA) as the primary outcome measure. We hypothesized that ITTO would increase costal diaphragm fiber CSA and further hypothesized a greater duration and magnitude of occlusions would amplify remodeling.

METHODOLOGY/PRINCIPAL FINDINGS

Sprague-Dawley rats underwent surgical placement of a tracheal cuff and were randomly assigned to receive daily either 10-minute sessions of ITTO, extended-duration, 20-minute ITTO (ITTO-20), partial obstruction with 50% of cuff inflation pressure (ITTO-PAR) or observation (SHAM) over two weeks. After the interventions, fiber morphology, myosin heavy chain composition and CSA were examined in the crural and ventral, medial, and dorsal costal regions. In the medial costal diaphragm, with ITTO, type IIx/b fibers were 26% larger in the medial costal diaphragm (p<0.01) and 24% larger in the crural diaphragm (p<0.05). No significant changes in fiber composition or morphology were detected. ITTO-20 sessions also yielded significant increases in medial costal fiber cross-sectional area, but the effects were not greater than those elicited by 10-minute sessions. On the other hand, ITTO-PAR resulted in partial airway obstruction and did not generate fiber hypertrophy.

CONCLUSIONS/SIGNIFICANCE

The results suggest that the magnitude of the load was more influential in altering fiber cross-sectional area than extended-duration conditioning sessions. The results also indicated that ITTO was associated with type II fiber hypertrophy in the medial costal region of the diaphragm and may be an advantageous experimental model of clinical respiratory muscle strength training.

Mechanisms of the inspiratory action of the diaphragm during isolated contraction

The lung-expanding action of the diaphragm is primarily related to the descent of the dome produced by the shortening of the muscle fibers. However, when the phrenic nerves in dogs are selectively stimulated at functional residual capacity, the muscle insertions into the lower ribs also move caudally. This rib motion should enhance the descent of the dome and increase the fall in pleural pressure (DeltaPpl). To quantify the role of this mechanism in determining DeltaPpl during isolated diaphragm contraction and to evaluate the volume dependence of this role, radiopaque markers were attached to muscle bundles in the midcostal region of the muscle in six animals, and the three-dimensional location of the markers during relaxation at different lung volumes and during phrenic nerve stimulation at the same lung volumes was measured using computed tomography. From these data, accurate measurements of muscle length, dome displacement, and lower rib displacement were obtained. The values of dome displacement were then corrected for lower rib displacement, and the values of DeltaPpl corresponding to the corrected dome displacements were obtained using the measured relationship between DeltaPpl and dome displacement. The measurements showed that phrenic stimulation at all lung volumes causes a caudal displacement of the lower ribs and that this displacement, taken alone, contributes approximately 25% of the DeltaPpl produced by the diaphragm. To the extent that this lower rib displacement is itself caused by DeltaPpl, the lung-expanding action of the diaphragm during isolated contraction may therefore be viewed as a self-facilitating phenomenon.

The output from human inspiratory motoneurone pools

Survival requires adequate pulmonary ventilation which, in turn, depends on adequate contraction of muscles acting on the chest wall in the presence of a patent upper airway. Bulbospinal outputs projecting directly and indirectly to 'obligatory' respiratory motoneurone pools generate the required muscle contractions. Recent studies of the phasic inspiratory output of populations of single motor units to five muscles acting on the chest wall (including the diaphragm) reveal that the time of onset, the progressive recruitment, and the amount of motoneuronal drive (expressed as firing frequency) differ among the muscles. Tonic firing with an inspiratory modulation of firing rate is common in low intercostal spaces of the parasternal and external intercostal muscles but rare in the diaphragm. A new time and frequency plot has been developed to depict the behaviour of the motoneurone populations. The magnitude of inspiratory firing of motor unit populations is linearly correlated to the mechanical advantage of the intercostal muscle region at which the motor unit activity is recorded. This represents a 'neuromechanical' principle by which the CNS controls motoneuronal output according to mechanical advantage, presumably in addition to the Henneman's size principle of motoneurone recruitment. Studies of the genioglossus, an obligatory upper airway muscle that helps maintain airway patency, reveal that it receives simultaneous inspiratory, expiratory and tonic drives even during quiet breathing. There is much to be learned about the neural drive to pools of human inspiratory and expiratory muscles, not only during respiratory tasks but also in automatic and volitional tasks, and in diseases that alter the required drive.

Differential activation among five human inspiratory motoneuron pools during tidal breathing

Neural drive to inspiratory pump muscles is increased under many pathological conditions. This study determined for the first time how neural drive is distributed to five different human inspiratory pump muscles during tidal breathing. The discharge of single motor units (n = 280) from five healthy subjects in the diaphragm, scalene, second parasternal intercostal, third dorsal external intercostal, and fifth dorsal external intercostal was recorded with needle electrodes. All units increased their discharge during inspiration, but 41 (15%) discharged tonically throughout expiration. Motor unit populations from each muscle differed in the timing of their activation and in the discharge rates of their motor units. Relative to the onset of inspiratory flow, the earliest recruited muscles were the diaphragm and third dorsal external intercostal (mean onset for the population after 26 and 29% of inspiratory time). The fifth dorsal external intercostal muscle was recruited later (43% of inspiratory time; P < 0.05). Compared with the other inspiratory muscles, units in the diaphragm and third dorsal external intercostal had the highest onset (7.7 and 7.1 Hz, respectively) and peak firing frequencies (12.6 and 11.9 Hz, respectively; both P < 0.05). There was a unimodal distribution of recruitment times of motor units in all muscles. Neural drive to human inspiratory pump muscles differs in timing, strength, and distribution, presumably to achieve efficient ventilation.

Efficiency of the normal human diaphragm with hyperinflation

We evaluated an index of diaphragm efficiency (Eff(di)), diaphragm power output (Wdi) relative to electrical activation, in five healthy adults during tidal breathing at usual end-expiratory lung volume (EELV) and diaphragm length (L(di ee)) and at shorter L(di ee) during hyperinflation with expiratory positive airway pressure (EPAP). Measurements were repeated with an inspiratory threshold (7.5 cmH(2)O) plus resistive (6.5 cmH(2)O.l(-1).s) load. Wdi was the product of mean inspiratory transdiaphragmatic pressure (DeltaPdi(mean)), diaphragm volume displacement measured fluoroscopically, and 1/inspiratory duration (Ti(-1)). Diaphragm activation, measured with esophageal electrodes, was quantified by computing root-mean-square values (RMS(di)). With EPAP, 1) EELV increased [mean r(2) = 0.91 (SD 0.01)]; 2) in four subjects, L(di ee) decreased [mean r(2) = 0.85 (SD 0.07)] and mean Eff(di) decreased 34% per 10% decrease in L(di ee) (P < 0.001); and 3) in one subject, gastric pressure at EELV increased two- to threefold, L(di ee) was unchanged or increased, and Eff(di) increased at two of four levels of EPAP (P < or = 0.006, ANOVA). Inspiratory loading increased Wdi (P = 0.003) and RMS(di) (P = 0.004) with no change in Eff(di) (P = 0.63) or its relationship with L(di ee). Eff(di) was more accurate in defining changes in L(di ee) [(true positives + true negatives)/total = 0.78 (SD 0.13)] than DeltaPdi(mean).RMS(di)(-1), RMS(di), or DeltaPdi(mean).Ti (all <0.7, P < or = 0.05, without load). Thus Eff(di) was principally a function of L(di ee) independent of inspiratory loading, behavior consistent with muscle force-length-velocity properties. We conclude that Eff(di), measured during tidal breathing and in the absence of expiratory muscle activity at EELV, is a valid and accurate measure of diaphragm contractile function.

Respiratory action of the intercostal muscles

The mechanical advantages of the external and internal intercostals depend partly on the orientation of the muscle but mostly on interspace number and the position of the muscle within each interspace. Thus the external intercostals in the dorsal portion of the rostral interspaces have a large inspiratory mechanical advantage, but this advantage decreases ventrally and caudally such that in the ventral portion of the caudal interspaces, it is reversed into an expiratory mechanical advantage. The internal interosseous intercostals in the caudal interspaces also have a large expiratory mechanical advantage, but this advantage decreases cranially and, for the upper interspaces, ventrally as well. The intercartilaginous portion of the internal intercostals (the so-called parasternal intercostals), therefore, has an inspiratory mechanical advantage, whereas the triangularis sterni has a large expiratory mechanical advantage. These rostrocaudal gradients result from the nonuniform coupling between rib displacement and lung expansion, and the dorsoventral gradients result from the three-dimensional configuration of the rib cage. Such topographic differences in mechanical advantage imply that the functions of the muscles during breathing are largely determined by the topographic distributions of neural drive. The distributions of inspiratory and expiratory activity among the muscles are strikingly similar to the distributions of inspiratory and expiratory mechanical advantages, respectively. As a result, the external intercostals and the parasternal intercostals have an inspiratory function during breathing, whereas the internal interosseous intercostals and the triangularis sterni have an expiratory function.

Interaction between the canine diaphragm and intercostal muscles in lung expansion

Changes in intrathoracic pressure produced by the various inspiratory intercostals are essentially additive, but the interaction between these muscles and the diaphragm remains uncertain. In the present study, this interaction was assessed by measuring the changes in airway opening (ΔPao) or transpulmonary pressure (ΔPtp) in vagotomized, phrenicotomized dogs during spontaneous inspiration (isolated intercostal contraction), during isolated rectangular or ramp stimulation of the peripheral ends of the transected C5 phrenic nerve roots (isolated diaphragm contraction), and during spontaneous inspiration with superimposed phrenic nerve stimulation (combined diaphragm-intercostal contraction). With the endotracheal tube occluded at functional residual capacity, ΔPao during combined diaphragm-intercostal contraction was nearly equal to the sum of the ΔPao produced by the two muscle groups contracting individually. However, when the endotracheal tube was kept open, ΔPtp during combined contraction was 123% of the sum of the individual ΔPtp ( P < 0.001). The increase in lung volume during combined contraction was also 109% of the sum of the individual volume increases ( P < 0.02). Abdominal pressure during combined contraction was invariably lower than during isolated diaphragm contraction. It is concluded, therefore, that the canine diaphragm and intercostal muscles act synergistically during lung expansion and that this synergism is primarily due to the fact that the intercostal muscles reduce shortening of the diaphragm. When the lung is maintained at functional residual capacity, however, the synergism is obscured because the greater stiffness of the rib cage during diaphragm contraction enhances the ΔPao produced by the isolated diaphragm and reduces the ΔPao produced by the intercostal muscles.

Diaphragm electromyogram root mean square response to hypercapnia and its intersubject and day-to-day variation

Diaphragm activation can be quantified by measuring the root mean square of crural EMG (RMSdi) (Beck J, Sinderby C, Lindstrom L, and Grassino A, J Appl Physiol 85: 1123-1134, 1998). To examine intersubject and day-to-day variation in the RMSdi-Pco(2) relationship, end-tidal Pco(2), minute ventilation (Ve), respiratory frequency (f(B)), and RMSdi were measured in seven healthy subjects on two occasions during steady-state ventilation at seven levels of inspired O(2) fraction (Fi(CO(2))) from 0 to 0.08 in random order. RMSdi was measured with a multielectrode esophageal catheter and controlled for signal contamination and diaphragm position. RMSdi was normalized for values obtained during quiet breathing at functional residual capacity, at Fi(CO(2)) of 0.04, and during an inspiratory capacity maneuver (RMSdi%max) as well as ECG R-wave amplitude at functional residual capacity (RMSdi/ECG(R)), f(B), and thickness of the costal diaphragm measured by ultrasound. RMSdi increased linearly with Pco(2) (mean r(2) = 0.83 +/- 0.10); at the highest Fi(CO(2)), RMSdi%max was 40.2 +/- 11.6%. Relative to the intersubject variation in the Ve-Pco(2) relationship, intersubject variations in the slopes and intercepts of the RMSdi-Pco(2) relationships were 1.7 and 1.8 times, respectively, and RMSdi%max-Pco(2) relationships 0.9 and 1.3 times, respectively, and were unrelated to f(B) and diaphragm thickness. Relative to the day-to-day variation in the Ve-Pco(2) relationship, day-to-day variation in the slopes and intercepts of the RMSdi-Pco(2) relationships were 2.8 and 4.4 times, respectively, and RMSdi/ECG(R)-Pco(2) relationships 1.3 and 2.2 times, respectively. It was concluded that the RMSdi-Pco(2) relationship measures chemosensitivity and is best compared between subjects via RMSdi%max and on separate occasions in the same subject via RMSdi/ECG(R).

Sex differences in thoracic dimensions and configuration

The volume of adult female lungs is typically 10-12% smaller than that of males who have the same height and age. In this study, we investigated how this volume difference is distributed between the rib cage and the diaphragm abdomen compartments. Internal rib cage dimensions, diaphragm position relative to spine, and diaphragm length were compared in 21 normal male and 19 normal female subjects at three different lung volumes using anterior-posterior and lateral chest radiographs. At all lung volumes examined, females had smaller radial rib cage dimensions in relationship to height than males, a greater inclination of ribs, a comparable diaphragm dome position relative to the spine, and a shorter diaphragm length. Female subjects exhibited a greater inspiratory rib cage muscle contribution during resting breathing than males, presumably reflecting an improved mechanical advantage conferred to these muscles by the greater inclination of ribs. Because of a greater inclination of ribs, female rib cages could accommodate a greater volume expansion. The results suggest a disproportionate growth of the rib cage in females relative to the lung, which would be well suited to accommodate large abdominal volume displacements as in pregnancy.

Efficient design of the diaphragm: distribution of blood flow relative to mechanical advantage

The mammalian diaphragm is composed of two separate muscles (costal and crural) connected by a central tendon that serves as a piston head for drawing air into the lungs. The two muscles are described as having different embryological origins, segmental innervations, and mechanical functions [De Troyer A, Sampson M, Sigrist S, and Macklem PT. Science 213: 237-238, 1981; De Troyer A, Sampson M, Sigrist S, and Macklem PT. J Appl Physiol 53: 30-39, 1982]. On the basis of regional blood flow measurements, the two muscles appear to be nonuniformly recruited at rest, but we anticipated that the two muscles would become uniformly recruited at heavy exercise to efficiently support the high energy requirements of ventilation. We used fluorescent microspheres to measure regional blood flow within the two muscles as an index of muscle recruitment from rest to heavy treadmill exercise in well-trained foxhounds. However, the heterogeneity of blood flow at rest persisted as exercise workloads were increased. Blood flow per gram of muscle remained twofold greater in ventral than dorsal regions of both muscles from rest to heavy exercise. This pattern was matched by a twofold greater regional mechanical advantage in ventral than dorsal regions of the two muscles measured anatomically. Hence blood flow was preferentially and efficiently distributed to those regions capable of generating the greatest inspiratory power independent of muscle mass. The two muscles were recruited from rest to heavy exercise as a single functional unit, not as two muscles under separate control.

Biaxial constitutive relations for the passive canine diaphragm

Samples of the muscular sheet excised from the midcostal region of dog diaphragms were subjected to biaxial loading. That is, stresses in the direction of the muscle fibers and in the direction perpendicular to the fibers in the plane of the sheet were measured at different combinations of strains in the two directions. Stress-strain relations were obtained by fitting equations to these data. In the direction of the muscle fibers, for strains up to 0.7, stress is a modestly nonlinear function of strain and ranges up to approximately 60 g/cm. In the direction perpendicular to the fibers, the sheet is stiffer and more strongly nonlinear. At a strain in the perpendicular direction of approximately 0.35, stress increases abruptly. The stress-strain relation in the muscle direction is consistent with observations of passive muscle shortening in vivo. However, the stiffness in the perpendicular direction is not high enough to explain the observation that strains in the perpendicular direction in vivo are nearly zero. We conclude that, in the passive diaphragm in vivo, stress in the direction perpendicular to the muscle fibers is small.

Adaptation of respiratory muscle perfusion during exercise to chronically elevated ventilatory work

Pneumonectomy (PNX) leads to chronic asymmetric ventilatory loading of respiratory muscles (RM). We measured RM energy requirements during exercise from RM blood flow (Q) using a fluorescent microsphere technique in dogs that had undergone right PNX as adults (adult R-PNX) or as puppies (puppy R-PNX), compared with dogs subjected to right thoracotomy without PNX as puppies (Sham) and to left PNX as adults (adult L-PNX). Ventilatory work (W) was measured during exercise. RM weight was determined post mortem. After adult and puppy R-PNX, the right hemidiaphragm becomes grossly distorted, but W and right costal muscle mass increased only after adult R-PNX. After adult L-PNX, the diaphragm was undistorted; W and left hemidiaphragm RM Q were elevated, but muscle mass did not increase. Mass of parasternal muscle did not increase after adult R-PNX, despite increased Q. Thus muscle mass increased only in response to the combination of chronic stretch and dynamic loading. There was a dorsal-to-ventral gradient of increasing Q within the diaphragm, but the distribution was unaffected by anatomic distortion, hypertrophy, or workload, suggesting a fixed pattern of neural activation. The diaphragm and parasternals were the primary muscles compensating for the asymmetric loading from PNX.

Shape of the canine diaphragm

In an earlier study (Angelillo M, Boriek AM, Rodarte JR, and Wilson TA. J Appl Physiol 83: 1486-1491, 1997), we proposed a mathematical theory for the structure and shape of the diaphragm. Muscle bundles were assumed to lie on lines that are simultaneously geodesics and lines of principal curvature of the diaphragm surface, and the class of surfaces that are formed by line elements that are both geodesics and lines of principal curvature was described. Here we present data on the shape of the canine diaphragm that were obtained by the radiopaque marker technique, and we describe a surface that fits the data and satisfies the requirements of the theory. The costal and crural diaphragms are fit by cyclides with radii of 3.7 and 2.3 cm, respectively. In addition, the theory is extended to include the description of a joint between cyclides, and the observed properties of the joint between the costal and crural diaphragms at the dorsal end of the costal diaphragm match those required by the theory.

Ratio of active to passive muscle shortening in the canine diaphragm

Active and passive shortening of muscle bundles in the canine diaphragm were measured with the objective of testing a consequence of the minimal-work hypothesis: namely, that the ratio of active to passive shortening is the same for all active muscles. Lengths of six muscle bundles in the costal diaphragm and two muscle bundles in the crural diaphragm of each of four bred-for-research beagle dogs were measured by the radiopaque marker technique during the following maneuvers: a passive deflation maneuver from total lung capacity to functional residual capacity, quiet breathing, and forceful inspiratory efforts against an occluded airway at different lung volumes. Shortening per liter increase in lung volume was, on average, 70% greater during quiet breathing than during passive inflation in the prone posture and 40% greater in the supine posture. For the prone posture, the ratio of active to passive shortening was larger in the ventral and midcostal diaphragm than at the dorsal end of the costal diaphragm. For both postures, active shortening during quiet breathing was poorly correlated with passive shortening. However, shortening during forceful inspiratory efforts was highly correlated with passive shortening. The average ratios of active to passive shortening were 1.23 +/- 0.02 and 1.32 +/- 0.03 for the prone and supine postures, respectively. These data, taken together with the data reported in the companion paper (T. A. Wilson, M. Angelillo, A. Legrand, and A. De Troyer, J. Appl. Physiol. 87: 554-560, 1999), support the hypothesis that, during forceful inspiratory efforts, the inspiratory muscles drive the chest wall along the minimal-work trajectory.