Protective ventilation in a pig model of acute lung injury: timing is as important as pressure

High positive end-expiratory pressure ventilation mitigates the progression from unilateral pulmonary contusion to ARDS: An animal study

BACKGROUND

Pulmonary contusion (PC) is common in severely traumatized patients and can lead to respiratory failure requiring mechanical ventilation (MV). Ventilator-induced lung injury (VILI) might aggravate lung damage. Despite underrepresentation of trauma patients in trials on lung-protective MV, results are extrapolated to these patients, potentially disregarding important pathophysiological differences.

METHODS

Three MV protocols with different positive end-expiratory pressure (PEEP) levels: ARDSnetwork lower PEEP (ARDSnet-low), ARDSnetwork higher PEEP (ARDSnet-high), and open lung concept (OLC) were applied in swine for 24 hours following PC. Gas exchange, lung mechanics, quantitative computed tomography, and diffuse alveolar damage (DAD) score were analyzed. Results are given as median (interquartile range) at 24 hours. Statistical testing was performed using general linear models (group effect) over all measurement points and pairwise Mann-Whitney U tests for DAD.

RESULTS

There were significant differences between groups: PEEP ( p < 0.0001) ARDSnet-low (8 [8-10] cmH 2 O), ARDSnet-high (12 [12-12] cmH 2 O), OLC (21 [20-22] cmH 2 O). The fraction of arterial partial pressure of oxygen and inspired oxygen fraction ( p = 0.0016) was lowest in ARDSnet-low (78 (73-111) mm Hg) compared with ARDSnet-high (375 (365-423) mm Hg) and OLC (499 (430-523) mm Hg). The end-expiratory lung volume (EELV) differed significantly ( p < 0.0001), with highest values in OLC (64% [60-70%]) and lowest in ARDSnet-low (34% [24-37%]). Costa's surrogate for mechanical power differed significantly ( p < 0.0001), with lowest values for ARDSnet-high (73 [58-76]) compared with OLC (105 [108-116]). Diffuse alveolar damage was lower in ARDSnet-high compared with ARDSnet-low (0.0007).

CONCLUSION

Progression to ARDS, 24 hours after PC, was mitigated by OLC and ARDSnet-high. Both concepts restored EELV. ARDSnet-high had the lowest mechanical power surrogate and DAD. Our data suggest, that ARDSnet-high restored oxygenation and functional lung volume and reduced physiological and histological surrogates for VILI. ARDSnet-low generated unfavorable outcomes, such as loss of EELV, increased mechanical power and DAD after PC in swine. The high respiratory rate in the OLC may blunt favorable effects of lung recruitment.

Pressure- and time-dependent alveolar recruitment/derecruitment in a spatially resolved patient-specific computational model for injured human lungs

We present a novel computational model for the dynamics of alveolar recruitment/derecruitment (RD), which reproduces the underlying characteristics typically observed in injured lungs. The basic idea is a pressure- and time-dependent variation of the stress-free reference volume in reduced dimensional viscoelastic elements representing the acinar tissue. We choose a variable reference volume triggered by critical opening and closing pressures in a time-dependent manner from a straightforward mechanical point of view. In the case of (partially and progressively) collapsing alveolar structures, the volume available for expansion during breathing reduces and vice versa, eventually enabling consideration of alveolar collapse and reopening in our model. We further introduce a method for patient-specific determination of the underlying critical parameters of the new alveolar RD dynamics when integrated into the tissue elements, referred to as terminal units, of a spatially resolved physics-based lung model that simulates the human respiratory system in an anatomically correct manner. Relevant patient-specific parameters of the terminal units are herein determined based on medical image data and the macromechanical behavior of the lung during artificial ventilation. We test the whole modeling approach for a real-life scenario by applying it to the clinical data of a mechanically ventilated patient. The generated lung model is capable of reproducing clinical measurements such as tidal volume and pleural pressure during various ventilation maneuvers. We conclude that this new model is an important step toward personalized treatment of ARDS patients by considering potentially harmful mechanisms-such as cyclic RD and overdistension-and might help in the development of relevant protective ventilation strategies to reduce ventilator-induced lung injury (VILI).

Time-Controlled Adaptive Ventilation (TCAV): a personalized strategy for lung protection

Acute respiratory distress syndrome (ARDS) alters the dynamics of lung inflation during mechanical ventilation. Repetitive alveolar collapse and expansion (RACE) predisposes the lung to ventilator-induced lung injury (VILI). Two broad approaches are currently used to minimize VILI: (1) low tidal volume (LVT) with low-moderate positive end-expiratory pressure (PEEP); and (2) open lung approach (OLA). The LVT approach attempts to protect already open lung tissue from overdistension, while simultaneously resting collapsed tissue by excluding it from the cycle of mechanical ventilation. By contrast, the OLA attempts to reinflate potentially recruitable lung, usually over a period of seconds to minutes using higher PEEP used to prevent progressive loss of end-expiratory lung volume (EELV) and RACE. However, even with these protective strategies, clinical studies have shown that ARDS-related mortality remains unacceptably high with a scarcity of effective interventions over the last two decades. One of the main limitations these varied interventions demonstrate to benefit is the observed clinical and pathologic heterogeneity in ARDS. We have developed an alternative ventilation strategy known as the Time Controlled Adaptive Ventilation (TCAV) method of applying the Airway Pressure Release Ventilation (APRV) mode, which takes advantage of the heterogeneous time- and pressure-dependent collapse and reopening of lung units. The TCAV method is a closed-loop system where the expiratory duration personalizes VT and EELV. Personalization of TCAV is informed and tuned with changes in respiratory system compliance (CRS) measured by the slope of the expiratory flow curve during passive exhalation. Two potentially beneficial features of TCAV are: (i) the expiratory duration is personalized to a given patient's lung physiology, which promotes alveolar stabilization by halting the progressive collapse of alveoli, thereby minimizing the time for the reopened lung to collapse again in the next expiration, and (ii) an extended inspiratory phase at a fixed inflation pressure after alveolar stabilization gradually reopens a small amount of tissue with each breath. Subsequently, densely collapsed regions are slowly ratcheted open over a period of hours, or even days. Thus, TCAV has the potential to minimize VILI, reducing ARDS-related morbidity and mortality.

Sustained vs. Intratidal Recruitment in the Injured Lung During Airway Pressure Release Ventilation: A Computational Modeling Perspective

INTRODUCTION

During mechanical ventilation, cyclic recruitment and derecruitment (R/D) of alveoli result in focal points of heterogeneous stress throughout the lung. In the acutely injured lung, the rates at which alveoli can be recruited or derecruited may also be altered, requiring longer times at higher pressure levels to be recruited during inspiration, but shorter times at lower pressure levels to minimize collapse during exhalation. In this study, we used a computational model to simulate the effects of airway pressure release ventilation (APRV) on acinar recruitment, with varying inspiratory pressure levels and durations of exhalation.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

The computational model consisted of a ventilator pressure source, a distensible breathing circuit, an endotracheal tube, and a porcine lung consisting of recruited and derecruited zones, as well as a transitional zone capable of intratidal R/D. Lung injury was simulated by modifying each acinus with an inflation-dependent surface tension. APRV was simulated for an inhalation duration (Thigh) of 4.0 seconds, inspiratory pressures (Phigh) of 28 and 40 cmH2O, and exhalation durations (Tlow) ranging from 0.2 to 1.5 seconds.

RESULTS

Both sustained acinar recruitment and intratidal R/D within the subtree were consistently higher for Phigh of 40 cmH2O vs. 28 cmH2O, regardless of Tlow. Increasing Tlow was associated with decreasing sustained acinar recruitment, but increasing intratidal R/D, within the subtree. Increasing Tlow was associated with decreasing elastance of both the total respiratory system and transitional subtree of the model.

CONCLUSIONS

Our computational model demonstrates the confounding effects of cyclic R/D, sustained recruitment, and parenchymal strain stiffening on estimates of total lung elastance during APRV. Increasing inspiratory pressures leads to not only more sustained recruitment of unstable acini but also more intratidal R/D. Our model indicates that higher inspiratory pressures should be used in conjunction with shorter exhalation times, to avoid increasing intratidal R/D.

Full-lung simulations of mechanically ventilated lungs incorporating recruitment/derecruitment dynamics

This study developed and investigated a comprehensive multiscale computational model of a mechanically ventilated ARDS lung to elucidate the underlying mechanisms contributing to the development or prevention of VILI. This model is built upon a healthy lung model that incorporates realistic airway and alveolar geometry, tissue distensibility, and surfactant dynamics. Key features of the ARDS model include recruitment and derecruitment (RD) dynamics, alveolar tissue viscoelasticity, and surfactant deficiency. This model successfully reproduces realistic pressure-volume (PV) behavior, dynamic surface tension, and time-dependent descriptions of RD events as a function of the ventilation scenario. Simulations of Time-Controlled Adaptive Ventilation (TCAV) modes, with short and long durations of exhalation (T Low - and T Low +, respectively), reveal a higher incidence of RD for T Low + despite reduced surface tensions due to interfacial compression. This finding aligns with experimental evidence emphasizing the critical role of timing in protective ventilation strategies. Quantitative analysis of energy dissipation indicates that while alveolar recruitment contributes only a small fraction of total energy dissipation, its spatial concentration and brief duration may significantly contribute to VILI progression due to its focal nature and higher intensity. Leveraging the computational framework, the model may be extended to facilitate the development of personalized protective ventilation strategies to enhance patient outcomes. As such, this computational modeling approach offers valuable insights into the complex dynamics of VILI that may guide the optimization of ventilation strategies in ARDS management.

Ratchet recruitment in the acute respiratory distress syndrome: lessons from the newborn cry

Patients with acute respiratory distress syndrome (ARDS) have few treatment options other than supportive mechanical ventilation. The mortality associated with ARDS remains unacceptably high, and mechanical ventilation itself has the potential to increase mortality further by unintended ventilator-induced lung injury (VILI). Thus, there is motivation to improve management of ventilation in patients with ARDS. The immediate goal of mechanical ventilation in ARDS should be to prevent atelectrauma resulting from repetitive alveolar collapse and reopening. However, a long-term goal should be to re-open collapsed and edematous regions of the lung and reduce regions of high mechanical stress that lead to regional volutrauma. In this paper, we consider the proposed strategy used by the full-term newborn to open the fluid-filled lung during the initial breaths of life, by ratcheting tissues opened over a series of initial breaths with brief expirations. The newborn's cry after birth shares key similarities with the Airway Pressure Release Ventilation (APRV) modality, in which the expiratory duration is sufficiently short to minimize end-expiratory derecruitment. Using a simple computational model of the injured lung, we demonstrate that APRV can slowly open even the most recalcitrant alveoli with extended periods of high inspiratory pressure, while reducing alveolar re-collapse with brief expirations. These processes together comprise a ratchet mechanism by which the lung is progressively recruited, similar to the manner in which the newborn lung is aerated during a series of cries, albeit over longer time scales.